🦶Are barefoot running shoe benefits benefits a fraud?🦶 We research minimalist shoes vs. maximalist shoes in 2020! What does the research say about barefoot running vs. shoes and the best barefoot running shoes in 2020!
There are 5 great reasons why barefoot running may be good for you and 1 major reason you want to stick with maximalist shoes over minimalist shoes in 2020! We then go over 5 great tips on how to start moving better as a minimalist shoe runner.
DISCLAIMER: This video and description contain affiliate links, which means that if you click on one of the product links, we will receive a small commission. Thank you for supporting us!
This is opinion only: For the viewer: Do not consider this video as a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. We strongly urge you to contact your own podiatrist or physician with any questions you may have regarding your medical condition. If you are having an emergency, call 911 immediately or see your physician. Do not allow this information to let you disregard your professionals medical advice or delay seeking based on information from this content. Do not rely on information provided by an online video such as this.
Healthcare practitioners: The content here is for entertainment purposes only. The authors have done their best to provide the most up to date evidence-based information, but this content should definitely not be considered any type of medical standard, and it definitely does not reflect individual practices in other geographic areas.
This information is the opinion of Foot and Ankle Web Services LLC, this is not the opinion of the APMA, MPMA, ACFAS, nor any association that anyone present in the videos he may be a part of. Do not take any of this opinion as fact, this is for entertainment only. See your personal practictioner for specific advice. Tom Biernacki is a Doctor of Podiatric Medicine with a degree title of DPM. He does not speak for any licensing college or provider of this degree. This is all opinion for entertainment and by watching this you agree to the above.
All images and additional video segments contained in the Thumbnails and/or B-roll segments are used in strict compliance with the appropriate permissions and licenses required from Techsmith.
This is Tom Ranecchi and today I'm talking about minimal shoe running. So look at all the muscles
at the bottom of your foot right here. So you have your Achilles tendon, you have all these
bottom muscles. When you wear a shoe like this, a gigantic huge shoe like this, these muscles are
going to waste. So the idea behind minimal shoe running is that it's going to work out your
muscles. It's going to get you in the best shape of your life. But what do the studies show? It's
been over 10 years since the so-called barefoot running fad showed up. What does research show
now? I'm going to show you the top five reasons you do want to barefoot run and the one huge
reason you don't want to barefoot run. And then I'm going to review my favorite barefoot running shoes.
Disclaimer, we can't actually give advice online so don't listen to anything we ever say.
Subscribe. We're going to bring you great videos coming every day while we're off
and things are on partial shutdown. So the Journal of Foot and Ankle Research,
over the last couple of years, they released something called the Minimalist Index,
which has been an amazing thing. It standardizes shoes. Why can't you study shoes? Because
everybody's different. Everybody has a million different variables with them. Every shoe is
different. There's no minimalist shoes that are the same. There's no maximalist shoes that are
the same. There's no neutral shoes that are the same. Even within companies, they flip-flop all
over the place and that's what makes these studies impossible. What works great for one person,
the other person hates and they're relatively similar people. And if you're ever working at
a shoe store like Al Bundy and married with children, your life will be miserable because
what one person tells another person makes them feel good, the other person hates.
And there's just too many variables. So that's why the Minimalist Shoe Index is beneficial. So
Journal of Foot and Ankle Surgery used five criteria. These criteria are flexibility.
So how flexible is the shoe? This is a zero on the Flexible Shoe Index right here. Pretty flexible,
close to a 100. Number two is weight. You know, this is a maximalist shoe, but it's actually
pretty light. This is a more minimalist shoe, also pretty light. So that's just one criteria.
Stack height. That means how tall is the shoe from the top to the bottom. Maximalist shoe,
it's pretty tall. So it's the exterior to the top. Minimalist shoe, this is more minimal.
Look at a little bit shorter, you know, compared to the two. There's quite the difference there.
The next is stability. So when you land on this, you can see how built up the heel is.
You're moving around, your muscles don't really have to work. So looking at your Achilles tendon,
I lost the Achilles tendon, but the Achilles tendon right here, when you're in a shoe this
big, the maximalist shoe, the Achilles tendon is barely working. Whereas the minimalist shoe,
it's working quite a bit. You still have to fire all these muscles and stabilize yourself.
One is motion. So in a shoe like this, you're moving around a lot. There's a lot of stuff going
on. It's not black and white details, but you have your flexibility, your weight of the shoe,
the height of the shoe, how much motion you have in the shoe and the stability of the shoe.
So that goes from zero. So this is closer to zero on the minimal shoe index. And this is closer to
100, although that's probably not quite a hundred. There's more minimal shoes out there.
Number two is the muscles in a minimalist shoe. Look at all these muscles and the Achilles tendon.
They're going to be working harder in a minimalist shoe. So a little shoe like this,
rather than a huge shoe like this. So your muscles get stronger. That means they're more
sore at the beginning, but they gradually get stronger and your foot gets better condition.
Number three is for some people, they're a lot better, especially if you have knee and hip
problems. With a shoe like this, you're going to take shorter, choppier steps. Whereas with a shoe
like this, you forget about any of your foot pain and you're taking huge long leaps. Your muscles,
your hips are working harder because your foot's not really doing anything. That muscle strength
and impact has to be absorbed somewhere. So it's just absorbing other parts of your bodies.
For some people that's good. For some people that's bad. Everybody's a little bit different.
Number four, there's a lot of running benefits. So there's a lot of studies out there and they're
linked below, but they show people who wear more minimal shoes. The shoes are lighter. They use
less oxygen. You're cutting, you're sprinting speed. Everything gets a little bit better.
So there aren't a lot of benefits that are claimed. These are not definitive because the
studies are not large in nature, even though some people believe 100% in this and will stand
by it to their death because it worked for them. And number five, you take shorter, choppier steps
with the minimalist shoe that relieves knee and hip pain. So if you're having knee and hip pain,
this might be better for you. Here's five bonus tips for minimalist running. You want to focus
on shorter, choppier steps. So more forefoot striking. So you want to land more on your
forefoot and you want to take more steps per minute. You want to start out slow. So number
three is you want to start out slow. Don't run 25 miles your first day. Run a little bit. Run to the
end of your street. See how it feels. See how you feel the next day. Ease into it. Prepare yourself
for soreness. If you're doing a lot, your front of the leg is going to be sore. Your calf muscles
are going to be sore. The bottom of your foot's going to be sore. Yes, the muscles are getting
stronger, but it's like going to the gym. Can you afford to work those joints out? If you have
arthritis in the bottom of your foot or your big toe joint, this will never help you. Minimalist
shoe stuff won't fix arthritis. And what fixes bunions and hammer toes is if the toe box is tight
in the front, it doesn't matter whether it's a maximalist shoe or a minimalist shoe. You don't
want a tapered shoe front. You want a shoe that has some room in the front. So if you have enough
room in the front, like you can see right here, if you look at the front right here, this minimalist
shoe, because it's not designed for running, is actually more tapered at the front than this guy.
So which one's better for a bunion hammer toe? Really, there's no definitive answer there.
So this is the huge con. The older you are and the more frail you are, the harder time you're
going to have with minimalist shoes. What that means for you is the minimalist shoes are going
hurt your joints. Your muscles are going to hurt more. Your ankles are going to hurt more.
Young people who are great athletes and very physically fit, this is better for you. I'm not
arguing with that. The more fit you are, if you're a super marathon runner who's already in great
shape, eating your greens, eating your vegetables, you're going to probably like the barefoot
running more than a 65-year-old with joint pain. The bottom line is people we see in the clinic
love these. If I told them to wear something like this, they would probably stop running almost
immediately and give out because they'd be so sore the next day. Fit young people can get away
with these and their muscles are worked a little bit more. Most people are somewhere in between.
You don't want to be 100 on the minimalist index. You don't want to be zero. So let's go over my
favorite types of minimalist running shoes. The Vibram shoes are the original. So as you can see
right here on these guys, it's individual toes that are wrapped. And as you can see, compared to
when we showed the maximal shoes, people are not as happy. Even though they do have their loyalists
and people are extremely in an uproar if you bash the minimalist shoes. So they're good for some,
but a lot of people hate them. Just keep that in mind. Look at that. 12% of people hate these
things. So scrolling down here, the complaints are there's not enough support. The seams are
bothering you. You're having a lot of foot pain. That's the main complaints there. So new balance
is a great option as well. You can see these don't have the individual toe covers right here, but
it's a flexible shoe. It's not a ton of support. It's not much heel raise for the most part, but
you can see same kind of thing. 4.1 out of five, which isn't as great as the maximalist shoes.
People complain about the narrow toe box. Some people love it. Some people claim it cures their
but other people hate it and say the stitching really bothers them. So another great one is
Arctaris. This is a little bit more expensive, but this is a very, very light shoe. You can
see here it's not individually toe wrapped. So some people don't get what they want, but it's a
very light, very flexible shoe. Same kind of thing. As you look at the reviews, 4.1, not as high as
the maximalist shoes. And people complain that it just rubs, you get blisters. It's not a lot
of support. That's the main problem with minimalist shoes. So it doesn't really come down to the
studies if you're unhappy with it.