La crise des identités nationales est désormais ubiquitaire, aucune nation n'échappe à l'archipellisation identitaire, qu'il s'agisse des pays démocratiques comme de régimes autoritaires. Partout, les identités nationales sont concurrencées par des identités infra-nationale de nature raciale, socio-culturelle, genrée, religieuse, ethnique, territoriale... et cette dispersion identitaire n'est pas exhaustive. Les causes invoquées à cette fragmentation des identités nationales sont nombreuses et complexes parce que s'enmêlent des facteurs de nature différente. Qui de l'économie avec la globalisation commerciale, qui du communautarisme avec la poussée des religions et la différenciation des modes de vie, qui de l'intimité avec une sexualité genrée, qui des mobilités avec l'expansion des migrations et les problèmes d'intégration, qui du relativisime culturel et du wokisme avec un multiculturalisme qui imprègne de nombreux interstices des sociétés contemporaines. Si l'idée moderne de nation est relativement récente, pour simplifier contemporaine des Lumières et des grandes révolutions de la fin du XVIIIe siècle, l'identité nationale ne saurait être une antiquité inamovible et gravée dans le marbre d'une histoire figée. Mais se pose alors la question : l'identité nationale doit-elle en référer à une approche universaliste (drapeau, valeurs, symboles de l'Etat) ou le récit national doit-il agréger, métisser, hybrider toutes les évolutions socio-culturelles, religieuses et morales.
Émile Malet reçoit : - Noëlle Lenoir, avocate, ancienne ministre, membre honoraire du Conseil Constitutionnel, - Jean-Pierre Le Goff, philosophe, sociologue, essayiste, - Gabrielle Halpern, philosophe, - Pierre Manent, philosophe, écrivain, - Julien Aubert, vice-président des Républicains, fondateur de « Oser la France ».
Présenté par Emile MALET L'actualité dévoile chaque jour un monde qui s'agite, se déchire, s'attire, se confronte... Loin de l'enchevêtrement de ces images en continu, Emile Malet invite à regarder l'actualité autrement... avec le concours d´esprits éclectiques, sans ornières idéologiques pour mieux appréhender ces idées qui gouvernent le monde. Abonnez-vous à la chaîne YouTube LCP Assemblée nationale : https://bit.ly/2XGSAH5 Et retrouvez aussi tous nos replays sur notre site : https://www.lcp.fr/
[Applause]
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
welcome to these ideas which govern the
world the crisis of
national identities taken from
national identities is now ubiquitous
it is everywhere no nation escapes
a form of
identity archipelago that it whether
democratic countries or
authoritarian regimes everywhere
national identities are in competition with
subnational identities of a racial
socio-cultural gender religious ethnic
territorial nature and this dispersion of
identity is not exhaustive the
causes invoked for this fragmentation
of national identities are numerous
and complex because
factors of different nature are intertwined:
the economy with
commercial globalization, communitarianism with
the rise of religions and the
differentiation of lifestyles,
intimacy with gendered sexuality,
mobility with expansion
migrations and the problems
of integration
which of cultural relativism and
voquism with a
multiculturalism which permeates
many interstices of
contemporary societies if the modern idea of
nation is relatively recent to
simplify contemporary of the enlightenment and
the great revolutions at the end of the 18th
century national identity cannot
be an inavoidable quantity
immovable forgiveness and engraved in the marble of a
frozen history but then the
question arises should national identity
refer to a universalist approach
the flag the values the symbols of
State or should the national story
aggregate crossbreed hybridize all
socio-cultural, religious
and moral developments with my guests we will
seek to respond to this
tension in the national identity Noël
Lenoir you are a lawyer, former
minister and honorary member of the
Constitutional Council Julien Aubert you are
vice-president of the Republicans and
president of the
Osz la France Movement Jean-Pierre legof you
are a sociologist and
essist philosopher Gabriel Alperne you are a
philosopher Pierre Manan you are a
philosopher and writer
[Music]
so is that we can talk about a crisis
of national identities and how do we
observe it Julien Aubert the
Olympic Games look at what happened at the
time of the Olympic Games it is
an opportunity for a country like France
to open up to world and to ask ourselves
both what brings us closer to what we
celebrate but also who welcomes and
when we see the controversies which have
followed one another we see that at the bottom of
each controversy there is the question of what
we want to be and what we
want to send to the world for example the
choice of the singer aan
nakamoura some said then you
have the identitarians who
attacked her skin color that's
racism but you have other
people who have says listen it's
not necessarily our style of song
she doesn't sing in French it
doesn't reflect the image we
want to send of our country
the official poster of the Olympic Games
uh where the cross of the Invalides had been
removed where there was no
French flag, some finally said this
futuristic Paris, this country which does not exist
without a flag, without a Republic and without a
Judeo-Christian culture. I found that
interesting, that is to say that it It is at the
moment when we finally
confront ourselves with the world that we see the
faults of a French society with
behind it also I would say perhaps a
power which seeks to promote a
culture which it perhaps does not understand
elsewhere that he doesn't like but
thinking that that's what people steal and
then also a resistance from a
civil society which uh which it perhaps expects
more common more
standard things from its own identity and I
would say we could find this type of
unease in other countries at other
times uh brexit for example for
the British here without wanting to
go overboard I think it's it's
this moment where there is a species of
precipitation of event that
generally it is the mirror of the own
identity disarray of a country Noël Loir
you share that yes I agree
completely I would say as I am a lawyer
you mentioned it that civil society
in the countries democratic but in
others also it is built on
the basis of a nation, that is to say a
community which means living
together for a very
long time in the case law of the
European Court of Justice. human rights we
referred to the French model of living
together, that is to say we are different
but we belong to the same family
so there was family identity,
regional identity and the State
that is- that is to say the tutelary figure of
the State and I am struck today to
see that the entry of what we call
multiculturalism which I link to the
cultural relativism so dear to l vistros
and also to foucco takes us on a
slope which is extremely worrying
because what is behind
the state there is the race war
that Michel Foucot wanted and the
race war for me is the return to
tribalism and I fear that sometimes without
knowing it we go back in time there
have been periods of regression in
history and I think that the issues
for the younger generations is
to know if they want to keep this
notion of let's say of of of of of family of
thought of value or if we blow everything up
it's called deconstructing
from what I understand so we are
really at a cultural and political turning point
in democracies you
see this deconstruction
Jean-Pierre legof yes yes I think
that moreover it is not simply
a policy it is also ENF infa
national with the withdrawal into the
communities that you indicated but
is also supra national that raises the
question of the way in which
Europe was constructed therefore and I think that
moreover the
communitarian reactions are a
possible reaction in relation to this move
forward and in which the
nation is missing but just one point I
think that I think that there is a crisis
of the nation but it is still necessary
define it you indicated two two
different conceptions of the nation I would
happily start from Renand at the
end of the 19th century so what is a
nation because I find that his
definition of the nation is interesting
to the extent that it seems to me it
goes a little beyond these two
oppositions insofar as it
articulates the past it is the memories
shared with glorious and
less glorious hours the present
consent and will the plebiscite
of every day and the future in
a common future the question that
must be asked when we pose the crisis of the
nation what remains for example
of these three aspects, that's it for
me and on the one hand it is a question the
second question is how we
got there and I think it has the
current deconstruction but we have to
go back to a long process of the 20th
century but that's another question
so Gabriel Alperne you agree
this
then or indeed it's it's it's it's
very interesting but and and there for
once for to extend the the subject in
fact I would perhaps like to come back already
to this term of identity and understand
why ultimately this question of
identity is also important finally
even on the scale of the human being
why is it so sensitive
the identity the identity and there I
rely on the work of a great
intellectual of the 20th century who is called
Elias Kiti and who explains precisely
that in fact identity refers to an
archaic situation for human beings
where ultimately before we were all
animals a bit in the savannah and therefore
when we encountered another be here we
needed to say to ourselves are you
prey or are you a predator
this is what category do
I classify you in are you going to eat me
or am I going to eat you and so
that's why ultimately when we
are in social dinners or when or
in the street finally here we state our
identity who am I who are you everyone
presents themselves declines their identity because
there is previously this situation
archaic indeed of the human being
to be able to classify and arrange one
another but but the thing is that
we see that this very rational aspect
of things where ultimately we
categorize we classify this is in fact
unfortunately a little transforming our
brain in a massive box production factory
and in fact we don't
realize but we do that all day long
all day as soon as we come across
someone we need to put them in
a box so there we put away our
colleagues in boxes we put the
professions in boxes the
manual professions the intellectual professions there are
the young people there are what we call
senior citizens in fact there are the
farmers there are the startupers there
are industrialists in fact we spend our
time categorizing and in fact
doing so without realizing it we
build absurd and
artificial boundaries between generations the
professions the people the
individuals and in fact without
realizing we create fractures precisely
between generations uh between
communities sometimes between ideas yes
but the the we the we where does
Pierre Manan come from that is to say that uh
what happened to that we
come to fracture archipelago separate
uh where does that come from if you what is
curious today is the use
of the term universalism you have to be
universalist and being universalist
means not being a prisoner of its
nation not be a prisoner of its
particular group but in reality the nations
were
constituted in Europe through
universalist references there were two major
universalist references the
Christian religion and then what we
conveniently call today the enlightenment
so uh the nations were not
built in spite of the universal or
against the universal each nation was
in European history a
proposition
of universality the rivalry between the
nations were rivalries of ideas of
man it was not in the name of my tribe
it was perhaps my tribe represents
humanity better than your tribe uh the
French culture is superior or not
or there you go between Germany
England and uh and and France for
example good so it there
was the period of glory if I dare say
even if this term would not be
disapproved by many today
but the period of glory of
European nations are periods where at the same
time as the nation asserted itself it
asserted a version a proposition
of universal and
today the universal and the
particular have turned their backs
and become enemies of each other
in any case the universal has become
of its bearer who was the nation yes
but to what do you attribute this
dechristianization because it is
it is concrete it is objective
today no Jean-Pierre Legoff well
I think that there is a process I am
not going to come back through the centuries but
if I knew you wouldn't example on the 20th
century there was a moment in my opinion
very important which was the war of
141 after 141 indeed there was
still a patriotism we saw the
development of a pacifist to reread what
Marc bloc wrote for example on the
period and on the other hand with
regard to the aesthetic avant-gardes you
have a movement which was not afraid
to say that it spat on the flag
which bore the glorious spiked helmet
which was the surrealism which was in the
minority at the time and avant-garde
so there was this trauma of the
war of 141 I will add in my opinion
a second moment which was important
it was after the Second World War
initially there was still
a
defense of the nation which was in my
opinion very patriotic and very based
on the defeat the reaction to the defeat
of June 40 that is to say never again
and the project of the 4th or 5th in
which registered different
politicians it was to say with
industrialization the development
of economy is giving back to France the
means of its power simply what
happened very quickly at the turn of the
50s and 60s is that we has changed
society, that is to say that from 62
the end of the Algerian war France
is at peace and a society develops
which we will call consumption and
leisure with a type of individualism
quite new finally which was already
present before but which will develop
that we could say quite hdonis for
which the idea of filiation uh no
longer works as before of a C Cece
that you call somewhere the
adolescent society yes with a people that I
called who are revolting at that time the
adolescent people and there will
truly be a questioning of
the nation in the name of this
individualist a questioning
I was going to say of authority but also
because we must take the process
that I call the cultural revolution
68 ARD over several years not
simply in the moment which is a
moment of catarcis but subsequently there
will truly be a settling of
accounts vis-à-vis of history it is the
nation will be assimilated by a part
of society as equal the two
world wars traumatize them with
an emphasis on the Vichy collaboration
which comes at that time plus
colonialism and there I would say that 'we have
learned to almost hate ourselves, we have
truly lost the self-esteem
which presupposes the nation and so it is in
this whole now I think that
indeed it is in crisis but I
also see the return of signs of a
possible return of the nation and that raises
in particular the question of Europe in
relation to what I consider to be a step
forward so yes you want to react
yes I I
in fact what happened at the time of the
lights it is somewhere that we
transposed faith in God into faith in
man and his abilities and
I will add that during the Second
World War from my point of view
it is I am not a sociologist but I
think that The Shoa had a profound impact on
European consciousness as a
trauma which then there was
the trauma I would say following the
Second World War but I think
it is a latent trauma which has
totally transformed the relationship that
we have in faith that we can
have in our own civilization with
secondly the idea that patriotism
pushed to the extreme led to
war led to destruction and
that we therefore had to be wary of it, hence
the link with what said
Mr. GOF who was to build
legal cathedrals aimed at
disempowering politics by
considering real power
should no longer be in the hands of
democracy which could make mistakes but
rather in the hands of judges which is a
reverse movement in light since
reality for years we had
instead tried to take away the
power to decide what was good or
bad to give it to people and in
reality we did exactly the opposite
by saying I prefer that the
European Court of Human Rights 'man decides
what is good or bad and not the referendum
deeply I would say antigolist and
therefore therefore I would say there is there is in my
opinion this I would say this who has who has
transformed societies or so
permanent Julien Aubert evokes the
choice is -what do you think
that today the Shoa remains a cursor
of identity
or as Steven
Spielberg, the great American filmmaker, has just declared
that the Shoa today has become a
new paradigm which consists of denying its
genocidal dimension, I would say that the Choa
came to the center of
European and in general Western consciousness
when we gradually took the
measure of what it had
ultimately been because emerging from the
war was
only one aspect of a
general catastrophe and it was only after a
few years that it began in
fact it became crystallized in
Germany with the
first trials of the concentration camp leaders
and gradually
Europe took Europe and The West
have become aware of both
the enormity and the uniqueness of
the choice and this has played a
considerable role in indeed the enormous
question mark that has risen
above of the whole history of
Europe so did
the experience of the choir
oblige us to in some way indict
the whole history of Europe and
the West that's one that's another
question I don't think but in any case
she has suspended this
question mark but what is happening
today is that the Choa is in the
process of getting out of this role
of one because of in a certain way
everyone is in the process of
appropriating it, it's
their choice, if I dare say crudely, is
n't that what makes it
part of
today? hui of
general disorientation since we have the impression that if
we cannot in some
way invoke a genocide of which we
would be the victim, we can no longer
say anything, right? 'it has become the
common currency of
political debate and therefore it is uh there
when the the crime par excellence the
singular crime became
uh provided the language general language
is the disorientation and the
reversal are complete you think
that we seek to get rid of
history by this blurring of
history Jean-Pierre Legoff I think
that at a moment there is a
disarticulation of European countries
with history in particular the cha being
an element that that is to say, there is
still a very penitential vision of
history which places all the catastrophes on Europe
and more broadly on the West
and that
has developed gradually,
I think. that
Europe, when we see the way in which we
were built, arrived in a
very
particular moment which was which had a lot
of angelism in counterpoint, that is to say,
after the fall of the wall we were going
towards I not take up the end of history
the alliance of a certain form
of economy plus human rights which
went directly towards the universal if
I dare say without going through the mediation
of nations and therefore for me there is a
given moment when the construction of
Europe was formed on a
somewhat idyllic angelic headlong rush where
it was almost the European citizen
it was not far from the citizen of the world and
when I take when I see again for
example certain texts from the 90s
2000s I can take we forgot
stroscan who says but the borders
go from the North to the South uh the
Mediterranean will be an internal sea uh
good and we will see that and you take Michel
recard on Turkey which will
allow us to finally
also talk about dunking
well that was it so there are more
borders so people there was
this idea of multiculturalism
because cultural relativism and
multiculturalism in my opinion
intervenes precisely in this in this
moment I just wanted to
pick up on a point in relation to what
you said about
hybridization it is true that
the history of a nation the way we
tell it which is plot is not the same
if we take for example the 3rd republic
after the war of 70 the way in which
the nation presents so there is definitely an
evolution in a certain way it is not
a
fixed immutable substance but in counter- point I
think that from this vision there is the
headlong rush and I will take the
notion of narrative identity from Paul
Ricker who says but ultimately to this
substantial entity of the nation he
opposes a narrative identity based
on a given situation which requires
resuming the story
precisely there is no longer a single
narration there are many but there is there is
there is the idea we must
still pay attention to one thing because
the narrative identity is 'is so
fluid and mobile which has a given moment
if at a given historical moment a
nation does not say here is a
national narrative to fix itself at a given moment
that does not mean that I mean it is
still individuals tend to
think about it I take the expression
cidriqueer another by PARM the others
and cultural openness is a
dissolution because to open yourself
culturally you still have to know what
you are yourself and what
parentage you are and I think that
this moment was particularly
important I spoke about 68 and the
cultural revolution of 14 of the
Second World War but the way
in which the European Union was built
initially in my allied opinion also with I
live to have the opinion your opinion Noël Loir
on this subject al me I I good I
remained European because it is
the heritage
but I have also changed my vision
of European construction quite a bit but also
from the more recent turning point I was
very enthusiastic when we
integrated the Charter of
Fundamental Rights of the European Union into
the treaty the result is that
given the evolution of the institutions which
all at the international level as well as at
national level
Julien Aubert spoke of judges there are
also the agencies there is
also the UN turned towards the
nation states the Charter of
Fundamental Rights has become an instrument
of negation of European culture
in that she has
national history are we going to
oppose impose forgiveness on Mr. Orban
I am going to say something that is not
politically correct a Gay Pride to
prove that he is joining the club of
European democratic nations
we are going to to oppose uh our legislation
on the veil is it is the Court of
Justice of the European Union and not
only the European Court of
Human Rights and therefore and at the UN there is
also negation the law of
omism turns towards the
democracies with Iran which is at the
head of the Nuclear Disarmament Council
and the Human Rights Council and
therefore the question I have is
firstly is the nation state
necessary uh to live together
since we are different but we
still have to be in the same house I
think that the nation state is necessary
I think that the history whether it is
national family or education
builds us and we must
constantly build ourselves and not deconstruct ourselves
and I wonder today at the age
I am about the reasons why
the West practices repentance then
as Jean said -Pierre Legoff we
feel and moreover the rise in
power of the national gathering
shows that this idea of nation has
not disappeared since it
ultimately becomes a reaction it is the
protest vote it becomes
nationalist which is still
incredible it is the vote for the nation
which is nationalist and I think
that we are at a turning point because either
there will be civil wars or we
see them a little in the making with the
proalestines, the proamas and the others
or we will arrive to mature and
relive together with another model
then Gabriel alperne with you I
would like to try to clarify the
debate you cited the writer Canetti
or for those who do not know Canetti
I remind you that he is a great writer
of culture I 'Was going to say
Austro-Hungarian in any case who comes
from Central Europe don't you have
the feeling that there is a fundamental confusion
between what Canetti says which is a
cosmopolitan culture and today
multiculturalism is that is to say that we
take multiculturalism for
cosmopolitanism, don't you think
that there is this
transformation that we can consider
as a
cultural one? That's a hell of a question or
uh the the the problem it is that
unfortunately too often in fact
behind culturalism in any
case the reality of multiculturalism
and unfortunately too often a juxta
position of community and and therefore not
not for once a real in
any case a real living together
so in fact unfortunately the term does
not always or necessarily in
any case designate the ideal here the concept
unfortunately does not always designate
precisely the reality as it
exists
today and for this time I
would like to apologize to bounce back because
there is a lot of things and so I
would just like to follow up on
what Julien Aubert said precisely by
saying that the moment of enlightenment where
actually faith uh faith in
God passes is transformed afterward
into once in man precisely what
would be terrible and we see clearly that
it is a temptation today is
that we see clearly that this faith in man
is in the process of being lost and here
it is rather once in new
technologies precisely and in the
replacement effectively with
artificial intelligence which makes it possible to
possibly resolve a
certain number of questions and and
and there is also an element on
which I wanted to answer when when
you were questioning everything at the 'time on
what is the responsibility finally in
fact where does this
archipelago come from and and how
could we explain it there is an
element that really appealed to me
during of the different debates for
the previous presidential election
it was all these televised debates where
finally we had a juxtaposition
of citizens who came to challenge the
different candidates by saying what are
you going to do for me and in
fact this sentence that 'are you
going to do for me it echoes
a terrible phrase from Rousseau
so it dates from the 18th century which says we
have astronomers we have
poets we have physicists
painters but we don't we have more
citizens and in fact what is terrible
is that it is as if everyone comes to
ask the politicians but what are
you going to do for me and therefore
to answer the question where
this comes from archipedization in my opinion there is
a double responsibility a double
fault at the same time on the part of the politician
who by categorization by clientelism
sometimes in his programs will say well
this is what I do for young people
this is what I do for seniors
that's it what I do for the
start-uppers this is what I
do for the teachers the nurses
et cetera et cetera and a fault
also on the part of the citizens who
ultimately no longer behave like
citizens but everyone comes to ask
and and and what to ask for its small
particular interest so this question is
how are we not in a
Jua position of small
mediocre particular interests but
precisely how we are going to be in this
general interest and that for once it seems to me
that it transcends questions of
multiculturalism or others the question
is not so much culture it is in
any case it is this question of
citizenship which actually raises yes
Julien Aubert I would like to react
first I believe that there are two
concomitant phenomena there is a
collective weakening which is quite
classic that is to say that at the end of the
cold war it is like a war in
reality in the same way as in 1918
people were suddenly awakened
pacifist internationalists or after 45
well after 90 it is the equivalent of a
conflict there is a kind of wave
of idealism which makes the nation
become a little tricard
then a second phenomenon which is a
phenomenon of exacerbation of
individual phenomena and I believe that
it is also the fact that the economy has
totally devoured the way in which we
perceive society uh it is 'first of
all, indeed, an effect of
globalization but in reality the citizen
disappears because he thinks in terms of
gain and interest, he makes his
microeconomic calculation and that ties in with
hedonism, that is to say, to make
a nation the past in any case we
judge it in the eyes of the present by saying
Colbert did this but today it
would be bad the present invades everything
that is to say that hedonism consists
of moreover we see clearly that our
societies are afraid of death evacuates
existential questions we are
only in a society of I of
eternal youth and therefore the individual
who is supposed to participate in a
collective project only thinks about his present
and the way in which he maximizes his
interest at the present moment as for the
future the politician does not give it
since he does not give a
global vision of society he makes
programs which is completely
different than what you have targeted and
and I I will still come back with one last idea
about the Choa, which is that I think
that the taboo has indeed evolved
because today there are two
ways of conceiving it when we see
that an Anne-Franck college is renamed
in Germany because we have to welcome
people from immigrant backgrounds
who do not feel comfortable because they
are Muslims because they
are from this country, this is where there is
sometimes a lack of understanding in
relation to from what happened in Europe
we see clearly that in reality the
perception I would say of the lessons of
history is not the same a current
appears saying the great lesson of the
choice is that it Above all, we must not
victimize minorities, so if
today's minority feels
uncomfortable with that, well in this
case we have to adapt and therefore we
relativize something that was in the
realm of the sacred in the 50s. first year
I would say of the ENF po Second
World War of Tab al pmanant we
spoke a little bit about this conflict between
immediacy and what
refers to history in identity
for a person who it's not
reactionary I want to quote the great
philosopher Anna arent she says that at the
level of identity there is a part which
relates to stability over time can
you PvE say a little
what is it that it can mean
keeping a part of stability over
time I don't know what Ananaarin
had in mind I can tell you what
I have in
mind starting from what Madame
Lenoir mentioned about
the 'Europe the construction of Europe
began as the continuation of
European history the continuation of
the history of European nations after
all after in 45 Germany devastated
defeated dishonored
France emerging from a defeat also
these nations want rebuild itself uh
take lessons from three
successive wars and
rebuild a Pacific Europe a
European concert finally Pacific and
rid of the excesses of
violence and the spirit of domination
of national arrogance which had
led uh to the catastrophe therefore
Europe
begins by extending itself in some
way by a certain fidelity to its
history it is a rearrangement of the of the
uh of the European concert by taking
precautions so that precisely
as Julien Aubert mentioned
earlier 'time the nations can no
longer get carried away with the excesses that we
had known something
strange is happening in the 60s 70s or so
Europe radically changes
perspective it is no longer all the
continuation of history or the
perfection of
European history is the erasure of
European history Europe claims
to start from zero Europe no
longer claims to accomplish this European concert that
history has established Progressiv
prepared but she quite abruptly she
decides a new beginning and what to
do to start again well
it is to erase the past Europe has
claimed from say the 90s to have
started from zero so we must erase
all all the marks of
ancient Europe erase the old religion
erase the old nations and start
from scratch what does it consist of
saying well the only the only reality of
Europe is European values
and European values what
are they human rights the
rights of the
individual man all men are
equal and therefore being European
means making no respect for
persons therefore no difference between
Europe and what is not
Europe 'Europe is Oé the right to exist in
reality so Europe will no longer be built
it's over since it decided
that it did not have the right to exist
as a particular human group you
mean that political Europe is
dead but it is not dead because
it was never born it was
never born it was built so as
not to exist at the beginning we the Europe of the 6
could have formed something thing
perhaps the gold of the new perhaps but
the more we expand the less obviously we
can constitute a political community
and in any case the principles are
such that since it is forbidden to
distinguish between Europe and what is
not is not Europe since Europe is
defined by the acceptance of everything that
is not it and the rejection of everything
that it was how do you want
Europe to exist yes so black Christmas
what is the part of
migrations in this phenomenon then
I think that there is ident it is
interesting me I think that on the contrary
Europe exists too much because it does
not respect national identities and
besides you know that we has abandoned
the term national identity to speak
of titional identity, that is to say
that Europe assumes
sovereignty skills it is in the
French Constitution which are delegated to it so we
delegate skills currency
visas to it immigration et cetera and
now the Islamic veil which
still goes extremely far and
it agrees to respect the
nation's identities not the Islamic veil if there is
case law from the Court of
Justice of the Union which indicates for
example that a
veiled woman can be prohibited in a
company since it concerns the market
to be in contact with customers but
as soon as she is at the
telephone switchboard or she I don't know is
in her office she can be veiled
that's it and so companies only have to
align yes but if it is
in a private condition no but the
Charter of Fundamental Rights which
copies both the preamble of the
constitution of 46 on
economic and social rights and the Declaration
of Human Rights of 1789 is
political, social
and economic civil rights which means that even in the
area which is normally that of
sovereignty, that is to say the everyday life
of people, there is no 'there are no more
borders it's over everything has been
shattered since even the Court of Justice and
we are talking about national identity it is
also about defense of the security of the
nation governs the functioning of I
hear I hear you Christmas the black
but what is the part of migrations
in this phenomenon then it is the second
it is the second I think that the
migration policy or rather the absence
of migration policy has led to
making
concrete the wish of the relativists we were
talking about levistros we can also
talk about Michel foutco de Bourdieu et
cetera that is to say that I was very
struck and frankly I am not in favor of
the
police hitting people of
color I was very struck to see the
president Biden kneel down uh
to apologize uh for what was
considered a racist act and I
am also very struck to see that in
our country uh well ultimately we respect
theocratic morals which are not
ours
uh the principal who comes uh
that is to say that it is an immigration
uh it is not an immigration
it is that the word assimilation which for
me was not shameful because it
made it possible to absorb a
massive immigration of Italians,
Yugoslavs and so on and even further
the word assimilation means that we
agree to sit at the table of others
and to respect the way in which what
Norbert Elias said the civilization of
morals now there is no longer of
civilization of morals there are no more
rules and even when we see that the
Magistrates' Union is attacking a decree
dissolving an organization of a
collective which is called the uprisings
of the
earth which therefore made a a certain number
of damages in a certain region of
France against the farmers and
then the and and who is party
is he are judge is gone and who
then the Magistrates' Union
parades in
prohibited demonstrations that deputies nupes march
in prohibited demonstrations or
parade because they are not
satisfied with a rule called the
majority I think that there is not
only a question of
national identity but there is a question of
survival of the nation yes then
Jean-Pierre Leoff right here in a
program Hubert Vedrine considered that
illegal immigration had torpedoed the
European political project Jean Daniel in discussions
with François Mitteran would have warned him
against this phenomenon do
you think
that today for Europe it is
impossible to control its
illegal immigration I don't know if it is possible
it seems difficult to say the least but we
still have to see the political will
that there is or is not to try to regulate
this situation on the other hand what I
believe is that it is a question
today who is who rep on
identity in the whole of society
it is enough to go and discuss with
Onir citizens everywhere this question
it is constant so it is a considerable challenge in
my opinion and I believe that
the speeches which consist of saying well
it is very complex and so on it
will not be possible if there is not a
somewhat clear and clear speech on this question I
think that even the European question the
very rejection of the powerlessness of Europe
on this question and that raises the
question of sovereignty including
national and the articulation of
national sovereignty today
many people are asking themselves the question
but what exactly is France or the
French State responsible for, what
can it do? It's a form of
image of the impotence of politics which
is given, that's it. which is very serious
in the question of immigration in my
opinion so now on Europe I
cannot be optimistic that is not the question
I think that there has been a great
disillusionment compared to what we have
known That's certain, I also think
that there is a feeling of
dispossession, as Hubert Vedrine
said, but it is a feeling of
dispossession in relation to the nation,
what the State can do today. nation and that
is still a relationship with Europe
which is very distanced, that is to say we
see it as an administrative machine.
I think that it is still very distant
from ordinary citizens. Well, I
cannot take the peasant question but
it's huge you say but how is it
that he managed to write and
decree a certain number of things
which seem totally absurd and
contradictory so there is a connection to
Europe what is- what is missing in my opinion
I think that there is always the
difficulty of a national success which
is linked to European construction
the articulation of the two it is not clear
we do not see it and it is even the story
national itself which is in question
in relation to everything that has been said so
I do not see in these conditions
what Europe is. I think we
must dare to ask the question now
I would tend to think
that what can bring
European nations together before speaking is when
you have a certain number of challenges to
face together there is a situation
today we experienced covid and there we
retrospectively discovered the way
of which we were more sovereign over a
certain number of things quickly like
masks for example or like
medicines it is still a
paradigm shift which in
my opinion is starting to come into play and I will add the
question of I say or finally the
question of Islamism which is
still something we have an enemy who
truly wants to destroy us who
wants to destroy the European nations and
there is a possibility I
very much believe that depending on the category
of the enemy it is something that
unites which can unite much
more finally much more at the same time
that we need a story on
the nation and on the construction of
the European Union I think that it is
terribly lacking in your opinion Julien
Aubert it's is this migration issue
which explains the trend
of populist and nationalist forces
and in particular for our next
European elections yes it is
something more global that is to say that
people want a change in
policy so you vote for a party
a that doesn't change you vote for party
it will not change and it will not change
it will not change
unless we put the church back in the middle of the
village that is to say
national sovereignty if I created a movement
called daring France with a r to
dare is because to think that
France has a future to think that we can
want the French project is
today a transgression in an
era where there is a
general disempowerment of
politics and a lack of differentiation of the
European project which 'prevents because
you know the big fashion today
is to refuse to judge and
distinguish therefore meritocracy is
bad when we make a
political representation it must be an
ethnic religious and
sexual photograph of the of the of the of the
population and the foreigner who presents himself
we cannot grant him finally
make him apply duties or
rights which would be different from the
citizens we cannot filter but I
say with this reasoning there in reality
the whole thing collapses and there are
European problems which are that it has a
psychological problem with the notion of
border as it was built by
removing borders within its
whole it does not know what it is to
establish a border and the proof
is that we do not constantly
enlarge without asking ourselves where
Europe stops when, quite
honestly, we could have said to ourselves,
this is what I am going to say is a bit
impolitically correct content of
recent years but Russia
culturally is undoubtedly more
European than Turkey even when
it is waging war
today but today if you
want besides the Islamists are
not mistaken since they have they have carried out
attacks for for the Islamists
Russia is obviously Europe
but independently if you
want from the epiphenomenon of
wars and so on when you look at
the history of Russia it is much
more backward to the the European space that
Turkey which with the exception of François
I had very few friends on the
European continent yeah so Gabriel
Alber the notion of hybridization you
looked at it extensively in a book and
I believe that it is a notion
which you have thought a lot about
today uh some to the
notion of national identity prefer
interbreeding
hybridization
multiculturalism and so on in your
opinion is there an alternative
a national model of integration at
least for one
part thank you very much you put in the
uh part of this narrative if you
want integration thank you thank you for
your question actually I have
been working on this question of
hybridization for almost almost
15 years actually that allows me to
extend the reflection
of Christmas the black where in fact
she pronounced this term of assimilation
here saying to herself there is this
question there which is asked to me in fact
during of the various debates
last year precisely on the whole
immigration law in fact it surprised me that
we were all so focused
precisely on the immigration question
although not very pro anti when in fact
it seems to me that one of the others
equally fundamental questions to
ask were the question of integration or
assimilation or something else yes and it
seems to me that this question, this debate,
in fact we did not have it whereas for
the moment it could have been a real
public debate finally in which model do we
fit in are we
in a model of integration so someone
well well very good and we assume it and therefore
public policies which result
here is where is -are we in a model
of assimilation in which case we say it and
assume it or is there not
a form of third way and in any
case me with this idea of hybridization
so and here I specify immediately by
hybridization it is not at all
creolization crossbreeding or whatever it
is it is not at all in any case
this this philosophy which is behind
this idea of hybridization I I I am
leaving in in any case it seems to me that
unfortunately in an idea in a
philosophy of integration we are
more unfortunately in any case it
can more
result from a sort of Jux position
of community identity and
unfortunately that does not make a nation
l integration as it is in any
case today with regard to
assimulation which actually
worked for
decades decades centuries even
the only reservation I have is when I
speak with lots of people who tell me
my grandparents were Spanish
Portuguese Vietnamese well that's it but
hey I don't know a word of Italian I do
n't know a word of Spanish well I have
nothing to do with these countries in fact that
's sad and there we say to ourselves well if
that's what assimulation is and if it's
ultimately total oblivion of where we
come from a language that could have been
transmitted to us and finally there is
a sort of amputation and an absence of
transmission there is something which
is a shame there and a form of
loss I find in terms of inheritance and
for the moment I think that we can have
both here we can be
fundamentally French and then
well there you go parents grandparents a good
well eh Spanish Portuguese we can
cultivate languages so we have to
master them perfectly but in any case
we can we can be and that's that's that's
this image of the Centor it's having a
foot in worlds but you still have to
know them cultivate them
work them research them
actually it's working
to be a S entor is a chimera no
but pierremanant there in what
Gabriel Alberne has just said is it that you do
n't think that we can
have a part of our national identity,
an intimate part which
calls upon and remembers another history,
a culture other than that of the nation
in which we live, yes of course, but
uh that's it. these are undecidable things
which depend on so many parameters
uh I can't say much they
are individual views uh which
can present all the
colors and shapes imaginable but
the main question is it's
not even the question of the story that
Jean-Pierre was talking about uh it's the question of the
political regime it's it's it's not
what is the national story it's are
we still a nation uh in
working order and that means are
we still a functioning republic
in principle we are
the French Republic and the
French Republic what is it is an old
nation which from a certain date
decided to govern itself itself by
the Republic by the Republican regime
and so for centuries we are
centuries yes that's about it a little
more we remove the phases of Empire
restoration here we are in the
Republic so that's it our
history the question today is
that we are still the
French Republic, that is to say, are
we still this old nation
which today governs
itself the answer is no for
several years we have decided to no
longer be this old nation which
governs itself since we have
renounced not France directly
but the Republic; we have renounced
the Republic since we have taken away
the right to govern ourselves. even
today it is no longer the
government and the Parliament which
governs it is the different
jurisdictions the international treaties
and never the Constitutional Council
unlike the
German Constitutional Court has redefined
the French regime as a republic
this governing it -even what
the tra did, so just a word
because we are reaching the end, there is
just one decision that I am quite
proud of, it was not me who was rapporteur
but anyway it was is that of
99 on the Council of
Europe Convention on minority and
regional languages where the Council was referred to
by the Prime Minister and the President
of the Republic and where it was indicated that
the common that communitarianism in
France is was not our
national identity, that is to say, we cannot
recognize groups that are
not citizens as having their own rights, which
means that there are no
religious rights, there are no
minority rights religious ethnic et cetera
that's a bit like the Republic but
it was a long time ago so listen to the
republic we have very little time Jean-Pierre
Leoff I think about the different
forms of belonging I think that we
must indeed there are always
affiliations I don't I'm of
Breton origin but I think the Republic
is in
Spain there are many
groups and so on the question is
the political space itself it is in
the political space itself that this
arises there is a republican conception
which for me remains despite everything a
regulating ideal it is the which is a bit of
an ideal I insist on this to forget
its affiliations first to
think of oneself as a member of the
national community which is a
certain individual definition of
citizenship if we let go of that we let go of
a lot of things so it's on
the political level it's your opinion on
the cultural level it leaves instead I am
on the question of identity uh
you have a bad identity reaction in my
opinion which is to think that
identity is rigid it is
fixed you have in power people who
think that identity is flexible
it moves every day the reality is
between the two but we must reintroduce
the emotional because the question of
belonging to the nation is not
only rational it is not only
ideological it is first of all a love
deep for for a country which has a
history a singularity which for me
makes it the most beautiful country in the world thank you
so listen we have more
time left we could have continued this
conversation for a long time but the
time is up I would like to
present to you a brief
bibliography of Samuel antonton that
we all know since he is
the author of this aborted revolution at
the end of history he published a
remarkable book on the clash of civilizations which was published by ODIL
Jacob not of the Ukraine by the way I
remind you then Noël le noir you
published with Philippe Valtou and Marc
Lambron l'Europe de domier à ne jour that
was
a beautiful Europe that one eh a little
bit with the Charlie caricaturists
ago for a while, yes, you say
it was a beautiful Europe, tells you that with
nostalgia with nostalgia because it
was a fracture and a rupture, therefore the
end of freedom of expression in
January 2015, thank you Julien Aubert
Emmanuel the false prophet, published by
Rocher Emmanuel he is a prophet of
the Bible or he is a prophet of the
present time he is a prophet who got
lost in the desert in any case
okay well we say no more here I
remind you Gabriel Alberne you
published all without wrong praise of
hybridization is that the
first hybridization is not the one which
hybridizes us to books and to culture
actually hybridization is it is
the idea of creating PS between worlds
quite simply here it is between the universes
the imaginations here are the
professions Jean-Pierre Legoff I remind you
that we have already talked about it that
you published my Roaring Twenties by
Robert Laffond and it is always these
famous Roaring Twenties that you
incriminate in the change that's it
yeah well I think it's a
revolution of the second half of the 20th
century which is a cultural revolution
which counted a lot in what we
have around what we discussed
today so Pierre Manan Pascal and
the Christian proposition is that
ultimately it is this statement I which has
been
erased I do not think that it has been
completely erased since I have I have
no but I I speak in the spirit of the
times it is it's it's I I I I yes
of course there is there is a
visible collapse but that doesn't it doesn't it doesn't say
everything about our spiritual religious situation
the the
the resources of religion are
are mysterious
so uh I don't know what will happen
tomorrow thank you so we stay with
this hypothesis I would like to
thank you ladies thank you gentlemen
for being so lively at my side this
very interesting conversation on I
believe that national identity is
really a very worrying subject even
if it does not appear directly I
would like to thank the LCP team which made
this broadcast possible
and before we leave I leave you
with this thought which comes from the south in my
eyes each historical community has a
different and respectable identity which
must be maintained and defended it is
an extract from a work by Max
Gallot
[Music]