In dieser Episode von @BreakingLab widmen wir uns dem hochrelevanten Thema: Nahrungsergänzungsmittel, kurz NEMs. Diese kleinen Pillen und Pulver, die oft als Mittel zur Verbesserung unserer Gesundheit beworben werden, sind in den Regalen der Supermärkte und Apotheken allgegenwärtig. Viele Menschen greifen auf diese Mittel zurück, um mögliche Nährstoffdefizite auszugleichen und ihre Gesundheit zu fördern. Doch wie viel Wahrheit steckt hinter den Versprechungen von NEMs, und sind sie wirklich die Antwort auf unsere Gesundheitsbedenken?
Gefällt Dir mein Kanal und möchtest du Danke sagen? Kanalmitglied werden und exklusive Vorteile erhalten: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC-Ivlaz1y9TToFnpzmA7adw/join ⏩ Erst informieren, dann supplementieren: Gerne schauen Sie einmal rein in meine Ratgeber https://bit.ly/RatgeberHowTo ✅ ❎ 100 % unabhängig ❎ 100 % studienbasiert ❎ 100 % medizinisch korrekt
Die Vielfalt der auf dem Markt verfügbaren Nahrungsergänzungsmittel ist überwältigend. Es ist kein Wunder, dass viele Menschen vor den Regalen ratlos stehen. Die Branche boomt, da wir zunehmend darauf achten, unseren Körper langfristig optimal zu versorgen, und NEMs scheinen eine einfache und erschwingliche Möglichkeit zu sein, gezielt Nährstoffe aufzunehmen. Allerdings sollten wir nicht vergessen, dass eine ausgewogene Ernährung normalerweise ausreichend ist, um unseren Körper zu versorgen. Dennoch können NEMs in Situationen helfen, in denen es schwer ist, eine optimale Ernährung aufrechtzuerhalten.
Es ist entscheidend zu verstehen, dass verschriebene Arzneimittel nachweislich wirksam sind, während NEMs in erster Linie unterstützend wirken und keinen nachgewiesenen Nutzen über die Mangelbehebung hinaus bieten. Ein kritischer Punkt, der Nahrungsergänzungsmittel betrifft, ist die fehlende wissenschaftliche Überprüfung. Im Gegensatz zu verschriebenen Medikamenten unterliegen NEMs keiner strengen Kontrolle, was ein erhebliches Risiko für Verbraucher darstellen kann. Die Quelle, aus der Sie Ihre NEMs beziehen, ist von großer Bedeutung. Der Preis allein ist kein Indikator für die Qualität eines Produkts, und Pestizide in NEMs sind ein unnötiges Gesundheitsrisiko.
Es ist unerlässlich, genau darauf zu achten, was in NEMs enthalten ist. Selbst die Form eines Nährstoffs kann entscheidend sein, wenn es um die Aufnahme durch den Körper geht. Wechselwirkungen mit anderen Medikamenten sind ebenfalls möglich und können die Wirkung beeinflussen.
Erschreckend hohe Ausfallraten bei Produkttests zeigen, dass viele NEMs nicht das halten, was sie versprechen. Das bedeutet ein reales Gesundheitsrisiko für Verbraucher. Sogar für Sportler gibt es ernsthafte Bedenken. Ungeprüfte Leistungssteigerungsmittel können langfristige Gesundheitsschäden verursachen und sollten vermieden werden.
Die Risiken von Nahrungsergänzungsmitteln überwiegen in den meisten Fällen. Je größer die Versprechungen sind, desto skeptischer sollten Sie sein. Wenn Sie weitere Informationen zu NEMs suchen, werden Sie auf meinem Kanal fündig!
▬ Über diesen Kanal ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
Mit „Video-Visite Dr. Weigl“ haben Sie den aktuellen und medizinisch-wissenschaftlichen Kanal gefunden, der Themen rund um die Bereiche Schmerzen, #Medizin und #Gesundheit verständlich aber basierend auf Fakten, Richtlinien und Studien beschreibt.
Rechtlicher Hinweis / Disclaimer: Die Videos dienen ausschließlich Ihrer Information und ersetzt niemals eine persönliche Beratung, Untersuchung oder Diagnose beim approbierten, qualifizierten Facharzt. Insbesondere bei Medikamenten gilt es Rücksprache mit Ihrem Arzt zu führen und die Packungsbeilage zu beachten. Die zur Verfügung gestellten Inhalte können und dürfen nicht zur Erstellung eigenständiger Diagnosen verwendet werden. Haftung ausgeschlossen.
Facebook- & Instagram-Icon: Icon made by freepik from www.flaticon.com Twitter-Icon: Icon made by Pixel perfect from www.flaticon.com Sound effects obtained from https://www.zapsplat.com 3D-Bildmaterial: Sharecare YOU Pro Website: https://www.sharecare.com/
Three quarters of all Germans take supplements and that underlines a pretty clear trend.
Every year, more supplements are produced in Germany.
What these vitamins and minerals really do is pretty advanced.
Yes, it should be recommendable from a medical point of view,
if many people compensate a possible under-supply with supplements,
because they may not be able to do it otherwise.
That's the theory for now.
But that there are also problems, Breaking Lab has looked at it
and I'm curious to see if you end up with a similar opinion on food supplements as I do.
And let's take a look at that together now.
What does this do?
So, before we get started, hello, my name is Dr. Tobias Weigel.
With my YouTube channel, I would like to make a contribution,
to clarify medically understandable and correct about diseases,
topics such as sports, nutrition, including supplements.
And if you don't want to miss anything, feel free to subscribe to my channel now.
In order for us to do well, we need nutrients, i.e. macronutrients,
but the basic components of most foods, i.e. carbohydrates, fats and proteins, form.
But micronutrients are just as important.
These include vitamins, minerals and trace elements.
We don't provide them with energy,
but they are important for metabolism, growth and energy production.
In drugstores, supermarkets and the Internet,
you can find countless offers for food supplements.
And the offer, as you say here, is really unclear.
And I can't blame anyone
if you get confused and stand in front of the shelf without any advice.
And in the end, the sheer mass probably causes you to take something
and simply put it in the shopping cart.
The industry is booming,
especially because we are increasingly concerned with
how we can provide our body with optimal long-term supply.
And food supplements are a supposedly simple
and usually also supposedly cheap way
to shoot up targeted nutrients.
Metabolic tuning is also a key keyword.
And a lot of it really has to do with being an influencer.
Maybe we'll get to that later.
So, and before we go any further,
a reference to my advisors,
because here I sometimes call alternatives to food supplements,
such as the best foods.
These are examples of foods that are part of a healthy diet.
Containing important macronutrients, important micronutrients,
or also this advisor here.
And this is especially about the topic of supplements.
Supplements for weight loss, supplements for muscle build-up.
What they can do, but where you have to be careful
due to dosing side effects.
So feel free to take a look at my shop if you are interested.
On the shelf there are mostly tablets, pills or capsules.
In addition to the vitamins, minerals and trace elements already mentioned,
there are also food supplements with amino acids,
essential fatty acids or fiber.
But also things like plants and herb extracts are actually quite in trend.
With food supplements, many people want to prevent diseases better,
improve their own fitness or compensate for defects.
Yes, as I said, the choice is increasing
and because a lot of nutrients are also offered in combination,
it is not so easy to find the right one for you.
Absolutely.
I would like to emphasize here that a balanced diet,
i.e. a healthy diet pattern with sufficient proteins,
this is a protein-rich diet pattern,
with a lot of fiber and with healthy fats,
usually automatically leads to a sufficiently well-nourished body.
Also in today's time, with the keyword,
yes, no longer so nutrient-rich soils, etc.
But sometimes it's not that easy in everyday life.
That's true and that's where the food supplements help
to maintain the illusion of optimal nutrition.
And very importantly, we often think that we eat healthy,
but in reality we don't do that at all.
But now let's take a look further.
With food supplements, many people want to prevent diseases better,
improve their own fitness or compensate for defects.
In a survey by the Federal Institute for Risk Research,
it turned out, for example, that 57% know or suspect
that they have a vitamin D deficiency.
Yes, exactly, I would have guessed that now.
Especially with vitamin D, there is a very committed community,
let's call it that, which voluntarily takes in vitamin D preparations
to compensate for a possible deficiency or undernourishment.
The vitamin D industry does a lot of advertising, let's call it that.
I have combined a lot of information in this guide.
And to be honest, I didn't want to do this as an advertisement,
but it says everything about vitamin D.
It's called the vitamin D bible.
Very important, two or three important facts about vitamin D.
First of all, you should always compensate for a deficiency,
no matter what deficiency you have.
Second, up to 4,000 units per day are permanently taken in,
without hesitation, for a short time, for one to two weeks.
In order to get out of a deficiency, up to 10,000 units per day are okay,
but only for a short time.
And thirdly, it is better to take 2,000, 3,000 or a maximum of 4,000 units per day
than to take 10,000 or 20,000 units per week.
More about this, as I said, in my independent book.
And another piece of information, yes, I also take vitamin D.
And now let's continue.
Over a third of Germans take vitamins in the form of pills or tablets at least once a week.
And here you can also see with this statistic why the topic is so relevant, so important.
If we take something with us every day or at least weekly,
we should be sure that the ingredients are really healthy
and do what we expect and hope for.
Why this is not always the case, we will see in a moment.
And then also very important, so many people supplement and you can always ask yourself,
has anything really changed in the health of these people because of this?
What is missing are studies that show that long-term intake of nutritional supplements,
be it vitamin D, be it vitamin B12, whatever, be it omega-3 fatty acids,
that they alone reduce the mortality risk in the long term.
That is so crucial.
What really proves it is that if you reduce certain risk factors in the long term,
such as unhealthy nutrition, that is, a healthy diet,
lack of movement, smoking, alcohol,
then you know that this lowers the mortality rate.
But there are no permanent studies or long-term studies that show
that the supplementation of this or that nutritional supplement lowers the mortality rate.
And there you have to make a clear distinction.
Nutritional supplements and drugs are very similar,
but the similarities end here.
Right.
In principle, drugs are supposed to cure diseases,
nutritional supplements are not.
That is, you are not allowed to apply them with preventive,
relieving or healing effects.
That's pretty crucial.
Yes, that's very important.
It's great that you say that.
I'm going to go into that in more detail in a moment.
Because that is of crucial importance for you as a consumer.
It's important to know that prescribed drugs have a proven effect.
They have to prove it.
Then you have to do studies.
And then the preventive effects that consumers promise themselves, of course.
And you can say that about these drugs.
Nutritional supplements have the most supportive effect
and ensure that the immune system acts on a normal level, for example.
You can't say that it promotes the immune system.
So we have drugs with proven effects and nutritional supplements
that can potentially compensate for a deficiency,
but don't have any additional effects.
That's important.
They contribute to the body working, but they don't heal.
That's a big difference.
There are also different legal foundations for this.
With vitamin pills, it violates the right to live.
Nutritional supplements are by definition food.
Headache pills, for example, are against the right to take drugs.
And that has pretty far-reaching consequences.
So there are very different procedures for both.
If you want to put a drug on the market,
it has to be approved in a trial first.
At the Federal Institute for Drug and Medicine Products
or at the European Central Authority.
Manufacturers then have to do studies
and prove that the drugs really work and are safe.
So it's pretty complex.
With nutritional supplements, it's much faster.
You just have to fill out a form online at the Federal Office for Consumer Protection and Food Safety.
And that's the key point for me.
And you should know, you have to know
why I'm more reluctant to take nutritional supplements.
Headache pills are perhaps a harmless example
because possible consequences are not so serious.
But even with really potent, dangerous drugs,
an effect is scientifically proven
and thus exceeds the potential risks.
At least it should always be.
That's why it's also mandatory that it's based on a recipe,
that we doctors use costs and do analysis.
In some cases, of course, you have to expect side effects.
But then you look very closely
whether benefits outweigh risks
and then, in case of doubt, it's not allowed, of course.
There have always been cases in which the process was flawed,
and subsequently severe side effects also occurred.
Yes, that unfortunately also happens.
Extreme case, contagion scandal.
But these are, you have to say, exceptional cases overall.
No control takes place with nutritional supplements.
You just have to fill out this form
and often you don't even know how these
nutritional supplements are then mixed together,
what comes in there, so to speak.
So, very important, a proof is necessary for drugs.
Nutritional supplements, actually anyone can do that.
You don't have to prove in advance
that the nutritional supplement is safe.
So you could put it on the market
where in the end there's nothing in it
or in the worst case something completely different
than what's on the package.
So only very few substances are explicitly prohibited.
But in the form you can already
write the taste of the nutritional supplement.
And that's a problem for you as a consumer, of course.
Especially the Internet.
The Internet is full of supposed miracle remedies
for, for example, everything.
Hair growth, child's desire, muscle growth,
more or less explicit healing of diseases.
Sometimes you even hear about cancer, cancer healing.
And in the end, none of this is proven.
And at this point we have to talk about the ingredients.
Because at the moment, only vitamins and minerals are regulated
which may be included in nutritional supplements.
For other substances, such as amino acids or herb extracts,
there are simply no regulations.
So you can mix things up in a colorful way.
Micronutrients like vitamins and minerals
are super important for our body,
but too much of it can actually be dangerous quickly.
They can cause cancer under certain circumstances
or, for example, the absorption of other nutrients
can be inhibited by such an overdose.
Right.
And the risk of an overdose is high.
Because to date, there are no uniform maximum quantities
for these micronutrients in nutritional supplements in the EU.
There are some countries with national regulations,
but Germany is not one of them.
The Federal Office for Consumer Protection and Food Safety
simply writes on the website
that quantities on the packaging can vary by up to 50%
from the actual amount in the product.
What the fuck, 50%?
That's why you, as a consumer, should also pay close attention
to what is in the products.
But often you can't even check that logically.
You can only look at the back.
And there are also big differences.
Because not every magnesium supplement
contains the same form of magnesium.
Magnesium citrate, magnesium sulfate, whatever.
And that can be decisive
when it comes to how much is actually absorbed by the body.
That's also a big difference.
Each of us takes food and nutrients differently.
If you also have to take medication,
it can also have side effects.
An aspect that is not taken into account at all.
And that can then hinder or intensify the effect of medication, for example.
So we can only hope that, as soon as possible,
it will really be controlled
and that you, as a consumer, can really reliably inform yourself
what is in the food supplement.
Because 50% deviation is a lot.
And it's actually inexplicable
why such a large range is also permissible.
And second, it's just important to know
which substances, with which diseases,
how they interact with their medication.
And not somehow promise some miracles on the Internet,
which then also has no legal consequences.
Because such health claims are actually not allowed at all.
But where there are no plaintiffs, there are no judges.
Because of the rather loose regulations,
there are again and again substances in food supplements
that you would otherwise make a pretty big deal about.
According to Verbraucherzentrale,
you can find in food supplements of foreign manufacturers
regularly pesticides, illegal ingredients,
of course toxins and microbes.
This is especially the case with products from the USA,
Canada, Asia and Eastern Europe.
So almost the whole world.
In principle, such food supplements
should not be sold at all.
But as I said, the manufacturer is responsible for the safety.
So, I just said it,
be sure to pay attention to which source you use food supplements.
Of course, food supplements are also produced
as cheaply as possible.
And apparently that means
that we also have to live with pesticide food supplements.
They want to make the same profit,
the same as the pharmaceutical industry, the food supplement industry.
That's why I would make sure
that the food supplements are already produced in Germany, in the EU,
and tested by an independent institute.
Fresenius, for example, or others.
Then you have at least a bit of orientation
to better order something from the Internet
that comes from somewhere
where the manufacturer is ultimately not at all tangible for us.
And try to find out
and then get the people in front of the court.
Especially retailers on the Internet are often not fair to him.
So at the first EU-wide Internet check in 2017,
and you have to let yourself go on the tongue,
the authorities found in 80% of the tested online shops
non-transportable food supplements.
55% even received so-called new foods
that have no permission.
Among them also very dangerous, such as the chemical dinitrophenol.
Dinitrophenol is often advertised as a fat burner,
but it also enriches the body
and can therefore be life-threatening.
So really surprising high numbers
if you've never heard of it, then you're really surprised.
With many of the products, the advertising promises are so adventurous
that you shouldn't be surprised.
80% of the total is of course not negligible
and represents a clear real health risk for every buyer.
So great that he mentions it here.
Please, everyone has to be aware of this.
Well, okay, because food supplements are among the food cells,
food monitoring is responsible for the control.
And because food supplements don't need permission,
the checks only take place when the products are already on the market.
And the checks are only test-based.
But the most blatant thing is,
these test-bases are found almost only in shops.
So for tests from the Internet,
there is actually no legal basis in Germany.
So with few exceptions, almost no testing is done.
In 2022, more than 31,000 new food supplements were released on the market.
At test-bases between 2018 and 2021,
the responsible authorities of the federal states
only took over 14,000 samples in total.
More than 6,000 of them were finally approved.
So around 42%.
This means that the food supplements were usually not properly marked.
There were inappropriate health-related information
and misleading advertising promises.
And some even violated the drug law,
exceeded the maximum amount or were health-harmful.
Okay, so for me as an athlete, these are of course frighteningly high numbers.
I have already pointed out the positive effect of protein powder in one or the other video.
But this is a completely different league.
This is about something else.
And I can only appeal here,
do not do without such unserious products from the Internet.
We hear it here, there is hardly any control.
You have to face that.
And although we have to talk about random findings
in the case of food supplements,
almost half of all tests are still dangerous for us as consumers.
If food supplements, then from trustworthy sources.
And only if a proven deficiency has to be fixed.
Don't just take it like that.
And above all, it has no effect on any healing.
That half of the controlled foods
actually have to be thrown out of the shelf first.
However, you also have to say that the controls are of course risk-oriented.
That is, what has already been conspicuous is also strongly controlled.
So you can't transfer it one-to-one to the market now.
And I don't want to panic.
But overall, the results are a bit like you think.
You should think about it.
Sure, that relativizes something.
It's good that you say that.
But overall, there seems to be a real risk, as I said,
that we could get questionable or even health-harmful products on the Internet when buying supplements.
We should at least know it.
And I think most of us were not aware of it.
It becomes really critical, especially when manufacturers deliberately mix doping substances in food supplements.
Often, such manufacturers want to achieve a strong effect through the doping agents
and thus ensure mouth propaganda so that the demand rises.
Like other manufacturers, they sometimes don't even know the prohibitions and monitoring lists of the World Anti-Doping Agency
and mix illegal doping agents completely unknowingly.
And especially often you can find the food supplements that are supposed to provide better muscle build-up, fat loss or booster effects.
And we've certainly all heard the news of cases where professional athletes were somehow locked up
because they noticed doping samples and were completely surprised and said,
I'm not doping at all, it can't be.
And especially in the fitness sector, i.e. in bodybuilding, in strength sports,
there are really mountains of workout boosters, regeneration aids, performance-increasing agents.
And if you look on the Internet, on TikTok you can also find all the routines, the supplement routines,
which will be thrown in 6-7 pieces tomorrow.
This means that we should be particularly careful in these areas,
because the potential training successes are not worth it
if you take the risk of damaging your health in the long term.
It is important to rely on tested and proven supplements,
e.g. whey proteins or creatine monohydrate from proven sources.
You can google that, you can look and at least rely on the manufacturer's statement on the Internet.
Or if it says on the back and, for example, an independent institute is mentioned there.
Almost 45% contained at least one potentially health-threatening substance,
22% even more.
A study has shown that in Australia, Great Britain and the USA,
between 6 and 9% of all doping cases in professional sports are due to food supplements.
In a study, 110 food supplements were examined,
which are related to such earlier doping cases.
In 24 cases, almost a quarter, the respective doping agent was not even on the label.
So that means it was mixed in, but you can't actually check it or read it.
It is difficult to say how big the problem with doping agents in food supplements in general is.
You would simply need more controls, which unfortunately do not exist.
Yes, back to the topic.
Now you as a non-professional athlete could say that a possible blockage is not a big problem for you.
But that's not the point, because the fitness studio does not carry out any tests or says no to charging or something.
But that's important.
Each of these substances can trigger potential side effects or cause unnoticed damage in the long term.
That's the critical thing about these doping agents.
That means it's not about them not being allowed to do more as a sport, but as I said, they get these damage.
And that's why it's important to pay attention to it.
We have now talked a lot about why you should see many food supplements rather critically.
But do we need the additional micronutrients in pills and co. at all?
Good question.
According to the Institute for Risk Assessment, there are healthy people in Germany
who eat a variety of foods, only very rarely in substitutions with vitamins and minerals.
Most people do not see an additional need for food supplements at the consumer center.
The daily vitamin C requirement is already covered with half a red pepper and a small glass of orange juice, for example.
However, the risk of undernourishment increases when you eat one-sidedly,
i.e. do extreme low-carb diets or the gut cannot absorb the nutrients well, for example when you are sick.
You need healthy people who have an increased risk of undernourishment,
for example pregnant, breastfeeding, elderly and actually also people who live vegan.
I mentioned that at the beginning of the video.
If you eat balanced, a healthy diet pattern is crucial.
Then the risk of undernourishment is not as high as you should take all the risks of food supplements.
If you belong to one of the groups I just mentioned,
then your doctor is the best contact person for possible food supplements.
The doctor can check whether there is a deficiency with the help of a reasonable blood test.
Yes, often you have to pay for it yourself, but you also supplement and pay for it.
Then you do the test beforehand, test the values, pay for them yourself
and then you know whether you can do without the supplements afterwards.
But if you go to the doctor and he says that this is a sensible thing because maybe you actually have a deficiency,
then it is even taken over by the health insurance company.
Therefore, this is definitely a smart move.
And one more thing, there are also other tests, i.e. so-called bioresonance tests, for example,
where electromagnetic vibrations should tell you whether you have a deficiency.
And here I found an investigation from Germany,
in which several people, a corpse and a liver cheese were examined with this method.
And that's no joke now.
With different runs, very different results came out.
And so, for example, the corpse was diagnosed with the best health.
Here I would always only listen to official test results.
And if something actually stands out, the doctor, your doctor, is also directly the right contact person.
And they don't sit on the costs.
The liver cheese test, of course, also made us laugh at the time when it was said.
As I said, your doctor is the best contact person.
You should save yourself everything else you can.
That means, in summary, food supplements are basically not bad at first.
Because there are groups that need them.
Especially risk groups should definitely go to the doctor and have it checked.
Exactly. So again, folic acid in pregnant women, vitamin B12 in vegans.
Many of us have a vitamin D deficiency.
Yes, omega-3 fatty acids, if you take too little of them.
And then it stops so slowly.
And there is just a big money machine behind it.
In the best case, you just spent a few euros.
In the worst case, tablets and pills are now overdosed or contaminated and harm our health.
And that can't go on like this.
That means, something really has to change, at least I think.
Nice conclusion. And I can only agree with that from a medical point of view.
The risks are mostly clear in most cases.
The topic of side effects and side effects is not taken into account at all.
And the bigger the promises, the more skeptical you should be as a consumer.
And above all, if you take too much of one substance, it may also inhibit another substance.
So if you are looking for more information on food supplements,
you will find a lot more information on my channel.
And I actually think that it should not go on like this.
And more transparency and regulation is really necessary.
Feel free to comment on this. What do you think about it? What do you say about it?
Thank you very much and stay loyal to me.