Lecture 29 : Forgetting - V

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
Sep 21, 2024
This lecture discussed slip of actions, source monitoring failures and its forms, suggestibility, bias and false memories.
Hello, I welcome you all in the lecture series of memory. In previous lecture we discussed about
forgetting and in forgetting we were talking about the concept of source monitoring failure.
Now why these sources monitoring failure happens is because of several reasons. Why is it important
in forgetting? As we know that forgetting help us to remove the trash, unwanted information,
irrelevant information from our memory system. If this doesn't happen then we may be inclined
to get confused with lot of information about what we had in the breakfast last several days,
weeks, months with what did we had in the lunch and what did we had in the dinner,
mix of information. If this filtering of information, if this washing of information
will not happen then person will be getting confused and it will be bit chaotic for an
individual to execute day-to-day task. So forgetting in some instances seems to be
a beneficial factor in human memory. So when we were talking about the monitoring
we discussed about it that how we monitor the sources. The monitoring of sources depends on
familiarity, frequency, dominance. But what happens when this monitoring
fails? What happens when this failure, to what extent it affects the human memory?
Now to discuss this, the first point is knew-it-along effect or hindsight effect.
Knew-it-along effect says that the term for when people report their information before
they truly did. What does this mean? What does this mean is that they do have an understanding
that this is going to be the information related to the question which has been put forward to them
or the task which has been put to them. Now in such instances what we have seen,
context seems to play a major role. Context provides lot of insight to an individual
and this is exactly the same thing which we have been discussing in the semantic memory.
Once you have learned something or once you have information about something, then how we are
storing the information, we store information in relation, in association. So when this association,
when this relationship is established, then people tend to know this information
before they truly experience the information. So information has not been experienced yet,
reality monitoring is not there at all but because of their prior experience, it happened.
And people believe that they knew this information prior hand. Now in addition to this,
there is another form of failure, cryptoamnesia. What is this? It is an act of unintentionally
presenting an idea as one's own idea. Something which you have encountered and you did not pay
attention to it, towards it, but unconsciously you have registered that information.
And that unconscious collection of information which unconsciously you have collected it,
you stored it, after several time has passed, days, weeks, months, years,
you brought that information from your unconscious mind and then you present it as your own.
So it is a form of plagiarism, it is a form of plagiarism but without your,
having an intent about it, without knowing about it, that it has been done.
So in many instances we have believed this cryptoamnesia where it has been observed is
in the music industry, where people repeatedly has listened a song, a rhythm, a melody and after
several years that form of melody, the rhythm, the piece of that small pleasant music,
start getting reflected in their original composition of music. So this cryptoamnesia,
and this is not intentional by the way, as I mentioned earlier, so this is an unintentional
thing. Source in the individual believes that the idea has been originated with him or her,
but in fact it was there in the system from some place. Now this becomes very difficult also
to trace down when and at what time you have registered or encoded this information.
Another form of source monitoring failure is reality monitoring. The judgment of whether
memory was something which you have truly experienced it or it was something you have
imagined it, such as a dream. So this has been a challenge in many instances, at many instances.
People do believe that the information which they have collected, they have experienced it.
For instance, every now and then we are sitting in front of the television, roaming around on the
streets and we experience lot and lot of information related to vacations. And then we are
looking people undergoing several vacations, people are travelling, people are travelling
inland or outside the country. Such immersive experience,
sometimes sitting in front of the television, it becomes very difficult for them to distinguish
if that experience which they are feeling it is actually their experience or something
which they may have been dreaming about it. Such understanding people feel has been
a part of reality monitoring. And reality monitoring is,
ensures the check that what is real and what is not real. Reality monitoring ensures
what you have truly experienced it and what you have not experienced it but you have just
learned it or you may have collected the information and you have imagined it
altogether. In another such failure is the confabulation.
Confabulation is fully imagine the memory which is not real at all and is usually made to cover
up the loss of memory. Confabulation has been seen with those individuals who are having
Korsgaard syndrome. And earlier we have discussed about the chronic alcoholism.
This chronic alcoholism leads towards the amnesia, the loss of memory, loss of information.
And when this loss of information is there, individual try to fill these gaps.
How do they fill these gaps? They fill these gaps with some made-up information,
the information which they can collect it or provide it which is not so real, which has not
happened. So here people just imagine that something has happened but actually in the real
sense it truly does not exist and they just try to fill those gaps. So confabulation seems to have
that side to it and many a time in the case of law people confess with this imagined memory
and they try to add just to ensure that they should not be raising, people should not be
raising a question to them what has happened, where the information has been lost.
And many a time people intentionally do this thing knowing the fact that they do not have,
they lack that amount of information. And to fill those lack of information they provide some
additional information. Taking this conversation further down the line with respect to forgetting,
we have also seen that there is some biasness. How this biasness is there?
Certain social situations present us with pressure to confirm our memories as well.
What are those situations? You are attending a birthday party of your dear one,
you are attending a wedding party of your dear one, you are attending an anniversary
party of your dear one. In such instances the demand to recollect the information
from a stored information is very high. To fulfil this demand of recollection of information
many a time people are biased towards certain context, certain familiarity, certain dominant,
certain frequency of information. Context definitely provides an insight to an individual
and has been very helpful to the individual in order to overcome the loss of information.
One such instance is the concept is the embellishment which denotes that the change
and addition, changes and addition or addition of information, addition of new information,
we make to a memory as a part of retrieval. And it is very quite common. When somebody
asks you 10 years ago do you remember our social gathering, we were having this and that event
and you were dancing. Do you remember the song you were singing that time? Now that time you
may not be recollecting the proper, you may not have the recollection of information.
In order to do so you tend to provide an information where you are certain inclined to,
you have a biasness towards it. So in such instances people tend to give their most
favourite song. Okay this is the song which I was playing or this is the song which I was singing
or this is the song I might have suggested. So what we understand is that many instances
social situation assist us and sometimes also create pressure,
create pressure to impress or entertain. So that we update our memory, we add information
in our memory, we add information our stored memory to please our audience.
And this addition or subtraction, this modification which we are making into our stored memory
is the embellishment. Now the act of enhancing a story changes the later retrieval as well.
Why? Because some information which you have stored or consolidated had a different impression
altogether. So if we take the circle and this line, if this figure as our initial memory
and if we do modification in these and if this undergoes embellishment then what will happen?
The memory which was this, we have added information, the grids and this is the new
memory. Now when we have done the modification in order to enhance this story, this story sorry,
to enhance this initial memory story, we have made these changes and when we have made these changes
the retrieval of this new memory will not be a retrieval.
If this is retrieval 1, then this will be retrieval 2. If we have to retrieve this,
for this retrieval we may need this information, but for this retrieval we need this information
because the addition has already happened. Some may say let us do the subtraction,
so you just talk about this. This is also new memory. If we are referring this as new memory
1, then we can say this is new memory 2. What is the modification? Grids are gone,
lines are gone, sorry not the grids, lines are gone. So the retrieval will also change
because the story has changed. So the classical experiment done by Bartlett
which we have discussed earlier also in relation to embellishment,
Tversky and colleagues asked people to retell a story in accurate and entertaining ways.
In an accurate and entertaining ways, they tried to add information to make the story more and more
pleasant, to enhance and enrich the story. They started to add more and more information
and what they found? They found that retrieval was affected by embellishment. More and more addition,
more and more subtraction an individual did, the retrieval also changed.
So recognition stayed the same, but the retrieval changed. In recognition, we are not
doing the recall, recollecting the information. In recognition, we are matching the information.
We are matching the information which is already present. So the matching of information,
if we are talking about a story, about a cow and a sheep, then we just have to match what is sheep
and what is cow. This information, this fact will not change. It was a sunny day, it will not change.
But when we are talking about the retrieval, the recollection of information after embellishment,
then what we will see? It depends on the content, context, frequency, familiarity,
dominance of the information as well. In relation to this, what we have also seen?
Forgetting. Many instances, as we were discussing, that forgetting assessed the individual.
In some case, memories do not exist at all, but individual tried to create the memories.
They construct these memories. And once they construct the memory, these individuals believe
that yes, the information is there. It might have been there. I may be able to forget the
information. I may have a tendency not to recollect detailed information, but the information might
have been there. And this becomes really difficult and challenging. As we were discussing earlier
about the imagined memory versus truly experienced. So here, while the recollection
of information, something which you have truly experienced, while recollecting the truly
experienced information, you may have some bits and pieces. You may have, you may also
lose some information. And in order to fill those gaps, you add some information. While doing so,
you are mixing the truly experienced memory with the non-experienced memory together.
As a result, the memory which is shaping up collectively becomes a false memory.
So which does not really exist or truly an individual has experienced. So memory
that are simply not true, but as they are. So constructive nature of the memory.
False memory test, these Roediger and McDermott did a very brave study. And what they did in
this study, which was being proposed as a procedure, DRM procedure. And in this simple
procedure to test the false memory, participants were being provided the list of words.
The list of words such as sand, water, waves. Now when the individual
sees the list of sand, water, waves, he or she starts connecting them together.
And when the participant is being asked to recall the associated words on that list,
participant mistakenly recall beach. Why? Because beach is associated with sand,
at beach you get water, and at beach only you see the sea waves. So participant created a
false memory here, created a false memory for this word. The word on the list seemed to activate the
missing words strongly enough that it would be required to. So on the list, even the word
does not exist, but participant tend to believe, participant tend to strongly biased that those
words are also there on the list. So when we talk about baking a cake,
cake, sugar, flour, yeast, and then this such list is given to them. They will be inclined to recall
egg or milk, without which you cannot prepare. So such false creation of memory is happening
because of their inclination. Because they tend to activate those items,
those informations also which would be present but were not being associated with the task itself.
And this is what mostly happens. These are the fillers, you know you fill the information.
Because there is a loss in information, loss of information has happened and in order to fulfill
those gaps and losses, you tend to provide some non-experienced or non-existential
experience of information there. Now the missing word, another thing,
the missing word is like a lure that can trick participants and believing that it was there on
the list. As we told you, now participant feel that there might have been, such information might
have been there. So Reminger and McDormand when they proposed this monologue DRM, they also found
participants were confident that the lures were originally on that list. Even when they were told
that the participants not to guess, but still they believed that that information was there.
Now this, why this association, because we discussed this earlier also, when we are storing
the information, when we are doing the encoding, when we are doing the registry of this information,
for the easiness, we do it in association of information. So when a word we are talking about
water, so water alone has many associations with many words, sun, plant, life, H2O,
holy, India, oceans, drinks, universal solvent, etc and etc. This is how the association is
happening. And this is mostly because of our semantic memory and this seems to be
getting activated over the line. So the recall of the lure is viewed as kind of false memory.
The lure, the thing which is making you biased, that such thing is there on the list itself,
is actually assisting in the creation of false memory. So what we have learned in this session
of forgetting is the forms of source monitoring failure, how the monitoring failure is happening.
Then we also discussed about the suggestibility and biasness and the false memories. With this,
we are ending the session on forgetting. And in the next session, we are going to start
the new topic. The new topic for our discussion will be memory disorders. And in memory disorders,
we are going to study few case studies. With this, we end this session. Thank you.
Thank you.
