Crystal and David Fung analyze the sociological disparities between dating and social structures in Asia and North America. They contrast the transactional, \"hard stat\" approach of Eastern marriage markets with the vibe-based chemistry of the West, while exploring how regional identities in China and gender dynamics shape success and identity globally.
Did I turn from a phone bro to a passport bro?
Listen, if you watch this podcast with my friend crystal run on the asian rebel club podcast, you're gonna find out
She is one of the most viral creators in the past year
Speaking about asian-american issues corporate life. Trust me
I'm sure you've seen one of her videos on instagram before today
I'm joined by david fung from phone bros
If you're anywhere near the asian-american content space, you already know who he is
He has been creating around asian-american culture identity and food for over a decade
Born and raised in the us and now living in vietnam. We have two spicy topics for you guys today
dating in asia versus north america from the perspective of asian men and women and
Chinese provincial differences and what that means for you if you are chinese a diaspora as you guys know
I'm crystal founder of asian rebel club warning. China lived across nine countries in asia and north america
So I see both worlds from the inside which is exactly why this conversation needed to happen
And david over to you. Tell us who you are. My name is david fung. I'm from seattle, washington originally
But I lived a lot in la new york, obviously the entertainment media capitals, but uh, mostly
I was online but did some mainstream stuff as well. Um, and yeah, I think that fung bros me and my brother andrew
Have just been talking about asian america chinese america the diaspora asia
Just a lot, you know what I mean? Like a lot over the years and we're still doing it
So is it the first conversation you've ever had with a female counterpart talking about these topics?
Well, probably not right because you've talked not in um, there was a few small like podcasters
But you're the first like big big female that we've had
Obviously you're on a lot, you know andrew did the anton podcast or like jeff kong's podcast
Or I don't even know how many podcasts we've been on over the years
But to be honest, you are the first female that i've ever seen it from a female and a male perspective
like I I don't think I ever saw
yeah, like a
A deep I don't know how I don't even want to say it this way
But like I was gonna say really like a asian female led now
I don't want to say that there's none because we were on one in brooklyn, but it was like a very small channel
but like
like the first
large platform
Where asian female sort of is talking about guy issues, I guess. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah
No, like I would definitely think that i'm just a guy in a girl's body to be honest with you. I uh,
Love intellectual debate about sociology and psychology. So let's dive right in. Uh,
The first topic is basically dating in asia versus north america. I know in your content you've talked about the transactional
Dating nature in like china. Do you think that that's dramatically different from north america or north america?
Just hides the transactional nature through more layers
Well, I think first of all dating is inherently transactional, right?
Like I know this is probably a hot take
But not really because you are looking for something in the other person while you're going on for day
Doesn't matter whether it's tangible right or intangible like emotional values
So like you it's it's really about like whether you want to make the transactions like what you're looking for more overt
Or you want to hide it in like more polite way
And the way I see in asia is that in a lot of places like singapore, you know
I live because I live in singapore. I live in china
Is that people are just more used to having the transaction out on the table?
So even if you you know go to india like i used to have a roommate who's indian
And he will show me this dating app that he used and you know
There's a lot of file data on the app where like person is like a lower class or a lower class
And everything is just like for you to know before you can even choose this person, right?
And it's the same thing with china where like, you know, I remember going to a interview in my career
And the person was like a ceo of the public company, but he's chinese and the first thing he asked me was that
You know, what what does your dad do and it's just very odd like they see this as like such a normal question to ask
And they just weed you out like very quickly, you know, where what is your class?
What is the benefit you can bring to me or are you going to be a liability, right?
And then so like I see that same dynamic happening in dating where people are very defensive
I think that asian culture is a very defensive culture. It's all about I I don't want to lose
So like they they were they're protecting themselves
So it's like how many houses do you have how how you know?
what is my salary and then like each party will want to like prepare the war chest so that
Like they don't get into like a losing deal. It's just such a
Transactional mentality out in the open now
Like I think north america like because america and you know in canada
Like I live in canada for a long time too, and it's just like such a diverse society
Everybody values different things and you are supposed to to value that right and a lot of like
I don't know like you can value chemistry. You can value adventure
You can value like spiritual costs and political costs like to each their own
So it's not one dimensional transactional, but it is kind of transactional in terms of like what you're looking for, right?
Because like how much of it for example is chemistry is coming from this person's status
Like let's just say all things equal like a person who you know is six feet
I don't know like white guy like trust fund finance whatever in manhattan and a person who isn't right?
Like I don't know homeless artists like everything else equal, right?
like which one would you choose like I would say most people will probably choose the first one and
Is that transaction like I don't know like I think that is it's just that they don't really talk about it as much as chinese
Yeah, I think that there's always like this pokemon card game or like magic card game or
Dungeons and dragons aspect to like matchups, you know
You put down this card of the female and then you put down this card of the male or the male and the female
Like and I think that to your point asian culture in general or ancient societies in general
Let's just take this out and bring it to the middle east or like india or something like that like ancient societies
They're more comfortable like putting the hard stats on each of the cards that you're playing in the game
yeah, whereas like western people would be like
Why do you need to look at it like a card game like dungeons and dragons or magic the gathering in asia?
They would just or ancient societies in general the east whatever you want to call it is middle east, right?
Like it would just be like nah
that that's the stats like we put down the stats the family name what the father does if the
If this match is either gonna go off these stats or not
Like to your point the singhai uh dating market and they don't even have photos of each other like
In the west the photos would be everything is tinder, you know, like people don't even care about what the other stats are
It's just gonna go off
Physiology or phenotype or like you know what I mean? Like yeah, and then I just was listing stats like uh, no photos
No, nothing
I think that's really intense also
Yeah, yeah it is it's like literally like marriage resume in the market
Well in the west is just gonna come down to looks like that would be like the initial filter
You know what? I mean? Like in china and shanghai dating market. That's the final like the afterthought
They don't care about it. They don't care. Yeah, that's crazy
That would be the craziest I would think if you just look at the shanghai marriage market with pure stats
No anything else they got like an essay that the
Daughter the son wrote in like 11th grade to show like their poetic skills or something. It's insane
Yeah, yeah, well, you know like one thing I think the most hilarious thing i've seen was that this guy in his like marriage resume
He was like i'm an older guy and i'm a virgin and i'm like what the **** man
Why would that even be on your resume? Like why would I want to be with a virgin guy, you know?
But yeah
So I could see I could see his thinking because he's like he's like yeah
That's just like everybody want that from a girl. They're gonna want that from me too
But then it just doesn't work. I mean, I don't know
like I think that if a guy is like
You know virgin in his like 40s and 50s like I would I would think there's something wrong with you, you know
So like yeah, i'm not sure I even told my dad that my dad was like, yeah
It was like a key that couldn't unlock any doors, but sometimes people would be interested in a door that's never been unlocked. Yeah, exactly
So I even told my dad that but that was like that's so weird
It's like there is no way for you to verify that right about a guy's virginity. So
That's actually pretty funny. That's funny that your dad took it to the to the biology level. That's actually funny too like a physician
My my dad is super open like he does not care about these topics
He would just give me that is such a Chinese answer hyper like logical to the to the so what's your take on that?
Because like obviously you now live in vietnam
And I know that you mentioned before like in north america
You also did asian women but like do you see the dynamic changing?
You know as you're now here like asian america is like the middle point
Asia is like super put the stats out there transactional
Asian america is here and the west is like a little bit more over here
But if you look at the elites of the western world, they operate a little bit more like asians low-key like the elites like
Rhode island providence delaware with massachusetts, they're gonna low-key act more asian, but they still gonna on the outside
Like, you know, oh, yeah, you can marry that like broke like wannabe rock star, you know
They didn't make it yet
but like once you get to where i'm from on the west coast where you're really free from these like old
Institutions like if you look at all the ivy league universities, they're all on the east coast where they have more than like
british bloodline thinking like
In seattle like you do see I knew this hot white girl that we grew up with who married this like, um
Mexican dishwasher that she worked at with at the tex-mex restaurant and she was hot too like that's unheard of
Like that's like uh, yeah, and that's not even that uncommon
yeah, it was still kind of a shock in the town, but it wasn't even like that big of a shock because we're just
Like oh, yeah, like she's just going for love
So it's like that's never gonna happen in an ancient society
Like it's not i'm not gonna say never but they're gonna make a movie out of it like aladdin
You know what? I mean?
Like that's how uncommon it is. It's gonna be like stuff for the fairy tales for generations to come
But yeah in the west people marry for a vibe for love, but they also gonna get divorced off a vibe or lack of a vibe
But so I think that yeah
Because people don't really view divorce in the west as like a a stain on a scarlet letter on you in perpetuity
Whereas in the east it might be like a scar. I mean, I think it's changing now in 2026
But for a while, it's like you you damage goods forever. Oh my gosh, you know in china because currently i'm in shanghai, right?
And my friends told me the craziest stories where first of all, everybody's getting a divorce shocking
I think half of my female friends were divorced and
they also were saying that because one of my
Guy friends who took forever to get married and they're like please get married soon because the second marriage market is very competitive
Because because a lot of them, you know get divorced and like, you know, they're they're already in the second marriage market, right?
Well, like he's still in the first marriage market. So they try to warn him
So that's really funny. That's really funny to tell somebody before their first marriage to already prepare for their second marriage
Oh my gosh
so like I definitely think I think a lot of
Chinese people don't really have or like asian in general don't really have commitment issues like that's such an american thing
So they just don't care like they will get committed
They will get married and worst case scenario. They get a divorce and blame on their parents
They're like you see I did this for you and it's like not working out, you know
I think for westerners they simply just like have commitment issues and they don't even do it
Yeah
I think that like dating apps really destroyed the west because you could find a new wife or a new husband in like
10 minutes like if you think about back in the parochial days like being in the village
Like just human interaction like didn't occur that way. Yeah. Yeah
I mean, but you know like you you think like that right because but it's just idea of it
You know that it's not really the reality either
Yeah, the east is more transactional than the west, but I think the west can be more transactional
But they hide it behind a lot of layers, but it depends per person like for sure
Dude white people, you know, I mean this is a little bit of a tangent
But I think they just conquered so much in the world over the past 500 years
They can kind of like make a bad decision of their partner
They don't need to like empire build and bloodline build and multi-generational like aristocracy build anymore
They're like they like pass that point. You know what I mean? Like they're just like, oh, yeah, I'll just
Let's do it. Why not? Like who cares but like minorities are like we still like still thinking in an ancient way
You know, we're not from a new world country. We're from an ancient country that still
Holds like some ancient beliefs. I definitely think there is a huge difference between the
Overseas
Asian right like asian-american versus like a huge country like china like people here don't really have
Scarcity mindset like that anymore like in a lot of groups, right?
Obviously in a lot of groups they still do but like as people get richer
They also start to think a little bit more like westerners in that department
Because like technically a chinese person in china is the white person of the west because they're the majority
In the leverage and etc
Yeah, totally so okay
So the question for you asian women and men who has more dating trauma you think or I rather in the west, right?
Like we're not talking about in asia, man in the west
I think the easy answer for anybody to give is asian men for sure
But I could see the argument for asian women having more trauma because it's just a completely different situation
I think asian women are actually in the game, but they're getting played out a lot in the game
You know what I mean?
Because like there's some things that make asian women feel like they can compete but then right at the moment it gets pulled back
But asian guys are not even in the game. We are like forced to be either stay in the enclaves
Import a wife from asia. Yeah, or kind of like
Not even be in the game now the young gen z guys, especially if you're really tall and good-looking
They're starting to get in the game more
Like for sure for gen z, you know, like 25 28 and under but i'm talking about for like millennials and gen x
You're either dating like exclusively asian women in the u.s
Or you're dating like a fob chick from asia
You know what?
So we're not we can't be in the white world to get our heart ripped out
But i'm saying that asian women can be in the white world
But oftentimes at least once they will have their heart ripped out like by a guy who didn't want to marry him
He wanted to marry a white girl
You know what?
I mean that the joy luck club type situation like you know that that that does happen
So I guess I guess there's two different types of trauma one is you're in a combatant in the game
But you have your heart ripped out at the last moment and when you couldn't even get into the mma, you know
You stopped fighting in b league. There's also like a fomo around not being the game
Do you see the situation being like a little bit better in places like new york?
Because obviously there's more women than men
and
Everybody who I have known. Yeah, who's gone to new york
Was just like they're just getting to a candy shop. Yeah, I agree
But a lot of people don't understand that like new york is not america
Like I dated a girl that looks white in new york, but her mom was like like a white
Uruguayan and her dad was white. Yeah, you know what I mean?
So it's like she was white, but she really wasn't white. She spoke spanish ate a lot of latino foods
Do you know what i'm saying?
Like that really is gonna you're essentially outside of the anglosphere when you're in new york city
Because it's like such a collection of people from around the world. So I think that yeah
I never count that like
I don't like it when asian guys date like a girl that they don't visually look like they should be dating
And then they're like, oh, yeah asian guys have a good i'm like nah because I lived in a really white like americana zone
And then I lived in manhattan manhattan
Yes to your point is dope for for a guy who can figure it out and be cool or whatever
But it's not representative of the larger game map, right?
I guess i'm saying it's such an international place
It's almost like saying like is dating in shanghai representative of dating in some village in china. Yeah
Yeah, yeah. Yeah, I guess you know if you do move to san francisco then it's like the other way around right?
It's like these people have like no luck because the discrepancy is just so big I agree with you
I think that like I think a lot of people are like not necessarily trauma
It's just like they have they don't really have the trauma of I learned something in the relationship because like I think
Relationships is something that you got to practice right like every single breakup everything single
Date teaches you something about yourself and then over time you get better at it
You also get more considerate and whatever
Towards another person but if a man never even play that game, like how can they even get better?
So it's like you're if you're
Looking at a person who's like 45 years old and only got like a one relationship, you know
Like they're probably really bad at this, right?
Like I don't know i'm just stereotyping that so like I don't know like trauma aside
I think it's just one of those things where like the later you get into the game that you know
The worse you probably play it too. So, you know, there's like accumulative layers of trauma as you go
Yeah, yeah what I guess to answer your question to sum it all up
What type of trauma are we talking about asian girls are gonna have a ton of repetitions
We call them reps in basketball like a ton of reps
Yeah, some of those reps that went downside on them
But asian guys the trauma comes from like I wanted to get reps
But maybe I didn't even get the reps that I wanted in practice. Like I didn't even I didn't get in the game
Yeah, yeah for sure
um, I gotta say I did see some statistics like yesterday a white girl talking about uh,
Girl versus like possible, bro
And she said that on average I think like an american girl and this is like race aside would have about seven
Sexual partner by the age of 30, but then like a lot of men will have zero by the age of 30
So, I mean that's kind of the discrepancy. We're talking about even race aside, right?
This is just how it is like the age that we're living right now in the u.s at least. Yeah, I think it's just uh
Whatever's happening in the western world specifically america with dating is like there's like a macro thing
And then there's micro slipstream trends within that that's like asian men's overall status improving
But then all men may be struggling as a general title boat thing. So there's a lot of competing trends
You know micro trends versus macro trends
Why do you think high achieving asian women are actually less dateable in the marketplace?
Like whether we're talking about asia
Or america, I mean, I mean I heard american women complain about this to some extent but obviously you're living in
And you see it a lot more. I think it might even be more stark in the east
Yes, it's interesting because I usually live in singapore. I'm in shanghai vermont
So it's almost like i'm having this like separate pocket for shanghai and like singapore, right?
And they are surprisingly different we're talking about this high achieving thing because singaporean women are
Not notorious, but they're famous for their high achieving attitude, right?
There's one thing about singapore because like guys need to go to army. So like when a guy starts their career
They are two years behind their female counterpart because the woman does not need to go to army
So you can see like two years of professional experience
Will make the women even more like intimidating right career-wise to like a man
And so a lot of singaporeans are like super high achieving
And I don't think that they have the same kind of problem as the girl here in shanghai
Like it's just insane how so like, you know, we're talking about the marketplace
In you know the people square right like the the dating corner and a lot of these files are actually from women
You know more of them are from women than a guy and I think the reason is they're just very competitive, right?
They're competing with men instead of like complimenting the men. So a lot of traditional chinese men, right?
They still want agreeable domesticated
Submissive girls and these girls because they gotta be very kind of aggressive and like ambitious in their career
They don't really have that like kind of femininity anymore and they're rewarded for that in their careers
So it's like you've got to pick and choose who you want to be, right?
You're either this person in your career this one that got rewarded by your career or you become something completely different
Which may or may not get rewarded by this man, you know, because like dating is risky, right?
So I think a lot of them they kind of run the ROI
Subconsciously and they have made their bet versus in singapore. I think that the men are just more accommodating in general
So they actually don't mind, you know, like the the woman taking the lead a little bit
Yeah, maybe in singapore, too
they're kind of stuck like you can't really there's no countryside you can't get a hot girl from the countryside in singapore like
It is a limited population. There's only three million three maybe four million people in the whole country like in china is 1.4 billion like
you can
Go to anhui get a baddie this feminine, you know, i'm not sure exactly but yeah
I could see like shanghainese like high
Achieving women just being so demanding that it's just like crushing for any guy that hits their standard, you know
Because guys they hit their standard
we also got a lot of options and they just don't want to adapt to like the
Because you know like we were talking about earlier
It's like I think a lot of chinese girls in the one child policy in china is raised like men, you know
Like because the dad has to put the mental cost in them too because he's not going to have a son
So it has to be the heir to the empire whatever mini empire every family
You know accumulates so it's like the woman is yeah
It's raised by the mom like a woman but raised by the man like the father like a son
So I think that yeah, it's very difficult because like that that the son's side probably helps them achieve in their career
Or like rise up that like nba style, you know, like lateral or you know what I mean?
like a little jumping up and stuff, but it's not
feminine for
For what the guy wants to be like coming home to every day. Yeah. Yeah
No, they they don't they actually I think that they because they have such a high standard for themselves
They tend to like look down upon men who don't necessarily have the same standard or higher than them right towards themselves
So it's like they're they're literally measuring themselves and the man with the same ruler, right?
These women are not
Complementary to man
They're more competitive with men and that's why they have such a big problem in the dating market where they're supposed to be
Complementary towards each other. Yeah, I remember I knew this girl in beijing and her parents like owned like a chemical company
And she had so many demands of her husband like had to be stay at home
Beijing, you know, she got to go for these big trips all the time to like go to conferences and stuff like that
She just ended up with like a nice sweet beta like half white guy, you know
Yeah, because like a white guy is more likely to like accept this positioning with like a power female
And then he can provide softness and the emotional support but if she wants another chinese alpha
First of all that hits her physical standards. He's not gonna want to put up with the demands. You know what I mean?
Like I couldn't yeah. Yeah, I see that all the time. Yeah, just get the get the beta white guy or part white guy
that's the solution to be honest like
That is a solution, okay, so
The next question for you is why does asian male market value go up when they leave america?
But asian women does not change the same way obviously when asian guys go to asia
They're in a patriarchal society. It's been that way for thousands of years asian men run asia to be honest like
For the most part I think outside of thailand and maybe japan now
Those are the only two countries that have the female prime minister
I think south korea did as well, but her dad was the prime minister obviously in the white world
I think that asian women that's their best play, you know
Like because they're gonna be able to play the asian female card, which is desirable the female card
Which is having a moment, you know, obviously since the feminist movement in the 70s and there's just a lot more benefits
I think to be an asian female in the west
Than an asian female in the east and there's a lot of benefits to be an asian guy in the east
Where there's a lot of disadvantages to be an asian male in the west, I mean it's as easy as like who runs those
Prospective hemispheres. So I meet a lot of asian guys that are in asia for like 10 15 20 years
You know what?
I mean, uh, but I don't meet a lot of asian girls that west like I would say like it's like 10 to 1 on the
expat level like i'm sure
I mean in like female coded city with the manor coffees and everything
but like it's it's even then I would imagine it's like maybe eight to one like I think females feel more comfortable moving to uh,
Shanghai than like ho chi minh or something. You know what I mean? Like bangkok or something like that. It's like hype male centric
yeah, like I I just think that the
The volume of expats is so heavily weighted on uh, asian american males than asian american females
Yeah, I would say, you know, that's definitely a problem in the expat community here in asia
Right because i'm it's funny because i'm expat in singapore, but i'm a local here in china
doesn't matter whether you're
An asian girl or you're in white girl
Actually a white girl struggles even more in the singapore expat community just because a lot of asian men so prefer asian women
so like
you know if you're like a white girl in singapore like
You if you break up with a white guy and a white guy has a lot more options in singapore, right?
You know comparison to white girls like they really struggle in their personal life and it's the same thing here
I remember one of my friends
She said that like everything was good in shanghai except for dating because dating was really tough for her
for sure for sure
I think asian girls man
I I knew it was like this one since I was a kid because I knew some girls that was in college and they took their
Like college trip and they will always pick europe like every time and then asian guys was always taking their college trip back to asia
So it was just right there. That is so funny. You can see that that was in my undergrad. I saw that one like 21
Yeah, that is so funny because now you mentioned it
I see it but like I never thought that was a reason like I never thought why yeah
I mean who who are they hooking up with on those trips?
Will be real
Yeah, anyway
Let's go to the provincial and local stereotypes and i'm gonna start with the north south east because I did a little bit
Research with deepseek just to see what deepseek has to say about the stereotypes
So deepseek said for south is interdependent and holistic and you know south meaning fujian and guangdong province, right?
They're practical pragmatic and business savvy offer stereotype as cunning shrewd or deceptive but also more interdependent and loyal to their in-group
And it says for east which is you know, we're talking about the shanghai area
So it says we're we're shrewd wealthy cosmopolitan
coastal elites
Basically, people are very adept at business living in fast-paced international environments
But they're also very calculating materialistic perhaps a little bit aloof towards
Those from inland or less developed region the north are they're more insulated
So they're thought to be more direct individualistic and analytical similar to westerners according to deepseek
I did not know that trades are often linked to a history of wheat farming which requires less intense
incorporation than rice patties
so I think the reason why we're talking about this topic is because a lot of
Chinese americans their parents are all from different parts of china, right and
A lot of them don't really know the differences between the different regions and we think about china as like the whole country
As one, you know one place
But if you know a little bit of the differences in
Between different provinces that you might know yourself a little bit better, right?
So that's the premise and david. What do you think about the explanation from deepseek?
I mean, I think it's got to be true to be honest
I mean, I think different provinces provide different upbringings and different thinking patterns
If you look in america
Most people from texas act dramatically different from people in seattle and people from seattle act dramatically different from people from florida
Because america is also a very big country with a lot of different climates
There's this theory that like america is actually low-key 11 different americas, you know, there's like yankee america
There's like appellation america and all these like different civilizational theories and in america. We don't know the differences either
I think in china
Just the provincial things have been that way for like so many hundreds or thousands of years that people feel more comfortable speaking on it
You know what? I mean? Like, um, so I think that you know for me
I have grandparents from guangdong. I have grandparents from shanghai. I have grandparents from shandong
So they all act different and what we'll talk about is different too like people from the north
They do care more about like china as like a governmental or like a civilizational like nation state bureaucratic entity
I think that people from the to your point, you know, hangzhou suzhou shanghai
They are more like very cultured and into a lot of art. I feel like they're into really art
You know what? I mean? Like tiantang or the the poems and you know, the all the things yeah
Dynasty with that centered around hangzhou like and then the people from guangdong dynasty. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah
and that's a good that's a considered a good dynasty too, right and then like
The guangdong has never been the the head of any dynasty to be honest, right?
And it's always been more mercantile and more outward facing and less inward facing like, you know
Cantonese people didn't control a lot of mainland chinese history
They've always been their own thing and they if anything they've been fleeing to uh, not fleeing but like migrating to southeast asia
for hundreds or even thousands of years, you know, so I think it's they are all different and and that
Affects the brain and it affects the brain of the second generation kids born in america
so I know that your mom was from shandong and your dad is
Like hong kong like canton ish, right? So like how did that affect you growing up? I mean, I think I just
Had access to different worlds, you know, like on the mandarin side when people hear you're from shandong, they like it, you know
They're like, oh
really
If you're from like shandong and for the old people that care about this old stuff, it means something, you know
And when you say you from guangdong, it's usually in mainland. They'll be like it's not that it's like, you know what I mean?
but like
but but but if you're if you're cantonese in southeast asia
It's different too because you you know, you probably ran a lot of economics and in the cantonese world
And they're gonna think more about their own family and getting money rather than the chinese narrative
i'm not saying 100 out of 100 but like they're more focused on the clan and
What they're doing than what's happening with everybody in the north the northern chinese
They concern with what's happening with like the country like is china doing good almost sometimes they could even care
As much as what's happening with their own bank account. Yeah, do you know what i'm saying?
Like where where's the thinking, you know?
like like fujianese people in my opinion are gonna get rich for themselves and their family and they
Don't really care about like what's happening with like not their their clan or their their family bloodline, you know
Like but that's why they get rich too. So it's really like how do you say what's right or what's wrong?
Yeah, yeah
I think that like it's it's very fascinating to me at least that I did not know that fujianese people have like a
Specific stereotype about them, you know, especially in america where like it seems like they run flashing, right?
Like the wenzhou people. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah
So like wenzhou are because you know
I'm from zhejiang province and wenzhou people are so different from like the mainstream zhejiang people
Because they're just like the jewish of our province and they will go to a random european country and they will do a small business
They don't necessarily do huge businesses
They they really love their autonomy and they don't really care whether it's a bit of nowhere country or mainstream country
All they see as opportunities. So I think that maybe for that is very similar to fujianese people
So why do you think that fujianese people dominate the overseas chinese business globally? They run factories and restaurants?
I mean, yeah, I think it depends on what sub-region of fujian you're from like in america to be honest
I think we have both we got like the gangster fujianese and uh more
Corporate or like enterprising fujianese. I know in the philippines. They just have the enterprising fujianese
Like but one thing that I know about fujianese people is they're just gonna go get to the money
You know what? I mean?
Like whether by any means necessary they're gonna get to the money
And if you look at like diejiu people like from caozhou like qiuzhou people
That's what we call them and then like hokkien people who are from generally from the xiamen region of like fujian
They left like hundreds of years ago in southeast asia
And they have these like even in china to this day, but in southeast asia as well
They have these like ways right the way is like a shihui like a little mini society society
They can act they can act like a bank or like a loan shark or even like private equity within themselves
But like not every chinese province is able to run that like I don't think hainan people or like guangzhou people
Or like guangxi people when they went to southeast asia was able to run that internal like hui system like internal lending
Yeah, because it requires quite a bit of cohesiveness and checks and balances but like wenzhou people hokkien people and diejiu people
they they are able to run that tight-knitness because uh,
They still like, you know to feel very clannish and very you know
What I mean like you to run that type of system you have to trust everybody because you're like lending money out informally
There's no formal structure to recall the money right would you would you say
You know, they're more like italian american in that sense. Is that what italians did like sicilians kind of?
Yeah, I would say some I would say so I would say so
like a little bit of mafia vibes a lot of like just you know, I mean not necessarily like
Cuomo and them were not mafia. They were like anti-mafia, but they still ran the same like tight-knit
You know sicilian. Yeah
System yeah, I would say so like
You guys run the anytime you're a tight-knit group
It'll allow you to run a lot of schemes in your community that a non-tight-knit group is
It changes everything. Yeah. Yeah for sure like concentrate amount of power
I mean I have definitely seen like, you know, actually a friend of mine
So he is italian american and he's dating a girl who's fujianese american from flushing
I was like, man, maybe they don't look the same on the surface
But i'm pretty sure like they have shared a lot of things in common
Yeah, their families matter a lot too. Like they're always like yo, my grandma doesn't like you my you know
Nana doesn't like you like you hear fujianese people say that all the time too
Like my mom thinks this about your mom or something like no other i've never heard other chinese people like talk
Mafia like that new york fgs to be honest
so so I mean
But why are they all like it seems like they have a huge presence in flushing and in this like restaurant industry
They just got the way man. They just run the system tight
Like there's a lot of plans like I don't even want to get into it too much
I got a friend who broke it all down to me who's deep on the inside
But like I don't want to blow anybody's cover
But they just it moves different because i've been in the cantonese community. Yeah, the cantonese community
they don't even trust each other to run schemes or
Run plans or complicated structures or canto people don't even trust each other to like take out the garbage to be honest
Let alone like why?
Why it's because cantonese people are very different
You know, you could be from like zhongshan like choysan jiangmen, you know
I mean like people aren't gonna fully like
They all speak canto, but their grandparents or great-grandparents probably spoke like a different mountain dialect
They're just not that cohesive because I think
Cantonese is a lingua franca
Okay, yeah, it's not a lingua franca that belongs to that tribe forever
You know, I mean nobody gonna come in and learn hokkien or learn dhu
That's like if you know speak those you're part of the tribe. Yeah, so they just run anything like I said any tight-knit
Globally, they i'll tell you this if you're from a non-tight-knit group
You don't understand how to tighten it groups operate internally. They can run any scheme. I don't you'll never
I mean am I missing out?
yeah, if you're not from a tight-knit group like that's why you got to be a normie and like rise up and get like
all these degrees and like
You know what? I mean?
Because I know people who like everything they did was outside of the public eye and their family have like 30 million dollars
Usd and nobody knew what the hell they did their whole life
You know what i'm saying?
But because think about it if you got to get these degrees from harvard
And then you got to work your way into anthropic or open ai or you know
Whatever is the next booming company get your stock options appeal to the other ivy league ceos and like c suite
And then like get your stock options and hope the company 20x is 40x to get 30 million
Yeah, that is so different than me and my squad speaking dialect running
You know what? I mean real estate or whatever things in like, yeah, wisconsin, you know, we run in chinese buffet super buffet
We're doing this and that and we got 30 million
You guys end up with the same amount of money like it's so different
It is very different. But you also mentioned there's institutional fujianese people in the philippines. So how do you explain that?
Uh, they're from a different part of fujian. I mean
I don't i'll just say you know, there's basically snakehead parts like sitoh
There's like snakehead parts and then there's just parts where people are just want to build some empires, you know
Do you think this eastern coastal?
stereotype of chinese elitism in the hangzhou suzhou shanghai area is
Justified or like where does it come from because it is an internal chinese stereotype
That the zhang zhi region is like all full of like cocky elitist
Well, I think there's definitely some truth to it. Uh, and uh, just some statistics right before we talk about the substance. So
These areas we're talking about two provinces in one city
So two provinces are jiangsu and zhejiang and the city is shanghai
They collectively occupy about four percent of chinese land, but then they also generate about a quarter of chinese gdp
So you're talking about a super concentrated piece of land that got a lot of economic activities going on
And in 2024 the regional gdp is about four trillion usd dollars
Which if it's a country that it will be a very developed country is actually more developed than korea
We're talking about the fact that these people do have something to go about right in terms of their slumishness
If you're looking at doing businesses and where things are going on
You don't necessarily need to go to for example, india mongolia
You know what? I mean? Because there are a ton of things going on there
So they are pretty much looking at each other right at jameson city
At jameson provinces for
The next action so I think that it's definitely justified and i'm not saying that this attitude is good
Because it does give you like a very silo point of view about what china is
and another thing I noticed about these group of people and i'm not sure if you agree with it because you told me that your
Grandpa's from shanghai is that they don't really go abroad that much
So like for example, i'm from hangzhou and I haven't really met anyone
That live in singapore like my days in in canada. Not a lot of people are from hangzhou
That live in these places because they actually don't need to go out for opportunities
So usually what happens is that like a lot of these people who if they do migrate they come from like a very wealthy
Background and they just want an opportunity for their kids education or something like that
For example, i'm not sure if you agree with it just because I heard that your grandpa's from shanghai. Yeah, my grandma
grandma
Yeah, there's the shanghainese, but uh, I would just say that um, okay like it's probably true
You know, I think that anybody that's from a very prosperous region of their country internally becomes like a little bit cocky
And can almost turn a little bit like narrow-minded
You know what I mean?
So I think that that shanghai region
Hangzhou suzhou more specifically shanghai really wasn't anything until the last couple hundred years. It just always had a lot of wealth
It's not too hot. It's not too cold. It's near the
Yangtze river
It's got the ocean
It's natural for the people in shanghai if that was the most advanced place in china for like a couple centuries
They're gonna just be like believe in their own exceptionalism
you know one thing I noticed about like
different human nature
Is like if your province or your city was like the ---- for like a few decades or centuries
Even if your province or city ceases to be the ----
You're still gonna keep that attitude for a long time
If you ever meet people from spain or like not really portugal but spain or india or france
They still act like they run the world but america ran the world for the last hundred years
But they still act like it's like they're you know, the colonial days. Yeah. Yeah
Do you think it's like a part of insecurity as well?
Because like a part of them actually does know that it's not the truth anymore. So that's why they have the attitude
Yeah, I think they know it's not the logical truth, but to them is still the emotional truth
Like if you talk to people from spain, they'll be like the most, you know
I mean the most like proudest person, you know
But spain probably hasn't been a superpower for like a couple hundred years already and they really care about their lineage
like they will be telling you that oh like
My ancestor was like playing, you know music instruments in this court or whatever
there's like something else that other than money that they focus on because they have such a
Long history of a prosperity. Yeah
Well to be to be fair and there's a little bit of a derivative
That's why europe to your point about the hangzhou people not leaving
That's why europe has zero good companies in 2026 because they focus too much on heritage
And they rely on it to extract like tourism income or wine or cheese money
But it's like that's why they do not care a lot of good companies are in china or america nowadays. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah
Yeah, well, you know the world's gonna change right and then it's already changing so much like honestly like living in shanghai has shown me
just the amount of abundance this place has right and this part of china like
I just think that like the world has not seen it if you don't live here
You don't know so I I just don't know what's gonna happen in the 5-10 years
where a lot of these products can go over to other countries and
Maybe there's gonna be more people moving to asia in the next 5-10 years
Like you just don't know what's a new world's order is. Yeah, and also like how
Does a gdp affect like somebody's material day-to-day life, you know, like I think that that's always a good question because you can look at countries
By the individual life or you can look at countries by like a macro gdp number. Yeah. Yeah
well
That's why we have gdp per capita ppp adjusted right like a lot of times the purchasing power
Is so different by region to region and if you look at china, for example, like the gdp per capita
Obviously, we're still a developing country
But if you look at the standard of living there is no way that you can convince me
This is a developing country, right? Like as I told you my toilet is heated in this apartment
Like that's a default setting you go to any other country
You can't possibly convince me that the apartment the heated toilet is a standard
Unless it's japan
Yeah, maybe japan it's so different also because I think that a lot of times, uh, you know
The product is produced here in china. So obviously they're newer they're
Cheaper to get so you can't really have that kind of advantage if you don't live here. Yeah
Gadgets are like a low amount of money like
yeah, even a poor person could afford to have like a motion sensing lights or motion sensing soap dispensers because it would be like
Just a few dollars more than a manual. Exactly
Exactly technology is worth nothing. But anyway, so I have one last question for you
Do you think that your passport bro? This is just my question
I don't think so because like, uh, I was still dating a lot of chicks and
Manhattan, it's more of
Just a different life. I just wanted to have
more flexibility with my income to to
Build out my team and restructure different businesses and I just thought that the west was kind of toppy
but the reason why
I I don't care if people call me that but I don't really call it that is because I had success in the west
As you know, whether as an individual or as like a company or like a brand
So I think that to me i'm just like checking out the rise of asia as an asian guy, you know
I think that definitely yeah
If you're like white or even and I mean to be honest, even if you're just anything but asian if you're in asia
You're probably like utilizing some sort of soft power arbitrage, you know
Like maybe a black guy is going to cosplay a rapper or a basketball player
maybe a white guy is going to cause play like timothy chalamet or
Ryan gosling or like whatever archetype they can subsume, you know in the in the world that doesn't have that but like for me
When i'm in, uh asia, like most people are gonna just speak the native language to me. I was in cambodia
They were speaking cambodian to me because like there's a lot of chinese in cambodia, too
So it's like to me i'm just like yeah, i'm just an asian representing asia
Even me I felt that way because I was from a very white part of canada
Coming to singapore. I just definitely felt like I was part of the group. It's it's such a refreshing feeling
Yeah, thank you so much davis great conversation always enjoy talking to you. No for sure and I really appreciate
uh, the asian rebel club and everything you're doing with uh, the instagram because
You're the only one where i've seen asian guys send your videos
In the thread i'm really flattered if this conversation sparked something in you share it
With someone who needs to hear it and if you are building a more true life not just more impressive
We would love to hear your story follow us on instagram youtube and tiktok at asian rebel club and join
Our newsletter for more ways to connect link in the description until next time