21 Video Views·Jan 13, 2024 #asatru #pagan #vikings Tom Kaye of the University of Oslo presents "towards a pagan ontology" at the Pre-Christian Religions of the North Conference, hosted in Oslo on the 10th of November 2023.
Follow the UiO Student Conference on Pre-Christian Beliefs Facebook Page for updates, more clips and videos, and updates for when and where the next student conference will be:
https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61555338394038
Sacred versus Profane. A clear and well entrenched dualism which rests at the heart of the study of past religions, inhabiting both the archaeological and historical approaches. The whole discipline is replete with dualistic modes of thought. Such a model pervades the majority of theory, from concept of “liminal space” to that of the Other-World model set out by stalwarts in the study in pre-Christian religion such as Jens Peter Schjødt, John Lindow and Simon Nygaard. This has certainly achieved much, but the issue arises as to how relevant these dualist modes of thought are to a polytheistic religion that actively defies such dogmatic and easy categorisations.
Indeed, many of these theories and models which one encounters within the field arise from a fundamental assumption at the heart of the field, a certain equivocation of religion with culture. That is religion is a subset of culture, a human creation, which exists separate from “nature” in what is typically labelled as the Nature – Culture divide. Or put simply, religion is separate from the material world that is “out there” and shared by all, as a product of a specific subset of humanity and their shared imagination. As such all manner of social constructivist and essentialist models can be applied onto religions of the past as they all fundamentally share an identical material world that exists “out there” and is objectively measurable. However, this divide is fundamentally a production of a modern Cartesian and Christian inspired system of thought which I seek to present as having no grounds to be applied to the pre-Christian past. In this presentation I will question the validity of studying and understanding Norsemen according to our own fundamental assumptions about the world and reality that are present not only the individual scholar but in the wider discipline as through its dualist approaches. That is, I present that a fundamental obstacle to understanding pre-Christian religion is of an ontological nature – the fundamental assumptions and classifications we make about the world.
I argue that a solution can be found in the recent Ontological Turn seen in anthropology espoused by key theorists such as Eduardo Viveiros de Castro and Martin Holbraad. Drawing off the non-dualism of Phillipe Descola, these approaches give primacy to their respective objects of study as a news means of theorising key assumptions or categories about the world. That is, one turns their object of study to supply an ontology for them as opposed to the typical assumptions of the scholar and their subject. As such I seek to present a turn towards a pagan ontology formulated off the source base that allows for new understandings and perspectives that differ on a fundamental level. Such would allow us to reconceptualise key elements and components such as sacrifice.
This to see different things within the pre-Christian past on its own terms, rather than the seeing things differently of reflexive approaches within the field.
See other videos from this year's Student Conference on Pre-Christian Religion here:
*COMING SOON*
See videos from the previous Student Conference on Pre-Christian Religion here:
The frenzied warbands of Odin - Tom Kaye:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aRgTaPjrfo8
An Introduction to Pre-Christian Frisian Religion - Hilbert Vinkenoog:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V4c4g7BanSo
An Analysis of the Viking's Paganism - Jonathan Fischler:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lraU1Vyd_dY&t=739s
Music Used:
Impact Allegratto - Kevin MacLeod
The Pyre - Kevin MacLeod
Raid the Merch Market:
https://teespring.com/en-GB/stores/history-with-hilberts-market
Go Fund My Windmills (Patreon):
https://www.patreon.com/HistorywithHilbert
Join in the Banter on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/HistorywHilbert
Enter the Fray on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/HistorywHilbert/
Indulge in some Instagram..?(the alliteration needs to stop):
https://www.instagram.com/historywithhilbert/
Send me an email if you'd be interested in doing a collaboration! [email protected]
#asatru #pagan #vikings
so once again thank you all very much
for coming I will now introduce our
first Speaker who is Tom K now uh Tom is
uh from the uh hallowed Isles of of of
England of Britain uh and he is doing a
masters right here in Oslo at the
University in Viking and medieval
studies and today he's going to be
presenting towards a pagan ontology so
Tom please take it away hello
everyone oh but please stand here so
that the chat could hear yes perfect
thank you so uh I've uh come to booll
with a bit of a theory in regards to our
subject but uh we get this started so
I'm got the rather you know uh h
Title Here towards Pagan ontology but
moving away from that I'd like to start
this all with a simple question how can
we possibly understand the pre-christian
past as moderns well the past that we're
looking at here is extremely different
from our Modern Life worlds and Concepts
theories and ideas it is so drastically
different and as such how can we even
begin to understand and perceive a lot
of the sources that are available to us
and how can we even begin to go about
constructing ideas such as religions or
concepts or beliefs and the like uh
indeed this is especially the case with
uh pre-christian religion because to the
modern mind it deals exclusively with
things like morals ideologies and the
like and also appears often at times
quite nonsensical illogical cryptic or
even horrific and I'd like to in essence
question how we can go about dealing
with
this so in order to do this I'm going to
have a brief discussion of the
terminology surrounding the subject as a
point of entry to try and get you guys
thinking about uh what influences the
way we understand things and how we go
about understanding things uh following
this I'm going to go over a typical
Solution profited by historians of
religion to this problem of
understanding and the issue of
terminology and then I'm going to
address why this is
unsatisfactory and why new approaches
are needed and from this I'm going to
have a brief overview of the ontological
turn as the solution with a couple of
examples just to give you guys an idea
of what I'm talking
about so we turn towards the issue at
hand and something that allows us to
explore how we go about understanding
the past and that is terminology and
yeah the difficulty in understanding
this past is apparent Even in our most
basic terminology in reference to it
whereby the uh beliefs and practices of
the IR and Germanic age peoples are just
so uh our understanding of it is defined
by our categor categorizations of it and
there the terms pre-christian and
religion which are typically used within
the scholarship to Define this
historical phenomena come with
considerable baggage and preconceptions
that may affect our understanding of
these past
peoples so we turn towards the first
term that we use to refer to this past
and understand it and that is
pre-christian uh this is used
extensively in the academic field as a
means of avoiding a the pejorative
associations of pagan or Heathen because
these were often words used by uh
Christians in reference to the uh
beliefs that came beforehand and as such
often have some uh connotations of
immorality and the like though this is
starting to change in the uh modern
field the problem with the concept
concept of pre-christian is it creates a
theological understanding of history and
for those in the room who don't know
what theological means it's an Essence
refers to uh an idea of History whereby
everything logically kind of comes up to
a single point in the now so this in the
case of this it implies that the pagans
are always going to convert they were
always going to become Christian and
they were just waiting the transition to
Christianity which is not a very good
way at looking at
history and also so this definition is
necessarily negative it is defined in
opposition to Christianity and as such
will always be understood in relation to
Christianity rather than as a valid and
uh complicated system of beliefs and
ideas in its own right and it's also not
that precise when you say pre-christian
that can be anything from the Viking age
right into the Bronze Age that's nearly
a thousand years worth of history that
you know that's an extended amount of
time that we can refer to so we need to
in essence start to change up our ideas
and terminology for this so as see even
the simple basic concept of how we go
about labeling it makes things pretty
complicated and affects the way we
understand it and now I'm going to be
turning towards the second uh key uh
point that allows us to kind of get to
grips more with the question of how
about we go how about we go about
understanding this pre-christian task
and that is religion and this is where
we get a significant uh significant more
baggage associated with it because the
idea that we have today of religions
with its Associated moralities holy
books Dogma churches and all of this as
a kind of discrete structure would have
been wholly alien to the average person
living in the uh Iron Age and Viking age
Scandinavia in uh the fact that you
could even separate beliefs or concept
is something that can be labeled even to
them would have been completely and
wholly strange and bizarre to them it
would have been simple everyday habits
or practices and a good example of this
uh concept existing similarly is when
for instance the uh English colonized
India they uh uh that's when the concept
of Hinduism as a like discreet entity
that can be labeled appeared for the
first time whereas beforehand it had
simply just been practices which had
existed for thousands of years and
didn't need labeling into this discret
entity it's only with the arrival of
judeo-christian Concepts in relevance to
Dogma that they felt the need to label
it and we are seeing a similar situation
with the uh beliefs of the iron and
Viking age whereby this is not a
discrete entity and it is one where with
considerable variation and it would have
been conceived of as not being a
separate discret
thing and as such I want to kind of ask
the question can we even describe this
collection of ideas and Concepts as
being religion it's something to
question and academics have recognized
that our modern understanding of
religion doesn't really map onto the
past too well and that as such have gone
about readdressing it or redefining it
in order to address this
problem and the typical solution as is
uh presented here
is one uh that I'm taking from the
pre-christian religions of the north
book which is this ganton volume and
about most up-to-date scholarship on the
concept on the concept surrounding it
and is where it's one of the key reasons
why we use all of the terminology of
pre-christian today at least within the
field and uh I'm going off uh Yen petot
who's a Titan in the field is a going
off his definition and he presents that
religion is a
worldview uh I very kind of similar to
culture and he uh separates this concept
of The Wealthy by connecting it to the
idea that it specifically has an other
world which is defined in opposition to
our world the this world and this uh and
in essence this is the what separates
the religious uh kind of ideology and
worldviews from the typical profane
worldviews and this is a concept which
is used commonly in the scholarship you
see for instance John Lindo us it and
Simon neod so it's one with a lot of
currency and if you remember my tri
discussion about the concept of how we
can separate religion we see potentially
an ability to separate religion founded
off its other
wealthiness however while they seem to
address the problems that we have in
approaching uh the phenomena surrounding
what we would describe as religion
within the pre-christian past this is
not enough
it when we test this model against the
source space it presents issues namely
on the fact that this very concept of an
other world creates this idea of there
being a supernatural versus natural
where you have a realm which is in
opposition to our world this world the
human world whereby all these spirits
and figures lie which is indelibly
separated and is simply the product of
human imagination and uh human idation
has no bearing in this world whereas
this world is the real measurable
objectively uh observable World which
while being very useful for a modern
perspective and you know our typical
modern way of looking at the world is
wholly in opposition to the way that
they would have well it's the way that
the people of the iron and Viking age
would have viewed the
world and as such this creates misunder
understandings and
issues and I'd like to present this as
being of an as being ontolog logical in
nature the this misunderstanding created
by such definitions that is our basist
assumptions about the world in which we
live and the way we categorize things
and I'd like to present that this
categorization of religion that's quite
common in the scholarship goes against
the way they would have categorized the
world around them and as such we have to
overcome these dualistic ontologies in
order to understand this distant
past so
why is uh this uh against the sour space
how why why am I saying that these
jistic ontologies do not work well
firstly we have many examples within the
source space of other worldly beings
existing in this world being from it or
simply traveling across it well beings
that we would describe as other worlding
obviously from the perspective of the
Viking age it may not have been so so
for
instance uh we have Alpha for instance
being described as residing within this
world and uh potentially taking on the
role of ancestors so a bit of blowing
the lines between human and spirit and
they are in they are what we describe as
supernatural beings and the world is
replete with the alpha so what is the
evidence for this well I'd like to turn
to corx Saga where we have a uh short
piece referring to a Lone Hill whereby
the AL far well within
it and this refers to the particular
character having to go there to
sacrifice her in order to uh heal
himself and as we can see in this case
we have a being that we describe as
being of a worldly and spir and you know
in essence separated from the human
world dwelling in the very World in
which the human in which we as humans
dwell and as such he has to question the
purely otherworldly nature if someone is
able to go to the landscape and interact
with these
beings furthermore it's not just in the
fact that they dwell within this
landscape in terms of questioning their
otherw worldliness but also the fact
that humans often are presented as being
related to alar either in the process of
becoming them as we have in FLA B where
King
Olaf uh is turned in a mound and
following his death is sacrificed to by
the people and we have a example of a
human being able to become an alpha and
creating this kind of ined
Bloodlines concept of beings that we
would consider to be otherworldly with
the human this world as is defined by
people like
sh it was for also a common practice
within the scul Corpus to refer to
Warriors as either murder elves or
councel elves morth elves or Roth elves
so we see this great blurring of the
Lines within the extent Corpus that is
available to us also while it must be
noted that a couple of my examples here
have come from sagas and this is very
debated within the uh scholarship in
terms of sources and I'm sure one of my
colleagues will address this very debate
about uh the relevance of sources and
how one can go about drawing conclusions
from them but my I'd like to put some
points towards certain elements within
this following a lot of the poetic ppose
so for instance the process described of
the sacrifice to the alha is very
similar to uh the uh sacrificial rights
we see described in certain perms
potentially as within Hong which my
colleague Peta will uh let you guys know
about so uh we and finally before moving
on from this concept of humans being uh
fundamentally interwoven with the what
we would consider to be Supernatural we
have a reference in in in lingal to
humans being described as being Nat
which are another creature that we would
consider to be Supernatural again Nat is
used as a means to describe both
creatures which are uh yeah again what
we would level as being otherworldly and
humans so we have to really question
whether you can separate these cre
creatures from the this world in which
we dwell that would be not understood
from a typical modern uh ontological
understanding and to further support
this uh
questioning this separation I'd like to
point towards the blurring of the lines
between humans and gods which appears
within the source space so uh for
instance we have bragi the old is who is
commonly quoted as the first scold is
where you know one of the first or the
earliest assest of scul per that we
had in small he is described as being a
God and this may this kind of bluring
the lines between historical figures and
God gods are notable furthermore it's a
common practice within the scalit Corpus
to point towards the rulers being the
descendants of gods and this idea of
rules being linked with the Divine and
the holy which again questions this very
nature of can we split this world and
the other world from one another when we
have people who are literally descended
from what we other worldly beings if we
can even say that they are otherworldly
for instance in Vela stanta 19 which is
a poem written by one of the Court Poets
of HW on yal Str a stringently pagan uh
uh ruler who very much had an active
Court producing pieces surrounding
this where he is described as the war
season generous descendant of Iger which
is one of the many Orin HEI and this is
a clear example of people being
descended being the physical
manifestations beings that we typically
consider to be other worldly and as such
can we even separate separate them in
the case that has been done with a shz
definition and note that this is a
practice common across the Germanic
cultural sphere whereby in uh in linga
Saga we have SN steron describing
various Kings as being descended from in
as well as within uh bead who describes
the mercy line of Kings as being
descended from Wen and these are
typically rejectors being uiz but I feel
if we start to question the fundamental
assumptions that we have caused by our
modern ontologies we could potentially
get closer to uh the source based and
what's presented
there so to conclude on the uh religion
as an otherw World ideology we can see
that this dualist understanding of
religion in which religion is
characterized by the this world other
world split we can see that it's wholly
inadequate to capture a complex uh
historical reality as is presented to us
within the
sources and and from
this can we even ask um you know from
this I'd like to question what what say
can we even Point towards the creatures
that have come up in this so far as
being even other worldly if they are so
present in this world and interact with
it so much and even potentially come
from it in some of the cases that we
have the blurring of the light between
humans and gods also we can question can
we even separate a religion uh from the
world if it's also so
interl so I'd like to present the
solution to this uh problem and that is
the what is variously termed the
ontological term uh as is presented by
anthropologists who encountered similar
issues when encountering their
ethnographies whereby the fundamental
assumptions of them and their field
often done according to the dualistic
lines that I've brought up gets in the
way of their understanding of the source
bases and stops them from seeing key
elements and what this purports to do is
take seriously the worldviews and
ideologies of their ethnographies and in
our case I'd like to present that we
take seriously our source base I we give
it logical Primacy we give it in essence
the idea that it becomes the ground to
which we test our assumptions and our
ontologies against and this brings me to
my first turning which
is
reflexivity is a concept which is common
already within archaeology we for
instance have Scholars like Neil price
who continuously uh test their uh
assumptions and Concepts against the
ground of the source space in order to
refigure them and the ontological turn
pulls for the same thing to do to be
done and in essence what we are doing is
we are taking our assumptions about
things like the existence of a thing
that is religion and testing it against
our source base
and seeing whether this works or not and
what we have seen so far is in our
taking our academic understanding of
religion as it exists I've taken it
tested against the source base and we've
seen that it is not uh it doesn't Accord
with it and as such we have to do
something about this because the testing
has shown it doesn't work and this is
where we come to the second key part of
the ontological tone which is
conceptualization or reconceptualization
whereby we take our ground our source
base upon seeing that our assumptions
that exist either on the personal level
or within the field do not work and we
refigure them in light of this uh Source
base and come up with new Concepts to
explain and describe this uh complex
historical
reality and in the process be able to
see things which we may not have been
able to see
beforehand so uh I'd like to uh conclude
on this and give some examples of a
reconceptualization that may be possible
so for instance we have been talking
about uh religion of this entire time
and we've shown that the concept of
religion does not fit so what if we
completely ditch the concept of religion
because we can't separate it from the
society in which uh we in which we see
the sacral and the Divine constantly
kind of be permeate the entire uh kind
of the entirety of society in which
there things that we consider to be
Supernatural part of the every day and
and they would not have understood this
understanding of separating religion as
something from it or another example
would be refiguring what we consider to
be Supernatural questioning what the
supernatural isn't even if there was a
supernatural according to the uh those
living in the iron and Viking age and
potentially refer to a uh paranormal
understanding whereby uh things are
considered to be part of this world and
part the world in which we dwell but are
but break conventions and ideas and
Norms in such a way that they become
significant and in essence I from this I
want to leave you with the idea of what
are our basis assumptions and how can we
reconfigure them how can we rethink
about things and our most fundamental
assumptions when they fly in the face of
our source base our um the realities
presented to us within it and uh thank
you and uh any questions
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
o