High Power Lithium Ion Microbatteries from Interdigitated Three-Dimensional Nanoporous Electrodes
Sep 5, 2023
"High Power Lithium Ion Microbatteries from Interdigitated Three-Dimensional Nanoporous Electrodes"
James H. Pikul, Mechanical Science and Engineering
CNST Nanotechnology Workshop 2013
Good afternoon everyone. My name is James Pekul. I work with Bill King in mechanical science and engineering as well as Paul Braun in material science and engineering.
And today I'm going to talk about our work on high-power lithium-ion micro-batteries.
And so the miniaturization of electronics is really, really fascinating from applications like cell phones to really, really tiny sensors.
There's a lot of amazing technologies that have been developed strictly because of the miniaturization of these electronics.
But one of the biggest components of electronics that hasn't been successfully miniaturized is the power sources that drive them.
And so you can imagine a whole new slew of technologies that could be enabled if you could finally miniaturize the power sources.
And so I'm going to talk about micro-batteries or basically miniature batteries today.
And so give me a quick overview on why micro-batteries are important and what they look like.
Here's the pointer. Here we go.
I'm going to look at first – there's basically two major types of micro-batteries.
There's thin-film batteries and there's three-dimensional batteries.
Thin-film batteries are actually very successful batteries.
They're about a $100 million market today.
But one of the big challenges is that the total thickness of the battery is only about 15 microns thick.
So that means the total energy density is limited by the total surface area.
So if you think about electronics or a micro-electronic device, maybe it's about a millimeter by a millimeter.
If you want a thin-film battery to power that electronic device, because it's so thin, the total surface area is going to be on the order of tens of millimeters by tens of millimeters.
And so to really get a micro-battery that's scalable to the same size as the electronics that they drive, you need to go into things called three-dimensional micro-batteries.
And these are basically batteries that have just three-dimensional electrodes, so electrodes that scale in the vertical direction.
And so there's been a couple of demonstrations of these.
But the main challenges for these types of batteries is, first, micro-battery integration and fabrication.
And so there's only been really four successful, fully integrated micro-batteries that have been reported in literature.
And that's because it's very difficult to fabricate anode and a cathode that are tens of microns wide and only a few microns away from each other.
Additionally, these micro-batteries suffer from high performance.
And so today I'm going to talk about our micro-batteries.
And our micro-batteries are three-dimensional.
They also have a fully integrated anode and cathode, and they have exceptional performance.
And so this is basically a schematic of what our micro-batteries look like, and I'll kind of go into the details of how we make these later.
But just looking at the rate performance, or the performance of these micro-batteries compared to other micro-batteries, we can see a huge increase.
I'm at a low-rate discharge, so this is a discharge that takes about an hour.
You can see that the power density of our battery is about six and a half times other previous micro-batteries, and our energy density is about twice that of the micro-batteries.
So already at low discharge rates, we have higher performance than your typical three-dimensional micro-battery.
What's really fascinating with our micro-batteries is that at high-rate discharges, we can achieve power densities that are about 2,000 times higher than other micro-batteries.
And so first I'm going to talk to you about how we achieve such high energy density, high power density.
First, let's go over how a battery works, just to re-familiarize all of us.
You kind of have two electrodes. You have an anode, and you have a cathode.
Basically, you store lithium ions in the anode, and then as you discharge the battery, the lithium ions are moved to the cathode, and the electrons are moved through your external circuit and re-meet with the lithium ions in the cathode.
And that's kind of your basic process. It's very, very simple.
And so the two kind of main parameters for how you determine if a battery is good or not is its energy density and its power density.
And this is actually also very simple. Energy density is related to thermodynamics, and power density is related to kinetics.
So the more lithium ions you can store, the higher energy density you have, the faster you can move those lithium ions and electrons back and forth, the more power you can have.
And the limitation with current micro-batteries, or current batteries in general, is that they can store a good amount of energy density.
Not as much as an electric car, but a lot higher than super capacitors, but they can't discharge that energy very quickly.
And kind of the major resistances to discharging that energy very quickly are lithium transport through the anode and cathode, and so that's limited by diffusion.
Electron transport through anode and cathode, and that's limited by conduction.
And then lithium transport through the electrolyte, and that's limited by diffusion also.
And so what we created is a micro-battery architecture, seen here, that allows us to basically precisely control the diffusion distances and have a highly conductive electrode.
So we can really increase the rate at which we move the lithium ions and electrons across the battery, and so that gives us a really high power density.
And the way we do it, and so this is just a unit cell of our micro-battery architecture, is with what we call a bicontinuous, three-dimensional, interdigitated, and nanoporous electrode.
So there's a whole bunch of adjectives, but all it really means is we start off with a metal foam, and so our foam is made out of nickel.
And then we coat it with a thin film of active material.
And so that thin coating allows us to control the diffusion distance of lithium through the active material.
And because the time constant for diffusion is related to the distance squared divided by diffusivity, by significantly reducing that diffusion distance, we can drastically reduce the time it takes for lithium to diffuse through the material.
We also, with our interdigitated design, can control the separation between the electrodes to increase power density.
And finally, the nickel scaffold allows us to have really highly electrically conductive material, so electrons can move in and out very, very easily.
And so this is a schematic of a full micro-battery cell, and this is the unit cell that you saw in the last slide.
And basically, our electrodes are just made of lots of these unit cells that are patterned in an interdigitated fashion.
So interdigitated fashion is basically if you took two combs and you were to put them together so that the comb fingers were interconnected but not touching.
And that's exactly what our micro-batteries look like.
And the separation between the anode and cathode allows us to control the diffusion distance in the electrolyte as well as the other diffusion distances I talked about earlier.
But here you can just see some SEMs of the micro-batteries that we create.
You have the anode and cathode.
They're about 15 microns tall and about 30 microns wide.
And you can see the active material we coat on it here.
We have nickel coated or lithium and manganese oxide coated on nickel for the cathode.
And we chose this material because it's easy to deposit as well as it's used a lot in commercially available batteries.
Also for the anode, we use nickel tin coated on nickel.
And we use nickel tin because it's a high-energy density material, and so we can extract a lot of energy from this material.
So if you look at the pore size of these, it's about 500 nanometers in diameter.
And then the interconnects between the pores are about 250 nanometers in diameter just to give you a little bit of scale.
And so with this micro-battery architecture, we can create a micro-battery that's fully integrated.
So we have the anode and cathode on a single substrate but also has really, really high performance.
So now I'm going to show you kind of how we make these micro-batteries.
First, we're going to just focus on how you make one single electrode.
First, you start off with a substrate that has a highly conductive material on top.
We usually use gold.
And then we use a self-assembly process to assemble polystyrene spheres that are about 500 nanometers in diameter onto the surface of this material.
We then take this material.
We deposit nickel through it in an electrodeposition bath, and then we remove the polystyrene.
And so that gives us the inverted foam, basically.
So it's just a highly porous metallic foam.
And then we deposit our active material on top over here.
But this is how we kind of integrate it into a full micro-battery system.
We start off with a glass substrate.
And on top of the glass substrate, we have the interdigitated gold electrodes pattern.
And so that allows us to precisely control the diffusion distance through the electrolyte.
And then we do the same process I just mentioned.
We assemble polystyrene, deposit nickel through it, and then we etch the polystyrene.
And so now we have these interdigitated nickel foams, basically, on top of a substrate.
But because in a battery the anode and cathode have to be electrically isolated from each other, we can use this to our advantage.
And the way we use this is we deposit the anode material by electrodeposition.
And then we remove the substrate from that electrolytic plating bath.
And then we deposit the cathode material using electrodeposition again.
And so it seems really simple.
But really, it enables a lot of technologies in micro-batteries
because it's so difficult to precisely deposit these materials at the micron scale next to each other.
But by utilizing the electrode, or basically the fact that they're electrically isolated
and the ability to deposit these materials using electrodeposition,
we're really enabling the integration of full micro-battery cells.
And then finally, we just do some chemical processing, and then we can test our batteries.
So we look at some of the performance data for our batteries.
We use, basically, the first plot we're going to look at is a C-rate performance plot.
And so it's a plot that's kind of used a lot by battery experts.
But basically, a C-rate performance plot basically plots the voltage profile of your battery
versus a whole bunch of different discharge rates.
And so a 1C discharge rate basically discharges your battery in an hour.
If you have a 10C discharge rate, you basically discharge that battery at 10 times the current density.
And so if you want to think about how commercial batteries perform,
at a 1C rate, they usually can extract almost 100% of their energy density.
But at a 10C rate, so if you were to try to discharge them at 10 times the current density,
they would only be able to extract maybe a few percentage points of their entire energy density.
And that's because the internal resistance is inside the battery.
But if you look at our micro-battery technology, you can see that even at 1,000 C,
so that's 1,000 times the current density that we're discharging this battery,
we can extract 30% of our total energy density,
which is a huge improvement over commercial batteries and other battery technologies.
But what that enables us to do is really get high power density,
but still maintain a high energy density.
And so we're not longer trading off high power and high energy.
We're able to get high power and continue to get high energy density.
And so we'll also look at the cycle performance of these micro-batteries.
And to do that, we basically cycle these at really low rates,
so about an hour discharge each for several cycles.
And then we discharge them at really high rates.
And all we're really looking for is to see if the micro-batteries kind of,
if their structure gets degraded or if the electric chemistry is somehow,
there's some sort of side reactions in the micro-battery when you discharge them at high rates.
And the way we can tell that is if you discharge it at a really, really high rate
and then you bring it back to the low rate discharge,
if you can't get the same amount of energy that you can get before,
then you know you're doing some sort of degradation to the system.
But we can see that after discharging at really high rates
and bringing it back to the low rate discharge,
we're able to extract basically the same amount of energy as before,
which means that the high rate energy density doesn't really affect
the total performance of the micro-battery system.
And so now let's look at kind of how our micro-batteries compare to other technologies.
And so to do that, we're going to look at a Rigoni plot.
And so a Rigoni plot plots power density versus energy density.
And basically it just gives you a really good landscape
for all the different energy storage technologies out there.
You have fuel cells over here, highlighted in blue,
that have really high energy density,
but you can't extract that energy density very quickly.
Over here you have supercapacitors, which have a lot of power,
but they have very, very small energy, and you kind of have batteries in between.
But what's kind of obvious is that there's this trade-off.
You either have really high energy density or really high power density.
It's really difficult to get both.
And so what a lot of people are focusing on
is finding technologies that are up here,
in this area where you have really high power density and really high energy density.
And so that's where our batteries are starting to move towards.
And you can see the data points for our batteries
highlighted in different colors labeled A through H.
And so these are all just different configurations,
different electrode spacing, different pore sizes,
giving us different performance.
But basically you can see that at low rates,
our energy density is about similar to other battery technologies.
But our power density is higher than even some of the best supercapacitors,
even capacitors that are recently published in articles like Science and Nature.
The power density of our batteries are higher than those.
And so that's really kind of fascinating,
because when you look at how you build a car or how you build a phone,
you always have these tradeoffs.
You either have to have a battery or a battery and a supercapacitor.
But now you can have one single technology
that kind of meets your energy and power density requirements.
And so it enables a whole sort of kind of new interesting applications.
And so kind of, let me give you an example.
I think I have enough time. Yeah.
To give you an example of kind of how that,
or how you realize that in a scale we're all familiar with.
And so first I want you to think about your car battery.
And so your car battery is about 12 inches long by about 6 inches wide
and about 6 inches to 12 inches tall.
So it's actually a pretty sizable lead-acid battery.
And the reason why it needs to be that big is because you need to power 4,000 watts
to start your engine, to get your engine to start cranking.
But what if your battery dies?
Right, so you have to go either replace it
or you have to go get it jumped by your friend next door.
But what if you could just take your cell phone and plug it into your car
and start your battery with your cell phone?
Well, with our energy storage batteries, our energy storage technology,
we're enabling devices that are the size of your cell phone
that can have the same power density as the car battery in your car.
And so that's kind of a scale where I think we're all more familiar with,
but that's kind of the difference between the power densities of our batteries
and the power density of kind of commercial, conventional batteries.
And so with this work, we fabricated 3D porous interdigitated micro-battery architectures
with short ion transport lengths.
We also integrated the anode and cathode on a single substrate using electrodeposition,
creating a fully integrated micro-battery cell.
And finally, we demonstrated high power density up to 2,000 times improvement
with still very good energy density.
And I would like to acknowledge some of our funding sources,
particularly the Center for Nanoscale Chemical, Electrical, and Mechanical Manufacturing Systems
and the Department of Energy Graduate Research Fellowship Program for funding me.
And with that, I'd like to invite questions.
Time for questions?
If you do have questions, can you please speak into the microphone so everyone can hear you?
So that was a good lesson in the difference between power density and energy density
and how you're optimizing.
But isn't there a very important parameter for battery charge, just charge cycles,
that you can get these high rates?
Yeah.
So let me go back to here.
So, yeah, as I said, you can charge about 100, you can charge about 10,000 times.
And so there's a lot of tradeoffs between cycleability
and what kind of technologies you would apply your batteries to.
So one thing that you can think about, so I brought this to this particular page
because it shows our cycleability.
So after 15 cycles, we get about 70% of our energy that we extract.
So the cycleability of our batteries is not that great.
But the reason why, basically, we lose 5% energy per cycle.
And so I think that's kind of where your question is targeted, right?
Yeah.
So the power density is limited by diffusion in the cathode.
And so we can use diffusion simulations in the cathode
to really kind of understand the space for how we can achieve higher power density,
how we can achieve higher energy density.
And, yes, one of the things we can do is we can decrease the pore size
to increase the power density.
But one of the drawbacks of that is we've only been able to go to 330 nanometers
before we get fabrication problems
because it's very difficult to conformally coat the active material
through these small pores.
The smaller you go, the better you go when it comes to manufacturing problems.
Yeah, okay.
So first question, we recharge it.
Using galvanostatic 1C charge, basically.
And then we hold it at the top charge, so at 4 volts, for about 20 minutes.
So we only demonstrated 15 cycles here.
So we can charge this, basically, continuously as long as we want.
But the problem is we lose capacity over time, right?
So we lose about 5% capacity after each cycle.
And so we can, it's not really going to, most batteries don't fail.
If they do fail, usually what happens is you might get an SEI layer
or some sort of dendrite that forms between the anode cathode,
similar to the way batteries fail in commercial batteries.
But actually most of our batteries don't really fail by that case.
What happens is they run out of energy density because of the capacity fail.
So the electrons are just not enough to turn anything over, maybe,
or so the future battery can end up the same way.
Yeah, I mean, if you recycle it, like, 30 times,
the power density would be reduced and the energy density would be reduced.
Yeah.
Good, so if there are no more questions, this is James Day.

