Why Victorian Clothing Is More Modern Than 21st Century Clothing

Victorian Threads
4 followers
5 Video Views·May 14, 2024
We explore how Victorian clothing, often seen as outdated or old-fashioned, actually embodies elements of modern fashion that are more in tune with today’s design philosophies than we might think. From structured silhouettes to thoughtful garment construction and sustainability practices, we delve into how the innovation and attention to detail in Victorian fashion make it surprisingly relevant in the 21st century.
Hello everyone and welcome back to my channel. I'm so so glad to have you with me here today.
This video is a week late because I got a nasty nasty cold and that prevented me from filming
or doing pretty much anything. I was in bed for a week and I feel like colds have gotten so much
worse since COVID. Have any of you experienced that? I feel like, I mean like I've had colds
before but none that have ever kept me in bed for a week. But anyhow, I apologize for this video
being late but I'm here now. So this is a remake of an old video. I made this video in
originally I think in 2019 and I wanted to remake it because, well for several reasons. First of all
I was not very good at filming back then. I didn't really know what I was doing so the quality has
gotten better. I also feel like back at that time I wasn't really writing out scripts for my videos
so I didn't really know what I wanted to say. It was all off the cuff and I wanted to have it be
more polished so I'd actually know what I wanted to say going into it. So I am remaking this video
here. I hope you enjoy. But before we do that I want to say please remember to like this video
and subscribe and turn on the notification bell so you can be notified of new uploads.
Leave comments down below. I love reading your comments and a huge huge thank you to the people
who support this channel on Patreon. I'm going to leave their names listed at the end of the video.
If you would also like to support this channel on Patreon there'll be a link in the description.
No hard feelings if you can't. I certainly understand money being tight. However there
will be hard feelings if you don't follow me on Instagram. The link will also be in the description
because Instagram is free. I'm also going to list my email in the description in case you need to
get in touch with me for any reason. Okay we're gonna get into it now. So Victorian era fashion
is known for being exaggerated. Every decade women were using their clothing to change their bodies
into some new exaggerated shape. Here is a rather humorous video to display the evolution of the
bizarre shapes that were fashionable throughout the 19th century. Now the 19th century or the
Victorian era, I'm going to be using those terms pretty much interchangeably in this video even
though the Victorian era started about a third of the way through the 19th century, but for the sake
of this video 19th century equals Victorian era. So the Victorian era is not the only time in
history when women and men to a lesser extent have used clothing to alter the shape of their body.
In the early to mid 16th century women wore a sort of hoop skirt that was called a Spanish
farthingale and it held the skirt out in a very cone shape and their sleeves were very wide and
had these trumpet shaped ends. In the late 16th century women had moved on from these Spanish
farthingales, these triangular cone shaped Spanish farthingales, and it started wearing bum rolls and
French farthingales which give the wearer the appearance of emerging from a drum. They had also
adopted the use of these things, these sort of proto corset type things, they're called a pair
of bodies and there were even references to sleeve farthingales. So these are basically hoop skirts
for your sleeves to make your sleeves stand out. At the same time in history men were wearing
something called a pease cod belly which is a type of padding that would go over the abdomen
and created the illusion of a pot belly and I swear I'm not making that up. They also used
outsized cod pieces which were of course phallic representations and they were also little purses
but they were a piece of clothing that was used to alter the appearance of the underlying anatomy.
Men and women also wore various types of padding and hoops and farthingales and proto corset type
things throughout the 17th century and then of course in the 18th century women started wearing
side hoops or panniers. These are the the ridiculous false hips of the ancien regime
and they were the standard uniform for women in every court in Europe. Side hoops remained a sort
of court uniform for decades after they had gone out of fashion and had been replaced by various
types of false rumps. So why are people obsessed with changing the shapes of their bodies with
their clothing? Part of this is what I like to call the child-bearing hips explanation and this
is the idea that people, especially women, like to exaggerate their silhouettes in different ways to
make themselves look more fertile. So they're exaggerating these elements of fertility. I think
that this is true but only to a certain extent. I think that humans tend to find signs of fertility
to be attractive and that is what they were going for. So for example an aristocratic woman in the
1760s would not have been thinking I will exaggerate my hips in order to make myself
look more fertile. No, she was thinking I will exaggerate my hips in order to make myself look
more attractive and it just so happens that what we perceive to be attractive generally lines up
with indicators of fertility. Although not always. But this would explain why people tend to always
go back to exaggerating the same elements of their anatomy. Why men tend to go back to codpiece type
things and why women tend to emphasize their hips buttocks and and breasts and not for example
trying to make their necks look thicker than they actually are or trying to make their heads look
unnaturally bulbous. Because if it were just about experimentation and trying new things surely
anything would be up for grabs. But no, we seem to be kind of going for the same basic silhouette
in different ways. People have also suggested the explanation that people in the past really wanted
to show off how much expensive fabric they could afford so they went for these very exaggerated
shapes. Again I think that there is certainly something to this but and I don't think that it
was a very one-to-one comparison. I don't think a woman in the 1760s would be necessarily thinking
I want to show people that I can afford this much fabric so I'm going to make my skirt very very wide.
I think it was much more subconscious than that. But whatever reasons people, primarily women, have
had throughout history for exaggerating their silhouettes those reasons likely did not change
once you got to the Victorian era. Rather what did change was the frequency and magnitude to which
people were altering their silhouettes through clothing and the accessibility of these silhouette
altering garments. The Victorian era was the first time in history when common everyday people could
participate in the body shape changing fashions. In all of the examples that I've previously given
bum rolls, farthingales, side hoops etc those were reserved for the elites, the aristocracy,
the super rich. For example while Marie Antoinette was dressing like this the average woman in Europe
and America was dressing like this. You can see that this woman is not engaging in the same sort
of body shape modification in which Marie Antoinette was engaging. Additionally the degree to which
people were wearing these body changing contraptions and the speed at which the fashionable
silhouette changed and the context in which people were wearing these garments changed. So again for
example Marie Antoinette was not dressing like this every day. This was only worn for very ceremonial
formal court occasions. Whereas in the 1880s most women would be wearing some sort of a bustle cage
every day. Now it might be a smaller one for the day-to-day tasks and then a larger one for more
formal occasions but some sort of bustle cage or padding would have been worn every day in the 1880s
for most women provided that they're not you know factory workers or working in some sort of enclosed
environment with heavy machinery. That was something new that came about in the 19th century.
An example of how ubiquitous and cheap these figure changing garments were can be found in an 1864 book
called A History of American Manufacturers. This book claimed that quote it is estimated that as
many as 60,000 hoop skirts of various sizes are made each day during eight months of the year.
That equals about 14.4 million hoop skirts in the year being manufactured just in the United States.
In 1864 when that book was published the population of the United States was roughly 35 million people.
Now assuming that roughly half of those were women and roughly half of those women were adults
that leaves us with approximately 8.7 million hoop skirt aged women in the United States.
So if the United States was not exporting any hoop skirts which it seems likely that they wouldn't be
or if they were they would be exporting very many of them because most other countries had their own
hoop factories that would mean that on average roughly every woman in the United States would
need to be buying roughly two hoop skirts every year in order to create this kind of demand.
Now that's a very rough estimation and those figures were done at one o'clock last morning
so take them with a grain of salt but it does give an idea of just how ubiquitous these fashionable
shape changing garments were. So why was that? Why did they become so ubiquitous and why did
they take off in the Victorian era with such a vengeance? And I think that can be summed up in
one word. Industrialization.
There are no exact dates for the Industrial Revolution but most experts agree that it took
place roughly between the years 1760 and 1900. In the very beginning its impacts were limited
primarily to industries and farming with the invention respectively of the cotton gin and the
spinning jenny. Also for the longest time I thought that the spinning jenny was called the
and I don't know why I thought that but just in researching for this video did I learn that the
rattling jenny is not a thing and it's called the spinning jenny. So that was a small galaxy rain
moment for me but with the invention of the cotton gin and the spinning jenny. Now these certainly
did have impacts on everyday people's lives. The spinning jenny made cloth significantly more
affordable than it was when it had to be woven by hand but in general the early advancements were
aimed at industries and not at everyday people. However by the 1840s these advancements these
industrial advancements had begun to trickle down and to impact the everyday lives of everyday
people. People began to decorate their homes with mass-produced knickknacks and mass-produced pieces
of furniture. They were wearing mass-produced jewelry. They were using increasingly more and
more complex machines in their everyday lives. The Victorians loved science and innovation and these
new industrial processes and products gave the perfect excuse to indulge in these passions. The
Victorians were so delighted by innovation and by science and they loved the idea of tricking
themselves and also they loved the idea of a cheap bargain. One of the biggest ways in which the new
industrialization impacted fashion was through advances in metalworking. One example of this is
sprung steel which was first invented in the 1760s. They discovered that increasing the amounts of
when it was in its molten state would increase not only the strength but also the elasticity of
the metal and over the next 150 years this would be put to various different uses including
fashionable ones. It was the discovery of sprung steel or the invention of sprung steel for example
that made the 1856 invention of the cage crinoline possible. The cage crinoline of course being a
steel petticoat that supports the skirts lightly and easily. It was also the invention of sprung
steel that made lightweight cage bustles and crinolettes and sleeve supports possible.
It also made corsetry a lot cheaper. While whalebone continued to be used in corsetry up
until the 1920s, beginning in around the 1860s the new sprung steel was beginning to be introduced
as an alternative to whalebone and that meant that corsets could be made much more cheaply
and the boning was a lot more durable. Another example of industrialism impacting fashion
is the relatively small seeming invention of the metal eyelet. For most of history eyelets
have been worked by hand and encased in thread or sometimes they would have a bone carved bone
eyelet. Those were expensive though but in the 1830s the metal eyelet was invented. Now it took
about a decade for the metal eyelet to become ubiquitous in fashionable applications but once
it did it was very clear that the metal eyelet was here to stay. While 18th century stays and
16th century bodies had been more aimed at smoothing out the silhouette and creating a
strong foundation for the heavy skirts and garments that would go over top of it, the invention of the
metal eyelet meant that Victorian corsets could be laced much more tightly than their ancestor
garments. Now while tight lacing was practiced in the 19th century it was by no means common,
however even though most women did not tight lace their corsets, Victorian corsets do have much more
of a shape that they impose upon the body than their ancestors had and that was made possible
by the invention of the metal eyelet. While it's true that pretty much all women in the 18th
century did wear stays, most 18th century women likely only had one set of stays and those days
would have had to last them for longer than a corset would have to last a Victorian lady and
because corsets could now be made much more cheaply and easily the fashionable corset shape
could change much more quickly than the fashionable shape for stays could change. Yet another element
of industrialization that impacted fashion was the 1850 invention of the sewing machine. Although
very elaborately crafted and cut and stitched garments had existed for centuries they were again
generally reserved for the super super elites. Most people were wearing simple garments cut from
simple shapes and sewn up with simple seams. The invention of the sewing machine changed that.
Before the sewing machine most people simply did not have time to fuss about with insertion
lakes and tucks and and gathers and frills and and what have you. The sewing machine made the
sewing process much much faster meaning that all of a sudden ordinary people could indulge in these
fashionable frivolous elements and that means that over the course of the 19th century you see
ordinary people's clothing becoming more and more ornate. Even their underwear is becoming ornate
and decorated and pretty even though nobody's ever going to see that. But they can do that now because
they've got the sewing machine which makes things go quickly they've got machine made lace so it's
cheap why not put it on your chemise. Similarly advances in weaving technology meant that fabric
became significantly less expensive over the course of the 19th century so ordinary people could
indulge in things like ruffles and over skirts and bustles and the like they could use more fabric
because they could afford more fabric because of the industrial processes. The new industrialization
also did not only impact women's clothing. A great example of how it impacted men's clothing is the
1885 invention of the celluloid collar and cuffs. This invention meant that men no longer had to pay
to have cloth collars laundered and starched instead they could just have one set of celluloid
collar and cuffs that could be rinsed clean under the tap every night and shaken dry and then go on
the next morning looking absolutely pristine. This meant that not only could more men partake in the
fashion for stiff collars and cuffs but also that collars and cuffs could become higher and stiffer
than ever before. Now I could go on ad nauseum about how industrialization impacted Victorian
fashions but I think you probably get the point. People had access to all of these new technologies
all of these things that they could never do before and they kind of went crazy with them and
you can see this in all aspects of Victorian life not just with clothing. For example when they
invented the telephone they were so excited that they named a pea after it. This is a time in which
people had the ability to do things that they could never do before and not only that but they
had the ability to do them on a massive scale a scale that would not have even been conceivable
just a few decades prior. In a way I think that the Victorian era is very very similar to the
Elizabethan age the age of exploration. In the second half of the 16th century Europeans were
being exposed to all sorts of new and different things from all over the world and again as a
result they went a little bit crazy with them. For example a lot of Elizabethan recipes call
for combinations of foods and spices that sound maybe a little bit odd to us today but they were
discovering all of these new lands and and things to which they'd never been exposed before and they
they wanted to use them in every way they could including by putting them on a plate. In 1577
the English clergyman William Harrison remarked on quote how many strange herbs plants and annual
fruits are daily brought unto us from the Indies Americas Tapervane the Canary Islands and all
parts of the world. Tapervane is another word for Sri Lanka or Ceylon. This new wonder and excitement
of discovery is very similar to the attitudes that we can see in the Victorian era surrounding the
fruits and products of industrialization. Because it was so influenced and driven by industrial
processes and industrial advancements Victorian fashion actually feels significantly more modern
to me than 21st century fashion does. Now it's true that some cutting-edge technologies these
days are influencing fashions things like virtual reality and 3d printing but these things are
novelties they're not mainstream and they're not driving fashion. Similarly synthetic fabrics are
ubiquitous today but again I would make the argument that they are not driving fashions.
Synthetic fabrics are trying to mimic the appearance of natural fibers they aren't pushing
the envelope in their own right they're just aping something else. In the Victorian era on the other
hand the industrial advancements were driving these changes in fashion directly that is something
that we did not see before the Victorian era and it's something that I don't feel like we've seen
since the Victorian era either. I'm going to close off this video with a comment left underneath
the original version of this video by Chloe Westfall Quirky Victorian quote
I think so much of the Victorian mindset was about conquering nature and shaping the world to their
liking. It was a very optimistic time not unlike the 1950s and 60s where the sky really seems to be
the limit for innovation and then not even the sky. You can see that a little bit in the styles
of those two decades but nothing after the Victorian era comes close to how extreme they took
it and as you said what really set the Victorian era apart from what came before it was that these
styles were actually accessible to all but the most destitute. No wonder the progress was so exciting
the average Victorian could really feel that he had a hand in it. I think that's why you see a
blossoming in those decades of everything from exploration to social reform movements to science
fiction and endless innovations. Everything could be changed and expanded and improved and the middle
class really felt like they had the power to share in that. So why not the human form? If not for the
first world war who knows how far into the 20th century this might have continued. So you're right
in saying that Victorian styles were more modern in spirit than anything we have today or have had since.
