As a lawyer and long-time reader of the New York Times, John found the recent attacks on Shen Yun "inexcusable." He calls for a fair and truthful re-assessment of Shen Yun and Falun Gong practitioners, starting with four major examples of the Times' failures in their coverage.
My name is John Moran. I'm a lawyer and a Falun Dafa practitioner. I wanted to offer my perspective
on the recent New York Times reports concerning Shen Yun. I also happen to be a longtime reader
of the New York Times. I respect the newspaper and I still think it has some great journalists
who do important work under difficult conditions. So I found the recent attacks on Shen Yun especially
disappointing. I want to acknowledge that it's fair for people to ask questions of Falun Dafa
practitioners and even for journalists to investigate Shen Yun. All I would ask is that
if a reporter is going to write a story about Shen Yun, that it be done truthfully and fairly.
That's especially important given the background where the Chinese government has spread hateful
anti-Falun Gong propaganda for 25 years. Practitioners in China have literally been
killed in custody because they tried to tell the truth about Falun Gong. Given that background,
it's inexcusable that the Times failed the basic test of honesty and fairness. And I'll give a few
examples of how they did that. First, the Times printed a headline that claimed that Shen Yun
enriches the founder of Falun Gong. That's simply untrue. There's no factual basis in the Times
articles to support the idea that Shen Yun money went to the founder of Falun Gong. The Times seems
to have made up that headline entirely just to make Falun Gong look bad. Another example.
The Times relied on accounts from a small group of former Shen Yun performers but did not disclose
that several of those performers only criticized Shen Yun for the first time after they associated
with the Beijing Dance Academy, which is a competitor of Shen Yun's, which the Chinese
government runs, the same Chinese government which has vowed to eradicate Falun Gong. So there's an
obvious conflict of interest. For the Times to promote the accusations of such people without
disclosing that obvious conflict of interest is indefensible. And the fact that the Times
concealed that from its readers shows that they were not trying to report the truth in good faith.
Another example. The Times described some Shen Yun skits that depict organ harvesting from
prisoners of conscience in China. And the Times claimed that there's actually no evidence of such
organ harvesting targeting Falun Gong practitioners, clearly implying that Shen Yun is spreading
misinformation or conspiracy theories by depicting the organ harvesting. But the truth is there is
evidence of organ harvesting targeting Falun Gong practitioners, where Falun Gong practitioners
have been killed to support China's organ transplant industry. I know because I've studied
that evidence quite carefully. In fact, a former New York Times reporter has testified publicly
that based on her initial investigation, she believed the Chinese government was killing
prisoners of conscience for their organs. But her editors at the Times would not allow her to
continue with the story. So the Times deliberately chose not to investigate the organ harvesting
story, even when one of its own reporters was onto it, and now recklessly says there's no evidence
of organ harvesting. There is evidence. The Times just chose to look away from it. One more example.
The Times claimed, again relying on the accounts of former Shen Yun performers who have an obvious
conflict of interest now, that Shen Yun discourages performers from receiving necessary
medical treatment. Well, there are a lot of medical records that disprove that accusation. The Times
just refused to give Shen Yun time to get patient authorizations and collect the medical records
from the providers. Several doctors have come forward to say that they practice in the area
near Shen Yun's campus and they treat Shen Yun performers all the time. Even one of the former
performers who spoke with the Times told the reporters in an email that most Shen Yun performers
receive regular medical care. The Times didn't include any of that in its articles.
Why would the Times conceal all of that information from its readers?
I think what's clear is that the Times wanted to print sensationalized stories that made Shen Yun
look as bad as possible and they were willing to sacrifice truthfulness and basic journalistic
integrity in order to do so. The last matter that I want to comment on is the Times' failure
to offer any perspective from the hundreds of former Shen Yun performers who warmly remember
their time at Shen Yun, or for that matter, to give voice to the millions of Falun Dafa practitioners
around the world. Why do so many people practice Falun Dafa? Why do all of those Shen Yun performers
and many others devote themselves to carrying the message of Falun Dafa? The truth is that Falun Dafa
has brought good health and miraculous experiences and deeper meaning in life to millions of people
around the world. There are amazing stories that could be told about that that would be more
interesting and informative than anything the New York Times wrote,
and that would have the benefit of being true.