Is Consciousness Ultimate Reality?

Human & Consciousness
3 followers
2 Video Views·Sep 29, 2024
Some say that consciousness is the only true reality—that everything else, including the universe, comes from consciousness. If so, how would consciousness relate to the world? Featuring interviews with Deepak Chopra, Donald Hoffman, Neil Theise, Fred Alan Wolf, Frank J. Tipler, and Charles T. Tart.
To seek ultimate reality is to follow explanations
until explanations end.
And when explanations end, what remains?
I'm looking for what remains.
Physicists see fundamental laws.
Believers see God.
Some see consciousness.
I'd love to see consciousness as ultimate reality.
But isn't consciousness an unnatural choice?
Isn't consciousness produced by brains?
Aren't brains evolutionary accidents?
Not so, say a few scientists.
While brains facilitate human consciousness,
cosmic consciousness generates brains and everything else.
What motivates this coronation of consciousness
as the cause of all reality, the progenitor of existence?
Is consciousness ultimate reality?
I'm Robert Lawrence Kuhn,
and Closer to Truth is my journey to find out.
I'd like consciousness to go beyond the physical world.
But must I reject the reality of the physical world?
Some scientists assert that consciousness causes everything.
But how can scientists who study the physical world
come to the extreme belief
that the physical world is derived from consciousness?
What evidence?
What arguments?
In the West, the notion that ultimate reality
is consciousness is not mainstream.
The scientists who so elevate consciousness
are not mainstream.
Could they shake up my thinking?
Consciousness as ultimate reality
is often associated with Eastern philosophy and religion,
perhaps originating in ancient India.
I begin with an Indian-American physician and teacher
whose work is predicated on the primacy of consciousness,
Deepak Chopra.
Deepak, among scientists and philosophers
who take consciousness seriously,
many of them now say that consciousness
is another fundamental part of the universe.
Do you feel that consciousness is ultimate reality
and everything else is derivative from consciousness?
The short answer is yes.
Consciousness, defined as awareness,
is ultimate reality.
It's truth with a capital T.
Now, scientists give labels to their experiences.
Electromagnetism, gravity,
strong and weak interactions.
Some of them are perceptual experiences.
Gravity is a perceptual experience.
I feel heavy, okay?
It holds me here on this chair so I don't fly,
which I can quantify in equations and all that.
Electromagnetism is a word
to describe certain behaviors.
So everything that we call the four forces of nature,
all mental, mathematical activities in consciousness,
they are words we have created,
and now we hold these words to represent fundamental truths.
But all they are is perceptual
and conceptual experiences in consciousness.
There's no reality to any of that, okay?
That's what science does.
It creates a language.
It creates a description of a conceptual
or perceptual experience.
So this is what reality is.
Reality is none of that.
What's a particle?
It's a space-time event in consciousness.
It's a happening in consciousness.
There's nothing outside of consciousness.
But that's pure speculation
because those events are repeatable events.
They are the kinds of things that people
from different cultures, different walks of life,
different experiences of all different kinds
can agree upon.
Systems of thought that we agree in.
But everybody agrees.
Yeah, but you go to a religious ideology,
and on consciousness, everybody disagrees.
Okay, wait, because nobody has experienced it directly.
Okay, that's why they disagree.
They think of it as perception, cognition,
all the things that are not consciousness, okay?
Consciousness is not a system of thought.
It is what gives rise to all systems of thought.
How, then, does consciousness create everything else?
Consciousness experience itself as forms of consciousness.
Color is a qualia,
or a form of consciousness within consciousness.
Sound is a form of consciousness within consciousness.
There's no sound in the world.
It's all vibration of molecules.
In fact, there is no world.
The world is a qualia gestalt, okay?
And it's all forms of consciousness
within consciousness that exist.
Everything else is a perceptual illusion,
including your own body.
It doesn't exist.
Deepak is not shy, and he does not equivocate.
Only consciousness is real.
All else is illusion.
It's jarring to hear.
Radically at odds with our everyday perceptions,
what we see, what we hear.
Those are so real, consciousness is so ethereal.
Absurd?
Perhaps not so.
Here's the argument.
How do we know those are so real?
Only by a consciousness.
We have one window on reality,
and consciousness is it.
Is the claim all mysticism and philosophy?
Any science involved?
Since perception helps make the case
for consciousness as ultimate reality,
I turn to a cognitive scientist,
an expert on visual perception, Donald Hoffman.
Don, is consciousness ultimate reality,
and how would you get there?
Yes, I do take consciousness as being the fundamental reality.
The burden on me, then, is first to say,
what do I mean by consciousness?
And I want a science of consciousness,
not a hand wave.
So, the burden is on me to give a mathematically precise model
of what I mean by consciousness.
The goal is to take that precise mathematical model
of consciousness and show, for example,
that it precisely gives rise to our current physics.
Then I can begin to try to show that it's at least consistent
to take consciousness as fundamental,
and to say that the physical world
is simply the contents of consciousness.
It doesn't seem conceivable that you can model consciousness
with the same type of mathematical rigor
that physicists can simulate and model
the physics of subatomic particles.
It turns out it's quite easy to do it.
If you think about it, we take for granted
that we can give mathematical models of space and time,
but if you just look at space and say,
how do you assign numbers to points in the space?
It was very, very bright people who figured out
how to assign numbers to the physical world,
and then all of a sudden this whole thing took off.
Well, they've done the hard work.
We can now do it with consciousness.
So, I can say, for example, in the case of color perception,
let the set X be the set of John's color perceptions.
I can quantify over his color perceptions.
I can start talking about transformations
of his color perceptions,
and I can use all of the tools of mathematics to do that.
So, I can say, here's a probability space
of my conscious color experiences.
Here's a probability space of the kinds of actions
I decide to take.
And I can then talk about maps among them,
and I can get a mathematically precise model.
I can follow that.
You are now generalizing John's color perception,
but that doesn't represent John's color perception.
That's a totally different category of stuff,
whereas the two masses in the gravitational equation
are those are the real things that you're talking about.
So, in the case of Newton and F equals G,
M1, M2 over R squared, that equation.
So, you have the masses M1 and M2.
Those are just numbers.
Right.
If you write down those numbers, they won't be heavy.
Right.
You won't feel any mass to them.
Right.
So, there's a direct correspondence.
You can understand that.
There is.
Everybody in the field who does psychophysics
uses mathematical models to represent the color experiences
that they're measuring or the motion experiences and so forth.
And your claim is that that's the equivalent
of assigning a number to the mass of an object.
That's exactly right.
When you do it in physics...
Does anybody agree with you on that?
Well, I think that...
Nobody at this table does.
Well, in psychophysics, it's the standard
approach.
I'm sure that's true, but that's answering
a slightly different question.
Okay.
The question is, is it the same thing as assigning
a number to two masses of body?
Oh, I think it's absolutely the same kind of thing
in the sense that all you're doing with the mathematics
is trying to write down a formal structure that you think
mirrors the key features of the domain of interest.
So, if I do a simulation of the weather, right,
you don't expect to get wet.
You don't need an umbrella to go check it out.
And if I give you a simulation of a mathematical model
of consciousness, I'm not going to, you know,
create conscious...
There's no ghosts that are going to appear.
So, if the mathematics is what it is,
it's only useful to the extent that it actually allows us
to predict our future experimental results.
And so, that's the way I'm using it for consciousness.
We're doing science.
I like Don's ambition.
But even if conscious behaviours could be simulated,
our personal, private, inner awareness seems radically
distinct from non-sentient objects.
I also cannot imagine how equations that describe
mental perception of sight and sound can generate
fundamental physics of particles and forces.
What motivates these scientists to claim that consciousness
is ultimate reality?
I meet a medical doctor, a liver pathologist,
who has come to believe that all things are conscious,
Neil Teiss.
If you had asked me whether I believed a panpsychist position
as opposed to an emergentist position about consciousness
two years ago, I wouldn't have had an opinion.
Now, I'm surprised to discover I do.
What's meant by those is an emergentist position
is that consciousness is something that emerges
from the universe when it is sufficiently complex,
like a human brain.
The panpsychist position is that consciousness is something
that pervades the universe, side by side with matter energy,
or part of it, or maybe actually is the stuff
out of which all of this arises.
Let me select a metaphor that helps the panpsychist
point of view.
A radio is playing music.
You can look at that and go,
there must be a tiny little orchestra in there.
Wow, they can play classical music and they can play rock.
That's really cool.
You open it up, there's no orchestra there.
What the radio is doing is it's a transducer of the radio waves
that we can hear.
So, the radio is taking this infinite,
vastly information-rich thing and narrowing its scope
so we can hear music.
That could be how brains work.
There's consciousness out there and the brain transduces that.
Isn't that a rather long jump that you've made?
No, I don't think so.
And I think it's a pretty apt one, actually.
I mean, that's pretty cool.
What are the pieces of evidence that you're using
or that's drawing you in that direction?
Two sets.
One, there is this sentience argument that I don't find
any place where it's absent.
I don't find where it wasn't here and now it's emerging.
That makes me think it's not an emergentist thing.
You find a continuum.
Okay, that's one.
Anything else?
There is the experience I have from contemplative practice.
I'm a Zen Buddhist student.
I've been meditating for 25 years.
But I have had experiences in meditation where my mind is not
something that feels like it's coming from my brain.
My experience of my mind extends beyond all boundaries,
is infinite, is clear, is rich in light and information.
Some people would call it pure awareness.
Maybe that's a delusion produced by my brain.
But that's not my experience of it.
And that makes me think, okay, maybe I'm perceiving something
fundamental about the world using my mind about mind.
I myself have not had such contemplative experiences.
But if I did, why would I assume that their origins were cosmic?
How could I reject the skeptical argument that mystical feelings
are all internal?
Apparent dissociation from one's body may seem powerful,
personal evidence of non-physical realities.
But such feelings are common in altered states of consciousness.
However induced, drugs, alcohol, sleep deprivation, meditation,
such feelings can be explained by brain processes alone.
But what cannot be explained is core conscious awareness.
That's my conflict.
I can reject scientific justifications for consciousness
being ultimate reality, but not that consciousness itself
is a great mystery.
To solve the mysteries of consciousness,
some scientists recruit the mysteries of quantum physics.
I visit quantum popularizer Fred Alan Wolff.
Though few quantum physicists take his speculation seriously,
Fred is undaunted.
Fred, working particularly in quantum mechanics,
do you see consciousness as something that's built up
from the more fundamental things of brain function
and then kind of emerging?
Or is consciousness something that is fundamental
and irreducible in itself?
It's fundamental and irreducible.
There's no way that you can build it up.
It's just like having the proton or even the quark
and trying to find everything based upon it being the fundamental
when the quantum field is really the fundamental,
which is an invisible thing.
It's the same question.
The things that consciousness does are the things
that we call normal awareness of, whatever it is.
But it itself is difficult to contemplate as it itself
because it's not a thing in of itself.
It's not limited by space or time.
We can see more of it, but not actually see it.
When we go down at the level of the quantum field,
which is not a material thing.
It would seem that the burden of proof is on you
because neuroscientists can show very strong correlations.
Some would even go to causation between activities in the brain,
in our sensory, visual, auditory, motor.
What you're talking about is kind of ethereal.
Well, it may be ethereal, but if you actually ask materialists
how they can prove from whatever they look at,
that there's a willful intent operating in that body,
if you can find their way of proving that,
then I would agree with them, but they can't.
So, one of the tests that you're using is willful intent.
How do you have willful intent in a purely materialistic world?
You don't.
You can't unless it's a machine, and we're not machines
because we're shapers of possibilities into realities.
That's what quantum physics predicts.
It predicts that a mind or something, an observer,
which is not material, shapes materiality.
So, what are the implications of that?
Is then willful intent, wherever it occurs,
the critical factor in giving us this sense
that consciousness is a real, independent,
irreducible part of the world?
I think it is, and it is now, I think, of interest
if willful intent can be discovered
in any materialistic way, but I don't think it can
because there's this process in quantum physics
where we can't mathematize.
We can't put it in a machine and make it work.
We can't really see how it is that we shape possibilities,
compact the wave function or collapse the wave function.
We can't see that process in any kind of material way.
Is there anything else other than willful intent
which gives robustness and actualizes
this concept of consciousness?
The necessity of there being an abstract world
prior to a material world, that if we try to explain
everything in terms of a material world,
we end up losing a lot of stuff that we can't explain,
whereas if we assume there is an abstract mental world,
the material world suddenly becomes more explainable.
I have to go back to the whole vision
of the platonic universe.
It's there that I think we are being led.
The reason I see that is that each of us has a sense
of what's beyond the blur of our own particular way of seeing.
In other words, we each have a platonic ideal,
and I believe that can only come because the platonic world
is the real world.
Fred starts with quantum physics,
but then finds a deeper reality, rooted in consciousness
or even in an abstract platonic world.
Quantum physics does indeed manifest strange traits,
but building a world edifice on this shaky foundation
seems, at best, premature.
I might like reality to be remystified,
which is why I should hear the critics.
I meet a physicist known for his unconventional ideas,
all based on his belief that the laws of physics,
not consciousness, is ultimate reality.
Frank Tipler.
Some philosophers have taken that concept of consciousness
and made it fundamental to the universe.
I think that's fundamentally misconceived.
I think that all of reality, human beings,
everything that goes to make us up,
is fully subject to physical law.
The human soul exists, and it's immaterial,
but it's a computer program.
You should think of the human mind, the human soul,
the human consciousness, as the result of a computer program
being run on a wet computer, which is called the human brain,
that we can actually quantify thoughts
using the same language that we use for information theory.
So there is nothing in the human consciousness
that is outside the laws of physics
and not fully capable of being described
in complete detail by the laws of physics.
So that means that consciousness,
our sense of soul, or a personal awareness,
is not only derivative from the laws of physics,
but in essence, it's no different than a chair,
which is also derived from the laws of physics.
It's not quite like a chair.
It's more like a word processing program.
Now, it's real.
It's immaterial, but it's still real.
But what is that program?
It's just a pattern on a CD, a blank CD, a CD.
It's still the same atoms.
What has changed, what has made a word processing program
valuable, why you have to pay for it,
is the change in the pattern of the atoms on the CD.
But notice the pattern is immaterial.
The pattern is rearranging the atoms
rather than the atoms itself.
The atoms are the matter.
The pattern is truly immaterial.
The soul is the same thing.
So you're using the term immaterial,
not in the sense of non-physical,
but in terms of something imposed on the matter
or a pattern of the matter, but it is the matter itself.
It's not non-physical.
Well, the laws of thermodynamics,
the first two laws,
the first one says conservation of energy.
That applies to matter, to the material.
We also have the second law of thermodynamics,
which involves a concept called entropy.
Entropy is the same sort of stuff as the soul.
It is a law which governs pattern creation.
So here you have, in the laws of physics,
distinction between body and soul.
The first law of thermodynamics concerns the body,
concerns matter, concerns energy.
The second law of thermodynamics controls information,
controls pattern generation,
controls and describes the spiritual world.
The spiritual world is real,
and it's there already in the physics.
To Frank, consciousness is derivative.
Only the laws of physics are fundamental.
In fact, Frank almost deifies physics,
as if God were another name for physical laws.
I like his creativity and his courage,
if not his conclusion.
Conventional science offers no convincing evidence
that consciousness is ultimate reality.
If I'm still in this game, I need to go unconventional.
Parapsychology claims that realities exist
beyond the physical.
I meet one of parapsychology's pioneers, Charles Tartt.
Charlie, as a psychologist who focuses on data,
some unusual data to be sure,
how do you view this question
about the irreducible nature of consciousness?
I view it through the lens of asking
how useful is the question?
What will different kinds of answers to the question
lead you to do, and what might you learn from that?
If you view it as fundamental, which is my preference,
then you're going to ask questions about consciousness
and do research on it that you wouldn't do otherwise.
If you make consciousness fundamental,
then it becomes very interesting to ask questions like,
why don't we experience telepathic contact
with each other all the time?
Why do we feel separate?
Is it simply because consciousness is so focused
on a particular physical body and brain
that it's ignoring all the other telepathic impressions?
And can we make progress on that?
Because if we can't, then maybe consciousness
is not fundamental, and it is reducible
to brain function alone.
If consciousness can be something other than the brain
and still not be fundamental,
it could be derived from something else.
Then let's find out what that is.
Is that possible in principle?
Because maybe if we're dealing in the physical world
of physical experiments and data,
that in principle, those kinds of things,
if they exist, are not susceptible
to the kinds of observations that we make
in the physical world.
When you ask an ultimate question like that, Robert,
I'm reminded of something that John Lilly
once put very nicely.
Something like, in the realm of the mind,
what one believes to be true tends to become true.
So the moral of all that is be careful what you believe.
If you believe in certain kind of limits,
your mind may create those limits for you.
If you don't, it may not.
Try it both ways and see what happens.
Well, I would put that almost in reverse,
that because I have a desire for consciousness
to be fundamental, I'm going to spend more time
and think about it and talk about it.
Maybe I'm just fooling myself.
Maybe, but what's the alternative?
Ha, ha, ha.
Well, the alternative is to face reality
and to look at the scientific data,
and if the scientific data doesn't support it,
put your efforts into things that make sense
and not into nonsense.
I'm an experimentalist. I'm a pragmatist.
I say try different approaches and see what comes of them
and see where it takes you.
If you go down some dead ends, that's fine.
You learn from the dead ends.
If you go to interesting new places, wonderful.
Some say that consciousness doesn't exist.
It is illusion.
Others that consciousness is the only thing that exists.
It is ultimate reality.
Here is a decision tree of questions.
Is consciousness entirely the product of physical brain?
If yes, stop.
Consciousness has no cosmic significance.
If no, ask, is consciousness reducible to or explainable
by something more fundamental?
If yes, seek what's more fundamental,
perhaps God or something like God.
If no, ask, is consciousness the only non-reducible thing?
If yes, then consciousness is ultimate reality.
If no, then consciousness shares ultimate reality,
perhaps with the laws of physics.
What if consciousness were ultimate reality?
It would not be a person in the sense of a personal God.
No intent, no will, no purpose.
Would pure awareness even make sense?
There could be enduring principles.
Our human consciousness could be somehow derived
from this cosmic consciousness,
and when we die, somehow return back to it.
Such cycles or forms of reincarnation
typify Eastern religions.
I guess it'd be better than stark physicalism,
though for me, not much better.
I'd hope something else is closer to truth.
For complete interviews and for further information,
please visit closertotruth.com
