Join my mailing list https://briankeating.com/list to win a real 4 billion year old meteorite! All .edu emails in the USA 🇺🇸 will WIN!
In 2001, my colleagues Andrew Lange, Jamie Bock, and William Holzapfel came up with a proposal for what would later be called BICEP. BICEP is an international collaboration that uses telescopes at the South Pole to look for signs of what happened moments after the Big Bang. In this video, I tell you everything you need to know about the program, the progress they've made, and what's next!
in 2001 20 years ago this year my
colleagues Andrew Lang Jamie Bach and
Bill Holt SEL came up with a proposal
for what would later be called bicep
bicep has morphed over the years into
bicep 2 bicep 3 and now bicep array it's
a stunning series of experiments that
unfortunately I'm no longer involved
with if you've read my previous book A
Farewell to Arms no losing the Nobel
Prize I described how I came to both
part weighs with and also be inspired by
the continuing developments with the
bicep team recently an analysis was
published in physical review letters one
of the most prestigious uh journals in
all of physics that has the most
stringent limits to date on Cosmic
inflation and the observable signature
that might or might not be present from
an early inflationary expansion of the
universe while I'm not involved with the
project anymore I'm fascinated by it and
I want to explain to you the
significance of these results and where
will cosmologist go from here come along
into the
impossible any sufficiently advanced
technology is indistinguishable from
Magic spoiler alert we haven't
discovered anything in this field in
terms of unequivocal proof or evidence
for an inflationary origin of the
universe there's a lot of circumstantial
evidence as we've talked about but
there's also competing models ranging
from s Roger penrose's conformal cyclic
cosmology to Paul steinhardt and ais's
balancing cosmological models and many
more that we will discuss in future
videos now the question of whether or
not the universe originated in a massive
super luminal expansion known as
inflation has fascinated me personally
since the early 2000s when I first came
up with the idea to build a tiny
refracting telescope one that Galileo
galile would surely recognize at the
bottom of the world Antarctica
specifically the South Pole and over
time we made more and more sensitive
upper limits that is we've excluded an
inflationary energy event above a
certain value cosmologists parameterize
the amount of inflationary gravitational
wave energy by what's known as the
tensor to scalar ratio the symbol is
lowercase R and that is the relative
ratio between so-called gravitational
wave or tensor pertubations and ordinary
density or scalar pertubations I'm your
density we've been setting limits on
these uh on these effects for over a
decade with the dedicated bicep series
of experiments and this new recent
result comes from the bicep 3
incarnation of bicep which is a massive
expansion to anything I would have ever
conceived of back in 2001 this is an
instrument that has about a half a meter
diameter aperture and it's uh
significantly larger almost three times
larger than the original bicep 1
aperture it can cram in many many more
detectors and couple those detectors
with very very uh sensitive phased array
type technology in the original bicep 1
we only had uh 49 polarized metal
machine feed horns that we use to detect
these tiny differences in the amount of
polarization in the microwave background
but the Incarnation of these telescopes
from bicep 1 to bicep 2 which use
transition ad superconducting detectors
to the current bicep 3 and now bicep
array series of detectors um has been a
slow steady increase not unlike your
iPhone H and its Evolution from iPhone 1
all the way up until the current iPhone
13 and back in 2001 we barely had I pods
and it's just stunning to think about
how far the technology has come and
these detectors are made by brilliant
colleague Jamie Bach at uh NASA's jet
propulsion laboratory and also uh
supported via a wide variety of
scientists all over the world and even
though as I say I'm not involved with
the bicep 3 and Beyond incarnations I
still can't help but feel a tiny bit of
Interest vested interest if you will in
the success of the project recently we
uh we heard a great fanfare announced
because of the threshold that was
reached by the bicep 3 experiment this
is uh reproduced from the physical
review letters article I'll show it on
the screen here that broke through this
barrier it broke through What's called
the an uncertainty level on the amount
of tensor to scalar ratio the amount of
gravitational wave energy in the early
Universe produced presumably by an
inflationary event where the inflaton
scalar field had fluctuations of the
space-time metric that then nucleated
waves of gravity which travel at the
speed of light endure for all time and
can make it to our detectors even today
but we choose to detect them and their
presence back on the surface of last
scattering and that surface of last
scattering is an imprint a fossil record
of how the universe looked when it was
only 380,000 years old so we're kind of
putting the detector system back as
close as we can to the source of the
explosion if you will if you think of
inflation as a sort of type of explosion
that ignited the big bang that we
subsequently measured the results
reported by bicep recently indicate that
that we're below the 1% level of
sensitivity the Precision level needed
to measure gravitational waves has
broken through the 1% barrier and even
though the likelihood of the
gravitational wave signature is slightly
above a mere uh two time multiple of
that one Sigma result namely the two
Sigma upper limit is actually higher
than the uh two times the
0.009 our uh Precision level uh that's
because the likelihood is slightly
shifted over I.E it looks to the naked
eye to the untrained brain as if there's
a slight detection of gravitational wave
energy but there's not there's not
significant enough to claim detection
but the the power and the procession
from uh from the relatively crude
measurements that we made with bicep one
and even other competing experiments
including my own experiments the Polar
Bear Experiment and other contemporary
experiments have have have yet to
approach anywhere near this level of
sensitivity now we hope to proceed even
further back in time and closer to the
source of primordial tensor pertubations
if they exist and remember the stakes
could not be higher because if inflation
takes place many of the most prominent
scientists do believe that the
Multiverse Paradigm is also ushered into
a state of believability maybe even
proof by discovering this and that we
know for sure would be one of the
conclusions because that's what happened
back in 2014 when bicep 2 made the
premature Discovery claim that we had
discovered gravitational waves from the
universe inflationary Epoch now that was
retracted later on our conclusion was
retracted we didn't make a blunder the
experiment is exquisitely sensitive and
far more sensitive than any other
experiment ever done of this type but
the interpretation as owing to a
primordial Cosmic event rather than dust
in the Milky Way galaxy uh had to be uh
essentially the uh uh disconfirmed um
result so we weren't able to establish
this conclusively now it doesn't mean
that gravitational waves don't exist it
doesn't mean inflation didn't take place
it doesn't mean the Multiverse isn't
true but we would like to have evidence
and so the bicep 3 team has now taken
data from more than just the one
frequency we used in bicep 2 namely 2 mm
wavelength 150 GHz frequency or with
bicep 1 we had three channels 90 GHz 150
GHz and 220 GHz but those detectors very
few of those operating in the in the
higher frequency bands now Cosmic dust
in our Milky Way galaxy was the ultimate
source of the large tensor tocala ratio
we claimed back in 2014 and is the
subject of losing the Nobel Prize but
that uh that was later found to be uh to
be able to be removed using data from
the plank satellite who were our
competitors at the time and still you
know kind of Frenemies and friend no
we're not friend we're not enemies but
we do we did eventually collaborate
together to R uh to reduce the
uncertainty uh from dust and actually
show that dust could contribute the
dominant the preponderance of the signal
that we claim to observe now what's
interesting is that bicep 3 is able uh
in the very near future if not now to
actually no longer need ancillary data
from another instrument namely from the
plank satellite to go deeper into the
removal process to get rid of the cosmic
Schmutz that contaminates the local
Galactic neighborhood the dirty window
the dusty window that we must look
through with our Cosmic instruments so
it's fascinating to note that kind of
the Gin has been thrown down by this uh
phenomenal team that continues to work
on a single goal and although there
hasn't been a detection this is an
important Proving Ground because what
does it starts to eliminate many many
classes entire classes of models of
inflationary parameter space so we're
able to really narrow down and zoom in
on the allowable regime in which these
inflationary models could have taken
place now will we ever be able to rule
out inflation I claim no because even if
we don't ever observe gravitational
waves we could still make the claim that
inflation took place but the energy
scale of inflation was too low to
manifest a observable background of
gravitational radiation that persisted
to this Epoch of last scattering so we
can't really falsify that inflation took
place some say that is a negative for
the inflationary model and and it's nonc
comporting with the scientific method
that things should be as Carl popper
said falsifiable in order to constitute
good science we've talked about that a
lot I won't go into it again in more
detail there are also haters of the
inflationary theory that POS because it
posits the existence of a Multiverse
which some claim is antithetical to the
scientific method because everything
that can possibly happen does possibly
happen we'll talk about that in a future
video as well on the physics of Free
Will coming soon so where are we we've
ruled out a lot of inflationary uh
models we would need to measure an
inflationary gravitational wave B mode
signal that I've talked about at length
in other videos uh in order to
conclusively demonstrate the existence
of these gravitational waves and that
would be important because that would
not only help provide evidence for
inflation and maybe even narrow down
even further as much as humans could
ever do narrow down the uh varying
parameters that characterize the
inflationary Universe it would also
eliminate other contenders for the
cosmic Genesis event in other words it
would eliminate things like the bouncing
model the E pyrotic model the conformal
cylic cosmology of Sir Roger Penrose the
string gas cosmology of Robert
brandenburger and kran bafa that we'll
talk about in other videos on this
channel so this non- detection is
actually an important stepping stone
towards an ultimate measurement perhaps
of the cosmic Genesis phenomenon if
indeed it did take place via inflation
and if it didn't we may see surprising
results along the way so these are
really truly heroic results um uh um I'm
happy for my former colleagues and
friends on the bicep uh experiment wish
them great success and of course with
our small aperture telescopes that we're
building here at UC San Diego at
Princeton University at UC Berkeley um
around the uh Simon's Observatory small
aperture telescopes these will hopefully
set an important limit or constraint or
detection perhaps of these primordial B
mode polarization signals and I claim
this is my editorial opinion that one
experiment cannot make a definitive
claim anymore we will not be satisfied
in this field of cosmology unless two
different experiments can confirm the
same type of signal they don't have to
measure the exact same thing that's
almost impossible in science they have
to measure broadly broad concept
consistency so that we can develop a
consensus that inflation took place if
again if indeed it did who who knows if
it did but it's quite exciting to note
that no one can really go uh to the
limits themselves no one goes to
Stockholm themselves anymore we need to
have confirmation if indeed this exists
and I think that hopefully uh we will
make great progress again as a scientist
you never want to bias yourself with the
confirmation Prejudice that you are
going to detect that which you set out
to detect because it often leads you to
reject things that are perfectly
acceptable uh but just don't comport
with your philosophical or scientific
worldview so for now this exciting news
released from the bicep uh Team the
bicep 3 team and I'm eagerly awaiting uh
new results to come from this uh
exciting field including results that
will come from hopefully right here at
UC San Diego and the Simon Observatory
team around the
world if you like this video You're
certain to like my conversation with
Juan M Desa about the origin of
singularities ads CFT and other Wormhole
Fascinations click here and don't forget
to subscribe
[Music]