Ranking Member Scott Votes “NO” on Extreme Bill to Rollback Students’ Rights

Committee on Education & the Workforce Democrats
56 followers
Sep 19, 2024
I rise to oppose H.R. 3724, what my Republican colleagues call the In Woke Higher Education Act.
H.R. 3724 attempts to circumvent the First Amendment to establish a whole new scheme
to regulate speech and association rights on campus outside of established precedents and practices.
The First Amendment protects some of our most deeply cherished rights as Americans.
Any student currently who believes the First Amendment rights are being violated
can bring a federal case against the public college or university.
In doing so, they have over 200 years of precedent and case law
that carefully define and determine what those rights are under the First Amendment.
This includes presidents that specifically address the unique nature of colleges and universities
as public entities that both must uphold constitutional rights
and must provide students with the safe learning environments.
But with today's bill, the majority would have us throw out all of the centuries of case law
and replace it with a hastily drafted substitute that claims to remove barriers that limit constitutional rights.
What the bill actually does is make public colleges and universities who would be acting on good faith
attempting to protect the safety and security of everyone present on their campus
subject to monetary judgments and possible loss of Title IV student aid
counter to Supreme Court precedent.
In so doing, my colleagues who purport to favor limited government are micromanaging
how colleges and universities must handle their internal governance processes.
Another one of the harmful misguided policies contained in the bill
creates a license for religious student organizations and public institutions
to discriminate against LGBTQ plus and other students
by allowing these organizations to avoid non-discrimination requirements
that apply to all other student clubs funded by student activity fees.
Student groups are essentially part of the college experience,
but if this bill becomes law, minority students would be forced to subsidize student groups
that discriminate against them.
In addition to micromanaging how college campuses dispute the First Amendment cases,
this bill would undermine the legitimacy of the college accreditation process.
For decades, federally recognized accreditors have served as one-third of the oversight triad
of the U.S. higher education system, along with states and the federal government.
Accreditation has meant to be the gold standard for college quality and performance.
After all, accreditation is a gateway to billions of dollars of federal student aid each year.
And I recognize that accreditation systems need improvement,
but unfortunately, H.R. 3724 does not make constructive reforms.
Rather, it is a baseless attempt to inject culture wars into an ever-important accreditation process.
For example, the, quote, prohibition on litmus tests invites additional federal oversight
into the accreditation process.
Under this bill, accreditors may not assess a school's commitment to any, quote,
ideology, belief, or viewpoint.
The majority complains that this will prevent a school from losing accreditation
if they do not have a diversity, equity, and inclusion office.
The reality is that there is no evidence that that's happening.
There are, conversely, several examples of state officials pressuring schools not to teach certain classes
or hold subjects that they believe cross the line between academic pursuit and ideological beliefs.
That's why the bill is so dangerous.
For example, under this bill,
the Department of Education could potentially revoke an accreditor's recognition
if that accreditor required science programs to teach evolution.
And if the accreditor said, no, you've got to teach, if it's science, you've got to teach evolution,
the department could potentially revoke the accreditation,
suggesting that such standards were an attempt to force a university
to commit to a specific partisan political or ideological viewpoint or belief.
Well, I think the fundamental basis of science,
that the accreditors ought to have the option of requiring if you're going to teach a science course.
H.R. 3724 represents a solution in search of a problem,
fundamentally seeks to undermine students' First Amendment rights
and the right to be able to join a student organization free of discrimination,
and it undermines our accreditation system.
So I oppose the bill and reserve the balance.
