why are Asian Asian movies considered so
much better than Asian-American movies
the internet is wondering that is
because you guys are Boxed In by the
society but maybe also your own mind we
got to talk about this meme from Reddit
Andrew it says let's be honest this is
pretty accurate East Asian literature A
government official helps a female
prisoner escape with the hopes of
infiltrating a rebel group but ends up
falling in love a gay couple slowly
break up during a spur of the moment
trip to iguan Falls a business executive
is ruined when black mailers kidnap and
chauffeur some by mistake A working
class family scams their way into the
lives of a wealthy couple that's got to
be parasite there's this really big
lizard Gogeta a samurai asked to commit
suicide in the courtyard of a local Lord
who suspects his motives and then it
goes Asian-American literature there's
this mom and she's bad we call it bad
mom all right so guys we're going to get
into what this meme actually means if
you guys are into Asian-American movies
and Asian movies then definitely hit
that like button and share this video
but you know what it's not a tired
Asian-American
cliche smalla finishing oil yes I know
that there's a lot of chili crisps out
there guys but this is a finishing oil
you can pour it out the bottle it's very
fun to use and very very tasty from
sichan Sicily guys I'm telling you it is
not something you've seen before unlike
potentially the themes that this meme is
talking about Andrew how true is this is
it true that every Asian-American movie
has to do with filial piety and the
struggle between a more Americanized
Second Generation and how they're being
raised versus all other Americans Andrew
Joy Luck Club crazy Rich Asians farewell
turning red tiger taale everything
everywhere all at once even shangqi has
a struggle between the Sun and the
father as a backdrop you know I'm not
saying that was a first story line maybe
it was a secondary storyline why is this
so true uh I guess there's a lot of
reasons for it and guys a lot of people
commented on why it seems like Asian
American stories are so what simple
they're so like onedimensional and it
always has to do with parent to child
because my initial take is that you know
so you agree with the meme I agree that
it's mostly true obviously we're
overlooking the Asian action movies
right which do very well but then a lot
of people complain oh it's all Kung Fu
flicks right it is true when there's
Asian action movies they're not boxing
in it they are typically doing some
roundhouse kicks they're doing like Kung
Fu or Asian martials martial arts for
sure um I guess to
me people are thinking okay how do you
have Asian characters and have it relate
to a mass audience of non-asians you're
talking about in a Hollywood funded
movie well how you get non-asians to
relate is that you have to tap into
something emotional that is believable
for that group so as in for a lot of
black movies it's a lot of the emotions
of uh being targeted or you know like in
some of the recent movies like uh
us us get out you know you mean white
people doing something uh devious to
black people yeah and then there's a
devious plan against black people or
there was like a lot of hood movies back
in the 90s and 2000s but the hood movies
went away yes so Asians are at that
point where they need the parent movies
it has to do with a parent it's not a
bunch of millennial asian-americans
going on a group it's not Asian Euphoria
yeah I mean I would say Joy Ride was the
closest thing because it's a comedy it
was an over-the-top comedy beef as well
possibly right beef was kind of there
too so you're starting to see some
projects that are more multi-dimensional
right you're saying stepping out of the
filopod Confucian Lane but the biggest
movies end up being the ones that can
hit you viscerally in the hearts of
everybody and that has to do with parent
to child complex and but does it have to
do only with the non-asians or is even
what you can sell to The 40-Year-Old
Asian-American community that is
possibly still
I'm not saying everybody is but there's
a portion that's very vocal about being
hung up about bringing stinky lunches to
school etc etc which is also a tired
theme that I saw people bring up in the
comment section which we're going to get
to people are saying that happened in
ABC too which is a new Disney Plus show
oh yeah ABC yeah no I'm saying that it's
a I'm saying these filial py movies that
to me and you and possibly some other
more sophisticated media consumers seem
so boring and tired cliches they're
still appealing to that 40-year-old
crowd that wants to trauma dump from
having the sticky yeah and to be fair
that 40 to 60y Old Asian-American crowd
uh they're influential they but they're
influential they vote they have
disposable income but they also they
didn't get to experience K-pop they
missed the whole Asian wave thing so to
them now they're getting an Asian wave
of content and some of them watch our
channel to be honest some 40
50-year-olds do watch our yeah I'm not
dissing you guys if those are the if you
want to watch 20 more of the Philly I
guess what I'm saying is I'm just
explaining that they had so little Asian
content that this is the Asian content
that they that still sticks with them
still touches their heart maybe joy
riding beef does not appeal as much
because those are dealing with such like
Millennial three more Americanized
almost like third generation like Ali
Wong is like third gen or whatever like
that I guess is there some example of
movies that are outside of this Andre
can you I know that you are talking
about this movie called unspoken that is
an American movie that cast a Chinese
Star are almost in like a taken type of
it's like a it's like a half Chinese
half American movie that's coming out in
2024 I just saw the trailer of it guys
unspoken 2024 look it up it's got a big
Chinese action star in it it's basically
about a father whose daughter comes to
America to stud intern to be an
international student she gets killed he
comes over to America and like wreaks
Havoc while trying to solve the crime
like taken almost like a Liam niss type
character right kind of it's like uh
kind of like Jackie Chan's The Foreigner
actually right he's on a war path that's
but it's kind of rooted unfortunately in
a lot of real stories yeah I think
that's a really cool movie that's going
to come out yeah I guess I could compare
this filial piy parental Asian movie
phase Andrew back to your point John
Singleton the 1990s boys in the hood uh
Menace to Society Above the Rim there
was all these movies about the inner
city that Hollywood was funding but it
almost felt like at that time even if
you were a black actor that wasn't from
the inner city like Cuba Gooding Jr you
got put into that lane cuz those were
the only movies they were making dude
how many black actors were asked to like
play basketball when they like didn't
play basketball you know like nowadays
they would just find a kid who can play
basketball right right right I guess
what I'm saying is it's like it goes to
show you that there's like these es and
flows and these candles that got to burn
and like you said the Hood movie candle
at least in Hollywood now there's power
and stuff like that but like it kind of
burned out on its own and then it moved
on to other candles that had to burn
anyway um yeah let's just get into the
comments section over here somebody said
ASAS in Asia are pulling from a way
wider and deeper pool of Concepts since
they just happen to be the majority
dominant race over there so basically
they don't get type cast because they
have every cast they have every lane
available to their at their disposal
yeah you have to understand like the
amount of
asian-americans in America is just like
a drop in the bucket compared to all the
Asians in Asia we are like such a small
group so even for us to be this
influential as we are it's somewhat
impressive I think I think you can take
some Solace David that we are just a
drop in the bucket as far as a number of
population but because we're in America
and we've achieved that asian-americans
have achieved something in America we
become
disproportionately influential across
the world how much do you think people
need to slow their expectations or is it
okay as we get more representation even
though it's like still stuck on that
candle that we be become unhappy with
that candle you know like it's tough
this cuz at one point you had nothing
now you have something but then you're
like dang it's all the same theme or
like 90% of them fit into the same theme
how grateful should you be is kind of
what you're asking I don't know how do
you feel how grateful has your
gratefulness for the content changed
over the past 15 10 years right somebody
said you know yeah you guys are right
there is not a 50 Shades of Gray but
Asian but there is stuff like beef and
Joy Ride which is a little bit more uh
getting laughs other than playing
yourself out like Ken Jong and Bobby Lee
did but maybe they were just subject to
what were the Dynamics of the eror as
well other this long people were writing
really long comments from this thread
right somebody said it's just our
situation of being a small minority so
the only thing that makes us different
is how we compare our childhood being so
different from everybody else around us
that's just where the game is at right
now so so he was kind of putting the
blame on the Asian-American writers like
why are we just writing sto stories
about how our childhood was so different
than our white neighbor right do you
think that that's true that like like
you said like the 40-year-olds that are
getting their movies made and picked up
by the studios those are the stories
that they're telling yeah for uh I would
say so yeah I guess they were probably
not from the time Ander where
International students were even coming
over and then especially all the
terrible things that have been happening
unfortunately um somebody said for there
to be movies there has to be original Ip
and there has and there is good
Asian-American IP and literature to be
made into movies but nobody really reads
it at least not as much as they should
and this guy was kind of blaming the
Asian-American Community for not
supporting the unique Asian-American IP
that does exist because asian-americans
don't consume Asian-American content
like on the literature side right right
right um somebody said was pointing out
yetep look at all the highly rated books
that could be option in the movies right
here but how many of you guys support
those and somebody said I can't stand
Asian-American media at this point it's
just rehashing the same old same old
somebody said yeah man it's all about
white kids said my lunch stinks I hate
that um are you sick of it yes or no for
yourself Andrew uh we're having this
debate about should you just be grateful
from how far the game has come or can
you be mad where the game is at I think
you can be grateful while only
supporting the things that you like like
I am so you're saying we're not at the
point anymore where we have to support
everything that comes out I am grateful
to see the progress because I think that
if you include m material from Asia
there is a lot of Asian content you
cannot if you put it in the same pool
yeah
but I don't think you should separate it
as much I mean dude Asian America is
like such a small part so I think like
we're doing pretty good not that I'm not
saying we should stop fighting but it's
just like you know the content wise like
we're get we just have to do better
ourselves like I don't think we're it's
as much as we're being held back anymore
I think there was that a time when we
were being super held back but I think
nowadays if the story is good and you
can get into the right hands it's got a
chance no you're right I mean did you
know a scientific sample size is one out
of 14 which means you essentially have
to be 7% asian-americans just this year
on the sensus became 7% so it's almost
like we just became a
scientifically like notable population
based off yeah but I think we've been
over represented in the power and income
so I think that's why I think we almost
feel like we're we're like a uh 10%
right um Andrew anyway here are some
Concepts we'd like to see Hollywood make
some Asian-American movies of here let
me throw this one out Andrew genz Tik
Tock Asians this is probably a really
Asians are overrepresented on Tik Tok
right Tik Tok is obviously a Chinese
platform but you know that's debated or
whatever but there's just a lot of
Asians in the Gen Z making Tik Tok yes
or no what what I would say is like if
there was like a movie about genz Tik
Tok Asians I think uh the genz Tik Tok
Asian would just be one of the
characters I don't know about watching a
whole movie about it because then you're
about the influencer world it seems
stupid I hate watching movies about an
influencer world movie where the main
guys like uh a wanabe urban white kid
right which is pretty common with the
broccol cut No Cap no key but the second
character is a Asian yeah sure uh aen
thugs from the 1990s versus uh modernday
ASN in Asian frats and sororities yeah I
mean there was that movie bang bang that
went around the Asian-American circuit
that we I watched that movie like three
times
uh ABG was a pilot for ABC right Asian
BB girl was a pilot ended up not getting
picked up right didn't get picked up so
there's been some attempts at it you're
talking about the ACN world that is more
like inter not like trying to go I feel
like it almost would be like that would
be uh the secondary character that you
delve into okay versus like the first
character would still be your kind of
like typical Asian right trying to go to
Berkeley but maybe they're in a lambas
at Berkeley would is more torn to the
asan side anyway um somebody said
something at a boba shop but with some
K-pop Love Story why can't Asians
execute a krama tier story but in
English amongst Asian amans have you
ever heard of Wong Fu
Productions that's what Wong Fu have you
ever heard of Wong Fu Productions guys
how many Boba shops have they filmed
that how many Boba shops have we filmed
that socioeconomic struggle but like
parasite but with asian-americans all
right man here's the story
this inspires me yeah something it's
class struggle class struggle between
the rich International class and a
middle class Asian-American kind of like
crazy Rich Asians but not having to go
back to Asia it takes place in America
oo and it that that that storyline is
possible in 2023 the rich kid either
lives at USC or and lives in LC and goes
to NY so you depict that there's this
Rich International kid who's like an
and then there's a humble
International kid and then there's the
Asian-American Americans and there's
like this whole triangle Clash type
thing that's they just show the
different tiers of Asian America as well
yeah that's true um Andrew a story
centering around rich Japanese baseball
players somehow either making it an
inspirational drama like Rudy or you can
have a bunch of crazy stuff happened cuz
obviously some of the highest paid
players in the MLB history are Japanese
now dude like an Entourage type series
about like Ichiro or like the a supposed
like Show's life yeah and then you can
show him going back Japan but also his
life in La which is probably pretty
crazy I bet you lil Tokyo about to be
lit sautell is going to be crazy for the
next 10 years um some inter Chinese
drama between mainlanders inter
mainlander provincial beef Taiwan
Singapore Hong Kong I said you hear so
much about it in the news why not all
right so let's just say this the story
is that war breaks out in Asia okay
crazy and a group of Asian-American
friends are asked to pick size
but they're Asian-American no but
they're like maybe they're born there
they came here you know what I me they
secured US citizenship but they still
they still have some allegiances how do
they feel as a friend group that's drama
yo that's Taiwanese friend a Mainland
Chinese friend whose parents are from
Beijing and then you got Vietnamese
friends you have a Korean friend a
Japanese friend and uh and then you
throw in uh an Asian from Russia right
right like a Siberian yeah um somebody
said uh how about this how about this
something where just your typical Asian
nerd is on a quest to become the coolest
kid in the school yeah yeah you're not
excited by that I think that you know
why I like that because you could sell
it to Hollywood cuz like we said there's
a lot of Concepts that would be good and
then there's the concepts you can sell
to the people who make the read I think
that one's just going to be so like blue
pill typical oh he becomes kind of cool
no I'm not saying that this theme hasn't
been done before but when have you seen
it executed
dunk was kind of like
that was you know he's going to learn
how to rap and then he's going to have
to like rap and make a song about the
school if you're a rapping nerd guys I
hate to break it to you Kevin G Robin
guy it don't work it don't work it works
a little bit but it doesn't really work
how about this something involving CGI
and the Chinese zodiac animals becoming
alive or or a world where the Chinese
zodiac animals are interacting with each
other and there anomor of sized make it
a horror film when it's your year that
animal comes back and tries to kill you
right because theoretically in Chinese
uh tradition it's bad when it's your
year yeah which is always weird so it's
like a Chinese horror film where it's
like it's the year of the snake it's my
year and then a whole bunch of snakes
come to me in my dreams and then they
come into real life and then you turn
into a snake and I start seeing snakes
everywhere um last but not least Andrew
I got one where Asians are in California
are just acting like
Euphoria you know just having the
typical crazy ups and downs I don't know
oh oh okay how about this they they're
Euphoria at school but then they go home
and they got to be traditional so it
shows the duality of them trying to be
them edgy selves and hide their uh
secret lifestyles of selling drugs doing
it doing all a little bit like better
luck tomorrow kind of like that but but
it it it still involves the parents you
can sell this yo is it noteworthy that
the first Asian-American movie to ever
get Hollywood distribution was better
luck tomorrow and better luck tomorrow
does not deal with filial piety in terms
of actually showing the parents it
doesn't really show that many parents
you're right yeah was more about Asian
kids from the nerd life trying to be
anyways guys which of those movie ideas
do you think could be successful maybe
someone should write a book or a story
based off of it I agree with your one uh
suggestion Andrew as my final takeaway
watch content from Asia as well because
Asian America is a candle that's going
to burn at its own pace just like the
hood movies burnt out or whatever in the
90s even though I liked them but you
know I guess you know I could see why I
was lopsided uh I would say that it's
just a candle that's got to burn so look
into content from Asia if you want to
see Asian faces live the whole wide
breadth of uh life stories and even into
the Fantasy Realm let us know what you
think of this in the comments section
below why are Asian Asian movies so much
more diverse in theme and consent
execution than Asian-American movies are
you happy sad about it or it is what it
is let us know what you think in the
comment section below we encourage the
debate until next time with the hotop
boys we out
peace