Coir, produced from coconut, has burst onto the scene, including for use in the garden. What are the benefits of using coir, and is it better than peat moss?
Buy your DirtFarmerJay caps, mugs, and t-shirts at www.dirtfarmerjay.com!
DirtFarmerJay shows the differences between peat moss and coir, and with no spin, shows the up AND downsides of each product.
At the retail level, both peat moss and coir come in compressed forms. Coir is in “brick” form (hard and dense), and peat tends to be in semi-compressed, plastic-packaged bales. Both need to have water added and the fibers spread apart to get the product ready to use.
The pH of the products is different. Coir tends to be close to neutral, with pH ranging from 6.0 to 6.8. Peat pH usually runs in the 3.5 to 4.8 range. pH will ultimately be decided by both the surrounding soil and the irrigation water. If alkaline/basic water is used on acidic amended soil or growing medium, that medium will ultimately become basic.
As for structure and durability, the two differ a bit. Peat does decompose faster, while coir is more durable. Think of other coir products you may be familiar with, such as doormats, natural fiber ropes, and scrubbing brushes. Peat and coir are used for starting mixes for seedlings and are not going to be the long-term medium anyway. As for structure, peat does tend to compress more in the soil, while coir keeps the soil “open” for longer.
Both have significant water holding capacities - many times their own dry weight. There is a wide range of statements of how much, but suffice it to say that both retain water well and help the soil to not dry out between waterings. Coir will carry around 40% of its own weight in water, peat moss about 60 - 65%. However, coir weighs more.
What about cost? It depends where you are in the world, simply because the further you all from the production site of either coir or peat, the more transportation costs need to be paid for.
Approximately 85% of the peat reserves are in Canada, so major markets for the product are both in Canada and the U.S. Peat is cheaper to produce and the cost of transport is relatively low. So, where we live in the Mountain West of the U.S., peat is cheaper than coir (at the time of filming, peat moss was $3.67 per cubic foot and coir was $5 per cubic foot).
The majority of coir is produced in India and Sri Lanka, with additional production coming from Thailand, Indonesia, Malaysia, Vietnam, the Philippines, and Brazil. Most of the major markets for the product (which is used for much more than agriculture!) are elsewhere, so there are significant shipping costs to get it to market.
Is coir or peat "greener?" This is a bit more complex than what is apparent. There are several “loud voices” indicating that the choice is plain - coir is the winner. Others say peat is being depleted in the bogs and this will lead to environmental disaster. Conversely, peat producers have no interest in not maintaining the long-term productivity of the resources they manage. Like the forest industry which constantly replants for future harvest, so do peat producers. Both peat and coir production and harvest, are NOT “one and done” propositions.
Add in fuel expended to transport, and the picture of which is more sustainable or “green”, and it becomes even murkier to name a “winner.” As far as working conditions, traditionally the coir industry has had poorer and more unhealthy working conditions than the peat industry. In all fairness though, that is changing as the coir industry stabilizes and has become a major economic force in the countries mentioned earlier.
After researching the subject, and reading material from various ideological viewpoints and academic papers, we at DirtFarmerjay.com are comfortable in using either peat moss or coir, knowing full well there are trade-offs for both products.
To help you become more informed on this subject, check out these articles:
Hey, Dirt Farmer Jay here from DirtFarmerJay.com.
What's better, peat moss or coir?
Well, there's quite a rumble out there on the internet.
People are pretty emotional about it.
Stay tuned and I'll give you some facts and you can make up your own mind.
Hey, Dirt Farmer Jay here from DirtFarmerJay.com.
Well, there's quite a discussion out there about whether peat moss is a good product
to use in the garden for growing starts or whether coir is.
And coir is a coconut product.
Sometimes it's a byproduct and sometimes plantations are planted primarily
to get a lot of coir.
So it's not just a byproduct, but it has burst onto the gardening scene.
Now, one thing before we go a bit further, let's get pronunciation downright.
Coir, spelled C-O-I-R, gets a lot of different pronunciations.
But let me just give you a memory cue that'll help you.
If you came up to me and we were talking and you felt that I was being a little sarcastic
and you said, hey, hey, are you being coy with me?
And I retorted, no, you're being coyer than I am.
You got it.
It's coir.
That's how it's pronounced.
Now that we got that little bit of unpleasantry out of the way,
let's talk about these two products.
Well, you've probably heard a lot of things out there or read a lot.
And if you've landed here, you have an interest in this.
What's better, coir, peat moss?
You may have heard a lot of material about this being a non-sustainable material
that the peat bogs, 80% of peat moss is produced out of Canada, by the way,
and the peat bogs up there, that they're killing off all of those areas.
It's non-sustainable.
It's really bad on the environment.
Well, like anything like that, you really have to do your research
and realize there's a lot of sustainability that is going on.
What kind of farmer destroys his ability to re-harvest again in the future?
And so they've done a lot of work to make sure that they can come back
in later years, re-harvest again, leave the ecosystem intact.
Coir, while it is true, is from the husk of coconuts.
And coconuts are used for a lot of other things,
such as culinary coconut flakes, coconut oil, coconut milk,
used a lot in Pan-Asian food, especially in Thai cooking,
where coconut milk is used.
To just call it a pure byproduct that was going to go to the dump anyway
is not accurate at all.
80% of the production of coir is done in India and Sri Lanka.
Other nations, such as Thailand, Vietnam, Malaysia, the Philippines,
and even Brazil and South America are other sources of coir.
So that ought to tell you something right there.
There's transportation costs and transportation carbon footprint
that goes into production of coir.
Another thing to consider is the working conditions of the human element.
If we put any weight on humans, and I hope you do,
then when these are produced, how healthy are the working conditions?
Well, coir is a very dusty product.
It's produced in countries that historically have not had good working conditions.
But in all fairness, there's a lot of work being done
because of the economic positive impact this product is producing in those countries.
So the trade and production associations are doing quite a bit
to improve the working conditions.
Now, what about the physical characteristics of both of these?
Well, as you can see right here, this block of coir is ultra compressed.
Once it is, let's say, reconstituted by adding water to it,
and you expand it, you and I can't get it back into this form.
This form is put in through a press forms
and using hydraulic, very high pressures that you and I are not able to produce.
Whereas peat moss is a semi-compressed product.
So you can see very compressed right here in the flakes here versus peat moss
that as you see me reach in the bag here and grab that and lift it,
it's somewhat big flakes, it's semi-compressed.
So a little bit difference.
pH, this tends to be very neutral.
If you remember any of your chemistry, 7.0 on the pH scale is neutral.
This is right around neutral where peat moss tends to run on the acidic side,
being around 3.8 to 4.0 pH.
But keep in mind that whatever you're watering your garden with
is ultimately going to determine the pH as well as the surrounding soil.
So where we live in the Mountain West in the United States,
our water is very alkaline, basic.
And so even if I put in a lot of peat moss,
ultimately it's going to neutralize because the water itself is basic.
It's going to neutralize and buffer this and all that.
So just keep that in mind.
For those of you thinking, I'm just going to plant things in peat moss
to grow acidic plants, but you're in a place that's got basic water.
That's a lot of work to maintain that.
What about durability in the soil?
Well, peat moss breaks down pretty quickly.
Coir hangs on longer.
It doesn't break down as quickly.
And to help you understand that,
think of some other coir products you're familiar with.
Some of those placemats that you've seen, the bristles.
How about some of those bristle brushes or for cleaning
that are made with coir or coconut fiber?
Very durable, very resistant to salt degradation
and salty or maritime settings,
and sometimes are made into ropes that did well in salty conditions.
So keep those in mind, the two different ones.
So what is better?
We'll read the resources in the description below
and make up your own mind.
As for dirt farmer Maggie and me, we're comfortable using either one.
We think they're both great products.
However, coir is slightly more expensive at this point.
You can understand that it has to be transported a longer distance.
Somebody's got to pay for that.
So but either one is fine because they both have environmental tradeoffs.
There's not a villain and a hero in this.
They both have contributions and attractions.
Well, if you found this video to be helpful, won't you like it?
And better yet, subscribe to our channel.
And when you do ring that bell, because then approximately every Friday
you'll be notified of great content about the home, the garden,
the kitchen, out in the shop.
It's just being a great homeowner where you can just do it yourself.
And while you're at it, check out Dirt Farmer Jay dot com
and look at our blogs, all sorts of extra content, ways
you can interact with us and our new merchandise line.
Hats, shirts, coffee mugs.
We'd love to have you be part of the family of those people
that just show that you just like to do it yourself until the next time.
This is Dirt Farmer Jay, Dirt Farmer Jay dot com.