mod12lec57

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
Dec 5, 2023
Reaction Feasibility based on Eh
[Music]
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
hello everyone so again welcome back to
a latest electro session so again let's
have a quick review of what we have been
up to in the last lecture session so I
guess right now or you know in Allah we
are now at the end of the course
right so we I just need to be able to
take a holistic approach to be able to
understand let's say quantitatively and
qualitatively any system that we look at
right and in that context to be able to
visualize that we looked at a particular
set of examples I believe over the last
three sessions right so let's just
quickly summarize them so we first set
we looked at one particular case where
we looked at no other reactions right
except redox obviously except the redox
right and we calculated the p-values for
two half reactions right except the
redox right and I think in the first in
this scenario we saw that I think you
know p1 was greater than p2 right and
from this you can then know that let's
say half reaction one will go as written
out as reduction right and the second
half reaction would need to proceed as
oxidation right but when we looked at
what do we say the example with respect
to the iron half reaction and considered
complexes right consider the formation
of complexes in conjunction with the
redox process right as in I believe we
have this particular half reaction right
Fe 3 plus plus l-tron goes to Fe 2 plus
this was our first half reaction right
so when we calculate this particular
p-value right so that's equal to P equal
to P naught right minus 1 by n1 electron
transfer right into log activity of Fe 2
plus right by Fe three-plus right this
is from our understanding of the ear
element system so when we looked at the
particular case when we concerned that
no complexes would be formed and we
would only have the redox reaction going
through right or the redox process
involved we saw that the PE 1
for this half-reaction was greater than
the p2 of the other reaction that we
considered right but with our knowledge
or the background that we had let's say
we know that we need to consider
complexes in this case because here you
have what do we say electron-poor
compounds here right again we have
complexes here that can be formed right
both with respect to or with Fe 2 plus
and the fe 3 plus cations right so when
we looked at that and then we calculated
that though we saw that P 1 was actually
less than P 2 right so what does that
mean one would proceed as oxidation
right and 2 that the second half
reaction would proceed as reduction or
as written right and again what does
this mean now what does this chain mean
that now Fe 2 plus will act as the
reducing agent and reduce the other
relevant compound right and reduce the
target let's see let me read that there
I guess yes this was the other scenario
we looked at but let's say the final
scenario that look we looked at let's
say that approach what you would expect
out there in the system was you know we
considered the formation of a solid or
precipitation - right so obviously out
there in the nature you would have
precipitation you would have complex
formation and redox process all you know
occurring simultaneously and obviously
the relevant acid-base reactions - so
when we calculated that for that
particular scenario or analyzed that
particular scenario right we had what do
we say now precipitation we looked at or
consider complexes right and obviously
in conjunction with the redox process we
saw that p1 was far less than p2 right
indicating that for those conditions Fe
2 plus is a strong reducing agent right
so I guess hopefully this approach right
or these sets of examples should have
helped illustrate what we have been
trying to understand since the last
couple of months I guess right so
as in you know all these chemical
process that we have discussed as for
the acid base complex formation redox
right precipitation they go hand in hand
and are interlinked right so it's a fine
balance between all these process
obviously at equilibrium right so we've
looked at these aspects right and now we
are going to move on to what we say the
eh approach right until now we looked at
understanding the relevant redox process
from the context of P right which is
minus log activity of the electron right
and understood the relevant aspects are
analyze the relevant aspects but you
know in general two people are you might
have heard of about the electrochemical
cells or in general I guess you might
have heard of me referring to P as are
the P naught values has Redux potentials
well that's slightly erroneous though
you know when we say redox potential
it's actually eh values that we are
talking about right again
electrochemical cells these are relevant
to the electrochemical cells right so we
are going to discuss these aspects right
again before we go further right again
similar to what we have done thus far
with each of the process we will also
briefly look at let's say how to set up
these what do we say equations to be
able to solve for the system at
equilibrium right by hand now again we
are going to have a very brief outlook
again and the reason being that as you
know in redox process mostly it's the
kinetic aspects that are relevant these
aspects that we are analyzing P you know
and such are using the women tech to be
able to understand the system will only
tell you what you would expect let's say
F equilibrium is reached right now what
are the conditions prevailing let's say
reducing conditions or oxidizing
conditions are such that would prevail
if equilibrium is reached right but
again keep as we know right the can't
explain here oh and you know we should
be careful and you know looking at
analyzing the system just looking at the
p values right for example in this
particular case or the example value we
looked at just because we say that fe 2
plus is a strong reducing agent and will
reduce the other compound doesn't mean
that it can go through right because the
kinetics can be relatively slow right
but at least you will be able to
understand you know which compound would
act as a reducing agent and third which
compound would be ready
and tears and so on right at least that
will help you understand the system yes
second we are going to have a very brief
outlook right with respect how to solve
it so I guess the general approach how
have we solved all these equilibrium
problems now right the general approach
what was that now right how we solve the
equilibrium relevant aspects now right
we always looked at our component valves
model right so similarly to here we can
follow the component balance so let's
say if I am looking at this particular
set of example though so what can the
possible components be right so you
usually would have chosen fe 3 plus and
fe 2 plus though right but how would you
you know account for these redox
reactions though right so in such a case
right you will choose your Ultron as one
of the components - right but you will
consider that obviously let's say the
relevant concentrations of these
electrons are relatively low right or
negligible but you know choosing these
electrons as one of your what do we say
components let's say well help analyze
ee or under you know calculate the
system i guess right or it will help in
getting at the system but obviously
again then you need to what do we say
look at man plating the other two
components - right and how does women
take calculate this again with respect
to women take right what is this
software about or what will this help
give me an understand understanding
about again keep in mind that women tech
doesn't give you an any idea about how
fast or slow the reactions are women
take is software that we can use to
understand what the system would be if
if and only if the system reaches
equilibrium right so when you try to use
women tech or utilize women tech to
analyze these redox what you say process
right or redox reactions that's
something to keep in mind that you are
only understanding the systems that
would are the conditions that would
prevail at equilibrium but again that
the kind exploited roles so that's
something you need to be able to
calculate looking at the relevant rate
constants or such right so we will take
though again I guess the aspects here
are obviously it will choose V Fe 3 plus
Fe 2 plus
and what we cellphone as components
right but I guess something that I
haven't mentioned out here the issue is
that if this is written as DS right with
such formation equations right you see
you can form one of your components from
the other two components which hits at
one of the fundamental what do we say
aspects of our what do we say now our
component balance equations right so how
do we how how does women take go about
this now right to be able to get out of
this particular what you say quandary I
guess you know women take introduces a
dummy variable right you know Fe
three-plus
Y Fe 2 plus X is your dummy variable
right and it now let's say uses this as
a particular what do we say way to be
able to help them solve the relevant
aspects as in let's say what will your
total electron balance be it's going to
be equal to let's say X or the Fe 3 plus
if you 2 plus right and if their other
target compounds let's say arsenic 5 to
arsenic 3 for the relevant half reaction
plus so on and so forth so how will this
Ultron transfer or the total electron
dance work now so let's say if the
Ultron's are being donated from this
particular half reaction to this
particular half reaction right so then
this particular term will be positive
and this will be negative and so on
right and again why is that because the
electrons are being what do we say or Fe
2 plus that says acting as a reducing
agent in this case right so then that's
donating electrons so X in this case
would be your the dummy variable here
with respect to the balance of the
electron would be positive here and 1
with respect to the arsenic which
receives let's say and this is oxidation
state 5 for arsenic if that's not clear
would be negative here right and Thurs
it would help understand or analyze the
system so similarly again if I am
writing Fe 2 plus total bounce it would
be Fe 2 plus relevant components not
component species with respect to the
complexes right and also let's say X Fe
3 plus by Fe 2 plus right
and so on right so again with respect to
a few three plus two it will be I guess
the net to their right and so the third
you know women take helps or you know
tries to what we say arrive at the
solution right so again such a brief
outlook is good enough for us right so
once you understand the approach you can
get that done if necessary but obviously
we will take will cut down on the time
so now we are going to move on to the
next aspect that we have talked about
which is the EH approach right until now
we have looked at the P approach to
understand the system and the relevant
aspects but again in an one mental
process or such you might have looked at
people looking at electrochemical cells
or such for promoting or propagating
certain kinds of reactions or such or
utilizing the relevant transfer of
electrons and what well manner I guess
right so in that context I guess right
you eh approach is worthwhile because it
helps you understand the system in a
better than that right
they are the electric potential here
let's see so let's see what this is
about but before we go further we need
to understand a few aspects here again
keep in mind that everything boils down
to one particular aslan let's say a
bonfire clove aspect as in every system
let's say or every process would be
driven by the sole motive of decreasing
its energy or the energy of the system
would want to be decreased now and this
is something we looked at in our initial
classes right when we looked at I guess
the Gibbs energy of the system right or
Gibbs energy of the mixtures right you
saw that it is always driven towards you
know being at its lowest possible state
or value right so again keep that in
mind when we work out these aspects so
just to what we say refresh your memory
if you remember this we had Delta G
naught right was equal to what we said
no minus RT natural logarithm of K K
here is the equilibrium constant
obviously right so I'm just trying to
illustrate an approach where we are
going to be able to try to like that say
the Gibbs energy of this system let's
say with the p value or molar Gibbs
energy of the electron let's say to be
more specific at
standard conditions to the p-value right
let's see how we can arrive at that
particular aspect so if people can
refresh their memory we looked at this
fundamental what do we say equation or
neuron let's say are very early in the
what do we say class right and let's
consider this particular what do we say
half reaction let's say right plus
Ultron goes to h2 right this is going to
be gas and this is in general the
reference what do we say half reaction
right so the equilibrium constant for
this would be let's say equal to one
let's say and now how do I calculate the
molar Gibbs energy of this particular
what do we say out on here right at
standard condition circuit molar or
standard molar Gibbs energy of this
particular electron how can I calculate
that now right so if people remember
that right this was based upon your
particular what do we say analysis as in
the Delta G of the reaction at the
standard conditions was equal to the
stoichiometric coefficient right times
the chemical potential right of the
products summation minus that of the
reactants right and again chemical
potential was nothing but also equal to
the molar Gibbs energy of that
particular element or compound molar
Gibbs energy of formation if required
right so how do we apply this - this / -
equation now here it's going to be 1/2
times Gibbs
formation let's say start condition h2
right hydrogen in the gaseous state
- that off let's say what do we have
here of that of H+ right - that of the
electron again one is the stoichiometric
coefficient here right but again these
are the elements here let's say right
and Thurs these two values would be
equal to zero right
and here we know Delta G of this / -
reaction was equal to minus RT natural
logarithm of K right and the equilibrium
constant for this is set as 1 this is
the rougher
half reaction rate so this value would
also be equal to zero now right so now
what do we have here though I guess the
G naught is equal to zero right so again
taking this further right similar to our
mu I at non-standard conditions is equal
to MU I naught right plus RT natural log
them into activity of that particular
compound this is M the particular what
do we see a equation that we analyzed
when we looked at trying to calculate
the chemical potential of the system at
non-standard conditions right when the
activity was no more equal to one so
that's the case that we have here so if
I apply this out here let's say so the
molar Gibbs energy of the let's say the
particular electron but no more at the
standard condition will be equal to that
at the standard condition plus RT
natural or damoff activity of the third
time right so as we just looked at this
particular value is equal to zero so now
I can simplify my system right and write
this particular molar Gibbs energy of
the electron to be minus 2.303 right RT
times P P right and simplifying this
further let's say looks like it can be
written as minus five point seven one
kilo joules per mole times PE right
again I know we are just illustrating
these what do we say you know
derivations here but just try to
understand the system here right so here
what we have what we are finally up to
or what the take-home message here is
that I can relate P which is used me a
measure of the activity of the electron
to the molar Gibbs energy of the
electron here right so that will then
again help me understand let's say if
let's say a particular electron you know
our molar Gibbs energy of particle one
is at a higher state let's say higher
energy state so I guess how would the
reactions proceed now the reaction
should proceed in such a way that the
energy would decrease right so you know
keep this in mind when we try to
understand the relevant system later so
here in such a manner right we can
relate the
Gibbs energy of this particular electron
let's say in particular system with
respect to the P of that particular half
reaction right so let's move on let's
see before we go further I guess there
is one other aspect that I need to write
up here so another approach that we need
to also consider obviously is the eh
approach say again here we people might
be familiar with this concept of P right
or the molar electrical energy right and
that's going to be equal to the product
of the charge electric potential and
Faraday's constant right molar
electrical energy charge electric
potential and Faraday's constant right
so it's so more or less equal to
potential energy is equal to let's say
MGH areas right you know that's an
analogy here yes what hatch would be
similar to or analogous to what do we
say now the electric potential here and
constant and constant here and mass here
would will be with respect to charge so
applying this with respect to our
particular electron let's see how can we
write this as bar is equal to charge for
the electron will be equal to minus 1 so
f times here we have the potential right
electric potential
so from this right what do we have here
H is equal to minus G bar by EF right
and again looking at the relevant
equation that we have here what how can
we write this as that's going to be
equal to plus two point three zero three
RT by F into PE right so here from this
particular setup right we now have what
we say let's say if we have a particular
value let's say P we can calculate the
redox potential let's say or the H
values right or we can calculate the
molar Gibbs energies of these particular
electrons let's say in that system right
so again keep in mind that here we
looked at the relevant aspects with
respect to the energy right here right
and the take-home message here would be
that when you look at or try to
understand the system you see to it that
the system would always move in such a
direction as to decrease the energy
the system right so again in the same
case here let's say we looked at a
relevant aspect here as in with respect
to the molar electrical energy right and
looked at that approach to be able to
calculate your docks potential in terms
of the PE values or the molar Gibbs
energy of the electron and we don't need
to mark up these what do we say what we
say little derivation that we are looked
at or minor derivations we have looked
at pardon me but keep the background in
mind so now I guess we are going to
obviously try to link what we have been
up to so here we are going to look at
two half reactions right so here we have
two half reactions s 4 4 2 - being
reduced to H 2 s right and also H 4 CL
right being reduced to CL - and here we
also have the log K and the P naught
values for these relevant half reactions
here right again what do we have here we
have the relevant half reactions here
obviously the standard form is to write
the mass reduction for ease of
understanding we have written them as
one electron transfer both of them we
have written them as one electron
transfer right so again here it's H was
here what do we say being what we say
reduce to CL - you can obviously look at
the relevant redox not read ox pardon me
oxidation states right so here let's say
we are going to first understand the
system in terms of what we have
discussed as for us and try to
understand it in terms of the P naught
values that we have looked at right
which we have here and we are going to
understand this graphically and it
should hopefully help understand the
system or visualize the system in a
better manner and at the same time we
are also going to look at the molar
Gibbs energy of the particular electron
and the redox potential here let's see
so let's say I guess I have a graph here
right so I have graph here and here we
have h fo CL + CL - in their standard
states so these would correspond to the
P naught values obviously right and here
we have 4 H 4 CL + CL - right here it's
how your p naught value 25.1 and for the
other half reaction it was five points
zero eight so for the redox couple hich
was yell and cl- the p naught value
twenty five point one is higher
the peanut 2 value let's say right 5.08
for the redox couple s4 for 2 minus and
h2s so at the standard state at the
standard state the molar Gibbs energy of
this particular electron let's say in
equilibrium with the redox couple H was
real and Cl minus would be at a lower
energy state right compared to the
electron in equilibrium with the redox
couple between s4 4 to minus and h2s
right so what does that tell you now in
which direction let's say would the
reaction proceed let's see if it were at
standard conditions now let's see
current conditions again as in
temperature 25 degree centigrade
pressure and the activity is being equal
to 1 right in what direction we would
proceed now again keep in mind that in a
way that the energy would decrease right
thousand the it would the electron
transfer would take place from this
couple to the other couple right the
energy is higher here it would want to
travel from the higher energy state
towards the lower energy state right so
let's try to understand the system in
terms of what we have discussed earlier
in terms of the PE now so if you
remember when we looked at or analyzed
the system in terms of P we said that if
P of 1 is greater than P of 2 right what
did we have or what we understand about
that now we mentioned that one would
proceed as reduction right reduction and
the other one would proceed as oxidation
so let's just try to visualize that here
what would that mean that would mean
here that H was CL will be reduced to CL
- right and how will it be reduced by by
h2 s right by h2 s right so here what
have you written now 1 is written as
reduction right
this is reduction here I mean I'm
obviously not writing down the
bounce-off reaction here and 2 will be
will go through as oxidation so what's
happening here if you look at the
combined system here h2s will end up
reducing h4 co2 CL minus and again you
know two aspects to understand here one
was that p1 not right is greater than p2
not and in that case we understood or we
looked at the real
generations too I believe right
especially with respect to p1 anyway
that one would go through a reduction to
as oxidation and again now here we can
understand it in terms of the molar
Gibbs energy of the electron and that it
would travel from let's say higher
energy state to the lower energy state
right but obviously this is that this
standard state right let's look at what
it would be let's say if it said non
standard state so for that condition
let's say we are going to consider pH to
be at 7 and I believe the example we are
going to look at is going to be H for Co
to be at 10 power minus 4 activity and
cl- to be at 10 power minus 3 and s 4 4
to minus and h 2 s both to be at at 10
power minus 3 right and how can we
calculate the p values now P 1 and P 2
right so obviously as we know the
general half reaction is P 1 equal to P
1 not minus 1 by n and being the number
of electrons being transferred times log
Q - right
and Q Dash is nothing but activity of
the compounds in the reduced form right
by the oxidized right so in this
particular half reaction what would it
be I guess the p value would be equal to
right P naught would be equal to 5 point
0 8 minus 1 by n only one electron
transfer right 1 log Q - right so what
would that be here so H 2 s power of 1
by 8 by s 4 for 2 - rise to the power of
1 by 8 and obviously because we have H+
here - we need to consider that H+ to
the power of 5 by 4 let's say right and
in this particular case it would be PE
is equal to P naught is twenty five
point one right - log Q - 1 by n again
the number of electrons being
transferred is 1 so it's going to be 1
times the reduced form right
cl- ^ 1/2 activity of water is 1 + / H
was he'll rise to power off at
stoichiometric coefficient half and
again hatch + rise to the power of its
stoichiometric coefficient 1/2 right so
from here we can calculate the p values
rate and let's see what the system would
be so here I have the calculated p-value
for these two redox couples as in H was
yield and cl- as for for - - and H 2 s
and at pH 7 and 10 power minus 4 and 10
power minus 3 respectively
concentrations for H was CL + CL - and P
at 7 and 10 power minus 3 for both these
couples here not both these couples
pardon me for the couple of s 4 4 2 - n
H 2 s so here we have the P values not
the P naught values so here we have 21.1
and once we have the p value you know
that you can calculate the molar Gibbs
energy of the electron right and again
how you can relate that to the redox
potential and same case here we can
calculate or we are able to calculate
the p value molar Gibbs energy and again
the redox potential right so let's try
to understand this in terms of what we
had earlier let's say as in the standard
conditions right so let's look at the
standard conditions so these were the
standard conditions right and these were
rd or at the non standard conditions of
pH 7 and 10 power minus 3 and 10 power
minus 4 concentration say again standard
conditions
- non standard conditions right again
from here and looking at let's say the P
values or such you can understand in
which direction they are which
particular what we say compound or the
reduced form would predominate or
oxidized form would predominate right in
relation to PE minus P naught right so
in one of the earlier classes right we
looked at how let's say similar to pH
and PKA by comparing the p values with
respect to P naught we could understand
let's say which particular compound
would predominate let's just try to you
know also the throw a stone at that
particular aspect here so if I am
looking at this particular what do we
say a couple H was CL and Cl minus
so PE here is 21 point 1 and P naught is
twenty five point one right so similar
to that pH and PKA graph right so what
would it be like obviously there's H+
involved here too so that's going to be
slightly a ruinous in trying to
understand that here but that's fine
here so if P naught is twenty five point
one right and P is to the left of it or
less than P not twenty one point one so
what which form would predominate now
right the one with the similar to the
acid base right the one with the proton
are here with the one with the Altran
are the reduced form would predominate
right so thirds in this case in this
non-standard condition the reduced form
or cl- would predominate right so same
case here again with respect to the
non-standard conditions in the
non-standard condition for s four four
two minus and h2s right what do we see
here
did we tablet that right twenty five
point one twenty-one yes so again here
two we see that P is less than P naught
right so again from the similar approach
of what we had earlier we will
understand that at the non-standard
conditions which one would predominate
now the reduced form or h2s would
predominate right again that just for
understanding the system and going back
to where we were we are now trying to
see in which direction let's say would
the reaction take place now at the
non-standard conditions right so earlier
we looked at these channel conditions
but rarely do we see or come across such
standard conditions so the non-standard
conditions the p values the molar gibbs
energy H values and so on or the redox
potentials and we again have the
relevant what we say values of the
activities and the pH values right so
similar to what we looked at with
respect to R with respect to our
standard conditions right
we will first analyze it with respect to
the P so here again PE one right let's
say I'll call this p1 and this p2 so p1
is now still greater than PE two right
so again what does that mean that means
that the first half reaction will go
through as reduction right as in H was
CL will be reduced to CL minus
and how will this reduction take place
now right and that will be taking place
because H 2 s will be oxidized oxidation
the second reaction half reaction will
go through as half reaction or h2s will
be oxidized to s were for - - in the
process this h2s will release electrons
which will be accepted by HOCl and then
be reduced to CL - right so that is from
the p1 or p2 approach here right so but
let's say try to understand let us try
to understand the system with respect to
the molar Gibbs energy of the outrun
here and here again you see that in the
redox couple right the electron that
would be in equilibrium with the redox
couple s 4 4 2 - and H 2 s the it's at a
higher energy state right and you see
that with the electron that's in
equilibrium with H was CL + CL - it's at
a lower energy state so again the
electron would want to transfer from
this couple to thee again this is a
layman's understanding I guess but more
or less here you can understand the
analogy with respect to the energy and
the system wanting to move in such a
direction that dmg decreases right so
from higher energy to lower energy state
and that's what you see here so the
electron transfer takes place from this
redox couple to this couple so that
means this couple is going to proceed in
oxidation or h2s is going to be oxidized
to s4 for 2 - in the process releasing
the electrons which would reduce your
particular H was here here right so here
I guess obviously now we should be able
to understand the relevant aspects in
terms of both the P values the molar
Gibbs energy system right and you know
if not immediately I guess now have the
intuition to be able to understand what
would happen in the system right so now
again in this context again you can look
at the docs potential to write as in
relative to the other so these aspects
we are going to start discussing in the
next session right as in the electro
chemical approach let's say and how are
what do we need to understand when we
look at a cell what's in an old what's
the cathode what takes place at that and
why is that relevant to us and so on
right and I guess with that I'll end
today's session and thank you
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
[Music]
