The Chinese Communist Party (CCP) engages in the world’s most comprehensive campaign of transnational repression, targeting exile communities, members of the diaspora, and supporters in dozens of countries around the world with digital surveillance, attempted censorship, and even physical attacks. This campaign has also reached university campuses in the United States, generating discussion among faculty, students, administrators, and policymakers.
As a new academic year begins, experts on transnational repression, Beijing’s influence on university campuses, and the persecution of Falun Gong shed light on how CCP surveillance, slander, and censorship impinge upon free expression and belief at American universities, and what university administrators and government officials can do to respond.
Hosted by the Falun Dafa Information Center and moderated by leading Confucius Institute expert, Ian Oxnevad of the National Association of Scholars, this webinar offers new insight into the key challenges facing universities and recommendations for action to best protect freedom of speech and belief for all students, faculty, and members of the campus community.
Like Ian mentioned, I was a graduate student at the University of Pennsylvania.
The Falun Dafa Club and its events have been challenged multiple times throughout my time
at Penn, but I'll just share two incidents of interference or pushback that the club faced that
really stand out to me. The first one was in November of 2020 during our promotion of a
virtual screening of a Falun Gong-related human rights film titled Finding Courage.
So shortly after we submitted the event details to GAPSA, the Graduate and Professional Student
Assembly, their weekly newsletter, we were informed that some Chinese international students and
alumni too, they had complained to GAPSA and PATCH, the Pan-Asian American Community House,
about the event. And what I found really interesting about this complaint was that
these students were upset that the Falun Dafa Club was allowed to advertise their events in
UPenn GAPSA newsletter. So it wasn't at the content of the film screening, it was that we
had the right to advertise our student events in the newsletter. And this was the first time that
I realized that not only would the nature of our events that we held as a club be challenged, but
sort of our privileges as students on campus would also be challenged simply because we were Falun
Gong practitioners. And after some discussion, the air was sort of cleared that if Falun Dafa Club
was a registered club on campus, which it was, then it indeed did have the right to advertise
their events in this newsletter. And at this point, we were also connected with representatives from
the CSSA, the Chinese Students and Scholars Association, to help clear any potential
misunderstandings that could be, you know, perceived from our hosting this human rights
film screening event. And it was also suggested that we perhaps work together on this event,
to which they declined due to the political nature of the event. And then a few months later,
the UPenn Falun Dafa Club also held a virtual film screening of In the Name of Confucius in
collaboration with over 10 other Falun Dafa clubs across North America, as well as Students for a
Free Tibet and Athena Institute. So In the Name of Confucius is a documentary film that exposes
the controversy over Confucius Institutes. University of Pennsylvania was offered a
Confucius Institute contract and rejected that in 2009, which was a unanimous decision of the East
Studies faculty at the time. But just a few miles away from UPenn, however, Temple University did
have an active Confucius Institute. And that same month, March of 2021, Tufts University closed its
Confucius Institute and the United States Senate unanimously passed a bill to tighten control
over Confucius Institutes across the country. So our organization was, you know, quite excited to
host this very relevant film screening and discussion and present it to the UPenn student
body. Our club also extended invitations to the university president, the provost, the CSSA,
and the director of Temple University's Confucius Institute to join the film screening and discussion,
you know, on this issue of academic freedom and then Confucius Institutes. And at the time,
I'd also just joined the GAPSA executive board as executive vice president of programming.
And in addition to newsletter advertisements, another service that GAPSA offers registered
clubs on campus to advertise student events is social media posting, you know, on the official
GAPSA social media channels. And given that the subject matter of the film was particularly
relevant at that time, and then also to the UPenn community and also had to do with academic freedom
in general, I suggested that our club submit this specific event for GAPSA social media promotion
to reach a broader audience. And the event was published in the weekly newsletter and then on
their social media channels. And the backlash from this was almost immediate, you know, with
comments and emails flooding in for almost two months straight, even after the event itself had
happened. And again, what I found really interesting and, you know, surprising to say the very least
were that most if not all complaints centered around a few arguments. So the first argument
was that it was inappropriate for GAPSA to advertise an event hosted by the Falun Dafa club
because choosing to advertise the Falun Dafa club's event was in fact political propaganda
offensive to Chinese students. Two, Falun Dafa club students for a free Tibet and Athenai Institute
are specifically anti-China groups with the sole purpose of criticizing China and provoking
negative sentiment towards China and Chinese people. Three, that promoting the film screening
was promoting hatred directed towards Asian people and specifically Chinese people.
And then four, that the content of the film screening and discussion were racist.
And this was, you know, quite a stressful and traumatic time for me and for our club members
because pretty much all of the public comments on the social media posts had nothing to do with the
film screening itself and were instead just personal attacks about the Falun Dafa club and
Falun Gong practitioners. You know, we were called disgusting Chinese terrorists and many comments
expressed that GAPSA and PEN should be ashamed that they had stooped so low as to allow a Falun
Dafa club to exist on campus. And again, this film screening was not hosted by GAPSA. You know,
the Falun Dafa club had simply utilized a service that's provided by the graduate student assembly
offered to all registered clubs on campus. But even after the event had occurred, these complaints
continued. You know, Chinese students were still emailing and essentially pressuring GAPSA to be
held accountable for the apparent anti-Chinese propaganda it had promoted for its promotion of
anti-Chinese hate and then also to ensure that something like this would not happen again.
There was even an open letter slash petition that was started in protest to this film screening
event and the requests in this letter were quite shocking to me. You know, over 70 Chinese
international students signed this letter which claimed that the nature of the documentary and
the film screening were highly controversial and political and then offended many Chinese students
on campus because it was, quote, the only political propaganda GAPSA advertised in this whole year.
And so the letter stated that because GAPSA's decision to promote this event hosted by Falun
Dafa club, it had isolated and upset the Chinese population at PEN that GAPSA should set future
rules so that something like this would not happen again. It requested that any and all future
promotions of events must be presented to the general assembly and then unanimously voted upon.
And then that if there were any students with concerns or oppositions to the posts after they
were published that GAPSA should withdraw these posts and delete them, you know, take them down.
And these requests were quite shocking to me because the CSSA is represented on GAPSA's board.
There is, you know, a council member specifically representing the CSSA. So implementing this
suggested policy would in fact marginalize Falun Gong practitioners on campus and essentially
silence any promotion of Falun Gong club events in order not to upset the Chinese international
population at PEN. And what was further shocking to me was that at a GAPSA general assembly meeting
and then also a GAPSA council meeting after the film screening, a Chinese international student
was allowed to present basically his side, his concerns about the film screening and the
promotion of the event, during which he showed slides that were highly misrepresentative of the
film screening and the discussion's apparent racism towards Chinese people. And he also
presented a slide that echoed Chinese Communist Party rhetoric that is specifically used to
justify the imprisonment, torture, and persecution of Falun Gong practitioners in China. So he used
these slides as a justification as to why it was wrong for GAPSA to have promoted a Falun Dafa
club event. And then this same Chinese international student among others also accused me of conflict
of interest and using my position on the GAPSA executive board to specifically promote political
propaganda for my own personal reasons because I was on both the GAPSA executive board and then
also part of the Falun Dafa club. And at no point during any of this, you know, emails, meetings,
presentations included, were Falun Gong club representatives invited or offered to join the
discussion or given an opportunity to publicly respond to any of these claims. And you know this
was a very difficult time for me and other club members because you know we're students first and
foremost. We're balancing our schoolwork with the weight of all these personal attacks and pushback
and essentially also feeling unable to join the conversation and speak our part. And honestly
despite all this that happened, I still feel like I'm one of the lucky ones because you know I felt
that I could speak up safely if I was given the opportunity to. But a lot of Falun Gong practitioners
or you know dissident student voices on university campuses are not so lucky. You know during our
hosting of the film screening of In the Name of Confucius, we had some host organization members
specifically request not to be shown in any pictures related to the event or have their
names published because one of their parents was still currently jailed in China for practicing
Falun Gong. And then another student whose life dream was to visit Tibet and they worried that
being shown in relation to this event that they helped host on an American university campus
would put them or their family members physically in mainland China in jeopardy. And you know I
don't have any relatives who practice Falun Dafa that are physically in mainland China
and in general I don't feel like I have to worry about the safety of myself or my family if I speak
out against the persecution or publicly choose to take part in a club event you know in the United
States. But even so around this time you know with all these personal attacks and pushback
my parents were quite worried for my safety and they sort of you know warned me to be careful
because I was outspoken and active in the Falun Dafa club and I often publicly associated myself
with Falun Gong activism. So just to finish my portion here I'll just highlight a few closing
thoughts about my my experience. I think through this whole process one thing that I do appreciate
is that the Office of Student Affairs sort of did step in to help steer the conversation in
the right direction and what I mean by that was that you know the Falun Dafa club's right to hold
space on campus and right to open expression was being challenged. It had been challenged in the
past and it was being challenged again. An appropriate administration did step in to make
it clear you know that complaints about the Falun Dafa club's presence on campus and right to promote
its events through GAPSA were not the same as concerns about the event itself. You know there
were two completely separate issues must be addressed separately and by the appropriate
people and it was also made clear you know that the event did not violate university policies or
the code of conduct and so therefore the club had not done anything wrong just because some
Chinese international students were offended by the promotion of this event. But I think overall
you know more needs to be done to proactively support you know the free expression of Falun
Dafa practitioners on campus or dissident voices on campus and make them feel safe and welcome at
their universities. You know I think there was such a knee-jerk negative reaction by most students as
soon as the Chinese international students accused us of racism and offensive political propaganda
that very few if any actually took the time to watch the film you know analyze the situation
and understand the event context and by the time some students had come to understand the entire
situation and that it really wasn't as simple as what the Chinese international students had said
the damage was already sort of done and you know so many Falun Gong practitioners on campus
were already hurt by everything said and done and sort of felt not safe expressing themselves
and I just think in overall we felt very unsupported as a minority group on campus
through this process and I think partially this could just be because most universities and
university administrations are just not prepared for something like this that when it does happen
they're not really sure how to react and then they err on the side of you know what they think
is caution to avoid potentially digging a deeper hole and then end up not saying anything but in
reality I think this just further discourages marginalized groups from feeling like they have
a place on campus and then they can openly express themselves without fear of retaliation.
In this specific experience of mine you know no administrators reached out first to our club
directly to offer any support or opportunities to join the conversation. I even reached out to a
contact at the university chaplain's office to sort of make him aware of the situation and ask
for further assistance and I didn't receive a response until about a month after all of these
conversations had ended like this whole thing was a month-long process it was a month before I
received a response that I had asked for and then it was only then that I even found out that you
know representatives from the chaplain's office had been aware of the situation and they had been
discussing the situation with other parties involved or other administrations but again
Falun Dafa club members were not brought into these conversations and were not directly offered
any resources or support so the Falun Dafa club did publish its own letter to attempt to join
the dialogue and express concern over the way that this event was misrepresented to which it did not
receive any responses from students or administrators and again I think the unsatisfactory way that this
was handled might just be because universities are unprepared to deal with these situations
they really don't know what to say and worry that you know anything that they do say might
come back to bite them so they just don't say anything but to me that's not really doing enough
to protect free expression on campus you know universities should be proactive about making
sure that Falun Gong practitioners or anyone really any dissident voices they're not feeling
isolated victimized or that they need to self-censor on campus just to feel safe and welcome
and I know that what happened to us at Penn was you know just one of many similar situations and
possibly on the less severe side you know that is faced by Falun Gong practitioners or dissident
voices on university campuses so overall I just think that there's still a lot much that a lot
much more that can be done by universities to improve in this aspect thank you