This video discusses a study by the Asian American Foundation (TAF) regarding what defines a \"true American.\" The speaker analyzes how different ethnic groups perceive the importance of race, birthplace, religion, and language in American identity, while offering his own criteria for being a \"good American\" and a \"patriot\" based on contribution and civic duty.
What makes you truly American? A new study shed some light. Let's talk about it.
So previously when this question was asked like, Oh, what makes you American? Which makes you
American? I would just be kind of like, Oh, well you're here in America. You're
kind of contributing to the country. You're just American. Like as long as you are here,
you're here. But it's really funny because given the climate of today and also given that
this year is going to be America's 250th birthday on July 4th, as you know, even though 250 years
actually for a country as significant as America is really not that old.
It kind of raises this question, you know, I know that you heard that empire's going cycles
of 250 years. So I'm just hoping America didn't peak yet, but even if it did, hopefully the decline
is slow. Hopefully. So I just think that right now people are really trying to grasp at a
definition of what makes you American, because I do think that politically speaking, it's,
it's supposed to protect you a little bit, you know, given that, you know, people are getting
snatched up and deported that crazy. And it's just looking really ugly right now. So who is
American? Well, shout out to TAF, the Asian American foundation, because they put in money
and work to do a study study of thousands of Americans to find out what people think
makes you American. And they broke it down by different ethnicities on what they rank is most
important. So we're going to go through this study, but also I want to, at the end, tell you
what I think makes you a good American, and then also what might make you a very patriotic American,
because I think they're a little bit different, but I have my own definition. And then you guys,
let me know down below what you think. So let's look at this graph right here. I'll pop it up
right here. It goes, how important do you think each of the following is to being truly American
when it comes to being white? How important is being white to being American? Well,
most U.S. adults say it's not that important. Okay, that makes sense because, you know, America is a
very diverse country. It's always been pretty diverse. And it is even more diverse now. So
Hispanic Americans actually ranked it the highest, but not by a lot. And then black people said 13%
said it was important. White people, 12% said it was important. So all those numbers are pretty
close to each other, 12, 13, 15. And boom, Asian Americans were like, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no,
not important to be white. Kind of funny. Let's go to being born in the U.S. About half U.S.
adults say it's important. And yet again, Asian Americans, AAPI think it's the least important.
And that's also because probably a lot of Asian Americans are actually foreign born and they also,
you know, feel like they contribute to America in a lot of ways. Surprisingly, black Americans are
said that it's the most important overall. And then Hispanics and whites. Okay. Now on being
Christian, do you have to be Christian to be American? And although I would say a lot of
American, I guess, values, or I would say moral character is based off of Christian ethics,
mostly. Let's see what people think. Okay. So Hispanics, 36% said it was very, very important.
64% of black Americans said it was very important. 34% of white people and also Asians,
of course, the lowest Asians were like, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. You don't have to be
Christian. And also AAPI does include South Asians. So that's going to include a lot of
Hindu or even Muslims. And then also Buddhist and also some Christians in the Asian American
sphere, but also like a lot of Asians are also non-religious. Now, one thing they did agree on
is speaking English. Everybody seemed to agree that it was pretty important to speak English
to be American. Even the Asian Americans who were generally like, Hey, nothing else. Hey,
you know, nothing else really matters except you must speak English. Okay. You have to speak
the language of the land. Okay. To communicate. Yeah. And I think that's true. You know, I think
a lot of Asians see the benefit of speaking English because that's a lot of how they got
more integrated and gained leverage in this world, you know, like as far as doing business and moving
up in the ranks and moving up in corporate, I mean, you have to speak some English. I mean,
Hey, listen, I love my Asian enclaves or my ethnic enclaves just as much as the next person,
but I do think coming to America and if you really want to live and succeed in America,
be integrated and part of the American fabric, which yeah, there's pockets where you don't
really have to, but you probably should try to learn some English, you know, but then again,
if you're like a 80 year old grandparent that comes over, I don't fully expect that really.
But if you're trying to work again and operate in America and you know, it's only going to benefit
you to learn English a little bit better so that you can, and that makes sense because you go to
any country. Okay. If I was to move to China, I would have to get my Chinese better. Even if I'm
going to be working in a whole expat community, me as a Chinese American speaking worse Chinese
than all these other expats, I would be ashamed. Anyways, let me know which one of these stats
down below was the most interesting to you. Now, I'm not surprised that Asian Americans
largely said that all these other factors were not very important to being American,
except for speaking English, because I think a lot of Asians know that they contribute a lot
to this country. And if you've seen past videos and see what I'm saying on my Instagram,
I'm kind of going off this thesis that I think Asians are per capita, per person, contributing
the most to America, doing the right things, not speaking on anybody else and not speaking on why
anybody else is not, but I just know Asian Americans truly are. I think they know that
they contribute a lot to America. So they're like, listen, man, like, so what if I'm not born here?
So what if I'm not Christian? First of all, America, is it really a Christian country? Like,
yes, God is in the constitution, but dude, there's no, it's not a religious state. It's
not a theocracy, right? Like some other countries, that's just kind of the base culture. I would say
Christian culture has defined a lot of American, especially like WASP culture, white Anglo-Saxon
Protestant culture, which is very, I guess you could say defining of America, at least a part
of America, a large part of America. But yeah, Asians are like, hey man, listen, I contribute
a lot. I own shops. I pay my taxes. I don't do this. I'm law abiding. Boom, boom, boom. I'm
American. I don't care what you say. Oh yeah. And I'm learning how to speak English. But here is
what I think actually makes you a solid, good American. Now, I'm very careful when I say good
American, not necessarily like the greatest, like patriotic, like the most patriotic hero Rambo,
whatever person, Captain America. This is not what makes you Captain America, but this is what
makes you a good American, I think. And this is really the baseline that we should all be
shooting for. Number one, contribute to the economy of the USA. I think this is big. I think
America is a heavy economic state. A lot of it is about how strong America is economically.
Identity wise, it's kind of shifting and waving and it's evolving and morphing right now and
people are trying to figure it out. And that's why it's getting a little messy out there.
But economy, economy, economy, that is the one thing that America is driven by. That's the reason
why in Chinese, America is called Meiguo, which is beautiful country because it was not only a
beautiful piece of land, but also there's the land opportunities. Golden Mountain, was it Purple
Mountain? I forgot the word. It's all about the streets are paved with gold. You know what I mean?
So this means you circulate money within the economy, you make money for America,
or you hire Americans and you're not just only making money in America and shipping it out.
I get it. You got to send money back home sometimes. That's cool. But if you have a large
company and you're making a ton of money in America and it's just going back out, that's not
really contributing to the economy of America. But again, maybe if you're hiring people that
counts for something. Paying taxes. Yes, I know this is self-explanatory. I know people don't
like taxes. I don't love them either, but it is part of being American. And you can argue on where
your tax dollars go and how they're used, but then, you know, that's going to depend on my next
point actually. But yes, paying taxes is part of being American. And Asians, for example, they pay
a very high tax rate. They pay the highest tax rate for people of their income level. Meaning
that when you compare Asians with kind of like upper middle-class white people that are making
the same amount, Asians are actually paying more taxes. Voting. I know you think your vote doesn't
matter, but also voting is actually a huge part of being American. Being that America is one of,
I don't want to say the few, but one of the great countries that you can actually vote in.
And I know that you may have not liked how most people in the country voted in the past
couple elections, but yeah, you vote. Your vote does kind of matter. And also, especially voting
for local, it even matters a lot more. I would say, I would say, if anything, people need to
really focus on who they're voting for in the local elections, you know, because those are
people who actually impact your streets, your life, your school. Don't take your vote for granted.
There's a lot of places where you can't really vote. I mean, there's still a lot of good countries
that you can't really vote in. So being law-abiding. Yeah. I think this, this definitely matters on
being like a good American, to be honest. Like you can't just keep committing a bunch of crimes
and crimes can be all different types of things. But of course the law of the land
is there for a reason. Next point is that you have some stake in the country's future. I mean,
you can kind of take this for what it is, but I think if you have kids here, you have a family,
you own a business, you own some property, you have a stake in this country's future.
And last but not least, this shouldn't be too controversial because pretty much everybody
agrees. You got to try to learn some English. Yes. I mean it like at least attempt to,
like there is no set bar. It kind of depends on where you're starting from and how much you'll
learn. But like, it's so easy to learn the phrases on how to kind of operate in another country and
English, especially if you speak another Latin based language, like it's really easy, but you
know, even when I go to a different country, like Thailand or if I'm in Vietnam, you know,
or obviously if I'm going back to China, I still want to learn all those phrases,
even if I'm just visiting. And especially if I move there now, I think that's what makes you
a good solid American. I think that's what most people should strive to be.
But what makes you a good Patriot, I do think the word Patriot, it means something different.
So I would say you just do all the above, but then you have to tack on some civil service.
And I think that's pretty much it. That's what makes you very, or I guess you support all of
US's national interests a lot. That would be like kind of next level. Like I think at the baseline,
if you're the good American, you don't have to necessarily partake in civil service,
although you should, but you don't have to, but then you have, and you don't have to outwardly
support all of the US national interests. But I think if you want to be like a Patriot, you know,
if you care about that title, then you probably should be. Anyways, let me know what you guys
think. I mean, overall, I feel like my points, it's not race-based, it's not religion-based,
it's not any of the, you can be from any other country, but that's what I think makes people
good Americans. And you know, so this whole debate, I don't know. You guys let me know in
the comments down below what you think. What else am I missing? You know, you can't have a laundry
list of too long, right? But you got to have some points, you got to have some metrics, you got to
have some type of standards, you know what I'm saying? But anyways, shout out to the Asian
American Foundation for social tracking of Asian Americans in the US status report. They release
one every year. I thought it's important to discuss, but yeah, let me know what you guys
think. And until next time, I'm out. Peace.