IITK NPTEL Structural Geology_Lecture 07: Strain Measurement [Prof. Santanu Misra]

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
1 Video View·Dec 3, 2023
[Music]
[Music]
hello and welcome everyone to this
online structural geology course and
today we are in our lecture number seven
and the topic of this lecture is a
strain measurement so the topics or the
areas we'll cover in this lecture or
mostly concept of strain measurements
and analysis we'll learn about different
geological markers that we use for
strain measurements there in one
dimension two dimensions and three
dimensions and then we'll have some
examples of strain measurements from
linear markers spherical objects and
then we will go to measurements of
strain in three dimensions so we'll
employ a method called FRA method or
center-to-center method and then we will
see how using this other techniques we
can also go and plot in in Flynn
diagrams and use Flynn diagram to
analyze the strain of different rocks so
as we have learned from the last two
lectures of deformation and strain there
are some sort of theories there are some
sort of backgrounds and it is possible
that one can retrieve the strain from
rocks through a range of different
methods and mostly you can determine
strain in one I mentioned two dimensions
and three dimensions based on the
outcrops you have based on the features
you look or you get in in your in your
different rocks so strain analysis
generally essentially the primary aim is
to miss the strain of the rock so this
gives you an opportunity to explore the
state of the strain in Iraq and also to
map out the strain variations within a
sample or in an outcrop or a region so
if you are analyzing a sample by
means of strain analysis you can
actually figure out whether the strain
is homogeneous heterogeneous isotropic
anisotropic etcetera etcetera so the
primary aim is of course the shape and
orientation of the strain ellipse an
ellipsoid this is what you need to
figure out in most of the cases we try
to do that and then this when you figure
out that what is the shape and the
orientation of the strain ellipse or
ellipsoids these also give you a lot of
information about the overall
deformation of this region so for
example you can think of that in a
sheared zone setting we learn about
shear zones later that you can figure
out whether the deformation was actually
simple shear or not then in a folded
layer you can also the distrain analysis
and it can give you some ideas of fold
mechanisms how did the fold happen in
past and then some sedimentary rocks
also you have some markers we learn
about it soon these also give you some
information of the deformation processes
you have probably figured out so far
that you need a strain marker if your
rock or the scale you are looking at is
homogeneous then it's not a good idea to
measure the strain from this rock so you
need some sort of markers or strain god
that actually gives you the idea that
that was the original shape and now what
we see in the field this is your deform
ship so you need to know the geometry
and some sort of angular relationships
of the object you are looking at which
was initially in a different shape and
therefore you actually figure out that
your rock is deformed so the common
geometries that you use for strain
analysis mostly in could include sphere
circle ellipse then some symmetric forms
mostly fossils we'll look at them soon
and some forms we
doubt symmetries but which has some
other special geometric relationships
and to do that to figure out that these
shapes like say sphere circle ellipse
etcetera etcetera structure geologists
generally used as strain markers mostly
some geological features like we use
fossils we use some conglomerates brake
shears then lights again these are kind
of fossils some individual grains if we
have to study the grains in microstrain
in very micro scale then reduction spots
and and so on so in addition to that
some deformed features also are helpful
for analyzing the strain for example if
you have a fault or if you have a fault
then you know what was the initial
disposition of these form surfaces of
the fault and the fold and by bringing
it back or unfolding the fold or making
the fault to its initial position by
some sort of analysis you can figure out
that how much strain was involved in
this processes so let's have a look that
what are the different markers that
structural geologists do use for
analyzing the strain and we look at from
linear objects to this spherical objects
one after another the first image or
first slide discusses the objects which
were initially linear and there we
generally consider some sort of fossils
for example what we see here this is a
belemnite an artist's impression which
is an extinct animal and if it gets
fossilized then it takes a shape of this
so this is a fossil of a belemnite of
course in the in this image this is
undeformed but now imagine that you know
the orientation of the belemnite
you know the shape of the belemnite and
now if this is
formed this piece then you can figure
out the strain using some methods that
we have learnt then also the bedding
claims are linear the traces of the
bedding plants are linear so I have
these bedding plants and now for example
if I consider this black layer and this
got folded so I can unfold this black
layer which is now folded and can figure
out that what was the magnitude of the
strain involved in making this fold then
we know that we have a sedimentary
feature which is cross beddings are
these angular relationships not always
but if you can get the same rock in a
different place with known angles that
can be also useful or helpful to measure
the strength now let's have a look some
a spherical or cylindrical objects and
here we mostly use some fossils and some
typical geological features what we see
in the first image is a microstructure
this is voids do you this you mostly
find in lime stones
and then also in lime stones you find a
very typical geologic feature which is
in this case this circular thing that is
known as reduction spot so these are
very much circular and these are
excellent strain markers also you know
that there are many creatures that do
burrows in beach sands or in river banks
so these burrows are later filled by
sediments and therefore it remained
cylindrical if it is undeformed for
example here these are undeformed
burrows so deformation of which can give
you an estimate of the strain of the
rock and similarly if you have the
burrow holes preserved and they can also
deform so a cross section of these
burrow holes if undeformed would be
circular approximately and if they are
deformed the cross sections would be
elliptical so these are essentially very
good strain markers now some elliptical
objects if you can consider they are not
perfect ellipses or ellipsoids but
mystically you can consider them that
they are of similar shape and geometry
for example pebbles or conglomerates as
you can see in these two photographs so
these two photographs you know what is
conglomerate it's some pebbles embedded
or hosted in a fine-grained matrix so
these are pebbles these at least in this
image these are not necessarily of equal
shape and geometry but statistically if
you consider say 10 15 20 30 50 of such
pebbles then you actually if they are
these are deformed you actually can get
an estimate of the strain of these
deformed rocks and the next one is of
course if you have some objects of known
shape and their angular relationships
and here we mostly use fossils the first
one you see is is a fossil image of a
fossil the the creature is a bivalve and
is known as brachiopod this is an
extinct one and the brachiopods were
available or their prolific in the art
in the Paleozoic time so you can see
that it has sort of a bilateral symmetry
so this line and this line if you
consider so this is 90 degrees if it is
undeformed so if it is deformed or if
you don't see that this angular
relationships are not maintained in some
sort of exposures then your rock is
deformed and using this you can analyze
the strain the the second photograph
this one is also a photograph of an
extinct animal so this is a fossil and
this this is a trilobite you know
probably from your paleontology lectures
and trilobite were also prolific more or
less at the same time when brachiopods
were there in the Paleozoic time now
what we see here that if I draw the axis
in an undeformed bracket in an
unreformed trilobite these ribs like
features that come out from this
creature they are essentially
perpendicular so if that relationships
are not there then you can figure out
that what is the
strain of this rock where this
brachiopod got fossilized now the last
two images the first one is again an
extinct fossil but this was prolific and
this have these animals have seen
dinosaurs because these were prolific in
the Mesozoic time because these and also
this image these two have a very typical
geometric feature on their coiling
so as you can see here these actually
follow this coiling actually do follow a
geometric formula which is known as
golden ratio so if this golden ratio is
not maintained in your deformed Rock
then you can figure out what is the
strain in by analyzing this this
geometry so based on these ideas will
now have some very basic understandings
are very we will learn some very basic
methods where we analyze the strain from
a deformed rock using all these markers
one very important thing to remember or
before doing all these strain analysis
from deform markers the first
consideration we do while we measure
strain out of these geological markers
is that these materials more or less had
same physical properties in terms there
in terms of their rheology with respect
to the overall country rock and you can
be sure that this is not the case
because this material is different your
host rock is different so they cannot be
deforming in a very similar way then
also these individual creatures are
individual eyelid line elements they can
also deform within themselves
differently to that of the country rock
which is also suffering the strength so
all these things you must remember value
to the strain analysis so these type of
strain analysis mostly gives you very
first-hand ideas of the stress
but to do a detail strain analysis there
are some other methods and we may learn
this in in in a course which is advanced
structural geology or so on so the
moving on let's start with the strain
measurement from a linear object what we
see here in this image this creature as
you see that some broken square-like
features like here here and feel some
materials so this is a belemnite fossil
that got Buda najd
so how did it happen that you had a
belemnite fossil like this which is
embedded in Iraq and now if you compress
this rock this way then this belemnite
fossil initially got fractured this way
and with time it gets some it makes some
pieces and this feature is Indian
geological context is known as Buddha
nudging so now you can imagine that if I
again come back to this if I join all if
add all these lengths that would give me
the l0 or the initial length of this
belemnite and if I add from here to here
or from here to here that would give me
the final length or deformed length so
this is exactly I tried to do here I
sketched this and plotted it here so
these are the individual lengths you
also need a scale or you can do some
relative measurements as well so in this
scale the photographer has given a scale
and if I see here this individual out of
this scale I can actually figure out
what is the length of this individual
Boo Dean's or individual segments of
this belemnite so if I add them together
then I get the initial length and also
the way they are disposed including the
gaps in between is my final length in
this image the initial length is six
point three seven centimeter and the
final length is ten point zero seven
centimeter using the formula of
elongation which is this one we can
actually calculate
the elongation of this belemnite and
also the surrounding rocks which is 0.58
so this is how you figure out the
deformation of or you get the strain
linear strain of an area if you have an
object like this but sometimes life is
not that easy for example what we see in
this photograph that we have this black
layer here this one you see very
similarly that we have seen in this
belemnite fossil that this amphibolite
layer got Buddha najd so you have I try
to make a sketch at the top with the
white one but at the same time while it
is Buddha noshing may be before or after
you see that it also has a little gentle
buckling that means it also got folded
the layer is not straight the way we
have seen in the previous slide so if
you try to do measurement out of this
it is difficult first of all it is not
recommended and if you do then you have
to be very careful considering other
factors now it can be even difficult if
you have a boobie najd
layer which is tightly folded here in
this case again this is an amphibolite
layer I made a sketch of this
amphibolite layer on the other side so
here the white one is your amphibolite
layer which got booed in urged and
folded we're not going to discuss which
one happened first what they happen
simultaneously or not but it's if you
would like to do linear strain
measurement you can also see that in
some parts this layer got thickened in
some part the layer got cleaned so
misery linear strain out of these type
of boobie Najd and folded objects is not
that much recommended unless you have
some other clues from somewhere else
let's say we'll look at how to measure
the strain from some sort of angular
relationships as we have learnt that
again this is a fossil of trilobite and
we know that it has an initial
relationship where this angle is 90
degree now I have two deformed images
which I collected from the web and I can
clearly see that at least in this case
this angular relationship is not
maintained and also in this case this
angular relationship is not maintained
now if I focus only on the angular
relationships then certainly I can
measure the shear strain these two
fossils and therefore the rock in this
case in these two rocks the host rocks
have suffered but again you can figure
out probably that these materials also
underwent some sort of other
deformations like pure shear or
combination of pure shear and simple
shear so that may not be possible out of
this but we can certainly measure the
magnitude of the shear strain at least
from the concept of this angular
relationship so if we try to do that
again this is 90 degrees then what we
see here the deviation from the right
angle which is the dotted line and what
is now is 43 degrees so simply by
putting the formula shear strain equal
to 10 of this 43 that gives you almost
close to 1 0.93 and in the second case
this is 0.53 we can do a similar strain
analysis from a very simple shear zone
so what we see here in this photograph
that this layer which was supposed to be
like this now it got deflected this way
okay so this deflection is essentially
due to some this angular deflection is
probably some sort of shearing
okay now if that shear happened there
for this
thing got a deflection and if we can
measure this angle we will see it how it
is done then we can actually calculate
the shear strength involved in deforming
this particular piece of rock so in this
case this angle is 32 degree and again
using the same formula shear strain
equal to 10 of 32 degrees you will get
this now if I have some spherical
objects which are exposed only in one
surface that means you don't see on the
other sides of this rock then they can
deform to form some ellipses if you have
these type of features in your field or
in your rock or in your sample then you
can get a very basic or primary idea of
this trend it doesn't give you the
strain magnitude but it gives you the
strain ratio so here is is a very simple
example that I had some initial circles
and these circles got deformed to form
these ellipses so you can measure the
long axis and you can measure the short
axis so what do you do in one column you
write long axis and in one column you
write short axis and then you plot this
that you write the values 1 2 3 4 and so
on and then if you plot long axis versus
short axis then if this rock has any
deformation then you should see a
deflection of course from the 45 degree
if it is 45 degree then X equal to Y or
long axis equal to short axis therefore
you have your spherical geometry
maintained but if it is not then you may
have some deflections from the 45
degrees and that may give you that the
very first or basic first hand idea of
of the deformation just to remind you
that these plots are these data are from
different
the objects not from the image that you
see here but you can you can try this
one and plot it it would come in three
different clusters because I used three
different shapes here the second one the
one of the most used strain analysis
from spherical objects in two dimension
is known as FRA method so it is given by
professor Frye it's a paper two
consecutive papers one in 1979 and then
another one in the same year with Hana
he wrote this paper
so this Frye method is very interesting
and it has some very interesting
concepts behind now the first concept is
it is written here but I would love to
read it for you before deformation the
Centers of the spherical objects had an
isotropic and uniform distribution that
is the distances between the neighboring
centers where statistically uniformed it
can be used even if there is a ductility
contrast between the spherical objects
and their host matrix the second point
is when a set of points which
statistically uniform distribution is
deformed the average distance between
the neighboring points in any direction
increases or decreases in the same ratio
as the length of the marker line in that
direction the maximum increase takes
place in the direction of the long axis
that's obvious of the strain ellipse and
the average distance between the points
decreases the most in a direction
parallel to the short axis of the strain
ellipse the actual ratio of the strain
ellipse and it's orientation is
determined by a graphical method which
is the Frye method so what is written
here try to understand this in an
illustration what we see in this image
or in this illustration that I had some
spherical objects
which are now sphere in two-dimension
this is my X Direction this is my J
direction
this red lines are a network of red
lines actually defining the distance
from one center to another center of the
neighboring circle now in this setting
if I deform it by pure shear manner like
this so here the elongation along X
Direction is 0 then it is 0.16 0.33 0.05
and 0.664 incremental progressive
deformation stages are given so clearly
if I deform this piece this way that
means the vertical Direction is the
compression direction and shortening
direction and the horizontal direction
is extension direction we can see that
with progressive deformation all
distances along the vertical along the
horizontal line are progressively
increasing right here and here it has
increased to this amount if we see the
vertical distances for example here if
we consider this distance it is also
decreasing with progressive deformation
and that's the principle of fry method
that in horizontal direction all the
center's would move horizontally and
they will tend to stretch and so on so
based on this now we learn how to plot
or how to work with the fry method to
get your strain analysis so here the
techniques are described what you have
to do that you say in this case what I
have shown that I have some circular
objects here and that got deformed to a
strain of 1.5 and you will get this in
your
field or in your thin sections when you
look at microscopes so it could be
stretch drains it could be some fossils
or whatever
now the methods are described here that
you have to first of all trace this this
individual ellipsis and then you have to
mark their centers in a piece of paper
and then with another piece of tracing
paper you have to move one point to
another point such a way that once you
keep in one Center your points your a
single point then you mark in all
tracing papers in in the in the tracing
paper all centers of the visible so
based on the this idea or the basics of
this fry method now we learn how to plot
this fry plot in a piece of paper or how
to do this analysis of strain using some
deformed different spheres but in 2d it
would be deformed circles so what do you
get is deformed objects deform circular
objects which are ellipses you can get
conglomerates feature deformed you can
get lights or voids in thin sections you
can get many other features like
reduction spots and so on you can also
use stretched or deform grains so you
can take an image and do the fry
analysis or fry method analysis for
measuring the strain so you need two
sets of tracing papers for that the best
idea is that take a photograph and have
a printout and in this printout you
overlay a piece of tracing paper and
then what you do that first you mark the
boundary of this tracing paper of
circular or a square boundary and then
on that tracing paper you
mark a dot somewhere and this is the
base and you don't have to worry that
where you are putting the center or what
you are putting the dots because it
would be statistically done the method
is statistical method so it will be
taken care of by itself now you have to
take another tracing paper and draw the
very similar border keeping the SIP
borders that you have made on the first
tracing paper or your base tracing paper
okay now in this tracing paper you match
the center points that you have marked
in the previous tracing paper now when
you are done then it would superimpose
your borders it would superimpose your
centers now keeping that you heat all
the Centers of this deformed ellipsis
and mark them as a dot that's your first
data set then you move this tracing
paper without rotating so that means you
have to translate and go to the center
of another grain and then you do the
same process and you continue doing it
so you have data sets for each and every
Center of these ellipses and while doing
this you will figure out that you are
clouding your tracing paper with lot of
dots and while you are plotting the dots
when you are at the end you will slowly
see that an ellipse would emerge like
this and based on your orientation you
can figure out once you are done then
this is your long axis so this is 1 plus
e1 and this is your short axis 1 plus e3
now this orientation it may not remain
as horizontal as it is you may have a
strain ellipse like this so this would
also give you the angular relations or
strain so this is a very basic method
that we always use for measuring strains
from deformed ellipses deformed circles
which you get in form of ellipses
there are many software's you can also
use it so I recommend that you download
some images of deformed objects it is
available or you just type FRA method
then take a printout and then do it by
yourself and you can send it to me or
the to TAS for for checking now the
final one is three dimensional strain
analysis if you remember the fling
diagram then actually you can get three
different types of deformed rocks in
three dimension one is El tech tonight
one is a steak tonight and in between
you have LS tech tonight's now also
because we have a three dimensional
scenario here you can also in the field
with some techniques are with some
typical observations you can figure out
what is your X Direction what is your y
direction and what is your Z direction
of the principal axis of the strain
ellipsoid now here I have three
photographs that we commonly do for
commonly go this place for four hour
with our students for undergraduate
field training this is near Shing boom
shear zone behind the rock mines and
there you have a layer or marker layer
of deformed conglomerates and this place
nicely exposes the three different
sections because we have foliation it is
possible to maze identify the different
the three different principal axis of
strains and their orientations so I have
three photographs here taken along X
Jade along X Y and
y'see sections as you can see here maybe
not very clear from these images but I
highlighted some of this stretched or
deformed conglomerates on each planes
what you see here in x-jet planes these
conglomerates are extremely stretched on
X Y and X jet planes they appear at
least in terms of their ellipticity more
or less similar what the students do in
the field they measured this long axis
versus short axis and then out of this
on each planes they figure out the
stretch and then they plot it in the
Flynn diagram which is you see here and
when they plotted it they got an
excellent cluster along the K 1 k equal
to 1 so that gives the students the idea
that the Shing home shear zone at least
the area they are looking at the strain
was flattening or sorry this strain was
a plane strain so if it was in this side
it would be flattening if it was in this
side it would be constriction we get
these features in other places but in
this area as an example this is a very
beautiful example you can see that this
strain here is plane strain so this is
how you do three dimensional strain
analysis using Flynn diagram before I
conclude this lecture I would like to
give you some remarks that I have given
you in the very beginning as well so
strain markers in deform rocks reveal
how much the rock has been strained and
information about the nature of the
deformation that is whether it is
flattening constriction and reaction of
strain axis etcetera etcetera you can
get it there are a number of techniques
I have just given you some very commonly
used and easily can be operated in the
field or with your computer or with a
piece of paper but there are many other
techniques for measuring strains I just
mentioned few like well her method
breading method
and our f5 method the books I referred
all these three techniques are described
so if you're interested you can go and
have a look what is most important
theory and technique behind all these
methods they do have certain limitations
and they have some sort of boundary
conditions you cannot do everything
using a single and simple method so
based on this I conclude this lecture
and I believe with these three lectures
on strain we have now a very good
knowledge on this topic so strain
deformation and strain analysis in the
context of deformation of rocks now the
question comes next that how do the
rocks deform so what are the different
forces that deform the rock how to
identify understand and classify these
different type of forces and their
actions so the answer of all such
questions are hidden in the study of
stress and stress tensor and they are
different components so that would be
topic of the next lecture and will cover
this in one or two lectures so for the
timing thank you very much enjoy trading
strain chapters thank you
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
