Lecture 27-Solution Thermodynamics-I

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
Dec 5, 2023
Solution Thermodynamics-I
Welcome, so in the last class we have been discussing about the Monte Carlo and molecular
dynamics simulations and I ended up saying about the thermodynamics, I would say some
thermodynamic concepts that we discussed in the context of simulations. So today I will
build up on that further to discuss what is known as a solution thermodynamics and based
on that we will develop the thermodynamics of polymer solutions, so just to put you put
this in context what we have discussed earlier in the very beginning where like the models
of a random walk that we applied to a single polymer chain, after this I have discussed
different cases where we have some interaction between segments like good solvent or poor
solvent cases but again you are looking at a single polymer chain.
So now I want to take a slightly zoomed out view a look at the behaviour of a solution
and by behaviour I really mean a macroscopic behaviour to begin with and then will come
back to a microscopic model for that behaviour of polymer solutions, but let us say we are
zooming out and we do not look at a polymer chain, we look at the solution of polymer
chains that is contained in there so it is very microscopic or macroscopic compared to
the view that we had earlier. Ok.
Before that let me just recap some idea of thermodynamics of simple solutions that does
not contain polymer right. So let us think about a liquid solution
and for the sake of simplicity let us say there are only 2 components that we call solute
and solvent, these are my 2 components and it is in a single phase liquid to begin with.
Ok. We will come back to the idea about the phases in a moment, but let us say it is single
phase liquid to begin with, then in that case if I use Gibbs phase rule it tells me a number
of intensive variables I need to specify in order to get thermodynamic behaviour of system,
number of intensive variable required to specify thermodynamic behaviour of system and this
case C is the number of components which is 2, P is the number of phases which is 1, so
we get 3, so we can have 3 intensive variables which will perfectly characterize the system.
Now we can make various choices again keeping in mind the idea that we discuss regarding
the conjugate variables. So let us say I pick temperature, pressure and composition. So
the composition I can specify in 2 ways. I can say either in terms of number of solute
and number of solvent, so we are refer solute as P, the solvent as S, but now if I say in
terms of number of molecules then these 2 are not intensive, therefore extensive variables.
If I want to use an intensive variable we can just define a mole fraction or a volume
fraction that will be intensive. So this will be like extensive and this can be intensive.
So we can either the specified (T,P, x) or we can specify (T, P, NP, NS) because using
NP,NS I can find x ok essentially we only need 3 intensive variables. So if I am given
both NP and NS that is the number of molecules of solute and solvent I can get the x that
is the mole fraction.
So now the relevant energy function in this case is the Gibbs free energy which I can
write in terms of Helmholtz free energy and for the reasons we will discuss in a moment,
so the Gibbs free energy can be written like A+PV where A here is the function of (NP,
NS, T,V )+ PV okay. So now we will note hear that I will do we started with a Gibbs free
energy which was a function of temperature pressure and composition. If I write in terms
of the temperature, volume and composition that is if use the Helmholtz free energy of
course I can separate out the PV term or it gives me certain mathematical convenience,
certain mathematical convenience when I am when I am doing this and I will elaborate
on that in this lecture.
So before this, if I want to define the volume fraction
of solute I can find it as something like the following, where Vp and Vs are specific
volumes of solute and solvent molecules.
So keep in mind that we do not refer to the actual volume of molecules because it is actually
what does what you mean anyway, let us say we have water, how do we define its volume,
is it the volume of electron cloud, is it some sort of a volume occupied the molecule
it is very arbitrary concept. So the way we are defining a specific volume is the change
in a volume if I add a molecule of water to a certain volume and it is present already.
So this is defined as a change in volume not as a volume of the molecule itself, it makes
some difference in the actual meaning, what it means is that it can be dependent on the
composition, the change in volume may be different by adding one molecule if I add in say a solvent
that is favourable to that molecule for a solvent that is not favourable, will come
back to this later but the basic idea is that we defined VP as douV/douNp the change in
volume, if I change, if I keep temperature, pressure and number of solvent molecules fixed,
if I add a molecule of solute. It can be different, a dilute solution compare to a concentrate
solution because change in volume may in turn depend on the interactions present inside
the system. Ok.
Similarly I can define VS as the following.
So with this particular means some specific volumes we can talk in terms of volume fraction
of solute of course for solvent it has to be 1-ϕ because both of them must add to 1
because there is no void its is either containing a solute or containing solvent.
So now although I have just said than VP and VS can be not constant, it can differ with
the concentration and so on we will now assume that let us what happens when they are constant.
It is an assumption until so far what we are doing is somewhat rigorous now what we are
making is an assumption so we assume that VP and VS are constant. So now by the way
before I do this I can write my volume V as Vp Np+VsNs and this is also quite general,
it is before the assumption that I am just made.
So if the Vp and Vs are constant then for a constant value of Np and Ns the volume is
also constant. Ok, because if Vp and Vs are constant here NpNs is anyway constant. So
V will be constant, what this means is the solution is what is known as an incompressible
volume because there is no pressure here in the expression I am writing of course the
pressure may appear in actual definition of specific volumes but if I ignore that in that
case what I am assuming is that the specific volumes are constant that means volume is
constant and when the volume is constant the system is considered incompressible so the
pressure does not change the volume. So although pressure and volume are conjugate variables
and they should work in terms of either P or V. Since we assume V to be constant, it
does not matter I can work in terms of both P and V. I can equivalently work in Helmholtz
free energy as I can do in work in terms of Gibbs free energy and that is the reason why
we use the Helmholtz free energy because it will simpler for the analysis that we will
do.
So now going back to where we started with I wrote G as a function of this which is PV+A
(Ns, Np, V, T,) V is anyway a constant here. So I can write it as
so we gotten rid of one variable because volume is constant.
So now if I look at this particular A term then A is also an extensive variable because
energy will change if the quantity of matter will change, energy is extensive, so now what
it means is since A is extensive, I can write if I take alpha times number of molecules
of both solute and solvent as I get an energy that is alpha times the case we started with.
Ok. Just a mathematical trick that will give you some dividend in a moment.
So now I can set alpha as say VP/V, so one I will have A(NpVp/V), now let us recall from
here, then this is same as ϕ because denominator is capital V here. So we have a ϕ appearing
here. This term if you notice carefully so there was no alpha here, if we notice carefully
I can write it as Vp/Vs multiplies by NsVs/V. Now this term inside the bracket is (1-ϕ),
so we have Vp/Vs 1-ϕ.
I will note down like what do you have in the left hand side, the first 2 terms I have
represented as a function of ϕ and temperature because VpVS anyway constant so this term
is anyway constant so I can write it as a function of ϕ and temperature, so we have
reduced one more variable you no longer talk about the number of molecules of solute and
solvent. I talk about the volume fraction of solute and then what I can write is A of
(NpNsT) =volume times some function of ϕT where basically I consume the factor Vp by
dividing by A and call that thing F. So the basic idea is I am writing the Helmholtz free
energy in terms of something we can refer to as Helmholtz free energy density.
The ( ϕ f of ϕ T) will referred as Helmholtz free energy density that simply means that
if I multiply by volume I will get the Helmholtz free energy. So going back here my G is now
PV+V multiplied by f of phiT which means ok.
So now I have a simple expression of the Gibbs free energy of the system in terms of PV terms
and something that we refer to as the Helmholtz free energy density, we do not know what is
the functional form of that f (ϕ,T) yet, but we can I will show you that why is that
particular form is very convenient to look at the mixing behaviour and the phase separation
behaviour of the systems.
Before this let us define what do I mean by mixing and phase separation. So let us say
if I start with 2 volumes of containers containing different volumes and different amounts of
the solute, let us see the first one has a volume V1, the other one has a volume V2 and
they have volume fraction of solute ϕ1 and ϕ2. If I add them together
we may form a new volume V with a net volume fraction ϕ. This only happen if the system
has a tendency to mix on the other hand if somehow even if I manage to mix a system to
have a certain volume fraction ϕ and volume V but the system does not have a tendency
to remain homogenous or remain in the mixed state, it will phase separate ok essentially
we not we do not always draw it within the same beaker just to demonstrate that they
are the different layers of volume that you can have. So, one of them you can call a concentrate,
other one you can come later dilute phase there are other things are basically we can
talk in terms of equality of chemical potential in the two phases when we discuss the phase
separation. The basic idea that I want to point out here is the system phase separates
to two phases.
So now the question is how does the function that we have derived does the Gibbs free energy
that was in terms of Helmholtz free energy density f ( ϕ,T) so how does this function
f( ϕ,T) can characterize the mixing and phase behaviour. What should be the form of the
function that will give you a mixing behaviour in systems what will be the form that will
give you a phase separation behaviour?
First of all before this we want to know whether that function is sufficient to characterize
the mixing and phase separation behaviour or not. We will see like when this mixing
or separation will occur, what is the criteria for that to happen. So if for example we look
at the first situation Helmholtz energy of the system is V1fϕ1 and if I say the pressure
is P then we have PV1+V1P1 as a Gibbs free energy just call it G1. Then similarly for
the second liquid we have V2p+V2f of ϕ2 and if they come together and form a homogeneous
phase we have G3=VP+V f (ϕ). We are assuming that it is happening at a constant temperature
such that we can write f (ϕ,T) as simply f (ϕ).
So now we know from thermodynamics that the process will be favoured if the resulting
Gibbs free energy will be less than the sum of the Gibbs free energy of the phases that
I have a mixed together that means- VP+Vf(ϕ) must be less than V1P+V1f (ϕ1) + V2P+V2f
(ϕ2).
The first thing to note here is since the volumes assume to be constant when I add them
together V1+V2 become equal to V, that means specific volume is assume to be constant.
So what this means is I can really cancel out these 3 terms what I am left with is basically
a term containing only the Helmholtz free energy density. So the mixing will happen
if this is the case or if I divide by V I can say mixing will happen
if we have so X1=V1/V for mixing.
Similar idea we can apply to phase separation so for phase separation you should have to
V f(ϕ) now the final state is phase separated which has 2 phases the energy in the states
will be lesser than the energy in the homogenous state. So this should be higher than so called
it as A, or I can say just small detail here or another idea the
volume of the two phases has to be different must be Va and Vb so now we have where xa=Va/Vb
ok.
So now we have a simple mathematical relation in terms of the function ϕ that characterizes
the mixing and separation behaviour. We haven’t yet discussed what the mathematical form is,
but we have already discussed what the mathematical form should be to have certain type of behaviour
that we can see. So the next class I will elaborate on this in more detail. Then I will
discuss that the other ideas that we discuss in thermodynamics like osmotic potential and
osmotic pressure and chemical potential. They can also be written in terms of this function
f(ϕ) for liquid solution and then finally we can extend the idea to polymers solution
and try to find what that function f is and based on that we can talk about the mixing
and phase behaviour in polymers solutions and other polymeric systems.
Thank you.
