Conflict of Interest?

HowNOT2
100 followers
Jan 22, 2024
What is ethical for me to sell? Does something need a "brand name" to be ethical? Or a rating? Or is it a process? Is it ethical to sell something someone told me was super good enough without testing it myself?
👉 Learn and SHOP at https://www.hownot2.com/shop
👉 Best EMAILS on Earth: https://www.hownot2.com/signup
👉 SUPPORT US and get gear discounts https://hownot2.com/support
👉 10% off ROCKY TALKIE by clicking https://www.hownot2.com/rocky
an email I got said I wanted to share my
perspective on testing the cheap stuff
and selling it I think there is a lot
more responsibility once you start to
actually sell what you are testing
versus saying it's out there I tested
some your mileage may vary this is a
response to an email that I put out one
two or three weeks ago and for reference
on my Saturday emails we spend more time
writing up the body and adding all the
content in those emails than I used to
spend making my long form videos back
when I was painting houses and doing
this on the side so a lot of thought was
put into a specific email about selling
offbrand gear and this is part of the
email that was sent to me and I want to
address it on the video because I think
it's a very interesting topic now we
have about 30 to 40 brands on the shelf
right now that are all name brand and as
I get deeper into this world of retail
and I have more of a relationship with
every manufacturer I see it's not super
special there are some brands that do a
really good job they're very careful
they're very proud of what they do and
they'll make it in their own country and
they'll baby everything and some of them
make money and some of them
don't but there's as you know if you've
watched this channel long enough I'm
pretty good at finding the flaws of
anything and I know more flaws that I
even share now that I get to see the
retail side of things so that's brand
name stuff nothing's perfect it's
overbuilt for a reason and then there's
this offbrand stuff that I see on the
internet this is a camp
lift this is not and we've been testing
it and it's interesting because the
information on it is horrifically wrong
the product didn't show up the way it
looked on the internet we don't know if
it's CE rated it's printed on there and
that's the issue we don't know anything
about that the thing is people are
buying this stuff and it's not just
Amazon there's plenty of places that
sell uh offbrand stuff that you can buy
in bulk let's call it what it is Alibaba
you can buy a bunch of stuff from
Alibaba and I guess put it on Amazon and
and you could be like great for dog
walking and rope rescue and firefighting
and aerial sils I don't know why they're
always throwing aerial s silks in there
they're just stuffing the title for SEO
I think that's my biggest issue with
offbrand products is the the
presentation of it I think there's a lot
more responsibility once you start to
actually sell what you're testing versus
saying it's out there tested your
mileage may vary a joke that I keep
throwing around which I don't know is
appropriate or not you can let me know
in the comments below if people are
insistent on using needles I want to
make sure I provide sterile ones if
people want to buy cheap off-brand crap
is it a value ad I guess is the question
it's the thing that I have to decide as
I'm deciding who to buy from is it a
value ad to research 30 brands that are
selling something off brand pick the
best one not the cheapest but like
somewhere in the middle you know it's
not usually the highest or the cheapest
and break it batch test it and be very
honest where it came from what it is and
how we understand the product to be this
was made in China and that is okay
a lot of products we have are made in
China Taiwan Vietnam Czech Germany
Greece Italy everywhere the the world's
not a very big place so that's how a lot
of stuff is made and even stuff that
says Made in
America uh was assembled in America you
don't have to do very much to the
product from components you got from
China to call it made in
America Jesus so I suppose that I'm not
infatuated with the labels I test some
stuff with a label that I am woefully
unimpressed by and then I test stuff
that is offbrand and I'm like oh my God
that almost broke my machine let's talk
about ethics first is it ethical for me
to sell a a this that's a straight
knockoff is that ethical for me to
sell this is not what I'm trying to sell
I want to be clear that's not the
problem I'm trying to solve I don't want
you to have something for $15 that
normally cost 60 and then there's a
whole bunch of risk of it not working
that is not what I'm trying to do and
that's what I want to make sure I
clarify the bulk of what I'm trying to
get on the Shelf that's cheaper would be
bolting Hardware because I think a quick
link that is5 or
$6 is a lot of money or chain that's
like $20 a foot if you want like quality
316 L or welded rings for 5 10 $15 a
piece so you could have wrap rings on
your bolting stations what if I told you
I could get all of that base cost plus
shipping
tariffs I could get it base cost for a
dollar each oh I don't know if I trust
that what if I told you a lot of the
places we're getting it from might be
only paying
that and it's one thing if somebody
invented something camp Camp designed
this they made it and somebody knocked
them off so going back to the first part
of the email is there there's a testing
side of Ryan and then there's a selling
side of Ryan and is that an issue I
definitely don't think it is or I
wouldn't be doing it the reason I
actually like it is is because I don't
care what you buy I have the nice
quality let's call them quicklinks
quicklinks are a generic product that
you can get anywhere it's not a custom
design thing I'm going to have the
quality UIA expensive quick links I'm
actually bringing in some from lapas
that are all tested piece for piece
because I want to have the best price of
the highest quality I can get right it's
lazy for me to just put $18 quick links
on the website and then that says like
you want quality or not you're shame on
you for not buying quality no I can get
quality for
like5 $6 for quick link but if you don't
need something name brand tested piece
for piece because you're putting a 10
mil quick link on a Repel
station and I break it and it breaks all
the time at 70
kons does it matter okay I wasn't trying
to get into this right away okay let's
no no we're going to go into it so this
brings us to the next part of the email
you definitely found some weakness in
the formal rating system with your
testing process but have you identified
weaknesses in your testing process how
are you going to identify and correct
mistakes before they impact someone's
life everyone will make mistakes it's
best to plan for them ahead of time if
you identify a mistake after products
have gone out how will you recall those
products I am less
infatuated with the number printed on my
gear because I know it was tested in a
lab and sometimes when you do things in
real life with it that you're not going
to necessarily get that number and that
drives me nuts stay tuned you think the
bolting drama was good wait till you
wait till we get to that but that's not
what this video is about but what about
weaknesses in my tests what's great
about the videos I do in my opinion is I
show you the entire process I show you
every test I do not omit any tests I
think it's valuable for people to see
and make their own decisions on whether
or not that testing was super good
enough now I try at least in the last
two years I have tried to communicate
clearly this was only a sample size of
three or six or 10 or whatever and we
didn't drop test it and I didn't change
the rate of pull and this is the
diameter of pin it's like we didn't this
isn't conclusive but just pulling on it
with my one trick pony the break test
machine that it did this thing and it's
interesting when you compare one thing
to another thing when you just do this
thing to it okay maybe I will kick the
standards as I go by everyone's like oh
we don't know if your testing's good
enough you don't even know what the
testing is of the C rating because it's
all behind a pay wall at least you get
to see what I'm doing and then when I go
to test things independently and I don't
even look at this e the standard dorms
and all that crap to make sure I test it
the same I don't care about testing it
the same I just want to pull and see
what happens because that's fun and it's
more entertaining that way and so when
it doesn't do what the number
says I want to know why I don't want to
try to pull it the way they pull it I
want to pull it in any any way I want
wouldn't it be neat if the standards o
I'm getting on the TR I'll get off in a
minute wouldn't it be neat if the
standards tested three or four different
ways and whatever performed the worst
would be the
minimum breaking strength I got guys I
got this really great method to test
something we're going to pull it hella
slow no no no catch on wait away no way
it could ever be pulled on in real life
and we're not going to tell anybody
about how we do it and the worst number
we get in the best case scenario we're
going to call that minimum breaking well
don't we're going to use Sigma 3 math
it's math the magic 99.7% chance it
never breaks below that as long as you
pulled away we pull it which we're not
going to tell you how F [ __ ] this is a
whole different video I'm not trying to
be in this video right now now if I test
a quicklink for 40 50 or 60 or 70 or 80
there's one there's for 90 killing
Newtons and all you're doing is
repelling on
it am I concerned no you could repel
with it with it not closed and you're
still not even going to probably deform
it enough don't do that I'm hypothetical
only is it a conflict to sell it a
conflict to sell the gear you're testing
every brand does
that literally all of them have to test
their [ __ ] before they sell
it how is that a conflict of interest
making sure the stuff that you test is
good now when I went to B lab it was
kind of refreshing to find out that the
engineers test the [ __ ] out of what
they're making and not just standards
they know what it's going to pass when
they send it to get certified but they
also want to make sure like the product
is going to be good overall that's nice
to hear I also know of other
manufacturers that don't test
anything EX at all the factory tells
them a number and they're like
manufacturers that use other factories
to make their stuff that it's not
inhouse like a like petzel for example
there's a lot of back and forth there's
a lot of lot of communication they have
a relationship with the factory they're
not just you know ordering pre-made
stuff and putting their name on it most
of the time but I think there's an
infatuation with the brand that they're
standing at the factory assembly line
and they're just like NOP more strong
aluminum here H little more sewing here
oh they're checking this no and they're
not they've never visited these
factories so what can a brand do a brand
can get specs from the factory they can
batch test themselves this is where
standards are good everyone has to go
through the same funnel to get approved
and before it goes out to Market uh a
lot of the stuff made in Taiwan China
and these off-brands can also get the
same approvals and and some of them have
legitimate CTS other ones do not and you
as the end
user might not either take the time to
look or be able to identify that their
CT expired 3 years ago or that they
photoshopped themselves onto aert so
what if I was able to get stainless
steel Hardware that I verified was super
good enough
stainless that was way overbuilt and I
put it on my shelf to make it available
for bolters because this is the problem
I was trying to solve I want to get
bolting Hardware that's affordable in
stainless for people who are bolting
with their own budgets or donated
dollars they're putting in that
everyone's using right it's a group
effort to get routes put in so it's
frustrating to not see more affordable
Hardware on the market and so I know
enough bolters and I know what goes on
that they'll buy quick links from the
hardware store with the logic of well
it's way stronger than on my rope yep
but there are different qualities of
Steel and people will use zinc plated
stuff and it's nice to offer stainless
at almost what plated steel cost for
people who want the cheapest thing and
are going to buy the cheapest thing and
I want to have better stuff out there
and so I'm willing to tie
up more money than I should into buying
a pallet of bolts a pallet of quick
links and rings and chain and all thread
and different epoxies I think that would
really help the community out now is
selling offbrand stuff bad for the store
no if I communicate that it is offbrand
that this is how I tested it I tested
three from every box from every batch of
everything
and that's it that's all the testing
anyone's doing if you're lucky I think
there's an infatuation with some brands
that they're testing every third
Carabiner and then there's people who
would just buy the cheapest cheapest
cheapest cheapest stuff and put it in
rocks that you trust your life to drives
me nuts now after much discussion with
several bolters I I've decided whatever
goes in The Rock has to be name brand
high quality because that's a pain to
replace uh wedge bolts it's going to be
name brand Glu and bolts name brand glue
is going to be not random epoxy from
China I never see hangers break at a
level that's dangerous for putting your
life on it if it's four mil
stainless or not stainless it's probably
strong enough and if it isn't if the
stainless is bad if the quicklink isn't
the right kind of stainless if it's not
L when they said it was 316 L it was
only
316 and somehow that mattered for
something that doesn't have a weld on it
then all of that Hardware is super
easily replaceable if it started to
corrode that stuff is so overbuilt you
can corrode like the rusty
stuff I don't even know if I could break
these they're so strong they're Rusty
they weren't engaging in the rock
well but the metal itself when it's a/
inch crap bolt even is strong even a
carabiner if it's offbrand even if they
don't use 7075 aluminum and they use
6061 because it's cheaper those are the
12 K rated carabiners by the way for dog
walking
firefighting rescue aerial silks
climbing Outdoors
Adventure um oh the fine print in the
description it says not for climbing but
all the pictures would lead you
otherwise to believe it is those break
at 18 kons don't use them for Life
supporting gear I'm just
saying carabiners have been so
welldeveloped at this point if they use
metal in that
shape probably going to hold you now
when you have moving parts like this
thing and it's not made right and you
got tolerances that aren't great on that
guy that is where you can have a problem
but back to the ethics of carrying
off-brand stuff I see how much work it
is to bring a product to Market I have
no desire to really do that I'm just
trying to solve problems that I see
which is Hardware is more expensive than
it needs to be because it's not that
special buting Hardware specifically
something that took create ity and time
and Engineering to design and
create I do not want to undermine the
work they're doing I do not import
Chinese titanium bolts even though
Sophia has hit me up I think 30 times to
do so because I don't want to undermine
what Martin is doing and now what lapas
is doing they're not they didn't invent
the quick link no that's the thing if
you identify a mistake after products
have gone out how would you recall those
products well I have a customer list of
everyone I sent it to and so I'd be able
to tell them those
90 Kon chain links are we discovered 70
kons no but for real I could communicate
more easily with who I sell products to
than a
manufacturer or brand because I know who
I sent them out to I don't send them out
to a middleman how would you feel if
someone got hurt or died because gear
that you tested or sold failed I've been
in that situation for seven years
putting information on the internet no
one was willing to put out at the time
that's why it's called how not to
Highline cuz that was the most creative
disclaimer I could have for don't take
this too serious and it's stuck it's
something I would rather teach people
safe sex and absence some people might
die because they watched a video came to
the wrong conclusion and did something
wrong but I actually find more people
even with the joke super good enough
more people look at their gear a little
bit more carefully more H holistically
and think of it better than what I saw
before I started making these videos now
when people say oh you're saving lives I
don't know if I'm doing that because I
might be introducing this sport to
people that have would never have gotten
into it if they weren't randomly
scrolling YouTube and I made this look
more fun than it was so I'm bringing
more numbers in but maybe lowering the
percentage if I'm lucky assuming a lot
people di some people have died
highlining the last year and it sucks we
lose people it sucks but you're playing
with gravity it is it is to be expected
we drive we get in car accies and we
just all get back on the road you get on
the road to go to the funeral it's like
you accept risk to go do things we
accept these risks to go climbing and I
accept these risks to put this
information on the internet but I think
having this information on the Internet
is way way way way way way safer than
putting a UIA or CE rating on a PC gear
and
go good luck you might not know why it
failed and whether your testing was
inadequate or there was too much
variance in the product quality or if it
was used outside the intended parameters
well then I would feel even less bad if
it was outside of the what was intended
use what if you found out it was because
of a mistake you made
somehow cynica Rock accident I forget
what brand rope which is probably good
for this example does that rope
manufacturer feel bad petel just put a
bunch of gons backwards they had a
recall the piranha and these are my name
brand people died with black Diamond's
Avalanche Beacon and they didn't recall
it after they knew it was defective Ed
rid's knife that stabbed somebody
because it opened while they were
climbing they didn't recall it I pulled
it off my shelf but they still sell it
the crack in the mega Jewel the edid
mega Jewel that uh just one batch but
that one was bad the soldering wasn't
good on some of the CCH original alien
and they
failed there is this this is the nature
of making gear big companies have issues
I am going to try to avoid them as much
as possible by being very transparent
testing the [ __ ] out of things and only
selling overbuilt things that' be really
really hard to screw your screw up I
also notice you have been facing
questions regarding Direction as a
tester reviewer and retailer and what
your role should be I like your videos
and trust you but when I saw the
sponsored video testing a product that
you then sold the be unicor ropes I felt
like it was a huge conflict of interest
you could be the most honest person in
the world and still experience implicit
biased I don't have any conflict with it
I have frustration that more
retailers aren't testing and reviewing
stuff just good here you go if I was
sponsored by petzel and I tested gear
that would be a conflict of interest
like if I if this said petzel petel
petel petel and I only tested petzel
gear that's a conflict of
interest when I test everything and if
you watch the videos you know I'm a
little harsh I'm so harsh it's actually
hard to get sponsorships so much so that
I I don't really have any in the queue
for testing like a specific product uh
the the Boling video coming out shortly
not
sponsored I really like the fact that I
test everything and sell everything and
you know how much be rope that I sold
after making that video if you watch the
unicorn video you see that I'm
not shouting Praises about it that's a
really nice way say I was afraid they
were going to be upset I'm grateful that
be was happy with the video and that I
put so much effort into it and that I
thoroughly explored it and what its uses
are good for and what it's not good for
the thing I'm frustrated with is they
don't have a good static rope something
that I would take for a big wall to haul
with or a semi-static rope like I would
love to have unicorn some of the ropes
that I want to haul with I think there's
value in those Niche cases I just don't
think I need I don't think I need unicor
in like all these ropes that I climb
with if I have no teeth on the on the
device now if it gets frayed a little
and I'm repelling you can repel past it
but I would butterfly not on that core
shot I wish people who
tested communicated more and people who
communicated their testing sold the
products they were testing I think this
is the best device over this this made
my life hell when I started to break
test stuff this has opened up a lot of
doors for me you can see how they both
work I've used them both they've both
been featured on the channel I have used
cap Sands I've used harken winches I've
used Ronin and I love these Z2 drill
powered pulley that I'm going to be
making videos about I did my homework
before doing it but you don't have to
buy it from me you can see all the
testing I did how many people do product
reviews we just watched a thing for like
a foldable treadmill like the handle
goes up like this and it weighs 92 lbs
and it's got these nice wheels in the
back and it goes at 7.5 M hour they're
reading the specs and unboxing it it's
only helpful as if you wanted to touch
it in a showroom before you bought
something but it's not helpful at all to
know if like it actually works I don't
stop exploring a product until I can get
the manufacturer to go wow or please
don't post that I like your videos and I
trust you but when I saw sponsor video
testing products you sold it felt like
it was a huge conflict of interest don't
trust me I show you all the information
and I try to make it as concise as
possible we have 140 break
tests for Wednesday's video and I don't
make you watch all of them but they are
in a spreadsheet for you and we go
through all the conclusions that we kind
of found and then all the information
we're not just feeding you conclusions
is like all the info is there you can
pause it or go to the blog and read it
and look and make your own conclusions
and then you can read the comment
section which I joke is the peer
reviewed section because you don't have
to just listen to what I have to say you
can see if like a whole bunch of smart
people can call me out for my [ __ ]
if there is any there never is ah don't
say [ __ ] like that makes me want to add
to the video maybe you should have an
Advisory Board of climbers and bolters
in the community they wouldn't vote on
things or control what you do but they
could help you work through different
topics like this my average video
unfortunately Takes Me 3 to N9 months
the video you see Wednesday started over
nine months
ago there was a lot of people I talked
to before I put it on the internet I
know it might not look like it but
you're getting a much more water down
version of Ryan which is probably good
for the brand I've
had many conversations about this
bolting stuff with bolters I respect and
that is why we came to the conclusion
that anything that goes in the Rock name
brand and I'm going to sell it at Cost I
would rather take out the
middleman to make it cheaper than to try
to put in something cheap because it's
so hard to replace stuff please stop
using plated Steel and the other
Hardware I'm going to get overbuilt
hardware test the [ __ ] out of it and
it's on the outside and can be easily
replaced if there was something I don't
know which I don't know which I don't
know what I don't know so here's my goal
for the shop I do want to sell
everything for climbing caving and
canyoning and quantities that make sense
you have what you need when you need
it but also not just that I want to make
sure people understand what they're
buying you can buy rated gear and use it
wrong and die or get hurt or whatever or
just just be at risk that you don't need
to be information is more important than
your rating of your gear do you think
information is more important than your
rating do you think information is more
important than the rating how to use
this device this rated
device I think is more important
than it being the right aluminum because
you could have the right aluminum in the
wrong
information and you get really hurt
soloing I don't even know if this is
intended for cine but what if the
aluminum was substandard but you knew
how to use it and how to mitigate it and
how to back it up I feel like that would
be almost more valuable it'd be nice if
you had both so the lack of information
from the middleman you buy your gear
from drives me nuts enough to try to
make a store what drives me n is it's
stuff other people trust their life to
that they're installing yeah and now
that I'm thinking about it like I've
never once seen a rating on a quick link
that I've clipped in the
wild you know what I mean like there's
no way that they're actually buying
rated quick links like all the
developers aren't doing that it's too
expensive and they know it's fine and
like when you're climbing nobody ever
thinks about it you just clip the
[ __ ] thing you know what I mean and
even if it's like Rusty like it's 10 mil
you know what I mean like it's this huge
thing I forget what this broke at but
this was a rusty quick link that was in
a cave and I it almost broke what I
connected to it in the machine so my
contribution to the bolting Community
has been the bolting Bible up to this
point but I noticed it's actually pretty
hard to get a lot of the bolting
Hardware that you want especially from
one place and you have to Source from
like seven probably seven eight
different stores before you can actually
have what you need to go let's say
remove a bolt and put what you want in
there rarely can you even buy healthy
3500 from a place that sells the glue in
that you want that sells the cordr bit
that you want that sells the wrench that
you want that sells it's it's a pain in
the ass I would love and I'm working 7
days a week on it at this point I would
love to have everything a Bolter needs
everything I'm going to be practice cord
drilling
today everything and then I would sell
it with the kit with the tube with the
thing that valved so you don't use too
much water and how to do it and Spares
and you could over buy the components
and then ship back which you don't use
as long as it's still in good shape you
can't hurt a drill bit you didn't use
you can't hurt a core drill core bit
that you didn't use like man when you go
out in the wild and you need bits and
one breakes or you're deep in a cave in
a bit brakes that sucks if you're
willing and it's easy enough to carry
extra components it'd be nice to be able
to have like 30 titanium glue in bolts
for your project and then and then you
only use us 12 which is better but
you're not stuck with all 30 of them
that you don't need like what are you
going to do drop it micr fractures are a
myth in titanium if you have bolt
removal tools I could maybe loan them
out and and make it so you don't have to
like buy this $400 device you use twice
and leave in a closet I would love to
sell all the hardware you need for
bolts at
cost and I'm going to be importing like
like like importing stuff from rammer
laas uh Titan climbing all these great
bolting Solutions there's no margin on
it by the time it's on my shelf and
there's free shipping and a credit card
fee and all this
[ __ ] like if you're supporting this
Channel The Way We price it is you're
getting it at my cost and uh I want it
to be like that for people who are going
to be buying at bulk and developing
routes for everyone to share because I
want the the best hardware out there and
I want to make sure if you're going to
buy quick links from me that I was able
to batch test it that they're stainless
that it matches the metal that you have
on
there and I don't need to make money on
bolting Hardware but I do need this to
be sustainable and so in order to do
that being sponsored by BL I don't know
if I signed a non-disclosure but it was
uh more than a th000 and less than
3,000 it wasn't enough to even pay me
five bucks an hour for the time I spent
making that episode it was the
validation and appreciation that they
gave me that meant more to me than the
few bucks I
got being sponsored this type of Channel
doesn't pay the bills a normal
sponsorship of a channel my size is
$20,000 no one is going to pay that and
that's for a 30 second if you if you
have ever thought about you know naughty
stuff and you need to go to better help
or if you want if you didn't want
anybody body to know you thought of
naughty stuff and looked up naughty
stuff there's nordvpn and then there's
skill share if you want to learn how to
look up naughty stuff this break test
brought to my rage Shadow Legends those
literally are $20,000 for the big
YouTubers and YouTubers my size that get
the views I get like my ad Revenue right
now I'm real honest about my numbers
anywhere between 2500 and 3200 the last
six months and that's I don't even know
how we got that because most of our
videos don't get the views like they
used to one I do here is ran on a
shoestring
budget and costs still cost a lot of
money so I hope it's not a turnoff for
some people if I sell products if I try
to have sponsorships if I try to sell
you a hat for $20 I make $2 on by the
time like every all the middleman that
make the Hat it's like I try to have 10
different sources of income to pay for
what I'm doing if I can make this
sustainable I can do more of it
