Can 1 American beat 4 French? Champagne VS American sparkling wine!

Fan Wine Cellar
14 followers
One Californian sparkling wine competes with four Champagne. Could Schramberg Blanc de Blancs beat Champagnes? Bollinger, Louis Roederer, Taittinger and Nicolas Feuillatte are ready to fight!
#wineculture, #fanwinecellar
So today is the final of Sparkling Wine Olympics!
Yeah!
Not because it's the final, but because it's Sparkling Wine
We love Sparkling Wine so much
Do you remember what we have as candidates, five candidates?
Bollinger, it'd be one
Tétangé, Louis Ruedere, Nicolas Foyette
That's right
Schramsberg, 2018
And it's the final with those candidates
So four champagnes and the Schramsberg
Yeah
And... Olympic song!
Bum-bum-bum!
Sounds a little bit better than the last time
Not sure the International Olympic Committee would approve, but...
It will be approved!
Beautiful bubbles
Are you thirsty?
I'm not going to drink, but I'm interested in tasting
Probably you drink the best
Why would I do anything else?
It's true
Do you think there would be any chance for the American sparkling wine, Schramsberg, to win?
No
It's not the quality
We're human beings, right?
Yeah
We know that champagne is the best
Whether it is or it isn't
So probably here, we are going to be able to decide which of the five wines is champagne
And therefore, we'll automatically be biased against the other one
And we can never be free from that kind of bias, right?
It's very difficult
I didn't prepare black wine glasses for this final
Because it's very hard to tell the differences from the color
Yeah, none of these wines...
Yes, you can tell differences in color, but it's not a pointer
The only reason I need to see the color with tasting champagne is I look for the Blanc de Blanc
I actually went through this last night
I had a beautiful wine Valerie brought, and it was clearly Blanc de Blanc
So as soon as you start looking at something that's Blanc de Blanc
But then it doesn't taste super champagne, super expensive
Then it's probably not champagne
Because generally speaking, you pay a lot more for Blanc de Blanc champagne
That's true
Therefore, if it's Blanc de Blanc and doesn't really taste like champagne
Then it's not champagne
Or very bad champagne
I got that mosquito, Peter
Well done
Who has fed me like for three or four weeks
I don't think they lived that long
Probably their descendant
But with white wine and red wine, the color gave so much information
So I prepared black glasses
Enormous amount of information
Yeah
Look at this, Peter
Among these wines, wine No. 4 shows a very particular ring, right?
Do you think this is Nestle ring?
I've gone and tasted it
It's also the palestine color
That's true
But it's delicious
It's delicious?
It's really excellent wine
But yes, my eye is on this one for the interloper
So is this the ring that's called Nestle ring?
That was Bill Nestle's ring
That's the Nestle ring
What is it for? Can you explain it for me?
No, we can't explain it
No?
It's just something he noticed
To him, all the sparkling wines
The high quality sparkling wines from the USA
tended to have the bubbles like this at the edge
Whereas with Champagne and many others, they didn't
See, it's different from all the others
Yeah
I don't know if it means anything
Is it? You see, it's different on your glass, too
Yeah
It's clearly different
Now, does that mean Champagne can't do this?
Look what we have to go through here
A beautiful Saturday afternoon
The sun's streaming down
Five gorgeous wines
With one of my best friends sitting with me
No!
I want to go back to ****
Oh, don't include that
But you've never been in ****
That's right
If you really loved me
You could have ensured that we did this tasting
Under similar circumstances of sun, timing, and weather
But in the bush in Africa
You did not do that
And there's no real law that says you have to love your friends
There's no law, I suppose
I think we can do that in the bush
I think... I know we are going to do that
Yeah
Whether we do it on camera or not
But I know we are going to do that
Because I'm getting older
And I only want to do fun stuff now
And since I'm running out of age, out of years very quickly
I can spend the money faster
I spend the money faster because by the time they catch up with me
To take the money back, I'm dead
You're getting better and better at really bad jokes
I see no end of it
No, well, I'm glad you see no end
I see a terrible end
What if I had to drink these great wines not in the bush?
I mean, there's some catastrophes out there
Are you ready?
I'm ready
How do you want to do this?
Let's pick gold medal, silver medal, and bronze medal first
Okay, let's do it
Then can you pick three best wines from here?
Yeah, gold medal, bronze, and then the three best wines
I didn't quite get that
What he's doing with all our tastings, you've seen it now
He is deconstructing the tastings so badly or so much
That I'm not sure now that gold means number one
Silver number two, bronze number three
Okay, that connection still holds, right?
That's still valid
I don't just call this one gold, but I'll tell you I like that one the best
Okay
No, that's not the case
Just checking
Number five is my gold medal wine
Number five is your gold medal wine?
It is
I love it
You love this?
And it is not Bolognese
And I love it
It's very champagne
It's quite chewy
It's piercing, it's focused
It's got a relatively high dosage, but it hides it well
Mid-weight wine, it's gorgeous, toasty
And I've got to admit that it's my style
I don't think necessarily it's the most expensive wine here
But I think it's the best wine here
And unfortunately, I think it's the best wine for me
Why do I not feel embarrassed about saying that is
I like to think that I've drank so much champagne
That the wine that I say is the best wine for me is the best wine
I apologize if that sounds very presumptuous, but...
Too late
I don't apologize too much
Okay
After all these years and particularly working with Jay
I've earned the right to a little bit of presumption
Alright
How about you? Which is your number one?
So your best?
It's my number five, yeah
Your number five
My best is the number two
Number two
Number two was my Thai second best
I love number two
It's slightly oaky and it's minerally
And I love the complexity
It may well be more expensive
But look, I scored that 18, I scored this 17.5
We're not talking about a big deal here
I like number five, too
No, you do
I prefer the first three wines
because they show a better acidity for me
The acidity that I look for in champagne
I respect your dumb impression
Thank you
Thank you, Peter
My next best wine is number one
Number one
Yeah, and yours?
I don't think so
My next best wine is number four
Number four
Yeah
So your best is number five
Right
And number four and number two are tied
They are tied, that is correct
As second best
You can break the tie
My third best is number three
Wow, so we are so different today, right?
Oh, every now and again, you have a shit day
That's only me who has a shit day
It's already decided
What do you think they are?
Number four is the Californian wine
Yeah, I also think this is a Californian wine
I also think it's excellent
Don't you think this is a little bit too simple compared to the others?
It didn't have some of those complexities that you expect in champagne
Just from where the grapes will be
I mean, you know, that bready, yeasty
It didn't have that
It's a beautifully made wine
It's very pure
Yeah, it's a beautiful bottle of wine
I hope it's the Schramsberg
because it deserves to be in this lineup
But I think it is
I think the others show overtly champagne characteristics
For me, too, this is the only wine that doesn't show the champagne characteristics
And it had the Nestle ring
So there is the champagne, okay
I thought number two would be Louis Ruedere
It doesn't have the elegance of this wine
But they never planned it to have the elegance
They wanted the oak and the this and the that
It's a spectacular wine
For me, Boulanger shows more oxidized characteristics
So I thought number three would be Boulanger
I think number one, Tétangé
Yeah, I agree
I also think number one was Tétangé
I thought number five was Nicolas Fayet
And it's the cheap one, right?
Yeah
Last time when I bought Nicolas Fayet, it was $38
And this time, it was $29
If you'd paid $38 for it, it'd be great
You see what you did to the wine by paying too little?
The wine said, screw you
Normally, you and I are very close on quality
Today, not so much
Yeah, today not so much
You're just having a shit day
I think the bottom line we can say here is
All of these are very worthy champions
But how can we decide which ones are gold medal, silver medal, and bronze medal?
We are so different today, right?
Just take my scores
Shall we see what they are?
Let's do it
Okay, so wine number one
We agreed this one is Tétangé
Yeah, this one is Tétangé
Well done, Peter
Well done, Jay
And then wine number two
I thought it was Louis Ruedere
Well done, Jay
Louis Ruedere
And wine number three
I thought it was Boulanger
It's a Boulanger
Oh, you're having a good day, Jay
And wine number four
We thought this was Schremsberg
Okay, yep
It's a Schremsberg
2018
I can't believe it
My best wine was the cheapest one
It's Nicolas Fayette
I have a feeling that you're looking for purer and purer wine
Absolutely
That's a great value
Yeah
What was your score?
Where did it come for you?
My score for wine number five, it was 91
I thought it was very good
Excellent
Yeah
I'm surprised
And there's a new superstar for me, which is Ruedere
Nicolas, Louis Ruedere
Yeah
This one got very good evaluation last time, too
By us, right?
Yeah, it did
Ruedere is spectacular
Tétangé is nice and clean
It's very clean
Look, they're all beautiful wines
So give me the prices, Jay, please
This Tétangé?
Yeah
It's $45
Louis Ruedere, $50
Boulanger, $50
Schremsberg Blanc de Blanc 2018, $32
And Nicolas Fayette, $28, $29
It's very hard to tell which one is the winners today
It doesn't surprise me
And the reason it doesn't surprise me is
These are the Grands Armand
They live or die by the quality of their brute non-vintage
They have to blend to a house style
And to a style that their customers understand and appreciate
So notwithstanding the fact that these guys make unbelievable wines
The Tete Cuvée, this, that, and the other
The fortunes of the Maison rest on that wine
That's the biggest value and money for them, right?
And so they have to be sure they get that right
Who cares if 10 bottles of Blanc de Blanc vintage
Get scored 100 points by wines?
No, it doesn't matter to them
They can't live on that
They need Wine Spectator to score these 95
So we are really satisfied with the price quality of Nicolas Fayette, right?
We are
It's one of the cheapest Champagne
And it's delicious
And it shows exactly the Champagne characteristic
Yeah, good shit
And this Blanc de Blanc, so pure
I'm so thrilled to see a non-Champagnois wine in this lineup
And most of the great ones that are out there
Are produced by the Champagne houses, just in a different world
We would have expected this to be a Rotary USA or Mame USA
Whatever it might be
And Schramsberg said,
We can do this
But we don't care what you guys do
Of course, they taste it all the time to make sure they don't care
And we also loved wine No. 1, Tétangé, very much
Fantastic
And wine No. 2, Louis Redere, as well
Absolutely
Listen, we're drinking Champagne here, okay?
Yeah
Even if you want to make crap Champagne, you can't
The laws are so strict
You are forced by the laws, whether you like it or not, to make decent wine
That's true
Yields are controlled, aging is controlled
That's the reason why we evaluate this one of the cheapest Champagne so high, right?
Nicolas Fayette
It tastes good
That's true
It was my best wine here today
I'm embarrassed and happy
So the Grand Marques are on their game and their price point is not outrageous
The cool kid view right now is that the Grand Marques are done
They're not on their game
The best Champagne being made right now is a guy who has 3 hectares of Pinot Meunier
inside of some hill and somehow or another
That artisanal wine, that's what we need to be drinking
Bullshit!
I love your tone when you said, bullshit!
And this taste improves it
I think I need to go to bed
Not yet, Peter, not...
Please, not yet
Is it okay for you not to decide which one wins which medal today?
Because they are all very good
And today, our opinions were so different
To answer your question?
Yeah
You want to delay giving our viewers what they deserve?
You want to mess with them?
You want to annoy them?
No, I don't want to annoy you
Just checking
You want to spend a lot of weeks tasting them and tasting them and tasting them
before you come up with a result?
Yeah, right
Okay, now I understand
Good idea
But you have two weeks to do this
Because I'm going to be making Riesling in the Moselle for the next two weeks
So dry Riesling that we are going to taste
We've already tasted the basic Riesling wines and we love them
We love the producer, which means we basically love his sauces
I cannot wait to get there and make wine from those great sauces
Yeah, so Peter will be away to Germany to make great Riesling
And we'll introduce those wines to South Korea and to the United States
Absolutely, we will
And in the meanwhile, I'll have two weeks of vacation from Peter
Cheers to Schramsburg
Great job
Yeah, cheers
Great job
And we are not paid for this evaluation, right, Peter?
We are not and we will not be
We've never...
If the wine was crappy, we would have said so
We've never been paid for this kind of evaluation
Are you kidding?
There are people who are suspicious about our integrity
Really?
Yeah
We are squeaky clean in a world that is absolutely not
Yeah, that's true
So keep watching this if you want the only integrity that's left in the entire world
If you want to learn about wine seriously from Peter and me,
please click on the join button right next to the subscription box
Then click on Wine Class Join button
This is way better than any other wine school in the world
A new wine class video is uploaded once every week
And we also do a wine class on live streaming once a month
If you don't like it, you can cancel it anytime
