Perlite, Rockwool, Coco Peat, Growstones...Which Should You Use and Why?

Epic Gardening
119 followers
4 Video Views·Mar 10, 2023
What's going on guys? Kevin from Epic Gardening here. You know,
I've been getting a lot of questions lately about what type of hydroponic media
to use in different types of systems. What should I use if I'm a beginner?
What are the downsides and the benefits of different types of media?
And I figured I'd just run through some of the stuff that I've grown with and
what I think about it. And keep in mind, you know, this is just my thoughts,
but I've done the research. I've tested out a bunch of different products and,
you know, I've got my favorites and I've got things I don't like as much.
So let's start running through it. The very first thing,
one of the bigger ones that's out there right now is,
is cocoa peat or coconut coir. Um, let me just zoom this in for you guys.
What is it? It's basically ground up coconut husks.
And in my opinion,
it is a super important development in hydroponic growing media,
just because think about it. You're in the jungle,
you're farming coconuts, you know, in a tropical region,
and where are those husks going really? Um,
they're going to be wasted a lot of the time.
And if they can be ground up and treated in a organic manner and then shipped
out to be used in gardens worldwide,
that's obviously a better result than just kind of tossing them in a landfill or
throwing them in the trash. Um, so what are the benefits though? Uh,
besides just that environmental impact, they've got some really cool benefits.
So number one,
it's fairly inexpensive and it's actually compressible.
So you can buy compressed coconut coir,
throw some water on it and it will absolutely blow up to these like impossible
sizes. Um,
it's very,
very surprising when you see a brick of coconut coir actually expand for the
first time. Uh, one of the few downsides though,
is that it does hold a lot of water. And if you're not careful,
you might actually drown your plants. But you know,
in my experience, as long as you're doing it right, you should be pretty safe.
And I gotta be honest, this is one of my favorites.
This is what I'm growing with most of the time right now.
I even use coconut coir seed starter plugs.
So I think you can see that I do like it a little bit,
but let's go on. Next one is expanded clay pellets.
A lot of you guys know this as hydroton, except for, uh,
or unfortunately hydroton no longer exists.
Now that's not to say that expanded clay pellets don't exist,
but the company that owned the mine that was pulling the clay out of the
earth for hydroton, that mines actually run dry. So there are,
there is no more hydroton as we know it,
but there are a bunch of different products or stuff like hydro corn.
That's more or less the same thing. Now,
this has been one of the most popular media of all time in hydroponics.
And part of the reason for that is that you can reuse it almost
endlessly. It's got a nice air to water ratio.
It retains water a decent amount.
It's pH neutral and it comes in a size that's actually pretty useful.
So it's not, you know,
it's not as granular as something like coconut coir,
but it is not as thick as something like a big
thing of rockwool, for example. So plants can work around it.
Plants can navigate through it without any type of problem.
Now, a couple of the problems that I have noticed as far as downsides are
concerned, it's pretty heavy. When you've got a full tray,
if you're doing an ebb and flow system or something like that,
it can get pretty dang heavy.
I found that it typically drains and dries pretty fast.
So roots might dry out unless you're using a system like, you know,
a deep water culture or an ebb and flow that is protected from the sun
in the sense that, you know, if you're ebbing and flowing,
during those ebb periods, you might actually, the, excuse me,
the water might actually dry off of the hydroton and the roots might actually
dry out and suffer some damage if you're not careful with how you position
those plants. These days,
it's a little bit harder to find and it is strip mined.
So if you're someone who's concerned about the environment,
that is something to think about. But, you know, I,
I like to think of the entire positive,
negative cycle of things.
If I'm going to be using it over and over and over and over and over again,
taking good care of it,
I don't really have a problem with the fact that it's strip mined because,
you know, it's,
it's much better than something that's strip mined and then immediately thrown
away. Sure to grow.
This is just a brand name of one of the typical sort of plastic
based growing media that's out there right now. A lot of people like it,
but you know, personally, it's not one of my favorites out there.
We've got some reader feedback here.
I thought this might be interesting to share with you guys. Reader says,
just don't really like this.
I feel like they re-blended a plastic medium as some magic media. I would,
I would kind of agree with that. In the industry, we call this stuff sure not to
grow. Pretty good there.
I currently use it in ebb and flow and my experience with it at first was
generally negative. So what I've noticed, and you know,
I want to appear unbiased. So I have grown with it.
I've grown a bunch of different things,
most notably my micro greens that I grow.
And I noticed that between a sure to grow pad soil
and a coconut core mix,
the sure to grow pad grew the absolute worst.
And it had a more likely chance of molding out, which, you know,
you think, wow,
plastic is a plastic based growing media is more likely to mold.
It doesn't make a lot of sense,
but I think it's just the way that it retains water in sort of a stagnant way
that that causes that mold to crop up more often.
It's not reusable.
So that's kind of what I'm talking about is you get something that's not only is
it not sort of a very sustainable product in the sense that it's oil-based
plastics,
but it's also not reusable because the roots kind of intermesh between the
growing media and there's really not much you can do to use it a second time.
So you pretty much have to throw it away. Not my favorite. Oasis cubes.
They're similar to rockwool. It reminds me of those florists.
If you go to a florist and you get the, you know,
get an arrangement to keep it healthy and to keep it surviving,
they'll put it in that gray sort of foam stuff. That's,
that's more or less what Oasis cube are like.
Really good for starting the seeds out.
So germination and seedling phases, I really prefer Oasis cubes.
A couple of readers have said they, they love the new Oasis cubes.
They've reformulated their blocks. It's an inert media like rockwool,
but a fraction of the price.
And they seem to say that it grows equally as well as rockwool.
So Oasis is pretty nice. Again, it's not sustainable, not organic.
So if that's something that you care about that's definitely something to
consider. All right, next one up is perlite. All right.
Perlite is something that's pretty well known in gardening in general,
something that people use in traditional soil gardening quite a bit.
There is no soil in perlite. However, it's actually volcanic glass.
It's air puffed. So it creates almost like a pumice sort of situation,
but it's actually much lighter than pumice. It's almost air-like.
When you grab a handful of it, it feels like you're not holding much at all.
And that is one of the benefits. It's very lightweight.
And it does retain oxygen quite well.
So you're not going to drown your roots out in perlite.
But it is almost so lightweight that it needs to be mixed in with another type
of growing media to actually have a good result because it's that lightweight.
It is strip-mined and it's small enough and there's enough airborne particles
that you could suffer some sort of health effect by inhaling the particles.
So, you know, I don't typically grow with full perlite. I've tried it before.
And like I said, it's a little bit too lightweight for me.
I'd prefer to mix it with something so I don't like knock it and it just starts
going everywhere. So that's kind of what I feel about perlite. Now,
starter plugs.
This is not necessarily a growing media as it is a growing option.
You can start your stuff in soil. You can start it in, you know,
a bed of coconut coir if you want to go the hydroponic route.
But if you want to do something really efficient,
and that's what hydroponics is all about for me. It's keeping it efficient.
I like to use starter plugs.
And essentially what that is is it's a pre-molded material that helps you
transplant easier. So as you can see in this picture,
it's got that sort of square shape and there is a bio-resin that sort of holds
all that material together. So when you pick it up,
it's not like you're just picking up a little square of soil.
It's going to stick together.
And you can actually get it in quite a few different formats.
You can do actual soil starter cubes. You can make your own if you want to,
or you can do coconut coir cubes, which is what I personally prefer.
One of the more popular ones is called the Rapid Rooter.
It's a peat moss based kit.
And on the sustainability side of things,
a lot of people are sort of bashing the peat moss stuff because it's run out
more or less in England and in other places in Europe.
But that's not the only place on earth.
Apparently Canada has reported that they have so much peat moss that they won't
run out for another a thousand years.
So that's just something to think about when it comes to sustainability.
And it's just such a time saver that I really prefer using these seed starters
to start my gardens. All right, now we come to rockwool.
Rockwool is one of the more famous nutrient or sorry,
growing media that's out there these days.
Very well known in the hydroponic growing community.
And the way it's made essentially is they'll melt rock and then they sort of
air spin it into these really long fibers,
which is what they then compress into these cubes.
So it's essentially rock in a thread like format that's been smashed together.
So, you know,
I'm not going to say that there aren't a lot of benefits to using rockwool.
It's fairly inexpensive. It's somewhat easy to work with, but you know,
it's just not that easy to dispose of. It's like these thin fibers.
It's basically taking something like rock,
turning it into something that can never really be reused or disposed of or
degrade. And then, you know, making a ton of that.
So there's just all sorts of little weird issues.
I'm personally not a fan of the fibers and the dust. So, you know,
that's just something that I like to consider.
And I actually wrote an entire post on this that got a little bit of attention
from one of the bigger rockwool companies out there.
So if you're interested, you can check that out. Let's get onto Growstone.
I was at a hydroponic expo and I came across Growstone and talked to one of
their sales managers and he gave me a bunch of the little samples. Oh man,
I fell in love with this stuff. It's so cool.
It basically is a hyper sustainable
product, which is important to me. And the way that they make it,
just check this out. Basically they make their,
they station their factories next to landfills and they go and they get all
of the glass bottles, glass material from the landfill.
So basically they're taking something that would have been stuck in the ground
for thousands of years, pulling it out.
They'll crush the glass into a powder.
They melt that and then they mix in calcium carbonate.
And what calcium carbonate does under that amount of heat is it starts to
bubble.
And that's how they create this volcanic rocks style effect that makes
Growstone what it is.
And the even cooler part is the heat that is put out by that whole process.
They recapture some of that and they actually use it to run their facility.
So it's a hyper sustainable product. And as a medium itself,
I found it to be extremely, extremely effective.
I've used it in ebb and flow and in deep water culture before.
Now the only downside is it's hard to clean because it's porous and sort of
rough. So roots will kind of stick to it and they won't come off.
So if you need to set up another grow with the same stuff,
oftentimes it's best to just scrap it and move on, you know?
So on that angle,
you may want to consider that it's not the most reusable thing out there,
but it's so sustainable that I almost don't feel bad throwing it away.
All right.
I'm going to touch on these lightly because some of these I don't have as much
experience with, but I do know that some people have used them. So rice hulls.
Personally, I don't, I can't imagine myself using it just because it's,
it's pretty small.
I can't imagine it'd be that porous and it would be an organic material that
would sort of decay over time. So I would not really use that.
Pumice is pretty close to perlite.
You can actually use it in a similar manner except for that it's heavier than
perlite. Perlite's very, very, very lightweight.
Pumice is only just a little bit lightweight, retains oxygen well.
Sand is something that people will use, uh, just because it's extremely cheap.
You can just go to the beach, get some sand and you're off to the races. Um,
you know, it's not as good for certain systems as it might be for others.
Like if you're putting in a net pot,
you're going to have to line the net pot or just not use sand because it's just
going to kind of pour out.
I think it may be good and maybe an ebb and flow sort of situation. But again,
I might mix sand with something else and not use it solely as a growing media.
Next we have gravel. Gravel is a pretty good medium.
It's a pretty similar to like a hydroton or a growstone situation,
except for probably a little bit less porous.
And probably the major benefit of it is that it's just really cheap and you can
use it over and over and over again.
Wood fiber is another one that's probably a little bit more on the fringe.
It's pretty efficient. Um, again, it's biodegradable.
It may not be sterile depending on where you get it.
But if you want to do it on the cheap, if you're really into the organic thing,
then go ahead and do it. Now brick shards,
I'm not going to touch on this too much.
It's pretty much the same thing as gravel,
but you do get the added elements or hassle of having to deal with a brick dust,
which is really not the most favorable thing on the planet.
Polystyrene packing peanuts. Um, you know,
I've seen people use these before. I personally don't.
I'd rather not grow with a polystyrene plastic. That's just not,
that's just not what I'm into personally. So, um, I would pass on this.
I just want to make sure that you guys know it. It is an option.
Now we've got vermiculite, which is somewhat similar to perlite.
It's a little bit different.
And a lot of people actually mix vermiculite and perlite together and go ahead
and use that as a growing media. But again,
I would say use this like you would use perlite and that you should probably
mix it in with something else. Um,
maybe like vermiculite plus coconut coir if you're finding that you don't get
enough drainage. All right guys, that is it.
That is the basics of hydroponic media and I'll be doing some more extensive
guides on the particular media, like what types of coconut coir,
what types of, of grow stones you should use. But you know,
if you're more interested, this post that I pulled all this from,
it's on the blog, it's at epicgardening.com slash hydroponic dash growing dash
media. So feel free to check that out if you want. And as always, hit me up,
Twitter, Facebook or the forums, or you can email me.
This is Kevin from Epic Gardening. Keep gardening players.
