Meredith J. Gill, professor of Italian Renaissance art and chair, department of art history and archaeology, University of Maryland, College Park. To think about angels among the world’s religions is to think about the question of embodiment. As messenger figures, they choose human form, yet they are incorporeal and without gender in their theological essence. Angels have long invited highly abstract and intricate categories of classification, particularly within the medieval university curriculum for which Bonaventure, the “Seraphic Doctor,” and Thomas Aquinas, the “Angelic Doctor,” wrote foundational texts. Yet angels have also invited the most sublime feats of artistic imagination. In this lecture recorded on April 28, 2017, at the National Gallery of Art, Meredith Gill discusses several angelic episodes in Renaissance art, such as Tobias and the Angel and the Fall of the Rebel Angels, reflecting on mortal identity and experience in early modern times.
In Sandro Botticelli's late painting of the Annunciation,
the Archangel Gabriel is a stunning brown-haired youth,
intent on his task of greeting the Virgin.
His genuflecting form communicates respect,
but also empathy in her understandable agitation.
These emotions are expressed in the dance of their hands at the center of
the composition, hands that express feeling, but also in
that space between them, their difference as beings,
angelic and mortal. Why angels? Why pursue
the most insubstantial, some might say most saccharine, peripheral and yet
commonplace of beings? We could perhaps answer this question
one way and by clumsy analogy. Just as today we take as truth that all
matter comprises invisible subatomic and atomic particles,
so too in earlier times angels were and still are for persons of faith
an inarguable article of belief and essential to the fabric of human
experience. Angels, the spirit world, have long had
their place in many world religions. Were we
transported to the esteemed University of Paris in the Middle Ages,
we might well find ourselves in a lecture hall reviewing
our required angelology homework. Saint Bonaventure, the so-called Seraphic
Doctor, and Thomas Aquinas, the Angelic Doctor,
and their teachings on the angels, troubling over such questions as the
individuality of an angel or whether they needed to speak to one
another to be understood. Is an angel simply the
condensation of air as Aquinas had in one place proposed?
In the late antique era, Saint Augustine, the leading theologian of the West,
made a telling observation. Angel, he said,
is the name of their office, not of their nature.
If you seek the name of their nature, it is spirit.
If you seek the name of their office, it is angel.
From what they are, spirit. From what they do, angel.
What does this mean? Angels are known by their actions,
for what they do, including choosing to look like angels.
Our senses tell us of their presence, observed,
heard, tasted, touched, and inhaled, but yet a presence that has to be
ineffable and fleeting. Angels are pure act,
as Dante said, meaning movement and transformation.
Their name means simply messenger. For medieval visionaries, angels might be
present simply as a sensory abundance, constituting cosmologies of color, light,
sound, and fragrance, synonymous with the angel's bodiless
essence. Each ordinary day at noon, in invoking the Ave Maria,
Gabriel's words at the Annunciation, the speaker briefly inhabited Gabriel's
role. For the artist, and also for the art
historian, the task of representation is a fantastic one.
A negotiation between visual conventions, such as wings and color,
and freewheeling imagination. Persons of Christian faith understood,
as they understand, that they are subjects of the Virgin
in the special company of her angels. Medieval and Renaissance Marian subjects
team with flights of angels, especially, but not only, in assumptions and
coronations. The 15th century artist Masolino painted
an unusually specific garland of angels around the Virgin at her Assumption, in
an altarpiece for a member of the papal court in Rome.
The artist generally follows the classification of the nine orders of
angels, according to the so-called pseudo
Dionysius, of the late 5th, early 6th century CE.
Immediately around the holy figures of the Virgin and Christ
are the highest orders. These appear to us now
rather as golden figures. The highest orders, the Seraphim of Divine
Love, and the Cherubim of Divine Wisdom.
Then in blue, in the outer circle, hierarchically,
from top to bottom, so beginning just under Christ,
there follow the thrones, who hold mandolas,
or little solid halos. The dominations, or dominions, in red,
carrying orbs and scepters. Third, the principalities,
protectors of religion and arbiters of the fate of nations,
carrying banners with the cross of Saint George.
Fourth, the powers follow in full armour,
with swords and shields. Fifth, are the virtues,
who work earthly miracles, and they hold scrolls, and I hope you can see those
details here. Finally, as messengers of God to
humankind, those who sometimes even appear to
human persons, we have the angels. This order, known
simply as angels, and they play musical
instruments. Missing are the archangels, who are one
rung higher than the angels, and I think the
reason for this is that in the apse of Santa Maria Maggiore,
where this altarpiece was located, the archangels appeared around and in
the context of the Annunciation, so Mazzolino perhaps didn't feel the
need to represent them here. Here, in the National Gallery,
Filippino Lippi's Coronation of the Virgin, from a bit later,
shows us only two orders. The second highest,
the cherubim, typically in blue, as heads and wings,
beneath bands of red cloth held up by full-bodied angels.
At first glance, the red cloth suggests the very highest order, the seraphim,
hinting, I think perhaps, that Filippino is playing with his viewers'
expectations, as he can often do. Like composers of music, artists push
themselves to the limits in describing the miracles of the Virgin's life.
Francesco Botticini, in his grandiose, and I mean
very large, vision of the Assumption taking place over a Tuscan landscape
in the National Gallery London, arranges his hovering rings of angels into groups
of three, again alluding to the tradition of the
nine orders. And speaking of music, we note here King
David, with his harp at the centre, on axis
with the Virgin, at the rim of the middle tier of heaven.
If, as medieval philosophers proposed, music conveyed divine knowledge,
then David was its royal conduit. The sound of his Psalm 19
was the sound of the harmony of the spheres, in concert with the angels.
Well, today I thought to focus on three themes by way of thinking about the
curiosities of angels in medieval and early modern times.
First, the musical angel. Music and dance have always been angels'
special provinces. We see a proliferation of angelic choirs,
dancers, orchestras, and little ensembles.
Looked at one way, angels and music lend one another an aspect of respectability.
As the humanist Egidius Calavarius observed in about 1470,
when he noted that God made everything of a certain number,
and that angels comprise a threefold hierarchy and nine orders.
Music is therefore generally accepted by virtue of number.
It is found everywhere. In this light, we remember that music
belonged to the quadrivium of the liberal arts as an abstract language
governed by universal principles, number, order, rhythm, and proportion.
Universal numerical principles are often close by where the angels are concerned.
When Cosmetura's lutenist angel at the right tunes his instrument at the
virgin's right in the Roverella polyptych as his fellow fiddlers and an organist
play in the foreground, we're reminded of the harmony of the spheres to which
the angel conforms, equal as he is to the perfection of the virgin,
to whom they all pay tribute. That the angel makes music an unseen art
reinforces the ineffability of the angel's nature.
Artists, though, represented him playing all manner of real and fictive instruments.
We have to remember that instrumental music was quite late in making its way
into the church's liturgy, where the word as song alone had prevailed.
The music-making angel seems to be, then, a way to unite ideas about the heavenly
harmonies and the heavenly spheres with secular instrumental innovations that
gradually influence church music as well as sacred drama.
Sometimes I also think that artists resolved official suspicion about the
decorousness of instrumental music within the sanctuary with humour.
The comedy can sometimes get a bit out of hand.
In the 1530s, in the cupola of the Sanctuary of the Virgin in Saronno,
Gaudenzio Ferrari, a musician himself, painted a jostling throng of music-making
angels at the Assumption. The Virgin, as a wooden sculpture, standing at the edge
of the cupola, appears somewhat displaced by angels, who should really be the
lesser players at this event.
Some among the instruments are more imaginary, even bawdy, than real.
But the real-life instruments include a zither, flutes, tambourines, a lyre,
lutes, and an organ with bellows.
Here we see double recorders and a lute, or theobo, it's a bit hard to see in its
full form, as well as a fictive kind of horn.
The organ, which Gaudenzio paints further to the left of this group, and which we
also saw in Cosmetura, was in fact the first instrument to be permitted within
the medieval church interior.
Perhaps fortuitously out of God the Father's direct line of sight is one of
the more famously humorous motifs.
A bagpipe player whose rustic instrument was a referent as well in general for
lower desires.
The artist's riotous orchestra, in which the angels seem to be competitively
attending to one another's melodies, as well as singing, praying, and dancing,
connects to the long tradition of musical angels going back to Psalm 150, in which
trumpets, psaltery, harp, timbrel, stringed instruments, organs, and cymbals are
listed along with dance.
And here at the right, we see the organ and the cello-like viola da gamba, or
perhaps its precursor, the viola, the most important instrument in Western
music, also a viola da braccio beside the organ.
Percussion instruments, however, were especially profane, and there's a
tambourine just, maybe you can see it, just up here on that side.
Percussion instruments were especially profane, quite apart from the general
inter-chorusness of instruments in the church.
Here, the tambourine above the organ joins other real and imaginary instruments
to claim for the angels a reality beyond liturgical strictures and beyond
performance practices.
Looked at in one way, Gaudenzio's imaginary instruments resolve contemporary
ambivalence about the presence of both instrumental music and music-making
angels in the church.
They are a knowing nod to the dazzling fiction of his painted creation.
In 1470, the great musical scholar, Johannes Pinctoris, voiced with grudging
resignation something of the nature of the music-making angels' decorum, noting
that painters, when wishing to depict the joys of the blessed, paint angels
playing various musical instruments.
The church would not allow this unless it believed that the joys of the
blessed are enhanced by music.
You can hear his reluctance in the way he's put that.
The joys of the blessed are also simply expressed in the sister art of dance,
as Psalm 150 notes.
Dance as a figural expression also centering on number and comprising a
commonplace metaphor for the hierarchical relations between the creator and his
dominion.
The winsome dancing boys of Luca della Rovia's Florentine canteria, or choir
gallery for the cathedral, literally illustrate the words of Psalm 150, which
are inscribed on the structure's horizontal friezes.
And I'm thinking of this panel here in particular.
The boys keep company with infants and young girls, other children of varying
ages who also sing and play instruments.
Their circling dance in the lower relief at left reminds the beholder of the
round or chain dance as a supreme symbol of cosmic order.
Though they may not obviously belong among the angels, these wingless
youngsters surely evoke the heavenly hosts, looking up, as some do, towards
the mortal choristers in the canteria above them.
In fact, these wingless children, in their diverse and unabashedly earthly
pursuits, make angels out of the living, singing boys above.
So from here, it's a natural step to perceive in dancing angels an affirmative
rehearsal of the pristine mechanics of the cosmos.
Angels remind their beholders of how, in the worldly arts of music and dance, the
practitioner might also approach participation in that same cosmic machinery.
In 1489-91, Filippino Lippi portrayed six musician angels dancing and playing
among the clouds beside Mary at her resumption in Rome's Santa Maria Sopra
Minerva.
He drew together, with economy and sophistication, the theology of the
incarnation, shown in the Annunciation directly below, with the triumphant
symbolism of the Virgin's ascent to heaven.
Winds, strings, and percussion sound together as three angel companions push
up from the ledge of the painted frame, carrying the angel cloud that forms the
Virgin's platform.
As in medieval angelology, nine angels circle the Virgin.
As the funerary chapel of a Dominican cardinal, Oliviero Carafa, Lippi
necessarily emphasizes the order's veneration of Aquinas, the angelic doctor
himself, who appears beside Carafa in the Annunciation, and you can see them
together at the right of the Virgin.
The didacticism of the chapel's iconography is brightened, though, by the
range of angelic types, stagehands as well as musicians, decorative
architectural ornament in grey and white, and sympathetic companions even to
the antique sybils in the vault.
That takes some thinking about.
In this, Lippi is responding directly to Aquinas's famous summa.
Angels for Aquinas were a measure of the gift of prophecy, which they passed
on to humankind.
But it is the angels in the Assumption revolving around the Virgin, peeking
from underneath her garment, extending incense burners and long tapers, in
whose smoke small angel heads are formed.
It's these angels who are the true inventions of the cycle.
The angel musicians are dynamic in their movements, and they call into question
Aquinas's critique of instruments, particularly the flute and harp, which
in his view quartered the wrong emotions.
Lippi earns respect among music historians for his accuracy, including his
trombone, glimpsed at the very far left.
You can't see the full angel, but also perhaps the result of his collaboration
and association with musicians and composers.
Less accurate, though, are Lippi's musicians as a viable ensemble.
He includes an angel below left, doing two things at once, beating a
three-stringed tambourine with a stick, while also blowing on a long flute.
A bagpipe player at the upper right sounds an earthy note.
His pipes are bedecked in carafe's red and white colors, taking the lead
perhaps among the group, whose draperies, tassels and ribbons unfurl in a
dance of their own.
The troupe brings with it more an air of the festival or street pageant.
Lippi was experienced and gifted in these arenas as well.
The Virgin is hoisted on her cloud, the angels again, as I've said, working
really as stagehands in this marvel.
All right, my second subject.
In taking up the popular theme of Archangel Raphael and Tobias, Italian
artists in their workshops responded to a range of patrons of both modest
and ample means.
This is Filippino's panel here, here at the gallery, of about 1475.
Most artists focused on the pair of Tobias and Raphael, and they generally
represented the couple with the medicinal fish of the story swinging
from Tobias's hand and the family dog beside them.
Archangel Raphael is one of the most sociable angels.
A principal angel in Judaism and Christianity, his name derives from the
Hebrew, Rapha, to heal.
His story, told in the Book of Tobit, like other apocryphal books, I'm
thinking, for example, of Judith and Maccabees, was included in the Latin
Vulgate Bible.
Renaissance readers would also have been familiar with the golden legend.
For them, Raphael and Tobias were as authentic as all other holy persons.
Raphael is a healer and exorcist who rewards piety while serving as a
prescient teacher and guide.
But his identity as an angel is unknown to his human companions until the
very end.
Within the mercantile culture of later medieval and early modern Italy,
Raphael was a uniquely accessible paradigm, for he was not only a divine
intercessor, an advocate for the soul's afterlife, he was also a just minister
on earth who rewarded loyalty within the family.
Raphael and Tobias's story has all the ingredients of epic adventure.
Actually, I think a movie, really.
Tested familial bonds, a journey, exorcism, romance, a fishing trip, a
miraculous cure, and a dog.
The only friendly dog in the Bible, according to some.
Luther drew daring analogies between the Book of Tobit and Greek comedy.
In his preface to the book, he noted that the work should be viewed as a
very beautiful, wholesome, and useful fiction or drama.
But there were also material, we might say bourgeois considerations at stake
as well.
One of Raphael's lessons is that almsgiving ensures special freedom from
death.
Raphael articulates this ideal at the moment right at the end before he
reveals his true nature as angel.
For confraternities in the early modern era, Raphael was the ideal protector.
And in Venice, where church dedications can be unusual, the archangel has not
only his own squalor, the squalor dell'angelo custode, but also his own
church.
The visual record is as long-lived as the written one, going back to Rome's
catacombs, where in a fresco Raphael instructs Tobias to gut his fish.
Visual interpretations reconcile Tobias's story to the miracles of Christ.
Raphael's command to Tobias on the shores of the Tigris showed him capable
of transforming fish into salvific forms.
For civic-minded Tuscans, the conjunction of familial loyalty with public
benefaction was especially meaningful.
Raphael and Tobias are, by association, custodians and protectors not only of
the body and soul, but also of tangible earthly practices and goods.
Bookkeeping, just compensation, gift-giving, magnanimous hospitality, and
above all, material riches.
For the security of Florentine sons traveling abroad, their fathers frequently
sponsored small images of this pair as votives to ensure their safekeeping.
From the mid-15th century onward, Tobias and Raphael appeared together either
as an autonomous subject or in altarpieces among the saints beside the
Virgin's throne.
In a few instances, Raphael also appears without Tobias, but with his
colleagues, Gabriel and Michael.
This iconography can be linked to the Florentine Compagnie dell'Arcangelo
Raffaello, a youth confraternity founded in 1411 and possessing a chapel in the
Augustinian church of Santo Spirito.
Botticini included Gabriel and Michael together with Raphael and his charge
here in his painting for the confraternity's chapel.
He was also a member of the brotherhood.
Wearing a belted chiton and sandals, Raphael appears here in his recognizable
archaizing angel costume, while Tobias is outfitted as the son of a well-to-do
Florentine.
The elegance of costume and dancing line amongst Botticini's figures bear
comparison with the young Leonardo and Verrocchio's Tobias and the Angel.
Verrocchio and his young apprentice, Leonardo, probed the possibilities for a
somewhat more psychologically complex portrait.
The interplay among visible and invisible, human and divine that is
inherent in the text, as well as in Raphael's nature as an angel, is less
obviously clear in these paintings.
Although Tobias's family are fully persuaded of Raphael's humanity, we as
viewers see his wings.
The sight of his wings, though, underscores the angel's assignment to take on
human guise, and they also symbolize his protection.
In a practical light, his wings serve, together with his larger size, to
distinguish Raphael from Tobias, who in the book is actually a mature and
marriageable youth rather than a boy.
The fish is also a visual conundrum as well, since it is referred to in the
texts as a large, even monstrous beast who presented a danger to Tobias.
Furthermore, by the time the pair had left the banks of the Tigris, the
creature had been dismembered.
These elements, the wings and the fish, constitute comic synecdoches for the
story, for they are knowing winks to us, the observer, of its deeper meanings.
Raphael's errand depends on visual deception, just as it also depends on the
several meanings attaching to sight and to blindness, both with respect to
bodily sense and as a metaphor for illumination.
After all, it's the fish that cures Tobias's father, Tobit, of his blindness
at the end.
In later Renaissance renditions, Raphael's likeness to human persons
becomes greater, and the natural setting expands.
In his lyrical oil painting, Giovanni Savoldo depicts the couple pausing in
the landscape as if in Virgilian reverie, the fish's open mouth and sleeping
dog bracketing them.
Raphael, with his capacious wings, instructs Tobias as to what he must do.
The pair partakes of the same rules of nature, including proportion, for each
is a handsome, possibly identifiable youth, and they wear the same contrasting
white and rose-orange garments.
In Renaissance betrayals of them, Tobias seems often, in fact, to bear the
likeness of a son, the young member of the patron's household, in whose honour
and for whose protection the works were often commissioned.
Well, the motif of the older youth joined by hand to his young charge, giving
educative counsel and moral guidance, lends itself to Renaissance as well as
classical ideals of friendship and love, especially male love.
One arena in which the spiritual, pedagogical, and social identities of
Florentine men came together was in the confraternity, particularly the youth
confraternity.
The Compagnia dell'Arcangelo Raffaello was Florence's first confraternity.
I think that's a big point.
And as an extension of its religious and social mission, the society played a
leading role in the theatrical and musical life of the city, after its
beginnings as a Laudesi, or singing company, dedicated to the protection and
education of boys from the ages of 12 to 20.
This fact alone is important, since Florentine children and youths under 24
comprised just over 50% of Florence's population, as revealed by the tax census
of 1427 to 1430.
In Luca della Robbia's marble choir loft, we may see in actuality portraits of
boys from Arcangelo Raffaello.
This would explain the older ages of some of the young persons in the reliefs,
and it explains their more informal arrangement, for they're not arranged as
a formal choir.
The enchantment of Tobias's story, its extended journey and its abundant
detail, seems to have inspired artists on both sides of the Alps to treat the
landscape increasingly as a subject in its own right.
Into the 17th century, the pair appears often only as a minor motif in landscape
paintings, as if one fissure in nature's order of things, namely Raffaello's
incarnation as a young man, motivated artists to reflect on the empirical
measures of the observed world in general.
Northern artists led the way, perhaps inspired in part by the proliferation of
prints drawn from the Book of Tobit that issued from presses in the Low
Countries after the mid-16th century.
All of this is perhaps another story, but I can't resist including just one.
Lambert's Sustres' Tobias and the Angel on their travels from the 1560s.
This is in Vienna.
Behind his pair lies a swiftly running river, a far view of an isolated
settlement and small figures.
While he may have seen his northern colleagues' renditions of Tobias' themes,
Sustres gave great lyrical expression here to the natural setting, which evokes
the glistening vistas of the Veneto where he had studied.
For patrons whose livelihoods depended on trade and travel, the central image of
the guardian angel, his bird wings protectively overshadowing the small boy,
must have held a particularly effective, even talismanic power.
When the young artist Raphael of Urbino arrived in Florence in 1505, he could not
have failed to notice the boisterous presence of the youth brotherhoods, but
especially that of Arcangelo Raffaello, the old confraternity dedicated to his
name saint.
In about 1512 to 1514, Raphael completed his own panel, the so-called Madonna
with the Fish, in which Archangel Raphael gently leads Tobias toward the
Virgin and Child, opposite Saint Jerome.
The reciprocated glances of the Christ child and the boy, who shyly genuflects,
as well as the yearning profile of the older angel, perhaps a poetically
conceived likeness of the artist himself, evoke a mutual affection and a
circle of understanding that we witness from the outside as a privileged
exchange.
Tobias's gesture, as his hand is gently led by Raphael's toward the Virgin, is
one of tentative probing, as if to test by touch the material existence of the
holy figures.
This is a delicious visual pun on the part of the artist, and there are lots in
Raphael.
In the course of his short career, Raphael was keenly aware of the many
meanings of the senses, especially of sight, and sight also as a metaphor for
discovery and enlightenment, and of the many meanings of angels.
These themes of sight and insight, of vision in the most inclusive sense,
coincide in the figure of the angel, who may be present yet invisible, light
filled yet without body, divine intermediary and earthly trickster.
So now my third example.
Like Tobias and the angel, the fall of the rebel angels is an unorthodox
subject from the point of view of Christian doctrine.
Aquinas had laid out the theological premise of the fall along interesting
lines.
Angels, he says, may assume bodies, but they do not have functions of life in
the bodies so assumed.
With respect to gender, Aquinas reflected, angels are of no sex so long as
they remain in heaven.
In the early decades of the 16th century, Domenico Beccafumi painted an
enormous, and I mean over 11 feet high, panel for the Carmelite friars of the
Sienese convent of San Nicolo al Carmine.
It was to be of Saint Michael subduing Lucifer, according to the opinionated
Giorgio Vasari several decades later.
Beccafumi's first attempt here registers to us at first, I think, as confusing.
Three lean nude figures dominate the lower register, while other more
abbreviated bodies lurk in the shadows below beside an impenetrable tangle of
animal forms.
In the upper part of the panel, Saint Michael is dominant, raising his sword
over the vanquished rebels.
Dressed in a fantasy of antique armor, Michael looks upward to a small, cloudy
vision of God, represented in very clever foreshortening.
Beccafumi offers us meditations on a sensational theme.
He does this by way of the angels, testing ideas of embodiment, sensory
apprehension, materiality, and transformation.
When his angels fall to earth, they become codes for an anxious humanity,
and these by way of the very stuff of his materials, his paint, the details of
the standing angels below.
In applying his brush, the artist confronted the corporality of angels.
With their fall, angels attained not only human-like bodies, and these by reason
of their flawed choice, but also those bodies' capacities for metamorphosis,
disequilibrium, sensory degradation, and pain.
They materialized to experience all the multi-sensory violence of nature.
This included changing into hybrid forms, experiencing excruciating physical
travail, and entertaining immoral ideas.
Beccafumi seized on the very question of angels' carnate or incarnate selves in
relation to human frailty and error.
Two more details.
Our viewpoint is at eye level.
We are in the company of these damned forms, literally forced up to their chests
and flailing arms.
Well, the Carmelite friars rejected this panel, partly, I think, because of its
lack of clear hierarchy, but also, I think, in relation to the transgressive
nature of this subject.
First, from the point of view of doctrine and the fall's various ancient
traditions, but also, second, with respect to the subject's intervention in the
otherwise discreet realms of angelic and human substance.
The fall has its fullest exposition in the teachings of Jewish apocryphal and
apocalyptic literature, and in these teachings, both angelology and
demonology are inextricably bound.
First, the rebel angel's actions have always been bound up with the idea of
will, beginning with the Jewish book of Enoch of the third century BCE.
Here, and in the later Hebrew Bible, we read of the contrast between the sons
of God, or angels, and the daughters of men, of the Nephilim, possibly
supernatural beings or their descendants who coupled with mortal women.
From this astonishing intermingling, a race of giants was born, and, too,
violence and anarchy erupted.
God dispatched his archangels, Michael, Uriel, Raphael, and Gabriel, to
punish and bind their fallen brethren.
In their earthly prison, the fallen angels would abide for 70 generations,
waiting until judgment, after which they would be hurled into an abyss of fire
to remain there forever.
In Bekefumi's second version, and here they are side by side, the second one
on the right, a different order prevails.
A full, red-mantled figure of God affects his judgment with a confident arm.
He's flanked by angels who are arrayed more stably above caverns and
sulfurous fires at ground level.
We sense here sharper, more tactile edges of forms and clearer recession,
as well as a pronounced colorism, from red in God to gilded yellow in Michael,
slashes of blue and pale pink.
Lucifer below is all gaping mouth and open claw, unmistakable and monstrous
abbreviations for the torments of hell.
I see Bekefumi wrestling mightily here with bodies and angels,
endeavoring to resolve a problem of identity, moral as well as physical.
Vasari tells us that Bekefumi abandoned the first panel because the figures of
Lucifer and his followers, I quote here, were rather confused owing to the
labor he bestowed on them.
That is, as most interpreters have introduced, that despite being a man of
ideas, as Vasari calls Bekefumi, he did not succeed in this first new
treatment of the subject to prove his ability, according to Vasari, to
exhibit his aesthetic prowess.
Directed by his patrons, if we believe Vasari, to the passage from biblical
revelation in which a vision of an angel overthrows Satan as a dragon and
imprisons him in a bottomless pit, the artist failed in his first attempt to
adequately and decorously adhere to the text in the confusion of his design and
possibly also in the excess of nudity among his figures.
Bekefumi partially covered every angel in his second panel and more clearly
demarcated the composition's architecture, notably the boundaries of
heaven and hell.
He radically revised and synchronized the positions and actions of God and his
agent, Michael, so that where before there were vacuums below a wispy God, now
a robust full figure of God dominates the upper third of the panel.
In this, the artist called upon some of his most adept technical abilities,
Vasari's style and grace, as he called them, including a kind of prismatic
lighting effect and otherworldly color.
Perhaps, as has been proposed, the friars needed not only a more legible
organization but also a God fully in control.
There was a Sienese tradition of rendering the fall of the rebel angels as
a vertical, hierarchically ordered composition, as in a small panel here on
the left from the 1340s by the master of the rebel angels in the Louvre.
Northern European artists, such as the Limbourg brothers on the right,
produced early depictions of the angels' vertiginous descent.
In an illumination from their tréricheur, God is seated outside the
manuscript page, surrounded by red seraphim and blue cherubim and flanked by
choir stalls that reveal the truancy of some of their occupants.
These rebel angels are tilting downwards, prodded by a small battalion of
archangels like coals in a fire as they cascade to earth.
When they hit the ground, beside Lucifer, their leader, they explode into
flames.
Hieronymus Bosch, who understood perhaps more than any other early modern
artist the moral resonance of sin, took the fall of the rebel angels still
further, for he adumbrated not only scripture, but also the weight of its
exegesis.
The Bible is, in the end, really quite laconic, not only about the creation of
angels, but also about their fall.
Here we're looking at the left shutter of Bosch's Last Judgment altarpiece,
representing the Garden of Eden.
When, according to Augustine, God created the heavens, he also created
spiritual beings, such that, let there be light, and there was light, of
Genesis, refers to the creation of angels simultaneously with the creation of
light.
It's a lovely, lovely topic for an artist in general.
It was at the moment of light's creation that the rebel angels chose to turn
away, to plummet then into the dark.
The angels' fall to earth then constituted a radical denial of their
ineffable, light-filled existence.
Well, Bosch understood the import of this light-dark opposition.
He also understood, as Augustine and others did, that the devil did not sin
when he was first made, but that it was pride that caused his sinning.
The devil foreknew before he fell that other angels would follow, and that
without the light of truth, I'm quoting Augustine here, they would abide in the
darkness of pride.
So Bosch shows the fall of the rebel angels above the Garden of Eden.
Thus, the degraded world of later generations is foretold, for one fall,
the angels, leads to another, that of humankind.
Above Eden, a black and white skirmish ensues with the lighter angels bearing
cross-shaped lances or staffs and swords as the rebels form black wings as if
before our eyes.
An angel on earth with a fiery sword lunges after the pair of Adam and Eve as
if to affirm the consequences of the tumbling disaster above.
So Beka Fumi's angels, languishing anxiously in hell, are unmistakably and
unsettlingly human.
All the more so for the fact that some, particularly in the middle regions of
the first panel, have bat wings and claws.
From our viewpoint, in front of the panels, we are in the company of these
damned forms, and like them, we must look up, up as a medieval chronicler
described the fallen angels' predicament, to see the glory they have lost.
Have we, though, fully answered the question as to why we have two panels?
That is, why the friars rejected the first one.
Siena's deeply unsettled political climate in the 1520s had its part to play.
At the same time, within the international context of debate about Catholic reform,
churchmen undertook to re-evaluate notions of hierarchy in all ways, and not least
the authenticity and authority of the saints relative to God and to the faithful.
These currents must have inflected the friar's unusual decision, if theirs it was,
to install the commanding form of God the Father in the second panel, where he
conventionally did not so conspicuously appear.
So the answer to the question of Bekefumi's rejected panel must also lie, I think,
with doctrinal propositions attending the character of the fall of the angels itself,
and its ancient and variant traditions in Judaism and Christianity.
The fall touches not only on a definition of evil, but also on the long shadow of dualism.
That is, within a Judeo-Christian context, on heretical themes pertaining to a
self-created evil principle in combat with a benevolent one.
In both cases, the rebel angels' actions have always been bound up with the idea of will,
beginning with the Book of Enoch.
Although we cannot link Bekefumi's paintings directly to Enoch, nevertheless,
the writer's reputation and traces of the context of his Book of the Watchers,
available to the Renaissance, offer tantalizing correspondence
with the ways in which the artist imagined his angels,
as well as with motifs in the lower regions of his terrestrial hell.
Among Italian intellectual circles, Enoch certainly had his admirers,
as too did the writings of the brilliant third-century Christian theologian, Origen.
Origen's perceived sedition lay in the radical idea of the intimate intermingling of substances,
human, soul, and angel.
For he taught that the soul pre-existed in angels before joining the human body,
and that the angels possessed autonomous wills
so that they, like human persons, could make moral choices.
This, too, had far-reaching and deeply unsettling implications.
The Church deemed Origen's teachings heretical in the 5th century,
and they were condemned as late as 1439 by the Council of Florence,
signaling at once, of course, their enduring vitality, as well as their controversy.
For in reality, Origen in his own day,
and also among Tuscan literary circles in the 15th century,
enjoyed something of an equivocal reputation,
including sympathetic readers and certain revival.
Origen's reception in late antiquity came to be mirrored in the 15th century
in that of none other than the Florentine humanist, Matteo Palmieri,
whose chapel Botticini's big assumption had adorned.
Palmieri's poem, the Città di Vita, which he modeled on Dante's Divine Comedy,
dwelt in part on the so-called neutral angels
and their journey from heaven to earth and back again.
Palmieri was more lenient than Dante,
who had discovered the neutral angels in the outermost circle of his hell,
at the gates reserved for cowards.
There, these shamefully undecided creatures mingled with humanity.
Palmieri followed Origen to such a degree
that his reputation was likewise forever tarnished
by posthumous accusations of heresy, rumors of book burning, and censorship,
a parallel to the burning of Origen's books in the Byzantine era.
Dante's neutral angels were lukewarm,
and as such, in John Fercero's words,
they are, for Dante, more contemptible than the worst of sinners.
For Dante, these were wretches who had never truly lived.
These miserable beings of the inferno,
who were stung to the point of bleeding by wasps and hornets,
never were alive, as Fercero puts it,
since they failed to make the commitment
which is the beginning of moral life.
I'm quoting Fercero here.
The single moment of angelic choice, as Fercero says,
as it related to the fall,
recapitulates the whole of man's moral existence.
And I end the quote there.
Thus, Fercero continues, angelology was the control laboratory,
as he puts it, for the analysis of human action.
When Vasari, with some ingenuousness,
speaks of the style and grace of the second panel,
the panel that made its way into the church,
he was likely responding not just to the clarity of the second design
and to the virtuosic language of its technique.
In both works, he would also have seen quotations
from the artist's 16th century peers,
quotations consciously drawn from scenes of righteous retribution.
I'm thinking of Raphael and Michelangelo.
These tributes Vasari likely appreciated,
along with the richer color scheme of the second panel,
I'm showing you the first here,
which draws attention more actively to the artifice
and imitation of the artist.
But the excessive labor of Becafumi
that led to the confusion in this, the first panel,
was also an indelible mark of the ambiguous status
of those fallen angels themselves.
Angels who bear the marks of mortal terror and bodily extremists.
In the first version, it is not clear who is descending
and who is ascending.
In fact, who is doing what?
An intriguing exchange in the lower center
indicates perhaps the artist's ambivalence
as to the identity of the angel Lucifer,
Lucifer himself,
and his uncertainty as to Lucifer's relation to Satan.
For by the medieval period, Lucifer was often considered
to have become Satan on impact with the earth.
So a standing male figure, older and clothed,
bends over an angel with dark wings
and attempts to lift him up.
The exchange here is tender as father to son
or as lover to lover.
Yet Satan as a monster is also here in the painting,
for above these two is a squirming hybrid octopus,
scorpion, bat creature,
as opposed to the more traditional winged dragon type
of the second panel.
The naked figures have not exploded into fire,
as in earlier falls,
so much as into materiality itself.
Though these figures seem to struggle
in their contortions against the limits
of their mortal being,
and though they look mournfully upward
from whence they came,
we're in no doubt of their suffering
or of their humanity.
To fall, after all, is to become
and to become sensate and vulnerable to feeling.
In this, the trauma of the angel's fall
leads not to an end,
but to a kind of beginning,
to an iconography of creation
in which our perception of bodily suffering
leads to a consideration
of the powers of the body itself.
What is a body?
And though the Carmelites would ultimately
install another panel in their Sienese church,
their own distinctive culture of contemplation
might perhaps have been better answered,
it's my opinion,
in this unfinished first fall
in which they would have been directed forever
to gaze upon the unresolved,
shivering boundaries of persons and angels,
of grace and choice,
flesh and not flesh.
Thank you.
I hasten to mention that
Meredith's book on angels is available
in the bookstore downstairs by the cafeteria,
and that Meredith will be glad to sign.
We have time, however,
for some questions before that,
if there are questions in the audience.
Yes?
I would just like to say
I believe in the angels,
and I would like to be on a retreat.
Thank you very much.
There's an opus on the work of the angels,
and they talk about the choir of angels,
but I learned more from this
than I ever did from one of them.
You made a distinction that I've never heard before
between Lucifer and Satan.
Can you elucidate that, please?
Well, it's partly one of the time period
in which we're talking about,
and it's partly one of language,
and it's partly one of interpretation.
Chaucer, for example,
understood, as many medieval persons did,
that Lucifer, before he fell,
was Lucifer, the angel of light,
but that upon falling to earth
with his fellow rebel angels,
he became Satan.
So he became the kind of leader
of the forces of evil spirits
on the earth and in the world,
so that for many persons
in the medieval period,
they were one and the same, essentially.
Lucifer became Satan.
But of course, the definitions of Satan,
of the devil,
these are vast and various,
and I'm only really touching the surface here
in trying to come to grips
with what happens
in this particular narrative episode.
But you seem to suggest at the end
that Satan is somebody different
from Lucifer in one interpretation.
Well, if, for example,
we accept in this early version
of Bekefumi's panels
that this figure bending over an angel,
this older, more commanding figure,
may be Lucifer himself,
then we have a problem
because there is a figure of Satan,
a hybrid, monstrous, demon-like form,
directly above these two,
quite separate from them.
On the other hand,
if we accept the argument
that on falling to Earth,
Lucifer becomes Satan,
then that's what we're seeing
above these two,
who remain simply angels, fallen angels.
Does that help at all?
Yes.
Thank you for your comment.
Thank you.
Other questions?
There's a young man in the back
who has a question.
Yes, I do.
Our mum would like to know
if you have women for real.
That's my brother, Matthew, from Australia,
who's just showed up.
An angelic visitation.
That's fantastic.
That's a surprise.
That's lovely.
Yes, angels are real.
You proved it.
That's fabulous.
Yes?
I was just wondering,
I was wondering if you
might suggest some works
at the National Gallery?
Yes, there are lots.
The Annunciations, of course,
Marcelino's Annunciation,
obviously the two that I showed,
Filippino Lippi,
and both the Tobias subject
and the Coronation of the Virgin subject.
But they're everywhere.
I mean, as I say,
as I sort of imply, I suppose,
the Gallery's paintings
are teeming with angels.
And once you start noticing them,
you can't stop.
But yes, the Annunciation
is a classic example,
but they're attendant
on all kinds of holy episodes
and not just those
concerning the life of the Virgin, right?
Can you think of a favorite of yours
that you like to bring people to?
I think the Jan van Eyck.
Yes?
The Jan van Eyck Annunciation.
And there are lots of angels.
I see Alison having gotten up.
There are lots of angels
in Alison's exhibition.
Yes.
Thank you again so much for coming.
Thank you.