------------------ 📣"Green policies" are devastating our farmers. We know because we talked to them personally - from the Netherlands to California. Now you can help us share their stories! 👉https://www.epochoriginal.com/nofarmersnofood
Earlier this year, Democrat lawmakers introduced a new piece of legislation into Congress
that will make it illegal for Americans to form militias. The bill, which you can see up on your
screen, was introduced to both the House as well as the Senate, and it's officially titled the
Preventing Private Paramilitary Activity Act of 2024. Its stated purpose would be to explicitly
outlaw the formation of citizen militia groups here in America, and more specifically, according
to the text of the bill itself, it will create federal criminal penalties for people who engage
in certain activities, including the following, publicly patrolling, drilling, or engaging in
harmful or deadly paramilitary techniques, intimidating elected officials, interfering
with government proceedings, pretending to be law enforcement, and so on. Now, perhaps ironically,
this bill likely had the opposite of the intended effect, at least on the public, because I know
for myself and several people who I spoke to, after hearing about this bill, our first reaction was,
can we form private militias? I mean, if they're trying to outlaw the formation of militias,
that must mean that it is currently legal to do it, right? Well, after looking into it,
the answer is a bit complex, to say the least. And so, let's go through the legal framework
surrounding militias as it currently stands, what this bill is trying to actually outlaw,
as well as the central question of whether you, as an American citizen, can go ahead today and
form your own militia. Now, to start with, let's begin at the very foundational document in play,
the Second Amendment. For a long time, one of the main arguments circulating online against
private gun ownership was that the Second Amendment does not actually give people the
right to own guns. The argument typically goes something like this, the Second Amendment doesn't
actually allow people to own guns. It only allows the state to own guns in order to form something
like a National Guard. Now, the reason for why this view exists is not a mystery. It's because
in the modern context, the plain language of the Second Amendment is a little bit confusing. Just
for your reference, here's exactly what the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution says,
quote, a well-regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free state,
the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed. And so it's quite easy
to look at the surface of those words and assume that the right to keep and bear arms really does
only apply to militias who are in service of defending a state. And in the modern context,
that is something like a National Guard. However, that is not in fact true. And to understand why
it's not true, we need to do two things. Firstly, we need to smash those like and subscribe buttons
so that this video can reach ever more people via the YouTube algorithm. And then secondly,
we need to look at a case that was put forth in front of the U.S. Supreme Court back in March of
2008, a case that's called District of Columbia versus Heller. In that particular case, what
happened was that the city government of Washington, D.C., they instituted a host of
different anti-gun regulations, including making it illegal for a person in D.C. to own a gun
unless that person received a license from the chief of police. And the licenses, they could
only be issued for one year at a time, meaning in a practical sense that you needed to go and
renew your license every single year. And so amidst these new regulations, a man who was living in
Washington, D.C. named Richard Heller, he went to the chief of police to get a gun license. He was
denied and therefore he filed a lawsuit against the city government arguing that in the way that
The case eventually found its way all the way up to the U.S. Supreme Court, where the principal
question to be determined was whether or not the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution
protected the right of the people to keep in their arms. And after hearing the case,
listening to the oral arguments, and deliberating for about three months, well, the majority decision
by the U.S. Supreme Court was that it does. The Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution does
protect the people's right to keep in their arms. Here's a short summary of the conclusion
from that majority opinion. Quote, the term militia should not be confined to those serving
in the military because at the time the term referred to all able-bodied men who are capable
of being called to such service. To read the amendment as limiting the rights of their arms
only to those in a governed military force would be to create exactly the type of state-sponsored
Now, to understand their rationale here, let's dissect the Second Amendment, starting by defining
two specific words that it contains. Firstly, what did the Founders, writing in the year 1791,
mean by the term militia? Because today, we usually conflate militia with something like a
state-run National Guard. But that's not what the word meant back then. In the late 1700s,
a militia referred to all free men who were capable of bearing arms. Basically, a militia
was defined as all able-bodied free men. Here's, in fact, how the majority opinion of the Supreme
Court described it. Quote, unlike armies and navies, which Congress has given the power to create,
the militia is assumed by Article I of the Constitution to already be in existence.
Congress is given the power to provide for calling forth the militia and the power not to create,
but to organize it, and not to organize a militia, which is what one would expect if the
militia were to be a federal creation, but to organize the militia, connoting a body already
in existence. This is fully consistent with the ordinary definition of the militia as all
able-bodied men. From that pool, Congress has plenary power to organize the units that will
make up an effective fighting force. Meaning, in plain English, that the term militia was understood
at the time to mean all able-bodied free men. And so, that's the first term, militia. The second
term that we need to define within the context of the Second Amendment is referenced to defending
the security of a free state. And so, what exactly was meant by a free state in the year 1791? Well,
unlike today, in the modern day, where the word state typically refers to an individual state,
like Oklahoma or Kansas, well, the use of the term a free state in the late 1700s referred to
nation states, what we today would refer to as countries. Here's again the U.S. Supreme Court
on this particular term. Quote, the phrase security of a free state meant security of a free polity,
not security of each of the several states. It is true that the term state, elsewhere in the
Constitution, refers to individual states, but the phrase security of a free state and close
variations seem to have been terms of art in 18th century political discourse, meaning a free country
or free polity. Moreover, the other instances of state in the Constitution are typically accompanied
by modifiers making clear that the reference is to the several states. Each state, several states,
any state, that state, particular states, one state, no state, and the presence of the term
foreign state in Article 1 and Article 3 shows that the word state did not have a single meaning
in the Constitution. And so, taking these late 1700 and early 1800 definitions into account,
here's how the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution would read if it was written today,
but still conveyed the same meaning. A well-regulated body of free men being necessary
to the security of a free country, the right of the people to keep in their arms shall not be
infringed. Then, the U.S. Supreme Court, they spent a good amount of time in this ruling going
through the relationship between the Prefatory Clause and the Operative Clause of the Second
Amendment, and without going into too much detail and too much legalese, what they were basically
laying out is that the first part of the Second Amendment, the Prefatory Clause, explains the
reason for why it is necessary, while the second part, known as the Operative Clause, explains what
the right actually is. And so, essentially, in order for free people to defend a free nation,
the right of the people to keep in their arms shall not be infringed.
All right, just to pause here for a super quick moment, I'd like to introduce today's sponsor,
which is a great company called Patriot Mobile. And they really are a phenomenal company because
while it's safe to say that there is a concerted assault on America's values happening right now,
companies like Patriot Mobile are bucking the trend and they're standing firm. I mean,
as a company, in both their actions as well as their spending, they strongly support the First
and Second Amendments. They strongly support the sanctity of life, as well as America's veterans
and first respondents. And better still, besides just having really good values, they are actually
a good company. They have great phone plans. By switching to Patriot Mobile, you'll still get the
same awesome nationwide coverage as the big providers, because Patriot Mobile actually
operates across all three of the major networks. It's just that by switching, you'll be doing
business with a company that doesn't undermine your values. Plus, they back their service with
a coverage guarantee. 100% of their customer service is based right here in the US, meaning
they're keeping the jobs here. You can keep your existing phone number, and you can either keep
your existing phone, or if you'd like, you can upgrade. And so just head on over to Patriot
Mobile dot com forward slash Roman, or just call 972-PATRIOT. Right now, they're having a special
promotion where you can get a free month when you use offer code Roman. That's R-O-M-A-N. And so
consider making the switch to America's only Christian conservative wireless provider. Either
call the number, or you can just click on the link right below this video. And furthermore, when you
look at it through a historical lens, and bear in mind the historical context, well, the true
intention of the Second Amendment becomes rather clear. Because the founding fathers of this nation,
they did not write the Second Amendment in order to go hunting, like people nowadays imply. They
had just finished fighting a bloody war against their own monarch, because that monarch had become
tyrannical towards them. And after that war concluded, they codified the Second Amendment
to the US Constitution, not so that Americans can go hunting, not even so much that we can protect
ourselves from petty criminals. But rather, the Second Amendment in the Bill of Rights was put
there to protect the citizens of the Republic from their own government, if and when the government
becomes tyrannical. It was written to give the people of the states the ability to protect
themselves, their families and their communities from a government that might, at some point in
time, become a terror to its own people. Now, with that as the actual general backdrop, the next
logical question becomes, how do people execute this responsibility? Because if you own a gun, and
I own a gun, and Dave owns a gun, and Mike owns a gun, well, that's great, we're all armed, but we are not
well regulated. Well, here's where things get a bit, you could say, messy. Back during the time of the
founding of this nation, well, there were many militias. In fact, Alexander Hamilton, while he was
a student over at Columbia University, he would quite literally spend his mornings drilling with
a volunteer student militia before then going off to class. However, after the founding of the
country, laws were enacted one after the other, which limited paramilitary activity to be only
allowed if the group conducting that activity is subject to the state. For instance, in the late
1800s, there was a law passed over in Illinois, which forbade, quote, bodies of men to associate
together as military organizations, or to drill or parade with arms in cities and towns, unless
authorized by law. That particular Illinois statute wound up getting challenged. The challenge wound
up making all the way up to the U.S. Supreme Court, and in 1886, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that
these types of laws, which make citizen military organizations illegal, do not violate the Second
Amendment. Then, about 20 years afterwards, something known as the Militia Act of 1903 was
passed into law. This piece of legislation, it created the modern framework for the National
Guard, which sits now underneath the U.S. Army, and then later also underneath the U.S. Air Force,
and it also codified a new definition of militia into the U.S. Code, creating two distinct subclasses.
According to Title 10 of the U.S. Code, Chapter 12, Subsection 246, the organized militia includes
the National Guard and the naval militia, while the unorganized militia includes all able-bodied
men between the ages of 17 and 45 who are either American citizens or have declared an intention
to become an American citizen. And so, here's exactly where we get to the heart of the matter.
The organized militia is the National Guard, while the unorganized militia consists of all
able-bodied young men. However, those able-bodied young men are not allowed to do their own thing.
That's because at the state level right now, all 50 states have some form of restrictions,
either in their state constitutions or as just statutes in the books, that limit private
paramilitary activity. Up on your screen right now is a report that came out of Georgetown University
titled, Prohibiting Private Armies at Public Rallies. And this report, it identifies four
different types of anti-militia laws that exist throughout the U.S., as well as which particular
states have those laws enacted. The first type is a constitutional provision that requires military
activity to be governed by civil authorities. 48 states have that provision written into their
state constitution. The second is a statute that prohibits private militia activity without the
authorization of a state government, which 29 states have in the books. The third is a type
of statute that's on the books in 25 states, which criminalizes certain paramilitary activity,
such as conducting public drills, as well as demonstrating the use of either firearms or
techniques that are capable of causing death. And the fourth type of law is a prohibition on falsely
assuming the uniforms or functions of law enforcement. 17 different states have these
false assumption statutes on the books. And so, as you can see, all 50 states have at least two of
these prohibitions. Some states have all four. And these different laws have the combined effect
of making it pretty much illegal for paramilitary groups to do almost anything in public.
Although, this is exactly where you begin to brush up against the First Amendment.
Because if you think about it, if I'm allowed to own a gun, and my friend Dave is also allowed to
own a gun, and Mike is also allowed to own a gun, and we're all allowed to train with our respect
of firearms, and then, as per the First Amendment, we're all allowed to associate with each other
at what exact point does our association and exercise of our rights cross the line into
illegal paramilitary activity? For instance, what if we go into the woods to practice shooting?
Or what if we form something like a volunteer search and rescue group, and we all carry guns
for defense against bears and coyotes? Or perhaps even more pertinent, what if me and my buddies
all happen to live in an open carry state, and we all want to go to a protest, and we all happen to
bring our rifles? Does all that fall under the purview of these laws? Because each one of those
things is a legal activity. At what specific point does it cross the line and become illegal
paramilitary activity? Well, to answer some of those questions, Congress recently held a meeting.
Specifically, after several events, after the alleged kidnapping plot against Governor Gretchen
Whitmer, after the shooting deaths over in Kenosha, Wisconsin with Kyle Rittenhouse, as well as after
what took place on January 6th, all these events, they, you can say, reignited the efforts of those
on the political left to crack down on militia groups, groups that they claim are instigating
violence and suppressing people's rights. And along that line, the House Subcommittee on Civil Rights
and Civil Liberties, they held a meeting to quote, examine the role of militia groups in the current
rise of right-wing extremism. This congressional meeting was held in May of 2021. It was led by
Democratic Congressman Jamie Raskin, and it was conducted under the banner of several different
meetings that are confronting violent white supremacy, something that the DHS claims is
the biggest domestic threat currently facing U.S. security. And during this meeting, you had
Ms. Mary McCord, who is both a former federal prosecutor, as well as the woman who was behind
this report right here, which detailed the anti-militia laws throughout the U.S., and here's
what she said regarding the legal framework that's currently in place in the U.S. in respect to
militias. And for your reference, I'm going to speed up the clip just a little bit so that we can get
through it faster. Unfortunately, there is a widespread misunderstanding that private militias
are constitutionally protected, but private militias are not authorized by federal or state
law. They are not protected by the Second Amendment, and they are unlawful in all 50 states.
First, since before the founding, well-regulated has always meant regulated by the government.
Historically, the militia consisted of all able-bodied men who could be called forth by the
governor. The well-regulation of the militia was baked into the U.S. Constitution, which gives
Congress the power to organize, arm, and discipline the militia, a power it exercised by authorizing
the state militias answerable to state governments. And it was baked into the constitutions of nearly
every state, which required that the military always be strictly subordinate to and governed
by the civil authority. Second, the Supreme Court has been clear since 1886 that the Second Amendment
does not protect private militias and that states must be able to ban them as necessary to the
public peace, safety, and good order. The Supreme Court reiterated this in 2008 in District of
Columbia v. Seller, which held for the first time that the Second Amendment protects an individual
right to bear arms for self-defense. Justice Antonin Scalia, writing for the majority,
pointedly contrasted that individual right with paramilitary activity, restating that the Second
Amendment does not prevent the prohibition of private paramilitary organizations. And third,
all 50 states prohibit private militias, whether through their state constitutions or other state
laws. However, despite that fact, there are well over a hundred militia groups currently active
throughout the U.S. doing everything from patrolling the streets during protests,
to marching in the streets themselves, to trying to keep businesses saved during riots,
to even going down to the U.S. southern border and helping border patrol to stop illegal migrants
from being able to pass through. There is even a large all-black militia group currently active
that has a stated purpose of creating their own state within a state. Peering by the hundreds at
protests from Stone Mountain, Georgia, to Louisville, Kentucky, demanding justice for
police killings and countering what they believe is the threat of right-wing militias.
It's a movement started in 2017 by this man, former musician and Army veteran John
Grandmaster J. Johnson. What makes us so different is that our goal is our own government,
our own country, a place where we can determine our own future. Is violence an option to reach
your goals? The United States was built on violence being an option. Violence should be the
last option. And notice something, these militias are operating out in the open. They are giving
interviews to the media and very often at events, they are marching right alongside the police.
And this is happening because despite the myriad of laws on the books throughout all 50 states,
well, these laws are very rarely enforced. And there's a number of reasons for why that is.
And here's again, Ms. Mary McCord speaking to Congress describing some of them.
These state laws are rarely enforced. They're not well known to local law enforcement.
Some local officials lack access to information to build cases or mistakenly believe that private
militia activity is constitutionally protected. And some local officials lack the political will
to enforce anti-militia laws, especially in areas with a high number of militia voters.
Congress should consider a federal anti-militia law. A federal law prohibiting private militia
activity in public while armed could provide a civil enforcement mechanism in addition to
criminal penalties, allowing the U.S. Department of Justice to seek injunctive relief and civil
forfeiture against armed paramilitary actors and their organizations. And that's exactly what
happened. Shortly after that congressional meeting, the Preventing Private Paramilitary
Activity Act of 2024 was introduced to both the House as well as the Senate. It now has 10
co-sponsors, all Democrats. And if passed, it would empower the federal government to prosecute
those people who are engaged in militia activities. Because right now, the federal government cannot do
it. It is a state issue. But with this law, if it were to pass, the DOJ can step in and prosecute
the people who either start or join militia groups. Now, as to whether this bill can actually
pass into law, it's doubtful. Right now, it's dead in the water. It will not make it past a
Republican-controlled House or even a split Senate. However, in the future, you never know. With these
types of things, you have one event that sparks public outrage, and all of a sudden, politicians
fall into line and they can pass legislation through like that. Regardless, though, that is
where we currently stand. All 50 states have laws in the books that ban organized paramilitary
activity in some way. It differs from state to state, but by and large, forming what we commonly
understand as a militia group is technically illegal. However, the laws against it are rarely,
if ever, enforced. And if they were to be enforced, there might very likely be an appeals process that
would reach all the way up to the U.S. Supreme Court. Because on the face of it, many of these
laws do seem to be in conflict with the First Amendment. Now, looking through the reams of
legal case files, the most recent case that's even remotely relevant to our discussion
was from 2017, where Ms. Mary McCord, the woman who was in that video speaking to Congress,
she sued several of the militia groups that showed up in Charlottesville.
She used the anti-militia laws in Virginia as the basis of her lawsuit. However, that case of hers
wound up getting settled, and so it's unclear how it would have actually played out in court
and through the appeals process. Regardless, that is the situation as it currently stands.
If you'd like to dig through my research for yourself, I'll throw those notes down into the
description box below this video if you're the type of person that likes to dig into the weeds.
And then also, I would love to know your thoughts. Because there really are two different ways to
look at it, like anything else. On the one hand, it appears that if you go by the intention of
the Founding Fathers, well, I don't know if you can say that their intention would have been to
Because it would seem that there's no reason to assume that the federal government and your local
state government could both turn tyrannical. And then what? You don't have a militia to defend
yourself? So it doesn't seem plausible that the only man that the state government would have a
monopoly on militias. However, on the flip side, it would be hard to have a normally functioning
if anybody who wishes to at any given time can form their own roaming militia and patrol the
streets with open carry guns if they so wish. So I guess there would be a balancing act. And as of
right now, and for the last 250 years, the courts have interpreted it to mean that militia power
should belong to the states. But I'd love to know your thoughts. Do you think that's correct? Or do
you think that goes directly against what the Founding Fathers intended? Please leave your
thoughts in the comment section below. I'll be reading through them later today, as well as
throughout the rest of the week. And then until next time, I'm your host, Roman from the Epoch
Times. Stay informed. And most importantly, stay free.