Richtiges Krafttraining ist immer eine gute Idee. Doch gilt das auch fürs Training bis zum Muskelversagen?
Tatsächlich wird dieses Trainingskonzept oft missverstanden. Falsch angewandt, bremst es Deine Fortschritte. Aber richtig eingesetzt gibt es Dir Rückenwind.
In dieser Folge erfährst Du alles, was Du wissen musst. Zum Beispiel:
Ob Du bis ans Muskelversagen gehen musst, um Muskeln aufzubauen. Brichst Du die 90-Prozent-Regel? Wie oft Du ans Muskelversagen gehen solltest. Bei welchem Trainingsziel es hilft, bei welchem (eher) nicht. Warum die Übung eine entscheidende Rolle spielt. Welchen Einfluss Deine Psyche spielt.
Anders formuliert: Versagen ist nicht immer die beste Lösung, um zu gewinnen.
Fitness with Marc, episode 423.
Welcome to Fitness with Marc, where it's all about looking good naked.
And here is your host, on his dining table there are always fresh flowers.
Maaaaaarc Maslow!
Moin Moin, I'm Marc Maslow, your stay-at-home fitness coach from Marathonfitness.de.
Let's talk about strength training.
Should you train until you lose muscle, or rather not?
You'll get the answer in today's episode.
The advertising partner of this episode is Koro.
I discovered Koro when it was still lockdown, because I like to order groceries online.
And I don't know about you, but I like to order large quantities.
I prefer to pay a little more and save in total.
Similar to the L'Oreal movie Papa and the Porters, where you order a whole pallet of mustard glasses.
I'm like that. I order large portions and that's enough.
And that's exactly what Koro offers.
They have high-quality food that you can order online in large portions.
And they last a little longer.
On their website korodrogerie.de you will find a huge selection of different healthy products.
Like an excellent almond mousse.
Or my absolute favorite are the ginger shots, which you can mix into your training drink.
Or as a thirst quencher, because there is no sugar in it.
It's just pressed, filled ginger.
It just tastes wonderful.
And third, I regularly order the Soya Protein Krispies with 75% protein and cocoa.
Great way to spice up your breakfast with protein.
And it just tastes great.
My recommendation, just click through the assortment on korodrogerie.de.
And if you enter the code FMM like Fitness with Marc when paying, you will get another 5% discount on your order.
Do you remember the first time you went to the weights and did strength training?
How did you go about it?
It could be that you just went to a short-sleeve rack, at least if you were in a fitness studio.
You took the heaviest weight you could still hold and did some exercise with it.
No matter which exercise, the main thing is an exercise and do it as well as you could.
One repetition after the other.
And the whole thing until you couldn't move the weight any further.
And then you took a break.
Probably until you felt good again.
And then you started all over again.
Sometimes it's good to approach things naively and really follow simple rules.
But this simple idea of simply moving weights until it's no longer possible and then pausing until you feel fresh again,
is also something that frustrates many people.
They ask themselves, is it really right how I proceed in the gym or would it be more effective in another way?
If we look at a training plan, it usually says which exercises you should do,
how often you should do these exercises, how many sets.
So the total training volume is usually specified.
But many people don't even know how intense they should push themselves when they go into a training set.
They also don't know how to build muscles and they also don't know how to build strength on the other side.
What they know is what is in their training plan, which exercises they should do and how many sets each of them.
And here is a decisive difference.
The results you achieve in training are a combination of different influence sizes.
If you want to build muscles, the muscular tension, the small micro-injuries in the muscle that are caused by the training and the stress on your metabolism play a major role.
And there are different ways you can manipulate these three variables, how you can influence them.
But most people believe that the way to achieve the optimum here is to go to the absolute limit with every set.
And that is also the reason why training to muscle failure is a topic that you see discussed in the fitness scene again and again.
Controversially discussed and a topic that is often misunderstood.
I have been dealing with the topic of fitness for several years now and I now know that there is no easy answer.
Some people believe that there is only one way and that is to train every single training set to muscle failure.
That is the secret of success from their point of view.
While others see it the other way around and say, no, with that the stress is way too high and you risk injury and over-training.
And as so often in life, the answer is, it depends.
It depends on you as an individual, it depends on your goals and it also depends on what preferences you have in training.
And if you go to training and take the time for it, then it is actually a good idea if you adjust this training to your individual preferences, to your goals, to your training level as much as possible.
That means, before you go to the gym the next time and go to muscle failure one more training set, it is a good idea if you ask yourself 5 questions that will help you to find the optimal solution for your training.
And we will go through them today.
And as a bonus, there is a 6th question to that.
That as a pre-announcement.
So, let's start.
Question number 1.
Is the training up to muscle failure necessary at all to trigger muscle growth?
That means, if you want to build muscles, do you have to go up to muscle failure or maybe not?
If we look at the scientific research, there are unfortunately not that many studies on that.
Basically, muscle hypertrophy, muscle growth is often an important goal, also in competitive sports, when we look at bodybuilding, but also in strength sports, then muscle build-up is often important to improve the competition performance.
And also in terms of optics, many of us look good naked with a strong physique and muscle build-up is of course important there as well.
Training up to muscle failure leads to a larger number of muscle fibers being recruited.
We see that confirmed by science as well.
And on this path, muscle build-up is set up.
And that's why you often see in competitive sports, that athletes train up to muscle failure.
If we look at the literature, then the consensus seems to be that training up to muscle failure is definitely a common, also a suitable method to strengthen muscle build-up, to build up additional strength and to break through growth plateaus.
So, if you train and don't see any further progress in muscle build-up, to break through these plateaus.
Nevertheless, it is also important, and it is also said in the literature, that training up to muscle failure should not be done permanently over a long period of time.
Because what we have found, when we look at the data, the researchers say, is that you actually slip into overtraining and the risk of injury increases.
That's why it is also important to look at who trains here, how much experience do you have in training, are you just a beginner, have you been training for a little longer?
And these are factors that have to be included in order to decide whether you train up to muscle failure or not.
There are also studies that have found that training up to muscle failure leads to a higher level of hormone secretion, specifically a higher level of growth hormone secretion.
In comparison to training that does not lead to muscle failure.
That in itself is not yet proof that muscle build-up is still being strengthened, but it is a reason why many athletes swear to it.
The question is, what do we do with it now? What does that mean specifically for your training?
So let's start with you, because at the end of the day it depends on what training goals you have set for yourself and how you prefer to train, so that it is as easy for you as possible.
And only when you have answered these questions can you ask yourself whether it makes sense for you to train up to muscle failure or not.
And exactly five points play a role and we'll go through them.
These are five questions that you can ask yourself and based on which you can then decide, does training up to muscle failure currently come into question for me or not yet?
And that brings me to the second question for today, how hard do you train? How hard do you want to train right now?
And that depends on the intensity of the training. The intensity of the training is perhaps the most important influence whether it is effective or whether it is even applied.
What do I mean by training intensity? I mean the percentage of your so-called one rep max.
Your one rep max is the heaviest possible weight that you can lift or press at the current time.
With a certain exercise, i.e. your maximum weight that you can move for exactly one repetition, you can't do a second one and you can't increase the weight any further, because then you wouldn't be able to do this one repetition anymore.
And my opinion at this point is that you should never go up to muscle failure if you are at 90% of your one rep max or over 90%.
Because if you go up to muscle failure with such heavy weights, then you will most likely not get any extra profit on the one hand for your muscle build-up and on the other hand there are a number of disadvantages.
You just don't want to go up to muscle failure with such a heavy weight, no matter if you do squats, if you lift a cross, if you press over your head or train your chest by pressing on the bench.
The point is, if you want to go up to muscle failure with such a heavy weight, then you will most likely have to do some exercises with the technique, you will be unclean and the risk of injuring yourself increases.
And at this point we can say that injuries are the biggest showstoppers of any progress in training. It is better not to train so effectively and therefore to continue than to have to pause in between due to an injury.
In other words, as a general rule, I would like to give you the following. If you go up to muscle failure, then please do so with lighter weights and they are roughly between 50% and 85% of your one rep max.
And yes, you can also estimate this. I have a calculator for this on my website, which I would like to link to you again.
And maybe as a note to these limits, 50% of your one rep max is not an intensity that I would recommend, because then you have to do a lot of repetitions to get to muscle failure.
This can be very uncomfortable and it just takes a lot of time.
And on the other hand, we have the 85%. The upper limit is not something that I would necessarily put in my client's training plan, because here you are already training with very heavy weight.
And if you wanted to do that, then my recommendation would be to look for a spotter, someone who helps you and ensures that you also train with clean technique.
And that brings me to the third question. How often is the training up to muscle failure brought to you? And that depends on your so-called training age.
Let's just divide the training age into three categories. Everyone knows them from us. There are beginners, there are advanced and there are very experienced athletes.
And it depends on where you are on this spectrum to judge what you need for your training. A beginner needs other methods than someone who is advanced or someone who is already very experienced.
Let's take the example of the beginner. Its main goal is to learn the exercises with priority number one. To train with the right form, with the right technique.
And by that I also mean the more demanding exercises such as the knee bend, the bench press, cross lifts, pull-ups, all basic exercises.
It is important to learn them with a clean form. That is the main task of the beginner.
And here it becomes clear that if a beginner would then go to absolute muscle failure, he would usually hurt himself more than it would benefit him.
Because if you are already very tired, it becomes more and more difficult to train with really good form.
And instead, what you can use is the so-called reps in reserve method, i.e. repetitions that you still have in petto.
This approach is great for beginners and it is also very effective for advanced.
How does it work? Well, instead of going to absolute muscle failure, you use another technique to get tired.
Because what brings you forward is the cumulative, the accumulated muscle fatigue, which also gives a growth stimulus.
Assuming you set yourself as a repetition goal 8 repetitions. You set yourself 8 repetitions for a set of training and at the same time make sure that you have two more repetitions in the tank, and that is the reps in reserve method.
Your goal for a set is 8 repetitions and you could, if you wanted, add two more repetitions and then you would come to absolute muscle failure.
so that you don't tire your muscles and you don't overwhelm yourself.
If you have been training for a long time now, if you are more advanced or already a very experienced athlete, then of course you can train more often until muscle failure.
The exciting question is now of course, how often should you really go to muscle failure?
Good that you ask, it also depends on what your goal is and which exercises are on your training plan.
Let's start with the first question, what is your goal?
And that's not trivial, you can first decide where you want to go.
Two classic different goals in strength training that you could follow are muscle build-up on one side or strength build-up on the other side.
This becomes nice and clear when we compare, for example, powerlifters and bodybuilders.
Powerlifters put the focus on maximum strength development and that also means that they train their nervous system so that the nervous system can handle more weight.
This means that powerlifters train relatively close to their one rep max, so they take very heavy weight.
In addition, powerlifters put the focus on heavy combined exercises, which are also technically very demanding.
In bodybuilding, the goal is above all muscle build-up and bodybuilders train with relatively lower intensities, i.e. lower weight, because the strength is not so crucial for them.
Bodybuilders also use smaller exercises, more isolation exercises, to work out individual body parts even better.
So they look at what the proportions of the body are and where they can put a little more musculature so that they get an ideal figure.
With these smaller exercises, the technique is not so demanding, which means that you can't do much wrong if you train to failure.
So we see that there are different training approaches and it also depends on which exercises you train.
That's why we can say that bodybuilders can train more often to muscle failure than powerlifters because the training approaches are different.
And that brings me to the fifth question, which exercises are on your training plan?
The more demanding an exercise is, the less likely it is to be trained to muscle failure.
Conversely, we can say that the less demanding, the simpler an exercise is, the more likely you can train it to muscle failure and the more often you can train it to muscle failure.
The most demanding exercise in terms of weightlifting is the snatch.
The tearing of the barbell over the head is not an exercise that you would want to train to muscle failure at all.
At least not if you are not a powerlifter, because training this exercise to muscle failure is dangerous.
But that doesn't necessarily have to apply to all multi-jointed exercises.
Let's take another exercise, which is also complex, very effective, very exhausting, which is the pull-up.
Pressing the bench, falling steps, all of these are demanding exercises that you should definitely train to muscle failure.
However, please be extremely careful.
And we can also say the same for squats.
And then as the simplest exercises, we have the one-jointed exercises.
These are exercises such as bicep curls, triceps push-ups, calf raises, leg stretchers.
These are very easy to perform exercises, not very complex exercises, and you can also train them relatively safely and relatively often to muscle failure.
And that brings me to the last, to the bonus question, if you will, for today's episode.
With what mindset, with what attitude do you go into training?
Muscle failure means that the person who is currently training is not yet able to perform a whole repetition of an exercise.
And that happens when the fatigue is too high.
Fatigue, on the other hand, can be quite subjective.
And it is almost impossible to somehow quantify the term fatigue.
It depends on how high your pain tolerance is.
It depends on what will you go for in an exercise.
So psychological factors play a role that influence exactly where the point of muscle failure is with you.
So it depends on the day and it also depends on the athlete himself.
That's why we can't say exactly if someone says he's gone to muscle failure,
if he's really gone to physical muscle failure or maybe he just shortened the training sentence.
And in fact, there are people who say it's absolutely fun for me to go all the way to muscle failure.
And there are other people who say, stay away from it.
I don't like burning this muscle in this form at all.
I don't want to go all the way to muscle failure.
I find that super uncomfortable.
I'd rather stay away from it.
And especially the latter would perhaps even say that strength training is not for me,
if they bring the belief that they absolutely have to go all the way to muscle failure.
That means that psychology, the attitude, plays a role and the way in which you go into your training.
And I don't want to evaluate that at all.
Every mindset is fine and you can also make progress in any way.
On paper, it would be, and we can see that at this point,
easy to say, okay, muscle failure, training to muscle failure,
may bring you ahead in the short term.
But in order to be able to judge in the long term whether training to muscle failure is the right thing for you,
you have to ask yourself a lot of questions beforehand and also answer them.
Because the goal is that you stay regularly in your training and achieve success in the long term.
So we can say that training to muscle failure is a useful tool in the training toolbox
that you are welcome to use if you already master the technique of the exercises.
And above all, you can use it if it suits your goals, your needs and what you're up to right now.
And then you can use it wisely and please be careful.
If you are listening to this episode and have not yet subscribed via Apple Podcasts, Spotify or other platforms,
then you should change that as soon as possible.
Because the best way to stay tuned is if you can get this podcast for free on your phone or your favorite device.
You can simply subscribe by going to Apple Podcasts and searching for Fitness with Marc.
Or you go to www.marathonfitness.de-podcast and click on subscribe.
If you like this podcast, you can also give something back.
Go to Apple Podcasts or Spotify, give me your five-star rating and write something nice.
I'll read it and I'll be eternally grateful to you.
I promise.
The point is, with your rating, you help make this podcast easier to find by people
whom this information could also help to improve their body, to look good naked.
So, do you know anyone who would find this podcast helpful?
Because the best compliment you can give me is a recommendation.