IITK NPTEL Structural Geology_Lecture 02: Introduction II [Prof. Santanu Misra]

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
3 Video Views·Dec 3, 2023
Hello everyone. Welcome to this NPTEL Structural Geology course. We are at our lecture number
2 and we will continue today with this introduction. So, where we stopped at our last lecture that
what are the different ways to look at the rocks particularly you have to when you see
a piece of rock or a photograph, the questions you should ask where whether you are looking
at a deformed rock, whether it is homogeneous, heterogeneous, isotropic, anisotropic, whether
the structure is continuous or discontinuous and most importantly what is the scale.
Now in this lecture, we will mostly cover what are the different ways to observe and
interpret a rock structure. So, the question we would ask mostly today is what does a Structural
Geologist do or what are the different processes a Structural Geologist follow to interpret
a rock structure. So, to answer this question what does a Structural
Geologist do is essentially is to observe deformed rocks in very very intelligent way
and explain with some scientific observations and evidences why and how they ended up at
their present state. And to do so, a Structural Geologist has many approaches and one can
categorize it in three different sections. The first one is field observation, second
one laboratory experiments, it can be real rock deformation experiment or analog experiment
and of course, analog I am sorry of course, the analytical and numerical modeling.
Now these three basic tools have their own limitations, we will learn it later, but at
the same time these three tools are also complementary to each other that what you cannot observe
or understand from the field, you can understand if you perform an experiment in the laboratory.
So, to continue this question again that the main job of a Structural Geologist is to interpret
and define on the basis of scientific data and at the same time a Structural Geologist
also does geologic reconstruction. So, the first part interpret and define structures,
a Structural Geologist has to deal with very complex interaction of natural elements, we
will look at it all these processes soon. Then most of the geologic structures as you
can imagine these are extremely large in their extent. For example, you can think of Himalaya
or the complexity of South India and so on. And these structures have formed time scales
that ranges from million to billion years and few processes are still happening and
with our human life span to we cannot see it happening, right. So, we see the end product
and almost fossilized. So, a Structural Geologist has a challenge to interpret this large scale
in space and time. And one more important thing that Structural
Geology has which is somehow advantageous to us is that most of the processes that happen
in nature are non-repeatable or non-reversible in nature. That is if something has happened
then you cannot go back with time with most of the cases. And then geologic reconstruction
is another type of challenges because it has several limitations and Structural Geologists
have to solve a series of jigsaw puzzles. For example, as I was talking about that it
takes a lot of time to produce a structure. So, the rate of deformation in earth is extremely
slow in almost every cases. There are of course, few deviations of this for example, if you
have an earthquake or if you have an impact crater formation. So, there are few things
that happen very quickly, but most of the other cases the rate of deformation in earth
is extremely slow and it is almost impossible to track through a human life.
And then you do not have any initial picture that how it was, how it looked before. You
do not have the entire picture as well because the some pieces are missing. You do not have,
you cannot access all the areas even if you can access maybe there is no exposure. And
on the top of that the deformation that we look at on the surface it is not a single
deformation. That means, one deformation has happened some time ago and then later some
other deformation which is occurring from other directions or in a completely different
nature. It is either demolishing or over printing the previous deformation.
So, this is a challenge of a structural geologist to reconstruct and interpret separate out
these deformations and what has happened at the first deformation, what has happened in
the second deformation and so on. So, at one point, at one time this is really challenging
sometimes frustrating for a structural geologist, but at the same time it is extremely fun and
this is why structural geologist, most of the structural geologists like their job very
much.
So, there are three basic ways a structural geologist looks at the structures in earth
or in nature. So, these are geometric models, kinematic models and mechanical models and
you can classify them together as direct methods of observations. So, to understand
that geometric models, these are mostly qualitative and sometimes quantitative. It does not involve
any other detailed scientific, what it does it simply try to interpret from what we are
observing its 2D or 3D representation, its orientation, how it is in a more comprehensive
way. We look at some examples later and these are mostly done using some data obtained from
field studies or some experiments. Kinematic model on the other hand is the next
stage of geometrical model, where a structural geologist after constructing the geometric
models, try to understand what are the different motions at different parts of the structure,
that which part has moved which way relative to the other parts. That helps you in the
next stage to understand the deformation, displacement, motion of things. You can imagine
plate tectonics which actually deals with the motion of the plates is a kind of kinematic
model. The mechanical model which is the most developed or most advanced model among these
three or we call it dynamic analysis which is highly quantitative. This model involves
interaction of material properties and forces and so on. So, these are mostly done by performing
some experiments, reconstructing the features in the laboratory and so on.
So, these three geometric models, kinematic models and mechanical models are very important
direct methods of structural geology study. Then, there is another method we call it indirect
method. In indirect method, a structural geologist may hypothesize a feature that Himalaya has
formed by this, this and this. And then, he or she tries to understand it by performing
some models, experiments or numerical models. The structural geologist collects data from
the field and then either prove this hypothesis or disapprove this hypothesis.
So, this is some sort of models or ideas that most of the structural geologists nowadays
do and these are done mostly for the processes that we do not see. For example, we do not
see the plumes, we do not see the mantle convections. So, there are many hypothesis and models by
which a structural geologist or tectonics expert or a geodynamist, they try to work
on some indirect methods and these are known as analytical models.
In the following slides, we will mostly focus on this geometric, kinematic and mechanical
models and I will try to give you a very basic idea that what are these, how these are done
and most importantly, how these are being applied to the real field. So, let us start
with the geometric model. If you remember in the last lecture, I talked about fold and
this is a fold. So, what we see here, this light yellow and dark brown alternate layers,
these are folded and the thickness of these layers did vary during the deposition and
it remain intact while it got folded. Now, if it was a simple fold, then no problem,
we can simply trace one layer and figure out how did this fold happen, which layer is,
but this structure is somehow discontinued with some slips. For example, this is one
and that makes, we can see from this relative displacements that it moved from one to another,
this is a part of the kinematic model, which we are not looking at, but the challenge is
to trace that if I look at this layer, this brown layer here, then where it is in the
other side. In this case, it is simple, it comes here.
Now, similarly if I look at this brown layer and again I have a discontinuity here, then
my challenge is to find out whether it is this one or the other one. Now, whatever interpretation
you make out of this, that whether this is this layer or the other layer, you have to
come up with some sort of logics and this logic is the fundamentals of geometric model.
For example, with this model, with this photograph, I prepared this geometric model, I did not
cover all these layers, but few of the layers are color coded and they are represented in
this way. So, this is a very simple example, how geometric models in structural geology
are constructed.
Now, can we apply it to a little large scale? The answer is yes. Here, we have one seen
sedimentary deformation and you can see that these alternate black, white and few light
brown layers got disturbed by a series of faults. Now, to understand it better, what
I tried to do, I tried, I made a geometric model of it which looks like this and here
you can better understand what are the different geometries of the layers, which layer moved,
where which layer is continued to where and so on.
Now, talking about the large scale, this is a seismic reflection image of a subduction,
a plate which is subducting under the sea floor. Now, looking at it, apparently it looks
very homogeneous with some sort of topography and some other little features. Creating a
geometric model of this reflection seismic data is a daily routine of a seismologist
and a structural geologist helps in this process significantly.
So, if someone who is an expert of constructing geometric models, apparently which is look
extremely homogeneous and most likely there is nothing, but this person would interpret
this structure in this way. So, what you can see, it has a basal decalma and then series
of thrusts are emerging from this basal decalma with the reflection data and some velocity
calculations. One can also find if there are some different lithologies and so on.
Again, I repeat this model does not include any of the material parameters. I had some
data and with this data, I had to interpret what has happened there. That is it. This
is the geometric model. Can it be applied in other fields? The answer is yes.
What we see here, this is integration of different sets of data. This is a computer
generated image. It involves millions and billions of data. This is a hydrocarbon reservoir
somewhere in the north sea. I took it from the internet. So, dynamic graphics is the
website. You can go and check. What we see here with this geometric model, this red patches
that we see at different areas, these are oil rich areas. So, once the geometric model
comes up properly with the interpretation of different geophysical, structural and other
petrological data, it is possible for an oil engineer to design the oils and then it can
actually intrude different parts of this hydrocarbon reservoir and extract oil.
So, geometric model is essentially important not only for understanding the structures
but at the same time, after understanding the structures, one can also explore simply
by constructing a perfect geometric model.
Let us look at the kinematic models. As I said kinematic models are one step advanced
from the geometric models because after constructing the geometry, the kinematic model includes
the relative displacements, motions of the observation we are making at. Now, what we
see here at the top photograph is a very classic structure that we commonly observe in ductile
shear zone. We will learn about it later. This is known as delta structure. Now, looking
at it, if we try to construct this geometric model without all these arrows and so on,
this is how it should look like. Now, it is possible to look at this structure
and with some other observations that this little ball which is inside, maybe it is rotating
this way and therefore, you have some sort of tail like features at the both ends. You
can also construct these foliations or little layers outside that concave embayment that
also proves that while this little ball is rotating, it was also dragging the other layers.
Now, again this model does not consider what is this material of this ball, what is the
material outside and so on. It simply constructs first the geometric model and then it considers
that what was the relative motion. This is very important as shear sense indicators in
structural geology. There are many other shear sense indicators, but this is one of the most
important ones.
Now, here is another one. This is a microstructure observed under microscope. You can see the
scale here. This length is about 500 microns. What we see here, a mineral grain is broken
along these planes and then there are some sense of steps. Now, these steps indicate
that one grain has moved past another grain and just looking at this, we can construct
that this grain has moved down relative to this and similarly others.
Now, this is a classic structure of structural geology in ductile shear zone as well in brittle
ductile shear zone and this is known as bookshelf structure. So, this is how it happens. So,
if you have a series of books, if you tilt the books, then they rotate past each other
and this is how they slip individually. So, this is a kinematic model again.
This is a field photograph and looking at it, I color coded the two layers with green
and orange and this is the displacement plane that has happened. So, you can quickly just
looking at this geometric model, you can say that this entire block has moved this direction
relative to the other block. So, once you interpret this, you are actually working on
a kinematic model.
Now, in large scale, as I said in the past lectures, the tectonic model, plate tectonics
is some kind of a kinematic model. Why? Because, it does not involve the individual material
properties of the plates, what are their different properties and so on. It simply constructs
that how one plate moved relative to other, what was the mutual interaction between them
and so on. So, this is how Himalaya is conceived, the development of Himalaya.
So, on the south side, you can see this is south, you have this Indian plate and then
here you have Tibetan plate and then Indian plate moved with time and then we have formed
series of thrust faults and then this is the present day configuration of Himalaya, where
we have lot of faults, major faults are known as MCT, MBT, MFT, STD and so on. There is
also certainly a Basal De Colma, which is MHT, Main Himalayan Thrust.
Now, this is a kinematic model, it does not involve any sort of forces, it does not involve
any sort of material properties, the dynamics of this plates and so on. But, if we have
to involve that, then actually we are approaching to develop a dynamic model. Let us have a
look.
So, this is the cross section of Himalaya and what we see here, that in this side you
have India, the southern part. So, here you have India and here you have Tibet. So, in
between you had this Tethy and sediments that got squeezed out from series of thrusts and
we have this present configuration of Himalaya. Now, to understand this entire process, how
did it happen, one can perform a dynamic model by conducting a sandbox experiment.
So, a sandbox experiment is a very simple experiment, which is scaled down from the
nature. So, this is a typical sandbox, what it does that in this space, you actually add
series of layers of sands, you have different colors to distinguish the different layers,
which represent or which are analogous to the sedimentary layers and then you drag this
belt, so that this sand bodies, entire sand bodies move from one side to another side
and this is a block, which is analogous to the rigid Tibetan plate, where the entire
Tethyan sediments are hitting and we would like to see, what is happening here.
Now, what you see here, that we are involving the materials, we would like to see, what
is happening with them. So, this is a dynamic model, we are involving some sort of forces
as well. So, let us have a look of this movie and see how it works. So, this alternate yellowish,
dark blue, then again yellowish, green, yellowish and the dark blue, these are different sand
layers representing or analogous to the sediments, sedimentary layers and you see deformation
has already started, the belt started moving from this side, what you see here with more
displacements, the series of thrust faults are being formed.
These type of models, not only discuss the dynamics of the processes, but it also tells
you the evolution of the process, that how from one set setup, one geologic setup, you
actually achieve a different geologic setup, just by adding some sort of deformation. So,
this is a quick view of this entire experiment, you can see series of thrust being formed,
they formed at different angles initially and while they rotated, they achieved a different
angle, it also achieved some sort of elevation and these are the very basic or key ideas
of mountain building processes and one can observe all these processes using a dynamic
model.
Now, if we try to look at to another geological process, which is folding and we try to understand
how one fold interferes with another fold in nature, then one can perform the analog
experiments. So, here is an example, that we have performed in the laboratory, what
we see in stage 1, we have prepared one fold, one set of folds here, where you can see the
folds are here and these are the hinge lines of the fold marked by the black lines. Now,
the folds are at an angle and then if I compress it, this is what we have done, then we see
some tiny folds are coming up and these experiments were performed to understand, whether the
new folds are generating are as big as the previous one or they are small of the previous
one or even larger than the previous one and we figured out that no, these are small, at
least these are very small in this case, but this is a dynamic model.
We tried to, why? Because, we tried to see, we tried to mimic the layers of the geological
features like the layers, when we form folds, these are ductile. So, we use some putty or
plasticine layers, which are ductile in nature, the scales and other things are also maintained
with respect to the geological scales. So, this is again a dynamic model. Now, one can
also do real rock deformation experiments at high pressure and temperature, because
most of the deformation processes in nature, that happen at depth and there we have pressure
and temperature. So, here is an example, a series of experiments
performed by one of my colleagues Aouke in ETH Zurich, with his famous Carrara marble
experiments. So, the first image, what you see here is an intact undeformed Carrara marble,
you can see the grain size is in equilibrium, more or less similar grain size, it has nice
triple junctions and so on. And then, Aouke sheared this at high pressure and temperature
and you can see, this is the shear direction, we applied and with evolution of the strain,
this is shear strain 1, this is shear strain 2 and this is shear strain 11.
You see first, what you observe is that, the initial grain size of Carrara marble has reduced
to a very fine grain size rock and with time, you can also see that, here we are trying
to develop some sort of directional layers in the rock. And this is exactly, what happens
in nature and in experiments, you can produce that with real rocks. So, this is a dynamic
model and based on that, with the stress strain curve, one can actually understand that, at
which stage of this deformation, what kind of features you see in your microstructure.
So, we are at the end of this lecture. So, some review comments from this introduction
section that we had in this lecture and the previous lecture. So, structural geology is
a highly interdisciplinary subject as you have understood and it was initially little
bit of descriptive subject, but now it is a very much quantitative science. The key
scale of a structural geologist is essentially, how you observe a particular feature in a
piece of rock or in an outcrop and then, based on your observation, you try to answer these
questions, why, how and when. One of the most important conclusions that we would like to
make from this introductory lecture that, it is the rock that contains the information.
You have to go and see the rock in the field. So, therefore, field geology is very important
for structural geologist. Now, scale is one of the very important parameter to study structural
geology. Whatever interpretation you do from a structure, it is important that you remember
what is the scale. Experiments, numerical models etcetera, etcetera have their own limitations.
They are excellent to mimic the complexity of the nature and they also complement each
other. Whatever interpretation you do out of your experiments or numerical models, it
is important that you validate them with the nature.
So, I conclude this lecture and in the next lecture, we will start a new topic that what
are the different structural elements that we measure, lines, planes and their mutual
relationships.
Thank you and stay tuned.
