IITK NPTEL Structural Geology_Lecture 13: Crystal Defects [Prof. Santanu Misra]

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 3, 2023
[Music]
[Music]
hello everyone welcome back again to
this online structural geology NPTEL
course and today we are on a new week
and we are going to learn deformation
mechanism part one where we will study
crystal defects and associated
structures and the topics we will cover
are mostly an introduction to crystal
defects and then we will classify the
crystal defects and describe some of
their associated features which are
important for studying structural
geology and in particular micro
structures we talked about the
deformation mechanism very briefly at
the very end of this last lecture it is
very important to realize the fact that
the deformation that we see the strain
the rocks do accumulate sometimes these
strains are extremely large so the
question always being asked that what is
the mechanism what is the process by
which these strains are being
accumulated within the rock mass and
most of the time we see that the entire
rock is not getting strained but it is
localized or channelized along a very
narrow area or narrow zone what we call
deformation localization now to
understand this process it is the study
of deformation mechanism that deals with
the various processes of grain and
crystal scale deformations which are
responsible for deformation and at the
same time accumulating the large strain
in the rocks now high grain and crystal
scale why not in outcrop scale or in
large scale or Tektronix cal now at this
time we have to understand the fact that
particularly in the ductile domain any
deformation that we see that do initiate
at a very
very small scale very micro scale to be
very specific and when we talk about the
micro scale we actually refer to the
atomic scale so the deformation do
initiate at a very very micro scale we
dim the crystal most of the rocks as we
know are crystalline solids poly
crystalline solids so it is therefore
important to understand what is
happening inside the crystal when we
apply some sort of stress how the
crystal is accommodating the strain what
sort of features we should see within
the crystals which are probably going to
trigger a large-scale deformation so
this is the topic of this lecture and to
understand this behavior within the
crystal the deformation behavior within
the crystal we need to understand first
what is inside a crystal now we know
that a crystal is generally the unit we
call it a lattice and within the lattice
we have the elements which we call motif
now when we define a crystal or what we
have learned so far from our chemistry
or physics lectures that classically a
crystal is defined as what is written
here a homogeneous solid formed by a
repeating three dimensional pattern
which is your lattice of atoms ions or
molecules which are your motives and
they have fixed distances between the
constituent parts now this sounds like
that it's very homogeneous solid or they
have equal or fixed distances between
their constituted constituent parts
their compositions or individual motifs
are very similar and so on which this
looks like a very perfect class
unfortunately the perfect place inside
the crystal hardly exists what I mean by
that the perfect crystal if we talk
about then it does not exist so the best
Grist
that you can think of would have around
one per spare be layin defects now all
these defects are imperfections that
makes a crystal to deviate from its
actual original definition are known as
crystal defects or what is written here
the imperfections within the crystal
structures are known as crystal defects
and crystal defects are very very
important in the deformation of rocks
particularly in structural geology and
at the same time in many other subjects
also in material science and other
mechanical processes so to classify
crystal defects generally people do
classify in three different ways so the
first one we call it point defect or it
is also known as zeroth dimension and
examples will see all of them vacancy or
interstitial now second category is line
defect because it is line so it is
one-dimensional and the examples of line
defects are
dislocations and then we have finally
surface defects surface defects are as
it as the name suggests it is a surface
so it is two-dimensional and the
examples are either free surfaces or
various types of grain boundaries so in
this lecture actually we are going to
explore these three types of defects so
first we'll take over vacancy
interstitials and so on that means point
defects then we'd go to line defects and
finally we'll conclude the lecture with
the surface defects now what is point
defect point defects are places where an
atom is missing or irregularly placed
within the lattice structure so atoms
around the point defects are displaced
from their equilibrium positions of
course if the crystal is not in
equilibrium that means there must be
something wrong and this wrong thing is
either one atom or one element is
missing or it's placed somewhere where
it should not be so therefore if an
element within the lattice is staying
somewhere else or is missing then the
crystal always tries to make things in
equilibrium but it cannot do it so
therefore there is a local differential
stress field that is generated in the
neighborhood of the vacancy and this
local stress field is very very
important in determining many processes
that primarily includes the diffusion of
substitutional atoms and in you can
think of many other processes that these
vacancies are responsible for these are
climb of age dislocations some forms of
creeps and increased resistivity we
learn particularly diffusion and
substitutional atoms very briefly in
this lecture but we learn more later on
diffusion creeps when we learn the
particular mechanism but today we look
at how climb of age dislocations do
happen with the assistance of point
defects so point defects are classified
in this manner what is given in this
slide so first they classified whether
your crystals are ionic or non ionic and
if your crystals are non ionic then you
have vacancy and impurity and within the
impurity we have interstitials and
substitutional vacancies within the
ionic crystals they are mostly two
categories one is Frenkel defect another
is Scott key defect and there are few
more but will mostly look at Frankel and
Scott key defect very briefly but before
that let's go to the non ionic crystals
and first take over the vacancy so if I
can see that we talked about as we see
in this in this illustration that if I
look at this area in particular the
atoms within this particular segment of
this lattice at
distributed very homogeneous li there
inter-atomic distances are constant and
so on however if we see this place in
particular or this place in particular
one atom or one element is missing so
vacancies are therefore the places where
an atom is missing or irregularly placed
within the lattice structure what is
important you see that these straight
connections that we see where there is
no vacancies as such are now somehow
distorted and they are distorting
towards the back in Seaside now this is
where these bonds or these lines as you
can think of are stretched or deformed
or distorted and these are the places
where you generate some sort of
differential stresses so these are
vacancies and let's talk about the
impurities there are two kinds of
impurities as you have learnt what is
substitutional impurity that means you
have a vacancy but vacancy is not vacant
it is occupied by some foreign atom so a
foreign atom came
it replaced the parent atom within the
crystal so this is known as
substitutional impurity and interstitial
impurity is when a foreign atom sitting
in the void of a crystal so somewhere
within the crystal it disturbs the
lattice structure but it does not emit
or remove any atom from the lattice so
here this one is an example of
substitutional impurity and this one is
an example of interstitial impurity now
most of the gemstones that we see or
that we are aware of are actually
results of substitutional impurities I
give you an example for example Ruby
Ruby we know is a fantastic gemstone is
red color but the host mineral of Ruby
the actual mineral of Ruby is nothing
but corundum it's aluminum oxide
now the chromium atom it replaces if it
replaces one percent of the aluminum's
inside this corundum crystal then it
becomes red and that's why it becomes
very very important to us or very
precious to us because of this late red
color so it's not a pure crystal that we
see as Ruby it is actually a corundum
aluminum oxide and in one side the metal
side we have aluminum replaced by
chromium and therefore we see the red
color and that's why it is expensive now
for the interstitial impurity you can
think of the carbon stills that most of
our soft Steel's that we use nowadays
including our cars and so on the carbons
are doped inside the ferrite crystals
which is a BCC crystal and this you can
think of a carbon atom inside a ferrite
crystal so carbon steel is a perfect
example of interstitial impurity now
when we learnt about substitutional and
interstitial impurities let's move on to
point defects related to ionic crystals
and as we have classified there are two
types of ionic crystals defect one is
Frenkel defect and another is Scott key
defect now ionic defects they do occur
when one of the atoms in an ionic
lattice is simply in the wrong position
or missing in this context of Frenkel
defect in an ionic lattice that occurs
when one of the ions is in the wrong
position
so what we see here this is a lattice
structure without any defect so this is
a perfect crystal as you can think of
and then you have some ions with
positive charges and some ions with
negative charges now what we see here
positive charged ions are missing from
this side and they are sitting somewhere
here and the same example it
and see the ion is missing and he said
it is sitting somewhere here now the
basic idea or one of the properties of
crystals with Frenkel defect which we
are discussing now is that that nothing
is missing in this frame so the number
of atoms are number of ions if we count
these remain constant therefore even if
there are vacancies are different type
of vacancies the density of the crystal
does not change on the other hand a
Scott Key defect is when you have a pair
of anion and cation are missing for
example as you can see here this one and
this one and anion and cation are
missing from this crystal or this
lattice and again here appear Hulu is
they have to disappear from the system
as a pair and if that happens then it is
known as Scott key defect and you can
imagine that if this happens then the
density of the crystal fairies so the
example of Frenkel defect is you can
think of as the example is given here
silver iodide which is a kind of
material or complex where in this case
the AG plus ion the silver ion is
missing from this actual site and it is
sitting somewhere else and Scott key
defects we mostly see in different kinds
of salts where for example here the KCl
ion the KCl salt where both K and CL k
plus and Cl minus they are missing from
the crystal now how point defects are
important to us we will learn more about
it but points defect are if there are
some sort of differential stress
externally or some sort of
disequilibrium then they try to move
from one site
to another side so if an atom jumps from
its lattice site into the adjacent
vacant site as its at its neighborhood
it fills the vacancy but because there
is no extra atom so it leaves behind
another vacancy so in effect that it
causes the shift of the vacancy to in
the opposite direction to that of the
atom what I mean by this or reading this
text is explained in this illustration
so what do you see we have a vacancy
here and we have a neighboring atom now
if this atom has to move then the best
place to move is to come to this back
and see side so what it decides it moves
to this place and the vacancy then comes
back to the position of the atom so
therefore in the next lap again the next
atom moves to this second C side and the
vacancy comes back or vacancy moves to
the position of the atom and here is the
same case so what we see here that in
this illustration that vacancies are
moving in this direction and atoms are
moving in this direction so therefore
their movements are opposite it's very
similar the way electricity moves or the
electricity goes so electrons move the
direction opposite to the electricity so
this is a very interesting idea that
we'll explore more and it involves also
the volume changes or shape changes of
the crystal during or due to the
movement of vacancies and atom in the
system but for the timing we'll stop
here
will will learn more about it when we
learn more about diffusion creep and
diffusion mechanisms let's move to the
next part of this lecture is line defect
or dislocations that we have learned now
vacancies as you have learnt are zero
dimension that means they are point
defects but line defects are
linear defects and linear defects are
commonly referred as we have learnt
dislocations and dislocations are
nothing but the lines through the
crystal along which a crystallographic
ordering is lost we'll learn more about
it soon so the dislocations are very
very important in terms of structural
geology so their movements and
networking's the movements and
networking's of dislocations control
many many things which are responsible
for formation of the structures that we
see inside the thin sections or even
large-scale structures so one of them is
they control the yield strength of the
deforming rock so strength of the rock
is controlled by dislocations and their
movements they also can produce various
types of micro structures and subsequent
plastic deformations of crystalline
rocks the dislocations also do
participate in determining the grain
size of the plastically deformed rock so
a plastically deformed Rock has larger
grain size or smaller grain size is
actually controlled by dislocations and
this happens through a process called
dynamic recrystallization this will also
learn in the next lecture and it also
defines the nature and orientations of
the grain boundaries so dislocations are
one of the most important crystal
defects that we deal regularly in
looking at micro structures and so on
the dislocations are classified in two
segments one is edge dislocation and
another is screw dislocation now we will
first look at edge dislocation and then
we'll understand the screw dislocation
edge dislocation is much easier to
understand and comprehend but before we
go to actual scenario let's get a
concept that what is dislocation now
what we have here in this illustration
we have a block
say a crystalline solid and then by some
means we made a cut halfway cut through
the middle of this block now because
this would be deforming plastically let
us assume that to understand or to
visualize better let us assume this is a
piece of rubber and then if you push it
in this side the top part only leaving
not at the base so it would try to
squeeze in this direction but because
this part is fixed so at this segment
this material would be much denser so
eventually it would look like something
like this where this edge of this cut is
fixed there is no displacement and then
along this line everything got slipped
along the plane that you made cut or you
can call it a glide plane now this has
to move following a vector and if we
consider that this is a vector because
they are applying the force in a similar
same direction so we can term it as B
will learn what is B later but this is
the basic concept of dislocation that
one side of this cut or one side of this
line has got a slip and another side is
not slipped so this part experienced
sleep and this but not now because the
volume or other things has to be
constant so in this segment you might
have some rearrangements of the atoms
within the lattice so that it can
accommodate this unit vector
displacement within itself so the
lattice the atoms they are arranged
accordingly to accommodate the
deformation whether the other part are
not deformed or not
as well now this line is known as
dislocation line that separates the
slipped and non-slip part so now if we
are trying to look at in our actual
diagrams or actual illustrations so what
happens when a dislocation moves now in
this first illustration what we see it's
a perfect lattice structure there is
nothing and then we apply some sort of
force in this lattice above this line
which will refer as glide plane now
initially when you apply the force will
certainly push the crystals or atoms I'm
sorry the crystals on this side so these
crystals will move a little bit now here
comes the very interesting part now it
can happen that all atoms in this area
it can receive this stress they can move
at the same time and they end up by
slipping each and every plane to give
you a shape like this which we'll see is
going to happen at the very end but if
you have to do it at one time the stress
you require is significant and
experimental studies showed that the
actual stress that requires to deform is
few orders of magnitude less so there
must be something happening or the
lattices are accommodating the strain or
moving the stress such a way within
themselves that reduces the strength of
the Rock yield strength of this system
or the crystal
now this is how it happens so what
happens that this line of atoms they
move but then they displace a single set
of atoms as well so therefore it doesn't
have any connection at the bottom and
this is where we produce our first
dislocation or the cut that we talked
about in the previous slide that before
this the material got slipped and after
that it is unsleep and then this
dislocation moves one after another and
finally it achieved to this shape where
we actually see that and unit length has
got displaced now this is how this
slipped and unzipped lengths got changed
continuously and finally we get into a
top part slipped but it did not sleep in
a single process but step by step the
movement of dislocations is very very
similar the way silkworms move or the
way our terms move on the surface okay
so if we try to look at in a different
way there's this dislocation so imagine
that this is our dislocation line this
blue line here and then this is our
glide plane and this unit vector that
the dislocation moved on the slipped
side along the slip plane is an unit
vector and it's known as burgers vector
so burgers vector is the magnitude and
direction of the unit sleep now this
burgers vector the spelling is very
similar bu rger
that we eat as a snack is absolutely
different to that what we call burgers
vector burgers vector is named after dot
scientist physicist please his name is
Jan burgers so don't confuse these
burgers to her
to eat burger now this is the plane
along which we have that separates the
slipped and non-slip part so if we can
project this plane in our in a flat area
then we see that this is the dislocation
line so you are projecting this area on
this surface so the yellow side is the
slipped plane and this light pink is our
non-slip plane right so this part got
slipped and this part cut non slipped
and what is separating slip and non slip
is a dislocation line now dislocation
moving along this direction with the
unit vector unit burgers vector we can
introduce another vector here which is T
that tells about the unit vector tangent
to the dislocation line now in this case
this burgers vector and this tangent
vector are perpendicular to each other
when they are perpendicular to each
other this is known as edge dislocation
or the propagation direction of the
burgers vector or direction of the
burgers vector is perpendicular to the
dislocation line now here is an example
what we see that
therefore this B and T their directions
their vector directions could have any
angle right so between the burgers
vector which is the magnitude and the
direction of the slip and the line
vector T which is the unit vector
tangent to the dislocation line so as we
learnt that if B is perpendicular to T
then we call it edge dislocation if B is
parallel to T then we call it screw
dislocation and if B is neither
perpendicular not parallel to T then it
is mixed dislocation so what we see in
this illustration
and this is what we have learnt this
this vector where B is directed this way
and T is directed this way they are
mutual relationship is perpendicular so
this is my edge dislocation but here as
we see that B and T these two are
parallel to each other
so this is screw dislocation now if
there is other relationships like for
mixed dislocation then they form
something called dislocation loops you
just learn the term we won't go much
detail of this now this is how they look
like if we try to draw them so is
dislocation is something like this and
now we know that it is defined with this
P either flipped or straight where screw
dislocation looks like something like
that where the dislocation is moving in
this direction and here dislocation is
moving in this direction for edge
dislocation here are two models that you
can see this one is edge dislocation I'm
sorry this one is a screw dislocation
and this one is that edge dislocation
where this is the rotation axis and here
this is the dislocation line now the
avene doesn't matter whether you are
dealing with age or screw dislocation
the end products or the sleep more or
less they appear very similar at least
we understand for our lectures this way
they could be very complex but we
understand it this way that when we have
age dislocation this this is the
propagation direction and this is the
dislocation line so they are
perpendicular to each other but because
it continues to move so eventually get a
slip of unit vector burger burgers
vector
but here it slips this way so
propagation direction of the dislocation
is this and it also moved in these
directions so they are parallel to each
other but eventually we end up with this
burgers vector now doesn't matter at
least from a very basic idea we can have
these diagrams in your mind that doesn't
matter whether this is a dislocation of
true dislocation we end up with the same
type of deform structure for our basic
understanding but actual thing is much
more complex or it could be even complex
so let's talk about that how do these
dislocations move from one side to
another side of the crystal we had a
very basic idea when we saw that one
atom is moving relative to it next we
saw the also the movement of the
vacancies so one vacancy moves and then
one atom moves to its opposite opposite
direction but for dislocations as we
have understood so far that it has to
move along a particular crystallographic
plane or what we have learned as a glide
plane now not necessarily dislocations
could move along the glide plane always
life is not always happy so sometimes on
the glide plane we have some obstacles
in the form of interstitials and the
interstitials are sometimes so big that
dislocations individual dislocation do
not have the energy to move or to to
sort of ignore this obstacles and move
further on the same glide plane if that
doesn't happen then it has to find one
way to move to another glide planes and
move accordingly so when it moves along
a single glide plane it is known as
dislocation glide motion of dislocations
along a crystallographic direction what
we see here that it is gliding on a
single
these are your individual glide planes
stacked in a crystal okay now a client
happens when you have an obstacle which
is impeding their glide motion it stops
the glide motion and it allows the
dislocations to jump to another
crystallographic plane and then continue
glide so this is glide then climb glide
another obstacle then again climb and
then it glides again and this is how it
occurs continuously now you clearly
understand at this point that glides
requires less energy than climb because
it has to climb so it requires some more
energy and energy can come from various
sources we'll learn about it later so
eventually if I look at it in a
different form it looks like this so
this is the glide entire place so you
see a fixed this look a crystallographic
plane and the dislocation is moving from
one array of atoms to another array of
atoms without changing the
crystallographic plane but here in this
case we just see in a different way that
probably here there was an obstacle so
the dislocations move to the next level
and it changed is glide plane and
continued moving as we see here so this
is how the dislocation glide and
dislocation climb are conceived now
let's talk about the surface defects
surface defects are classified in two
segments so one is external surface
defect and another is internal surface
defect we won't talk about much or we
won't consider the external surface
defects but just to know that if atomic
bonds are broken over an area then you
create two free surfaces and the area is
double of the area you had it has some
other implications but we are
going to deal with this but we are
mostly concerned about internal surface
defects and within the internal surface
defects we have we can have surface
defects between the same phases and
between the different phases between the
same phases we have grain boundaries
stacking faults twin boundaries and so
on and we also can have grain boundaries
in within different phases and also a
different kind of interface boundaries
so from now on we'll mostly look at
grain boundary and twin boundaries also
kind of grain boundary we look at mostly
these two will ignore stacking fault for
the time being so what is grain boundary
we all talk about that the grain
boundary is straight grain boundaries
curvy grain boundary is serrated and so
on but from the crystal point of view or
crystallographic point of view a grain
boundary is a boundary between two
regions of identical crystal structures
if we are dealing with same phases but
different orientations now here we have
two examples this is iron oxide and this
is calcite you see that there
compositionally they are very same but
because they are differently oriented
maybe this grain here is oriented
differently compared to this screen here
and this is why probably we see some
lines in between them we see different
colors here this is cross polar this is
calcite through cross polarized light
this is a thin section and we see
different colors because the grains are
oriented differently we see different
colors this we have learned from our
optical mineralogy classes or mineralogy
classes now when we talk about different
orientations there are possibilities of
various orientations from 0 to 90
degrees or more so we classify them
mostly in two categories low angle grain
boundaries or ill age
B or high angle grain boundaries or H GB
there are also a classification tilted
and twisted grain boundaries we are not
going into that right now now low angle
grain boundaries as it suggests suggests
that one grain orientation can be
obtained by rotation of another grain
across the grain boundary about an axis
through an angle so that means I have
for example two grains now if my finger
tresses are the lattice orientations are
or so on then they can have different
really oriented by this angle and this
is the rotation axis okay so if this
angle is low then this is low angle
grain boundary if this angle is high
then this is high angle grain boundary
but how they look like so these are low
angle grain boundaries I have given two
examples as you can see that this
probably is defining one very low angle
grain boundary where this and this two
different areas or two different lattice
structures I am NOT saying the grain
stem yet but their angle is only four
degrees very less so these are known as
some sort of sub grain boundaries where
the angle between the two grains are
very very less and here this is also a
sub grain boundary with more with higher
grain boundary angles and what is
important that this could be probably
your grain boundary what is important
that these grain boundaries are marked
by dislocations and if we have
dislocations at the grain boundaries
that means the grain boundaries are also
the storage or a places where you can
find more or more dislocations then high
angle grain boundary as you can see here
this is your
grain boundary and in this case the
grain boundary angle or high angle is 40
degrees therefore this is high angle
grain boundary
now how high you need to make a high
angle grain boundary or how low you need
to make a low angle grain boundary that
varies from studies to studies but
generally 15 degrees or low is low angle
grain boundaries and 15 degrees or above
is high angle grain boundaries that more
or less the convention but sometimes
this 15 degree shifts to 10 degrees and
so on now there is another type of train
boundary where which is known as a twin
boundary when two differently oriented
crystals so it has a grain boundary but
they are attached together such a way
that they share some of the crystal
lattice points in a symmetrical manner
what we have seen in other images for
example if we come here the previous
slide the lattice of this grain and the
lattice of this grain they are not
sharing any of the atoms of the
neighboring grain but if it is a twin
boundary then they share so this is the
twin grain boundary okay so they share
so this line of atoms are shared in both
grains and if that happens then this is
a twin boundary tween is very common in
most of the geological minerals for
example this is a sketch of an albeit
mineral so this is a crystal without
twinning and these two blue Plains are
your twin flames and these are your twin
boundaries now twin boundaries we can
also classify in two different ways one
is contact twin boundaries or contact
two in flames and penetrative twin
boundaries or penetrative twin planes so
contact two in boundaries they share a
sort of single composition surface often
appearing as mirror image to each other
for example
we see here a quads or this is a laser
light but in penetration twins the
individual crystals have the appearance
of passing through each other like they
sort of penetrate one crystal and of
course it has to be done in a symmetric
manner so here are two examples what we
see here this one is 4pi right and this
one is for story light as you can see
from this it seems that it almost went
inside the crystal but that happened in
a symmetrical manner so this is how we
conceived so far a grain boundary we
have seen probably under microscope
different crystals their grain
boundaries and so on but actually if you
can scan it or if you can x-ray it with
some inner eyes then the individual
grain boundaries are like these these
blue lines and they are separated even
if their compositions are very similar
they are separated because their
orientations for example here the
orientation is like this and here the
orientation is like this so they are
essentially different for example here
the orientation is like this and here
the orientation is somehow like this so
they are somehow different and that's
why we see them in a different way now
this grain as as it appears here for
example if I can see that these grains
is extremely homogeneous there is no
dislocation inside in this area there is
no vacancy inside there is nothing so
it's perfect but that is not the case
always so this individual place can also
be deformed it may have also some sort
of sub grains and so on and therefore we
see different kinds of features for
example and loes extinctions in quartz
we'll learn more about it soon so we're
at the end of this lecture so I believe
with this lecture you are now more or
less convinced that whatever deformation
we see in rocks but
in ductile dominum Reformation they all
initiate at a very very micro scale in
atomic scale now how to how to feel them
how to understand that yes these are
there because they are in atomic scale
and unless you have some sort of very
very high resolution microscopes like TM
or so on you don't see them so in the
next lecture actually we will see and
learn what are the different expressions
of such atomic scale deformations and
their typical arrangements and what are
the different kinds of micro structures
which are responsible for all these
arrangements and deformations so this is
the topic in the next lecture we will
divide it in three segments the first we
learn Kathak lastic processes that is
not really some sort of in some in some
some study that involves all these
things we learnt but this is very
important in structural geology but then
we will go to INTRUST aligned
deformation and diffusion creeps where
these things that we learnt today would
be very important so till then goodbye
thank you
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
