Which is better - oiled or oilless shop or worksite air compressors? You can get either readily, but which type is the best investment?
#compressors #oillesscompressors #singlestagecompressor
You can buy both oilless and oil-lubricated compressors for the worksite and shop. I’ve had an oilless unit for over 5 years and recently replaced it with an oiled version after weighing the price point and life of the equipment.
Oilless units use plastic and low-friction coatings to reduce friction and association wear on moving parts. They tend to run at higher speeds, directly off the motor shaft. They are entirely dependent on air movement for cooling. Because the components that form the air pump on an oilless unit are not entirely encased in the pump, they typically generate more sound (noise) when they are running than an oil-lubricated unit will.
The larger the unit for average shop applications, the more likely the compressor will have an oil-lubricated air pump. That’s fine with me!
I like the fact that I can change the oil as needed, that the pump runs at a lower RPM, is quieter and lower-pitched than an oilless unit, the pump is more durable and runs at lower operating temperatures than its oilless counterpart.
Why the lower operating temperature? There are 3 reasons:
Lower RPM. There is a small pulley on the motor shaft and a large combo pulley fan on the air pump shaft. Because the piston or pistons that create air pressure are usually larger than on oilless units, a large amount of air is pressurized in a short time. High RPMs are not needed to get the same results.
Larger Cooling Fan. As mentioned, the air pump pulley is also a sizable air fan that moves a significant amount of air across the heat dissipation fins of the air pump. Lower temps mean longer life. It’s as simple as that.
The oil does a better job of lubrication AND acts as a coolant. Non-detergent compressor oil is very efficient in keeping all the operating surfaces inside the air pump coated and will not as readily mix with water as detergent oil will. Efficient lubrication reduces friction - so less heat. That’s not all though. The oil itself, as it moves around the air pump’s oil sump, cylinder walls, crankshaft, piston connecting arms, etc., also acts as a coolant and transports heat away from the pump’s “hot spots” and dissipates it to cooler areas in the pump.
Overall, the oiled unit is heavier construction, including a cast-iron air pump case and better motor. Our compressor will be set up as a stationary unit, and we are enhancing the unit further by installing a higher capacity air filter, a valved drain line for the air pump oil (to make oil changes easier and cleaner), and an air tank drain valve extension to make it ultra-easy to drain condensate out of the air tank every few days of operation.
You can see those enhancements by visiting this link:
COMING SOON!
With all that the oiled compressors have going for them, they are my first choice for our shop compressor.
Just Do It Yourself!
[Music]
hey dirtfarmer J here from dirtfarmer
j.com you've probably seen out in the
tool stores both oil lubricated air
compressors as well as
oiless is there really a difference yeah
there is let me tell you all about it
stay
[Music]
tuned hey dir farmer J here from dir
farmer j.com are you in the market for
an air compressor and you're trying to
make a decision of whether to use an oil
lubricated compressor like this uh
DeWalt unit or going with a oilist type
of compressor now this is a little bit
older one but there are a lot of them
out in the market now you'll see them as
C uh pancake compressors smaller
compressors and they look pretty
compelling and the price point is very
nice usually compared to a larger one or
with the oil ones but let's compare them
side by side so why are they oil oiless
well uh one of the things they're trying
to do is not have you have oil in a sump
like here uh that is out on the job side
or can leak out or if the compressor
ends up on its side or tilt it over uh
you don't have a problem with oil going
where it shouldn't uh that's certainly
something that is a benefit um the
second thing is lubrication from these
oiless type of compressors comes from
Teflon coating
uh slippery
surfaces uh areas that don't need to be
lubricated aren't bathed in oil Plastics
that sort of thing so um that's how they
accomplish it but there's some tradeoffs
number one with that initial purchase
price being lower over the long hul the
oilist does not last as long uh at least
in these types of units uh job site
compressors small shop areas and that
sort of thing there's industrial units
that's a whole different game so we're
not covering that here but these will
not last as long as these for a couple
reasons one temperatures are totally
different operating temperatures in uh
the compressor head itself secondly oil
itself acts as a coolant it is actually
pulling heat away from the head bathing
everything here and the fan is carrying
it off this is not as efficient because
it's just um depending entirely on air
movement to remove it the third tradeoff
is noise level this unit runs
substantially quieter than this unit so
I'm going to put the shrouds back on
this in a moment so we're comparing
Apples to Apples on sound output and
you'll be able to see on the DB meter
the difference in sound level between
this type of unit and this unit but
before we do that I want you to take a
closeup where I'm going to hand rotate
this so you can see the workings and
then we're going to turn it on also
without the shrouds you so you can see
how this is working and then we'll show
you a diagram of this one over here so
you can kind of see the difference of
how they're both accomplishing
pressurization of air so let's go ahead
and take a closeup of this
unit okay I'm going to hand rotate the
uh the fan unit here which is kind of an
unusual setup itself in that um it uh
just the way it's moving air is a little
bit suspect it this is more like beating
the air but what's connected to it is
the lower end of um the counter weights
on the crankshaft the connecting rod to
a little piston that's exposed in this
sleeve and you can hear this is oiless
but over time it clearly could use some
lubrication so you can see the workings
of it as I rotate it by hand right there
well let's go ahead and turn it on and
you'll see how fast it operates and
therefore it's also going to generate
higher levels of sound let's give it a
shot all right let's turn on see what we
get pretty darn noisy what do you
say another difference that is really
apparent is just looking in how these
operate the oiless unit uses a single
smaller piston whereas a unit like this
this particular one has two Pistons as
you can see in the diagram and just the
size of the two different heads is quite
notable uh both on the intake and the uh
output side of how much work each stroke
is having to do do therefore this one
can run at a lower RPM therefore
reducing wear and tear on the mechanism
and lowering the sound that it creates
all right let's go ahead and take it the
sound output difference between this
unit the oiled unit and the oiless okay
let's see what
happen
around 100 DB now let's go over and take
a look at this
one so the bottom line is if you have
the budget and you're going to do some
kind of air compressor system that
perhaps is in your garage or shop where
mostly the unit is stationary or is set
up to be stationary I would definitely
go the oil lubricated kind simply
because it's going to last longer it's
quieter uh you can change out the oil on
a regular basis at a good maintenance
interval and just keep the equipment
running a lot longer uh the noise levels
are significant during the filming here
uh Rob who is H the camera and I
attempted to have several
conversations why we would run this and
while we would run that and you could
see the DB levels but the sound level
from a perception size is notable this
we're able to hold a uh a level of
conversation about the same level I'm
talking to you right now whereas over
here we were yelling at each other to
make it clear over the top so there is a
notable difference and if you want to be
a more comfortable and safer in your
shop um this is the way to go versus
that one we used this DeWalt compressor
as the model for our discussion between
the uh comparison between the two types
but if you'd like to know more about
this compressor check out this video
here where we did a product review on
this and feature some of the things that
are really cool on this take a look at
it and while you're at it check out this
other video that YouTube thinks is
perfectly up your alley your interest
check it out and we'd like it if you
watch it too until the next time this is
dirtfarmer J with dirtfarmer
j.com