SpaceX's Starship Human Landing System Moon Shot - You may be surprised what is possible!

Tech Level
93 followers
30 Video Views·Dec 8, 2022
This video is sponsored by Surfshark VPN. Hey hey Marcus House with you here. Today we'll have a
closer look at how NASA and SpaceX might fly to the moon. We already teased the scenarios in the
last video talking about SpaceX's human landing system and what mission options could be possible
but today we want to add some numbers to this. True that there are lots of official numbers
missing but we've now found some clues on how it might go. We're curious about your scenario
ideas too so feel free to share them in the comments. So before we get to landing people
with Starship on the moon I just wanted to give you a short introduction to the core physics that
we need to handle the scenarios that we're drafting. One of the most valuable resources
when flying in space of course is propellant and I say propellant not fuel because mostly
the propellant comes as a fuel and an oxidizer together. Here oxygen is usually the heaviest part
of the mix. The extremes that we see right here is with hydrogen and oxygen but already when
burning kerosene you need quite a bit more oxygen compared to say jet engines. Rocket engines are
extremely inefficient in their ability to transform propellant into velocity but to be fair aircraft
have two major advantages. The aircraft doesn't have to bring oxidizer along to burn the propellant
it can just use the surrounding air and it uses that air as well as reaction mass. That's the
mass needed to push out the back to accelerate away. So unlike flying through earth's atmosphere
where this is all around us flying through space requires that we bring our own oxidizer which is
very expensive. While that missing air as reaction mass in space has the disadvantages that we've just
mentioned there is one good thing though. There is little to no air resistance slowing us down in
space so once we've reached the required velocity we're able to just coast to our destination.
That being said there are times when we need to change our velocity. For example when launching
we've got to accelerate from a standstill on the earth right up to orbital velocity which is up
around eight kilometers per second and we need to do all of that in just minutes. Here is the thing
though once the engines shut off in that near complete vacuum there is very little slowing us
down. We are moving so fast that as we fall we are actually falling around the earth. Even though
there are no engines firing there is no thrust needed to continue hurtling around the world at
over 27 500 kilometers per hour. Now in space if we want to change our orbit or escape earth's gravity
we need to change velocity again. Applying thrust to further increase our speed in this same
direction actually makes the opposite side of our orbit stretch right out making it more elliptical.
Once the required velocity is reached the engines shut off once more so unlike traveling in a car or
an aircraft a rocket fires its engines for a short period of time and then it simply coasts the rest
of the way in a vacuum. There are of course low thrust options with very long duration burns that
don't necessarily follow this rule exactly but this is a story for another video. So anyway a
critical measure of a rocket is the amount of potential velocity change that it has available
with its propellant load and engine capability. The mathematical term for this is called delta v.
A rocket engine burns propellant very energetically and spits it super fast out the
back of the rocket. Using a delta v calculator we can determine quite easily how much propellant
that we need to bring along. But we need to know something else very important as well the engine
efficiency. This measure is called specific impulse or ISP. When the propellant is burned in the
combustion chamber of the engine the dense propellant expands into hot gas. This accelerates
the gas and particles to some stunning speeds and we are talking kilometers per second. When directing
those high velocity particles with the help of a rocket nozzle it propels itself and anything
attached to it so the rocket away in the opposite direction. This is the same idea as shown right
here. For every reaction there's an equal and opposite reaction and that is where our change
in velocity actually comes from. So ISP is measured in seconds. The sea level raptor engine
has an ISP of around 350 seconds so we can use that number just as an example. This basically
means that an engine capable of one metric ton or 9.8 kilonewtons of thrust will burn through
one ton of propellant in 350 seconds. This one ton of thrust means accelerating one ton at 1g.
So breaking this down if said engine would propel a spacecraft of one ton of mass using one ton of
propellant we'd end up with 9.81 meters per second squared times 350 seconds which is about 3.4
kilometers per second. So yeah that is nice but just hang on the weight of the propellant is
missing here and this is what makes things a little tricky. We need to carry that propellant
as well so we could start off with say a two ton spacecraft instead. One ton of propellant and when
all that is burned we are left with a one ton spacecraft. The acceleration here starts off much
lower in the beginning and it approaches 1g as the fuel is emptied out. Luckily for us though some
smart people here found the rocket equation. Here we just need to take the start mass of our vehicle
so the rocket propellant and the payload in this case two tons and then we divide that by the end
mass so everything without the propellant that is one ton remaining. On this we apply the natural
logarithm the ln multiply it with isp and g and now instead of 3.4 kilometers per second we're
looking at just 2.4 kilometers per second. That doesn't sound quite so good anymore does it? And
if we double or triple the propellant load we see diminishing returns. Each additional ton of
propellant gives us less additional delta v in return and this makes space travel such a challenge.
Okay so the rocket equation doesn't always sound that motivating but despite this
humanity achieved the manned Apollo moon landings in the 1960s and 70s so it's about time to do it
again and NASA has said multiple times now that this time we are aiming to stay. That is the key
to this video. We want to set up a lot of infrastructure on the moon and I think the
first major tasks for the human landing system will be to set up camp. So while the Apollo program had
a focus on a wide belt around the moon's equator Artemis's focus is quite narrow on the south pole
close to the likely water resources on the moon. We could see a base right here and Elon Musk has
even been talking about moon base alpha a number of times. This needs a load of cargo and capable
lander for the crew and therefore we put our heads together and apply the math that we've just
introduced to you to find a rather reasonable scenario. One lesson we can see right from that
rocket formula is that we have to have a low dry mass to carry a lot of payload. That is why SpaceX
is already testing thinner three millimeter steel to reduce weight. I don't believe this is yet on
vehicles such as ship 20 but it could come up in the next few iterations. All that said we think
that a standard cargo ship or tanker can achieve around 100 tons of dry mass. The raw HLS will be
likely below that though. There's no need for flaps or heat shield. Even fewer engines are possible
despite a lot of HLS imagery showing us three sea level Raptors and three Raptor vacuum engines. We
don't need the sea level engines at all since HLS will never return to earth. Just replacing them
with one additional Raptor vacuum engine would do and that would offer better ISP overall. It is
true we need to add some landing thrusters some larger solar panels and cooling systems but we
think that 85 tons for the empty HLS is possible. No pressure there SpaceX. So to that we can add
either cargo or crew cabins or maybe a mixture of both. NASA's current focus is initially on two
human landings supported by SpaceX and since we're stepping on new ground here quite literally
we're not sure if they are thinking of reusing the HLS at all during these first few missions.
As mentioned in the last video the phrasing used was that SpaceX are contemplating reusability.
Based on that reusable idea though it's quite realistic that they could load an HLS up with
cargo a flight deck and a habitat and use it both for the landing and to get the crew back to the
Ryan capsule. So the question is is that even possible and if so how much can be done? Thanks
to ANAIS's launch trajectory model here we estimate that a fully loaded HLS after being launched with
the booster will end up with about 30 to 80 tons of remaining propellant once in low earth orbit or
LEO for short. That is barely enough Delta V to do anything useful. We could visit the
International Space Station with that margin but the moon nowhere near. We need a lot more
propellant hence SpaceX's overall plan to use tankers to refill the HLS. So just to put into
perspective the Delta V required for a moon mission let's see what NASA did with Apollo.
Translating the dashed lines here into metric we already need around 3.1 kilometers per second
just to reach the moon. Once we're there we've got to get into a low lunar orbit or LLO and
finally we need to land and launch back up from the surface. That adds up to about 8 kilometers
per second. With the HLS concept a bunch of refill missions to LEO is the only way to even consider
such a mission. This is also critical to SpaceX's plan to make life multi-planetary. Knowing that
though we need this system to work reliably within the next two years to demonstrate an uncrewed
landing. So far there hasn't been any large cryogenic propellant transfer in space at all
so this will be a big first if they can pull that off. SpaceX isn't alone with the orbital
propellant transfer ambitions though. United Launch Alliance is also trying to make the Centaur V,
the upper stage successor of the ACES idea, capable of doing that too. We really love
exploring these topics in depth and it's a real thrill to see what we could be capable of once
the infrastructure is set up. Of course your support allows us to make these videos and
explore these options so thanks so much to all of you for subscribing here to stay up to date.
Just liking and sharing makes such a huge difference to us. So yes the first step here is
we need to refill the HLS in low earth orbit and this will certainly be a launchy endeavor because
running the launch trajectory model again we estimate the amount of usable propellant in
orbit delivered by a tanker to be just shy of 170 ton. This is obviously based on quite a variety
of vehicle assumptions at this point. Now I hear you say hang on Marcus SpaceX says it's 100 plus
tons to low earth orbit. Well just a little food for thought. SpaceX says right here that it's 100
tons plus for a polar orbit of 98.9 degrees at 500 kilometers. This requires quite a bit of extra
delta v than simply heading east when launching from Kennedy Space Center or Boca Chica. So we
think it could actually launch quite a lot more mass to orbit. Assuming this number HLS needs to
rendezvous with at least seven tankers so it can be fully refilled. So we're going to run through a
few of these numbers in some simulations to do these moon missions and see how we go here. But
first a huge thank you to Surfshark VPN for sponsoring this video. So as the internet gets
more and more involved in our daily lives it's really important to protect yourself from those
who may want to get your information. With a virtual private network or VPN it brings on protections to
disassociate your identity from what you're doing. That's a huge benefit especially when we're all
Now along with those great features of keeping who you are on the internet safe it also provides
a few more upfront benefits as well. With Surfshark VPN you can open up opportunities to view content
that is blocked geographically from you. That could be entertainment or perhaps even social
media platforms that have restricted news sources from you. With the simple switch of your country
you can begin watching that previously locked content. Surfshark offers access via 65 countries
with 3,200 plus servers available so there are heaps of options to explore and this is all with
the number one goal of protecting your privacy and security. To give you peace of mind when surfing
the internet you can also use it on a range of supported devices such as desktops or smartphones
and you can do all of that just with one paid account. If you are contemplating using a VPN
just head to surfshark.deals.com and you'll get 83% off and three extra months for free. Using
those links also helps to support me here as well so check it out. The link is right there
in the description below. So yes let's run through a few of these numbers in some simulations and
we'll see how we go here. Firstly we're going to get us a nice encounter with the moon and perform
the Translunar Injection Burn or the TLI. We can start from a 200-ish kilometer orbit as we see
here. The Apollo values of 3.1 kilometers per second is just right here. Let's now time warp
to the point where we reach the influence of the moon. There we go there and we see here that we're
not heading towards the moon's equator. No NASA's plan this time is to operate from a Near Rectilinear
Halo Orbit or NRHO. This orbit is a highly elliptical one over the lunar north pole. It uses
the interference of the gravity between the moon and earth to slowly turn its inclination with
earth's rotation. That enables a polar orbit around the moon where the earth never disappears out of
sight. Here they want to install the Gateway Station but even before that Orion and HLS need
to meet here since Orion doesn't have enough delta-v for a low lunar orbit. Now due to the
overly simplified mechanics of Kerbal Space Program here the NRHO isn't quite possible but
you get the idea. Because of the high apolloon of the NRHO the orbit insertion burn isn't that much
about 50% of what is needed to go directly into a low lunar orbit. But this is where we want to go
once we're docked with Orion to transfer the crew to the surface. If the periloon here is on the
north pole but we want to get to the south pole entering LLO with about 750 meters per second
does make sense. Once we're here it is then time for the descent. The thrust to weight ratio the
precise timing of the burn and the hovering required before touchdown there are some margins
needed here and we know what the Apollo missions needed for their landing. Again translating this
to metric units they needed around two kilometers per second for their descent. After the crew run
all of the experiments and conduct an incredible mission on the moon's surface for the first time
in over half a century it'll be time for the ascent back to low lunar orbit with close to
1.9 kilometers per second of delta-v required. Even after this though we still need to return
to NRHO to meet back up with Orion. So yeah getting to the moon meeting Orion getting into a
low lunar orbit and then landing launching again and heading back to Orion adds up to quite a lot
of delta-v in total around nine kilometers per second. In the beginning of the video we had a
look at this curve for an ISP of 350 seconds we need close to 13 tons of propellant for every
ton of dry mass that is HLS crew cabins and payload but we do have an advantage here actually
the 350 seconds of specific impulse was for the sea level version of the Raptor. HLS we believe
will rely on Raptor vacuum engines they will likely have 380 ish seconds of ISP so how much
does that increase of 30 ISP change the propellant requirements well check this out instead of 13
tons we now only need 10 tons that added nine percent of ISP reduces propellant by 20 some very
nice exponential shenanigans going on right there that's the reason why slight increases of ISP can
do so much for a rocket's capability to transport payload but you may ask well Marcus how is that
helping when we want to bring 100 tons of cargo to the surface well you're completely right there
85 tons of dry mass for the HLS maybe 30 tons for the crew cabins and then 100 tons for extra
payload requirements a whopping 2200 tons of propellant is going to be required there
way more than what the HLS could hold here so that's no good just hang on though we've got two
things missing here first of all once we leave 100 metric tons of payload on the surface after
we land the first time the propellant requirements drop a substantial amount it's still not quite
enough though so what else can we do let's introduce an elliptical orbit refilling around
the earth before we even start the translunar injection burn that is going to require more
refilling missions with tankers but this doesn't add too much complexity to what is already needed
anyway looking into the formula we can see that this refilling orbit doesn't need much additional
delta v just 1.4 more kilometers per second required and this is the orbit that we end up in
a 200 by roughly 8700 kilometer orbit this should be all of the extra delta v requirements that we
need to complete our mission but just look at this number to pick up the crew and deliver 100 tons to
the surface and of course return the crew back to orion we need 12 launchers of the full starship
and booster stack we are burning now over 55 000 tons of propellant and 11 times the tanker needs
and return on top of that the crew then need to be launched on orion as well so we need another
launch of the sls all of these flights just for one landing on the moon in comparison the apollo
program did this with just one saturn 5 weighing in just shy of 3 000 metric tons so why would we
do this well one simple reason delivering vast amounts of cargo to the surface apollo only
delivered some lightweight instruments the rover as an example weighed in at around 210 kilograms
in this new mission the aim is to deliver 100 tons to the surface useful payload that will
stay there because of this it's easy to see that an order of magnitude more launch mass
gets us about two orders of magnitude more useful payload to the surface of the moon
but just hang on a second we can make this idea even better the idea is to set up camp at the
lunar south pole right so is it possible to actually return the hls itself back from nrho
after the mission is complete and land it back on the surface at the base we are going to need extra
propellant for that once again after working it out we found that just four additional launches
of tankers one of them flying the whole way to nrho and back is actually enough to pull this off
the tanker slightly refills the hls once again and that provides enough delta v to actually land
back on the surface we have crew cabins engines and high quality metals on the surface now ready
to become part of moon base alpha and support further exploration i mean this makes a lot of
sense right yes it's another 20 000 tons of launch mass to do this that's true but think of the
benefit of having the full ship remain on the surface of the moon that could be quite an astounding
thing to do so to sum all of this up we're quite confident that the spacex hls concept can work
given a variety of refilling missions in various orbits in order to do any of this though spacex
needs the starship vehicle to pass a whole bunch of milestones the first one of course is the orbital
launch coming hopefully in just a few months we need to re-enter a starship in one piece and reuse
it repeatedly we need to catch the largest booster ever made right out of the sky and begin reusing
that as well they need to achieve the capability goals with isps dry mass and thrust matching
something similar to what we've calculated again no pressure there spacex they also need to conduct
quite groundbreaking propellant transfer in orbit they can design and test the hls with our crew
and then finally they could replace the sls altogether and start what a time to be alive we
can't wait to see where all of this is going so yes stay tuned and if you want to see more mission
design speculation let us know in the comments thank you very much for supporting what we do
here you could be a regular viewer of our content perhaps a patron or youtube member supporting what
we do or you could be picking up some sweet gear from our merch store including this shirt that
you see right here that design is also available in a wide range of products and clothing styles
no matter how you support know that it contributes significantly to what we can do here and allows
us to increase the time that we can collectively spend in research including this video right here
if you'd like what we do here and you'd like to help assist us you can join as a youtube member
via the join button below or you can also become a patron at patreon.com slash marcus house either
of those options gives you access to chat to us more directly via the linked roles on our discord
server you can also have your names listed right here like these other amazing people and you also
get earlier and add free access to the videos to watch before anyone else thank you to the team
that helped create this video and if you're interested in these topics and you would like
to keep up to date remember to subscribe here below and follow me on twitter at marcus house
in the tile in the bottom left here today we have my previous video talking about the hls missions
in the top right is my latest video and in the bottom right content that youtube has selected
from the channel just for you thank you everyone for watching and we'll see you all in the next video
