Lecture 32 - Stability and Amplifier Design - I

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
Mar 1, 2024
Concepts Covered: Signal Flow Graphs, Stability of Amplifier, Input and Output Stability Circles
[Music]
[Music]
welcome to Arab transure design course
uh in module five we discuss about uh
all the basic component inductor capacit
capacitor resistors and how we can draw
on cheap all the components now we are
going to move towards the amplifier
design which is very important as far as
this course is concerned so we'll see
that how uh different ways we can design
amplifier and the mostly if you see the
transceiver the any receiver in input
the first component is low noise
amplifier that we already have seen and
why low noise amplifier is the first
block that also we have discussed while
we discuss the receiver architecture and
in the transmitter the uh amplifier
which is widely used is a power
amplifier so this two amplifier is
important and in order to have the base
of the Lan noise amplifier and power
amplifier this lecture will discuss
about the all the equation
or uh stability that is important for
both so uh amplifier
design uh if given the S parameter of
transistors uh how are we going to
design the
amplifier so here you might wonder that
how we can get the S parameter of
transistor so in order to get the S
parameter of transistor mostly Network
analyzer is used and you you need to
bias the your transistor in saturation
or in active region so that it can give
the amplification and you will find the
S parameters even it is not only one
transistor there is a possibility as we
have discussed while discussing the
Active Components there is a possibility
that it has a more than one transistor
or transistor Network so that will
consist a two Port Network we'll discuss
about that uh how you can consider the
two Port Network and get the S
parameter uh what are the important uh
parameters or consideration when you are
designing
amplifier the one of the most important
part is the
stability so the first uh parameter that
is important for understanding is a
stability then transducer gain or power
gain so there are various uh gain
equation that you should aware about uh
based on the S
parameters DC biasing is also important
because your uh transistor should be in
active or saturation region there is a
power added efficiency uh for power
amplifier when we discuss more in detail
about power amplifier we'll go for the
pae bandwidth of the amplifier because
uh we always uh strive for higher
bandwidth and we have already discussed
that if we want to achieve the high bit
bit rate or data rate we are going for a
higher bandwidth so bandwidth is also
important then impedance matching
because uh when you're connecting low
noise amplifier with the antenna your
input impedance should be match so that
maximum power will transfer similarly
when you are designing a power amplifier
your output impedance should be matched
uh to the uh antenna so that it will
transfer the maximum
power noise no doubt it is important for
uh low noise
amplifier uh output power for power
amplifier and linearity is important for
both lowo amplifier and power amplifier
we will try to go for each according to
the amplifier that we are targeting
uh if if we are going for power
amplifier we will go for uh we will
identify the power added efficiency
linearity matching and all other
important parameters when we discuss
about the lone no amplifier how we can
get the lower noise impedance matching
higher bandwidth so this when we discuss
the amplifier all this parameter will
come across so in this lecture we'll
discuss about the
stability
so before going for the stability it is
important to understand the signal flow
graph because there are many equation
that we are going to use we'll use a
signal flow graph to come up the final
equation so here if we any flow graph
techniques uh will provide us an
analysis technique applicable to as
parameters the means to visualize the
power flow in a circuit
uh each variable is designated as a node
so here A1 B1 a A1 B1 A2
B2 A2 B2 will be designated as a load as
a
node so uh if you if you see here this
is a two Port Network and there is a
incident wave A1 and reflected is a B1
we already discussed about this when we
discuss the S parameter and here your uh
incident on the port two is a A2 and
reflected is a B2 so all this uh in this
two Port Network this you can Define as
a node so each variable a b is design
designated as a node so there is a four
node in this two Port Network so this is
called incident node so A1 is a incid D
node B1 is a reflected node at the Port
one similarly at the output B2 is a
reflected node and A2 is a incident node
so there are two incident node A1 and A2
and two reflection node B1 and
B2 and always in the two Port Network
when we are considering two port or
three port or four port uh n number of
ports can be made so so when we are
making a uh two port for that always the
signal will travel from A to B so if you
see that a from signal from A1 is
traveling to B2 and that is given by so
B2 is equal to S21 S21 A1 so S21 is
given by B2 by A1 Sim similarly you you
will have a s uh 1
one so which is equal to B1 by
A1 so you'll get B1 which is S11 into A1
so your A1 is Multiplied with the S11 so
what is this called This is a magnitude
of the branch so this this is called a
branch this is a
branch and this is a node
so now here uh you can also get s22 so
your B2 which is equal to s22 A2 and
your
B1 is equal to so if you uh work around
your B1 will come as a S11 A1 Plus S1 to
A2 and your B2 will will be S21 A1 + s22
A2 so that that is reflected in the
signal flow graph so always remember
that signal is traveling from A to
B now we will see that if we have a
complex Network let's say if it is a two
port or one port or not more than that
we can easily do by just uh using the uh
step by step signal flow analysis but if
we have a complex uh uh signal flow
graph then how can we solve so in order
to solve that Meson has given one uh
formula and if we use a meon semantic
then it is easy to find out the transfer
function of a signal flow graph so as as
designated there are a path so there are
a different terminology for that in
order to understand there are different
paths a continuous succession of
branches transferred in their indicated
Direction no node being encountered more
than once so that is called a path now
there are two paths one is a forward
path uh then there is a reverse path is
also possible so path connecting input
and output is called a forward path and
path which is connecting output to input
is called reverse path there are input
node as I told there is a input node in
the
uh previous slide and there are output
node so an input node is called a node
having only outgoing branches so let's
say always a has a outgoing branches so
that is a input node then output node
the node which is all the incoming or
ingoing branches so that is called a
output node so in that case b is output
node because all the branches is coming
to the B
then path gain uh in the previous
example S21 or S12 that are the path
gain so product of the branch which we
multiply is a path key then Loop so when
it is a two paths so path which
originates and terminate at the same
node is called a loop no node being
encountered more than once and loop gain
product of the branch uh multiplier
around the loop is called a loop gain so
we will use all this uh when uh we try
to find out the transfer
function so what what M rule says first
if you want to find out the transfer
function you need to find the input and
output node what is your input node and
what is your output node and then you
can find out the gain uh T which is a
transfer function T from the input to
the output you can write it down as a
sigma k p p k Delta K so here PK is
nothing but a path uh path gain of a c
forward path so if there are two path it
is a P1 and P2 if there are three path
P1 P2 P3 so as how many path is uh
required to reach from one node to
another node there is a possibility
there is a One path two path or more
than that then Delta or Delta K so Delta
is given by
a sum of all so Delta which is equal to
1 minus sum of all individual Loop gains
so there are various loops on the on the
signal flow graph so 1 minus sum of all
individual Loop gains means individual
it is not connecting to each other then
plus some of the loop gains product of
all combination of two non-touching
Loops so if there are non-touching two
Loops then the sum of the loop gain
products so we need to multiply the loop
gain and then it is a added minus some
of the loop gain products are all all
possible combination of three
non-touching Loops so this is important
this is for two non-touching Loops if
there are three uh non-touching Loops
then we'll do minus three uh
multiplication of the sum for three
non-touching Loop and then Plus four
non-touching Loops it will go on
increasing it depends upon how many
Loops you have so based on that this
Delta can be written out so that is a uh
and the denominator and Delta K is the
value of delta using Loops not touching
to to the K path K path so it is uh
let's say if we have a One path from uh
uh input node to Output node and the
loop which is not touching to that path
you should consider in a Delta K so in
order to understand more in better we'll
try to solve one small problem so here
what is the application to find the
input reflection coefficient of a loaded
two Port Network so this is a two-port
network and it is loaded by jedel so
when it is a reflection coefficient
which is a JL at that time the signal uh
for the reflection coefficient output in
output or input the signal will travel
from B to a so that it will form the
loop there is a reflection from uh B uh
so here it is A1 this is a B1 it
is B2 and this is a A2 same thing here
A1 B1 B2 and
A2 so how many paths are there here so
if we want to find the input reflection
coefficient that is a gamma
in what is a gamma in that is nothing
but B1 by
even so if we what is the input node now
so your input node is a even1 and your
output node is a
B1 so this is your A1 so we have
identified this is the input node as per
the mess semantic uh Rule and this is a
output node
now signal is traveling from input to
the output so how many parts are
there how many parts there are two parts
so you always ask yourself this question
that how many paths are there so if if
you if we check once there is a One path
which is
this there is another path which
is
so there are two paths how many Loops
are there there is only one Loop that is
a s22 gamma l so now based on this we
can write down the uh equation of M
semantic so now we have identified gamma
in two parts so because there is a two
parts it is a P1 + Delta 1 plus P2 Delta
2 divid by
Delta what is the gain path one P1 gain
that is a S11 so that that is given by
S11 path to gain P2 which is equal to
S21 multiplied with the gamma L and S12
so this is a gain of path two what is
the determinant Delta there is only one
Loop so that is 1 - s22 gamma L because
of that Loop is a
uh we we we have only one Loop that
needs to be considered and determinant
for uh one so path one so if you
consider this path then there is only
one non-touching Loop that is a this so
that we should consider 1 - S2 to gamma
L and for determinant 2 Delta 2 there is
not any Loop which is not touching so it
is equal to 1 now when we keep all this
parameter Del Delta means P1 P2 Delta
Delta 1 and Delta 2 in this equation
we'll get a reflection coefficient gamma
in so gamma in is given by S11 so P1 is
a S11 into Delta 1 so Delta 1 and Delta
both are same so it is S11 plus S21 that
is a uh S21 gamma L S12 that is a uh
path gain P2 and then this is a
determinant
uh Delta 2 is Multiplied with 1 and
Delta is 1 - s22 gamma l so this is the
way you can use a m uh semantic rule in
order to find the reflection coefficient
gamma in uh you can do the same thing
for gamma out this is uh one homework
for you now we will move to the
stability so we are going to use this
equation in the
stability so so why stability is
important that always that question will
come in our mind we don't want our
amplifier to
oscillate so what it's called stability
of amplifier or its resistance to the
oscillation we don't want our amplifier
to oscillate and how we can reduce that
that will provide the
stability now
stability uh so when you have a two Port
Network like this and you have a uh s
parameter which is provided to you or
you have find out by using any simulator
that uh and you need to find out the
inut what is the input impedance
impedance matching Network in between
these two and there is a output matching
Network between these two so uh in order
to get the amplification so what
stability is analyzed by S parameters
what kind of matching networks that we
do and the types of termination let's
see here there's a JS at the source side
and JL at the load side so how how we
can reduce the oscillation so in
amplifier if we try to remove the
negative resistance so oscillation is
happening because of the negative
resistance and on the positive side when
we are when we discuss the oscillator we
try to add the negative resistance but
now we are discussing the amplifier we
will try to remove the negative
resistance so in order to remove the
negative resistance always to have
unconditional
stability if you want unconditionally
stable amplifier then your input
impedance heading should be greater than
zero it does not have any negative
resistance similarly the output
impedance so input impedance should be
greater than zero similarly output
impedence should also be greater than
zero for all values of JS or JL or means
whatever JS and JL that we choose but
your real part of input impedance if we
see from this side so J in from this
side or uh J out from this
side that should be greater than zero so
that is a condition for the stab
for all value of JS and JL we can also
mention because JS and JL also are a
passive Network and real so the real
part of ZN plus Zs should also be
greater than Zer or real part of Z out
plus ZL greater than Z so what
ultimately it means that your gamma
s should also be less than zero or or
gamma L is also less than zero and in
order to find the stability condition
for stability you have your gamma
in should be also less than one and
Gamma out so gamma in so if you see the
gamma in from this side it is a function
of the entire output so your gamma L as
well and when we see the gamma out it is
a function of gamma s the input side so
gamma out should be less than 1 so how
we will find the uh stability so in
order to find the stability we will try
to plot a stab stability curve how the
stability Curve will come into the
picture let's discuss about
that so there are two uh stability
Circle one is the input stability Circle
and output stability circuit we already
understood that in order to have a
stable uh amplifier your gamma in or
gamma
out should be less than one but we want
to make the boundary so we are we are
considering the boundary so what we we
will do gamma out we will make it is
equal to 1 and then we will provide the
boundary of the unstability and
stability the region the difference
between the stable region and the
unstable region that we will get when we
make a gamma out is equal to 1 so gamma
out when you so this is regarding the
input stability Circle so gamma out is a
function of gamma s because as if you
see this uh figure so your gamma out if
you see the gamma from this side uh from
this side then it is a function of the
input side
JS it it is a function of the G gamma s
so GMA out which is a function of gamma
s and we are putting the equal to one
that is a stability that will provide
the stability boundary we don't want
greater than one we want less than one
so this is a boundary which will tell us
the difference between less than and the
greater than one now we already have
find out the equation for gamma out and
Gamma in
by using a signal flow graph so gamma
out can be given by s22 plus S12 gamma s
S21 / 1 - gamma s it is a
S11 so this is a gamma out which is a
function of gamma s equal to
1 now if we try to uh rewrite this
equation in the form of circle you will
get a circle which is given
by gamma s - S11 conjugate minus Delta
conjugate s22 / by S11 squ minus Delta
Square similarly you will get a uh RS
which is a uh radius of the circle S12
S2 1/ S11 Square minus Delta Square here
Delta is given by this equation S11 s22
s - S12 to S to one so this gamma s uh
so in order to find the gamma s you have
a center of the circle this is the
center of the circle and this is the
radius of the circle so you can find out
the input stability circuit so uh let's
see that if there is a SM
chart and you have a this is a center of
the SM chart
then you you you have some gamma
s so you have some value of
RS that is a uh radius of
the this is a center of the circle so we
first we find out the center so the
distance is the center of the circle
Cs and then you B based on the value of
RS you are going to plot
the
so the then this will be the RS radius
of the
circle and what it says that this is
a this is called a input stability
Circle it is also denoted as a gamma out
GMA s is equal to 1 so sometimes it is
also written as a
gamma out is equal to 1 so don't confuse
yourself gamma out is equal to 1 is the
input stability Circle it is not output
stability Circle because gamma out is a
function of gamma s and it will provide
the value of the input uh reflection
coefficient which will provide as the
difference between the stable uh
stability and unstability so this
equation as written here
it defines
the it defines a circle separating a
potentially unstable and a stable region
so what is a unstable region potentially
unstable region that it will identify
based on the this circle so this uh
either this part is a stable or unstable
will be considered based on the value of
S2 and it can be find find out that
which portion is a stable region now we
will take out the same Theory to the
output stability
Circle so the difference between the
input stability and output stability
Circle that when we are discussing the
output stability that at that time uh we
will consider the input reflection
coefficient which is a function of gamma
L and when we are considering the input
stability Circle the gamma out the
output reflection coefficient which is a
function of gamma
s so for output stability circuit your
uh input reflection coefficient is is a
function of gamma L we will provide the
boundary equal to 1 when you write it
down you will get a uh S11 + S12 gamma L
S21 uh which is uh if you for form the
uh circle equation this is a circle
equation which will come up and your uh
Circle uh that is a output stability
Circle gamma L CL and RL is given by
this so this is this will provide you
the center of the circle and this will
provide you the radius of the circle and
you can plot the circle as we discussed
in the last slide so what it defines the
equation of circle separating the
potentially and stable and a stable
region in the gamma L plane so in the
previous it is the gamma as plane and
your gamma in uh equal to one defines
the output stability Circle so do not
confuse with comma in it is a output
stability Circle it is not a input
stability
Circle so we'll take some example one
example that how can you consider the uh
mean how can you differentiate the
stable and unstable
region so in order to get the stable or
unstable region first of all what what
you need is your uh for gamma s is equal
to zero so here in in the previous
equation where the gamma s is equal to Z
what it means S2 Plus if we consider
this in this case if you consider gamma
s is equal
to0 which which point will Define the
reflection coefficient zero that is the
center of the SMI chart so this is this
point so the GMA s is equal to Z that
that that means this is a center of the
SM so in this equation if you make the
gamma s is equal to Z that that means
then only
s22 will tell us that your which region
is a stable and reach region is a
unstable so as mentioned here a gamma s
is equal to Z we have a gamma out which
is equal to
s22 so the point gamma s is equal to Z
is a stable point if your s22 is less
than 1 so s22 is less than 1 your gamma
s is equal to 0 is a staple point and
that will Pro the
stability now if you drawn the gamma out
Circle which is equal to one which is
outside then this is a potentially
unstable region so if you find the value
of gamma in this uh blue color region
then it is a unstable but in this white
uh transparent region it is a stable on
other side if your S2 is greater than
one that means this this is a gamma s is
equal to 0 which is this point Center
Point is a potentially
unstable if s22 is greater than 1 so
then this transparent region this is a
potentially unstable and this is a
stable so this is very important to find
out the difference between what is a
stable region and what is a unstable
region so how you will find out the
stable or unstable region you first
identify the gamma s is equal to zero
plane gamma s is equal to 0 point and
then what is the s22 for
the for for the input stability Circle
and S11 for the output stability Circle
so
here uh one more thing we can take uh
one more
example
so if we draw the SM
chart and if you are drawn
the uh I am just showing the some
portion of the uh stability circle now
if this point in this
case uh we will take it both the uh
example if your s22 is less than one so
now in that case this
portion because s22 is less than one it
is inside this uh and your stability
circle is like this then this point is a
stable point so this region is a
stable on other way if your s22 is
greater than one then this portion is a
stable so always make sure that at when
where your gamma s is gamma s or gamma L
is equal to 0 point is lying and based
on that you can identify the stable
region what is a stable region and what
is the unstable
region now how we can make a stable and
unstable we'll try to uh find out one uh
small example we'll try to draw so
here there is a resistive loading can be
used to make a transistor
unconditionally stable so we all know
that if there is a uh this is a real
part of J in which is greater than zero
if this real part is negative in some
some sense then if we try to add some
more resistor then this negative
resistance we can convert into the
positive resistance by adding the
resistance at the input side or
resistance at the J
out greater than zero resistance at the
output side so this is the simplest way
to make a your two Port Network
unconditionally stable by adding
resistance at the input side or
resistance at the output
side so here in uh your real part of JS
plus Z in greater than zero or real part
of JL plus J out greater than is equal
to zero so what will happen when you try
to add a series or parallel resistance
then this uh this will go out mean this
potentially unstable region will go out
and then entire whatever you will choose
the gamma s or gamma L will be
stable so only one resistance is a
sufficient at the input side so this is
at the input side or you can make a uh
at the output
side and uh the this can also be one of
the way for finding out the stability in
the uh your uh to introduce a stability
in your amplifier but there are some
disadvantage of using a resistor uh
stability of the resistor so uh we will
take one small
example now in this example uh this
transistor as parameter was given and
then
the reflection coefficient based on the
gamma out and Gamma in the input
stability Circle and output stability
Circle has been drawn so this is output
stability Circle which is drawn like uh
with a purple color it is attaching to
the some of the point on the SMI chart
uh this is a j wi me
chart
and there is a uh input stability Circle
that is also touching on the SMI chart
now based on the JY Smith chart you can
find out the real part if it is a Jed
this red color will denote the real part
so this correspond to some value here
and if if you multiply with the8 + 50
that means the resistance you add 9 ohm
resistance in series and at the input
side because you are considering the
input stability Circle the same uh same
stability Circle which is ASM totically
also touching to other conductance
Circle and that is providing you the
admittance that is 7 by 50 that is a 14
M if you convert into the resistor it is
a 71.5 ohm in parallel so this is for
input side you can either connect the
series resistance or parallel resistance
according to your need and you can make
this circle out so that will be the
input style input side it is a stable
and for output stability Circle uh same
thing when you are considering the real
part you need to consider the red line
58 into 50 that is a 29 ohm you connect
into the series of the uh transistor and
it will give you the output stability or
ASM totically it is also touching the
this is also touching the Y SMI chart
means conductance of the Y SM chart and
that will provide the 500 ohm so this is
how you can find out the uh stability
you can introduce a stability this is a
unconditional stability into the your uh
transistor network but you need to use
the resistor so we'll discuss more about
this in the next class thank
you
[Music]
ah
