Does All-In-One Paint ACTUALLY Work?!

Welcome to the Woods (Melissa Woods)
160 followers
3 Video Views·Dec 3, 2022
Hi, welcome to the Woods fans, it's Melissa.
On this episode of This or That DIY,
I'm going to be comparing and contrasting
all-in-one paint and primer paint
with a regular, old-fashioned primer
and then a paint to see which one is more durable.
And if you truly can, skip the priming step.
You'll see behind me that I have an old drawer system
for our entryway-like storage.
And this is very old.
It has this laminate veneer on the front.
It's a very glossy surface.
I'm gonna paint it.
And I'm gonna compare and contrast the two paint products,
but I'm also going to show you
what a difference sanding ahead of time makes,
especially on a glossy veneer like this.
Now, I wanna tell you about the first paint
we're gonna be using.
This is the brand Heirloom Traditions,
and this is one of the most high-end paint
and primer-in-one brands on the market.
I am friends with the owners.
I've used this paint on multiple projects
without priming, without sanding.
It does have great adhesion,
but I've never put it up to the test like this.
Now, we'll definitely need two coats for full opacity,
but there are plenty of white paints
that you need even three coats,
so I would say that this has great hide and coverage.
Now, for the other drawer on top,
we're going to be using this primer,
and an hour later, I'll coat it with paint.
This primer is sold at Home Depot,
and they say it's one of their most popular primers.
Kiehl's is definitely a popular brand.
This super glossy type of furniture,
I would say is comparable to the melamine-coated furniture
that you would buy at Ikea.
I'm hopeful that this tutorial could be helpful for you
if you try to paint Ikea furniture.
However, I would say that painting furniture like this
is definitely not a long-term finish.
Even if you're using high-quality paint,
anytime you paint furniture,
you're gonna need to do touch-ups
and realize that it can't possibly look perfect
for a very long time the way that a great stand job could.
Now, for the bottom two drawers,
I'm gonna pull them out, and we're going to sand them,
and then I'm gonna do the same comparison,
but with sanding involved.
The paint I'm gonna use
is this Sherwin-Williams interior latex,
and this is professional-grade paint,
so it should adhere beautifully over the primer.
Okay, it has been several months
since I filmed the last portion of this video.
You can see that I'm a little bit blonder and less pregnant,
and so we are going to take some keys
and test out how our finish has held up over time.
Now, I waited this while because paint has to cure
before you can really get a solid test,
and what we're gonna do is just try and scratch it off.
If you remember, this one is the all-in-one paint.
This one is the all-in-one paint with sanding first.
This one is a primer and paint separately,
and down here, this one is sanding,
then primer, then paint, so let's check it out.
Let's test how the all-in-one paint has held up first.
So I can make a scratch,
but it is not coming off down to the glossy finish.
Now, this is the all-in-one paint with sanding first.
Same, I can scratch it off, but it's not coming off easily.
This one is the primer and paint together.
Oh yeah, that scratched off to the gloss quite easily.
That scratched off all the way down.
Here's with sanding first.
Huh, it just scratched the paint finish.
It didn't come off all the way,
so sanding really did make a difference.
To be honest, I wasn't really sure
how this was gonna turn out, but the comparison is clear.
The more expensive all-in-one paint
really was quite durable.
The more durable option,
especially if you're trying to skip some steps
and get it done quick versus paint, regular paint,
or like a primer and paint,
and the prep work makes all the difference
because if you're using just regular products,
then sanding beforehand
can help it adhere significantly better,
and that was proven in this example.
So I hope that you learned something in this video.
Let me know in the comments below
if you ever tried all-in-one paint before
and what your experience was.
Thanks for watching Welcome to the Woods.
We'll catch you again next time.
