The Truth About Plastic Recycling ... It’s Complicated

Protecting The Environment
106 followers
This video is brought to you by Incogni. The three R's, reduce, reuse, and recycle,
have been drilled into our heads as a way forward towards a sustainable future.
The plastic industry focused heavily on selling us that recycling was the perfect solution to
the plastic waste problem. Yet plastic recycling has turned out to be trash. Literally. In fact,
most of the plastic we've produced so far has ended up in landfills or worse, in the food we
eat every single day. Does that mean recycling is a scam? Or is there a way forward that won't
waste our time when recycling waste? There's some interesting innovations that may help
solve some of the problem. Let's see if we can come to a decision on this. I'm Matt Ferrell.
Welcome to Undecided.
If you're anything like me, it's probably second nature to collect all of your plastic and paper
waste each week and put it in the recycling bin out by the curb. It's the least we could do to
help keep our neighborhoods, land, and oceans clean. Which is why my level of anger just
kept jumping up a step as I learned the details of why and how plastic recycling isn't actually
working. In 2017, researchers conducted an analysis of all plastic ever made worldwide.
Based on the results, as of 2015, only 9% of it has been recycled.
Before we get to some of the solutions, we have to understand why and how we were sold this bad
bill of goods. Let's take a step back in time to see where it all started. In 1970, 20 million
Americans took to the streets for the first Earth Day, marking the onset of the environmental
movement here in the U.S. People protested against a legacy left by a century of polluting.
The plastic industry was one of the emerging evil villains that was targeted by the new movement.
Feeling the pressure, Big Plastic came up with a solution. That same year,
the Container Corporation of America sponsored a U.S.-wide contest
to design a symbol to represent and encourage people to recycle. The contest was open to high
school and college students, and the winner designed what we all know of as the recycling
symbol. As soon as the plastic giants realized the power of that symbol, they recycled it as
part of a greenwashing strategy. In 1988, the Society of Plastics Industry introduced
7 Resin Identification Codes, or RICs. You can find one of these 7 marks on the bottom of pretty
much any plastic container, from a water plastic bottle to a yogurt container. It identifies the
resin that was used in its construction. So what's wrong with that? Well, only two of those resins
are recyclable. The RIC's design was incredibly similar to the recycling logo,
and that was not by accident. It was a dirty trick to muddy the water and fill it with plastic.
When ASTM International slightly changed the RIC's design, it was too late. After 25 years,
the visual link between RICs and the recycling symbol had already been cemented into our minds.
And that link seems to be as durable as the plastic is. In 2019, the Consumer Brands Association
interviewed 2,000 Americans, and two-thirds of them thought they could recycle any product
bearing an RIC on it. Ironically, this misinterpretation caused the spread of a
wasteful practice known as wish cycling, which means you recycle something even though you're
not sure whether it's recyclable or not. However, your recycling wish may not come true. Instead,
some of these materials contaminate the plastic recycling system, which means you'll cause
problems at Materials Recovery Facilities, or MRFs. It's there that operators have to spend
time sorting waste from the recycling stream, and they may need to shut down the plants in some
cases. Basically, this makes the process slower and more expensive. That means to save time and
money, more plastic will find its way into landfills or incinerators. Aside from the RIC
image association trick, oil and gas companies have spent millions to promote recycling.
According to an NPR investigation, they did this even though they doubted the practical application
and economic viability. That's because recycled plastic has a lower quality, yet a higher cost,
compared to its virgin alternative. In fact, besides the difficulty to implement,
the recycling process downgrades plastic quality. A plastic product can be recycled up to a maximum
of three times, and you'll still have to sneak virgin plastic into the mix at every cycle to
compensate for the quality degradation. According to three former top executives interviewed by NPR,
recycling was just a clever move to postpone plastic bans and keep selling their fossil
fuels. Before I get to what changed with recycling and what could be done about it,
there's another industry that's also hiding in the shadows and using clever tactics to take
advantage of all of us. That's data brokers and our privacy. I'd like to thank today's sponsor,
Incogni, who helped me get some of my privacy back and they can help you too.
Just recently I signed up for a newsletter from a company, and I won't name who it was,
but after I signed up I saw a major increase in the number of promotional emails I was receiving
from companies I'd never heard of. That's because they sold my information to a data broker.
I've also had my information leaked through data breaches like the one from Target a few years ago,
which can end up in the same exact places. I'm sure you've experienced this too. Incogni can
help with this. We have the right to request that data brokers delete our information,
but it takes a lot of time and effort. I signed up for Incogni, gave them the legal right to work on
my behalf, and then just sat back and relaxed. You'll see updates in your account for which
data brokers they've sent legal requests to and which ones have complied. It couldn't be easier.
If you want to take back some of the control around who has access to your personal information,
give Incogni a try. The first 100 people to use the code UNDECIDED at the link below will get 20%
off Incogni. Thanks to Incogni and to all of you for supporting the channel.
Now back to what changed the conversation around plastic recycling.
Despite their pseudo-green marketing efforts, the plastic industry can no longer hide recycling's
failure. I'm talking about the Great Pacific Garbage Patch, where plastic has been collecting
in an area twice as big as Texas. Recycling issues were thrust into the limelight when
China's National Sword Policy sharply cut the import of the world's recycled plastic in 2018,
which decreased by 99% compared to 2017. This cut through a huge monkey wrench into the world's
recycling system because the U.S. and other high-income countries had been exporting 70%
of our recycled plastic to China. We're still paying the price for this reduction from China,
since average household recycling fees are now 11% higher than they were in 2018.
I can hear you already. How on earth were we sending our recycled plastic
halfway around the world to China? The short answer is it was a cheap way to get out of sight
and feel less guilty about it. So let's dig into the plastic pile just a little bit though.
Before China turned off the plastic recycling tap, we were shipping loads of MRF residual
bales over there. Unlike high-value wastes such as water bottles, these bundles of plastic pieces
aren't worth sorting and recycling in the U.S. Instead of being dumped into a landfill or
incinerated, residual plastic bales were loaded on trucks en route to the nearest port on the
U.S. west coast, where a cargo ship shuttled them across the Pacific. So how did the Chinese make a
profit out of our low-value plastic? First, China's exports to the U.S. trump their imports,
which means China's cargo ships normally leave America with a lot of unused space.
In other words, carrying those bales to China was dirt cheap. It was better to ship nearly
worthless plastic on board versus leaving the cargo ship empty. On top of that, the Chinese
experienced massive economic growth over recent years, which drove the demand for pretty much any
raw material, including recycled plastic. Finally, they could rely on plenty of low-paid
workers to do the sorting. So why did China shut their borders to our waste? Well, on paper,
China said that the incoming plastic was often contaminated with hazardous waste,
harming their workers and environment. Chances are that after factoring in the healthcare and
environmental remediation costs, the Chinese government realized that our waste was no
longer worthwhile. Imagine that. Now that China is rejecting our plastic, what happens next?
While other developing countries in Asia, like Malaysia, took over,
the final result is always the same. As reported by over 60 different sources, most of our plastic
ended up going into landfills or being burned because of our recipients' poor waste management
standards. The problem is that after having relied on China for so many years, we haven't
developed a domestic recycling infrastructure. As a result, many of our collection and sorting
operations are just shutting down. Municipalities like Philadelphia turn to waste-to-energy plants,
which are also known as incinerators, as the only alternative to landfilling. Yet even when
using the best technology, burning plastic may release dioxins and other harmful pollutants
into the air. However, regulators are trying to rethink our recycling system.
Last July, Maine was the first U.S. state to adopt an extended producer responsibility law
for plastic packaging. Based on the polluter pays principle, the EPR policy shifts recycling
costs from the taxpayers and local governments to packaging brands. Besides paying a fee,
companies that want to sell plastic packaging will have to develop reuse schemes and easily
recyclable products. As reported by the Extended Producer Responsibility Alliance, EPR programs
helped its state members reach plastic recycling rates of up to 68%. Other states have bills on
the table to follow Maine's lead. However, sorting recycling operations is only one part of the job,
and we'll need to create a China-independent market for recycled plastic. And that's just
what Oceanworks Marketplace is trying to do. Last year, the Amazon of recycled plastic was
the first company to receive the Oceanbound Plastic, or OBP, certification in the Americas.
As the name hints, OBP is plastic that was on its way to the ocean, but hasn't gotten there yet.
To be more specific, OBP is all the plastic that you'll find on land or waterways within
50 kilometers, or about 30 miles, of the shoreline. Oceanworks focuses on OBP because
it's cheaper to collect, more widely available, and has better quality than the plastic that's
been rotting in water. By putting together a supply chain for OBP, Oceanworks is giving
discarded plastic a new life. Their collectors, located mostly in Southeast Asia, intercept
plastic before it enters the ocean and provides manufacturers with the raw material. Then the
finished goods are sold in Oceanworks Market to brands worldwide. As a result, the company is
not only reducing ocean pollution, but they're also promoting valuable products made out of
plastic waste. Clothes, accessory bags, dog toys, and even card readers have been made from this
plastic waste. But Oceanworks isn't the only one reducing the demand for virgin plastic.
According to the Ellen MacArthur Foundation, several brands, including giants like Nestle
and Coca-Cola, contributed to the increased amount of post-consumer recycled plastic in packaging
by 60% between 2018 and 2020. Its uptake is expected to grow as more companies have committed
to squeeze even more recycled content inside their products by 2025. Clearly, plastic recycling is a
complex system. At the end of the day, it works if you can make money out of it. As I mentioned
earlier, this depends on the type of plastic. For instance, unlike residual bales, there seems to
be a market for high-value PET bottles or even OBP. So how about recycling materials other than
plastic? According to the Environmental Protection Agency, when combining recycling and food waste
composting, we divert 32% of our total municipal solid waste from landfills. When looking at
different types of waste, paper and cardboard account for two-thirds of our overall recycling
capacity. In comparison, the plastic share is under 5%. Yet there are some alternative
solutions to plastic recycling. Remember the three R's? Reduce, Reuse, Recycle? That earthworm
that's been drilled into our heads? We should shift our focus towards the first R, which means
reducing the amount of plastic waste we create. Over the last few years, plastic-free materials
have been mushrooming ... literally. I've talked about this in a previous video. For instance,
using mushroom roots or mycelium, you can create foams that are more sustainable and cheaper than
polystyrene-based ones. Ecovative was the first company spreading the mushroom packaging spores
around the world, making foams that a fungi consumes 12% less energy and releases 90%
fewer CO2 emissions than plastic production. You could also dispose of it in your backyard
composter, where it will turn into soil nutrients within 45 days. Moving from the woods to the sea,
we can harvest another plastic-free material that's been blooming lately.
Believe it or not, you can wear flip-flops that are made from algae. A startup has been developing
a solid biofoam by baking algae oil. The foam can be used to make flip-flops components such
as footbeds and outsoles. Once the algae footwear has walked to the end of its life cycle, you just
chuck them out into a compost pile, and after about 6 months you won't see any footprint left.
While they won't disappear as quickly as mushroom packaging, they'll still walk away from the
environment much faster than traditional flip-flops made of non-recyclable plastic.
I've also got a video on algae-based plastics if you're interested.
And speaking of making things vanish, NotPlaw made an invisible packaging out of seaweed.
Not only can you eat their transparent pouches, but they will biodegrade in a matter of weeks.
Besides plastic-free materials, there are biological ways to get rid of plastic.
Now, ironically, plastic dumping has caused a positive side effect.
I guess Darwin never thought about plastic-eating microorganisms
as a consequence to his evolutionary theory, but that's basically what happened.
Many scientists around the world have realized that certain microorganisms can digest
polymers, like PET, into its basic units. These can then be upcycled into new,
higher quality polymers or reused as is. For instance, UK and US researchers teamed
up to engineer bacterial enzymes that eat up plastic. Back in 2018, scientists had already
broken down PET into its two building blocks, terephthalate and ethylene glycol.
While EG has multiple applications, like car antifreeze, TPA is pretty much useless.
Yet last March, this same group cooked up a new enzyme that loves munching on TPA.
That's a plastic-breaking advancement when you think about PET as ubiquitous in food packaging
and taking 400 years to decompose. A Korean research team made a similar
achievement in 2021. However, in this case they combined a PET-hungry enzyme and microalgae
to design a phytoplankton that broke down a commercial PET water bottle.
The main trouble with enzymes is that they only work within a narrow temperature range,
and their scale-up may still be a long way off.
Yet the French company Carbios launched a pilot plant last September to demonstrate
the upcycling of PET waste into new PET bottles.
The truth is that plastic recycling has never worked. It was built on a lie.
And the reason being that except for a few valuable items like plastic bottles,
it's never been profitable enough.
And while regulators and private companies are trying to improve the economics of recycled
plastic, the future belongs to upcycling methods and plastic-free materials like mushrooms and
algae. Disposing of plastic pollution will take time. Meanwhile, we could change our
shopping habits by buying more plastic-free goods whenever possible, but we could also
demand more transparency and accountability from the plastic industry and politicians.
So are you still undecided? What do you think is the best path forward for recycling?
Jump in the comments and let me know. If you liked this, be sure to check out one of these
videos. And thanks to all my Patrons and to all of you for watching. I'll see you in the next one.
