What Are 100-Point Rated Wines Actually Like? (All Merlot?!)

Fan Wine Cellar
14 followers
We’ve all seen them, the elusive 100-point rated wine. This selection of top-rated Merlot wines taught us a lesson about point scores and Merlot.
#wineculture, #fanwinecellar
So I just got a invite to a crazy wine tasting in Napa Valley where they've collected some of
the most expensive wines in the world and I'm gonna shoot it. So the overalls. If they want
to drink Merlot we're drinking Merlot. No if anybody orders Merlot I'm leaving. I am not
drinking any f***ing Merlot. Hey I'm here at uh this tasting is actually happening at Tambor Bay
in Calistoga in Napa and they must trust me because they left me with $13,000 in wine alone
in a room with a bunch of glassware. I can't express how ridiculous this selection of wines is.
To the untrade eyes these wines look like regular bottles but believe me they're anything but normal.
These are the wines I've only just read about in wine reviews. So I want to know what are
these wines like, what's different about these wines, and which one performs the best. And it's
not just my palate. The tasting group includes a Merlot collector and four winemakers with
decades of experience making Merlot in Napa Valley and in Bordeaux. After each blind tasting flight
we discussed tasting notes, made guesses to where we thought each wine was from, and ultimately
picked our favorites. And while opinions separated our choices there were two wines we nearly
unanimously agreed were the best. It was important to assess these wines blind because even though
these are some of the most highest rated Merlot in the world, the prices range wildly from about $100
to $4,500 a bottle. So let's find out a little bit more about each bottle. Known as Petrus this
wine comes from a 28 acre vineyard on blue clay soils in the eastern portion of Pomerol, Bordeaux.
This is arguably the most famous, most exclusive Bordeaux in the world. Also happens to be 100%
Merlot. A super Tuscan wine owned by the Antinori family that was first established in the 1980s when
a renowned Russian-American winemaking consultant Andrei Chelichev saw the blue clay soils on Masetto
Hill and urged the Antinoris to plant Merlot here. This is a rare, hard-to-get-your-hands-on family
wine of Petrus. It's made in the same vineyard as Pomerol but with barrels not selected for the
Petrus flagship Merlot. The Verity collaboration started in 1998 between the Jackson family, who
a Bordeaux winemaker. La Muse is Verity's Merlot-dominant wine made in classic Bordelais
fashion. To establish this winery, Capchandi family hired Helen Turley and John Wettlaufer
to establish their vineyards and winemaking practice. The work resulted in completely
replanting the vineyard in 2002 to take advantage of the microclimate. You can actually see how
different this vineyard is from space. This is a 30 acre vineyard sitting in Pomerol on sand over
iron-rich clay soils. The winery consulted with Michel Rolland in 2013 with winemaking director
Muriel Cazaux with the goal to make the best wine possible. San Gustio Eretinano sits at the hills
of Gaoli and Chianti on Chianti Classico on lime-glonce soils. La Ricoma comes from a demanding
site at high elevation which has been overseen for 40 years by winemaker Martini de Cigala.
Another Chianti Classico estate on limestone clay soils, La Parida, was first 100% Merlot
Super Tuscan wine which first started in 1985. This is from a seven acre single vineyard wine
very high above sea level. Despite what pricing suggests, La Ponce's isn't a second label of
Lafleur. It comes from a two acre plot within the state which is a strip of clay soils on a
predominantly gravel site. This wine has grown in Calistoga and Napa Valley since 1978. Three Palms
has 49 acres dedicated to Merlot production on low fertility loam soils. For many in the know,
it's considered one of the most age-worthy Merlot in Napa Valley. The first thing that struck me
about this selection was the high price disparity. The most expensive wine is more than 10 times more
than the least expensive wine. This is an example of the Veblen effect. It's an economics theory
where demand increases as price increases. Luxury goods capitalize on this function. You can often
find great quality for less, but because of brand recognition, the Veblen effect creates
irrationally high prices. And in the case of Petrus, the brand is so recognizable that pricing
is well above similar quality wines. So I really wonder how does Petrus perform in a blind tasting?
The second thing to note is where do the wines come from? There are four wines from a tiny
appellation in Bordeaux called Pomerol. Three wines come from Tuscany. One in Bulgari along the coast
and two in the hills of Chianti Classico. And three wines come from California, from the Napa
Valley and from Sonoma County. These three regions, Pomerol in Bordeaux, Tuscany, and the north coast
of California are the current benchmarks for Merlot and Cabernet Sauvignon. They are the stick
by which we measure all other fine wines in this category. And since these are considered benchmark
regions, I kind of want to know how they compare against each other. And lastly, the disparity
between wine ratings. When you're a wine with a rating over 90 points, the difference between 92
points and 100 points is sizable. And yet several wines had large disparities between their ratings.
But honestly, I kind of expected this. Ratings, I kind of take them with a grain of salt.
These top critics use the 100 point scale and each of them follow a different methodology
for reviewing wines as well as a different aesthetic for what makes a great wine. Not to
mention outside influences like what you ate for breakfast and the other wines in a tasting can
greatly affect your score. In fact, our tasting today has the same issue. It's influenced by a
type of bias called anchoring bias. Each wine we taste will inevitably be judged by the one before
it and not solely on its own merit. So acknowledging this bias, I have to admit, I still want to know
which one is my favorite and where my opinions lie with the critics. So the results! The two wines
that everyone thought were undeniable, even tasted blind, were Petrus and Macedo. Petrus hit the Merlot
markers perfectly. It had rich cherry chocolate fruit, a spiced floral quality, plenty of
minerality, and a savory quality with a full body and big tannins and acids that were perfectly in
balance with one another. The critics generally agreed, giving Petrus a 96 or 98 point rating.
I probably would have rated this wine higher. Macedo was the wine in a league of its own,
tasting different from all the other Merlot wines. It was rich and rustic with ripe black cherry,
lots of leather and tobacco flavors, and layers upon layers of textures over a long
lingering finish. Meanwhile, the critics lost their minds over Macedo and gave it the highest possible
score. It's true, this was no prototypical Merlot and perhaps this is why it received such high
accolades. So I had three questions answered in this tasting and I have to admit, I was surprised
Petrus was my favorite. I was kind of hoping to tell you that there was a super crazy outperforming
value that beat Petrus, but I guess if you want the best Merlot in the world, you need to save
your pennies. Still, I don't know that I would say it's 10 times better than the cheapest wine.
It was marginal gains. As far as the regions, Bordeaux, North Coast, and Tuscany, I thought each
region was exceptional. They were unique and a great place to grow Merlot. For example, Castello
d'Emma, their Laparita, could have aged for several decades. The duck corn from Napa Valley had
explosive acidity and beautiful fruit. It did not disappoint. And the Chateau Le Fleur from Palmyra
was just nice. It was everything anyone would ever want in a high-end Merlot. So for me, there was no
clear winning region. They were all great, delicious, awesome wines. Last question, did I agree with any
critics? Honestly, I came out of that tasting thinking that I don't know why critics rate wines
the way they do. For me, as long as the wine isn't flawed and I generally like it, then I back out a
layer. For example, the big one, no one ever talks about this, price. Also, if the winery is using
poisonous chemicals in their vineyards, I kind of care about that too. So these kinds of information
kind of affect my overall rating of a wine and it doesn't necessarily have to do with its overall
hedonistic appeal. As far as the argument of Cabernet versus Merlot, Jake, who worked at
Chateau Le Fleur in Palmyra, kind of says it the best. My generation, I feel like that negative
connotation with Merlot doesn't exist as much. And so people might be more willing to venture out
and try it. Merlot is one of the most beautiful grape varieties that exist and makes such
exceptional wine. So I say why not? And with that, one of the things I mentioned in this video are
Super Tuscans. This is how we have wines like Masetto, La Parida, and La Ricoma. So if you want
to learn more about Italian wine, you are going to love this story. And until next wine and next time,
happy tasting, peace out.
