PART 2: Full Committee Markup of the Authorization and Oversight Plan for the 119th Congress

Energy and Commerce Committee
68 followers
1 Video View·Mar 1, 2025
The Committee on Energy and Commerce will hold a markup on Tuesday, February 25, 2025, at 10:30 a.m. (EST), in the John D. Dingell Hearing Room, 2123 Rayburn House Office Building, and subsequent days as necessary, to consider the Authorization and Oversight Plan for the 119th Congress.
https://democrats-energycommerce.house.gov/committee-activity/markups/markup-authorization-and-oversight-plan-119th-congress-full-committee
and I gave you my personal answer as a
member of the minority the committee can
do that that falls within my Amendment
but I'm putting forth this amendment
because what I see happening right
now is the same thing that we see in
authoritarian
dictatorships is the same thing that we
saw King George
do to
colonists and that is if a me M of the
press has the tarity to disagree with
the president to criticize the
president or say something he does not
like he threatens to take their license
away or the FCC threatens action to
punish
them and if we continue seeing that and
it gets worse then yes I think this
committee should do something about
it I you
back the general lady
yields Mr chairman
what that's
fine I appreciate I appreciate the
response however I again go back to
we've just witnessed four years of
weaponization of every single federal
agency including the the explosive
practice of switch boarding in which we
saw Federal a agencies including the
Biden
FCC put incredible pressure on private
entities to comply with wholly
unconstitutional blatant violations of
the First Amendment and you had nothing
to say about
it no I do not yield
okay so the hypocrisy once
again is shining bright and clear the
American people have absolutely spoken
out loud and clear they are sick and
tired of the weaponization of government
this committee is serious about the
oversight capabilities that we have and
we will
exercise the general lady's time has
expired chairman I yield uh the chair
recognizes a general lady from
Massachusetts Miss
Tran I moved to strike the last word
uh I'm not sure if on in oversite the
subcommittee chose to bring uh a hearing
for what you just described as
weaponization of every single agency by
the Biden Administration but do I need
to remind you all that you're in the
majority you could have done that right
you could have actually called that
hearing we can't do it I wish we could
we will soon I yield uh my time to the
gentle lady from
Virginia yeah Mr chair actually M Tron
made my point but I want to reiterate
it for the last two years you were in
the majority and could have had whatever
oversight hearing you
wanted I wasn't here
before 2023 so I can't speak to what
happened whether or why it did but
here's what I did do I sat in the
Rotunda and heard the president of the
United States say there would be no more
weaponization of federal government
agencies was that a
lie what I have noticed in my short time
in Congress is many of the
accusations made by Republicans are
confessions and so what I see
happening
is a a
president and his whatever Elon Musk
is moving to take
control of as much of the federal
government as they can moving to take
control of our military leadership ship
moving to take
control of the press in whatever form
that it
is so that they can push out their
propaganda so that they can quash
descent and that is authorit
authoritarian leading to dictatorship
that is exactly what George Mason warned
against when he wrote the Virginia
Declaration of Rights that I quoted
earlier today
and I'm here to
say I'm not going to stay quiet about it
I
youe my I yield my time to the gentle
lady from New York thank you you know I
it just because we say things or a
person says something doesn't mean that
it's true and I've heard a lot of things
about weaponization of every agency even
the example on FBI and Twitter files I
served as a vice ranking member for the
oversight committee the entire last term
and all of these examples that are being
provided went through the oversight
committee investigation and it was
nothing burger after nothing Burger led
by James comr whiffing week after week
on this stuff this idea that the FBI I
know they say things but we actually
went through it it would be concerning
wouldn't it it would be concerning these
examples I genuinely please because
after a year James comr could not pro
procure a single example of the FBI
forcing Twitter's action in fact
Twitter's own lawyers said in
court in their own testimony as a
company that that was alleged that
people are alleging was so-called forc
their own lawyers said that they were
never Co worst or made by the FBI to do
anything at all in court in front of a
judge and so I mean when we talk about
the first amendment I'm curious as to
what my colleagues feel about this
Administration having their own acting
directors of Immigration and Customs
Enforcement for example going on Fox
News threatening sitting members of
Congress myself
opening a Department of Justice
investigation because I shared people's
constitutional rights with my
constituents where where's the Free
Speech verdict on that I'm going to get
locked up for it if yall do it you
better throw away the key I'll tell you
that much but
genuinely the the this idea that that
the majority Republicans are the
bastions of free speech eliminating the
white House Press court today and their
independence and the president of the
United States saying I'm only going to
pick the journalists that cover me or
who whatever Twitter accounts that they
favor the most now I mean let's dispense
with this folks this is this is this is
enough thank you I yield
back General lady yields the chair
recognizes a gentleman from Virginia Mr
Griffith thank you Mr
chairman so it's not quite going to be
six weeks I understand they're not going
to present all of the the other side is
not going to present all their
amendments I'm sitting here with you
know prepare prepared for another 30 but
I hear that's not going to happen uh I
will say this on this amendment though
and this is where we've been the whole
day the document that we're dealing with
covers all kinds of things in very
general terms so that it is available to
this committee to investigate what it
needs to investigate and we've gone down
Rabbit Hole after rabbit hole after
rabbit hole on specifics and
details didn't need to happen but here
we are and it's a part of the process if
the other side wants to bring all these
issues up we can but let me make clear
on the freedom of speech that I feel
very strongly about freedom of speech I
would submit and and I know the G lady
uh from Virginia who's my former
colleague in the Virginia House of
delegates knows uh some of this but but
she referenced uh the U Federalist
Papers and then she referenced George
III I'm going to reference George III
and John wils I am probably the only
member of Congress who has a caricature
of John
wils on the wall in his office now some
of you are going John wils who in the
heck is
that John wils was a Rabel Rouser in
London and he wrote a newspaper called
the North Britain and he made a
reference in North Britain 45 to the
Earl of but who was a North Britain he
was from Scotland and might have
participated in the revolution of 45 or
the rebellion of 45 by Bonnie Prince
Charlie and so he was making a slam on
the Earl of but who would be what we
would call today the Prime Minister and
George III in attacking those
policies he would later be U arrested or
attempted to be arrested in the courts
determined that because because he was a
member of parliament at the time that he
was writing these celicious things about
the king and the Earl of
but he could not be prosecuted he was in
touch with the Sons of Liberty and thus
is the basis of the freedom of speech
and I could get into General warrant but
that's not the subject of this amendment
but he was also the basis the The Wil
site rean of the 1760s was also the
basis for our prohibition against
General warrant him and Mr Otis so just
so that everybody knows both sides of
the a care about this issue we just
think that the document we currently
have would allow us to have plenty of
debate on this in our various
subcommittees without us having to have
been here for 12 or 13 hours I yield
back I yield to the gentleman from
Alabama Alabama Mr Palmer I just want to
point out uh some real examples of
political censorship and intimidation in
February 21 two house Democrats urged
cable satellite and internet programming
Distributors to drop Fox News News Max
and and one americ news in April of 21
uh the Biden Administration met with
Twitter to Advocate that conser
conservative users be shut down in July
of 21 the White House confirmed that it
was in regular touch with social media
companies about monitoring content it
deemed misinformation I could go on
demanding that big tech companies this
March 22 hand over information about how
many social media users I could go on
with this the interesting thing is is in
this committee and a markup oh my God a
resolution of
inquiry
good um
uh a resolution of inquiry was marked up
in the Energy and Commerce Committee was
introduced by my friend buddy
Carter uh that would have forced the FCC
to disclose any documents that detail
politically motivated censorship whether
it was
deplatforming um other examples of
censorship and every Democrat on this
committee voted against it every one of
you voted against
it it's just inter to me that all of a
sudden now you're you're concerned about
political censorship
I yield
back I yield back gentleman yields is
there any additional discussion on the
amendment if if there is no further
discussione the ranking member is
requesting a roll
call will the Clark please call the
rooll Mr L Mr L votes no Mr Griffith Mr
Griffith votes no Mr bakus Mr bakus
votes no Mr Hudson no Mr Hudson votes no
Mr Carter of Georgia Mr Carter of
Georgia votes no Mr Palmer Mr Palmer
votes no Mr
Dunn Mr
Dunn Mr D
dun Mr dun votes no Mr
kensaw Mr Joyce Mr Joyce votes no Mr
Weber Mr Weber votes no Mr
Allen Mr Allen votes no Mr balderson Mr
balderson votes no Mr fure Mr fure votes
no Mr fluger Mr fluger votes no Mrs
harbarger Mrs harshberger votes no Mrs
Miller Meeks Mrs Miller Meeks votes no
Mrs kamik Mrs kamik votes no Mr oberti
Mr oberti votes no Mr James Mr James
votes no Mr B Mr Ben votes no Mrs
howchin Mrs hin votes no Mr Fry Mr Fry
votes no Miss Lee Miss Lee votes no Mr
Langworthy Mr Langworthy votes no Mr
Kane Mr Kane votes no Mr Ry Mr Ry votes
no Mr Evans Mr Evans votes no Mr Goldman
Mr Goldman votes no Miss fedorek Mrs
fedorek votes no Mr palone Mr palone
votes I miss
deette miss
chowski miss
chowski miss Sakowski votes I miss
Matsui Miss Matsui votes I miss Caster
Miss Caster votes I Mr tonco Mr tonko
votes I miss Clark Miss Clark votes I Mr
Ruiz Mr Ruiz votes I Mr
Peters Mrs
Dingle Mr visi Mr VC votes I Miss Kelly
Miss Kelly votes I miss beragon miss
Bagon votes I Mr SoDo Mr SoDo votes I
miss shrier m Sher votes I Miss Tran Mr
hand votes I miss Fletcher Miss Fletcher
votes I miss okazi Cortez Miss oazo
Cortez votes I Mr aen Claus Mr aen Claus
votes a Mr Carter of Louisiana Mr Carter
of Louisiana votes I Mr
Mendez Mr Menendez votes I Mr
Mullen Mr
lansman Miss mclen Miss mclen votes I
chairman Guthrie chairman Guthrie votes
no
has everyone been recorded does anyone
seek
recognition the clerk will report the
result chairman Joyce on that vote there
were 19 eyes and 29 NOS the amendment is
not agreed to are there any further
amendments
for what person for what purpose does
Miss trean seek
recognition uh Mr chairman I have an
amendment at the desk the clerk will
report the
amendment which amendment is that Mr TR
uh
h12 amendment to draft oversight plan
h12 without objection the reading of the
amendment is dispensed with and the
gentle lady is recognized for 5 minutes
in support of her Amendment thank you Mr
chairman I am offering this amendment to
make it clear that this committee has a
responsibility to provide oversight of
medicare's drug pricing negotiation to
ensure that Americans are getting the
best deal possible on their prescription
medication now I know that my colleagues
are put out and maybe even a bit annoyed
by these amendments but these are
important debates these are debates that
our constituents want us to have because
the the times that we find ourselves
living in are dramatically different
than when we adopted the committee's
oversight plan last
Congress now because the inflation
reduction act because of the inflation
reduction act Medicare finally has the
power to negotiate drug prices on behalf
of American patients a long overdue
Common Sense policy that people across
the country overwhelmingly support and
saves our government money for too long
pharmaceutical companies dictated prices
with no accountability forcing seniors
and hardworking families to pay
exorbitant costs for life-saving
medications now the largest
pharmaceutical customer in the country
Medicare can leverage its bargaining
power to secure lower drug prices just
like private insurers and other
countries have done for years and passed
those savings onto American taxpayers
this is what the American people have
been demanding because they're tired of
choosing between putting food on the
table heating their homes and affording
the medications that they need to
survive now it's up to Congress to build
on this progress to not only ensure that
we're lowering drug prices and that
remains our priority but that we're
expanding the portfolio of drugs being
negotiated so that more people see more
savings when they're at the pharmacy
counter our Focus must be on lowering
health care costs and expanding access
to Affordable medications not rolling
back or walking away from policies that
finally put patients first this is a
moment to listen to the American people
and make sure medicare's ability to
negotiate remains strong so that no one
is forced to make the impossible
decision between their health and their
Financial Security the inflation
reduction acts Medicare price
negotiation inflation rebates and
out-of-pocket caps are already driving
down costs for seniors but we must
ensure that these policies are
implemented effectively and deliver the
savings patients deserve strong
oversight by this committee will also
help identify opportunities to expand
these benefits to more Americans
including those with private insurance
so everyone can access affordable
medications I urge my colleagues to
support this amendment and I yield back
the balance of my
time anyone seeking in recognition for
discussion gentleman from Georgia you
recognized for five minutes move the
strike the last word Mr chairman I speak
in opposition to the amendment since the
passage of the inflation reduction act
the IRA or the by Biden and
Congressional Democrats drug pricing
control scheme seniors have seen fewer
choices in affordable prescription
medications and skyrocketing
premiums it's also anticipated seniors
will have less access to Innovative and
life-saving Drugs in
2024
year in 2024 year over over-year
Medicare Part D premiums jumped by over
20% while the number of plans that
exited dep Part D program decreased
increased by more than 10% in some areas
such as California individual plan
premiums Jump by almost
60% more consequentially the law has
already had chilling effects on research
and development of new therapies Mr
chairman I have said and I continue to
say and please hear me clearly in 10
years in the Georgia state legislature
and 10 years in Congress this is the
worst legislation I have ever seen more
consequences the law has already had
chilling effects on research and
development of new therapies since the
laws
passings in August of 2022 there have
already been 40 research programs
discontinued and 22 drugs cancelled in
oncology Alone six drugs have already
been discontinued couple with cuts to
several research programs the evidence
is clear that price controls don't work
and have drastic consequences that only
hurt patients extending these policies
to commercial markets will further
exasperate the challenges created by the
IRA that only lead to continue price
increases for patients at the drug
counter it will also lead to Patient
delays in receiving life-saving care and
overall reductions and access to life
preserving and lifesaving medications
we've already made bipartisan solutions
to hold Pharmacy middleman pbms
accountable and increasing transparency
we can and we should work to ensure
these policies become law in addition to
pursuing bipartisan market-based part
policy solutions that will lower costs
without sacrificing life- saving
Innovations this amendment does nothing
to accomplish either of these and I urge
members to vote no and I yeld back
gentleman yields back is our further
discussion gentleman from Florida
recognized for five minutes thank you Mr
chairman and I yield to the general lady
from
Washington I I just was listen to this
conversation about drug pricing what our
patients want what have been great
decisions and I will tell you that what
I hear from my constituents is that $35
insulin has been a lifesaver I get thank
yous all the time and I don't believe a
one of you voted for that I'm gonna now
yield uh to my colleague Lori Tran from
Massachusetts thank you I just um happy
to get so many things out on the record
today because I think if I go back the
12 hours when we started I heard we're
gutting Medicare to the tune of nearly
$1
trillion and now we're going to roll
back the savings that we have passed on
to patients who need life-saving
medication so they can expect their $35
insulin to go back up we will stop
Medicare will stop uh negotiating drug
prices so that they can afford their
medicine at the life saving counter and
there will be no expanded portfolio or
more people who will get the benefit of
uh affordable prescriptions that's great
that gives me all I need not only to uh
uh that gives me all I need thank you
and I reclaim the time on the night
where we saw a vote to cut
$880 billion dollar from Medicaid you're
going to attack the IRA I find that to
be very
interesting Mr chairman Jim yield back
gentleman yield back gentleman Yi's back
gentleman from Alabama recognized for
five minutes thank Mr chairman I yield
my my time to the gentleman from Georgia
Mr Carter Mr chairman again let me
explain $35 co-pay on insulin is great
for patients but it does nothing for the
cost of the drug it still continues to
go up it is not going to address the
cost of the drug to the insurance
company and ultimately to the patient
yes a 30 if we can cap copay Mr chairman
I'm reclaiming my time
$35 Cod payment is great but it does
nothing for the cost of the drug the
drug continues to go up and that's not
the problem the problem is the middleman
the pbms that are causing the drugs to
go up and I Y
back gentleman yields back to gentleman
from Alabama this I yeld Mr chairman
gentleman yelds back is there any
further discussion gentleman from
Massachusetts uh the gentleman from
Georgia makes a good point that the
pharmacy benefit managers play a
massively distorting role as the
middleman of drug pricing and they have
caused the drug list prices to inflate
to the detriment of the people who pay
co-pays based on that list price which
is why it is so
disappointing that we were within 12
hours of passing bipartisan PBM reform
at the end of last Congress that the
gentleman from Georgia worked so hard
and so diligently to get to the finish
line and then Elon Musk tweeted one mean
thing about it and speaker Johnson
flinched the health insurance Lobby
flexed and speaker Johnson got scared
let's hope that speaker Johnson doesn't
get scared this time around and actually
works to lower health care prices for
Americans not just prescription drugs
but also the care for at Home Care for
Seniors for perinatal care for new
mothers by not cutting
Medicaid I yield back himman yields back
Is there further discussion G lady from
Washington uh I'll just note uh
as somebody with type 1 diabetes who
relies on insulin I heard from my
endocrinologist that when we dropped uh
insulin prices to $35 a month for
seniors the insulin making companies
independently dropped prices for each
one of each type of insulin long acting
short acting you name it so that the
out-of-pocket cost to Consumers would be
$35 they saw the writing on the wall
that we were coming after them and they
made those changes so yes it did change
the price of those medicines and it does
save
lives G lady yields
back there further discussion seeing
nonee the vote occurs on the amendment
the gentleman from New Jersey requested
a roll call the clerk will report will
call the
rooll Mr L Mr L votes no Mr Griffith Mr
Griffith votes no Mr bakus Mr bakus
votes no Mr h
no Mr Hudson votes no Mr Carter of
Georgia Mr Carter of Georgia votes no Mr
Palmer Mr Palmer votes no Mr
Dunn Mr
Dunn Mr Dunn votes no Mr
kensaw Mr Joyce Mr Joyce votes no Mr
Weber Mr Weber votes no Mr Allen Mr
Allen votes no Mr balderson Mr balderson
votes no Mr fure Mr fure votes no Mr
fluger Mr fluger votes no Mrs harburger
Mrs harburger votes no Mrs Miller Meeks
Mrs Miller Meeks votes no Mrs kamik Mrs
kamik votes no Mr oberti Mr overaly
votes no Mr James Mr James votes no Mr B
Mr B votes no Mrs howchin Mrs hin votes
no Mr Fry Mr Fry votes no Miss Lee Miss
Lee votes no Mr Langworthy Mr Langworthy
votes no Mr Kane
Mr Kane votes no Mr rouy Mr ruy votes no
Mr Evans Mr Evans votes no Mr Goldman Mr
Goldman votes no Mrs fedorek Mrs fedorek
votes no Mr palone Mr palone votes I
miss
deette miss
chowski miss trakowski votes I miss
Matsui Miss Matsui votes I miss Caster
Miss Caster votes I Mr tonco Mr tonko
votes I miss Clark Miss Clark votes I Mr
Mr Ruiz votes I Mr
Peters Mrs
Dingle Mr VC Mr VC votes I Miss Kelly
Miss Kelly votes I miss pagon miss pagon
votes I Mr SoDo Mr SoDo votes I miss
Sher Miss Sher votes I Miss Tran Miss
Tran votes I miss Fletcher Fletcher
votes I miss Ocasio Cortez so Kazu
Cortez votes I Mr aen Claus Mr aen Claus
votes I Mr Carter Louisiana Mr Carter of
Louisiana votes I Mr Menendez Mr
Menendez votes I Mr Mullen Mr
lansman Mr lansman votes I miss McCullen
Miss McCullen votes I chairman
Guthrie chairman Guthrie votes no anyone
seeking to answer the roll call seeing
no one seeking to answer the roll call
the clerk will report
chairman Guthrie on that vote there were
20 eyes and 29 NOS the amendment is not
agreed
to for what purpose does the gentleman
from Florida seek
recognition Mr chair uh to present
Amendment
H4 the clerk will report the
amendment amendment to draft oversight
plan
h14 without objection the reading the
amendment is dispensed with and the
gentleman is recognized for 5 minutes
and support of the
amendment thank you Mr chairman you know
I care about affordable health coverage
for all Americans both my constituents
and yours and so this amendment is
continuing on that theme but this time
with the ACA uh making sure that the
health coverage continues to be
affordable you know in Florida a lot of
people may be surprised now we have the
largest Obamacare Exchange in the nation
4.6 million Floridians get their health
care private insurance through the
Affordable Care Act Exchange
Texas and California also have giant
Obamacare exchanges in my district we
have the second most in the nation and
the top five are all in Florida 237,000
people getting their health care through
the Obamacare exchange and in 2021 we
passed the premium tax credit it was a
smashing success we saw people save
thousands of dollars and many many more
people in places like Florida and Texas
and California and up getting Private
health care uh in lowering the uninsured
rate but this is the thing this premium
could go away this premium tax credit
could go away if we don't extend it
before the end of the year in fact
millions of Americans will see their new
rates come out in May if Congress does
nothing which is why it's a critical
importance as we see the CR coming up
because the bill is going to come due
and it's going to be huge for folks I
was looking at the Kaiser Family
Foundation
calculator in a family of four middle
class upper middle class making about1
to $125,000 a year they could expect a
$113,000 increase in their payments and
if we're talking about now with Medicaid
in Florida if we see these drastic cuts
of $ 880 billion dollars and U that
affects our chip program where we have
$2.4 million children on KidCare well
that also now people are going to have
to get both those in a family of four
two kids ins shorted that's another 8 to
10 grand and so when you look at we're
talking about 8 to 10 to 12 Grand per
family in increases that we could see
before the end of the year and the bill
comes due it ends up being about 20 or
$30,000 for health insurance for a
family of four and then it gets even
worse with nursing homes because it's
about 30 to 50 Grand to pay for a
grandma uh who no longer is getting
covered by Medicaid uh to make sure that
she's covered um in a nursing home and
inflation is one of the top issues if
not the top issue so I would imagine 8
to 12 Grand more that folks are going to
be paying every year is um going to be
something that they're going to notice
we don't want the bill to come do for
Florida families in May or for any other
families and so this is another fork in
the road we have an oversight plan where
we could do something about it or it
could be ignored but the bills still
come in due and so I hope I can get your
support and yield back Jim and's back is
there any
discussion seeing no further
discussion the vote occurs on the
amendment a roll call vote has been
requested by the general from New Jersey
the clerk will call the rooll Mr L Mr L
votes no Mr Griffith Mr Griffith votes
no Mr bacus Mr bakus votes no Mr Hudson
no Mr Hudson votes no Mr Carter of
Georgia Mr Carter of Georgia votes no Mr
Palmer Mr Palmer votes no Mr Dunn
Mr Dunn votes no Mr Crenshaw Mr Joyce Mr
Joyce votes no Mr Weber Mr Weber votes
no Mr
Allen Mr balderson Mr balderson votes no
Mr fure Mr fure votes no Mr fluger Mr
fluger votes no Mrs harshbarger Mrs
harbarger votes no Mrs Miller Meeks Mrs
Miller Meeks votes no Mrs
kamik Mrs Kik votes no Mr oberti Mr
oberti votes no Mr James Mr James votes
no Mr B Mr B votes no Mrs hin Mrs hin
votes no Mr Fry Mr Fry votes no Miss Lee
Miss Lee votes no Mr Langworthy Mr
Langworthy votes no Mr Kane Mr Kane
votes no Mr ruy Mr ruy votes no Mr Evans
Mr Evans votes no Mr Goldman Mr Goldman
votes no Mrs fedorek Mrs fedorek votes
no Mr palone Mr palone votes I miss
deette
Miss trakowski Miss chowski votes I miss
Matsui Miss Matsui votes I miss Caster
Miss Caster votes I Mr tonco Mr tonco
votes I miss
Clark Miss Clark votes I Mr Ruiz Mr Ruiz
votes I Mr
Peters Mrs
Dingle Mr VC Mr VC votes I Miss Kelly
Miss Kelly votes I Miss baragan Miss
baragan votes I Mr SoDo Mr SoDo votes I
miss Sher Miss sh votes I Mr Han Mr Han
votes I miss Fletcher Miss Fletcher
votes I miss Ocasio Cortez Miss
OAS Miss Osio Cortez votes I Mr aen
Claus Mr aen Claus votes I Mr Carter of
Louisiana Mr Carter of Louisiana votes I
Mr Menendez Mr Menendez votes I Mr
Mullen Mr lansman
Mr lansman votes I miss mclen miss mclen
votes I chairman Guthrie chairman
Guthrie votes no is anyone seeking
answer the roll call seeing none the
clerk of a
report oh excuse me I'm click has
reported yes so how's Mr Allen reported
Mr Allen is not reported not reported Mr
Allen votes no the clerk a report
guess into their report it's open
chairman Guthrie on that vote there were
20 eyes and 29 NOS the amendment is not
agreed to for what purpose does
the general lady from Washington have an
amendment uh yes I do Mr chairman I have
an amendment titled
h26 CER
report amendment to draft oversight plan
h e 26 without objection read the
amendment is dispensed with and the
general lady is recognized for five
minutes to sport of her
Amendment thank you Mr chairman uh as a
pediatrician and a member of Congress I
am always laser focused on the health
safety and well-being of children and
their
families measles is one of the most
contagious diseases known and thanks to
widespread vaccination it was declared
eradicated in the United stes States
over 20 years ago now fast forward to
now 2025 and measles has infected over
100 people in Texas and New Mexico just
in this past week a majority of those
cases are children nearly all are
unvaccinated 20% have been hospitalized
and you know what all of these could
have been
prevented make no mistake this measles
outbreak is the direct consequence of
baseless antivaccine rhetoric much of
which has been propagated for decades by
our secretary of Health and Human
Services Robert F Kennedy Jr confirmed
this month by Republican Senators
knowing full well what they were getting
into this kind of vaccine Mis
misinformation and doubt spread by Mr
Kennedy is beyond irresponsible it is
reckless he continues to question
settled science and scare parents some
of whom choose not to immunize their
children putting their children and
others at risk for diseases that are
absolutely
preventable I expressed serious concerns
with his nomination uh to lead an agency
that is charged with protecting our
nation's health and making decisions
based on sound science and uh now that
he is in I believe it is time to hold
him accountable and to that mission and
my Amendment mandates that this
committee summon secretary Robert F
Kennedy Jr to appear in person and to
testify every time there is an outbreak
of more than three cases of vaccine
preventable illnesses including but not
limited to measles MPS menitis pessis
polio and
vericella his Senate confirmation for
this position was a travesty it was an
embarrassment sadly there will be tragic
consequences to this and he needs to be
held accountable by answering to us here
in this committee I encourage all of my
colleagues to vote Yes on accountability
and I yield back is there a discussion
on the amendment gentleman from Georgia
you're recognized for five minutes move
to strike the last
word Mr chairman I I move to speak in
opposition to the amendment the
committee's oversight plan clearly
states clearly states that the committee
will conduct broad oversight over
CDC the oversight plan already includes
broad Public Health oversight so this
amendment is unnecessary and although
I'm might add is perhaps the most
detailed Amendment I've ever heard and
I'm very
impressed I urge my colleagues to vote
no on this
amendment gentan yields back Is there
further discussion gentle lady from
Massachusetts I moved to strike the last
word in support of this thank you um the
head health director should be a trusted
source of science-based information
someone the public can rely on during
Health crisis instead he has played a
significant role in fueling vaccine
conspiracy theories given the dangers of
this disinformation it's essential to
call him in whenever a preventable
disease outbreak occurs and I really do
credit um my colleague from Washington
for the detail in this amendment because
I think it's wholly actionable by our
oversight committee everyone on this
committee should agree that vaccines
have saved lives for decades protecting
Children and Families from deadly
diseases and preventing public Public
Health crisis the fact that we are still
fighting against disinformation about
something so fundamental to Public
Health it's not just uh frustrating it's
dangerous Robert F Kennedy's Jr's
Reckless spread of vaccine
disinformation puts lives at risk sewing
distrust in proven science and
endangering communities and you don't
have to take my word for it or my
colleagues word for it look at the
consequences of RFK Junior's actions in
Samoa his dubiously titled antivaccine
organization the Children's Health
defense had spent years amplifying
discredited lies about vaccines
including the measles vaccine when he
visited the island nation in 2019 he did
so with the goal of scaring parents away
from the vaccine months later a measles
outbreak swept Across the Nation
infecting thousands and killing 83
individuals almost all of whom were
small
children that could happen in our
country and I think it would be
responsible of the committee that if it
does because he has to sit at that table
and answer for it to this day Mr Kennedy
has refused any accountability for those
tragic preventable deaths including
during his testimony before the Senate
just weeks ago when he said quote we
don't know what was killing them and
quote that's a lie and it's one that was
called out by Samoa's director general
you know as a mother I know I'm not
alone here many most of us have children
we would do anything to protect our kids
every parent should have the confidence
that when they take their child to the
doctor they are making the safest most
informed decision possible not one
clouded by conspiracy theories and
political opportunism the politization
of vaccines is costing lives and we
cannot allow anyone especially the HHS
secretary to undermine Decades of
medical progress the stakes are too high
we must stand up to disinformation
ensure that every family has access to
the truth vaccines save lives and
spreading lies about them has deadly
consequences Mr Kennedy must be held
accountable by this committee and
required to answer for his role in
spreading misinformation when a
preventable outbreak occurs on his watch
I urge my colleagues to support this
amendment and I yeld back GLE lady Ys
back is there any further discussion
seeing
none the vote occurs on the amendment
the gentleman from New Jersey has
requested a recorded vote and the clerk
will call the r
Mr L no Mr L votes no Mr Griffith no Mr
Griffith votes no Mr bakus no Mr bakus
votes no Mr Hudson no Mr Hudson votes no
Mr Carter of Georgia Mr Carter of
Georgia votes no Mr Palmer Mr Palmer
votes no Mr Dunn Mr Dunn votes no Mr
Crenshaw Mr Joyce Mr Joyce votes no Mr
Weber Mr Weber votes no Mr Allen Mr
Allen votes no Mr balderson Mr balderson
votes no Mr fure Mr fure votes no Mr
fluger Mr fluger votes no Mrs harburger
Mrs harburger votes no Mrs Miller Meeks
Mrs Miller Meeks votes no Mrs kamik Mrs
kamik votes no Mr oberti Mr obti votes
no Mr James Mr James votes no Mr B Mr B
votes no Mrs hin Mrs hin votes no Mr Fry
Mr Fry votes no Miss Lee Miss Lee votes
no Mr Langworthy Mr Langworthy votes no
Mr Kane Mr Kane votes no Mr rouy Mr rouy
votes no Mr Evans Mr Evans votes no Mr
Goldman Mr Goldman votes no Mrs fedorek
Mrs fedorek votes no Mr
palone Mr palone votes I miss
deette miss
chowski miss chowski votes I miss Matsui
Miss Matsui votes I miss Caster Miss
Caster votes I Mr tonco Mr Mr Tonka
votes I miss Clark Miss Clark votes I Mr
Ruiz Mr Ruiz votes I Mr
Peters Mrs
Dingle Mr VC Mr VC votes I Miss
Kelly Miss beron Miss Bon votes I Mr
SoDo Mr SoDo votes I miss Trier M Trier
votes I Mr Tran Mr Tran votes I miss
Fletcher Miss Fletcher votes I miss Osio
Cortez Miss Osio Cortez votes I Mr aen
Mr aen Claus votes I Mr Carter of
Louisiana Mr Carter of Louisiana votes I
Mr
Mendez Mr Mendez votes I Mr
Mullen Mr
lansman Mr lansman votes I miss mclen
miss Mullin votes I chairman
Guthrie chairman Guthrie votes no the
clerk is there anyone seeking
recognition to vote on the CN n the cler
report
chairman Carter on that vote there were
19 eyes and 29 nose the amendment is not
agreed to so I just announce it appears
there's one more amendment to be offered
and then we'll also have to vote on the
plan so we should have two more votes so
uh what purpose gentleman from New York
seek recognition Mr chairman I have an
amendment at the desk the um the clerk
will what do you have the number of the
amendment it's the Alzheimer's research
tonco
Amendment the clerk have that Amendment
the clerk will
report allim Alzheimer research offered
by Mr tonco that objection the read of
amendment is dispensed with and the
gentleman is recognized for five minutes
in support of the amendment thank you Mr
chair uh my colleagues my amendment is
simple and
self-explanatory it would simply require
this committee to examine the impact
that the Doge Personnel cuts are having
on our federal research efforts to
address Alzheimer's disease let me be
clear our federal research Enterprise
and in particular Alzheimer's focused
research are programs that have long
been championed by B bipartisan members
of this committee I'm indeed proud to
have worked with my colleague and our
chairman Mr Guthrie on a number of
pieces of Alzheimer's legislation over
multiple congresses that have helped
informed our federal response on this
devastating disease
has been a good friend and a steadfast
leader in the fight to provide hope to
those struggling with an Alzheimer's
diagnosis as the Energy and Commerce
Committee we literally built the federal
Alzheimer's research infrastructure
together these are programs that we
developed drafted and debated right here
in this very room it's the type of
serious sustained bipartisan work that
every member of this committee should be
proud of the programs we have authorized
have led to countless breakthroughs that
help us better understand Alzheimer's
and related dementias that have given
Millions across this nation and indeed
the world hope that American Ingenuity
can one day rid the world of this
terrible Affliction again this is
something we should all feel
institutional Pride for in a bipartisan
fashion this is good work this is the
type of thing that we all come to
Congress to accomplish but at this
moment I don't feel proud I feel angry
whiteart anger because instead of
supporting American innovation and
Ingenuity instead of working to provide
hope to families across Nation unelected
bureaucrats led by Elon Musk are working
at this very moment to tear that hope
away just last week it was reported that
almost one tenth of the workers at the
nih's center for Alzheimer's and related
dementias card have been fired by Elon
Musk and his doge team included among
the reported Cuts was the incoming
director for the center Kendall van
curan Jenson widely recognized as a
leading researcher in the field her
research was particularly impactful on
helping to enable early detection of
Alzheimer's one of our best hopes in
delivering effective treatments
furthermore according to ABC News one of
those fired recently published a first
author paper in a high impact Journal
yet we're told they were being fired for
poor performance the outgoing director
of card Andrew Singleton told colleagues
in an email that the layoffs would and I
quote have a profound impact on the work
we do to understand and treat this
disease this is not seeking without
waste fraud or abuse this is simply a
meat cleaver how am I supposed to
explain these cuts to the family in
Boston spa that I represent who are
looking for any hope for an aging parent
who has just received that heartbreaking
diagnosis how do I explain that this to
our friends living with Parkinson's and
other neurological disorders who
understand that this research was also
their hope how am I supposed to explain
these cuts to researchers at the
University of Albany who are at this
moment working to develop groundbreaking
screening tools to help address early
detection I'll close with a plea to my
colleagues this is not a partisan issue
it's an Institutional one none of you
voted to bring this wanting cruelty to
Alzheimer's patients but you can vote
today to say with one clear voice that
the Energy and Commerce Committee wants
to put an end to it let's stand up in a
bipartisan fashion and put a stop to
this utter nonsense I ask you to support
my Amendment with that Mr chair I yeld
back the gentleman Ys back to the chair
recognizes himself for five minutes to
speak on the amendment I just want to
say uh to my good friend from New York
that we have worked diligently together
and and a lot of times people when I
know all of us are home and and talking
to different groups of people they say
why can't you find things to work
together on and and the things that
we've worked together on just don't make
the news at night because we trying to
get things solved and work together and
most of the issues that we work on this
committee are similar to The Bold act
and and the air support act and things
that we have worked on together in
Alzheimer's research and even today's
hearing and though it's been contentious
and we have differ opinion vast
difference opinions we've all been
respectful to each other throughout the
day and and I and I appreciate that I
want to tell the whole committee I
appreciate that and I will tell you we
are going to continue I buried my
mother-in-law last year I know that we
have members on this committee who
taking care of their mother and and
others that have experienced this and
we're going to continue to work on
Alzheimer's we're going to make sure it
goes forward and uh the the amendment is
not needed because I can commit to
everyone I think everybody here it's not
just the human cost of Alzheimer's is
what it does to the the person that has
it the family the caretakers of the
family changing your whole life to try
to accommodate somebody with it I've
seen it and so we're going to continue
to work on it but also it's estimated to
cost the government over a trillion
dollars a year after a 20 I think it's
2050 and I was telling uh someone I said
this is really going to affect my
grandkid said wait it's my kids I'll be
84 in 2050 and so it it it is it's it's
going to completely put an extra burden
on so I will commit to you we are going
to focus on Alzheimer's Alzheimer's
research and I'm looking forward to
continue to working together with you on
this well I appreciate that Mr chair but
in the meantime there's a real concern
that this time that's going to elapse
could set back that research and I
appreciate suffocating the hope but with
that I yield back I appreciate that and
I will yield to the gentem so the
gentlem Georg doesn't need I will yield
back back Is there further discussion
just a roll call seeing
none the vote is on the amendment of
roll call being requested the clerk will
call the row Mr L Mr L votes no Mr
Griffith Mr Griffith votes no Mr bakis
Mr bakus votes no Mr Hudson no Mr Hudson
votes no Mr Carter of Georgia no Mr
Carter of Georgia votes no Mr Palmer Mr
Palmer votes no Mr Dunn Mr Dunn votes no
Mr khaw
Mr Joyce Mr Joyce votes no Mr Weber Mr
Weber votes no Mr Allen Mr Allen votes
no Mr balderson Mr balderson votes no Mr
fure Mr fure votes no Mr fluger Mr
fluger votes no Mrs harburger Mrs harsh
Barker votes no Mrs Miller Meeks Mrs
Miller Meeks votes no Mrs kamik Mrs
kamik votes no Mr oberti Mr oberti votes
no Mr James Mr James votes no Mr B Mr B
V votes no Mrs hin Mrs hin votes no Mr
Fry Mr Fry votes no Miss Lee Miss Lee
votes no Mr Langworthy Mr Langworthy
votes no Mr Kane Mr Kane votes no Mr ruy
Mr ruy votes no Mr Goldman excuse me Mr
Evans Mr Evans votes no Mr Goldman Mr
Goldman votes no Mrs fedorek Mrs Fedor
votes no Mr palone Mr palone votes I
miss deette Miss
chikowski Miss trakowski votes I miss
Matsui Miss Matsui votes I miss Caster
Miss Caster votes I Mr tonko Mr tonko
votes I miss Clark Miss Clark votes I Mr
Ruiz Mr Ruiz votes I Mr Peters Mrs
Dingle Mr VC Mr VC votes I Miss Kelly
Miss Bon Miss Bon votes I Mr SoDo Mr
SoDo votes I miss Sher Miss sh votes i
mran mran v votes I miss Fletcher Miss
Fletcher votes I miss alasio Cortez M
oazo Cortez votes I Mr aen Claus Mr aen
Claus votes I Mr Carter of Louisiana Mr
Carter of Louisiana votes I Mr
Mendez Mr Mendez votes I Mr
Mullen Mr lansman Mr lansman votes I
miss mclen miss mclen votes I chairman
Guthrie chairman three votes no anyone
seeking to roll call seeing none the
clerk will
report chairman Guthrie on that vote
there were 19 eyes and 29
NOS the amendment is not agreed to is
there anybody else seeking recognition
for
amendments seeing none I first I want to
thank the clerk and the staff at the
table all the staff on both sides of the
aisle for their hard work and for this
committee for this committee to set the
standard there has been Fierce and
passionate debate because people have
different views on different things that
is exactly where we're here but it's
also been respectful the entire day and
is very much appreciated and uh now the
question now occurs on approving the
committee on energy commerce
authorization oversight plan for 119th
Congress all those in favor well rad
call has been requested by the gentleman
from New Jersey the clerk will call the
row Mr l i Mr L votes I Mr Griffith I Mr
Griffith votes I Mr bakus I Mr bacus
votes I Mr Hudson I Mr Hudson votes I Mr
Carter of Georgia Mr Carter of Georgia
votes I Mr Palmer Mr Palmer votes I Mr
Dunn Mr Dunn votes I Mr kensaw Mr Joyce
Mr Joyce votes I Mr Weber Mr Weber votes
I Mr Allen Mr Allen votes I Mr balderson
Mr balderson votes I Mr fure Mr fure
votes I Mr fluger Mr fluger votes I Mrs
harshbarger Mrs harbarger votes I Mrs
Miller Meeks Mrs Miller Meeks votes I
Mrs Kam Mrs kamik votes I Mr oberti Mr
obery votes I Mr James Mr James votes I
Mr B Mr Ben votes votes I Mrs hin Mrs
hin votes I Mr Fry Mr Fry votes I miss
Lee Miss Lee votes I Mr Langworthy Mr
Langworthy votes I Mr Kane Mr Kane votes
I Mr ruy Mr ruy votes I Mr Evans Mr
Evans votes I Mr Goldman Mr Goldman
votes I Mrs fedorek Mrs fedorek votes I
Mr palone Mr palone votes no miss
deette Mr chowski
Mr Kowski votes
I Mr Kowski is off I and on
no Miss
Matsui Miss Matsui votes no Miss Caster
Miss Caster votes no Mr tonko Mr tonko
votes no Miss Clark Miss Clark votes no
Mr Ruiz Mr Ruiz votes no Mr
Peters Miss Dingle Mr VC Mr VC votes no
Miss Kelly Miss Bagon Miss beragon votes
no Mr SoDo Mr SoDo votes no Miss shrier
Miss Trier votes no Miss Tran M Tran
votes no Miss Fletcher Miss Fletcher
votes no Miss Osio Cortez Miss oazo
Cortez votes
no Mr aen
Claus Mr aen Claus votes no Mr Carter of
Louisiana Mr Carter of Louisiana votes
no Mr Mendez Mr Menendez votes no Mr
Mullen Mr
lansman Mr lansman votes no miss mclen m
Miss mclen votes no chairman Guthrie
chairman Guthrie votes
I is anyone here to answer the roll call
that's
not seeing none the clerk were a
report chairman got through on that vote
there were 29 I's and 19 NOS 29 eyes 19
NOS the committee engine Commerce
authorization oversight plan for 119
Congress has been adopted and without
objection staff is authorized to make
technical conforming changes to the plan
considered by the committee today so
ordered without objection this committee
is adjourned
