Hi, hi everyone. Welcome. Welcome to today's real talk. All right. Well, first of all, thank you everyone for
responding to my
Request for help this afternoon. I received a fake email
Someone with ill intention, you know telling me that YouTube has terminated my my channel and I reacted
So I and then later I realized it was a it was a fake email because the email address didn't look right
But that I got sidetracked from preparing for this live stream
Because I spent some time trying to figure out what I would do if my channel was was
Terminated, but anyways, it was a false alarm. So well, thank you everyone for for writing to me
all right, so let's see what we can do today for
Given that I have limited time to prepare for this, but we'll talk about
BYD and Tesla last year in the early of in early months of 2023. That's more than a year now
Yeah, I did two live streams
Two live streams comparing Tesla and BYD and they were quite detailed. So now I want to do a follow-up
Because you know things have changed
We all know that exporting China's excess industrial capacity is one of Beijing's
Strategies to revive its economy and Jenna Yellen was just in China to address the problem
right to address the concern that the American government has
With China's unfair this type of unfair trade practices
China's Commerce Minister Wang Wentao is in Europe right now
to address Europe's probe into
Chinese EV makers
Unfair, you know pricing
Practices by having
You know extraordinary government subsidies
so it appears that the Chinese given by what
Wang Wentao has
Signaled in Europe. It looks like China is ready to fight a trade war at least in Europe
and at the forefront of this EV war is Tesla and
BYD
Tesla is the world's leading EV maker and an American company
While BYD is China's leading EV maker
Now
This in early January
When news came out that during the last quarter of 2023
BYD officially surpassed Tesla to become the world's largest pure EV maker
by producing
42,000 more cars ahead of Tesla it created so much media attention not just in China
But also in the West
Elon Musk was forced to respond on X saying that compared with traditional automakers
Tesla's positioning is closer to that of an AI and robotics company
Although BYD lost to Tesla
In in total sales in Q1
2024 right so that was the last quarter of 23 in the following quarter the first quarter of this year
BYD lost to Tesla
But the momentum the Chinese EV makers enjoy seem
Seems to overshadow to be overshadowing Tesla
And on January 25th Tesla released its financial report for 2023
Although it delivered 1.8 million EVs
Which is a 38% increase from last year with total revenue up 19%
And it reached the total revenue reached almost
97 billion dollars
Net profit was down 23% from the previous year
Tesla retained its position as the global leader in the in the pure EV
Because BYD was closely behind with 1.57 million cars delivered
That's pure EV
Then four days later on January 29th
I think in an effort to keep the the good narratives that the publicity momentum it has
created for itself
In the early days of January
In an effort sort of to respond
Tesla's
Less than satisfactory financial results BYD released its proforma
Financial statement for the year. It's I think it's it was a forecast. It was not final the numbers looked so
illustrious that they outshined Tesla's bottom line by many folds
BYD
expected its net profit
To quote to be close to 30 billion yuan a year-over-year increase over 80% and
basic earnings per share
at 10 yuan per share compared to
5.7 yuan last year
That's a over 40% increase and BYD's total sales for the year reached 3 million
3.02 million vehicles with a growth of nearly
62% so you see it's
I
Think in my opinion, that's more of a publicity, you know, the the Chinese really know how to manipulate the public opinion
they're the master of
mind manipulation and so the Chinese media
came up with this this narrative which has been
Picked up and repeated by mainstream media in the United States as well
It basically said I'm reading you kind of a translation from the Chinese media. It says
What the Chinese media celebrated the new milestones?
the many milestones the Chinese auto companies
accomplished
last year and
So this includes BYD became the world's first new energy vehicle company selling over 3 million vehicles in a year
China's exports of new energy vehicles reached a 1.2 million
an increase of
70.77% over the previous year a historic high the country sold
9.5 million
electric vehicles
presenting
32% of total new vehicles sold
Which is basically it's saying that one in three new cars sold in China was an EV
Last year and China also overtook Japan and became the world's largest auto export country
by exporting nearly
5 million cars
So
so all the buzz about
Tesla is gonna lose to you know, BYD
So because of all the publicity
Since then Tesla stock has dropped 30% year to date
While BYD stock remained flat
Earlier in the year
Elon Musk came out to warn that Chinese EV firms could demolish automakers around the world
And then at the end of the at the end of Q1
Came another Chinese competitor Chinese cell phone maker Xiaomi released its first EV car called the SU7
With attention-grabbing exterior that looks like a Porsche
And a price tag under which is cheaper than a Tesla Model 3
The company received 10,000 orders within four minutes and
In less than 30 minutes, it sold 50,000 cars
Suddenly Tesla faces not just one but two major Chinese competitors
So Tesla is an American EV maker while BYD is a Chinese company
Their competition is the epitome of US
US-China competition
Which is a it's a competition
that the that China had no chance of winning
given its political
System if the US didn't indulge in wishful thinking
Okay, so let me give you a little history
Just very quickly Chinese government started to offer subsidies to EV companies as early as 2009
Now different from the US subsidies, which are offered to customers most of the Chinese subsidies were offered to manufacturers
CCP's own data or CCP's own publicity
Declared that the central government has spent 150 billion yuan
Which is about 22 to 23 billion dollars in 13 years and that's central government
and so local government subsidies are
at
Least as much and that's only the official numbers. The real numbers could be could be much higher
And so it was said that the highest amount a manufacturer can receive is
120,000 yuan a car per car and that's even more than the cost of you know, the
cost of manufacturing
So this created fake EV companies that made fake EV cars
With the purpose to defraud government subsidies and that that's the source of Chinese EV graveyard
so as the Chinese EV market was
You know geared towards, you know
defrauding government subsidies or making monies
Elon Musk went to China to set up his Giga factory
I'm not saying that there weren't good Chinese EV companies there were
But they were not what it what they are now today
So when Elon Musk went to China to set up his Giga factory
He was given the privilege of being allowed to have a wholly owned
company in China in
Return Tesla must have its supply chain in China
In another word Beijing wants Elon Musk to help build China's EV
industry supply chain and
Elon Musk agreed. He benefited from his Shanghai Giga factory and made money, but he also
nourished
his competitors
right
tremendously
so and and then leading the pack is BYD a company backed by a Warren Buffett's capital and the Chinese government
and then the very company that's threatening Tesla's dominance in the industry or perhaps even
existence in the long run
So now Musk must have realized that very few companies in the West can fairly compete with Chinese companies
Because they are backed by the state, right? This is an unfair competition
So with that said now let's talk about let's compare Tesla with
BYD the first factor in the competition is the political factor. I mean there I
Realize this type of
Analysis, I mean to do a comprehensive analysis
I would have to spend a week, you know studying everything trying to be as inclusive as possible
But the things that I'm going to tell you are are are things that I don't think other media outlets have talked about
So but that doesn't mean that they are the only issues that these
EV makers face, right? So I'm just telling telling you some of the things that I see
That are not being discussed. So the first factor in the competition is the political factor for both
Tesla and BYD, but they're different
well Tesla
The the biggest challenge Tesla face in China is the Chinese government
However, it has another challenge. That's its relations with the left-leaning
American government and mainstream media
The left-leaning
Mainstream American media
Are not on Tesla not on Elon Musk's side
For his political views and for his friendliness perhaps towards Donald Trump and the like
many of the media reports covering the competition on Tesla and BYD are
cookie-cutter pieces coming straight from China for example
The Chinese media boasted BYD's 3 million car sales last year as a major
milestone
Way ahead of Tesla's 1.8 million cars
However, that's an apple-to-orange comparison because BYD's 3 million
includes 1.4 million hybrid EVs
Right. So in terms of pure EVs BYD is behind Tesla by about 200,000 cars
because BYD made 1.57 million and
Tesla made 1.8 million cars
But if you google how many pure EV
cars BYD produced in 2023, you'll get 3 million. I mean I tried to find I
Google so hard this afternoon trying to find how many pure EV cars
BYD produced in
2023 in English. I couldn't get an answer
Every media reports is telling me 3 million, 3 million
And I eventually found the number in Chinese. If I do the same search in Chinese
I was able to find it. So at least to me the Chinese media outlets were more honest with
how many cars BYD made and the English media were not saying
We're not, you know being more at least Google search was not being
Accurate. So and I scroll down on the Google search results and I couldn't find the correct number
So this shows you that the leading narratives in the United States
Want the public to believe that Tesla has fallen so behind than BYD
But is that really the case?
Now BYD's geopolitical risks have been
You know, it faces has been or have been sufficiently professed like
It's facing, you know tariffs and resistance from from around the world
it's facing probe in Europe into its
you know, the
Unfair pricing. I mean, what do you call that?
The high government subsidies that it received to help reduce its price so
Those have been widely discussed by mainstream media. I won't cover that. But however, there's another hidden political risk
Now, you know, the EV industry in China is overcrowded and competition is so intense that it's
Getting a little out of control
When the Chinese compete with each other they are ruthless
Tesla is in its own category in China and the rest of the Chinese EV makers are in another category
right, so
I think Tesla enjoy its own category because I mean
there are a group of
Consumers in China who would pay a premium for a Tesla car because it's a Tesla
It's telling me my camera has limited battery, but it should be fine
Okay, another technical challenge anyways, so but all the other
You would think that all the other Chinese
EV makers will get together and compete with Tesla, but that's not the case instead
They will compete with each other
So when when
Xiaomi when Xiaomi
Came out with its new car that the su7 people say
BYD's biggest competitor is not gonna be Tesla. It's gonna be Xiaomi
Another story that came out in March was on or around March 10th
the CEO of another EV Chinese EV maker called Song San
Exposed online that the founder of BYD, Wang Chuanfu, the legendary Wang Chuanfu
Who is a CCP member had two children
Out of wedlock and
Both children are American citizens and they own
Like real estate prime real estate in actually I have a I have an image of that
Here's the guy exposing on internet with his ID
Saying that yeah that the founder of BYD has two I think they're grown children. They're not young children. They're grown
And these and and they have their Americans and they have properties in in in the US
so
You know, this doesn't sound politically correct
Recently, you know the CCP has mobilized the little pinks the patriotic
Chinese youth to launch attacks on large
national private brands
for any
affiliation with the West or with Japan
remember the the owner of the wealthiest man in China the guy who owns the
It's called the Nongfu Shanchuan the spring water guy the guy who owns the water brand in China
he was so
Viciously attacked for something that's related to
To Japanese culture people were boycotting his product, you know
So from that perspective, so how do you know BYD?
You know will not be boycotted one day if
The owner has
Direct families that are Americans and how do you know BYD can be trusted?
When the regime needs it to beat out an American competitor
Right and don't laugh. This is not the logic that that we follow
This is the logic the CCP has instilled in the minds of the Chinese people
So BYD's Chinese competitors or anyone who is resentful of BYD could use that against it and that's
I mean, it's very possible. And when it's allowed enough, it will get Xi Jinping to think
Do I really trust that?
BYD guy
you know and
And then the fact that you know, he had finance backing from from from from the legendary American
Capitalist, you know Warren Buffett
It can all go wrong politically for for BYD. So
So this is this is the type of political risk
That that could be that could come back and haunt BYD one day given the way China is going right
The next thing I want to talk about is operations
One Chinese writer compared BYD to Tesla by saying this it says
Tesla's market value is
551 billion dollars
Seven times that of BYD's which is 80 about 80 billion
Tesla's profit is 2.6 times of BYD
Tesla's profit per employee is 12 times that of BYD
I
Updated the numbers to reflect the 2023
Financial results if you if you plug in 2022 data
The the disparity between the two companies was was even higher
so Tesla has a hundred twenty eight thousand employees worldwide BYD has
570,000, you know more than four times more it has 70,000 already R&D staff
And that's more than half of Tesla's total global employees
Tesla Shanghai Gigafactory has 20,000 workers. They make 1 million cars in a year
That's 50 cars per person on average
By comparison BYD employees on average make three cars in a year
So the operation
Efficiency is vastly different
So you may wonder why?
Well
Other than you know, the company one, you know, I mean there are many reasons to explain that but one primary reason
is
Tesla's manufacturing process is the manufacturing philosophy or the manufacturing
Approach
Approaches are different. So Tesla's manufacturing process is basically assembling
The many components purchased from various suppliers
So for example, the batteries come from CATL LG and Panasonic
Panasonic
Tesla's motors are self-developed, but they are produced by two Taiwanese suppliers
So the Shanghai factory is responsible for
assembling and not manufacturing
Battery installation is said to be the most critical part of the process and the number of workers
Involved in in doing that in Shanghai at the Tesla factory is no more than 1,000
BYD however employs a vast many
a vast army of people because it manufactures most of the components itself
except for windshields tires and some
Intelligent hardware almost all components are self-produced
UBS in Europe once had reported that 75% of BYD's
Dolphin models were produced by BYD itself
So in an ideal world BYD's model is more friendly to quality control
because
Because the manufacturer has control over the entire
manufacturing process right in an ideal world
However in China, I think this approach is actually
Riskier this is because in it's the opposite of
Western operation that that would be the norm right when you control your own manufacturing process
then
It should be you know, you have a better
Control over quality, you know, you have better quality control, but in China, it's I think it's worse. It's more prone to problems
Well, think about it this way in CCP's highly centralized culture
Today's Chinese are not known to be good at overseeing and coordinating
large-scale
Sophisticated industrial processes and that's why China's industrial software applications are very behind
You know other countries like the United States it's not because China doesn't have
great
Software engineers. In fact, it has many great software talents, but large
industrial software applications require
Collaboration from different teams of experts and so and there and it's a long process
So the the very narrow
Centralized approach to problem-solving is
Cannot handle that kind of process. So I don't think today's Chinese are good at overseeing or coordinating large-scale
complicated industrial processes
Particularly in an economic downtime when people are not well paid or not or not well motivated
in the summer of 2023
BYD Changsha
Facility had an exodus of employees
Because they were they were unhappy about their pay. Their base pay was only
1950 Yuan
That's
Like basically the minimum salary in the city
And the base salary is less than half of the base pay of workers as Tesla Shanghai factory
now base pay
You know and that people compare the paycheck like I think in Tesla in Tesla Shanghai factory people
Make you know like twice as much
like if if if the Chinese
Worker in BYD makes 4,000 then you know like
Tesla factory workers will make like twice as much
So test so BYD is a company not known to pay its employees
well, or at least from from the
From the media reports we've seen it's Vietnam factory also had employee protest
I think was last year
And they demanded higher pay
So some people call BYD factories sweatshops. I mean sweatshops
Now think about it
the sweat sweat sweat shop the sweatshop model may work for making
low-cost gadgets or clothing
But the sweat sweatshop model or mentality does not work when you make
sophisticated sophisticated machineries
It's prone to quality issues
So there have been many cases of battery fires
Surrounding BYD cars, but state media in China remained quiet
Some individuals have talked about BYD battery fires
According to an article on Chinese auto website called PC auto in a month of May
2023 alone
BYD had 16 cases of battery fires
And the worst is that in some cases the doors and windows
Remained locked or you cannot open them and the operator couldn't get out
Imagine the casualty when when you're when the car is on fire and you are locked in you cannot open
The the door just doesn't open the window doesn't open
And so this person really just said what you know, I mean that I will provide the links
I had many great reference links for this for this talk and they're
Interestingly, they're all from mainland China
You know the mainland Chinese have done a lot of comparisons between BYD and and
Tesla so I'll provide the links to you after this talk. So
Now if similar things if if Tesla had one fire in China, it would be all over the news
But BYD has had many cases of fire but not a lot of people talk about it
So Tesla's manufacturing model relies on suppliers and it has effectively decentralized
QC concerns, right you manage your quality control issues by managing your suppliers
And I think this model works better in China's environment
Versus BYD's highly centralizing. I produce everything in my shop
I think BYD will be producing EVs much cheaper than Tesla, but its quality issues will be
can be concerns when it's when
when
BYD increase its exports because those quality issues cannot be hidden anymore
Once it's there in once they're in the foreign in foreign markets
All right. Now, let me talk about market shares
So in 2023 Tesla had 10% of the Chinese EV market while BYD had 30%
Tesla had 55% of the US market while BYD isn't in the US yet
BYD sold
92% of its cars in the Chinese market. So the bulk of BYD's revenues from
Came from its
Came from the Chinese market last year now
With its declining economy
And and the I really question the growth, you know
I mean, I don't have numbers to back up my claim by really
Question the kind of extraordinary growth BYD had in China last year
with its domestic sales
That's just a question I have in my mind haven't got time to look into that
So any of you who have knowledge in this area can share your insight with me. I just
I mean if you look at all the other industries, it seems to be
flat if not down, but where
Who are buying so many?
EV cars last year
But anyways, but with the extreme weather people experienced last winter
And then the bad experience with with the batteries and then the amount of fires that we've seen in China
I don't know if that kind of growth in China that kind of domestic growth is
sustainable for BYD. So BYD desperately needs to expand its
foreign markets
So its exports in 2023 increased from 2% previously to 8%
Of its total sales. So in the past 98% of BYD's sales were
Domestic only 2% were
Exports now it increased that 2% to 8% and that's 240,000 vehicles in 2023
Most of these cars were sold to Southeast Asia. That's what the Chinese media said
Because it is that they say that BYD has 26% of the Southeast Asian market
Tesla's popularity in Southeast Southeast Asia is just picking up
It definitely hasn't sold as many cars as BYD has
But in Google search Tesla ranked number five among all auto makers and this Chinese writer believe
It's quite remarkable
and
In Hong Kong and Singapore
Tesla is the most searched car
BYD's total sales to Europe was 13,000 cars in 2023, which isn't too much
Which isn't much compared to Tesla
Tesla's Model Y was the best-selling car across Europe in 2023
With 250,000 units sold and its Model 3 sold a hundred and one thousand
Now what I want to show you is
in 2023
Russia
was China's
Biggest destination in terms of car export. I want to share this with you
So this is a chart coming from the Chinese side. I don't know if I can see this
Yeah, you see this is based on the sales volume for the first 10 months of
2023
Russia
With the number is the unit measure is 1 is 10,000. It's not thousand
So the seven three point six means seven seven hundred thirty six thousand. Okay
So for the first ten months of 2023
China exported seven hundred thirty six thousand cars to Russia and that's not just EV. That's all
cars
followed by Mexico
Belgium
Australia
What else I can't see the image. I mean you guys can recognize the
The the country by the map and then oh and then UK and then Saudi Arabia
And then the Philippines
Okay. Oh
The pink is
traditional cars the blue is
EV cars
Okay, so for example Belgium Belgium the bulk of the cars were
EV cars
All right. So the blue is EV. The pink is traditional is traditional cars
and then
Look at the
exporter
This is the top 10 auto exporters Chinese auto exporters
Published by China China's I think it's passengers Association
What is it I can't really see cuz my my my camera blocked my own slide
so you see how
BYD ranks what oh, no, sorry pink pink is
2023 the first 11 months of 2023 and then the blue is the first
Is 2022 so this is this is total cars. This is not broken down by EV or not
This is total cars
by manufacturers and
It's the blue is 2022 and the pink is
2023
Yeah
so so you see how
Tesla ranked number five
and then BYD rank number
Seven so in terms of total number of cars made in China
That were export to other parts of the world
Tesla is ahead
So and
Then Chinese are saying that their projection of the Russian market is
huge
China's export car auto export to Russia grew
700% and Chinese car brands
It's mark the market share of Chinese
auto brands in
Russia was only 9% in
2022 it grew to 37% in a year
and
Russia jumped from
Ranking number 11 the 11th
11th largest destination country
You know that receive that that import cars from China to number one and
According to a Russian estimate in 2024
Chinese cars
will
saturate Russian market and may reach 80% and
EV cars that the Chinese sells in Russia, for example the new
I
Think it's no, I think it's Lee auto
For example the car was selling at
450
Yeah, 450,000 yuan in China, but the price in Russia is double
So the Chinese is making a lot of money in Russia
So that's what I would say I think this is interesting
I think the I think overall the Russian market and in the south
south east
Southeast Asian market have helped
BYD
Last but not least I want to quickly mention the challenges that Xiaomi presents to Tesla
After its initial
after the initial frenzy of you know buzz
now people are talking about the quality issues that Xiaomi cars have and
I think the consensus is that
Xiaomi is a cell phone
cell phone maker and Chinese cell phone makers are very good at marketing
They know they're there the marketing gurus. They know how to sell
cell phone however
You can use the same
marketing
Tactic to sell a car because what people are looking for is different
I mean you could sell a cell phone by telling people how cool it is, you know by you know
Focusing on some of its features and people may be drawn to it
Particularly young people but cars people look for safety, right?
So now the the Xiaomi there are like various sorts of safety concerns that have surfaced
and such as its break and
And something else so those I saw there's like a list of nine safety concerns people have with
Xiaomi cars, so I think they don't pose as much of a threat to Tesla as
BYD
Alright, so that's just my
Gathered information given the limited time I have. I hope this is helpful
That's all
All right, okay
All right. Let me see crunch the Grace Hopper
number 67 from Newport Beach
SoCal Southern California
Catching up from 10 minutes back. All right. Well, thank you crunch the Grace Hopper
Hello, okay
All right
Brian cow, well, thank you Brian. I
Will post there were at least four or five links. I think the Chinese have really done a very good
analysis
And I think some of I mean they do
Overall, they maintain a tone the correct political narratives that are more in favor of BYD
But if you really read through read through the details and the data they provide there are a lot of good points
So I will provide the links there were like four or five links that I used
So that those of you read Chinese can can can use them as references
But I cannot find the same information in English here
All right
Okay, I don't think I have a lot of questions
I won't take any questions tonight because I do have other things I need to take care
I thank you very much for joining me and I'll see you later this week. Thank you. Bye. Bye