Lecture 26

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
Oct 22, 2023
The lecture highlights the poetic world of Tara Patel whose delineation of the agonizing experiences of women made her a unique woman’s voice. Her only poetry collection Single Woman reflects the changing relationship of men and women in contemporary society.
Good morning friends and welcome back once again to NPTEL online certification course
on Indian poetry in English.
As you all remember in the previous lectures we have been talking about postmodern Indian
English poets and in the previous lectures we talked about two major poets namely Eunice
D'Souza and Lakshmi Kannan.
Actually credit goes to Eunice D'Souza who actually brought some major voices who were
not paid too much attention, some major voices especially those of women's voices in her
anthology entitled Nine Indian Women Poets.
And today we are going to talk about one of the most significant major assertive voices
of Indian English poetry namely of Tara Patel.
The worth of a poet usually we understand when a poet writes so many volumes and a poet
has got so many collections to his or her credit.
But you will be surprised to know that today we are going to talk about a poet who had
got only one volume or only one collection to her credit yet.
The sort of spark, the sort of power, the sort of theme that she took upon actually
made her a very revolutionary force to reckon with.
So before we go to talk about Tara Patel's works and her poetic oeuvre let us also talk
about the background, the scenario which actually prevailed during the time when Tara Patel
started writing.
All of you are reminiscent of the fact that Indian poetry in English especially Indian
writing in English has got three or four phases.
The very first phases as we have been talking about was the phase of colonialism when our
poets were actually imitating their masters.
I mean the English or the British poets.
Some of them were imitating the British romantic poets, some of them were also imitating metaphysicals
or whatsoever and then came the new wave that is of nationalism from 1900 to 1950 and after
independence we have seen the rise of modernism and this modernism also affected Indian English
poets.
Now we are in the phase of postmodernism and in postmodernist phase which actually is influenced
by many of the voices from different countries, from USA, from England and from some other
neighbouring countries as well.
So the period from 1980 to present can be considered to be the postmodernist phase of
Indian writing in English.
So this fourth phase was not only having poets who were males but women's voices also made
themselves heard in this phase.
As I told you earlier that we have already discussed poets like Eunice D'Souza and Lakshmi
Kannan but then there are some other voices also who might have not contributed that much.
Their voices were so forceful and in this regard we can talk about the voice of Tara
Patel, needless to mention that in the lectures that follow later we will also be talking
about Meena Kandasamy and then Tamsula Au, Mamang Dai and many more.
So Tara Patel is one such strong voice of women's poetry which actually belongs to the
period of this postmodernist phase of Indian poetry writing especially in English.
Now since I have said that Tara Patel became famous only because of her one volume or only
because of her one work that was entitled Single Woman.
Now in this collection you will find poetry which actually deliberates upon and discusses
the themes which are confined and confined only to women's issues.
Now who was Tara Patel?
Tara Patel actually was born in 1949, she had an early education in Gujarat and then
she switched over to Malaysia where she spent many years especially 20 years in Malaysia
and then she came to Mumbai where she not only started writing but she started working
as a freelance journalist also that was her job.
She was also familiar with Isim Ezekiel who not only supported but also appreciated the
efforts of this poet Tara Patel.
Tara Patel is a poet, a columnist and a freelance journalist.
Her only collection entitled Single Woman was published in the year 1992.
So naturally when a poet writes in 90s now you can think about what sort of change the
poet can bring about in his or her poetry.
So one can find a vestige of revolution because till now we have been talking about those
women poets especially who have been trying to assert their own voices and they are actually
they had been trying to write in a manner where one can say there was a sort of feminist
concern but too much of feminism or when the feminist voices started to be heard then actually
became some different topics.
Sometimes it is not only about a feministic voice but it is also about the self because
now the woman has come out of her own right of being a feminist and when the feminists
actually allowed them this expression, this free expression naturally the poets took into
their over some other questions but as an exception Tara Patel was confined mostly to
the issues of women's poems.
So her lone collection entitled Single Woman has got many famous poems, some of the poems
we shall take up for discussion and in order to see how Tara Patel in a very transparent,
in a very frank manner, in a very ruthless manner not only attacks the world of men,
not only attacks the world of men but at the same time Tara Patel actually uses a language
which is open, uses a language which does not have the subtlety of ambiguity or that
poetic ambiguity which many people consider it to be a sort of spark.
But what Tara speaks, Tara is very candid, very frank and she frankly also speaks and
writes about the body, the woman's body rather she very frankly talks about sexuality.
So this in a way became quite uncommon in a country like India where the males were
not writing anything so transparently about bodies but when it comes to women writers
or women poets they have started writing in such a fashion.
So some of the poems which are included in the collection entitled Single Woman are titled
Woman, then comes Request, then comes In Mumbai or Bombay, then Mother, then In a Working
Women's Hostel, then Now and Then and there are many more poems.
We shall take up some of the poems in order to make our discussion more interesting and
also to explore how Tara Patel even though one can find the treatment of women by men
in Tara Patel's work and especially but then there is a different sort of opposition and
the opposition is there is an opposition of misandry.
I mean it appears now they are not revolting against men but rather there is actually a
sort of yearning for desire and this desire can be satiated and fulfilled by men only
because in one poem after another we can hear the voices of loneliness, the voices of alienation,
the voices of dejection, the voices of despair, the voices of debasement, the voices of the
neglect of the body, the voices of marriage, the voices of unfulfillment in a romantic
marriage.
And at times there is also the illusion of love which is actually transferred with in
many of the writings of Tara Patel.
Now as I have been saying that Tara Patel's themes actually were confined to women's
issues and since she had only one collection to her credit then whatever poem we can take
up for the discussion we will find that there is a sort of agonizing experience of women
in the poems of Tara Patel.
And this agonizing experience is actually born of the unfulfilled desire and sometimes
of being abandoned, sometimes of despair, sometimes there one can find a sort of existential
crisis at times.
Now it is no more confined only to getting their equal rights which was actually one
of the main aims of the feminism movement but now there is actually a cry for love,
for relationship.
So, majority of these women poets they have actually been talking about relationships
of men and women.
There are at times challenges to the traditional norms but then one cannot deny the fact that
since there is a frank assertion of sex and sexual desires so there are sexual frustrations
also depicted in the poetic oeuvre of Tara Patel.
There are questions of unemployment but then this unemployment has also been treated in
a very different manner because this unemployment especially while dealing with the unemployment
in major cities where the poet says that the unemployed can sleep at any time of the day.
The unemployed people and then while talking about that poem, we shall come to that poem
if time permits us.
So, there she talks about how the desire increases and how the unemployed people often when they
get even a 10 rupee or a 20 rupee note or some money I think they start thinking about
so many things.
So, there is a conflict within selves then we can also find a class between expectation
and reality.
The world you expect of to be a sort of dreamy place but at times it becomes a very dreary
desert and then the theme of corporeality of the body is also working in majority of the poems.
So, since he has got only one collection it is actually time that we took up some of the
poems and let us start with the very important one which actually is entitled Woman.
I shall read some of the lines and it would not be possible to describe and discuss all
the lines but whenever there is a major line where we find Tara Patel's voice we can find
because the persona in Tara Patel it actually cries for a sort of voice and the voice for
a sort of fulfillment and then in such a way she actually talks about how the tradition
always comes in and between but such a tradition has actually to be revolted against and that
is why some of the poems of Tara Patel actually bring a sort of rebellion but then this rebellion
she considers to be good, she considers to be better and let us have a look at these
lines of this famous poem entitled Woman where she says, a woman's life is a reaction to
the crack of a whip, to the crack of a whip, treatment of women at the hands of men.
She learns to dodge it as it whistles around her but sometimes it lands on the thick, distorted
welt of her memory, they have actually been used to a sort of subjugation but this subjugation
actually becomes a part of her memory, the part of the memory of the persona and it
keeps the persona haunting time and again and what this welt of memory does, reminding
her of lessons learnt in the past.
So here the poet, the poet actually takes us back to the past where traditions were
most revered and the women were supposed simply to be a sort of commodity, they were
simply subjected to a sort of persuasion but now the time has come that the women can get
out of it, now the women can have a control of her own rights and duties, a freedom of
her own choice.
Then in rebellion she turned her face to the whip, then in rebellion she turned her face
to the whip till pain become a river in flood, wreaking vengeance.
Now an attitude of revenge, it was only in the past that they could be subjected to any
sort of persecution but now she has actually been able to turn her face to the whip, meaning
thereby she can confront now, she can confront the years of our tradition and she can rebut
it now, she ran away to live as an escaped convict or a refugee or a yogi in wilderness
of civilization.
So, what the woman can do or what the woman are supposed to do, she can run away from
all these things, she can turn the tables upon the man-made world and she can go to
live as a sort of escaped, as an escaped convict, the simile being used here or a yogi
in wilderness of civilization beneath the thick distorted self, distorted self of her
memory.
So, in her own memory she finds how women have been subjected to all sorts of persecution,
sufferings, anguish, pain and what not but then now she can look back and she can find
her distorted self of memory, she dreams, she keeps on thinking, it comes to her in
a dream, she dreams anyone could have touched baby smooth skin with kisses and we find
a sort of self-esteem, a sort of self-sympathy, a sort of aggression that she wants to wage
against the man-made world but at the same time she says, she dreams anyone could have
touched baby smooth skin with kisses, she is actually deprived of love.
But then in her wealth of memory she goes back and she actually yearns for a sort of
love.
So, it appears that a woman who has been subjected to all sorts of trials and tribulations
now, then when she stands face to face with their aggressors, she has only got a dream
and in her dreams she thinks if somebody could be so compassionate, if somebody could
shower the same lady with the kisses of a baby smooth skin on her.
But then this continues, the sort of love that the woman is yearning for this continues
in one poem after another.
Actually, Tara Patel's poems are revolutionary in the sense that not only does she talk about
a woman who has been subjected to all sorts of suffering but then in her heart of hurts
because now there is a sort of loneliness and the poet may also think of herself sandwiched
between either a sort of lonely person or a loner.
It is only for the time to decide and so in her yearning, in her desire, in her craving,
in her crazy body or in her crazy soul there comes a sort of request.
And to whom is this request?
This request is not to the feminist but this request is to the men of the world and to
the men who have actually left the women because there is a new age where once you become
conscious of your own rights perhaps after few years you feel yourself like a lonely fellow,
like a fellow who has been abandoned and then again the body and the heart they actually crave
for a sort of beseeching, they crave for a sort of request.
So, we can also take some lines from another poem that is titled Request.
Sometimes, now in the earlier poem we talked about how the woman goes back to her wealth
of memory, now in her wealth of memory when she thinks of all bad things, now she imagines
there is a different sort of imagination now and she imagines and in her imagination there
is a request and she says sometimes for old times sake you should look me up.
Now, here is actually the desire of a woman who feels herself neglected, who feels herself
deprived, who feels herself dejected, who feels herself as a cost of a thing and she actually
vouches and vies for a sort of love and love of whom?
Love of a man, love of a man who could satisfy her feelings, love of a man who could satisfy
her carnal desires, who could satisfy her wills, what are those wills?
You should look me up, have lunch with me, I will pay the bill, I will pay the bill,
how little I know you though I loved you for so long and still do for old times sake.
There is actually a dig on the man's world but at the same time a woman who feels that
she cannot live alone, she always vies for a sort of companionship, for a sort of friend,
for somebody to give a sort of companionship and that is why she says you should look me up,
have lunch with me and you see the irony and she says earlier the practice was that you
wanted to oblige me but now I want to oblige you but only for myself, I will pay the bill,
how little I know you even though I loved you for so long and still do for old times sake,
can you because I have been left, can you even for the sake of the old times, can you come,
can you have a lunch with me even at my own cost, you cannot forget me so completely.
Remember me a little and meet me sometimes, once in a while for a good luck, do not negate the
past, indulge me in the past, the memory which has always been very painful and perhaps we cannot
forget this neither you nor I but still even when you forget, can you really forget me completely
but even for the sake of that love, why do not you come for a good luck, why do you want to negate
the past because we always say it is all over, it is all over, you have to forget things and the
poem furthers not because I want to embarrass you by unfolding the past, I do not want to embarrass
you, it is not your lack of love which distresses me anymore, I am no longer obsessed with a blind
emotion, my emotions are no more blind which promises everything and nothing, you have to
be young forever to be in love like that. Actually, once this feminist phase is over
or the women have been able to get back their due, now but then the aging process with times
as one ages, as one has to live a life of abandonment, still one wants to revive one's old
times by saying young forever to be in love like that, the love that we had that might have been
sort of treacherous but still I want to retreat, I want to get that love back.
I will not bore you with detail of how I lived for months after your exit, it actually talks about
the disappointment and the dejection in love and still the persona here says I would not embarrass
you, I would not be talking about because you might be frustrated when I start unfolding the
memory lane and I talk about alleging you how you exit, how you left me and had an exit.
But because I am pining for an old pleasure, pining for, yearning for, craving for, thinking of,
have lunch with me one of these days, I miss you most when I am eating alone.
So, here there is the persona not only talks of recovering or retreating to the old love
in order to get herself have the feeling that one has always to be young to be in love like that.
And then the last stanza where she says a man should look up a woman sometimes for old times
sake, for reasons other than those which are obsolete, regions other than those which are
obsolete, have lunch with me, I will pay the bill. So, I am ready to pay the bill and she says pay
the bill, it can have different connotations. But then the poet, the persona here wants
simply to revive in the memory in order to have a sort of recovery, a recovery of the sort of
loneliness and the abandonment that she is facing and that is why she says a man should look up a
woman sometimes simply for old times sake, time passes on, time fleets fast, we become aged,
we become old, but then we can still revive, we can still have a sort of assertion, still we can
have a sort of satisfaction of our old time love. So, every man should try to look up a woman
sometimes for old times sake. Now, having seen and read this poem, you
might have noted certain concerns or certain characteristic features of Tara Patel s poetry.
Tara Patel s poetry, when she talks about tradition which actually binds a person,
tradition creates a sort of binding, but then we are advancing, advancing in terms of age,
advancing with the situation that are around us, the world is changing and in the changed world,
we should not say a goodbye to our old love. The setting is Indian, but time and again
you can find that there is a voice, there is a sort of outcry and this voice sometimes makes
us feel that it is persona s personal voice. As regards language, you can feel that the
language flows very spontaneously, it does not have the use of vocabulary which is very difficult
for people to understand, rather the vocabulary is very simple. Of course, as we take up some
other poems, you will also find that how these single women, they have to face different
situations in their life and specially in the metros where they have to face different realities,
the realities of growing up, the realities of a working woman, the realities of aging,
the reality of when you are sandwiched between social compulsions and your personal desire,
where the desire always is relegated to the back seat.
And then, there is a stark reality of women s life, where their freedom which they are vying
for and how this new freedom actually not only fills their own life with a sort of blessing,
but there is actually a sort of disgust, there is also a sort of disillusionment,
there is a note of alienation and loneliness, where people specially in metros they look for,
where there is a lack of communication you will find, the same lack of communication
which T.S. Eliot has written or mentioned in one of his major collections entitled
The West Land, where the lady also feels herself to be very lonely and she simply wants to talk
to her own person, her own man who simply says, yes, I remember we are in a rat celly where the
dead men lost their bones. So, there are talks of locked Indian womanhood where there is a tradition
and then there is also a critique of the dominance of man.
Here we can take up one line which actually denotes the anguish, the anguish of a lonely lady,
a lady who has been left, a lady who is vying for companionship and a lady who finds her freedom
bolted. Gift me a smile, a smile I can float on, I have nothing in my life to claim,
I have nothing in my life to clutch on, at least a smile can make my life easier.
Warm myself in, if you give me a smile, I can not only float on, I can rather move on,
I can save myself, a look, a touch, word, smile are all on part. I think a smile is just like
a touch, it is just like a look. I mean here the lady talks about a sort of indifference with
growing age, how the solitary woman suddenly becomes an object of indifference, an object
which does not attract any attention. So, there is a sort of cry, there is a sort of
self-denial. Now what the lady should do? And the lady now talks about how of now and then.
I mean there is, with the title of the poem only we can find that there is a sort of comparison
of the two pictures but unless and until we go through the lines we cannot understand the
nitty-gritty and the beauty and the benignity where the lady as I said, a lady who actually
being in a house, having all sorts of manifestations, having all sorts of facilities,
feels a sort of loneliness, a sort of disintegrity, a sort of disintegrated self that the lady becomes
and the lady says, you want to talk to someone, it is actually, time and again you will find you,
you, you. And who is this you? This you is none other than the persona of this poem.
You want to talk to someone, you want to talk to someone seriously, quietly, without the
distraction of getting angry, of crying or touching, you do not want to beg. Now the time has
come, then when the persona feels herself or himself alone and in this period of loneliness
she simply wants to talk to someone and talk to someone very seriously, very quietly, she is not
at all bothered about what the people will say now. So, see the new voice, the new woman's voice,
she is not at all bothered about what the world will say, you want to talk to someone,
not confidentially, not in private, the whole world must listen in, you want to talk to someone
because silence is a kind of suicide. My dear friends, the contemporary world has
become such where people living in the same tower, in the same apartment, they are all divided,
individual selves separated, there are many new things that are developing and the poetess has
very beautifully mentioned here and she says, now the time has come, then when I am thinking of
talking to someone seriously and I am not at all worried about what the people will say,
because now this silence is a killer, this silence will kill me, this silence is just like a suicide,
has not a time come when with growing age all of us become a thing of neglect and we want that
we should be paid attention to and specially somebody who was loved once upon a time and then
somebody who is actually yearning, longing to hear the voices of love, the voices of compassion,
the voices of cordiality, the voices of commitment, you want to be a teen.
Hike up a hill, again goes welt, the well of memory, you want to be a teen, you want to go back,
kiss beneath a lime tree in the light of a hundred candles before a Catholic shrine,
no regulations now, I want to go back to enjoy the pleasures of the past and then the new woman does
not bother about what people will say, the colour of genias burning in your eyes, the desire just
like the beautiful genia flower, here the poet actually talks about the genia flower which is
planted and grown in America, fine. And then she is not confined only to long for a talk,
rather she also says, you want to eat oranges, try dodging raindrops, make clouds in your coffee,
when did you last look into a mirror, age has come upon you and when did you last look up into
a mirror and smile like a geranium petal, when did you last dream, when did you last get wet,
when did you last became emotional, when did you last became romantic.
So, the old days actually are hounting at the back of the mind of the lady, you want to talk
and talk to someone other than yourself, now you do not want to talk to yourself because this
silence cuts you to the quick, you want to have a sort of companion, fine. This isolation in a
metro city, no, it is actually killing people, every now and then people appear to be quite
alone, in the end you do not want to talk to anyone, you want to keep quiet, you want someone
to talk to you, you have talked to yourself too much. So, there is a sort of introspection now
and you cannot talk to yourself anymore, rather you want someone to talk to you,
someone should ask you about how you are, someone should ask you about how your days are passing by,
someone should say some amount of sympathy, some amount of compassion, some amount of love,
some amount of concern because this aging will not stop.
And this aging and this passing on, no, sometimes becoming a loner, sometimes living in a woman's
hostel and then there is another poem which is entitled in a working women's hostel, this actually
talks about the fate of those women who have to take their shelters in the hostel because at least
in the hostel they could get some companions, at least in the hostel they can come across
some other people and specially in a women's hostel where they can share their joys, where
they can share their sorrows and the lines of the poem are very beautiful my dear friends.
So, let us look at some of the lines even though time is always wanting but then we can always
continue. The evening is an experience of high tide, twelve stories above the city,
no, the persona of this poem goes to the terrace because inside there is complete silence,
inside there is isolation, goes to the terrace in order to see the world moving,
in movement alone is rest my difference or you see how she questions herself,
am I lonely or am I a loner? So, there is a sort of conflict, there is a sort of self-doubt and
she thinks have I been left alone or am I a loner, is it my fate, is it my attitude,
the difference must be resolved quickly now, my private communion is overlooked by superior
balconies and terraces and then as the lines move further she says, a patchwork of lights
coming on complete godly with the stars, the rising full moon tells a familiar story.
So, there is an analogy between the full moon and the lady here, so thinks about how the moon
also is alone, a bridge purrs inspires fear, a trip over, now see the beautiful use. So,
when we whenever we talk about the word purr we are suddenly reminded of cat and when we are
reminded of cat we are reminded of the sort of fear that the cat very beautifully purrs,
the silver wings fluttering on the crazy floor, a distant sea roars in my ears.
So, from the t from the terrace I can come across all sorts of feelings and look at the sky,
look at the sea and then I can hear a sort of roar in sight, up here flight is a dangerous illusion,
crying is a terminal argument, I return to my room. So, having found nothing, having simply found
some analogies of loneliness I come back to my room and in the second part the persona says,
waking up at night is a symptom of aging. What actually makes us all revere Tara Patel
is the way her line flows without any inhibitions, without any botheration but there is a natural
flow and she says, I kick inside the warm weather when there is loneliness, nobody,
no companion then I suddenly retreat to my own self, I look at my own limbs, I actually touch
my own thighs is an embarrassment in the winter cold, I try to fold myself up in supplication
to hear myself more clearly, it is actually very confessional.
And and she says, listening to my own confessions is a third degree past time, I function as a one
woman courtroom, I have sealed up my life, I, I, in black, I have sealed up my life in black
envelopes, I have sealed up my life in black envelopes. So, black stands for darkness,
black stands for negation, addressed to no one in particular. So, what is there? I find myself
that I have no companion with me, no one to come and join me as a companion and I find I have
sealed up my life in black envelopes addressed to no one in particular, addressed to no one in
particular but then confidential, it is the rough wool of a man you want tonight and every night.
So, the bodily, the carnal desires and then towards the end, she says, a woman can feed
herself, love begins with a man, to leave alone is of course, a very difficult task
and you need human companion. So, here the woman talks about a woman's desire but then we have seen
and many of the poems of some other poets where even, even other poets have also mentioned about
this loneliness and then they have actually been longing for human accompaniment and so on and so
on, the color of bones is in my hair now and I have come to a standstill, it appears as if
everything has come to a standstill, the passing days have a posthumous touch to them, the passing
days, it appears as if it is a posthumous touch to them, now I do not feel any touch,
now I do not have any regret because now I am still yet I think of, I think of my own confession,
am I lonely or am I a loner. So, this conflict between the self,
between the body and the soul continues in one poem after another.
So, having discussed all these now, we can find that Tara Patel's poetic world is full of
Indianness where you can find about certain traditions, where you can also find about the
use of many Indian words in the form of imagery, gulmohar, sindoor, poetry, saree, all these
things are there, there are mythological characters also getting mentioned in the poetic world of
Tara Patel where she talks about Ram, Sita, Krishna, Yogi and all, majority of her poems
have got Indian settings and it would not be out of, it is not be a sort of exaggeration to quote
here what M. K. Nayak says about Tara Patel, what she says is that interesting feature of Patel's
verse is the sparseness of imagery in it, sparseness of imagery in it, it is a poetry
of transparent directness, one can find that the language is very direct, it is perhaps here that
the influence of Ezekiel is to be seen, you must remember that Ezekiel was a great support and
Ezekiel had also influenced Tara Patel too much. So, it is unfortunate what he says is,
it is unfortunate that Patel ceased to publish after her first collection, she did not have
any other collection after her first work but then the amount of, but the amount of knowledge,
the amount of pain, suffering, the amount of anguish which we have found in Tara Patel's
poetry is full of despair and existential crisis where in one poem after another you can find a
note of despair as if in some other poem where we find a sort of alienation in now and then
where she talks about you want to talk to someone because silence is a kind of suicide,
such powerful lines that we come across. So, and then in a way she challenges the male hegemony
but then as Bruce King has rightly said that there is actually a treatment of women by men
but then the opposition is not a sort of misandry, I mean in earlier poets we have
found that they have talked about man's indifference but here we find the persona of
Tara Patel actually wise for, yearns for human company, for men's company and that is why she
says you are cursed by your parents, you cannot love voluntarily.
So, again there is a dig on the tradition and she says that all sorts of relationships have
been hampered because you cannot love voluntarily, you cannot love somebody because you want to love
or because you have a choice. There are quite many things in Tara Patel's world but then we can find
that Tara Patel is free from the mention of sexual taboos and all, she actually at times appears to
be very unconventional but what she speaks comes out from the depth of her heart. We can take
one very important poem entitled Calangute Beach, we can take some of the lines before we come to
end this talk, when in this poem, the poem is entitled Calangute Beach where she talks about
how she denied the advances to an American for whom she had her longing but then she could not
because the persona in this poem is actually an Indian and she says his invitation to go
swimming naked was turned down, a long brown look accentuated the loneliness of my inhibitions.
And then what is of utmost importance is when the poet says both of us knew there was no time
for persuasion, I needed, I should have gone to share the sun's wine, sun's wine with him,
it is such a man's arms, it must be permanently afternoon, it is such a man's arms,
there must be pleasure, there must be complete happiness but then again she takes a dig where
she says women sleep in India just skin deep baby, for weeks I can brood of nothing else,
he is a growing regret, she shows a regret, he is a growing regret, the denial to him was a
sort of regret and then a very beautiful metaphor is being used here, like a red bulb off and on
reminding me of men I cannot afford because traditions come in in between and that is how
I find life to be left alone, life to be lived without any companion.
So, having discussed all these we can take some of the critical assessments or critical
views about Tara Patel very quickly where Eunice de Souza what she says is Patel s work is
weariness so extreme that it sounds almost post Thomas and what Bruce King has said
no matter how much about tragedy or even if victims usually end in victories, triumph,
affirmation, heaven, dignity, Patel simply ignores such expectations and conventions,
she actually is unconventional as I have been saying, she has written a book of poems about
life s disaster without pretending it really is not so bad after all.
So, Patel does not consider herself to be a poet but then as readers when we read her poems,
we find the real poet that Patel was and Paniker and Chandraka in their article says,
the woman who suffers and the mind which creates are so closely identified here,
I mean the woman who suffers and the mind that creates us the one and not two.
What Tara Patel has to say, it said without any disguise, without any deception, without
any inhibition and that is what we have been belabouring over in this lecture and I think
that we have been able to understand the real worth of Tara Patel.
And before I close, let me take a very important line from Tara Patel who says,
my permanent address is hell and further you already remember when she says, I function as a
one woman courtroom, I have to decide for myself because in my court, I see my cases being discussed
and it is my own courtroom, I have sealed my life in black envelopes addressed to one in particular.
I think with this, we have to wind up this talk. Thank you very much. I wish you all a very good
day ahead. Thank you. Waiting for you to discuss on another topic where we shall discuss another
woman poet named Menaka Sibdasani. Thank you very much.
