In Episode 04 of the Falun Gong Bulletin, we'll cover the 5 key trends for 2023 listed in our latest report. We'll also recap the 2023 International Religious Freedom Summit and share the top three takeaways.
Be the first to read breaking news updates from one of the largest civil disobedience movements in the world. Subscribe to the FalunInfo newsletter today: https://faluninfo.net/subscribe
Welcome to Falun Dafa Information Center's new show,
The Falun Gong Bulletin, where we cover news from China
and give our analysis on why it matters to us
even here in the West.
Hi, I'm Ben Maloney, Digital Outreach Director
for Falun Dafa Information Center.
And I'm Cynthia Sun,
Researcher at Falun Dafa Information Center.
On today's show, we're gonna go over our five forecasts
for the persecution of Falun Gong in China
and what the 2023 could hold.
And then we're also gonna do a recap
of the 2023 International Religious Freedom Summit
that Cynthia attended in Washington, D.C.,
and give you our top three takeaways from our experience.
Why don't we get it started, Cynthia,
and you can talk a little bit about this report,
which is key trends in 2022, what to watch for ahead,
which is a report that Falun Dafa Information Center
published, it's available online,
and it was one that got a lot of attention
at the summit as well.
Why don't you walk us through the five trends for 2023?
The first trend is targeting Falun Gong practitioners
as part of censorship efforts surrounding spikes
in COVID infections and deaths.
The second is high-tech surveillance deployed
to monitor and detain Falun Gong practitioners.
The third is new international sanctions and imprisonments
of CCP officials involved in the persecution of Falun Gong.
The fourth trend is the fate of Falun Gong in Hong Kong.
And the fifth trend is transnational persecution
of Falun Gong practitioners.
And so maybe we can go back to the first trend
and break each of them down.
The first trend really targeting Falun Gong practitioners
as part of censorship efforts surrounding the spike
in COVID infections and deaths.
This actually brings us back to 2020.
At least 12 practitioners were detained
as part of censorship efforts to suppress the information
of COVID-19 going out.
And this year, as we know, the lockdowns have lifted
and zero COVID policy is no more in China.
And so we see a lot more activity
surrounding Falun Gong practitioners
and uploading information on, you know,
jumping the Great Firewall and trying to alert people
outside of China to what is actually going on
within the borders.
Yeah, right.
And it's important for the viewers to understand
that the reason Chinese Communist Party
is so focused on the Falun Gong practitioners
to get getting this information out
is not just that it's happened historically,
but that Falun Gong practitioners have developed software
to get around the Great Firewall.
They have organized pipelines
and information networks out of China.
And they also are the largest number, right,
of people persecuted in China.
So they caused the biggest, quote, unquote,
threat to the truth actually getting out,
whatever that truth is around human rights,
or in this case, around some of the things
actually happening on the ground with COVID.
There's a couple examples maybe you could give as well.
So Xun Na and 10 other practitioners
were detained in early 2020.
She was sentenced to eight years for sending information
about what Beijing looked like and the lockdowns in China.
And Feng Bing, the second practitioner
that we feature on Falun Info is pretty well-renowned.
He's a YouTuber actually that went into Wuhan hospitals.
And for a whole week, he documented what the body bags
and what was actually going on
with all of like the COVID infections inside of Wuhan,
the hotspot of where COVID actually spread out from.
This year, we've seen dozens of reports on Minghui
and of practitioners like jumping the firewall again,
just like they did three years prior to send information out
the targeting of Falun Gong that we expect
would be more likely in regions of Northeastern China,
like Hebei province, Shandong province, Jilin province,
and Heilongjiang province.
These regions in Northeastern China have been historically
where the persecution is the harshest
and also where more Falun Gong practitioners are located.
Why is it the harshest in those areas?
Not only like the density of Falun Gong practitioners,
but also a lot of the security apparatus
is also located in Northeastern China.
And so they just have the resources,
the amount of people to carry out this persecution campaign.
And going into the second trend,
it's similar high-tech surveillance
used to monitor and detain Falun Gong practitioners.
We've covered Hikvision alarms in the past episode,
but there's an emerging technology
called the Health Code app,
which was mandatory for all Chinese citizens to have.
It marks you as green, orange, or red
to indicate if you have been in close contact
with COVID-19 individuals,
or if you are safe to go out and go to grocery stores,
go to your workplace, go to school.
This tool was actually used as a suppression tactic.
One practitioner reported last year,
police threatened to change her health code
if she didn't renounce her faith to Falun Gong
and sign an oath that she would stop practicing Falun Gong.
It's a good example of how the Chinese Communist Party,
whatever technology they can use
is really a repression tool.
So ostensibly, it looks like it's some sort of health tool
that also, we should note, restricts your movement,
restricts if you can go to your job, make money,
restricts if kids can go to school,
restricts where you can move around.
And then the reality is,
obviously the Chinese Communist Party
is not using it for health.
They're using it as a tool of repression.
Exactly.
And so emerging technologies just like this,
just like the health code app,
the Falun Dafa Information Center will continue to monitor
and document the cases.
Trend number three is new international sanctions
of CCP officials involved in the persecution of Falun Gong.
In the past few years,
the Biden administration has actually sanctioned
several perpetrators of the persecution of Falun Gong,
top level CCP officials.
For gross human rights violations.
For gross human rights violations,
especially in Sichuan and Fujian.
And in 2023, we actually expect,
as more cases are documented,
that Northeastern China, like the perpetrators there,
will also be under-
Sanctions. Sanctions.
The two people sanctioned by the Biden administration
are only a small percentage
of the hundreds of perpetrators.
Every city, every province has police officers,
local officials, neighborhood committees
that are involved with the persecution of Falun Gong.
And so for the past 24 years,
especially in these upcoming years,
since the Blinken and the Biden administration
has already expressed that they are willing
to sanction under Minitsky Act and others,
these human rights violators,
it's important to continue to send these lists their way
so that they can sanction more in the future.
Trend number four is the fate of Falun Gong in Hong Kong.
Falun Dafa Information Center is especially concerned
about the rights and freedoms
of the community of Falun Gong practitioners in Hong Kong.
Since the adoption of the national security law in 2020,
some suspect that Falun Gong practitioners
could be banned or violently persecuted
like those in mainland China.
And what we've seen is that pro-Beijing officials
have issued public calls to ban Falun Gong in public.
At least one incident in 2021,
authorities fined practitioners for holding an exhibit.
And although Falun Gong practitioners
have been able to continue practicing their faith,
doing meditation in parks and the like,
in 2022, there are at least three cases
at the low levels of judicial court
where courts punished attacks on Falun Gong practitioners
or information booths and upheld basic rights
such as freedom of expression
and the display of a Falun Gong banner in public.
In 2023, we expect that incidents will continue to happen
just like this, but we'll have to see
whether the courts continue to uphold
these freedoms of belief, freedoms of expression,
or if they set the precedent this year
that the national security law
is actually going to ban Falun Gong.
The fifth trend is transnational persecution of Falun Gong,
which ties in from earlier.
The CCP's persecution of Falun Gong
has rarely stayed within the borders of China.
Refugees and local practitioners around the world
have faced surveillance and harassment,
including in Chinatowns and on college campuses.
So the most prominent case was in New York last year
where an individual who was suspected to have ties
with the CCP and the local consulate in New York
went around for a week going to information booths
where volunteers would pass out pamphlets of Falun Gong
and he destroyed banners, he destroyed a Bluetooth speaker.
It was a targeted coordinated attack
because for that entire week,
he went around several locations
and repeated the same battery.
Right, and this is something we should note
that it's not just this one individual as a trend.
Like we knew that, for instance, in Houston,
this used to happen a lot.
And then when the consulate famously got shut down
in Houston, these incidents suddenly dried up
and no longer happened,
which helps to kind of prove the point
that perhaps there was those relationships
that actually the consulate is the one driving
these individuals through whatever means
to actually coordinate these attacks.
The center is also concerned about covert tactics
to masquerade CCP opinions in the West,
such as in newspapers, on social media,
and among policy influencers
to spread anti-Falun Gong sentiments.
Right, and that's important because that can happen
through a variety of ways.
Obviously, the most egregious being,
somebody physically going to assault the booth,
but there's many ways that they can push,
the Chinese Communist Party pushes
their anti-Falun Gong narratives.
Cult label was a very famous one.
Racist.
Yeah, racism, different aspects,
different political aspects and political labels.
So the Chinese Communist Party can push that through,
any ways, right?
Like think tanks or-
Diplomatic.
Yeah, Western media, opinion pieces, or paid media.
When you read something about that,
we would encourage you to look at all sides,
yeah, and kind of see where the real facts are there.
But that's a really good segue.
Those top five trends, again,
my report, which is printed here,
is available on the website.
We'll link to it below so you can have a better look.
But I know that this report was a big topic
in the IRF, or International Religious Freedom Summit,
which you just went to in Washington, D.C. very recently.
Curious if you could tell us a little bit
about what is the IRF Summit,
what was Falun Dafa Information Center doing there,
and how did everything go?
Yeah, the IRF Summit is held annually.
This is the third year that it's been held
and the third year that we've attended.
And it's basically to increase public awareness
about religious freedom around the world
and how it's being suppressed, essentially.
Right, and it's, just for clarity,
there's the largest NGOs are there,
there's policy makers, and like I saw,
Blinken issued a statement well-wishing the IRF,
so there's a lot of connection
between the U.S. government and NGOs,
and this is a pretty big deal.
Yeah, and there was also a legislative,
the president of the legislative UN from Taiwan
was also there, which is one of their top officials as well.
So usually, Falun Dafa Information Center
has a booth with information such as the latest report.
And also, this year we featured three speakers.
The first was our executive director, Levi Browdy,
who spoke on a panel about documenting dissent
and how Falun Gong community has been able
to have these cases from the past 23 years
and how to best clarify them to Western people
who might not know what's going on inside China.
Especially around forced organ harvesting, is that right?
Exactly, yeah.
And we also had two other speakers
who are actually victims of the persecution, unfortunately.
Grace Chen and Simon Zhang personally had experiences
being persecuted in China
or their families being persecuted.
Those who follow our social media will know
that these two are at the top
of our family rescue initiatives.
Can you tell us a little bit about,
for people that aren't as familiar,
a little bit about Grace and Simon, just high-level,
what their stories are for people that don't know?
Grace Chen is a high school student in New York.
Her parents were detained in China in 2020,
so it's been over two years now
since she's had any contact with them.
They were sentenced to an unknown length of time,
and so she was just there to really share her case
with people and to find out how best
to help them find freedom.
Simon Zhang is an architect in New York City.
His mother was actually detained this time last year
during the Beijing Winter Olympics.
During that month, he was advocating.
He was trying to find out how to get her released.
After that month, she was actually found
to have been killed in police custody from the persecution.
Both of their cases were really moving,
and they really highlighted how widely
this persecution impacts people, even here in America.
Tell us a little bit about the reception
to their stories.
I know they were on panels with other victims,
but can you tell us a little bit about what they said,
or maybe we can play some clips?
Yeah, sure.
Grace Chen, she was featured at the Youth Track
with other religious prisoners of conscience,
but her testimony was especially moving
because she also had experiences growing up in China,
being fed propaganda when she was in elementary school,
being kidnapped once when she was on her way
to kindergarten, leaving to America by herself
at the age of 14.
And then after a year, not being able to have any contact
with her parents, finding out that her parents
were detained from a news article,
all of that was really shocking to hear
because she is so young.
She's still in high school.
Probably best if you hear it from herself.
So we have a clip here to play.
In the fall of 2020, my parents were arrested
with eight other Falun Gong practitioners.
When I found out, it was so sudden and shocking,
but I wasn't that worried.
I just called my mom and dad a few days ago,
so I thought they would be okay and call me again soon.
A week passed, and I still had hope.
Then two weeks, three weeks, four weeks went by.
Every time I heard the phone ring,
I hoped it was my mom and dad.
I never called.
I felt so miserable.
Every night, I cried in bed.
I became quiet at school.
I bookmarked every single article
about my parents' arrest on my laptop.
I felt like now I was all alone in the world.
You just heard from Grace's own words
how she was affected by the persecution.
You can watch her full speech on faluninfo.tv
or on any of our social media.
After watching her speak, everyone in the room was in tears.
There were other people who also similarly
had experiences of persecution, but she was so young,
and so they were just applauding her,
trying to encourage her,
because it's very difficult to come
and talk about such a horrific experience.
But Grace is also the second generation
affected by the persecution,
because she was born in 2005,
so it was actually years after
the persecution had already started.
After she graduates this summer,
she'll be unable to go back to her family in China
because they're arrested
and there's gonna be security issues with her going back.
We'll do a follow-up episode in the future, maybe,
with Grace, or if you have any questions,
please leave them in the comments below,
and we might do a Q&A if she's willing to share her story.
As for Simon Zhang, his panel session
was with human rights experts,
such as Nina Hsieh and Katrina Lantos-Sweat.
He mainly highlighted the impact of the persecution,
as we just said, about his mother,
because she had also been detained in forced labor camps
several times before her most recent detention last year,
in which she passed away.
I'll let him explain it in his clip here.
On March 21, 40 days after she was arrested, my mom died.
My father demanded an explanation,
but was only met with indifference.
Instead, nearly 50 policemen guarded my mom's body
and monitored my parents' apartment.
On April 7th, my mom was cremated.
My father was forced to give permission.
After the police threatened, they would fire my cousin,
who is my father's close nephew, from his government job.
They also threatened him, my father,
using photos of me joining Falun Gong events
in United States, telling him that they know everything
about what's happening here.
His experience was rather harrowing,
but he wishes that, you know, by telling his story,
that other practitioners, the millions that are still
in China, won't have to face the same thing that he had.
You can also watch his full speech on FalunInfo TV.
I met a lot of incredible people.
I'm really grateful for the experience.
A lot of congressional members and human rights experts
were very interested in Simon and Grace.
They were very willing to help,
so we have a lot of takeaways from the whole experience,
which I'd like to share.
Sure, yeah, give us some of, like,
maybe the highlighted three takeaways
from some of your learnings and experience at the summit.
So overall, there was a general awareness
about, you know, the Chinese Communist Party's abuses
of human rights and suppression of faith.
Overall, there was, like, a lack of awareness
of how to deal with it or what to do to stop it,
because a lot of people have, like, the conceived notion,
maybe that, you know, China's so far away
that we're unable to do anything about it,
or, like, it's the concerns of the people in China
and not our concern, but I found a lot of people
were willing to listen, and a lot of people
were willing to brainstorm together ideas of what to do,
and we actually have a lot of ideas.
One of them we mentioned earlier was sanctions.
We've seen that actually impacts, you know,
the perpetrators personally.
If you don't know, the sanctions actually prevent
the perpetrators and their families from coming to America.
If they have any land, property, assets in America,
those are seized.
Their children are unable to come to school here,
and so it really affects them personally.
The sanctions as well as other avenues,
like exposing their crimes even,
like the simple act of documenting persecution,
the crimes that they're trying desperately to cover up,
that's also one of the avenues to actually make change.
We also had a recommendation of,
this was for mainly the ambassadors
and any diplomatic staff who are going to China
to meet with victims of persecution,
to meet with people who are affected
by the persecution of Falun Gong that are here in America,
and because those stories really,
I mean, like you heard earlier,
those stories really do matter,
and it's like people's lives that are at stake here.
And the last one was the bills.
The United States has yet to pass a bill
about forced organ harvesting and-
And Falun Gong Protection Act.
And the Falun Gong Protection Act.
The United Kingdom and Canada have already set a precedent.
The UK actually passed two bills
regarding forced organ harvesting
that we've talked about in previous episodes,
and those have actually made a rather big impact
because it completely stops the economic trade
of medical equipment between the United Kingdom and China.
And it also prevents organ tourism from happening.
And then the second takeaway was USURF,
which is the United States Commission
on International Women's Freedom,
actually have prisoners of conscious forms
that anyone can fill out.
So I really wanted to share this with the viewers
because anyone can just go onto the website,
and if you have a family member abroad
that is being persecuted, that you know is detained,
and there is some sort of document or evidence of it,
USURF is actually looking for help in this regard,
and they're requesting that people send them in
because if they're not sent in,
then they're not documented.
If they're not documented,
then legislators and policymakers can't really act on it.
Right, so just so I'm clear,
one of the ways that the government,
whether they're doing the sanctions
or they're looking at bills,
one of the ways that they understand the scope
and the individual cases is through this portal
that people document cases, is that right?
This is the number one resource for policymakers
to make these decisions into law
and to really consider it as high priority.
We'll also have a link for this
in the description box below, so please send them in.
The third takeaway was really the impact
that victim testimony could make,
as you just saw with Grace and Simon in our clips before,
and also our previous victims
that we've brought to the URF Summit.
It really moves people and it really helps people
humanize and visualize what's really going on
inside of China,
because there's a basic understanding
that the CCP is a violator of human rights,
but how does it really impact the people, the community?
How, for Grace, her whole school was indoctrinated
by this Falun Gong propaganda,
and her teachers would talk about it,
her faculty would talk about it.
She was really scared to even say
that she was a Falun Gong practitioner
because she was worried that her family
might be taken away from her,
which now we know that they were.
And so just having, I guess, a space for them
to really tell their stories
that they weren't able to in China
was really important to remember,
because we have all of these statistics.
In our report, we have analysis of all these trends,
but impacting-
It's happening to people.
It's happening to people, just like us.
And not even in our worst nightmares
would we think of all of these,
like forced organ harvesting, all of these crimes.
And so what the Falun Dafa Information Center
really hopes is that we can bring you more stories
in the future,
and also that you'll be willing to listen to these stories
because it really makes the difference for them.
Thank you for joining us today
for the Falun Gong Bulletin.
Until we see you next time for the next episode,
feel free to share this clip
or this video with your friends and family.
Thank you.