The 11th Circuit Court of Appeals has reinstated a ban on the federal government’s Title IX rule in four states, namely Georgia, Alabama, Florida, and South Carolina.
And the courts have dealt another setback to the federal government's Title IX rule in four states.
The education department says the rule offers vital protections against sex discrimination.
However, free speech advocates are concerned about the introduction
of gender ideology into the provision.
The rule is part of the Civil Rights Act that was passed in the 1970s.
We'll learn more about the impact of this court ruling from Sharice Trump.
She's the executive director of Speech First.
Yeah, absolutely.
So we're very excited actually to announce that the 11th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals
is actually granted what's called a preliminary injunction against the DOJ and the Biden
administration's Title IX in favor of Speech First, Alabama, Georgia, Florida, and South Carolina,
Parents Defending Education, and Independent Women's Forum.
We are all involved in this lawsuit to protect our students in those states.
And when the court granted this, what this means, it's a very important first step
in preventing this policy from taking place.
And this first step is essentially the prevention of that policy being enforced in any school system
or in any public university campus or anyone who takes federal funding that has a Title IX policy.
The new Title IX policy cannot be enforced as long as we are in the process of litigation.
And that is what we are excited about because right now our students in those states are
protected just as much as the other students in the 20, I believe 22 states that have also
sued and been granted preliminary injunctions in this case.
And on that note, Cherise, K-12 Dive says that this latest ruling means that these states have
a substantial likelihood of being successful in arguing the case.
Your comment on that or just what are the free speech concerns surrounding this?
Yeah, our major free speech concerns have a lot to do with the addition of gender identity as a
protected class and the removal of a very important free speech protection that was
in the previous policy that's called the Davis Standard.
And the Biden-Harris administration completely gutted that and removed all free speech protections
that were in that policy. So now we're in a situation where if you don't use someone's
preferred pronoun or you don't use someone's, you know, you don't use certain gender affirmation
language, then suddenly you can be actually accused of a Title IX sexual harassment claim
and processed to the fullest extent of the policy and even maybe the law according to
whatever state you're in. So this is seriously concerning for a lot of students who simply
don't believe in maybe this LGBTQ movement. They don't believe in transgenderism and they
want to be able to speak out against it or they want to be able to speak out against
men participating in women's sports. They want to be able to use whatever pronouns are
grammatically correct rather than someone's preferred pronoun. However, all of this is
protected speech under the constitution. But the Title IX policy says that unfortunately,
they are going to be removed of those rights. And so that is what speech first is primarily
concerned of with regards to free speech. And I'll say that in the 11th Circuit decision,
they even noted, they acknowledged our previous precedent that we had set in that circuit
against University of Central Florida. Previously, we won a case in two years ago against University
of Central Florida's discriminatory harassment policy that specifically targeted constitutionally
protected speech in the very similar manner. And the court this time around said that the
Title IX policy does show some serious First Amendment concerns. So that is where we're
standing right now. We are very confident going forward in this and we're looking forward
to the court's ultimate decision. And this is not the first blow by the appellate division
to the Title IX rule that Biden rolled out back in April. So Cherise Trump,
the Executive Director of Speech First, thank you. Thank you.