🦶We review the best minimalist barefoot shoes, the best barefoot shoes for flat feet, bunions and plantar fasciitis!🦶
0:00 – Barefoot Shoes vs. Orthotic Slippers 0:12 – Research and Experience with Patients 0:23 – Barefoot Walking: My Experience 0:33 – Myths and Misconceptions 0:48 – Not Everyone Benefits from Barefoot Shoes 1:29 – Injury Risk with Barefoot Shoes 2:23 – Research on Barefoot Walking 3:11 – Running Form and Barefoot Shoes 4:03 – Transitioning to Barefoot Shoes 5:03 – Natural Walking and Running Myths 6:01 – Pros of Barefoot Shoes 7:05 – Risks of Barefoot Shoes 7:52 – Biomechanical Exams and Adjustments
DISCLAIMER: Dr. Tomasz Biernacki received his Doctor of Podiatric Medicine degree from Kent State College of Podiatric Medicine in 2013; he completed his Surgical Reconstructive Foot Surgery & Podiatric Medicine Residency in 2017; he completed 2x traveling Fellowships in Diabetic Surgery, Skin Grafting & Nerve Surgery. He is double board certified in Podiatric Medicine and Foot & Ankle Surgery. Dr. Biernacki is a licensed podiatrist & surgeon in Michigan. This video should not be used to self-diagnose and is not a substitute for a medical exam, cure, treatment, diagnosis, prescription, or recommendation. It does not create a doctor-patient relationship between Dr. Biernacki and you. It would be best to not change your health regimen or diet before consulting a physician and obtaining a medical exam & diagnosis. Always seek the advice of a physician or other qualified health provider with any questions regarding a medical condition.
Today I'm going over barefoot shoes versus orthotic slippers, super maximalist shoes,
crazy orthotics. Do all these make your muscles weak? Do all these cause bunions? I see all these
videos making claims. Hey, shoes cause bunions. Shoes mess up your back. Caveman walked barefoot.
What are the lies, the myths, the secrets of barefoot walking? I'm going to tell you in
this video, we're going to go over all the research, my experience seeing thousands of
patients and we're starting now. So I know that was kind of a sensationalist intro. I actually
love barefoot walking. I do it a lot myself. I've seen patients have great results and I've seen
patients suffer. There's so many lies. There's so many myths out there. Nobody's really rooting
this stuff in studies. People use sensational books where somebody goes and runs with a hidden
tribe in Brazil and spoiler alert, those guys get smoked in races anyway. If you look at the
world record setting marathons, all these guys were super shoes. Now they're making all the records,
not barefoot walking. They use it with super shoes. So it's kind of funny. Like people accuse me
of selling expensive shoes, but the reality is I don't sell any of my own shoes. And number two,
some of the biggest affiliate offers I get are to sell barefoot shoes, which are not cheap if you
look at any of them being advertised. Myth and lie number one, barefoot shoes are suitable and
recommended for everybody. They say, hey, these things straighten your legs. They strengthen your
muscles. That's the myth. The reality is the suitability of barefoot shoes varies greatly.
People have different biomechanics. Some experience benefits right away. Some immediately have
problems, ligament damage, injuries, like right off the bat. And then the next claim is, hey,
you just haven't given enough time, but my patients are actually developing stress fractures and
damage. A relevant study to this is Hollander in 2015 in the journal of foot and ankle research
highlighted that even individuals that wear minimalist shoes have a high variability in
their walking over a long period of time. There is a need for a personalized approach. I'm going to
tell you my experience with barefoot walking shoes. I actually have people come in and walk,
and I look at their hips. I look at their knees. I look at their feet. People who have straight hips,
straight knees, straight feet, who are already healthy, that's who benefits barefoot walking.
If one knee's turning in, if one hip's turning in, as you're walking, you're going to load your
muscles so unequally that you're going to have shin splints, stress fractures, posterior tibial
tendonitis, Achilles tendonitis right away. And most of the patients I see are older people with
joint problems, with peripheral neuropathy. That's kind of the problem with the barefoot shoes. If
you're perfectly straight already, that's when the strengthening works. It's kind of like lifting
weights in the gym. If I put the squat rack on my bar and I'm tilting unequally, I'm going to damage
myself. But if I'm already perfectly straight and have perfect technique, I can really load that up
and my body can handle it. That's a good way to think about barefoot shoes. But let's focus on
getting you straight. Myth and lie. Barefoot shoes completely eliminate injury risk. The myth is
switching to barefoot shoes will prevent a lot of running-related injuries. The reality is while
barefoot running can alter how you walk and run, what they do is they shorten your steps. You take
shorter, choppier steps. So there's less bend through your hips, less bend through your knees,
less bend through your ankles. For a lot of people, that extreme range of motion is what causes
tendonitis or joint problems. For those people, and especially younger people, that makes a huge
difference. Other types of people, if you're stiff, if you weigh a lot, you're going to develop ball
foot pain, heel pain, plantar fasciitis pain, potentially. A study in 2013 by Ridge in Medicine
and Science in Sports and Exercise found that bone marrow edema in people's feet, so that means bone
swelling, dramatically went up in the first month or two while barefoot running. So there is a lot
of bone risk. It's not that you're risk-free. It goes back to point number one. If you're already
healthy, strong, and flexible, you're going to tolerate this a lot better. Those shorter,
choppier steps won't load your joints as much, but you will have less cushion and more impact
injury. Myth in line number three, barefoot shoes naturally improve running form. The myth is that
simply wearing barefoot shoes will automatically improve your running form. Barefoot running does
encourage more of a forefoot strike. You take shorter, choppier steps, and it does force you
to consciously focus on your technique, which is good. You can develop some bad tendencies with
supportive super shoes, whereas barefoot shoes do make you walk with shorter, choppier, more
focused steps. The Journal of Sports Medicine and Physical Fitness in 2016 by Fuller showed that
barefoot running does change your strike pattern, but it doesn't necessarily alter injury risk. Myth
number four, transitioning to barefoot shoes is quick and easy. The reality is it's not easy.
It can take a long time. If you're young, healthy, and fit, you will transition. A study in 2018 by
Johnson in the Gait and Posture Journal highlighted the need for gradual transition, and we're talking
months and months. I have a great guide on a walking program, how to start a walking program
if you're older, if you're stiffer, but I always tell people start slow for about six weeks.
That's how long it takes for your ligaments to adjust to get a little bit more flexible.
So you don't want to do it all at once. If something's hurting, you want to dial it back
and ease into it. I'm not saying barefoot running's bad, but there is an adjustment phase.
Myth number five, barefoot shoes are a natural way to walk or run. We were cavemen. We were
meant to run and walk. Minimalist shoes are the closest to a natural state. The reality is our
ancestors hardly lived any years at all, developed crippling arthritis. They were shorter. A lot has
changed. We sit in chairs. We sleep in beds. We do a lot of stuff differently. Our ancestors,
while they did walk more barefoot with less supportive shoes, they developed physical
conditioning, more biomechanics to do so over time. Nature is a great magazine. A study in 2011 by
Lieberman on the biomechanics of foot strikes over large populations noted that even amongst
barefoot people, there was a huge variability in running gait and foot strike. Even though they
were barefoot their whole life, there's still a huge genetic difference in how they walk and run.
So here's kind of the big secret. There are pros of barefoot shoes. They encourage shorter,
choppier steps that don't load your body as vertically. There's a lot of good studies that
it is a more natural biomechanical foot strike. It does strengthen lower extremity muscles,
and gradually it makes you think about your gait and your muscles do get used to walking.
There's an improvement in sensation. You can feel with your feet and adjust, and it can help you
prevent injuries, but there is a risk for injury or biomechanical injuries. Specifically, stress
fractures through your bones. There's less cushion. If you have a bad back, bad hips,
tight hamstrings, tight knees, and you try to do this too aggressively, you're going to have
a lot of joint problems. And I see that predictably with a biomechanical exam. If I do
a biomechanical exam and somebody has issues, the vast majority of the time they will have a hard
time adjusting. Not all the time, but the majority of the time. There's limited protection for
biomechanical issues. Ingrown toenails, bunions, hammer toes. Specifically, if you have less
cushioning in your foot, if you have less flexibility, you can't absorb this damage,
and it can lead to foot-specific injury. Most of the people that come in with foot problems
can't get through that adjustment period. You want to ease into it. Do a little bit of barefoot
walking during the day, but wear good supportive shoes, good supportive orthotics to let your
joints, your muscles heal. And the big secret is you have to get a biomechanical exam. If you're
struggling to adjust to this, if you're not a healthy 20-year-old or 30-year-old fitness influencer
who has an affiliate deal for barefoot shoes, it's not going to be the easiest thing in the world,
even though barefoot walking is great once you adjust to it eventually.
The way I talk about adjustment is biomechanical exam, see where you're injured, see where you're
tight. Just like a dentist straightens a tooth, I would tell people start with a shoe that holds
you a little bit straighter. Start with a soft pre-made orthotic, then potentially a custom
orthotic. And as you're already straight, that's when more and more barefoot walking makes sense
because your knees are straight, your hips are straight, your back's straight.
It's then easier to adjust.