이스라엘-하마스 전쟁: 언론이 이야기하지 않는 것 [ATL:NOW]

NTD Korea
703 팔로워
255 비디오 조회수·2023. 10. 18.
여러분의 후원은 큰 힘이 됩니다.
하나은행 (주)에포크미디어코리아 415-910022-14004
깨끗한 세상 깐징월드로 영상을 시청하세요
https://www.ganjingworld.com/ko-KR/channel/1f908nu4fl03sApAWetIeZ7Ly1vd0c?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=ntdkorea
앱으로 보기 편한 에포크TV
https://kr-mb.theepochtimes.com/app
© 에포크타임스 All Rights Reserved.
Hello, everyone, and welcome to American Thought Leaders Now, our spinoff series of the original
American Thought Leaders program. Today, we're going to do something a little bit different.
Our associate producer here on the show, American Thought Leaders, is Karis Rea. Karis has also
been involved in a number of different Jewish organizations, including the Jewish Leadership
Project, and we're going to talk about the situation in Israel together.
Karis, it's great to have you.
It's so great to be here on camera with you. Thank you.
Yeah, it's amazing. You're usually behind the scenes. And we've been talking a lot about what
has actually transpired in Israel with this Hamas invasion. And I guess we just decided that we have
to share some of our thinking. Why don't you just tell me, for starters, how you think things stand?
Yeah, so today, there have been about 1200 Israelis that have been butchered by Hamas
terrorists. That is the equivalent to around 30,000 or 40,000 Americans, if you adjust for
population. And this is a very big deal, not just for Israelis, but for Jews around the world,
because this is the greatest loss of Jewish life in a single day since the Holocaust. And I don't
think that a lot of people watching this from the outside necessarily understand that Israel is a
very small country. It has about 9 or 10 million people in it. And, you know, it's the size of New
Jersey. It's very small. And it's surrounded by enemies and existentially trying to survive as
the sole Jewish state in the world amidst a sea of about 50 Muslim states and many, many Christian
majority states. So I think Jews and anti-Semitism are frequently taken out of the equation here,
what's going on. But for both diasporan Jews and Jews in Israel, this is really an attack on their
identity. Well, I want to mention one more thing here. A lot of people don't realize this. There's
only about 14 million Jews in the world. And somehow, I've actually tried asking people
from time to time what they think, and they generally believe it's a much larger number.
Right, right. And this is in comparison to about 1.5 billion Christians, I think is the latest
estimate, and about 1.4 billion Muslims. So if you just imagine that, if you imagine 14 or 15
million Jews next to over a billion Muslims and Christians, I think that really puts the whole
thing in perspective. I think Americans might be shocked by that statistic because we are all
familiar with the Jewish community, right? I mean, half of all, half of these 14 or 15 million Jews
basically live in the U.S., and the other half lives in Israel. And then there's a small community
here and there in France, in Britain, in Argentina. But the Jews have virtually been
wiped out from most places in the world, including the Middle East. A lot of people
are familiar with Palestinian refugees, but not a lot of people are familiar with the fact that
close to 1 million Jewish inhabitants of Arab countries were ethnically cleansed in the late
1940s. Most people don't hear about that because this was around the time that Israel was established
and Israel absorbed them with open arms, and they eventually became citizens of Israel.
But anti-Semitism is really something that I think the mainstream media leaves out of this
equation when talking about this conflict. I watched some hit on MSNBC the other day, and
for 10 minutes, they were trying to come up with explanations for why Hamas would launch
such a brutal attack on innocents. And they never mentioned Hamas's charter. They never
mentioned their goal. They never mentioned what they're so clear about trying to achieve,
which is not a Palestinian state, as many people in the West assume,
but actually the destruction of global Jewry.
It says in their charter that they want to eliminate every Jew from the land of Israel,
from the Zionist entity, and then move on to the rest of the world. So we're talking really
about genocidal anti-Semitism here. Unfortunately, in a lot of Arab Muslim cultures, kids are still
raised with Jew hatred from a very early age, right? You have books like Mein Kampf or the
Protocols of the Elders of Zion, which are still very, very popular in these places. And it's
really become part of their mentality as they grow up. And this is the case in Gaza, too,
because Hamas rules with an iron fist. It's a terrible, terrible regime to be living under.
And they raise their people in the curriculum, in the mosques, in the media with state-sanctioned
anti-Semitism. One of the things we've been discussing is this has been a clarifying moment
for some people, certainly a lot of people I've spoken to, some people you've spoken with.
They didn't realize the brutality or just the extreme depravity of the type of things that
happened during this invasion—desecration of corpses, rape as a tool of war. There are many
things that children—I have a close friend whose friend's grandmother was executed while they used
her own Facebook live stream to alert the world to what was happening. It can be hard for people
in the West to fathom this kind of thing, the glee that's shown on the faces of some people
committing these acts and so forth. I think that when people are brought up with this idea that
it's okay and right and good to hate people, their very existence, it can lead to that.
It's incredibly disturbing, just as a concept. I think this is one of the most
terrible forms of abuse that's inflicted on people is to teach people that way,
to believe that hate of any sort is not only acceptable, but is an appropriate and almost
positive somehow thing that you should accept in society from a very young age.
Yeah, absolutely. There's been this mainstream media, this messaging going on for decades,
really since the Six-Day War, that this conflict is really about land. But in actuality,
if you go back in history and you really understand how this conflict has played out
and you listen to Palestinian media, not just in Gaza, but also in the West Bank,
formerly known as Judea and Sumeria, then you recognize that this is actually a tribal war,
that this is really about ideology. It is really about religion. Jews have been hated
since time immemorial, and anti-Semitism is a really interesting form of hatred. It's no worse,
no better than any other form of hatred, but it functions a little bit differently than, say,
anti-Black racism, for example. Anti-Semitism is sometimes very difficult to recognize unless
somebody is blatantly saying something like, gas the Jews, like we just saw at the Sydney Opera
House, where thousands gathered supposedly in support of Palestine, and yet they were chanting,
gas the Jews. Anti-Semitism punches up as well as down. What that means is that in addition to
Jews being seen as lesser than, inferior, vermin, rats, they are also seen as all-powerful,
master manipulators, the puppet masters holding the strings.
The protocols of the Elders of Zion material.
Exactly. Fundamentally, anti-Semitism at its core is a conspiracy theory,
and it morphs to suit the needs of a given society. Jews are historically the scapegoats
when something is going wrong in society. At the beginning, Jews were hated because we
supposedly killed Christ. We were hated for our religion. Then after the Enlightenment,
science and even eugenics became the highest of moral values, and Jews were then hated for their
race. During the Holocaust, Hitler said that Jews were a race and that we were the inferior race.
Now, the values that are very important to us in society are human rights,
international human rights. The shift, it's moved from Jews as a people to Jews as a nation.
Israel is the collective Jew. It's the only Jewish country in the world. Like I said,
it's the size of New Jersey. Yet, the amount of focus on this tiny country that we get from the
media and from academia and even in our halls of Congress is just staggering. Nobody imagines why.
Nobody imagines that less than 100 years after the Holocaust, this could have anything to do
with anti-Semitism. I think there's another element here too,
if I may. Increasingly here in Canada and the United States, there's been a whole load of
education around how the West is collectively, Western civilization is evil. It probably
shouldn't even exist and is the source of a lot of the ills of the world. I think Israel,
being the only Western nation in that region surrounded by a whole bunch of countries which
have a very different value system, the Western approach is the source of evil in the world.
If it wasn't for the U.S. doing all the terrible things it does, we'd be in a much better place.
I think that's a preposterous view, but I think that also lands on Israel in the area of same
vision. I think that speaks to an incredibly successful propaganda campaign that have led
academics to believe that Israel is some sort of Western colonialist nation coming in and
stealing indigenous land, when in reality, again, we can get into the history. I'm very happy to do
that, but that would take quite a long time. If you go back in time, you see that
Jews have never left this land for thousands of years. They never left despite so many of them
being exiled from the land. They always, always came back. There was always a presence there.
The land was known as Judea and Sumeria. Arabs are from Arabia. The French are from France,
and Jews are from Judea. It's very, very simple. You might say, well, aren't Palestinians from
Palestine? What a lot of people don't know is that the term Palestine is actually a colonialist
invention. It was always Judea and Sumeria until the Romans came and conquered the region.
They had to disassociate it, once again, disassociate the land from its roots. They
renamed the land Syria-Palestina, referring to the Philistines who were battling with the Jews.
So that term Palestine isn't so much indigenous as it is colonialist. The identity of a Palestinian
actually referred to Jews before 1948. You had something like the Palestine Post,
which was a pre-Israel newspaper that was a Jewish newspaper. The idea of a Palestinian
Arab as a national identity started in the 1960s with Yasser Arafat.
But before then, Palestinians didn't see themselves as a distinct national identity.
They saw themselves as Arab, maybe Syrian Arab or Jordanian Arab. That doesn't mean that now
they don't identify as a people. They certainly do, and that's valid. But if we go back and we
trace the roots and the indigeneity, we find cracks in the mainstream narratives about Palestine.
When Jordan illegally occupied the West Bank after 1948, which nobody talks about,
people love to talk about the Israeli occupation, but nobody talked about
Jordan when it was occupying Judea and Sumeria from 1948 to 1967. They ethnically cleansed
its Jewish inhabitants from that region. They destroyed synagogues and cemeteries. It was
horrific. And in order to disassociate the land from its Jewish roots, they renamed it the West
Bank, meaning west of the Jordan River. And so a lot of what people today consider Israeli
settlers in the West Bank, a more accurate moniker for them would be refugees,
because many of them are simply returning after they had families one, two generations ago
that were ethnically cleansed from that land. Nikki Haley was really attacked the other day
for her comments in the media. She said, this is not just a war on Israel. This is a war on America.
And I understand why she was attacked. And I don't think that that was necessarily a
a productive way to say what she wanted to say, but I understand her sentiment.
These jihadist groups, Hamas, Hezbollah, ISIS, and there's so many too in South Asia and Africa,
they might seem like distinct enemies because they're all kind of fighting with each other
and vying for power. But if you actually look at their charters, if you read their charters
and you read what they want, they all have the same goal, destruction of Western civilization,
right? And the replacement with a global caliphate, Islamic caliphate. And that starts with
the Jews, right? Because Judeo-Christian values, right? Jews in a lot of ways are the foundational
element of Western civilization, or at least Western morality, right? And so they first believe
that they have to wipe out the Jews, global Jewry, and then you go to America, and the rest
of the West will fall. So that's kind of what Nikki Haley meant by that, because she really
understands the ideology behind these fundamentalist groups.
Thanks for that, Karis. I do want to touch on one more thing. And it's just something I've
observed. For example, looking at the Russia-Ukraine war from the beginning. In the U.S.,
at least, and certainly in Canada, let's say the powers that be have been telling lots of lies.
Basically, a lot of people feel like they've been propagandized. They don't want to trust anything
that's coming from the narrative. In some cases, people have this reflexive reaction to be
just whatever is the narrative, the opposite must be true. I even understand that and sympathize
with it. If you stand with Ukraine, then that became almost like a tribal moniker or something
like that. You couldn't just say, look, this is terrible. Ukraine has just been invaded by Russia
and people are being killed. I see a similarity there. People are hearing, you need to stand with
Israel, right? And what does that mean? And some people, because of this phenomenon I just
described, reflexively go to the other side of this without really just thinking about what
happened. I want to encourage people to think about what you saw, think about what happened.
Because it's such a small population, relatively everyone almost knows someone by one or two
degrees of separation that has been impacted in a horrible way—killed, abducted, whatnot.
There's a lot of near first-hand accounts that are possible for people to get.
I want to explore this a little bit.
Even myself, I have family there in Israel and I just found out yesterday that that kibbutz where
those 40 babies were butchered and some of them decapitated, I realized last night that I had been
to that kibbutz. I stayed on that kibbutz for a week because my first cousin used to live there
and work there with her boyfriend at the time. His whole family is still there. They hid in a
bomb shelter for over 48 hours. Thank God they are all safe, but most of their friends are dead.
To your point about Ukraine, I sympathize with people who are hesitant to jump on any
sort of bandwagon, especially when it comes to war. When you say I stand with Israel versus
I stand with Ukraine, you're saying something a little different. When you say I stand with
Ukraine, what you're saying is I stand against Putin and I stand with Ukraine in terms of it
being victorious in this war. But when people say I stand with Israel, I hope what they mean
is that they recognize that this is an existential war for Israel. It's a war of survival. Israel is
the only country in the world that has become acceptable to question its right to exist.
We talk about taking out the Iranian regime or the North Korean regime, but we never
question these nations' existence, their right to exist as a sovereign state.
When you say I stand with Israel, what you're saying is I stand with the existence of Israel
as a Jewish state because there's been such an accepted narrative that Israel has no right to
exist. I watched Tucker Carlson the other day talking about some of our officials' responses
to this. God bless Tucker. I think he's wonderful in a lot of respects, but I think he really missed
something going on here. He's wary of us getting into another war. He criticized Lindsey Graham
for saying that Biden should be threatening Iran right now and he thinks that we should
stay out of it. But I don't think Tucker understands the details. Here's what he's
missing. Israel faces Hezbollah in the North, which is another genocidal terrorist organization
that has as its foundational mission the destruction of the Jewish state and every
last Jew inside it. Hezbollah has 150,000 missiles, more precise missiles than Hamas has,
pointed directly at Israel. Everybody in the North is terrified that Hezbollah is going to
take advantage of this moment and they are going to strike. There has been a massive mobilization
of Israeli troops on the northern border. They might even start evacuating the Kibbutz there.
And if Hezbollah strikes, Israel will need assistance from the U.S. and from Europe if
that situation arises. So I actually support what Lindsey Graham said. He offered a very good
deterrent to this situation that would almost guarantee that America is not dragged into
another war, which nobody wants, and that is to threaten Iran's capacity to produce oil.
All Biden would have to say is, should you give Hezbollah the green light, because Hezbollah,
just like Hamas, is a puppet of Iran and they take instruction of when to strike from Iran.
If Hezbollah gives the green light to Hezbollah, Biden could say, then we will send a few missiles
over and we will take out your oil refineries. Iran has four oil refineries. If Iran has no
capacity to produce oil, the regime is done. This is what they rely on. They are sanctioned
by most of the Western world and they get all of their money from China, from North Korea,
from Russia through oil. And I cannot imagine Iran would take the muzzle off of Hezbollah
if they thought for a moment that we were going to destroy their capacity to produce oil. That is
what deterrence means. And so the way that I looked at Lindsey Graham's proposal is actually
a way to prevent America from entering a war. Karis, thank you for sitting down with me
on camera for once. Thank you. And now it's back to work.
