Lecture 25: Physical Properties of Bitumen (Part 3)

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
Dec 1, 2023
In this lecture, we will discuss about Durability, Purity and Safety Tests.
Welcome back friends. If you remember in the last class, we were discussing about the physical
properties of bitumen. In the last class, we covered different consistency tests which
are used to characterize the flow behavior of bitumen. This lecture is a continuation
of the last lecture. Today, we will start by discussing about the durability aspects
of bitumen. When we talk about the durability test, what
does durability signify? Durability indicates the ability of any material to retain its
desirable properties over its lifetime. When it comes to bitumen, we are more interested
to see how aging affects the properties of bitumen over a period of time.
Bitumen ages during different stages of its use. It ages when it is during its hot storage,
it ages during the production when it is mixed at elevated temperature with the aggregates
and after the compaction in the field when the pavement is open to service, it ages during
its service period also. What happens during aging that the organic
molecules of bitumen which are present in the bitumen, they get affected by oxygen,
by UV radiation and also by changes in temperature. Here, oxidation is basically reaction with
oxygen is the most important factor which contributes to the aging of the bitumen. Because
of these processes, it can be an oxidation, it can be the effect of UV radiation, it can
be the effect of changes in temperature. Finally, the stiffness of the bitumen increases.
A way of describing stiffness, let us say we talk about the penetration value and the
softening point value. So, what we expect that after aging the penetration of the bitumen
will get reduced and the viscosity and the softening point of the bitumen will be increased.
Of course, the extent of this change that is reduction in penetration or increase in
softening point will depend on various other factors including the type of bitumen we are
dealing with. The aging of bitumen, it also increases the penetration index and if you
remember penetration index is basically a parameter which indicates the temperature
susceptibility of bitumen which we have discussed in our previous classes.
Shell bitumen handbook has given almost 15 different factors that are responsible for
aging of bitumen. Among these different factors, the important factors which are
identified are as follows. Oxidation which I said is the most important factor contributing
to the aging of bitumen. Volatilization where the lighter components in the bitumen and if
you remember from our discussion on chemistry of bitumen for example, the malty infractions,
they get evaporated because of high temperature. Another important factor is the steric or physical
hardening of the bitumen. We will be discussing about what actually is a steric or physical
hardening. This is also sometimes called as thixotropic hardening of bitumen.
And the fourth important factor which contribute to aging is the oxidation of oil. Before even we
move forward, I wish to comment here that even out of these four factors, the first two factors
are found to be more critical. These are the 15 different factors which Shell bitumen handbook
has shown that affects the aging of bitumen. You can see in the first column, we have factors
that affect bitumen aging. You can see the list, we have oxidation, photo oxidation,
volatilization, we have polymerization, steric or physical hardening and so on.
There are so many different factors and these factors are in turn influenced by various other
parameters such as the exposure time, the temperature at which the bitumen is exposed
or heated, oxidation, UV radiations and also the position of the mix in the pavement. Whether the
aging is happening at the surface or the aging is happening within the mixture.
Let us now discuss about these important parameters which we say contributes to aging
one by one. Let us start with oxidation. What happens in oxidation is that the exposure of
bitumen to oxygen create polar groups that contain oxygen and it tends to associate into micelles
which means it will agglomerate into larger size and this tends to increase the viscosity
of the bitumen. Specifically, we will see that because of oxidation, there will be a formation
of carbonyl group and a carbonyl group is nothing but a functional group having a carbon atom double
bonded to oxygen. So, we can have several different molecules in this form. So, it leads to the
formation of carbonyl groups. For example, we have ketones, we have carboxylic acids and so on.
So, this carbonyl groups, they increase the molecular weight because of this oxygen atom
being attached to the molecular system. The degree of oxidation, it depends on
various factors. For example, the temperature at which the bitumen is exposed to. It also
depends on the period of exposure, how long the bitumen is exposed to oxygen. It also depends
the film thickness which is basically the bitumen film thickness over the aggregate
particles. If we talk about the effect of temperature, studies have shown that above
100 degree Celsius, 10 degree Celsius increase in the temperature of bitumen can double the
stiffness of the bitumen. This means that if we have a bitumen, let us say we are heating it at
160 degree Celsius and at 160 degree Celsius, the bitumen viscosity now let us say is neta.
And if we heat the bitumen at 170 degree Celsius which means we are increasing the
mixing temperature by 10 degree Celsius. So, the bitumen which we will get after
heating it to 170 degree Celsius will have an approximate viscosity of 2 neta. So,
this means that the extent of aging is very high specially at higher temperatures.
The other factor which contribute to aging is volatilization or the loss of volatiles. Here,
the lower weight oils they get evaporated when the bitumen is subjected to higher temperature.
And what are these lower weight components? They are basically the components from the
maltene fraction of the bitumen. Loss of volatile is definitely a function of temperature and also
exposure conditions. Loss of volatiles basically depends on the diffusion rate and also the depth
of diffusion. Therefore, if we have a dense graded mix with higher film thickness which
lowers the depth of diffusion, in that case the loss of volatiles will be relatively low.
Another important point to note here is that most of the paving grade bitumen which is
in the industry, they basically have lower volatile components and therefore,
this factor is not very significant. The next factor which we are going to discuss
is the steric or physical hardening. What happens here is that even if you keep the
bitumen at a room temperature for certain period of time, it may happen that the viscosity of the
bitumen increases. You are not heating it, you are just keeping the bitumen at a particular place.
Why is this happening? Because bitumen has some polar components. If you remember,
for example, asphaltene is a polar molecular group, we have resins which are also polar
molecular group. So, these molecular groups, now since they are polar, they have heteroatoms
attached to it, they have the tendency to interact also within each other. So,
they interact within each other, the molecular orientation can get changed,
it can reorient itself, it can restructure itself and therefore, finally, the viscosity
of the bitumen can increase. Steric hardening can also happen because of slow crystallization
of waxes which are present within the bitumen system. However, this process is reversible.
If you apply the heat, the association which has been formed will disassociate and the
bitumen will go back to its initial state. So, this is basically a reversible process,
whereas the first two factors which we have discussed that is oxidation and
volatilization, they are irreversible processes. The last factor in our list is oxidation of oils.
Here what happens, the lighter components or the oil fractions within the bitumen,
they may sometime seep inside the aggregate pores. Now, this depends on the oxidation
tendency of the bitumen that how readily it allows the oil fraction to come out of it and
it also depends on the porosity of the aggregates. Of course, if the porosity of the aggregate is
higher, the chances of oil oxidation becomes higher. Out of these all factors which we have
discussed, I just want to reiterate that oxidation of bitumen is the most critical
and important factor which contributes to the aging of bitumen.
Now, let us see that how different factors affect the aging phenomena and it changes
various properties of the bitumen or the bituminous mixture. The first graph which
you see here, it is the graph between the change in the softening point in the y-axis
and the mixed temperature. So, this graph tells us that how the temperature at which
we are exposing the bitumen, it can change the aging phenomena. If you see that around let us
say 180 degree Celsius, the change in softening point of the bitumen is somewhere around 4 to 6
degree Celsius. The same bitumen if we subject to a temperature of let us say 200 degree Celsius,
this change can be as high as more than 7.5 degree Celsius. This shows that how critical
is the effect of temperature on the aging process of bitumen. Sometimes what happened that let us
say we have made a bituminous mixture and it is being taken to the site or it is still in the
plant and there is some delay in the process of compaction in the field. So, sometimes practitioners
or contractors, they have a tendency to heat the bituminous mixture just to ensure that the
workability is proper. Because the logic here is if you increase the temperature of the mixture,
the viscosity of the bitumen will come down and that will facilitate the workability of the
mixture. However, we have to realize that this increase in temperature if you are heating
additionally the mixture, the bitumen is getting exposed to higher temperature which can parallely
lead to subsequent aging within the mixture and this can be very detrimental to the long term
performance of the final bituminous mixture. The second graph, it shows the effect of film
thickness, the bitumen film thickness over the aggregate particles on the aging index.
And what is aging index here? It is a representation of the extent of aging. So,
here aging index is defined as the ratio of the viscosity of the binder after aging and
the viscosity of the binder before aging. So, you can see that higher is the film
thickness of the bitumen over the aggregate particles, lower is the aging index which
means that a bituminous mixture with sufficient film thickness can reduce the aging of the mixture.
Typically, the film thickness somewhere ranges from around 5 to more than 12 micrometers. So,
some of the literature says that on an average the desirable bituminous film
thickness is greater than 6 micrometers. The third graph, it shows the variation of
penetration at 25 degree Celsius versus the void content in the bituminous mixture. So,
this graph tells us how the voids in the bituminous mixture affects the aging phenomena.
Here you see that the initial penetration of the bitumen which was taken from the refinery
was found to be 100 decimillimeter and the penetration of the bitumen which was obtained
after mixing it with the aggregates was found to be 70 decimillimeter. So, of course, the bitumen
has undergone some aging during the mixing process because of which the penetration has
reduced. Now, what they have done? They have extracted this bitumen from different mixtures
which have variable void contents and what they found that when the void content in the
mixture is typically let us say more than around 6 percent, there is a very significant reduction
in penetration of the extracted bitumen from the mixture. So, lower are the air voids within the
bituminous mixture, lower will be the extent of aging. People have also tried to see that
how bitumen ages over a period of time and few of the studies have agreed that a hyperbolic model
can be used to describe the change in the material property with change in time.
Here delta p is the change in any property, let us say it can be a penetration, it can be
softening point, it can be viscosity. T is the time at which we are measuring the change in
properties and A and B are model parameters. So, here this can be seen from this particular
graph where you see that in the initial period when the value of T is less for example,
let us say when we have taken the bitumen, use the bitumen for the production in the mixing
plant and we have compacted it in the field, you will see that there is a steep increase in the
viscosity of the bitumen where the y axis represent the aging index which means the
viscosity has increased at a very faster rate. Once we have compacted the bitumen in the field,
now the mixture is not exposed to the extent of temperature it was exposed in the mixing plant,
is not it? In the mixing plant we were exposing the mixture to a temperature let us say around
160 to 170 degree Celsius, maybe more than 150 degree Celsius. When we compacted in the field,
the temperature of the mixture was still higher, higher than 100 degree Celsius,
maybe in the range of 100 to 130 degree Celsius. Now, once the mix has been finally,
compacted the temperature has come down and the pavement is open to traffic. Now,
the temperature of the bitumen or the mixture it depends on the ambient temperature or the
temperature of the location where we have used the mix, but of course, that temperature will
be typically less than let us say 70 degree Celsius. So, after the bitumen is put into service,
after the bituminous mixture is put into service, the exposure to temperature get reduced and now
the rate of aging it slows down and you can see that gradually the slope reduces.
And this slope here it of course, depends on various factors of the mix, of the bitumen,
of the film thickness of the bitumen over the aggregates and so on. So, overall what we have
discussed up to this particular slide is that aging is a phenomena which increases the viscosity of
the bitumen, which changes the properties of the bitumen over a period of time and there are
various factors which can affect the aging process. Temperature is one of the factor. In fact,
the type of plant can also affect the extent of aging. The same mix when produced in a drum
mix plant will have a lower aging in comparison to the mix if it is produced in a batch mix plant.
Why? Because in the drum mix plant there is a presence of water vapor which reduces the
oxidation process. The aging also depends on the bitumen film thickness, higher the film thickness
more is the resistance to aging. It depends on air voids, lower the air voids more the resistance
to aging. It also is dependent on the extent of UV rays. Now, this is typically applicable to the
only top few inches of the mix where the sun rays are basically incident. So, because of the UV rays
which are falling few inches first few inches of the bituminous mixture can have higher aging
in comparison to the mix which is at a lower depth. And it also as I said now this is something which
I already mentioned that the extent of aging also depends on the position of the mix.
Since the top surface is exposed more to oxygen and UV radiations, it is obvious that the extent
of aging will be higher in the top surface maybe first few inches of the mix in comparison to what
we get at the lower depth. This slide shows how the chemical components in the bitumen it changes
because of aging. Very briefly we have discussed about the chemical components of the bitumen in
the second lecture if you remember. Therefore, this particular slide we will be able to easily
understand. What happens is that because of oxidation when this oxygen atom gets
attached to the molecule of the bitumen mainly sulfoxides and ketones are produced which
increases the molecular weight of the entire system. Lesser amounts of dicarboxylic anhydrides
can also be produced and carboxylic acids are also produced typically at a later time after aging.
Now, this is what happens in the molecular orientation. If you see the four components
which we discussed that is the Sara fraction, saturates, aromatics,
resins and asphaltenes. It is seen that because of oxidation the lighter components the oily
fractions the aromatic fractions they over a period of especially in the initial period
during the production there is a reduction in the amount of aromatics. So, what happens when
the lighter fractions are exposed to oxidation for example, aromatics they will get converted
to resin like molecules, resin like molecules will get converted to asphaltene like molecules.
So, you see the asphaltene content it will increase over a period of time,
but the extent of increase is more significant during the production and compaction process.
Similarly, the aromatic fractions and the resin fractions they tend to increase in the initial
period, but once the bituminous mixture is put in service the extent of the change will become
lower and which is very obvious because the extent of oxidation will get reduced. And
additionally it is seen that the change in saturate is not very extensive in comparison
to the change in aromatics and resins. Having said this since now I hope that we
understand that what is ageing and what are the factors that contribute to ageing. Now,
let us see that how can we simulate ageing in the laboratory and try to study the ageing
phenomena of bitumen. The entire ageing phenomena can be broadly divided into two parts short term
ageing and long term ageing. Short term ageing of the bitumen happens mostly during production
and mostly during compaction. So, the binder it undergoes ageing when it is mixed with the
aggregates at elevated temperature and is finally, compacted in the field. After compaction when the
temperature of the bituminous mixture comes down and the pavement is open to traffic a slow process
of ageing will start and this will continue up to the entire life of the bituminous mixture and
this phenomena is called as long term ageing. So, this graph we have already seen in the
previous slide and just to recall the importance of this graph that the ageing is more significant
during the mixing production and the compaction of the bituminous mixture and during in service
the rate of change in ageing or increase in ageing is relatively slow. Here an important
point to note is that short term ageing basically happens because of two process loss of volatiles
and oxidation they act simultaneously during the production stage whereas, in long term ageing it
is mostly the oxidation which is more critical. Therefore, in the laboratory whatever test we
will use to simulate this process should consider these two effects. So, to consider the
oxidation and to consider the effect of volatilization short term ageing is done
using a thin film oven or a rolling thin film oven. They are used to simulate the
hardening process which happens during the production stage of the bituminous mixture.
The first picture it shows a thin film oven whereas, the second picture it shows a typical
rolling thin film oven. Let us discuss about these test methods one by one. Let us start
with a thin film oven test. Thin film oven is a simple ageing test where we have a oven and we
have a plate arrangement to keep the bitumen. Now, since in the plant the bitumen is basically
occupies a very thin film over the aggregate particles therefore, in the lab also the depth
of bitumen is kept low to replicate this thin film which is present during the production process.
Here approximately 50 gram of bitumen is taken and it is kept in the cylindrical flat bottom.
When you put the 50 gram bitumen in the cylindrical flat bottom it will occupy approximately the depth
of the film which will be created will be approximately 3 mm and this 3 mm of bituminous
film which we create is exposed to higher temperature which is similar to what we get
during the production process. So, the conditioning is done at 163 degree Celsius which you see is a
very high temperature and the shelf is basically continuously rotated at 5 to 6 revolutions per
minute and this process is carried out for 5 hours. After the completion of the test we will
take out the bitumen from the oven and we can measure the change in properties of the bitumen
which is change in property after the ageing and the property which we measured before ageing.
And this property can be anything it can be a change in penetration, change in viscosity,
change in softening point, any parameter can be used to quantify the extent of ageing that
has taken place. The loss or gain in weight can also be reported after the test.
Coming to the rolling thin film oven test, this test is a form of variation of the thin
film oven test. It is expected to age the bitumen to the same degree that we get in
the thin film oven test, but in a relatively lesser time. What we do here is that we have
some transparent glass bottles which you can see. So, a specific amount of bitumen is first taken
and it is put inside the glass bottle. This glass bottle is manually rotated so that this bitumen
covers the periphery inside circumference of the bottle and it occupies a thin film there.
We have several bottles and these bottles can be kept horizontally in these slots inside the
rolling thin film oven. The bottle is placed inside the rack at 163 degree Celsius and it
is rotated around the horizontal axis. Further what is done in this test is that the orifice
of the sample bottle it will pass through a point where we will blow air jet and this air
jet is blown around 4000 ml per minute which helps to purge the vapor which gets accumulated
inside the bottle. So, this rotation inside the rolling film thin oven is carried out for a
period of around 75 minutes after which we will take out the bottle. We will scrap the material
from inside the bottle we will collect the bitumen in a container and this bitumen we
can further subject to testing similar to what we have done in the thin film oven test.
We can measure the change in physical properties, we can measure the change in rheological properties
and then quantify the extent of short term aging that has taken place in the bitumen.
These are some typical pictures of a rolling thin film oven set just for your reference. You
can see that we have a oven and this is what the inside of oven looks like a close up view where
you can see that these bottles are placed filled with bitumen and we have a air jet here which will
blow air near the orifice of the sample bottle as it keeps rotating inside the rolling thin film
oven. Talking about the long term aging, long term aging in the laboratory is simulated using
a pressure aging vessel and just to remind you here we are trying to see the effect of oxidation
because oxidation is the primary factor which influences the long term aging of the bitumen
in the field also. So, here a pressure based process is used where we accelerate the aging
which is going to happen for a period of around 7 to 10 years in just few hours in the laboratory.
When this method was developed, it was developed in the Iowa State University. Several trials were
done to change the pressure the bitumen is exposed to, the temperature the bitumen is exposed to and
the duration for which the bitumen is exposed to that particular temperature. And then the
results of the obtained aged binder were compared with the results of that which is obtained from
the field. And finally, several changes were made and some standards were defined by which
we can subject the bitumen to long term aging such that this bitumen which we get after the
aging process will be similar to the bitumen which we will get from the field after approximately 7
to 10 years of service. These are some of the components of the pressure aging vessel.
We have a pressure aging vessel here, these are this is a tray system or a pan holder and this
is the pan which is put inside this pan holder. So, several pans can be put so that the amount
of bitumen which can be aged at a particular time is higher and then we have a vacuum oven
system to further do the conditioning. If we talk about the procedure, here we take
the RTFO age sample because in the field also long term aging will happen only after the short
term aging. So, therefore, it is important that the bitumen which we take and subject to long
term aging is actually the bitumen which has already undergone the short term aging process.
So, we take RTFO aged binder and it is placed in the steel pans which I just showed you in
the previous slide and it is kept inside the pressure aging vessel for 20 hours and the
pressure which is applied is approximately 2.1 mega Pascal. Initially when the test was developed
only 100 degree Celsius was used to subject the bitumen to long term aging, but then it
was found that this 100 degree Celsius can be too harsh for bitumen which is actually
used in a relatively colder environment and it can be too low specially for mixes which
are used at a location with very very high temperature very harsh climates.
Therefore, finally, three temperature ranges were decided based on the location where we
are going to use the bitumen. 90 degree Celsius is used in a relatively colder climate where
typically we will use a bitumen of performance grade 52 or less. We will talk about the
performance grade later in the presentation. This is a way of grading the bitumen as per
the superpave grading criteria. 100 degree Celsius is used for moderate climates typically
where the bitumen which will be used will be PG 58 or higher and 110 degree Celsius is used
for harsh climates where the bitumen which typically will be used will be of very stiffer
grades. After we subject the samples to this particular
pressure for this time of 20 hours and at a particular standard temperature, the sample
is further removed from the pressure aging vessel after releasing the pressure very gradually
and then the sample is kept in the oven at 163 degree Celsius for 15 minutes. After that
we will scrap the sample from the cans and we will put it in a vacuum oven for 30 minutes
at 170 degree Celsius and this is done to degas the entrapped air if any which might
have come from the pressure aging vessel. So, after the completion of this process we
have the final binder which is a long term aged binder and we can further subject this
binder to various tests and can determine the extent of aging which is occurred in that
particular sample. Now, researchers over a period of time they
have debated upon these aging methods on whether they really are able to simulate the short
term aging or the long term aging and researchers have also tried to find more simple methods
which can be used in the laboratory using simple equipments and the final goal is to
get a binder which represents or which can simulate the actual short term aging and the
actual long term aging. So, this particular paper is one such paper
that have tried to evaluate the use of a simple draft oven for simulating short term aging
and long term aging of asphalt binders. Like this there are several other papers, but this
is one paper which have been referred to even by other researchers for aging their binder
using a simple draft oven. So, now, we have come to the end of our discussion
on the aging of bitumen and the tests which are used to quantify the aging in the laboratory.
Now, let us discuss about the next test which is the purity test. Of course, it is of interest
that the bitumen which is used in the construction should be in its pure form. So, how do we
judge whether a bitumen is actually in its pure form? This can be done by a solubility
test on bitumen. What is actually done that the bitumen is dissolved or is diluted in
carbon disulphide or trichloroethylene. So, in these two solvents pure bitumen is
entirely soluble. So, what we do we take a bitumen of known weight, we dissolve it in
the standard solvent and after that this solvent is filtered through a glass fiber pad. Whatever
material is left on the glass fiber pad is washed, dried and it is weighed and we have
to ensure that the purity of the bitumen is at least 99 percent if it has to be used
for paving applications. The final test in our list is the safety test.
Safety test is done to ensure safe working conditions when workers are heating the bitumen
at the site to very high temperature. This safety is quantified using two parameters.
The first parameter is the flash point of bitumen and the second parameter is the fire
point of bitumen and the flash and fire point can be measured together using the Cleveland
open cup apparatus. What is done here that we have a cup a brass cup which is filled
with bitumen and then we continuously heat the sample and in between what we do we bring
a small flame and pass it over the surface of the cup periodically.
So, when the temperature of the bitumen will become very high typically more than 200 degree
Celsius, it may happen that the vapor which is released it will flash. So, that particular
temperature where the vapor of the bitumen flashes is basically the flash point of the
bitumen. Fire point is a temperature little higher than the flash point where these vapors
will actually combust and it will catch fire. So, for the safety both the flash point and
fire point are reported and we have to ensure that whenever workers are working in the field
they should not heat the bitumen to a temperature which is as close to the flash and fire point
of the bitumen. So, these two pictures are some typical pictures
which shows the Cleveland open cup apparatus and the procedure of flash and fire point
adopted in the laboratory. Now, since we have discussed many physical properties of bitumen
the different codes the IS code, the Indian specification code, corresponding ASTM code
and the AASHTO code they are listed in this particular table and if anyone is interested
you can just download these codes or purchase these codes if required and you can look at
the procedure which is adopted in the laboratory to carry out different tests or to evaluate
the different physical properties of the bitumen which we have discussed.
With this we come to the end of this presentation and in the next lecture we will start discussing
about the viscoelastic properties of the bitumen and we will also see some of the rheological
experiments which are carried out to quantify the viscoelastic properties.
Thank you.
