Introduction to Elemental Analysis by ED-XRF (Justin Masone)
Sep 5, 2023
For more information, visit https://nanohub.org/resources/22621
Justin Masone
6/3/15
Introduction to Elemental Analysis by ED-XRF
I'm Justin Masson, I'm here from Shimadzu Scientific Instruments.
We're going to talk about EDX today.
Just give you a brief overview of what Shimadzu is, we're a global corporation, we've been
around for 140 years, established in 1875 in Japan.
We're ranked top five instrument providers in the world by Chemical Engineering News,
so we're, have pretty broad business, we offer an extremely broad range of products or solutions
as we like to call them.
I'll just list a few here, all different types of chromatographs, spectrometers, you can
do environmental analysis, here's what more people would be interested in, a lot of physical
measurement devices, x-ray devices, balances of scales and so forth, so we have a pretty
broad line.
Show of hands, who here is familiar with XRF, x-ray fluorescence?
A couple, okay, a handful.
XRF is an analytical method to determine the elemental composition of many types of materials,
and I build it elemental because people always ask the question, well, can it tell me about
bonding or molecular information, it cannot.
X-ray fluorescence deals with the manipulation of the inner shell electrons, so we can't
determine oxidation state, we cannot determine bonding, purely elemental information.
It can also be used to determine the thickness and composition of layers, coatings, and plating,
so if you have a plating sample, we can determine the thickness of that plating, what the composition
is, a common, if we had an EDX here, a common little demonstration I would do is to determine
the copper plating thickness of a penny, it's copper over zinc, it's a pretty easy or fundamental
way to, as an example of that type of analysis.
Also it's fast, accurate, and non-destructive, this is one of the biggest benefits of using
EDX, it's non-destructive, so you take your sample, you don't have to, if you're doing
elemental analysis, traditionally it's done by AA, ICP, ICP-MS, you have to get your sample
into solution, that could take a significant amount of time, cost a lot of money, with
EDX it's non-destructive, so you just take your sample and put it in a device and hit
go.
Requires minimal sample prep.
EDX can be in solid, liquid, powder, or filtered form, so solid meaning you can take your sample
and just stick it in there, liquid you could put it in an XRF cup, powder you could also
put it in an XRF cup, or you can press it, there are different reasons why you'd want
to do one or the other, and filtered you could, if you have a liquid solution you could deposit
on a filter paper, wait for it to evaporate, and then measure it in the EDX.
So what is EDX?
EDX for F stands for energy dispersive X-ray fluorescence.
Energy dispersive means we could discern the energies of X-rays, X-rays is a form of energy,
in this case it's our ionizing radiation, and fluorescence is the phenomenon of absorbing
energy and then subsequently releasing energy.
This is a very basic diagram of an EDX, we have an X-ray source, this is our sample,
we have radiating X-rays that hit the sample, generating fluorescent X-rays, which are then
detected, goes through a preamp and digital pulse processor, and then on our PC we actually
see the spectrum and get the quantitation results.
Very briefly, what are X-rays?
They're a kind of electromagnetic energy, this right here is the electromagnetic spectrum,
so they're in between gamma rays and UV rays, wavelength between .01 to 10 nanometers, and
the energy of that is .125 to 125 kEV, roughly.
Also two different terms for X-rays, hard X-rays are greater than 10 kEV and soft X-rays
are less than 10 kEV.
So how do X-rays interact with matter?
When X-rays strike matter, some are absorbed, some pass through, some are scattered.
Absorption and penetration depth depend on elemental composition, density, and the thickness
of the matter, and I've got some more slides on that because we always get questions on
that.
But the most important or the most applicable interaction is that secondary X-rays are generated,
these fluorescent X-rays which are characteristic of that matter.
So that's what allows us to take this unknown sample right here, stick it in this instrument,
and have the PC tell us, oh, that's iron at this concentration.
So there are all different ways X-rays can interact with matter.
X-ray diffraction deals with Rayleigh and Compton scattering that can be transmitted,
just like when you go to the doctor and get an X-ray, or they can interact with the valence
electrons, and that's where we get XPS.
But we're concerned with X-ray fluorescence, and again, that's when we absorb energy and
then subsequently release energy.
Additionally, degree of fluorescence, as I said earlier, depends on really the composition
of the sample, so the thickness of the sample, the density, what it's made of.
Roughly penetration depth, the source on the Shibazu EDX7000, it's a rhodium X-ray tube,
so for a rhodium K-alpha X-ray, the energy is around 20 keV.
Penetration depth in lead is pretty shallow, 25 microns about, but up through water it
can get to 3 centimeters.
So it really depends on density and composition of the sample.
How do X-rays interact with atoms?
First we need an atom.
Then we'll take our radiating X-ray, which ejects an inner shell electron.
Now we have a vacant hole here, and we need to fill that, so electron from a higher energy
shell falls down, releases energy, releases a fluorescent X-ray.
This right here is what we measure.
Now this fluorescent X-ray has a discrete energy, and it's indicative of that sample
material.
I think I've got an example on another slide of what it is, but our detector measures the
energy of this X-ray, and from that energy we can know what the transition of what specific
transition of which element that is.
So different types of transitions, they're labeled K, L, or M, depending on the final
resting place of the electron.
So if we have a transition that happens from a higher shell to the K shell, that transition
starts with a K, and then alpha, beta, gamma, those are indicative of where the electron
came from.
So when you look at a spectrum, you'll see, say, iron K alpha.
That means we know that an electron from the K shell was ejected, an electron from the
L shell fell down to fill that hole and released a K alpha ray.
Ratios of K alpha to K beta rays are fixed, so some of the algorithms in the software
use that ratio for overlap correction and matrix correction, things like that.
These are called characteristic X-rays.
As an example, this is an iron atom, so we have a K alpha transition here, and as I said
earlier, this is a very, this has a discrete energy, it's indicative of this transition
of this element.
So just as an example, we can do our, some mathematics here, E equals H nu or Planck's
constant times the speed of light over the wavelength.
We fill that in, we get about that 6.40 KeV.
You can check that if you want.
You then take a look at an energy table, and this is one that we put up, but if you
just Googled XRF transition energies, you know, whatever, you'll find charts like this
all over the web.
So we look at iron and the K alpha transition, and that's given on the table as 6.400 KeV.
As you can see, there's nothing really around it, manganese at 5.895 and cobalt at 6.925.
So this 6.400 KeV energy is very indicative of an iron K alpha transition, so we know
that it's iron.
This is what a typical spectrum would look like.
The Y axis is in terms of counts per second per microamp.
The voltage and current of the X-ray tube can be adjusted depending on what your sample
is, what you're trying to excite.
So if you increase the current, you're going to increase the intensity of the signal as
well, so that's why it's counts per second per microamp.
The X axis, KeV.
This goes from 0 to 40 KeV, and this right here is where a peak is labeled.
This is calcium K alpha.
This is what a data output screen looks like.
As a general example, we have a list of elements here, concentrations, types of analysis, type
of analysis.
FP stands for fundamental parameters, which is standardless measurement.
So fundamental parameters uses the fundamental physical parameters to correlate intensity
versus concentration.
You can also create a calibration curve that would be a more accurate way.
FP can vary by about 20% depending on what your sample type is.
So this instrument cannot see carbon, however, I think this was a, I forget, this might have
been like a organic sample, and I just set it as a balance so that the concentrations
would be more indicative of what was actually in there.
If I didn't have carbon as a balance, then all these concentration percentages would
be skewed because it would want to total to 100%.
This is an analytical range of the two EDXs we offer, 7,000 and 8,000.
Ten years ago, EDX wasn't that popular in a research lab because the sensitivities just
weren't there.
They're primarily used by geologists to qualitatively determine what was in your sample, but as
the detection methods got better, our use of this technology has expanded greatly.
So you can see some of these heavy metals, these high Z elements, we can get down to
about 100 ppb concentration, which is pretty good when you don't have to get something
into solution or digest it.
This is the basics of an EDX system.
This is the EDX 7,000, but it's similar to most EDXs in the market.
You have an x-ray tube right here.
In our case, it's a rhodium tube.
Filters, filters are a way of just conditioning the x-ray beam.
This will help you limit the irradiation area of a sample, and you use that in conjunction
with a camera.
In this instrument, it's a CMOS camera, but collimators come between 1, 3, 5, and 10 millimeter
collimators, so if you wanted to irradiate just a small part of your sample, you can
use the collimator in conjunction with a camera to position it and just irradiate that small
section of the sample you need.
When the x-rays are detected in the EDX 7,000, 8,000, it's a silicon drift detector.
Other type of detectors are silly detectors or silicon pin diode detectors, and they all
have their pros and cons.
The sample is irradiated from the bottom, so we don't have to account for sample height.
This is an image of the Shimadzu EDX 7,000 slash 8,000 right here.
It's very small.
It's benchtop.
It weighs about 100 pounds.
This is the analysis area right here.
So it's a pretty large chamber, which can handle a big bulk sample, if need be.
Why use EDX?
I said earlier, elemental analysis, traditionally done by AAICP.
That requires sample prep, sample digestion, cost analysis is high, got lots of consumables.
Some of those instruments require a really highly trained analyst.
With EDX, most importantly, there's no sample prep, so you don't have to change your sample
or alter your sample in any way to get the instrument to analyze it.
Detection limits are pretty high for heavy elements, less than one ppm, which is high
when you don't have to digest your sample, get it in solution, and thus dilute it.
Extremely low cost of analysis in terms of time and money, so there's no gas requirements,
no exhaust, no sample waste, uses less bench paste.
It's easy to use, so you don't need to have a highly trained analyst to run it.
No consumables other than the x-ray tube and detector, which lasts three years, five years,
ten years, depending on how often and how roughly it's used.
Just some examples of all the applications that we have right now.
Ceramics mining, so it's all elemental analysis.
This one's probably most relevant, thin film analysis for semiconductor disks, liquid crystals
and solar cells, which is all different industries that use this instrument or use this type
of technology.
I've got a couple of applications here highlighted.
Foreign matter identification, again, this is making use of the collimator and sample
camera, so what we're doing here is we have this, it looks like a plastic sample right
here with this unknown foreign matter right here, so what we can do is measure this area,
which is the blue line, what we're calling the clean area, measure the red area, which
is the contaminant, and as you can see here, it's probably stainless steel.
We can overlay the spectra and see what's different.
We can subtract out the clean area, treat that as a blank, and one of the beneficial
features of our software is this matching library.
So there are libraries included, but you can also make your own libraries.
So right here we have this, we have our unknown sample and we want to see what it is, turns
out to be, we can put it through our matching system.
SUS is a Japanese designation for stainless steel, so it gives you a difference factor,
so most likely this is stainless 316, and again, you can make your own libraries for
whatever you need.
Another example, hazardous substances and products, this is more in line with ROS analysis.
ROS is R-O-H-S, which is European Restriction of Hazardous Substances for these elements
down here.
So as you can see, we use standard samples.
This is a polyethylene resin with these standards in there, and these spectra are the plastic
base material, then the scrape paint, and then the paint plus plastic base material.
This type of application is usually used in a manufacturing plant just for screening.
They'll pull a product off the assembly line, stick it in there, whatever.
Thin films.
So right here we have a copper substrate with nickel, phosphorus, and lead plated on there.
So what we did here was simultaneously analyze the plating thickness and the composition
of this film.
We set the base element to 100%.
You could fix the concentrations if need be.
You can have up to, in our software, up to nine layers.
So it's not just one layer, up to nine layers.
Here's another application example.
Qualitative analysis of cement, I should say quantitative actually, not qualitative.
The good thing about cement is that you get plenty of standards from NIST.
So we used these standards from NIST to create a calibration curve.
First we press the sample in a 25 ton press for 60 seconds.
The reason you want to use a press, if you had just the powder sample and you put it
in a sample cup, there's a film that goes in the cup, and that could absorb some of
the radiation, so you lose sensitivity.
So if you press it, you don't need to use that film, and you'll get the best sensitivity.
Also, with a powder, if you want to analyze something under a vacuum, vacuum will give
higher sensitivity for lighter elements.
You cannot do that with a powder in a cup.
You'll destroy the instrument.
So if you want to do that, we would press it using a simple hydraulic press.
Just some of the calibration curves from these samples, LLDs and results.
As you can see, most importantly, it's a very accurate and precise instrument.
Another question people often have is, how accurate, how precise is it?
Because most people's experience with EDX is geology, it's just a way to qualitatively
tell it's in there.
But in the past 10, 15 years or so, advancements have made it very possible or very applicable
to a research laboratory.
Another application, polymer film.
So what we're doing here is we're determining the thickness and concentration of polymer
films.
We have a new feature of our software.
It's called the background FP method, where it incorporates the X-ray scattering into
the standard fundamental parameters calculation.
So it uses the Compton scattering to determine the thickness of the film, while simultaneously
determining its constituent elements.
Very briefly, talk about scattering.
Two types of scatter radiation, Compton scattering, Rayleigh scattering, Compton is inelastic,
is elastic scattering.
This is what it looks like on a spectrum.
It's labeled rhodium K-beta, rhodium K-alpha.
This is the Rayleigh scattering.
And the C, after that, refers to Compton scattering.
Compton scattering is going to be much more intense in plastic samples or light element
samples.
So you can see here, this red line is lead, this green line is Perspex, which is a thermoplastic
polymer.
So in lead, there's almost no, there's absolutely no Compton scattering.
But in this polymer, we get large Compton scattering.
So since the thickness and density of material, since the, well in this application, the thickness
of material affects the Compton scattering, we can use that Compton scattering to figure
out the thickness of the sample.
So you can see right here, these are three, the overlap spectra for these three polymer
films of different thicknesses.
This is the Compton scattering right here.
So six micron, 12 micron, 25 micron, all give different intensities for the Compton scattering.
Thus, we can use that to determine the thickness of a film.
And this is the result of the polyester film thickness measurement done by background FP.
This is the determined value.
This is the reference value, or what it is.
And this is what's, how it was measured by micrometer.
So you can see it's a very accurate analysis tool, possibly more accurate in this way.
You know, 14.5 compared to 14, and then, you know, 29.7 with a reference value of 25.
And then with, by micrometer, you're only getting a range of 26 to 30.
Additionally, just another application, just continuing on, this is a simultaneous determination
of the film thickness and elemental composition.
So pretty much the same thing, but we actually determined the composition of what was in
this polyethylene film.
We'll have the slides on here if you guys want to read through this.
This is just all different examples of applications we have.
So these will be on the website in the presentation.
For more information, you can visit our website.
We have a whole separate section for applications and other information about EDX analysis.
I think we're running out of time, so why don't we just open up to questions now.

