2 Video Views·Dec 4, 2023
El Salvador earthquake, Hurricane Mitch, Community participation, Red cross, Participatory design methodology, Progressive housing approach.
To access the translated content:
1. The translated content of this course is available in regional languages. For details please visit https://nptel.ac.in/translation
The video course content can be accessed in the form of regional language text transcripts, books which can be accessed under downloads of each course, subtitles in the video and Video Text Track below the video.
Your feedback is highly appreciated. Kindly fill this form https://forms.gle/XFZhSnHsCLML2LXA6
2. Regional language subtitles available for this course
To watch the subtitles in regional languages:
1. Click on the lecture under Course Details.
2. Play the video.
3. Now click on the Settings icon and a list of features will display
4. From that select the option Subtitles/CC.
5. Now select the Language from the available languages to read the subtitle in the regional language.
[Music]
[Music]
welcome to the cause disaster recovery
and build back better my name is RAM
Satish an assistant professor in
Department of Architecture and planning
IIT Roorkee today we are going to
discuss about the build back better
practices especially in the case of
progressive housing in algebra this is
also one of the important chapter which
has been compiled in the build back
better which has been edited by Michael
Ian sentir shillerman and come in
Dearborn and it is from the practice
side of it how they brought all the
lessons from practice and this is where
it's been edited by Carmen fairer and
Calvo with Concepcion heteros and Thomas
Maya so this is a chapter and we discuss
and how after 2001 at quake in and sabda
how the reconstruction activities have
started and what are the processes that
they have implemented and what are the
learnings we are taking back for that
how it has informed the other practices
also and in that region and it is also
giving us some kind of guidance what to
do and what not to do and how community
participation is also very relevant and
what are the stages of the participation
and what are the roles of each
organizations and there is a
participation partnership and also the
coordination and the supervision of it
so all these things collectively put
into the kind of management of the
project so many of you at least from the
Asian geographies many of you may not
have heard of Zelda which is the
smallest country in the Central America
so it is about the 48% of inhabitants of
al-sabah
live in the poverty or in extreme
poverty so it's almost if you look from
the North American and so so this is
where Assad comes and many of you have
to understand that the America the North
America and the foul
is very diverse even within North
America the very great diversity exists
and great challenges exist within the
North American region and in South
American though they have the richest
mining sector and there is just natural
beauty but they also have been unequally
distributed with various challenges
especially with the earthquakes which is
very common in South American caves in
other classes we have also discussed in
the case of Peru how it has been dealt
and today we are going to discuss about
the El Salto
so this particular disaster 2001 and
this has been destroying more than two
hundred thousand houses and already
there is all vulnerable component of
existing housing shortage you know plus
the earthquake the disaster adds on to
it so what are these existing shortages
existing vulnerabilities from 78 to 92
there's a very cruel civil war which has
killed more than 125,000 people and the
moment you are talking about a civil war
it has have impact on the economy and
the major infrastructures in 1986 then
again a severe earthquake has hit the
san salvador more than 40 thousand
houses has been destroyed and prior to
tyre 2001 in 1998 this hurricane mitch
has produced the serious floods killing
250 people and affecting the most
successful experiences of the
post-conflict reintegration process so
in 2001 again it has one is a major
earthquake which has been affected
within a span of 30 days it has affected
six points of religious scale earthquake
has been hated and about eighty-five
percent of the national territory has
been under impact and now you can see
here there's a multiple disaster being a
hilly areas a mountainous areas you can
see the landslides along with it not
only the earthquakes the ground is not
just moving around so he
landslides on the other side you have
the Hurricanes which is again so this is
a multiple hazard phenomenon which
existed in all served our geography and
one is after the earthquake
obviously with many NGOs come into the
big picture and they want to give their
helping hand or the support or the
technical expertise or a kind of
financial supports so that is how this
is the time different red cross
associations like one is a Spanish Red
Cross along with the Salvadoran Red
Cross how they have also associated with
in the Red Cross associations how they
have also associated with each other so
that they can learn from other know
practices which they have already
learned from different parts of the
globe so that is how they have come
together and they have come up with
rather than a courthouse in concept they
started with a progressive housing as a
solution because they have considered
different experiences what they have
learned and that is where they have come
up with a progressive solutions so one
is what is progressive approach these
are the houses developed in different
stages in incremental way right
and many people gets a core house
approach versus with the progressive
housing and a core house approach we
give a core dwelling unit and then
people add on to it so they try to make
in a kind of bigger like what you can
see here is you provide some basic
things and then people add on to it you
know like here the lives Andres work
which has been in the garage hold up and
you can see his work in Chile's of what
it has been provided and what the people
have made incremental e how they are
modified these places but here one has
to understand it's like the incremental
increment allottee is almost like 100
percent of increase but this is
something whether it is possible or not
that one has to look into it but whereas
in progressive approach
it is unlike the code willings not
making a house bigger but we're making a
house finished you know - the complete
manner that is the most important aspect
of the progressive approach and when the
first earthquake hit in 2001 the Spanish
Red Cross has created the special plan
for earthquakes in else after which is
cities in accordance with the plan of
action of Salvadorian Red Cross and
includes three phases one is the
emergency phase the stabilization and
the rehabilitation and humanitarian aid
and recovery and the reconstruction
phase which is the final phase so in the
emergency phase it talks about because
of the earthquake and landslides
removing the debris with search and
rescue and the first aids providing
health evacuations search some family
reunifications have been taken up a
relief delivery like food shelter the
basic needs the hygiene conditions the
epidemic an endemic disease controls in
the relief camps so this is a the whole
part contributes to emergency phase once
people gradually stabilize and
rehabilitation the humanitarian aid
phase this is where the global
strategies to cover basic needs of
displaced population in shelter water
and sanitation livelihood and also the
psychological support for mental health
and in recovery and the reconstruction
phase so it is a follow-up on to the
previous phase and this phase is
identification and definition of
projects to rebuild the houses of
infrastructure and as well as the
projects for community and the economic
development so now this is how they come
up with one is the various intervention
strategies how the partnership of this
Red Cross associations have brought
together and one is they had two options
of rent resettlement with the
tractor built approach and
reconstruction with the progressive
housing approach how they come together
and how they make it in a progressive
approach one is in the rebuilding
process they have given one of the
important aspect is becoming the
participatory aspect and the community
and it has to be a continuous process it
is not that the important lesson they
learned is you deliver and you move away
so it has to be a continuous effort how
one can raise their capacities and take
it in a continuous approach
environmental protection and the
sensitivity to cultural factors so it
didn't just only this progress to
approach it didn't ended only with
construction of the dwelling but the
virginal design was conceived so that it
can be extended and improved by the
users in their own time depending on
their resources and needs so how they
can expand with their own feasibilities
on the resources so there are some
general guiding principles of this
progressing housing approach the houses
were built on the same land on which
they have existed before the earthquakes
one of the reason they have to think
about this because first of all they
should make sure that this provided this
is not at risk of flooding or land
slopes so they have to ensure that
whatever the land the nearest possible
vicinity so they need to build on the
same land or at least in the nearby
vicinity and the families held the
ownership of the land because in this
aspect the main important aspect and the
Google Earth recovery also will be
discussed about the Catholic Relief
Services how they manage the housing in
their own land because first of all the
sense of ownership is retained as it is
okay
the most important part in earthquake
resistance is you have to ensure that
this is going to benefit assistant
building and it could be capable of
withstanding an earthquake simulated
those that has occurred without
collapsing so it has to ensure that
there is no loss of human life and the
damage that the damage produced would be
repaired by the user steps so that it
could be repaired by minimal
interventions and the community
themselves can repair it as quickly as
possible and the constructed area per
house was about 42 square meter and 36
of which would be roof divided into
three rooms with a porch
measuring of 6 square meter outside so
this have been implemented the
participatory approach where the
communities were involved in the process
so I'll anyways I will discuss with you
with the process how the community was
involved and how it has related to the
built form on the project management and
community involvement was essential
during the whole process from the design
of the house to the completion of the
house so there are three stages one is
the first stage the basic construction
of the structural elements we talk about
any structural elements like the
foundations the columns to structure the
basic structure of it and then these
individuals from each family within the
community have contributed the unskilled
labor that has created some kind of
employment opportunities and this has
also enhanced the participation and now
in this the moment the community is
coming forward to provide some kind of
unskilled labor to make their own houses
where they feel dignity about making
their own house the stage two there are
associations the Red Cross applied some
materials like for example in terms of
hollow concrete blocks or any other
which are not locally available and it
also have provided the necessary
technical advice through the electric
local technical teams so them recite
supervisors and again the materials how
the Red Cross has provided the materials
which are not available
locally and the stage three which is
talking about the completion which has
the portable water supply and the
household plumbing systems which onto
the service mechanism part of it now how
this whole process the community
participation has been approached one is
they talked about approaching through
the social organizations the communities
the local communities through their own
networks so because the Red Cross
personnel will be coming from somewhere
else who may or may not be familiar with
the local communities and that is where
the disco which is a kind of community
organizations become a kind of interface
between the local communities and the
various energy was coming and working in
it in that process what happens is
communities establish a trust on these
agencies which can actually negotiate
and make create an interface between
both the groups so finally after having
a thorough analysis of the 14
communities in San well center they have
selected nine communities within that
poutine for the reconstruction process
so for this progressive housing project
mainly they have covered in the two
major municipalities one is a tech Luca
an Vera patch within the Department of
Sandman CENTAC and each community
includes El Arco Llano grande el Pinto
Santa Cruz de Paris yo Santa droves and
Jose debo just never oriented San
Antonio jeboa San Ysidro so these are
all concluding about about 582 houses
now the oil issue to do with the land
tenure so the people who were already a
legal owners of the land or had a lot
land ownership documents so that you
know these particular communities have
been processed and these communities
have received help from the Town Hall on
the
provided with the professional service
of lawyer which brought down the cost of
the process so once they have a
legalized document legalized process of
it so it can actually have you know
brought the regulatory framework into
the process so that it can cut down some
cost but there were also some families
whose houses are located on a land that
belonged to a railway company because
you know you have the revenue line you
have the railway land or in some cases
of the mining adultage land so but in
this case the people who are residing on
the railway land so or to other private
individuals so these people have been
excluded from the project for reasons of
ownership so this is how this has been
considered but obviously one has to look
at it obviously what happens to these
you know what kind of NGO support they
give because the basic tenure
also makes a big difference in the
criteria of the selection of the end you
know the beneficiaries and how it is
implemented as I said to you it's a
participatory design methodology the
communities have collectively prepared a
house design so the think-tank process
has went to the bottom level
interactions and what the did was to get
a real scale understanding so they made
about the outlines with just two lines
of blocks you know that this is going to
be your space so you have this is your
room and this is the veranda this is
another room you know so basically they
made a mark out plan with keeping those
two lines of the block so that they get
a real space understanding with one is
to one scale then the house is consisted
of a unit with a gable roof and walls of
made of concrete hollow blocks
reinforced horizontally and vertically
so horizontally and vertically when we
need to refer with the earthquake
systemic course which recommends that
have a vertical reinforcement and as
well as the horizontal bands the sill
band the lintel band the roof band and
the plinth beam and the diagonal gracing
all these things they are talking about
the
earthquake-resistant futures and as we
inform the gross floor area is about 42
square meters divided into two bedrooms
nine square meter each and a common area
of 18 square meter and approach of
school six square meter
so as I discussed with you about three
stages stage one which is a partial
construction so here the communities who
are the stakeholders the communities
they also provided some kind of informal
the unskilled labor at this process and
the local builders because for a group
of some of the local builders were hired
by the contractors and the construction
supervisors for every group of thirty so
you have one supervisor who is looking
at it there is another which is a social
promoter who is looking at the whole
community level and for 50 to 70
households is one of the social promoter
has been appointed in that way there's a
clear transparency and there's a create
the flow pattern of the communication
from starting from a household to group
of households to the community level and
also you know across various smaller
communities so what they did was in the
initial stage they didn't the excavation
and laying of the foundations as per the
course the earthquake resistant
structure has been built and the walls
were built about the sill level about
1.7 meters in the bedrooms and 1 point 1
meter in the remaining areas so the roof
was built and covered paved so this is a
stage one is you can see the vertical
reinforcement and the stage one is
completed with a half finished product
with a small roof walls on the basic
structure there's no windows there's no
dose nothing then in stage two this is
where the completion by owners so
communities also have provided so
the earlier stage the materials were
provided because these concrete blocks
were not available locally so the
agencies have provided the concrete
blocks but in here the communities as
per their feasibility is as per their
available resources they have developed
they brought the doors and windows and
here the master-builders apart from the
social promoters the master builders and
the bricklayers have provided training
for the communities so that you know
they understand the basic construction
techniques because that will help them
tomorrow if something happens they can
do by themselves and the lintels and of
the doors and windows and the walls has
been finished with all the plastering
and the waterproofing part of it by
rough coating and outside walls and
finishing touches applied to the whole
house so this is a stage 2 but then if
you look at the contributions the Red
Cross have provided the materials which
are not available locally and they also
provided some kind of workshops to
organize this whole process and in a
technical support and monitoring because
they have even they need they need to
provide the technical support to the
common design one master builder per
community so for each community they
have given one master builder one brick
layer for each 20 houses and 11 social
promoters in total of the whole 582 so
in family they provided the materials
like the gravel sand and things like
that
and also the doors and windows and they
also provided the labor which got
training later on under stage 3 the
service completion of it the water
supply and sanitation so here they
installed a sink with two taps a system
of removing grey water connected a
system in each houses for the excreta
disposal and there has been also some
workshops which has been conducted for
the community the training and you know
interactions so the community needs how
are these identified because this is
where the participatory diagnosis have
been implemented
CREB the community what the community
was on how they are learn about their
needs and analyzing the current
community of situations so this has been
the the descriptive lure of a community
have actually given a significant
understanding of their needs and wants
and the feasibilities and even after
this construction people have been
engaged in certain training process
because they need to get into
understanding how to maintain the
service aspect how to maintain the raivo
the greywater take off all the water
supply aspect the sanitation aspect or
the waste disposal so there have been
got training on the cleaning the area
around the house removing superficial
runoff water house maintenance
construction of natural barriers
protecting slopes planting trees and
extending the house you know some kind
of awareness has been programmed with
the community and with this there has
been various public projects like
schools like this one school of Haggadah
land you know which has been developed
on a house for people with physical and
mental disabilities which has been
constructed and there are six
educational centers which has been
constructed to cater the needs of the
community and looking at the timeline we
have about five hundred there what are
the results starting from the 2001 from
May onwards it is about the planning and
drafting of the project document so it
looked at analyzing the needs the
combination of the cooperations of
different agencies and how to go ahead
with it and then in August somewhere the
construction of the pilot house have
been constructed and the September
October we see the social promoters were
hired and the tender documents were
issued and awarded to successful
construction companies to carry on with
the construction aspect and this is
where the stage one which we discussed
about the unfinished structure the basic
skeleton of the house
and here we talked about the stage to
where the communities have come forward
and they put some materials and they
raise some funds together to for buying
some materials and this is where the
stage to have occurred under stage two
in the last stage when they are about to
get so they looked into the service
infrastructure as well so what are the
results now there's been a constant
community involvement and a
participatory workshops have been like
you can see that every morning the
community is team is meeting and
learning different aspects of the
housing project and how to go ahead with
it so that is what they worked on a more
to learn as you work and the main here
the one thing is main users themselves
have played an important role in their
own recovery and what are the direct
impacts of this progressive housing 97%
of the population have been covered new
employment have been generated and
improved the standard of living
strengthening the social networks
because they start working together
breaking cultural stereotypes of women
in involvement because woman has been a
major asset and where people were came
forward to be part of the recovery
program in terms of decision making the
construction and the serve the Red Cross
as active role the local Red Cross and
even after five years one can see that
you know how they are able to maintain
their gardens the fabric of the house
what are the constraints you know every
project will have its downturns
difficulty for communities for finding
finances in the stage to because what
they do is in order to procure the
materials some people are able to effort
some people may not and then they used
to collectively do some place or shoes
to gather some funds and that has also
has an impact on the specific deadlines
of the project and the other thing we
did discuss about the tenure and the
ownership the legal procedures regarding
the land ownership which also took some
time and the study concludes that active
participation from the community is a
viable altar
because that is more flexible in many of
the cases in this course what we are
studying is a participation
participation and participation families
able to meet their economic obligations
and they're expected to as they will be
expected to make a hefty contribution so
in that way they have been organizing
themselves and extensive knowledge of
the country culture and its life is a
paramount so one has to work with the
local communities the trust has to be
developed and only a part of it has been
developed in the remaining part has been
developed by the users and how to
optimize the time taken to carry out the
project then some constraints how the
families have a very amateur level of
supervision you know that is also
because they may not be building from
the building background role of social
promoters was a crucial importance
because they had developed a trust
between the community on the red cross
training of local people and social and
technically so that has given them some
kind of employment scope that they can
work as a Masons they can work as a
skilled persons so these are some of the
understanding from the LCF dark caves
and how it's slightly deferred from the
cold core building approach to a
progressive housing approach and how
communities are involved in the process
of it I hope this helps you thank you
very much
[Music]