How strong are rappel rings? It only needs to be about 2x more than your weight to hold you during a rappel (in case you don't rappel smooth). Add a little safety ratio for good measure and it's super good enough. The problem is if it wears down. https://www.instagram.com/kevhamrich/ pulled this rolled aluminum SMC rappel ring off a popular route in Yosemite and it broke at 1.5kN instead of it's 14kN it is rate for, which is legitimately dangerous.
00:00 Intro 00:45 Aluminum Tests 03:40 Titanium Tests 06:01 Steel Tests 09:06 Deadly Aluminum Ring 09:47 When to use each one 12:24 Bonus Test: Line Locker
What are we doing?
How's my hair?
Rappel rings.
Let's test these today.
We've been collecting these for six months.
We have aluminum, titanium, and stainless.
They're a little bit different for each one.
We've got several different brands.
And the most interesting one
is this rolled aluminum rappel ring.
If you've ever rappelled on rolled aluminum,
and they're pretty light,
you're like, eh, is that gonna hold you?
Sometimes you'll see three or four of them
stacked on webbing that goes around a tree
just because I don't think very many people trust them.
I know I haven't in the past,
and I'm gonna find out what good ones break out.
And then we're gonna find out what this worn down one
on a popular route in Yosemite,
that's gonna be the special bang at the end.
Oh, microfractures.
Why do they look so beat up?
Maybe I got them off of routes, I don't know.
Let's start with the rolled aluminum ones.
Bobby, we should have plexiglass on the machine.
Wouldn't get all that cool footage if we did.
Well, that is shocking.
I bet you're curious how strong this is though.
And I'm gonna be that guy
and make you wait until the end of the video.
We'll break that last.
Here are some DMM rings that are rated for 23 kilonewtons.
And I pulled them off of an arborist harness off the sides.
They're a little bit more flat,
and they are either CNC machined or forged.
This hit my shield.
I'm glad I have that.
Yeah, that didn't bend at all.
It was all in the nothing.
Doesn't really look deformed.
This broke at this.
So now let's test these GM hot forged aluminum rings
rated for 25 kilonewtons.
It's not as clean of a break as you can see.
It's got more of a jagged thing.
It definitely broke way higher than it's MBS.
So that's good.
Wow, this one's actually less round than the other ones.
So these next rings are pretty flat from CMC Rescue.
They're rated for 5,000 pounds,
and they are machined out of flat stock.
So this is the most endangered that I've felt.
I stand behind this.
But after stuff breaks, I stand up,
and there was enough lag time in the bounce
that it came right here and hit in this box.
It bounced off the wall.
Oh, that's a low result.
I don't know what 5,000 pounds is off the top of my head.
But it's not 21.82.
So broke at 4,905.
Not MBS.
You're in danger.
Rated for 5,000 pounds.
Whatever, super close enough.
That broke lower.
That makes it really awkward to make a video
and put it on the internet.
But I'll do it anyways.
Shall we break the titanium?
This titanium ring is from our friend Martin
at Titan Climbing.
That's at 6.5.
That's at 10.
I'm gonna move now.
You think it's strong enough, Bobby, to use?
Yes.
So Martin says that at 60% wear,
it meets the 25 kilonewton standard.
It's shocking just how much heat is generated
from, I don't know, putting on 20,000 pounds of force.
And like all the ratings and markings
here on Martin's titanium ring,
I got titanium from the Krabi Bolting Fund in Thailand.
And there are no markings on these,
but they are trying to be good stewards of the money.
They do have because they are trying to put
titanium bolts and replace bolts in that area.
And they need titanium.
And we're gonna find out if these are super good enough
or if they need to go replace all these now.
You'll notice here that it broke right
where you put the Sharpie.
I think that really compromised the strength.
Does Sharpie weaken titanium?
Find out.
Ouch, shit.
God damn, that's hot.
So that, by the way, is 10, just for reference.
What is that, an 80 to one safety ratio?
That's 10 kilonewtons.
You'll be happy to know that the Sharpie
didn't compromise the sample.
I moved it so it wouldn't break there.
There you go.
I'm not gonna touch that for ya.
So this steel ring, it's stainless,
I believe 304, is from Fix Climbing.
It is bar stock, 10 millimeter, I believe,
and it is TIG welded.
What's it rated for?
35 kilonewtons.
32 kilonewtons is what it started with.
Touch it right there.
Not too bad.
No?
Oh yeah, it's not nearly as hot as that titanium.
Had to angle grind the dings off of this so it'd spin.
32, it does that.
Oh, I broke the weld!
Super interesting, they both broke in the weld,
though this one failed at over twice the strength
that this one failed at.
So very different weld quality.
Oh no, I think we might have been pulling
on the weld with that one.
Yeah, we were.
But this one we were pulling against.
Yeah.
Yeah, so maybe it's just how we pulled it.
I don't think so.
I think just the weld wasn't as good on this one.
But this is still 10 kilonewtons
above what they rated it for.
But we have a PLX we can try now.
Can I just make a note here
that this five millimeter soft shackle
is what's holding these tests?
That's just a fun fact.
It's funny people think we're watching this as it happens.
We are around the corner, guys.
You have already seen the results before we have.
Broken the weld!
Oh wow!
Oh, look at that, it's a belly button.
The next ring's a forged steel, there's no welds on it.
I think it's because it was holding it at the, wait.
Damn it!
It broke my last purple spin set!
It was doubled up?
I've always wanted to break one of these.
And I've never been brave enough.
This one definitely wins.
We might have to angle grind that off.
Oh, that's not good.
I mean, it's not that big of a bend radius,
but it wasn't on threads.
Bonus test!
We didn't even know it was gonna be in this video.
Okay.
Maybe we should just put that on the museum just like it is.
It got up to 94 and held it there.
Yeah.
So, it definitely wins.
It's all stretched out, but I'm not,
I mean, it's still got a lot to go
because there's no tearing starting.
I'm thinking maybe 110, 120 on that one.
Yeah.
Are you top roping with these?
This is overkill.
Now that we're done breaking the strongest ring we have,
let's break the weakest one we have.
I didn't know rolled aluminum rings could look like this.
Oh my God.
I'm glad I turned on the load cell.
That legitimately could kill someone.
I mean, if you simul-rappelled on that,
you'd easily generate that force just sitting on it,
let alone bouncing or moving from side to side.
Yeah.
Terrifying.
What a difference between these two rings.
With these rolled aluminum rings,
it does not take that long for this to happen.
Yeah, yeah.
It would take a lot, a lot of wrapping
for that to happen on the-
On the steel.
Yeah.
For it to show anywhere.
So the milled aluminum rings didn't stretch at all.
So the milled aluminum didn't stretch at all.
The steel and titanium stretched a lot.
The rolled aluminum stretched.
And the titanium sparks a lot.
And span sets aren't as bummer as I thought.
And I don't think you should just grab your favorite ring
from this video and stick it on any anchor.
For example, if you're in Krabi, Thailand
and there's a titanium anchor,
probably a reason,
you should probably put a titanium ring on there.
Titanium is there because of the corrosion
that happens between the type of rock
and the ocean environment that it's in.
And this is a titanium bolt from Martin.
But if corrosion is not a huge concern,
steel does wear better,
as you can see in the bolting Bible.
My opinion is use stainless when you can.
There are instances where you have wear parts
that will wear very fast, say mussy hooks,
that if you have a quick link
and it's easy to remove and replace,
I think it's okay to use non-stainless.
In this case, this wore out much faster
than it was able to corrode.
This was desert environment, but still no corrosion.
It doesn't wear out fast.
It wears out faster than it corrodes.
The whole reason of having a mussy hook
or an open rope system where you can just clip your rope in,
you don't have to untie and thread your rope
through like a fixed ring at the anchor.
This is really nice.
It's a popular route, right?
Yeah, this probably saw hundreds,
if not thousands of top ropes in a sense on that.
So if these are being used,
they're gonna be used on popular routes
and therefore they're going to wear out before they rust.
But then like you see chains all the time and they rust.
This is one that we pulled off of Sugarloaf
here in Northern California.
This rusted and it was staining where it was.
Not only was it like leaving a brown rust stain,
as the coating leached off the zinc,
it was killing everything on the rock
that was there, all the lichen and living stuff.
If people are gonna trust their life to it,
it's nice not to be connecting your rope
to something that looks rusty.
And it's nice not to have, I don't know,
brown stains anywhere.
It's ugly and it's more impact than we need to make for,
I mean, it's not that much.
How strong is it you ask?
Well, we're about to find out after we turn off this video
and start the next episode.
So you'll have to subscribe for that.
Now, if you're going to be top roping 90 students
at a time in a class,
make sure you have a 90 kilonewton repel ring.
Otherwise, don't worry about it.
It's super good enough and just click this.
And that's the test of the week.
So with this third ring, we'll do an interesting test
I've been wanting to know.
This is a web lock.
You can put your webbing in one way
and you can pull it this way and it'll lock it in place.
But if you use a ring, it's called a line lock
and it just holds it in place
if you're not tensioning on that side, for example,
you don't have sewn loop
and you don't want to have a second web lock.
But I've always used the big stainless steel rings
because, well, old aluminum doesn't seem that strong.
Bite of webbing and you put in the ring once
and then you do it again in that circle.
And then in that hole right there,
you can place your pin
and place the pin into the hole that that creates.
And it's locked in place.
It's called a line lock for a reason.
And now that is locked.
I'll tension up my web lock.
And now that is something we're going to test.
And we're going to see, if we set this in correctly,
if that ring is going to bend first
or if the webbing will break first.
And on REI's website,
somebody asked if you can use it for this purpose
and SMC themselves said you can.
We're going to find out if that's true.
That's awfully diplomatic there, Ryan.
Is that off-brand?
It is a little off-brand.
If you're going to have high tensions in a park,
which you have to, to have the slack line
not touch the ground in the middle.
And we're talking about a slack line
longer than 20 feet long.
That is like, you're never going to pull a three to one
or whatever, so tight you're going to hurt anything.
But when you get into long lines,
if you have aluminum in the system
and you have carabiners,
aluminum carabiners in the system,
and they have that cyclic loading from the wind
from going voo, voo, voo, voo, voo.
And that is what will break aluminum.
And I'm the super good enough guy.
And that's sketchy.
Long lining is dangerous if your gear fails
because the gear at the tree will literally,
when the webbing snaps, hit the other tree.
And if you're in the middle of it, it's happened.
My feelings have been validated.
Hold on, let me see the force.
Okay, 12 kilonewtons is pretty high,
but like it starts to deform around a four
so you can technically achieve if you're long lining.
If you're going to do slack lining ever, use steel.
Use these to connect your web lock
and use steel rings if you're going to use a line lock.
And if you do use a steel line lock,
it is going to reduce your webbing
more than if you have it in a web lock
because the bend radius.
But this is a rappel ring video
and I shouldn't get on that bandwagon.
Plus soft shackles are better in every way.
No, you can't do a line lock with soft shackles.