The inner critic can be destructive and limiting. Sometimes it seems like the negative self-talk comes from an enemy within. In this video I draw from the work of Jay Early and talk about the 7 aspects of the Inner Critic. As strange as it may seem, this voice is actually trying to help. The only problem is that it is overly excessive. I talk about how to reconcile with the Inner Critic rather than fighting it or denying it.
For Online Counselling, visit https://www.drdavidmaloney.com Procrastination Video Course: https://www.drdavidmaloney.com/procrastination-course-101 Relationships Video Course: https://www.drdavidmaloney.com/relationshipsvideocourse Thanks for watching. If you enjoy my content, remember to like and subscribe for more.
Dr. David Maloney is a Psychologist and therapist. His has trained in a variety of techniques (person-centered, Gestalt, ACIM, psychodynamic) and works with people on a wide variety of issues. His main areas of expertise are in self-esteem, motivation, and relationships.
Hey guys it's David here. In this video I'm going to talk about what is the inner critic.
In terms of even knowing how to deal with it or what do you do with this thing and it can seem
like an enemy within us sometimes. First of all understanding really what it is is a big big step
in that because there's a lot of confusion in that. So we're going to deconstruct the inner
critic and leave you in no doubt about what it is, what it's trying to do and is it a bad guy?
Maybe it's not a bad guy we'll see that's what we're going to talk about.
So this issue of the inner critic I'm going to read a question and it might help us start our
sort of examination of the inner critic and this question it starts off it says I've been
practicing shadow journaling. Now shadow journaling is something I talk about it's
just allowing that inner critic to come out and speak and you write it down but I've been
practicing shadow journaling for a few weeks like you talked about in the past video and I've been
mindful about how the inner critic talks to me throughout my day. The more I become aware of it
the more clear it is becoming just how negative and destructive it is on my life and yes it is
destructive we'll talk about that. It makes me feel worthless and afraid all the time.
Why is this voice here? I mean what function does it serve and is it ever possible to
fully get rid of it? So that's what we're going to talk about. What is it? Why is it here? Why
is it showing up and what purpose does it serve and what are we going to do with it? Can we get
rid of it? Should we get rid of it? So when we're talking about the inner critic we're talking about
that voice it kind of chimes in it's a fearful voice it's a voice that fills us with a lot of
doubt insecurity limitation and there's many different words for it many different ways people
have classified it one of them is the super ego that's Freud's version for Freud and for Jung.
Jung called it the negative animus and what that really is it's kind of like a father-like or a
patriarchal inner voice an authoritative voice that's chiming in and giving us feedback all the
time often it seems like it's intrusive uninvited voice that comes in another way to think of it is
I like it's a sub personality it's a part of your psyche that chimes in every now and then
another concept that's useful to think about this inner critic is that it's a system of thought
it's actually it actually isn't really you this part of yourself right it's a it's a system it's
a whole framework of thought think of it this way your nervous system is your body it's always
looking for danger that's its job your nervous system is designed to keep you safe all the time
if your nervous system could speak okay this is what it sounds like it's the voice of be careful
be careful be careful all the time it's always looking out for danger
and this inner critic is actually a really central part of all of that
one thing I'm going to talk about here is something called universal thought so what
does it sound like what does the inner critic sound like here's a few examples of what it sounds like
I need to know what to do that's the inner critic I'm just going to give you a few examples here
I need more money life isn't fair I need to make a decision I can't do anything right I can't
disappoint people there's too much to do I'm worthless it's my fault I missed my chance this
should be different it's my fault I'm a failure I need to understand more I did it wrong I need
to do it right I need to be in control money will make me happier I'll be better when I have more
money so sometimes it's in the form of an high voice like it's an internalized voice as if it's
your voice other times people say that they'll hear you you need to improve you can't let that
happen again so really it's what we're beginning to realize is this is really an internalized voice
usually from much younger in life that now is there chiming in all the time and the thing about
it is it's not always bad okay now I get that it's very destructive and it is destructive it's
crippling to a lot of us it's not always bad there's usually a grain of truth in it but the
problem is that it's completely out of balance this inner voice this inner critic comes in
almost like it's completely aggravated and it's shouting at you for attention sometimes
when it's really really aggravated so it'll tell you things like you're bad you're wrong you're
you're inadequate you're worthless you're guilty and again just to point out if your nervous system
could speak your nervous system preoccupied with only one thing your safety if it could speak this
is what it sounds like now we tend to think of it as a problem we tend to think of it as an enemy
within almost now what I'm going to say here is that believe it or not there are no enemies within
you there are no enemies within you this voice although it is destructive and it's it's out of
balance it's over the top ultimately what it's trying to do is keep you safe which is it's quite
bizarre really when you think about it like that like it's the last thing it doesn't seem helpful
in in any way but it's actually trying to be helpful it's identifying danger all around this
is the problem with our modern day life our nervous system is there is no physical danger the nervous
system will always have to do its job so it gets busy looking for problems it becomes maybe even
hypervigilant in its environment looks for problems identifies threats and will point chime in with
this over-the-top input for you now that's all very broad and generic I'm going to talk here about
more specifically about what it is what is this inner critic what does it look like
we talked about some of the universal thoughts that it draws on none of the the thoughts that
come from the inner critic are original original thought our universal thoughts are all repetitive
you may notice that your inner critic keeps saying the same things over and over again it's not
creative and different individuals we all have the same I'm not good enough I need to do more I
need to be in control they're universal okay so there's nothing original about these thoughts
it's not a creative thought system but I'm going to describe seven aspects of the inner critic and
this is from Jay Early's work and it's really really interesting to to to realize that there's
different aspects even within the inner critic and maybe you recognize some of these there's
seven of them I'll list them off first of all we have the perfectionist we have the inner controller
the task master the underminer the destroyer the guilt tripper and the conformist
and all of these things in our life it looks like they show up and they hold us back they're hurting
us but believe it or not they're all trying to help in their own kind of dysfunctional way
when we learn that that's actually a big piece in healing this because we begin to realize there's
no enemy within I don't have to get rid of this I don't have to avoid it I don't have to
deny it's there or distract myself from it all I need to do is to reconcile with it we need peace
we need less inner conflict but to start off with here this is something I talk about in my channel
a lot which is the perfectionist which is a massive part in procrastination this inner critic
doesn't help with this at all so what is this perfectionist that Jay Early talks about well he
says this critic tries to get you to do things perfectly it sets high standards for the things
you produce and has difficulty saying something is complete and letting it go out to represent
for best work so it's that it's not good enough it's not good enough it's not good enough it's
not good enough it needs to be better you haven't done enough work on this yet needs more time
that's the voice that's what it sounds like this inner perfectionist
its expectations probably reflect those of people who have been important to you in the past so
again think parents think teachers high standards maybe we made mistakes in the past they were not
really accepted or that we were undermined for them and this perfectionist becomes a part of
this perfectionist is only trying to prevent you from being judged harshly okay and experiencing
the pain of that so it it it gets in this oftentimes it's this procrastination thing
where it's never finished it's never finished so that's the perfectionist maybe you're you're
acknowledging that maybe I don't know maybe you recognize that in yourself the second thing we
have here is the inner controller and when I think of the inner controller I think of
the shamer this is the thing that the voice that shames you for certain things that you do in your
life so Jay Early says this critic tries to control your impulses so eating drinking sexual
activity etc it is prioritized or sorry polarized with an indulger or an addict which is it fears
can get out of control at any moment it tends to be harsh and shaming in an effort to protect you
from yourself so again it's excessive it's not particularly helpful but its motive is safety
keeping you safe protecting you from yourself in this case and it's motivated to try to make
you you a good person who is accepted and functions well in society okay so it's protective
that's what it's doing here but it uses this excessive shaming tactic so if you notice there's
an internal dialogue of maybe you eat that food or you have an extra drink at the weekend or
something and there's this shaming thing coming in that's what this is when you start to reconcile
with this you'll realize okay this voice isn't my enemy it's excessive but I realize what it's
trying to do next one the task master again I talk about this in my procrastination course I
call this the chronic doer the person who is always always busy all the time the task master
this critic wants you to work hard and be successful it fears that you may be mediocre
or lazy and will be judged a failure if it does not push you to keep going it's pushing often
activates here we go a procrastinator or a rebel that fights against its harsh dictates so I talk
about that in the course also any of these have to voices that we have which is a part of this
task master you have to do this you have to do that eventually a part of us an autonomous part
of us will rebel against that and that results in a stalemate in which we we don't do anything we
don't relax but we don't work we're just stuck in this constant state of indecision and that's what
procrastination is chronic doer again although it although it seems very very harsh again it has our
safety in mind again this is why the nervous system is speaking this is what the nervous
system sounds like if it could speak safety safety safety it only cares about safety next
the number four the underminer this one the underminer is very very prevalent it's a way to
cope with bullying for instance maybe we've had trauma from bullies in the past this critic tries
to undermine your self-confidence and self-esteem so that you won't take risks it makes direct attacks
on your self-worth so that you will stay small and not take chances where you could be hurt or
rejected so again it's saving you from rejection it's taking this job on and undermining you
yourself so that you'll be safe from doing it at least they you have control over that now and
those people over there that you don't fully trust they won't be in charge of that
there's afraid of your being too big or too visible and not being able to tolerate judgment
or failure so maybe you have this voice that's telling you don't go out and socialize it's too
dangerous now it doesn't say that overtly maybe but it's it's trying to keep you small invisible
not to be seen again this is the hyper vigilance that we get from abuse or bullying in the past we
become very very sensitive to our surroundings that's the underminer that we get from that
next is the destroyer now this comes from trauma really if there's been really really bad abuse in
the past or really difficult life situation this is how the nervous system deals with a really
negative event situation it makes pervasive attacks on your fundamental self-worth fundamentally who
you are to the core of your being it shames you and make you it makes you feel inherently flawed
and not entitled to basic understanding or respect now why on earth would our nervous system do this
you must you might be asking yourself how could that possibly be helpful
this most debilitating critic comes from early life deprivation or trauma and it is motivated
to believe that it is safer not to exist okay so the trauma is so painful it doesn't want you to
go through that trauma again it convinces you that it's better off if you don't exist again
way out of balance way too excessive in the feedback that this that this is given
and we see this in depression we see this obviously in suicidal ideation
but it just goes to show that there's this isn't about a character flaw when this happens
this is people always trying to do their best even in terrible terrible situations
but the destroyer it can also be in other things the destroyer can also be there in
relationships it keeps just destroying things to keep them keep you safe keep you away from them
next we have there's no two left we have the guilt tripper and this is the one that i say
it uses the past as a weapon the guilt tripper this is when we get those cringe memories popping
into our awareness something's reminding us of the nervous system the the inner critic is showing us
these past failures this critic is stuck in the past it is unable to forgive you for wrongs you
have done or people you have hurt it is concerned about relationships and holds you to standards
and behavior prescribed by your community culture and family it tries to protect you
from repeating past mistakes by making sure you never forget or feel free so again it's basically
saying never let that happen again look remember remember remember this happened look what you did
look what you did look what you did again just trying to stop you doing it in the future completely
unhelpful really but it's coming from a place of safety just safety preoccupied and finally we have
the conformist and i talk about this in terms of the tribal acceptance when we're young the most
important thing is that we're accepted by people around us they feel safe and if that isn't there
it's a big problem for us so the conformist tries to get you to fit into a certain mold based on
standards held by society your culture or your family it's all about fitting in for safety
it wants you to be liked and admired and to protect to protect you from being abandoned
shamed or rejected this is a massive one this is really the most fundamental one there is
because the fear of being abandoned or to be left alone is really the most traumatic feeling that
there is the conformist fears that the rebel or the free spirit in you would act in ways that
are unacceptable so it keeps you from being in touch with and expressing your true nature
okay so anytime you think about taking risks or to express something authentic about yourself this
conformist will come in and start making comparisons okay look at this this is not acceptable this is
the other people do it unhelpful makes you feel restricted inside it's it's really difficult for
creativity to come through with this part was there but again it's all about safety so i know
i've been repetitive here and i'm going to finish up this video here at this point because i just
want you to sit with those again just one last reminder we have the perfectionist the inner
controller the task master the underminer the destroyer the guilt tripper and the conformist
all of them working in their own little way to keep you safe with this excessive emphasis on
safety right so i'm just going to leave it there for now but that's really answering the question
what is the inner critic why is it their safety and can we ever get rid of it and that's what
i'm going to focus on in in more detail later but getting rid of it does not involve ignoring it
pushing it away pretending like it isn't there distracting yourself what it does how we how we
deal with this is we have to reconcile with this we have to recognize that it's afraid and it needs
to feel safe again and we have to bring your authentic personality and this voice of the
nervous system the inner critic into alignment okay and we have to convince the nervous system
it's okay i hear you i recognize you but we're safe i promise we're safe convince it that it's
safe that is not achieved through positive thinking or denial that is a process and that's
what we're going to get into more in in a little while here so thanks so much for watching food
for thought i hope that was helpful and i'll see you again soon bye for now