Committee vote on I-2081 (Parents' Bill of Rights)

Washington State House Republicans
23 followers
Mar 1, 2024 #waleg #fixwashington
The House Education Committee takes executive action on Initiative 2081 (establishing a Parents' Bill of Rights). The initiative passed the committee by a 14-1 vote. #waleg #fixwashington
For more information on I-2081, view our summary of the initiative here: https://houserepublicans.wa.gov/i-2081/
the house education committee will come
to order good morning
everyone uh we have a very busy
schedule uh we are um going to uh take
executive action on house initiative
2081 concerning parental rights relating
to their children's public uh school
education uh Shall We Begin please with
a quick overview from staff a briefing
on the high points of the
initiative good morning Madam chair
committee members glad to be with you
early on this 54th day of the
legislative session house um excuse me
initiative 2081 declares 15 rights that
parents and guardians of public school
children have including rights to
receive or be notified of academic
medical safety and law enforcement
matters rights to examine and inspect
certain materials and records and rights
to opt their children out of certain
activities there are no amendments in
the books for the
initiative thank you are there questions
of
Staff seeing none Vice chair
Shavers Madam chair I moved that
initiative 20181 be reported out of
committee with a due pass
recommendation it has
been it has been moved and seconded uh
that initiative 2081 be reported out of
committee with a pass recommendation are
there
amendments there are no amendments is
there
discussion representative rud uh thank
you madam chair uh asking for a yes vote
from the committee um and appreciate the
most amazing briefest briefing Ethan um
on a on a a long bill or initiative um I
think that uh as we heard in committee
um a lot of what is in this bill is
current law um but I do believe there's
a lot of value for the public um parents
in particular um to see all of this in
one location um it can be difficult to
to track um especially for folks that
aren't in the
legislature um these kind of topics as
they're interwoven all through Statute
in various places so um I appreciate
that this bill was introduced by um
representative Walsh and and I
appreciate the chair um providing the
opportunity for the public um to have a
voice in discussing U the issue of
parental rights so um I'm looking
forward to uh seeing this on the ballot
and asking for the committee's
support thank you are there further
remarks representative stonier thank you
madam chair
um when I first heard of this initiative
I was frustrated I was thinking Here We
Go
Again recognizing how many times Public
School teachers
intent and public school leaders
intentions are
misrepresented thinking about how
intentional I was when crafting language
in the comprehensive sexual health
education Bill to
ensure that parents had the opportunity
to not only review what would be taught
but to also make sure that they could
opt their kids out of that education if
they wanted to do that um in at
home um I was comforted by the briefing
and the legal council that much of what
we have intentionally put in
statute is unchanged by this initiative
which Still Remains uh leaves me feeling
frustrated because the need for this
Clarity shouldn't be beyond what this
letter of the law law
states but here we are
again I'm comfortable supporting this
today because I know that it does not
change the protections that we work so
hard to establish in the other committee
that I sit on I know it does not disrupt
the access that students would have to
services at their um school-based Health
Centers I know now that mental health
counseling and access to reproductive
Health Care will not be undermined by
this initiative
and while I'm frustrated at the
misrepresentation that often
comes with talking
about whether or not par parents have
the right to be involved even after so
many
intentional this session and in sessions
before in my work and in the work of my
colleagues to be clear about
that thanks to the briefing and the
legal council I feel comfortable
supporting this
today thank you are there further
remarks representative orti
self thank you madam
chair um Madam chair I I heard a a lot
of we heard some stories of what uh what
seems to be um some parents uh
experience or perception of what's
happening in our schools and I am very I
was confused I was sad I was perplexed
Madam speaker in my school as a school
counselor when I have groups with kids I
send home notices to the parents and
they opt in they signed giving me
permission to pull their children out
and meet with
them uh when there ever there is a
crisis and we
intervene the first chance I get I
contact
parents we have curriculum that parents
get notified that we're about to do like
a safe touch curriculum parents have the
right to opt out and we contact them so
Madam speaker we've worked so hard to
make sure that the rights of parents I
have worked so hard my team has worked
so hard to make sure that parent voice
uh is at every level and that they know
and we protect the rights of any child
that opts out we make sure that there is
no harassment that they are well served
so to hear some of those stories I I
think school boards need to step up if
that's what's really happening and
address some very critical issues in
those areas it really saddened
me but Madam speaker I will say this
that as uh someone who has advocated for
years with my community and communities
of color to be included in those spaces
that is where the work needs to continue
to happen um we I have been advocating
that parents get translated materials
that our refugees and immigrants
understand uh their rights and how to be
involved and access to our school system
and we have failed in lots of areas um
so that is the area that I'm hoping that
if we're going to clarify things that we
need to clarify that all parents every
parent no matter where they're from no
matter what their language no matter who
they worship or don't worship needs to
be at the table whenever we have
committees materials need to be
translated for them they need to have a
voice and we have failed in that area so
that's the area I hope that we're going
to really beef up as we make sure that
we include them in all these processes
I'll be real honest with you we send out
notices uh to parents on on my groups
and we send them in
English and I have to call parents
myself in Spanish and explain to them
what I'm doing and I have to try to find
someone to speak to them in Ukraine or
Russian or Korean and that is not okay
this is stuff we should be doing so
we've got some work to do and I will
acknowledge
that but I will also acknowledge that we
have teachers who are working so hard to
partner with parents and to work with
them and we have put so many things in
Statue to ensure that parent voice and
so to all the teachers out there that
work so hard to do that keep doing your
great work uh we do it because we know
it's right parents are our partners keep
doing that great work for the areas we
need to improve on to include all
parents we'll keep working on that area
as well and I will say this I also am
concerned concern as a school counselor
that we not use this to marginalize or
hurt or harass any student in our school
system that we protect all students from
any of that regardless of our views and
at the time that that's
ends we need to be back here and put in
the protections to protect them we are a
public school system which means every
student that walks in that door must
feel safe must feel included must see
themselves
and I will continue to fight to that end
thank you madam
speaker thank you are there further
remarks representative
Couture thank you and good morning Madam
chair I just uh wanted to to say uh that
uh I'm proud that we live in a state
where the people have the authority over
the government and that in our states
Constitution they have the ability to uh
send us initiatives like this they have
the ability to legislate and that not
any one of us here or anyone in these in
the capital is more powerful than than
the people of
Washington
and it's incumbent upon me that when
they send us an initiative whether I
agree with it or not that um that we
have to listen
to what the people are
saying and with this initiative over
400,000
people signed on the dotted line that
they believe that we should
reaffirm uh these parental rights and
that they should have there should be
more transparency and
accountability uh in our school system
and I don't think that this
initiative
disparages uh uh some of the work that
is done in schools or some of the hard
work that our teachers and our staff do
um I can tell you that as a as a a dad
of of four kids um who all went to
Public Schools or go to public schools
in my
district um especially a dad of special
needs kids who are in special
education that over the years I have
been frustrated from time to time with
uh you know the the lack of um feeling
as a parent that I have power in in the
Ed in our public education system when
it comes to making sure that kids who
are like mine uh get what they need to
get the best education we can possibly
deliver to them and of course uh there
is a a little bit of a crisis uh with uh
we can we can do much better um um
delivering the basic education to make
sure that our comprehension rates are
better than they are now and we have
seen a lack of enrollment and and of
course the pandemic hurt things a lot it
hurt our schools it hurt our families
um and we're still in some ways
recovering from that
time and I think the spirit and intent
of this initiative although it
essentially reaffirms what is already
current is that parents uh want uh to be
involved they want to be the sole and
first educator in their kids' lives and
they don't want to feel like anything is
hidden from them or that they do not
have authority to parent their kids and
we've had a lot of discussions about
parental rights in other areas but when
it comes to education um this is one of
the most important things a parent
uh or a family and the school our public
school and the child are going to
Endeavor on for the next 18 18 years of
that child's life and um I stand in full
support of this initiative especially
the spirit of the initiative that
parents rights matter that they should
be able to see and consent to things
that happen in in their child's
education and I believe we should pass
this initiative um it's important to our
families and finally uh Madam chair I
think that um this initiative passing
this initiative is a good first step to
helping rebuild trust with those who
have lost trust in our public education
system thank you thank you further
remarks representative
pette thank you madam chair
I am voting no as an attorney who knows
that this initiative doesn't repeal any
rights I'm voting no as someone who's
been a Law School faculty and public
health faculty and as a parent because I
know that rights without remedy are
losery and because of fears of
misinterpretation
misapplication and because of the
glaringly
obvious problem of who has been left out
of this so-called parent Bill of
Rights I'm worried about
misinterpretation and the effect on
students who most need access to
counseling or health care who
will have messages and
misinterpretation that caused them to
think that they can't get that without
fear of disclosure to parents and
others
this initiative may
not actually affect the right of someone
to and a student to have
private uh access and ensure that
privacy but it's about the messaging and
it leaves us with an immense amount of
work that we will have to do to address
the epidemic of mental Health
needs needs to make sure that students
have counseling about drug use
about sex and avoiding
pregnancy
about their gender
and the fears of students who are gay or
queer or transgender for
disclosure and it will leave us with a
mountain of work to do to aure those
students that they have to be protected
and get the help and counseling or
health care they need and desire I'm
worried because of who is left out in a
so-called Bill of Rights for parents
when we've been working here in this
Committee in the legislature so hard to
provide the rights real rights with
Staffing and funding and remedies for
parents who have disabilities and whose
children have disabilities and they are
entirely left out of this initiative and
I'm very concerned that the parents who
need English translation to effectively
participate in their children's
schooling are left out of a so-called
parents Bill of Rights leaving us with
even more work to do
to try to ensure that this is not
misinterpreted as some exclusive Bill of
Rights because it wasn't drafted with an
inclusionary uh
body as it would have been if it had
been drafted here in this committee or
in the legislature and for those reasons
as a parent and as an attorney I am
voting no thank
you thank you further remarks repr
representative
Nance we thank you madam chair we know
it takes a village to raise a child
parents and teachers coaches and mentors
I'm the proud product of Washington's
K12 Public Schools I benefited from
great teachers great coaches great
mentors and from strong parental
involvement as well and it made a really
big difference in my journey when I was
in sixth grade I went through a rough
stretch and my teachers Mr corsetti and
Miss soiri were able to call my parents
in and actually discuss um a game plan
to get me back on track and that helped
me get back on track I believe this
initiative to the legislature will help
many of Washington students get back on
track and stay on track and as lawmakers
we should Advance policies that build
the strongest villages to raise
Washington's kids I believe I believe
this initiative to the legislature is in
that spirit and so I'll be voting for it
let this just be the next step in our
journey to support all of Washington's
kids no matter what their educational
backgrounds or aims no matter what their
family background looks like we should
be there in their corner to support
every child here in Washington thank you
thank you further remarks representative
Eslick thank you chair Santos I too will
be voting yes on this and it is a fact
that parents that are involved in their
children's
education help to grow children to be
successful it is a fact the more
involved they are in their school it is
a fact that that child has a better
chance to grow up to be healthy and an
asset to themselves and to their
family I was very fortunate to be able
to adopt a little girl at 2 and a half
and by the time she was ready for school
I was in that classroom with her it is
an amazing process and and it and what I
think that this bill has really done
this initiative that's really done is
emphasized to the parents that they do
have a voice and it also emphasiz to the
staff that they need to listen to the
parents and they all need to be working
together so I'll be very pleased to vote
Yes for this initiative thank you thank
you for the remarks representative
Timmons thank you madam chair you know
as we heard during public testimony on
this initiative parents play a f a
foundational role in the education of
their children as the father of a small
child myself I know I sure want uh say
in his education when he goes to
kindergarten and Beyond and that's
really what I appreciate about this
initiative frankly is that it affirms
the rights of parents and the important
role that they play in our education
system uh I do share some concerns
though which which have been uh
articulated by my colleagues here I'm
I'm very very concerned with the state
of mental health of our students and the
well-being um one of my takeaways from
the the public testimony during this
initiative is the weight of the world on
children at the moment frankly and this
initiative I think adds some anxiety to
some students and that has me very
concerned in addition to parents
Educators and support staff play a
fundamental and foundational role in the
education of our students as well and
each and every student deserves a
quality education and to feel welcome
and
supported in in their educational
environment so I'm voting yes in this uh
for this initiative today because I
believe that parents do have a right in
their children's education and I support
that but I also take seriously the role
of oversight that this legislature plays
for our education system and I'm going
to be monitoring how this initiative
takes effect and I'll be ready to stand
uh on behalf of students and Educators
as needed moving forward so I voted yes
thank you madam chair thank you are
there further
remarks representative
Harris thank you madam
chair I'm of the same faith of Mr
Hayward who put up the $8 million for
these
initiatives and Mr Hayward moved from
California and moved his 40 employees
here I think the major reason that uh
any man puts up $8
million is because he probably felt like
he couldn't get this through the process
and listening today he probably was
right um he moved
here because he just wanted to take care
of his
kids um I I think this is very
inclusive I
think
that Mr Hayward ran this through as I
understand probably eight attorneys but
there's always a smarter attorney than
the other one I just really
believe that this is a balancing of life
and Society at times I served on a
school board because I was concerned
about my
children uh and as I got involved in the
process I believe our education system
is phenomenal in many
ways but I believe we make sometimes
decisions that become family decisions
here and it concerns individuals and I
believe this is a difficult Balancing
Act but I absolutely will be voting for
this I believe
that if anything was happening to any of
my
children I would want to
know I don't think this takes that away
from them
I I just can't fathom not having a
relationship with my child if they
wanted to do something that they
couldn't come to me and talk about that
I understand there's families that are
that are not in that
situation but this won't preclude that
but this will open the door I hope for
dialogue within
families and I'll be voting
yes thank you are there further
remarks
the chair urges a yes vote um we've had
uh truly a robust discussion on this
final passage even though I would
probably argue most of us knew how we
were going to cast our vote when we
walked into this
room and I think it is because the
underlying issues are still very
challenging and troubling for us
regardless of how we cast our vote
today we have heard from the
public that all is not right in our
world of Education all is not right for
our
primary uh
constituents we've heard uh today and we
heard throughout the testimony that
nearly
450,000 washingtonians
signed uh the these initiatives I do
want to place that in a little bit of
context that's less than 6 and a half%
of the state's
population
nonetheless the message is loud and
clear that parents do feel
disenfranchised that is something that
many communities have been saying for
Generations indeed it's one of the
reasons I am here in the
legislature because people in my
community felt
disenfranchised by the institutions by
the systems by the policies by the
procedures they did not feel heard they
did not feel
seen and so I very much resonate with
that
messaging but there's another message
here and it is the one that makes
this vote
difficult for many of us on this side of
the
aisle and that
is students have rights
to and as the good gentleman from the
17th just indicated not everyone has the
great
Fortune to come from a great
family with two loving
involved parents and it's not just that
it's all of those in combination it
could be any one part of those you could
have a loving parent who is working five
jobs to provide for a roof over your
head and food on your
table so parents need to be heard and
seen but so do students and there is
fear right now in the
community I have always been proud that
this committee has made a point of
saying that we are going to be student
centered in our policym and success
focused student
centered and so I am glad to know from
the many attorneys that this initiative
does not dislodge many of the basic
protections that are student
need and rely on to feel safe to be
seen to be protected by the institutions
and the systems and the policies and the
procedures that we collectively on this
committee and in the other building are
responsible
for
ultimately we will have to monitor to
make sure because
because in the end all of these systems
all of these institutions all of these
policies and all of these
procedures must be administered by
people and frankly we are the wild card
it's our biases it's our perspectives
it's our histories especially for those
of us who are fortunate enough to be in
position of power it is incumbent on us
to Monitor and make
sure that the protections that we
believe parents and
students need deserve are and are
entitled
to are
upheld but today I will be voting yes
not only for parents but I will be
voting yes for students to say
we I stand with
you and we will walk this journey
together and with that I will ask staff
to please pull
up the committee standing
report and call the
role
Shavers all right
R Shavers votes I Roode rip Roode votes
I McIntyre I rip McIntyre votes I
Bergquist rip burus votes I Couture I
votes I Eslick I esck votes I Harris
Harris I re Harris votes I mlto vot I
rep mlto votes I Nance I rep Nance votes
I Ortiz
self Ortiz self votes I
pette pollet votes nay do not pass steel
Ste vot I re steel votes i stonier i r
stonier votes I Timmons Tim Timmons
votes I Santos s Santos votes I the
chair would ask that members please
check your vote as it's reflected on the
committee standing report before you and
indicate whether or not you wish to
choose or correct your
vote hearing none would you Max please
announce the vote totals Madam chair
there are 14 eyes one nay zero absent or
excused by your vote you have reported
initiative 2081 from committee with a d
pass
recommendation before we adjourn this
committee I know some people will need
to leave to uh get us ready for our
day's work uh but um this is the last
meeting of uh the house education
committee um and I would invite uh the
ranking member to um say some closing
remarks
thank you madam chair um I primarily
wanted to um just acknowledge and thank
staff for the tremendous amount of work
that that they do um both oppr staff um
and our caucus staff uh I've worked very
closely with um Stephanie all session
long um as a team to work on our side of
the AIS to develop um our legislative
priorities and it's been a lot of work
but very reward in um I know there have
been a couple bills that have taken uh
an an ordinate amount of uh time um and
I appreciate in particular Megan spent a
lot of time in uh in rooms with
representative Ken and I working on
isolation and restraint um and uh and so
I just appreciate the dedication and
long hours that are put in to support
all of us up here in being successful in
serving um our constituents back home um
so uh on behalf of committee thank you
so
much thank you uh ranking member um the
chair would also uh say take this
opportunity to express my personal uh as
well as on behalf of all of the
committee members um both Democrat and
Republican to our staff
I think it goes without saying we could
not do our job if we did not have the
best um team in the legislature I am
inclusive of both our uh caucus staff as
well as our nonpartisan staff I think
you know as an individual I come to rely
on each and every one of
you um and I appreciate that uh that um
I I know that when um I don't have
immediate access to Alice I can go to
any of the nonpartisan staff and I can
go to the uh Republican caucus staff um
and that is something that preserves and
protects this
institution that we call the people's
house um I would finally um just say
thank you to the ranking member the
assistant ranking member to my vice
chair to all of the members of the
committee for your Goodwill for your
good hearts for your intentionality
about focusing in on the needs of
students um we've not always had an easy
time plowing through
policy but at the end of the day we have
managed I think to show our public
that education can
be and should be a
nonpartisan matter for the sake of all
of our children so with that um I am
going to ask uh Vice CH Vice chair
Shavers um to please present our staff
uh all of our staff uh with a little
token of our appreciation and I will
invite all of the committee members to
rise as well as the audience to rise and
thank our
staff and with that the house education
committee is adjourned I did last
