Lecture 29: Advanced Biological Wastewater Treatment: Membrane Bioreactors

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
Oct 22, 2023
This lecture contains Concept of membrane bioreactors, Types of membrane bioreactors, Fouling in membrane bioreactors, Advantages of membrane bioreactors.
Welcome everyone in this NPTEL online certification course on Biological Process Design for Wastewater
Treatment.
So, in the previous lecture we started studying regarding the advanced biological wastewater
treatment systems and in the previous lecture we studied regarding the fluidized bed bioreactors.
So, continuing further today we will be learning regarding the membrane bioreactors which are
nowadays used in the biological wastewater treatment.
So, membrane bioreactors certainly have membrane which is used in combination with the biological
processes.
So, membrane bioreactors used a combination of biological processes along with the membrane
filtration that is overall together called as membrane bioreactor.
So, in this case actually the degradation of any solid material or the biomass or of
that of the pollutant occurs inside the bioreactor tank.
So, we have all the COD etcetera gets removed in the biological reactor.
Further that separation of the treated wastewater from the micro-oxygen because the micro-oxygens
are present and the biomass is there and the pollutant occurs inside the bioreactor, so
we have to separate them.
So, there is option we can use the settling tank or we can use the membrane bioreactor.
So, in this case the separation of the treated wastewater from micro-oxygen it is done in
the membrane module.
So, MBRs operate with micro-oxygens agglomerated in the form of flocs and they are maintained
in suspension by mechanical mixing.
The membranes act as a selective barrier to these flocs and depending upon the characteristic
of the membrane they block substances of higher molecular weight or with characteristics which
impede their transport through these barrier.
That means we have two sections in a way.
One section in which the treatment of the wastewater happens where the pollutants are
biodegraded in presence of micro-oxygen, so this is step 1.
After that the micro-oxygen treated wastewater go to the step 2, where the separation of
the micro-oxygen occurs via membrane, so this is the membrane bioreactor.
So, we can see here the traditional wastewater treatment using an activated sludge process.
So, we have activated sludge process in which the wastewater is coming, the solid removal
happening in the physicochemical treatment, then some pretreatment happening, after that
in the activated sludge we have air which is there and the treatment happening.
After that we use the settler or the clarification unit where the settling happens, some of the
sludge is recycled back or other is wasted.
Now after this the treated effluent which is coming out is further sand filter and disinfected
before effluent goes out.
In place of that in the membrane bioreactor, here the case of external side stream membrane
bioreactor is given, there could be possibility of this membrane inside also.
So here again up to this section the unit, the treatment unit is common with the traditional
activated sludge process.
Then we have aeration zone also which is common as compared to earlier.
Now after treatment in place of clarifier and sand filtration we have a membrane system
where a membrane module is there which allows only effluent, treated effluent or clarified
effluent or effluent without any solid material and biomass etc. to go out.
This biomass or microorganism or sludge is recycled and some of the sludge is wasted
also.
So, this we are replacing this particular thing with membrane system in a membrane bioreactor.
So, this is the membrane bioreactor.
Now in the previous figure we can see the changes in the layout of the wastewater treatment
plant where the conventional activated sludge process is replaced with an MBR system.
It can be observed that the area required for the installation of equipment may be smaller
when the MBR is used.
Since we are not using any secondary settling tank in the MBR system.
So that means there is a configurational change is happening and actually the area required
will be smaller in the MBR system.
In addition to obtaining a reduction in the bioreactor volume because of this the MBR
can operate with higher sludge concentration.
So that means we can operate with higher sludge concentration, bioreactor volume will be decreased
and also the overall quality of the treated effluent is much better in an MBR system
as compared to in the activated sludge system.
So these are the advantages that we gain with the MBR system.
Now the MBR system was developed in 1960s as soon as the ultrafiltration and microfiltration
membranes were developed or were commercially available.
The original process was introduced by Dorr and Oliver.
However, it combined the use of an activated sludge bioreactor with class flow membrane
filtration loop.
The breakthrough of MBR system happened in 1989 with Yamamoto and co-workers idea of
submerging the membrane inside the reactor itself.
So this happened earlier.
The other key aspects in the recent MBR development were the acceptance of the modest fluxes and
the idea to use two-phase bubbly flow to counter fouling also because in the membrane bed reactors
the membrane, here the fouling is very important parameter which we will be discussing later
on.
So membranes used in the reactor, which type of membrane has to be used, what material
etcetera.
So membrane is a material that allows the selective flow of certain substance.
So this is the classic definition of membrane.
In the case of water purification or regeneration, the aim is for the water to flow through the
membrane but retain the undesirable particles on the other side itself.
So generally two types of membrane materials are used in the membrane bioreactor and these
are organic-based polymeric membranes.
So this is there.
Then we have ceramic membranes which are used.
So broadly two types of membrane materials are used in the membrane bioreactor.
Now these polymeric membrane materials and ceramic membrane materials, the different
types which are used include polyacrylonitrile, high-density polyethylene, polyethyl sulfone,
polytetrafluoroethylene and polyvinyl difluoride are used as polymeric membrane materials in
the membrane bioreactor.
In case ceramic-based materials are used, then the commonly used ceramic-based materials
include aluminum oxide or alumina, silicon carbide, titanium dioxide or titania and similarly
zirconium dioxide or zirconia.
So these are the commonly used ceramic membrane materials in the membrane bioreactor.
So certainly they must be having some comparison.
So polymeric materials, they are subject to mechanical damage.
So there is a possibility that if some very high flow rate is there, etcetera, then some
mechanical damage may happen.
So bundles of hundreds of hollow fibers are generally available.
They are also vulnerable to chemicals also.
It is possible that if the pH is low, then these polymeric materials may get affected.
That means their mechanical as well as chemical stability is lower as compared to ceramic,
sorry this is ceramics, ceramic membranes.
Now, but they are lower cost in terms of capacity as compared to ceramic membrane.
Ceramic membranes are higher cost, but they have very good chemical resistance and they
have higher mechanical strength and also they may be available in one piece per element
also as compared to polymeric materials which are available in bundles of hundreds of hollow
fibers.
So these are the certain comparison, certain advantages and disadvantages.
Ceramic membranes are better, but they have higher capital cost as compared to polymeric
membranes.
Now, types of membrane bioreactors, so how the membrane bioreactors may be there.
So we earlier took the advantage of external side stream module, so but there is a possibility
of internal submerged modules also.
So in the case of internal submerged modules, the modules are submerged inside the biological
treatment unit itself.
So that means we have influent which is coming this in the biological treatment system.
Here actually this system of module is such that it will allow only the water to go inside
this and this water will be taken outside, the permeate will be effluent, treated effluent
will be taken out.
So there are different 2, 3 modules or many internal modules are kept inside the wastewater
treatment or the biological water treatment section itself, the activated sludge process.
In the second case, the influent goes inside in the activated sludge process where the
treatment happens and after the treatment, the water along with the micro-oxygen is treated,
taken to the external module where the separation of the micro-oxygen, sludge, etcetera happens.
The treated effluent depending upon the requirement may be recycled and the permeate is taken
out.
So majority of the effluent will be taken out and further be treated depending upon
the requirement or it may be discharged as such.
So this is the difference.
So we have 2 membrane bioreactor types, one is the internal, another is the external one.
Now membrane with the external module, the filtration modules are outside the aerobic
tank, hence the name side stream configuration.
The biomass is either pumped directly through the several membrane modules in series and
back to the bioreactor or the biomass is pumped to the bank of modules from which the
second pump recirculates the biomass through the modules in series.
Usually the external and side stream configuration is used for small scale high strength applications.
So where the wastewater characteristic, the COD is very high, for that case this module
is used.
Now MBR with internal module, in the immersed membrane bioreactor configuration the filtration
element is installed in either the main bioreactor vessel or in the separation tank.
The modules are positioned above the aeration system fulfilling the 2 functions, the supply
of oxygen and the cleaning of the membrane also.
Usually the internal and submerged configuration used for larger scale but low strength applications.
So where the wastewater characteristics, the COD etc. is low.
Now the fouling in the MBRs is one of the most critical factor which affects the membrane
bioreactor performance.
So fouling is the process by which the particles, the collider particles, the solute micromolecules
are deposited or absorbed on the membrane surface or pores by physical or chemical interactions
or by mechanical action.
So in any case if the particles, may be collider particles or some micromolecules get deposited
on the membrane module, then it affects the performance of the MBRs.
Now there are various types of foulings which are possible, one is biological, so like bacteria,
fungi.
Then we may have collider particles like clays, flocks etc. getting deposited.
Then scaling the mineral precipitates, they may also get deposited.
Similarly organic pollutants may also be there like oils, polyelectrolytes, humectants etc.
So all these may get deposited on the membrane module and thus foul the MBR.
Now operating factors involved in the fouling, so critical flux.
When the operation is carried out with a constant flux, a gradual increase in the transmembrane
pressure is absorbed due to fouling.
So that means when we have a module, now the module is having certain pores.
Now when these pores are getting blocked, actually the pressure which is required to
maintain the same flow rate across the membrane, so that will increase.
So that means the TMP, the transmembrane pressure will be increased for maintaining a constant
flux.
This is what happens because of the fouling.
The sustainable flux is the result of the compromise between the fouling and productivity.
So since the operation with higher fluxes enhances the fouling, most MBRs operate with
the low fluxes.
So lower the constant flow rate, lower are the chances of fouling and we can maintain
that flux.
So this critical flux is important where the fouling is minimal and that critical flux
is always maintained for longer duration of treatment.
So this is how variation in the transmembrane pressure with operation time at different
fluxes.
So if flux, we can see the F1 is, flux is higher than F2 and this F3.
So we can see with lower flow rate, the time of operation is higher and the pressure drop
only after a certain time it will suddenly increase, whereas when the flux is very high,
this time of operation is much lower as compared to when the flow rate is less.
So we have to critically decide at what fluxes we have to operate the system.
So this is a critical factor.
Similarly, concentration of suspended solids.
An increase in suspended solid is generally considered to adversely affect the permeate
flux or lower flux and greater TMP will be observed in this case.
So we desire the suspended solid to be minimum present in the water.
A significant increase in the fouling rate happens when the volatile suspended solid
is increased from 6 to 10 gram per litre.
So this increase in the VSS also increases the fouling rate.
So this is again.
Then the sludge age or the sludge retention time.
So this is very important parameter for treatment of wastewater in the activated sludge system.
Now operation of the system with higher values of SRT leads to higher VSS content.
So that means though the sludge age is important factor and sludge age will affect the treatment
efficiency.
However, if the sludge age is higher, it will increase the VSS content in the reactor.
And if the VSS content increases, the chances of fouling also increase.
So we have to suitably decide in the membrane bioreactor that at what sludge age we have
to operate the bioreactor so that the membrane module can work efficiently and the minimum
fouling happens.
Also the level of dissolved oxygen in the reactor.
In general, the higher level of DO allow the system, the biological system to operate with
good filterability and low fouling rates.
So that means if we can maintain higher level of DO inside the biological reactor, the fouling
in the module will be less due to the formation of cake layers with lower resistance.
And because flocs have a larger size and they will be blocked easily and the overall structure
will be more porous.
So we have to see that we have to maintain a certain level of dissolved oxygen inside
the reactor always.
Now the effect of pore size and distribution in the membrane.
So what is the pore size of the membrane module?
This is also important.
Fouling which is caused by the deposition of organic and inorganic materials at the
entrance of the pores is irreversible.
So we have to see that in particular for organic and inorganic material.
So this can significantly lower the performance of membrane with larger pore.
So we have to select pores which are smaller in size so that the organic and inorganic
materials are blocked beforehand and they do not go inside the pores.
Because if they go inside the pores, then they will be blocking the pores.
So it is better to have decide the pore size and its distribution beforehand.
So the effective pore size should be known and for the system where organic and inorganic
materials are very high, after biological treatment we have to see that the pore size
is much smaller as compared to the size of organic and inorganic material so that the
blockage of the pore does not happen.
Now occurrence of fouling in the MBR.
So fouling occurs in number of stages, in particular like three stages.
So first the conditioning of the clean membrane with a contaminant increases in the TMP, this
is contaminant, increases in the TMP for short period.
So this is the first stage.
Then here the conditioning happens during the initial treatment itself.
Now the slow fouling during which the TMP increases linearly or shows a weak exponential
increase.
In the second stage the slow fouling will happen and the TMP will slowly increase.
After that the rapid fouling will happen with sharp increase in TMP.
So this we have seen here also, there are stages where there is nothing is happening,
only linear increase is happening and then we have exponential increase in the fouling
which is happening.
So this is the stage.
Events contribute to the occurrence of these stages like microbial flocks, EPS, SMP are
essential agents for fouling phenomena to occur.
So we can see the different stages.
So here the gradual clogging of the pores through the action of micromolecules which
is shown by open circle and then the microbial flocks which are bigger in size, the dark
circles is shown.
So we can see initially the pores are getting blocked by these micromolecules.
After that we can see these microbial flocks are also slowly and slowly blocking this fouling
this membrane and after certain time both are fouling and in fact because these microbial
flocks are now blocking the pores and these microbial flocks are bigger in size as compared
to the pores of the membrane.
So overall the smaller size pores, that means the micromolecules are also getting blocked
and they are not able to pass though their size is smaller.
So overall blocking or fouling is happening here, so this is there.
Now we can see in the stage 1, during the first stage the conditioning of the membrane
surface by micromolecules occurs.
So we can see here the conditioning is happening and the flocks can also reach the surface
and adhere reversibly to it, leaving traces of exopolymeric material undetaching which
contributes to the conditioning of the membrane surface, thus the pores are becoming clogged
here.
In the second stage, restriction and clogging of the pores, deposition of the flocks in
the regions where there is low level of shearing and the formation of thin biofilms and cake
layers in sub-region of the membrane take place.
So that means the microbial flock is coming, they are now slowly and slowly blocking.
Fouling occurs when operating with fluxes below the critical flux.
So under this condition if you are operating below the critical flux then fouling also
happens.
In this phase the contribution of EPS is significant.
So extrapolymeric substances which are coming, they also are blocking.
Then the stage 3rd, the phenomena of fouling becomes self-accelerating.
Some of the pores are totally clogged and result of this event is rapid and almost exponential
increase in the transmembrane pressure, the TMP.
So we have two types of substances or products which affect.
One is called polymeric extracellular substances, the EPS and the soluble microbial products.
So EPS are relatively broad class of substances of higher molecular weight which are found
in constituent matrices of biofilms and microbial flocks.
With regard to their chemical nature, these are predominantly polysaccharides, protein,
phospholipids or nucleic acids.
So they actually affect the fouling of material a lot.
Similarly, SMP, the soluble microbial products are comprised of various soluble substances
in the liquid phase such as polysaccharides, proteins, secreted by the microbial cells
and decomposition product of the flock matrices and cells and substances present in the waste
water.
Both of them are determined using extraction or separation techniques, but they affect
the fouling a lot.
How to operate and take care of the fouling in the membrane bioreactor?
So one of the option is to carry out the physical cleaning.
So it is carried out to restore the permeate flux and remove the fouling layer.
So this is physical cleaning can be performed after certain time for the membrane module.
One form of the physical cleaning is called as relaxation and consists of stopping the
permeate flow for short period with the continuation of the aeration substances which cause the
fouling are returned back to the liquid phase from the membrane surface.
The efficacy of physical cleaning tends to decrease over time and becomes irreversible
after certain time, so this is possible.
Then we have chemical cleaning.
This can be performed by implying low concentration of chemical agents in the form of daily back
washing.
So that means we have to daily back wash the membrane module and it can also be carried
out weekly with a higher concentration of chemical substance.
So if we are carrying out the back washing daily, we can use the lower concentration
of chemical agents.
If we are carrying out weekly, so we have to use higher concentration of chemical agents
as a preventive measure and this is done.
The transmembrane pressure is the main parameter for defining the protocol and thus the cleaning
frequency which is in practice can vary from every 3 months to once in a year.
So depending upon the TMP at which the system is operating, we can decide the chemical cleaning
frequency whether it should be daily or weekly or 3 days after.
So this will depend upon the transmembrane pressure.
There are certain advantages of MBBRs.
So there are many features and improvements involved in the membrane bioreactors.
One is the reduction in the equipment cost because we are not using the clarification
system.
Then also we do not need to use the sand filtration unit, etc.
So we can have reduction in the equipment cost.
Certainly the space requirement is much lower as compared to the activated sludge system
followed by a clarification unit and a sand filtration unit.
It improves the disinfection as compared to that other system and gets a better clarified
water.
The product, this system removes 95 to 99 percent of the BOD, COD, micro-oxygen and
nutrients from the effluent and lifetime is maybe greater than 10 years depending upon
how we operate the membrane bioreactors and how we are taking care of the fouling.
So MBBRs certainly have few advantages and these systems are growing and their operation
is slowly and slowly getting well known to the operators.
So depending upon the reactor size, the type of wastewater to be treated, the membrane
bioreactors are now becoming common in the wastewater treatment and they are being integrated
with the biological treatment process where the strength of wastewater is higher or the
strength of wastewater is lower but the quantity of wastewater is higher as compared to earlier
means.
So the integration of membrane bioreactor with the traditional system is increasing
and with the knowledge which is being gained and also with the quality of the membrane
module materials which is increasing, the usage of membrane bioreactor in the wastewater
treatment system is also increasing.
These are the different references which have been used in this lecture.
You can, you are referred to study these references further and thank you very much.
We will continue further with the advanced biological wastewater treatment in the next
lecture.
Thank you very much.
