Dr. Helena Braga joins us live to talk solid state electrolyte batteries, their advantages over Lithium Ion and realities of entering the marketplace.
In Science News: Earth's Magnetic Field: Will it flip? Sea pineapples - the secret ingredient for stronger thin films Where does phosphorus come from and is it rare in the Universe? Solar powered water filter
And a special THANK YOU to Sarah and David for filling in last second as host schedules shifted. They did a fantastic job even more so when you consider that they had almost no notice or training!
=== OUR REAL-TIME DISCORD CHANNEL === All of the TMRO Shows are created and maintained in our Discord channel. Escape Velocity Patrons have access to a special room, but we also have free #general rooms that anyone can participate in. Join in for free at https://discord.gg/9NkkFWD
=== TMRO IS CROWD FUNDED === TMRO shows are crowd funded. If you like this episode consider contributing to help us to continue to improve. Head over to http://www.patreon.com/tmro for funding levels, goals and all of our different rewards!
Hello and welcome to The Conversation. My name is Sarah and I am joined by Lisa and David and
behind us we've got Dutta producing and peeking back there is Jade. We will have her later on
on the show but in news we've got... Will the Earth's magnetic field flip?
And... And can sea pineapples revolutionize thin film coatings? All right and Jade has an
interview with Dr. Helena Braga about the future of batteries. Okay all that and more coming up
on Tomorrow Science, Discovery 1.05. All right before we get into the news we want to give a
huge shout out to our Escape Velocity citizens. These people contribute $10 per episode. In return
they get their name in all three segments of the show, exclusive access to our Escape Velocity
Discord channel and so much more. Every bit helps and we wouldn't be able to continue making these
awesome shows if it weren't for you. So for a complete list of rewards or if you would like
to become a citizen of tomorrow, head on over to patreon.com slash t-m-r-o. Okay you were saying
about the Earth's magnetic field, let's hear it. Yes, will the Earth's magnetic field flip again?
A new study published in PNAS answers that very question. The Earth's magnetic field is known
to flip periodically throughout the millennia. This was discovered in the 50s and the 60s as
Earth scientists began to magnetically map the ocean floor and stripe pattern were discovered
that eventually led to the widespread acceptance of plate tectonic theory. As the magma emerges
from the fault it solidifies as it contacts the cold ocean water. As it does so all the
magnetic particles of the magma having lined up with the magnetic field freeze in place
presenting the polarity preserving the polarity of the field for that portion of the magma. Now as
the ocean floor was first mapped a stripe pattern emerged and not only that but it was symmetrical
on both sides of the fault. This was the holy grail of plate tectonic theory. This is what
really clinched it. What's more you could trace the patterns back through time since as you
progressed along the ocean floor away from the fault you are going back in time and you can
determine the ages of the flips by dating the rocks. A flip would mean that if you had a compass
and used it after the flip the needle would point south instead of north or vice versa.
Approximately of course since the magnetic poles do not line up precisely with the geographic.
These reversals occur on an average of about every 200,000 years but the actual time can
vary considerably. It has been 780,000 years since the last flip so according to the average we are
overdue. Now since we have been monitoring the field strength in modern times there has been
a measurable weakening. This has led scientists to consider the possibility that the field could
be approaching a flip but realize that since we had never seen one before we have been uncertain
how they actually manifest themselves in detail. Enter the science of paleomagnetism.
In a study published in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
on April 30th earth's magnetic field is probably not reversing. Researchers have discovered that
the pattern of the earth's field today is not very similar to patterns that have existed in the past
when the field flipped or reversed. In today's field we have what is called the South Atlantic
Anomaly. This is an area where the inner Van Allen belt comes closest to the earth's surface
due to geometrical realities concerning how the magnetic axis is oriented relative to the
geographic axis. The belt dips lower here and is actually a problem for satellites. The Hubble does
not operate when passing through this area for example. The area of the anomaly has been seen
to expand indicated here by the field strength decreasing since its discovery in 1958 and is
believed to be due to a the continued weakening of the magnetic field's overall strength. So actually
to be more precise the field can ultimately do two different things. The first is a reversal or
a flip as I previously described. The second thing is an excursion. This is where the field weakens
and gets all scrambled up and then it returns back to its previous orientation. So this map
shows the earth's magnetic field during two recent, geologically speaking, periods of the earth's
history. These field patterns discovered do not match what we are currently seeing today with the
South Atlantic Anomaly. Today's pattern more closely matches and I quote from the article
in earlier times centered at 49 and 46,000 years ago. The field is comparable to today's
field with an intensity structure similar to the today's South Atlantic Anomaly.
These fields which are strongly similar to our field today did not go on to develop into an
excursion or a reversal. This indicates that our current weakening field will eventually recover
and not lead to an extreme event. All right good to know. That means our navigation on the planet
is not in danger. Right like for now like birds will be okay. All right all the animals that use
the magnetic field will be fine and you know for now but eventually it's going to happen
for now we're okay. All right and just so we know the Van Allen belts what could you remind me those?
The Van Allen belts are areas in where the radiation gets trapped in the earth's magnetic
field around the earth and so they're areas of concentrated radiation. All right cool okay and
now I have heard just now that there are such things as sea pineapples and I'm really intrigued.
Well yeah I mean sea pineapples they actually are a thing and new research that was published
yesterday May 4 in the journal Advanced Functional Materials shows that sea pineapples
may actually be the secret to improving the strength of thin film coatings. So what this
research was looking at was sea pineapples or their scientific name is tunicates and they're
marine creatures that are actually known as a pest around some parts of the world
but in some parts of the world they're also eaten as a delicacy. People eat these things
but the researchers found that if the tunicates were processed by controlled acid hydrolysis
which just kind of means like breaking down using acid the remaining compounds are called
cellulose nanocrystals which I'm going to call CNCs from now on and don't get that mixed up with
like building stuff CNC machines this is different and so these cellulose nanocrystals
CNCs could be used to strengthen thin films and CNCs are not new they can actually be made
really easily from wood pulp waste left over from things like lumber and paper industries and much
research has actually looked into whether wood derived CNCs could be the next big biological
material with like similar similar properties to bone or ivory and they were strong but they just
turned out to be too brittle if you just used the wood CNCs alone and that's where tunicates come in
so all CNCs whether they're made from wood or from tunicates can form helical nanostructures
when left to dry into a film and helical just means spiral each individual nanofiber is like
a stair in the staircase and multiple fibers pile on top of each other to form the staircase
like you can see in the top left corner of that image there labeled A it's like a staircase
and so the researchers just started with a mixture of just wood CNCs and they tested what
happened when they added different amounts of tunicate CNCs they got these really striking
patterns that are characteristic of staircase shaped molecules when they looked at them under
the microscope but they also found that a mixture of about 30% tunicate CNCs combined with wood
had the most strength each of the images that you can see here below the below six images show
an out of plane ductility test or basically how much you can bend it before the film breaks
and each colored line there was the amount of curvature before the film snapped but the
researchers also found that mixtures greater than 10% tunicate CNCs were great at reflecting
UV radiation and this was totally unexpected so if you have a look at the bottom right hand
graph there each of those lines peak at a certain point where that particular percentage mixture of
tunicate CNCs reflects the most amount of light and so the bluey purple ones which are from 10%
onwards they peak in their UV wavelength so they reflect UV light and so it's kind of thought that
these CNC mixtures could have new uses like protective coatings for things like eyeglasses
or maybe they could be used in things like food packaging or biomedical instruments so
I thought that was pretty cool neat little thing that these scientists found out
all right the sea giving us new technology every day all right now David yes uh how abundant is
phosphorus in the universe astronomers from the school of physics and astronomy at Cardiff
University have been working to find out what is phosphorus good for well it's absolutely necessary
for life as we know it as it is used in the body as a phosphate that is a polyatomic ion if you
remember that from your high school school chemistry that is just a fancy way of saying
that it is a molecule with an electric charge in this case negative three courtesy of its oxygen
atoms now when it comes to biology chemistry is destiny and phosphate has very useful properties
that render it indispensable to life as we know it the reason I'm emphasizing this of course is
because the life on our planet is the only life we know about so that limits us as to our
understanding of life but phosphorus is so darn useful that I for one would not be surprised if
all life required it also even though there may be other forms of life out there they by
definition would only have access to the same chemical building blocks that we do
and that sets limits on what is possible chemistry is destiny phosphate groups also
form part of the backbone of the dna molecule that other part being a sugar called deoxyribose
they bond together resulting in an alternating sugar phosphate backbone it is the specific
properties of the phosphate ion that help give dna its helical structure as well as enabling
it to be water soluble as well the nucleic acids that form the rungs of the dna ladder
are not otherwise naturally so atp or adenosine triphosphate is another really important organic
molecule that uses phosphorus this is the molecular energy currency of the body and energy is stored
and released by the molecule in the formation and breaking of the phosphate bonds phosphate can do
this because of its four oxygen atoms bound to the phosphorus and still having a net charge
so now i have convinced you how important phosphate is to life as we know it the natural
conclusion is that in order for life to exist elsewhere in the universe there needs to be
phosphorus and that is what brings me to the main topic of my story recently astronomers from the
school of physics and astronomy at cardiff university have been using the william herschel
telescope to observe infrared light from two supernova remnants the crab nebula and cassiopeia
a they were specifically looking for iron and phosphorus i've already discussed phosphorus iron
of course is also important for amongst other things making up the core of a planet if you
wanted to have a magnetic field but i digress the results of the comparison were surprising
they found much less phosphorus in the crab nebula than cassiopeia a these results are
preliminary and they've asked for more telescope time to look at the nebula again to check if they
miss some but the implications of these findings are that phosphorus just lying around in abundance
when a nebula begins to collapse to form a new star system where life can potentially arise
is not a foregone conclusion it might very well depend on you being lucky enough to be part of
the right kind of nebula one that received material from the right kind of supernova
explosion one rich in phosphorus dr greaves said ominously the route to carrying phosphorus into
newborn planets looks rather precarious we shall have to wait and see if we can learn more about
phosphorus abundance in the universe in the meantime be thankful that a supernova billions
of years ago and far far away died that you might live all right phosphorus can't get enough of it
we need a lot of phosphorus it's important stuff all right now lisa i think you had something about
a solar water filter yeah so uh research that was published just two days ago on may 3rd in the
journal advanced science researchers found a way to harness the power of the sun the sun to filter
water with near perfect efficiency so i'm really excited about it they actually modified the design
of something called a solar still and solar stills have been around for hundreds of years
you can basically make one yourself like with some plastic sheeting a couple rocks
uses the power of the sun to heat up water so that it evaporates into water vapor this water
vapor is purified and you collect it by letting it condense or turn back into a liquid and if
you built your solar still correctly then you can usually collect that purified water away from
contaminated water but the problem is is that these designs aren't really that efficient they
take in the heat from the environment and heat up and then lose that heat back to the environment or
surrounding air and that heat isn't used to evaporate the water but now researchers have
come up with a way to keep their solar stills cool and they've done that with some pretty cool design
they used paper coated with carbon and placed it in a triangle roof shape with both ends draped in
water as the water traveled up the paper through wicking it gained heat and evaporated causing even
more water to be drawn up and by laying the paper at this uh steep angle it received less direct
sunlight than if it was laid horizontal which helped keep the paper cool you can see in this
image that the flat version or image b got as hot as 42 degrees centigrade whereas the sloped
versions were much cooler only uh the 22.4 degree slope only reached 25.6 degrees celsius
and the researchers actually achieved an evaporation of 2.2 liters of water per hour
per square meter of the device under one equivalent sun of light and phd graduate
haumin song believes that if this technology is upscaled to the size of something like um
like a mini fridge it could generate 10 to 20 liters of clean water every single day but
i think the coolest thing is that by using low cost materials this technology could be a real
alternative to water filtration for people in need and they've even got backing from the national
science foundation's small business innovation research program that's created a startup called
sunny clean water to bring it to the people who need it the most all right okay now we're going
to take a quick break and then we'll come back with jade thank you everybody we've always looked
give us comfort help us find our way we see ourselves out there when we look up
it inspires us on for something we don't yet know we yearn to go there so we venture forth
we choose to go to the moon in this decade and do the other thing
not because they are easy but because it will serve to organize a vision
the exploration of space will go ahead whether we join in it or not many think we stopped exploring
but we know our journey didn't end we've only just begun come with us and explore tomorrow
hello and welcome back to the conversation before we dive into our main topic we'd like to give a
huge thank you to our escape velocity citizens we also want to thank our orbital citizens these
people contribute five dollars an episode in return they get their name in the second and
third segments of the show voting rights on upcoming roundtable discussions free worldwide
shipping from our tomorrow swag store and so much more every bit helps and we wouldn't be able to
continue making these awesome shows if it weren't for you so for a complete list of rewards or if
you would like to become a citizen of tomorrow head on over to patreon.com slash tmro so today
i am joined and honored to be speaking with dr maria elena braga she's the engineering professor
from the university of porto in portugal as well as a research scientist at the university of texas
austin seen she's also a senior research fellow at the materials institute headed by colleague and
lithium ion battery co-inventor john good enough where she is currently expanding our understanding
of solid glass electrolytes and glass batteries hello dr helena dr maria elena braga how are you
i'm fine i'm fine thank you for inviting me it's it's a pleasure and i saw so many interesting
things in the first part of this program i congratulate you because even because i started
with magnetic fields exactly analyzing the rocks so it's very interesting for me and all the other
interesting um small programs that you you have presented here very very interesting well thank
well thank you so much that definitely means the world to us we're glad you tuned in for the
new segment um so i guess as we get started i think it's important to ask what is a solid
state battery and how does it improve upon our everyday lithium ion battery okay so let's start
by what is a battery a battery is composed by two electrodes in which the ions and electrons
react and um with with with the compounds that is that makes the electrodes and it's
made by an electrolyte which is more or less like a carpet to ions um and where the electrolyte
is a very bad conductor of electrons because we want the electrons to go through the external
circuit to give energy to all our appliances for example our computer so we don't want the
the electrons to go through the interior of the cell now in a lithium ion battery that
electrolyte which is that that so-called carpet for the ions is liquid and it's a flammable liquid
so it's it happens very frequently that these flammable liquid because
some dendrites which are kind of branches or swords that
go from one electrode to the other they they grow inside your battery they form short circuits
for the electrons to go through inside the battery and when the electrons uh cross the
the battery the battery heats up and because you have a flammable liquid you the the explosions
can occur and we have heard about a lot of explosions so to to overcome that problem use
the idea is to substitute the liquid the flammable liquid organic liquid by a solid state
electrolyte fascinating okay so um and i think that brings me to my next question which i actually did
already see in the chat here um so to wkd actually asks why aren't lithium ions good enough anymore
now i know you just listed a couple of potential risks with using these batteries um but is there
a big overall reason why we would need an improved type of battery like an overall
different design of it so the first reason i would say is safety as i was telling before
the lithium i all lithium ion batteries have to use an organic liquid electrolyte because
lithium cannot be in contact with water because otherwise it would it would self
self explode so um so so you have to use an organic electrolyte so the first
reason is is this safety reason because you cannot overcharge the battery otherwise if you
overcharge the battery you start forming uh there are other spurious reactions that occur in your
electrolyte in your in our battery as we we are seeing all these dendrites grow these kind of
branches in in our left side of the image and they can go through the the separator that separates
the two electrodes and when they do they are the perfect the perfect pathway for the electrons so
they don't go through the external circuit they prefer they prefer to go to the short circuit
they are like us they use the the law of the the least effort so so the electrons will go
through inside inside the battery and then this may cause an explosion because we know
uh you are in agreement with ohm's law and there is another law that says that you that that if you
have a high a low resistance in your cell you high resistance in your cell you are going to form a lot
so so the electrons will will will go through the cell and and there will be a thermal runaway
and an explosion so this is the safety is is is the the biggest issue the other issue is that
the lithium ion battery of today has evolved as almost as much as it can evolve so
we are achieving the almost 100 percent of the capacity or energy density that is directly
related with the capacity of the battery so for these type of cathodes or elect positive
electrodes that we use in the in the today's lithium ion you cannot increase the capacity
anymore or or there's just a small amount of left to increase so um the improvements in in the
lithium ion battery are just uh engineering improvements so at the surface and the contacts
and so it's not anymore a breakthrough or a step increase or a leap that can be done with lithium
ion and they just they are just determined the capacity is determined by the cathode so
we cannot improve much more the the the energy stored in the lithium ion so that's why we want
a new battery it's not enough the energy that we store in the lithium ion absolutely so you
mentioned breakthrough and that brings me to my next question i understand a lot of your research
was in material science and engineering so i have to ask what was the breakthrough for you and your
team in developing the design of using glass or developing the solid state battery so actually i
am a physicist so i i we were as and professor good enough is also a physicist and when i started to
in the glass the the the most important property for me was actually the the high dielectric
constant that the glass has not not not um the the how fast the ions are are conducted in that
in the electrolyte so let's remember that the electrolyte is like a carpet for the ions
so they they have to be conducted in in a fast way so that we don't lose the energy to to conduct
them in a battery but in a capacitor that is instead of an electrolyte we use a dielectric
material this means it's a material that can form uh molecules that are polar so they have
a zone which is more negatively charged and the zone that is more positively charged let's imagine
like water for example and so if the material is what we call ferroelectric so yeah exactly
in the electrolytes here in a in a conventional battery you have the what people are worried about
is the conductivity of the ions in the electrolyte so how fast they are conducted
in the electrolyte so that no energy is lost or a minimum amount of energy is lost
in our case we use the the the capacity of of a dielectric material
which which not only has fast ions but also has dipoles that can align and form chains
that are aligned with electric fields and so this is the principle of how a capacitor works
so they actually the charge is is conducted through the alignment of the the the dipoles
so this gives an extra surface charge that has to be that has to be compensated at the interfaces
so this is very important this would be the breakthrough for our batteries is that not only
they have ions that are conducted in a fast way but they have these dipoles in as in a ferroelectric
material that can align and bring an extra surface charge which is going to
to create other phenomena inside the battery like the possibility of charging a super capacitor
inside the battery like at one interface in the battery this is a little bit difficult to explain
without our figures but I hope you can understand that besides the the usual electrochemical
energy that is stored in a battery we can store electrostatic energy like in a capacitor so this
is mainly the important message or the important what we think it's important is the breakthrough
in our technology absolutely well thank you so much for explaining that that certainly does have
like a lot of really amazing implications and obviously there's a long list of positives with
these new batteries such as longer battery life higher energy density not blowing up in my pocket
which is always a plus but there's a question in the chat that I was actually going to ask as well
they ask what are the qualities of solid-state batteries other than safety can they be quick
charged safely also what are the downsides what are the potential complications from these new
batteries so very good question actually usually solid-state batteries can only be used at around
50 60 degrees c because they are not they are not the ions are not as fast traveling in the
electrolyte as in the liquid and we can understand this that the fusion across a solid is usually
slower than across a liquid so the problems with the solid-state batteries is usually related to
this what the people do to overcome this problem is that they make thin layers of electrolytes so
that the thickness is of course smaller and so the ions don't have to travel a long distance so
they don't spend energy by traveling so this is the downsides of a solid-state battery but
if in our case if in a battery you have these chains that can align then the ions don't have
to travel all through the battery you have the ferroelectric possibility as in a capacitor
and so the the ions only do small displacements in in the battery so we can we can use these
batteries not only at room temperature but at lower temperatures as well because we have that
extra which are the dipoles that align and and connect like they make the connection between the
two interfaces of the electrodes and they make the connection of the charge between the two
interfaces so the ions only approach one interface and get away from the interface but they don't
have to travel all the way through one side to the other from one electrode to the other
also because our electrolyte contains a lot of ions so if the ions start to
plate which means react with the electrons on for example the negative electrode
they don't have to be immediately replenished by the ions on the cathode which is what
usually happens in a battery because there are a lot of ions in in in our electrolytes so these
these are advantages that make the possibility that allow the possibility of working with our
batteries at low temperature awesome so um so we've heard about kind of how this improves upon
you know our everyday lithium-ion battery but what are kind of the implications for these
improved batteries obviously everybody wants a battery that lasts longer especially when it
comes to cell phone use and whatnot but what about transportation as i understand from some
of my research is that this can have huge implications for you know kind of transitioning
more into green energy vehicles so what types of implications would this have on the broader scale
so of course we need we still we are still at the the the coin cell level we need to to make
actually the industry needs to make the scale up but we are very confident that the scale up is
is is going to be possible so what do you need in a car you need a battery that charge fast
and that and that can can be self autosufficient for a long a long
pathway for a long run so for being autosufficient for a long run you need to have a very high
energy density or capacity to store to store electrons and ions in your in your in your battery
so as in our case because we not only have the electrochemical storage like in a normal battery
but we have the electrostatic storage as in a super capacitor we have an extra energy that can be
stored in one of the batteries the one that we would think that we think would fit better for
for a vehicle because we are studying different kinds of batteries or different kinds of
architectures but for the one for the car I would say that this is what happens we have the
electrostatic as well as the electrochemical component so that kind of doubles the the
the electrochemical component so we have a long a high capacity and on the other hand you need to
charge fast because you don't want to wait for a long time in your station even if they are very
nice and you can have a coffee or or some cookies and rest a little bit you don't want to wait there
for a long time so you want to charge fast your car so as as I was saying because we have the
electrostatic component we can charge fast at least that that component and and this makes the
the the the the the cell the battery very attractive because we can we can we can charge
it fast and and this is one of the important issues in in batteries for cars. Absolutely
so you did mention that they do work in lower temperatures and actually we have a question from
our very own Minnie Soge and she asked would they be well suited to work on Mars which is
extremely cold and would experience extremely low temperatures?
I think that from Mars we still have to to to improve a little bit more well I can what I
can say is that we we are making experiments at minus 20 degrees C and we can work with them at
minus 20 degrees C and eventually at minus 30 but that will not be eventually possible to work in
on Mars or I think that we would we would still need to to to come up with another breakthrough
or or or all the other researchers that are studying these studying batteries. Awesome
well it's definitely it's a it's a stretch goal but I'm sure we'll get there someday.
So there's a really good question from to WKD and they ask have you found any commercial partners
already to assist with development and getting this on shelves at stores? There are a few
there are a few industries and other partners in negotiations and
some of we we have already started to work in research with with some but I cannot be very
deep into this because this is University of Texas
issue and I don't want to to go further to tell more about this. But it's it's good to know and
it gives us hope that there is some traction there and that there is going to be further
development and that leads me to my next question. How long do you project it'll take until these hit
the mainstream market and we can actually see them being used on a bigger scale? From what I
understand lithium-ion batteries originally took over a decade before they became commercially
available. So using your future predicting skills how long do you think it'll take for these?
Of course I don't have a crystal ball I would like to but no.
Well I think this this depends much more on the industry than it depends on us because
what we do is is that we we work on the concepts we make coin cells and we develop the strategies
and and the the architectures and try to understand how the batteries work and what are the principles
underneath the how they work. But the develop so the scale up making them big and and and
make all the tests that that need to be done for a commercialization especially in vehicles.
This has to be done by industry this this is the the purpose of the industry not the purpose of
researchers at the university. So we are trying to go as far as we can go but we our our main
motto is to make research and the development should should be made by the industry. So it
depends on the industry the industry has a lot of skilled scientists as well and as
and they have the proper tools and and so on. This will be faster if not it will be
slowlier but hopefully it will come out. Absolutely well Dr. Braga thank you so much for
speaking with us today. Where can viewers go if they want to learn more about solid state batteries
and the progress of them? Well that's a good question. We are actually we will have a site
in some months but so far we don't have an updated site but they can study they can go to
the papers even if it's it's for you know for more more with more technical detail. But
I think they can they can search for our names and see our papers. This would be what we have
right now definitely but in the future we will have a site where where we have we put all the
news and more details. Well that's exciting I look forward to seeing that. But yeah absolutely right
you google any sort of either solid state battery or Dr. Braga and there is a wealth of journals and
all sorts of wonderful resources that you the viewer can actually go read into. Believe me
it's a fascinating topic. I had to read everything at least three or four times before I kind of
understood it. But once I kind of grasped the meaning of everything it's absolutely fascinating,
extremely exciting. So thanks again so much for joining us. You definitely enlightened us and
helped us understand everything so much better Dr. Braga and we are so excited to hear about
the progress of the solid state batteries. So thanks again for joining. It was my pleasure and
my honor and I see that you have a wonderful fantastic project and keep on going like this
and making all these spots. We need to to talk about science to everybody and it's very very
interesting. Congratulations you are the ones that are that should be congratulated. Oh thank you
that means the world to us. So stay tuned we'll be we will be back after a short commercial break
to answer your comments from the last show. So we'll see you in just a bit. Science it both draws
us together and tears us apart. Brings discoveries to cure us and threaten us. It is neither good
nor evil. It is what we decide to make of it. There is so much more to learn and we are curious.
Together let's explore the science of tomorrow. Welcome back to the conversation. Before we get
started on last week's comments from last month's show we are going to give a huge thank you to our
Escape Velocity citizens. We want to thank our orbital citizens and of course our suborbital
citizens. These people contribute two dollars and fifty cents per episode. In return they get their
name in the third segment of the show. Free U.S. shipping from our Tomorrow swag store and so much
more. Every bit helps and we wouldn't be able to continue making these awesome shows if it weren't
for you. So for a complete list of rewards or if you would like to become a citizen of tomorrow
head on over to patreon.com slash tmro. All right so last month on our show we spoke with Guy Trudeau
M.D. from the University of Ottawa about the Marrow experiment. All right so we've got some
comments about that. Actually sorry this first comment is from YouTube and it's FPV reviews.
Okay it hardly matters but just for the record taking a breath sample first thing in the morning
must refer to the waking time for each astronaut and not for the actual morning aboard ISS which
there would be approximately 19 for every Earth day time equivalent. Okay does anyone have any
comments on that segment? So I think this one is referring to so with the Marrow experiment the
astronauts or the subjects actually had to give a breath sample as soon as they woke up in the
morning. It had nothing to do with like it was when they woke up not when like the ISS passed
into like wake up time or Houston wake up time anything like that because like if you're not
aware the ISS does go around the Earth like you get 15 sunsets and sunrises every day because it
it goes around the Earth so quickly so you don't have to do 15 breath samples.
They don't have to go to bed every time it goes around. It's like 15 nap times.
Oh man you're like the shortest circadian rhythm ever. All right oh all right so then yes FPV
reviews it was about when the astronaut woke up first time. All right we've got another comment
from AZ Offroadster from YouTube. Okay getting a bone marrow sample from the pelvis is not as
bad as some say. It's no picnic but I felt worse. Not asking why. The doctor that took mine
was a small Asian woman. She needed to call in help to actually get the needle in. You're not
selling me on this. Yeah the fact that you would need more than one human strength to get a rather
thick needle into knee bones doesn't exactly sound like a walk in the park but you said it's no
picnic. Yep puncturing bone with steel. But hey this person's felt worse so we don't know this
person could be like wolverine status pain. Right every time. Yeah like he's like gone through some
stuff right this was like nothing. I got you. Yeah but it sounds like it's still an important thing
to do getting bone marrow samples. So it's good that it's not the worst thing you'll ever feel so
let's have it done. I mean unless you've like never experienced like you know like oh my god my arm got
chopped off type of pain in which case I'm sure getting a marrow sample extracted is an experience
to be had. Right probably childbirth but this doesn't sound like it comes with the oxytocin
after so there's no. Okay love it now. Can't get an epidural for that.
All right our next comment is from YouTube Francisco Pinto. Great episode congratulations
for the interview it was really amazing. I'm looking forward to watching the interview with
Dr. Maria Helena Braga Portuguese speaker like me although she is Portuguese and I am Brazilian.
We love your shows down here. Thank you so much. We love doing them. I hope you enjoyed it. I hope
it lived up to your expectations. Hi Brazil. Hello Brazil. And Portugal why not? Portugal is beautiful.
All right and we know all about batteries early solid states. Yeah. Okay another one from YouTube
we have LBCG. Okay this one's a suggestion. If you feel like there's loads that can be said and
your shows are too far apart then once every two weeks maybe or I say that knowing it's a lot of
work and a long day so whatever's best. Okay is this about a comment that happened last show we've
got so much stuff we want to say. Must have been during After Dark. That's when we had a whole
conversation about wanting to do more overachieving. I would love if we had a show every
two weeks and you know what that's the whole point of like bringing on you know Sarah and David and
expanding the cast because yeah and also thank you for coming on the show like I know it was
really last minute but you guys have done an amazing job and yeah the whole reason that we're
bringing more people into the show and training everybody and cross-training everybody and making
them feel uncomfortable with roles they've never done before at the last minute is so that we can
train up a cast suit to have enough people to be able to spin up more shows and have them going
every few weeks without absolutely exhausting everybody. So that's kind of reasoning behind
that and I hope eventually we will get to have a science show every two weeks hopefully when I
finally get back to the US but yeah that is the ultimate goal. The ultimate goal is weekly so
we'll never stop. All right LBCG had another suggestion oh one more suggestion although it
could be a lot of work how about visits out to actual labs and discussions with scientists there
you can call them science documentaries or something else copyrighted all right it could
make for interesting shows and you can shoot footage on location for great visuals that would
be epic like little field trips. I'm down uh let's pitch it to Ben. Hey Ben how do you feel about that?
Oh no that would be. Hey Ben this is happening you get no choice in the matter. I know right.
Decided Lisa just said. We're just gonna do it rogue we're gonna just do it live. Tomorrow rogue.
There you go yeah no that would be amazing especially if we went out to like some really
neat labs or you know maybe a JPL visit here and there let's stay on the street basically. Just
you know yeah I think it'd be neat. I'm yeah I like this comment I don't think it'd be too
much work but then again I'm not the technical person so I could be like in my eyes rolled out
so hard right now just throw up and talk to people it's not that much work. And again this all comes
down to you know having the shows grow and expand and one way that we can do that is by having more
resources um and that's where you know the crowdfunding comes in. The bigger that our
supported supportive network gets the more things we can do and the cooler stuff we can do you know
with science we can go into labs and we can do stuff on location with space we can do live launch
coverage um but it all comes down to having those resources and which is why we're so grateful to
all the crowdfunders and citizens of tomorrow that we have at the moment too. So and even if you can't
contribute you know with money sharing the show helps a lot as well because then we can reach
greater audiences and and maybe that will help us get more resources too. Yeah thanks. Never know if
get set in front of the right pair of eyes and then all of a sudden bam private investor
billions of dollars all of a sudden we're on mars I mean it can happen no yeah
all right so thank you LBCG for the great suggestions we're working on it and you can help
all right okay so next month we hope you will come back for our interview with Alex Moss
CEO and founder of Canaria Technologies they're building wearable tech to fight fatigue related
workplace injury and medically monitor astronauts in space that sounds exciting I mean I'm already
hooked all right well it's a good thing you'll be doing no I'm just kidding by the way okay so before
we go we do want to recognize our ground support citizens these people contribute one dollar per
episode in return they get access to after dark as soon as it's posted on demand access to our
exclusive citizens only hangouts and so much more every bit helps and we wouldn't be able to continue
making these awesome shows if it weren't for you so for a complete list of rewards or if you would
like to become a citizen of tomorrow tomorrow head on over to patreon.com slash tmro all right
thank you everybody thank you and signing off see you next month