Can anxiety be improved by taking vitamins and other nutritional supplements?
Psychiatrist and nutritional science expert Dr. Daniel Monti gives his insights on Vital Signs with Brendon Fallon.
“Once somebody has developed true anxiety, one supplement isn’t going to be some cure-all for it. You really need to take a whole life approach to it,” says Dr. Monti.
Of course, getting the right nutrition is crucial to such a strategy. For instance, the right fats can help counter inflammation that damages brain health and function, he adds.
How much do we need and what’s the best way to get them?
While the “wrong” carbs can spike anxiety, the “right” carbs promote brain health and potentially a calmer mind.
Which super green (carbs) does Dr. Monti personally prioritize and how much is enough?
Ideally, we’d get all our nutrients through food. Due to soil depletion and other factors though, our food can be sorely nutrient lacking. This is where supplementing micronutrients comes in, says Dr. Monti.
He completes his triad of key nutrients by revealing a vitamin commonly low in people with anxiety and depression and the best way to supplement it.
Dr. Monti is professor and founding chair of the Department of Integrative Medicine and Nutritional Sciences at Thomas Jefferson University, where optimizing brain health and micronutrient therapies are among the specialty treatments offered.
Be it from work, from relationships, from study or other sources, we're all exposed to some level
of mental and emotional stress in our lives. While we can't always control those circumstances,
we can improve how our bodies and our minds respond to stress and a crucial aspect of that
is through nutrition. Today we break down nutrition for a calmer mind to its three
most basic components with the help of brain health expert Dr. Daniel Monti. Which foods
spike anxiety? How does brain inflammation disrupt calm of mind? And which nutrients
can douse the flames? Join us to probe these and other aspects of nutrition for a healthy mind.
Welcome to Vital Signs where we learn how to get healthier from all angles,
from the biochemical and nutritional to the things we do that nourish our minds and our souls.
I'm Brandon Palin. Dr. Monti is professor and founding chair of the Department of Integrative
Medicine and Nutritional Sciences at Thomas Jefferson University, where optimizing brain
health and micronutrient therapies are among the specialty treatments offered. Dr. Monti,
thank you for joining us on Vital Signs after all this time. Always a pleasure to be with you.
I'm really pleased to have you on to talk about this topic because I see you as a doctor who's
at the intersection of psychiatry and integrative medicine that looks at all these very
promising, often natural ways of resolving things like anxiety, depression. First up,
I want to start by focusing on supplements today. We've heard about different supplements like
vitamin D, like magnesium, omega-3 that can be helpful for anxiety. But if someone is
having difficulty functioning, if the anxiety is impacting them in different ways in their
day-to-day life, could they really expect supplements to have a significant effect on that?
I think your question is really leading to the importance of the answer because anxiety needs
to be addressed in a multifactorial way. Once somebody has developed true anxiety,
then one supplement isn't going to be some cure-all for it. You really need to take a
whole life approach to it. I start by looking at any possible causes of the anxiety. Is there
something going on in the person's life that is making their current anxiety levels worse?
Oftentimes, stress is a big contributing factor. And does the person have effective
means, mechanisms of coping with stress or whatever the stressful situations are? And
there's a lot of different directions we can go with that from meditation to even exercise,
but also going back to the original question about supplements, diet in general, because
people can be consuming things that make anxiety worse, such as substances that are excitatory to
the nervous system, like too much caffeine. Oftentimes, people are getting burned out
and stressed, and then they're looking to combat that with things that push the nervous system,
such as caffeine and other types of stimulants. When we do this, then we're on a perpetual
negative cycle. It can make anxiety worse. It can make coping with the stress harder
and debilitate the person over time. So what does the diet look like? What types of things
is the person consuming? So if somebody is eating a simple carb diet and grabbing
lots of convenience, starchy, sugary foods to get through the day, they're going to have these
blood sugar ups and downs, these spikes and then crashes. Those spikes and then crashes
can contribute to a feeling of anxiety and also take away from the person's overall psychological,
emotional reserve. So we need to sort of think about those macronutrients. There's the
macronutrients, so carbohydrates, fats, proteins, which need to be balanced because if they're way
out of whack, that can also lead to some issues with anxiety. And is it a balanced diet in terms
of that? Because we want to make sure that there's lots of healthy fat, to your point about
omega-3 fatty acids, even if we have to supplement that healthy fat, because those fats are
anti-inflammatory. You mentioned inflammation there, and this is something I see come up again
and again in terms of brain health. We know that inflammation is a component of mood disorders,
we know this. And in fact, even some of the medications that are used for mood disorders,
for depression, are shown to have some anti-inflammatory effect, some of them.
We know that inflammation is one of the culprits of neurodegenerative decline.
We know that inflammation is one of the culprits of Alzheimer's disease. And inflammation is made
worse by a lot of the factors that I just mentioned. In fact, some people are even calling
Alzheimer's disease type 3 diabetes because of the big contribution of metabolism. But back to
depression and anxiety, the same factors that make cognitive decline worse make depression
and anxiety worse. And I say depression and anxiety together because the two very frequently
go together. It's not typical for somebody to be experiencing significant day-to-day anxiety,
but have an upbeat mood. The two usually go together. And inflammation makes this whole
process worse. This is known. And so we want to mitigate inflammation. And one of the ways we do
that is with diet and making sure that we have enough of those anti-inflammatory foods, which
includes those omega-3 fatty acids that you mentioned, those foods that we know sustain us,
those foods that actually contribute to a more anti-inflammatory picture like leafy greens and
healthy fats, because people tend to grab comfort foods. It's a negative cycle that I
often am helping people to get out of. And we do it in a step-by-step way. And that's where
there is a role sometimes for supplementation of the healthy fats like omega-3 fatty acids.
And omega-3 seems to be a really critical component of a good diet for general brain
health, for countering inflammation and potentially reducing anxiety. But how should
people be getting this? What is the optimized way to get the omega-3 that you need?
So I'd like to get as much of it as possible from the diet, but I'm also a proponent of taking
extra omega-3 oils in different ways. So in terms of the dietary sources of them,
when it comes to animal protein sources, the preferred one is fresh fish. And there's some
that are better than others in terms of having the omega-3 fat. Salmon is rather common when
it's wild. It has better quantities of the omega-3 fat. There's others such as mackerel.
But really, I tell people, choose the ones that they like with the preference being the non-large
predatory fish. So things like swordfish are problematic because they have more mercury
content, tend to have more parasites. So the less predatory fish, some of the smaller fish.
Tilapia, on the other extreme, is problematic too. It's a smaller fish, but it tends to have
more toxins than some of the other fish. But really, there's so many options. So whether
you like snapper or bass or salmon, just go in the direction of fish. And in the preparation,
add some extra olive oil because that olive oil, which is actually omega-9 fat, but still
anti-inflammatory for a couple of different reasons, really helps with the overall picture.
So I tell people, get extra virgin, cold-pressed olive oil, put it on everything. And you can also
get healthy oil preparations in places like Whole Foods or health food markets. You'll see
in the refrigerated section, they have omega-3, 9 combinations that you can add to your food or
add to your smoothie to make sure you're getting that extra amount in because it's hard to get
enough. I add some to my smoothie here and there every day. And if you're doing that on a daily
basis, if you're getting some fish and adding some quality olive oil to different meals,
would you say that's generally enough for the average person to take care of that?
That is enough for the average person. And then when you think about snacks,
the person who's struggling with mood issues tends to, again, migrate towards those comfort
food snacks that are really pretty bad for us and have lots of chemicals and blood sugar highs and
all of that. If you can transition to things like almonds, walnuts, pumpkin seeds, nuts and seeds,
those kinds of things, not peanuts, you're going to get more of that quality fat and also some of
the other nutrients that are in those that have a stabilizing effect on blood sugar.