With Blue Origin, SpaceX, Virgin Galactic and Masten Space Systems all working on reusable rockets we ask: are we watching the reusability rocketry renaissance unfold?
This is the first episode encoded at native 1080p/24 via the new switcher and record deck. If you have issues, please let us know. Upgrade is part of our path to 4K.
In Space News we have: * SpaceX CRS-8 Launch and Landing * Blue Origin Launch and Landing * Beidou Satellite launched via LongMarch 3A * Progress Launch via Soyuz * Shijian 10 Launch via Long March 2D * US Military rules out collision as cause of Hitomi satellite’s woes * ExoMars safely on its way after an upper-stage explosion
TMRO Live is a crowd funded show. if you enjoyed this episode consider contributing to future live shows. You'll find immediately after becoming a Patron of TMRO your skin becomes amazing, you're more attractive and life is generally better for you* More information, rewards and super powers can be found at http://www.patreon.com/tmro
* -- There is no factual evidence to back up these claims nor does TMRO guarantee anything stated.
Okay, tomorrow begins right now.
And welcome to Tomorrow, Season 9, Episode 12, nothing from you guys.
For Saturday, April 9th, 2016, my name is Benjamin Higginbotham.
I'll be joined by Jared, Carrie-Anne, and Space Mike in just a moment, but before that
happens, I'd like to give a huge shout-out to all of the patrons of Tomorrow who helped
to make this specific segment of this episode happen.
These are the people who have contributed $10 or more to this specific show.
We are a crowdfunded show, and every single dollar helps.
To find out how you can help crowdfund the shows of Tomorrow, head on over to patreon.com
slash t-m-r-o.
That was a fairly slow Newsweek, so, um...
Yeah, no?
I don't know.
Anything you want to talk...
Just start with Mike.
I'm sure he's got something.
You got anything to talk about this week?
Well, I mean, there...
I feel like there was something pretty important that happened yesterday, um...
Let's see.
I'm sure it's in the rundown here somewhere.
Oh, yeah!
SpaceX made history again!
Ah!
Holy cow!
So SpaceX successfully launched a Falcon 9 rocket yesterday, and this was at 2043 Coordinated
Universal Time.
Let's check out the launch footage.
He's so excited he pulled out his hair.
So, like I said, this took place on Friday, April 8th, and this was launching their eighth
commercial resupply Dragon capsule filled with cargo and experiments bound for the International
Space Station.
Many space enthusiasts remember the last attempt that SpaceX made launching a Dragon capsule
to the International Space Station on CRS-7, when the second stage exploded during flight.
But on this flight, CRS-8, you could almost feel the sigh of relief when Falcon 9 successfully
went through main engine cutoff and second stage ignition.
And for that, for all the... the entire part of the ascent of the launch went successfully.
And probably the part of this flight that will be remembered for the longest time is,
of course, the successful landing of the Falcon 9 first stage on the drone ship at sea, titled
Of Course I Still Love You.
And many said it couldn't be done, but SpaceX did it.
Just what an amazing, amazing accomplishment.
What a proud moment for everyone involved with this.
And just listen to the crowd that went on for quite a while cheering this moment.
So amazing.
And this changes so much.
This stage that we're looking at right here might just be the first stage that SpaceX
is able to reuse and refly again.
And hopefully everything goes smoothly with the inspection and all of the test firings
of this particular stage.
And oh my goodness, hopefully the price will go down like they projected and just everything
will go great.
And just such a huge moment.
I do need to mention, though, that notably on this flight, probably the biggest high-profile
payload on the Dragon capsule was Bigelow's Expandable Activity Module, or BEAM, which
over the coming weeks is going to go through quite a bit of testing as it's being birthed
to the International Space Station and expanded and going through its whole gamut of tests.
So very exciting.
And we'll be reporting on that as that happens.
DatDog had an interesting question, which was, hi, hi, where are the seas?
Do you happen to know that?
I do not.
I don't know.
I would have to do some research on that, but I have no idea how high the sea levels
were.
I saw it.
You can even see in the footage there, you know, the drone ship kind of tilting back
and forth and it was still able to stand up.
And actually, when I was watching it live, the people I was with asked me how it was
able to do that.
And I figured because most of the weight's at the bottom there with the engines and whatever
remaining fuel is left over.
I read on the weather report in the morning that the seas were six to eight feet.
Yeah.
SpaceTogether88 in the chat room is saying one to three meters.
Yeah.
So there you go.
Yeah.
Pretty good size.
And moving along, I think you've got some more reusability coverage there, Space Mike.
That's right.
And last week, last Saturday on April 2nd, Blue Origin successfully launched their new
Shepard rocket for the third time and successfully landed that.
Let's check out their footage of their launch.
This was from their test site in Texas.
And in a nice change of pace, Jeff Bezos actually gave a heads up as to when this launch would
be.
Although it was only a day's notice, it was nice to see something more specific than quote
unquote we'll be launching soon.
And although they didn't live stream the launch and landing, Bezos did the live tweet during
the launch and gave updates on the performance of the vehicle.
And as I said, this was launched on Saturday, April 2nd at around 1500 coordinated universal
time and the rocket performed as expected.
They were able to have a nice touchdown with the capsule and they were even able to fly
to a slightly higher altitude.
They reached an apogee of 103.4 kilometers.
Last time they got it to 101.7.
And during the landing, which you can see there, they didn't use propulsion until almost
the very end, right near the last 3000 feet is when they ignited the BE-3 engine.
And any problems with that would have seen the rocket destroyed.
But as you can see here, they were able to successfully ramp up the engine and have enough
thrust to be able to successfully land.
So very cool, very cool and very great news for them.
And something else that I found really interesting about this particular launch is it had two
microgravity experiments on board, one from the Southwest Research Institute and the
other from the University of Central Florida.
So this is a big deal that they have essentially beat their competitors by being able to fly
suborbital science now.
And there's only more test flights that are going to happen this year.
And there's going to be experiments on every single one of them.
And this will just lead up to eventually the end goal of flying people on board this vehicle.
And very cool.
And I hope that both Blue Origin and SpaceX are able to continue with all of their reusability plans.
Awesome. Thank you, Space Mike.
All right, we've got some other launches that happened over the last two weeks.
Two weeks, right? Yeah.
Over the last two weeks.
The first one happened Tuesday, March 29th at 2011 UTC.
This is a Long March 3A.
And I'll speak quickly because I only have like 20 seconds worth of footage.
This is the this is one of the Beidou satellite navigation systems.
This is the 22nd satellite launched for China's Beidou system.
It's the second satellite launched this year.
And it's going to have worldwide global positioning services running by 2020.
It's going to have an accuracy of about 33 feet, which is 10 meters or so.
And you're also going to have speed estimates within less than one foot per second in time
measurements of around 10 nanoseconds or so.
So that one launched, that one launched, like I said, this like two Tuesdays ago on March 29th.
And they had another launch that we'll get to in a second.
But we also had a Soyuz launch to the International Progress,
launching via a Soyuz to the International Space Station.
I'll just talk over the very long ignition sequence.
This was Thursday, March 31st at 1623 UTC.
In any moment now, the Soyuz rocket should release.
There you go.
Beautiful ascent, sending the Progress spacecraft to the International Space Station.
That is a uncrewed spacecraft.
It will autonomously dock with the space station.
It was bringing 3,126 pounds of fuel, water, and supplies up there.
Some, well, I almost said badly needed things.
They're fine.
They're okay.
It's not like if the spacecraft had lost, been in any sort of trouble.
But certainly, you still need to refresh the supplies on the space station.
And one of the other things you need to resupply is the fuel.
It's bringing up 1,190 pounds of fuel so that the International Space Station can help
re-lift itself into a proper orbit, as well as do orbital maneuvers to avoid space debris.
So somewhat important for the fuel.
It's actually going to be a very busy time at the space station because is Cygnus still
up there?
Cygnus is.
Cygnus is still docked.
So Cygnus is still attached.
It's still berthed.
We've got attached.
We're going to say attached.
Berth is stupid.
So Cygnus is still attached.
It is.
Cygnus is still attached.
We've got the Progress attached to the space station tomorrow, I believe.
Yes.
And then we've got Dragon going up, which will be attaching in just a few days.
So they'll have three spacecraft.
And we have two Soyuz right now, I believe.
Yeah.
So we've got three active spacecraft, and then the two Soyuz are not active, right?
They're in passive mode, I believe.
Yeah.
They're just kind of recovery, like, oh my gosh, we need to get out kind of thing.
Lifeboats.
Yeah, lifeboats.
So they need to have enough lifeboats for the six astronauts on board the International
Space Station.
That's what the two Soyuz do.
But then you've got three more active spacecraft up at the International Space Station sometime
early next week.
That's when all of that will be happening.
So really good on them for being able to figure out how to juggle all of this.
What a huge, monumental task of maintaining all these different spacecrafts at the same
Lots of logistics involved in that.
Logistics.
That was the word I wanted.
Thank you.
All right.
And finally, I mentioned China had another launch.
They had a Long March 2D on the Xizhuang 10.
Here you go.
I like that shot right there.
Then the engines blew out the camera.
But yeah.
It was deep for a second.
For a moment, it was really pretty.
Tuesday, April 5th at 1738 Coordinated Universal Time.
That's sending up a suite of 19 microgravity research experiments.
It's going to take a couple of weeks.
They're going to be investigating fluid physics, easy for me to say, combustion in space, material
science, biotechnology, and the effects of microgravity and radiation on plants and animals.
What's really cool about this is in order to do that research, they need to be able
to send some stuff back.
And they're going to be doing that in about two weeks.
About a week now at this point.
A fifth?
No, no.
About two weeks or so.
That return capsule will actually parachute back down.
And since 1974, China's actually done that 25 times before.
So this is not the first time they've tried to do a return mission.
They actually had, I believe, one failure on their return missions otherwise.
So a one out of 25 failures.
Not too bad.
Pretty good.
Yeah, absolutely.
But they're also going to leave an orbiter up there continuing to do other experiments.
They're actually going to be doing combustion experiments in space.
And that's what that orbiter's going to do after everything else is done.
You probably don't want to do the combustion experiments up front.
Yeah.
Probably not the first experiment you want to run.
Typically.
Get that payload back on Earth, then light things on fire.
Yeah.
That's how that's going to work.
Just like what they're doing with the Cygnus.
Exactly.
We'll light it on fire when it's not attached to the space station.
Exactly.
So they're doing a bunch of really cool things there.
And yeah.
So that launched, like I said, April 5th.
Jared, talk to me about some possible collisions.
Now that we're done talking about successes, let's go on to some failures.
All right.
That sounds like fun.
Two weeks ago, during a regular check-in on orbit with the Japan Aerospace Exploration
Agency's Hitomi X-ray Observatory, they detected that there was a weak signal coming from it,
indicating that something was wrong with the actual satellite.
So ground-based observation has found that there are multiple objects in the same orbit,
which indicates that there was some type of event that has generated the debris around
the X-ray telescope.
So further evidence has showed that Hitomi's orbit decreased by 5 kilometers as well, indicating
that there was a velocity change of about 14 kilometers an hour in its orbit, and its
current spin rate, which we can actually see in this footage that was taken in Arizona,
I believe, through a telescope, looking at Hitomi spinning there.
It's spinning around once every one and a half to two seconds, while the debris around
it is rotating about once every 10 seconds.
Now, the United States Joint Space Operations Center has ruled out a collision with orbital
debris.
And JAXA is unsure of what the problem could have been as well, because data received before
the event indicated that the pressurized tanks inside Hitomi were perfectly fine, and that
the batteries were in perfect shape as well.
And JAXA says that recovery still may be possible.
They've been working on it very much for these past couple of weeks.
They say that it's going to take months in order to get it back.
And it was supposed to look in the X-ray spectrum of light, looking at black holes, galactic
clusters that would help investigate the large-scale structure of the universe, and also help increase
our understanding a little bit of dark matter as well.
But not so much anymore.
Not so much anymore.
Now we can understand X-rays as they spin at about one and a half.
I don't think we'll have a very good focus.
Maybe we could do an all-sky survey with it, but not as detailed a survey as we would have
liked to have.
So since the tanks and the batteries are fine, do you have any theories as to what might
have happened?
Maybe like a thruster firing or something like that?
Well, they were fine.
They were fine.
That doesn't mean they still are fine.
Yeah.
All the telemetry up until the loss of telemetry said that everything was OK.
So honestly, to me, it sounds like some type of either a pressurized tank ruptured or a
battery exploded.
So we don't know.
And real bummer for that, because there was an experiment on there that was running to
detect X-rays at extremely cold temperatures with its detector.
This was the third time it had been sent up.
In the early 90s, it launched on a Japanese satellite, and the rocket failed.
And then they launched it on another satellite in 2005, and that satellite, the helium coolant
in it, the tank ruptured.
And all of that fell out in less than a week after on orbit.
Those poor scientists.
I feel really bad for those scientists.
They got to be like, oh, finally, finally, we've got it.
And then, no.
Just like loss of telemetry, loss of vehicle control.
They sound very confident that they're going to be able to recover the satellite.
So they're going to give it every chance that they can.
And Japan has a very good record of recovering missions that don't necessarily go according
to plan.
Well, I mean, OK.
But again, loss of telemetry.
Do they have commanding of the vehicle?
They do not have commanding of the vehicle, so it's still out of control.
I'm just going to say, all right, all right.
You never know.
They could go, oh, we figured, you know, if they can get commanding to the vehicle, it's
a different story.
Yeah.
So I'm just going to be an optimist and say that hopefully they'll be able to, but the
engineer in me is like, no chance.
So unfortunately, it sounds like the mission's over.
Didn't they just launch this too?
Is this the same one that they launched back in February?
Yes, it is.
It didn't even have a month on orbit.
It was supposed to last for three years as well.
Oops.
Yeah, they were still in the commissioning phase, too.
They still were not actually taking in data with the spacecraft.
Yes, Hunter says, Jackson projects confidence, but there's zero chance on this one.
Yes.
There's never zero chance, just like there's never 100% chance either.
Those two N's don't actually truly exist, but 0.0001% chance is what, again, it all
changes if they get commanding or telemetry.
Yes.
If they can get something down or back up to the vehicle, it's a little bit of a different
story at that point.
Yeah.
But without commanding control, I don't know what they think.
They're working on it, too.
Oh, I would assume that's the first thing you try to do is like, can we talk to the
vehicle?
Yeah.
So, or the vessel?
Yeah.
The satellite.
All right.
Unfortunately.
And let's talk about more explosions, Jared.
Why not?
Why?
We're just ending off the news with like a-
Spaceplosion.
Like a space destruction derby going on potentially, but we don't know about this one because
there's lots of conflicting information about this one now, which is that a couple weeks
ago some interesting imagery came out showing the upper stage of the proton launcher used
to send ExoMars trace gas orbiter to Mars.
And let's take a look at what that actually looked like.
So here it is here.
Now, there was some confusion about what is actually in this image because people thought
we were looking at ExoMars with the upper stage there.
That's actually just the upper stage.
So it's been confirmed that the imagery we have here is just the upper stage.
And that appears to show what, for my just Yahoo on the street assessment, is a big cloud
of debris around the upper stage.
Now that upper stage is known as a breeze M.
Why is there a big cloud of debris around the upper stage?
Well, satellite watchers who are, I would describe as experts on things like this, suggest
that the breeze M went through an energetic event.
Perhaps.
An energetic.
There are never explosions, by the way.
There's always a rapid unscheduled disassembly or an energetic event.
Space is awesome.
So luckily it did that after detaching from the ExoMars trace gas orbiter.
Now an initial check in with the ExoMars trace gas orbiter shows that everything is okay
with it.
None of the instruments were damaged or anything like that.
And breeze M upper stages have exploded before, previously in 2007, 2012.
No, they've had energetic events.
Excuse me, energetic events in 2007, 2012.
And actually, earlier this year in January, one that was launched last year went kablooey
as well.
However, Roscosmos chief Igor A. Komarov says that this is merely speculation and that the
breeze M upper stage did not suffer a catastrophic destruction, excuse me, energetic event.
Now he notes that telemetry showed that the collision avoidance maneuvers, so basically
burn your engines so you don't run into the spacecraft, he showed that that worked.
Also the passivation of the upper stage, basically vent all of your fuel overboard, worked as
well.
And some are suggesting that what you're seeing there are what's known as hot pixels, which
are basically dead pixels that show up really brightly instead of dark.
That could be.
That could be it.
That could be.
They didn't have a pixel janitor.
Yeah, but I, you know, when you have a good track record of exploding upper stages, it's
a little difficult to buy it.
They don't explode, they have rapid unscheduled disassembly.
Or energetic events.
That's very true.
You know, it was brought up in the chat room and I didn't do, you know, none of us wrote
this down in our show notes, but I'm going to throw you, throw this one at you really
quickly.
Yes.
Kepler is in emergency mode.
Yes, there's also that too.
Do you know anything about that one?
Yeah, the Kepler Space Telescope, they went with their usual check in on Thursday just
to make sure everything's fine.
Like, hey, how's it going?
Hey, how you doing?
Kepler went, ah!
Yeah, Kepler was like, something's wrong!
So I haven't heard any updates about it, but we know that Kepler has broken reaction wheels,
which is not a good thing to have, and reaction wheels is what you use to point your spacecraft
in the correct direction.
So they've been using this interesting system where they actually use pressure from sunlight
reflecting off of certain parts of the Kepler Space Telescope, so that way it can stay pointed
very precisely as it drifts looking through the sky, but yeah, it's in emergency mode
and nothing's been said since then, and that's not good, because there's already a lot of
things that are broken on Kepler that you don't want to have broken on your spacecraft.
But you know, they're going to try to recover it.
Jared, I feel like the news was reversed this week, where Mike and I got to be like, oh
my God, these impossible things happened!
And now you're usually like, we're going to do these impossible things!
And then this week it was, you're right, and then this week you were like, all of these
normal things are failing.
Yeah, everything's going, ah!
Everything's going wrong!
We're having energetic events left and right!
No!
Energetic events!
Emergency!
Meanwhile, how are you doing, Carrie Anne?
Yeah.
Yeah, anything from the chat room before we go into break?
Yes.
Yeah, I mean, chat room's been all over the board.
They of course were asking about Kepler, so I'm glad you managed to keep that, or catch
that a little bit.
There were a couple of questions about, Mike, do you have any ideas what the Gs were on
descent for the Blue Origin vehicle?
Let's see.
No idea.
I can only speculate based on what information they gave of how fast they were going and
what altitude they started their burn at, but I have no idea.
As far as I know, I haven't been able to find telemetry data like that from Blue Origin.
I heard 5 Gs is what they were decelerating at, roughly.
No idea.
Yeah, but that's just what I heard.
I can't verify that.
And then there was, Jay Quack was saying that it was his or her first time tuning in live,
and it's hard to keep up with the live show and the comments, but we somehow managed to
make it look easy.
No, they just threw an entire person at it, so it's okay to worry about it.
That is indeed what we do.
She does nothing but comments.
That's why I'm always head down.
I apologize.
Really, really hard.
Then Vax Hedrum was talking about the possible of the stuck thruster, not ExoMars, it was
the one before that, Hitomi, thinking that the rotation, it's because of the fast rate,
that possibly it was a stuck-on thruster, or a blown-off fuel line.
But if the thruster was stuck in an on state, wouldn't that rate increase, rapidly?
Unless it was just a burst?
Hitomi's a big satellite, so it's not a small one.
It's about...
Thrusters generally don't put out small amounts of...
2,500 kilograms, I want to say?
It's a biggin'.
Well, but then, shortly after Jared kind of explained his thought process, then Vax kind
of came back and said, well, I'm kind of with Jared on that assessment.
It was good, though.
There was a little bit of debate going on in the chat room about what possibly could
be.
Nobody knows, and we're probably not going to ever know for sure, I guess is the best
way to say it.
We can speculate that nobody will have an exact way of what happened to Hitomi, unless
we can recover it and then get telemetry from it, and then we can really pinpoint what it
actually is.
That would be awesome.
DanTC24 asks if they've just ever tried turning it off and back on again.
I mean, if they hadn't, that's just silly.
We tried unplugging it, but, you know.
There you go.
And Minisoach asks if we still have the shuttle, could we repair Kepler?
No.
Isn't that in orbit around the sun?
It's in orbit around the sun, yeah, and it's pulling, and it's in a trailing orbit, too.
Don't we need that special shuttle that they used on...
Armageddon.
Yeah, we could do that.
Let's just screenshot the shuttle with solid boosters right around the moon after we fuel
up and blow up Mir.
Yeah, I'm pretty sure that Bruce Willis just kept that one from the movie, so you could
probably just call him that.
That's right, that was the one with the crazy Russian when they were blowing up...
Was it Mir?
Yes, they blew up Mir.
Oh, that was fantastic.
And it didn't even look like Mir.
So, there you go.
On that note, let's go ahead and go into break.
This week's hashtag is hashtag relaunch, because we're going to be talking about the reusability
renaissance.
Stay tuned.
We'll be right back.
And welcome back to Tomorrow.
Now, before we get into our reusability renaissance main topic, I did want to give a shout out
to all of the patrons of Tomorrow, who've helped to make this specific segment of this
episode happen.
These are the patrons who've contributed $10 or more to this specific episode, but there
are multiple levels.
You also have the patrons who've contributed $5 or more, and those are our producers.
I'd like to give a shout out to everyone who's contributing to the show week after week.
Without you, we couldn't continue to do this.
If you'd like to find out how you can help crowd fund the shows of Tomorrow, head on
All right, let's go ahead and get started with our main topic this week, which, as one
can imagine, because we just had two major events.
We had the SpaceX landing on a drone ship out at sea, the Autonomous Spaceport Drone
Ship, and we had Blue Origin relighting their booster and flying it for a third time to
suborbital space, both huge accomplishments.
But this is not the first time we've had reusable spacecraft.
We've had the Space Shuttle, and then now New Shepard and Falcon 9.
So how are we moving from Shuttle?
I guess, what am I trying to state here?
What is the difference between Shuttle and New Shepard's booster, Falcon 9, Virgin America,
or, Virgin America, Virgin Galactic.
Virgin America doesn't exist anymore anyway.
I meant Alaska Airlines.
There you go.
So what is the difference between Shuttle and these other newer vehicles?
I was actually on Reddit, on slash r slash space, and people are like, I don't get it.
We did this.
We did this in the 60s with the Shuttle.
What's different?
I mean, we've talked about this before about how the Shuttle was refurbishable, and the
cost of refurbishing the Shuttle was actually quite a bit more than anyone had really projected,
including the engineers who designed it.
And with New Shepard and with the Falcon 9 first stage, and a couple other smaller efforts
that are going on right now, we still are looking at refurbishments.
I mean, it's not completely reusable.
SpaceX still needs to look at all the engines and do test firings and pressurization tests
and all sorts of stuff to the first stage before they can relaunch it again, and Blue
Origin has to do the same thing.
They didn't just fly it for the second time and stick it in the garage somewhere and then
decide to launch it again.
No, there was lots of tests and lots of different things that they had to do to the vehicle
before they could launch it again.
So we're still kind of in the refurbishment, but I feel like it is getting closer to reusability.
But again, you know, what is the point of this?
And just like what the Space Shuttle was supposed to be, it was supposed to be the cheapest
way of accomplishing reusable spaceflight that was ever supposed to exist, and it didn't
quite live up to that.
So we're still kind of in that unknown phase, in my opinion, right now with these newer
vehicles where we're looking at kind of what the costs involved with refurbishing and reusing
them are.
And that is what's going to decide whether or not all these efforts are worth it, in
my opinion.
Ghost2501 asks, can SpaceX make all parts of Falcon and Dragon reusable?
Well, I mean, they do have lots of plans.
It seems like with the second stage of the Falcon 9, they had plans to eventually start
reusing that, but it seems like all the plans for that are on hold, if not, you know, indefinitely
canceled.
The Dragon capsule, yes, they are looking at lots of ways of refurbishing that.
And correct me if I'm wrong, but I do believe that they have reused some of the Dragon capsules
that they recovered that were recovered by parachutes in the ocean.
And with some of those, they're working on Super Draco thrusters to be able to land the
Dragon capsules on land somewhere, not just to have splashdowns.
And in that sense, they're having more efforts with the Dragon capsule to make it reusable
and refurbishable as well.
And lots of different work has been has been going on that.
And eventually the goal to have all of the elements be reusable.
But as of right now, just the first stage and the Dragon capsule is what's being worked
on.
So why are we there?
Are we at the reusability renaissance?
Right.
Are we away from refurbishability?
And are we now?
I mean, because it's not just SpaceX and Blue Origin.
You've also got Masten Space Systems, although the key difference there being they fly really
small things and they haven't even gone to suborbital space.
I'm looking at you, Dave Masten.
I need you to go to space.
How awesome would that?
I'm looking at you, Dave Masten.
I need you to go to space.
How awesome would that be?
So yeah, I mean, are we there?
Are we at the reusability renaissance now?
Is now the time when reusability is a real thing?
I feel like we're in the opening stages of that potentially coming on.
But like I said on Twitter yesterday, the real revolution isn't happening right now.
The real revolution is going to happen when the rapid turnaround actually starts to happen.
When you can land that first stage booster, bring it back into the Cape, and then have
it ready to go the next day refueled and ready to fly.
Dave Masten does that now.
That's when the big revolution in terms of bringing those costs down, which is the overall
goal of full reusability, or even partial reusability, is to bring those costs from
way up there to maybe like right here.
But Masten Space Systems does that today.
He can turn around.
He can.
He can turn around same day.
He can.
Like he can launch twice.
He did.
He won the Northrop Grumman Lunar Lander.
What do we call that thing now?
Northrop Grumman Lunar Lander XPRIZE Challenge.
Thank you.
All of those words.
He won that doing exactly that.
Yes.
But does, so why do we count that?
Why is that not counted in the list of things?
I don't know why we don't count that.
That is a very important thing because they're gathering a lot of data on what it's actually
going to take in order to get your rocket ready to go again.
And they're showing what rapid reusability looks like.
But of course then comes the idea as well.
What are you doing?
Are you doing test flights?
Are you actually delivering payloads?
So I guess that's where the differentiation occurs that.
And the whole boundary of space is a big thing too because there were other vehicles in the
past that were similar to a lot of Masten's projects.
I mean, we had DC-X.
We had, gosh, I just had it on the tip of my tongue, a rotary rocket.
And those did have atmospheric flights.
They did have atmospheric test flights.
But none of those vehicles did get past the boundary of space, including some of the small
scale tests of the X-33.
And that I think is kind of the big qualifier in a lot of people's minds, especially in
the space enthusiasts community, is did they reach the boundary of space?
And you have Blue Origin doing that with suborbital and that's great.
But everyone's looking at being able to have orbital launches.
And the big deal with the SpaceX Falcon 9 is being able to have an orbital rocket that
can send up quite a bit of payload into space.
So is that, I mean, the rockets aren't actually, are the rockets crossing the 100 kilometer
mark?
They are, aren't they?
The first stages are crossing that mark, right?
Yeah.
Is that kind of what we're defining then?
Is that like...
Well, 100 kilometers, the common line is space.
That is the official...
No, I know.
But is that what we're defining as like, okay, this is when it's a big deal is once we've
gone past that and anything below that is like, okay, that was neat, but that's still
in the air?
No, I still feel like even like what with Masten is doing, it's still very important
because you have to gather that data and everything.
And just because Masten is doing it on the small scale doesn't mean that it's not as
important.
It's just that maybe they're not moving as rapidly as we would like them to move or maybe
they're not moving on to more complex vehicles like we would like them to for now.
I'm going to throw it to the chat room and then I'm going to come back with a Virgin
Galactic question.
Is there anything chat room-wise?
All kinds of fun things.
You sound angry at them.
No, it's just...
Why do they keep saying things?
Sort of.
It's a lot to keep track of.
Let me see.
Let's all look at our screens.
Yeah, let's totally do that.
You're being yelled at by calling it a ship, not a barge.
No, didn't Elon say it's not supposed to be...
I don't know.
Hunster corrected Johnny Boy saying, as Musk said, it was a barge, but it's been refitted
enough to self-propel so you can call it a ship.
Who called it a barge?
I don't know.
I can't keep track of everything.
I think I called it a drone ship.
It's a thing.
That could be that.
Let's see.
Green Jim is wondering if you really are a Dave Mastin fan because, I mean, you kind
of are.
Well, yes.
Yes.
I have a man crush on Dave Mastin, and I think everyone knows that, but I really would love
to see him.
And I know he's working on some really cool things, but I would love to see his crafts
go beyond the bounds of Earth's gravity.
There was a question about, can SpaceX make all parts of Falcon and Dragon reusable?
I think, in general, you can't make absolutely everything reusable.
Yeah.
Things like bearings, that's kind of a little difficult to do.
Yeah.
Because they're entering at hypersonic speeds, and they're also not exactly optimized for
flying hypersonic speeds.
Right.
Yeah.
I think we keep trying to compare it to, you know, we keep saying an airplane, right?
You fly an airplane from LAX to LaGuardia, and then you completely take it apart and
rebuild it, and you don't want to do that, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
It's not quite, I mean, that's the analogy, but that's not quite where we're going with
that.
Vax Hedrum corrected and said that we're all Mastin fans anyway, so that's totally fine.
Emmer Tiger says, in a word bend, no, there's no finish line.
It's going to be a steady progression of pushing the envelope to make it more useful, capable,
and cheaper.
Oh, that's great.
That's fantastic.
Yeah.
I totally agree.
Yes.
And, yes.
But we're starting to do that.
We're starting to do that.
We didn't, I don't think we pushed the envelope for like the last 30 years.
Right.
We had Shuttle, and we just kind of hitched everything on Shuttle and said, Shuttle, good
enough.
And I don't think anyone, well, we settled for Shuttle, and didn't realize maybe we're
actually capable of a lot more.
Don't get me wrong.
Shuttle is great, but I'm also very glad it's gone, because now look at what we're able
to do.
Yes.
I mean, obviously this is just the beginning of stuff, but it's super exciting, and it's
multiple areas in that this is all happening.
Yeah.
And I think that's even more exciting that it's not just one company.
Right.
Blue Glacier is saying in maybe another couple of years yet, they're still in the testing
stage, which I think is something that you and I kind of had talked about a little bit.
You know, there's still just a lot of testing going on in terms of getting to that rapid
reusability.
All right, so let's focus on rapid reusability, because it's not just reusability, it's rapid
reusability.
Yeah.
Because we constantly say that Shuttle is refurbishable.
It wasn't reusable.
It was very expensive to refly Shuttle.
It didn't actually make a whole lot of sense when you looked at it.
But let's talk about Virgin Galactic for a moment, because they might be able to turn
it around quickly, but they're doing that by essentially replacing the entire engine
every time.
Mm-hmm.
Right?
Is that rapid reusability?
Is that part of this, or does it not matter that that's what they have to do as long as
they can keep their cost down?
Well, I would imagine that if a Falcon 9 comes back, and you inspect it, and you see that
there's ... If you do a bore scope on it, and you look in there, and you see that there's
something wrong with some of the turbo machinery, you're going to pull that engine out and put
a new engine in.
And I don't think anybody's going to say that, oh, well, it's no longer a reusable vehicle
because we had to pull an engine out to put one back in.
But it wasn't designed to do that, whereas the Virgin Galactic's craft is designed to
have the entire engine removed and replaced every time.
I suppose.
How much of the total cost of the vehicle is the engine?
That I have no idea.
Mike, do you have any idea?
I have no idea either.
Well, we can't even really say on that since Virgin Galactic is still going back and forth
on what kind of engine they want to use.
Yeah, that too.
Yeah.
Well, but they're not on the human rated version, are they?
I mean, on the human rated version, they're swapping between ... They're not adding the
...
I can't remember if they're back on regular rubber, or if they're on the special nylon
mix.
I have no idea what they're at right now.
In both of those, unlike their Launcher One, it is removing the engine every time on both
engines, right?
So, while we can't answer the price question, they're definitely removing the entire engine.
I just thought it was something interesting to think about.
I figured I'd throw it out there.
Any comments from the community?
Well, somebody was talking about second stage being reused, and then there was a whole conversation
talking about fairings and recovering the fairings and reusing the fairings.
Somebody was concerned that maybe the fairings were really expensive because they're made
out of fairies.
Because that's our chatroom.
Good point.
Right.
So, there's that.
Somebody, Roepi?
Roepi?
Says, what do you think of X-Course piston pump engines?
Oh, awesome.
Vax Hedren was really enjoying that one.
So, yeah.
X-Course engines are awesome.
I believe they used a version of them on the Rocket Racing League, which isn't even...
I don't think that's even active anymore, but those planes with those rocket engines
are super cool.
So, yeah.
That's...
Unless you guys have any final...
Go ahead.
Well, Space Cat is asking, how much of the craft needs to be rapid reusable in order
for it to be considered a rapid reusable vehicle?
At what point is it refurbishable?
And I think, going back...
That's a nice differentiation.
These are interesting questions that...
It's kind of like the, what makes you an astronaut?
Do you just have to cross that 100 kilometer line?
Is that what makes you...
Or are you just a space tourist because you didn't do any training?
Stuff like that.
Some of those interesting questions that ultimately don't matter, right?
I mean, it doesn't...
As long as we're driving the price of space down and getting that launch, the number of
things up, right?
So, as long as cost is going down, number of launches is going up, we're doing good.
And what we're able to do in space increases, that doesn't matter how we get from point
A to point B, we're pushing the market forward, we're pushing the industry forward.
But it is...
I mean, these are curious questions that I would love answers to, or at least thought
processes on as, you know, what does make a vehicle rapidly reusable, right?
What is that turnaround?
Does it have to be a day?
An hour?
Right?
A plane doesn't turn around in a day.
It turns around...
45 minutes.
45 minutes, right?
Is that...
How about?
Is that how fast you have to be able to turn around?
I mean, Dave Mastick would probably do that, but he's probably the only one in this entire
group.
At the moment.
At the moment, yeah, exactly.
Or is it a day?
Is it a week?
I mean, how often do you turn around?
I mean, a week for a rocket right now would be incredibly fast.
Yeah, I mean, I think the fastest...
I'm gonna take a guess here, but I think the fastest processing of a shuttle through the
operational reprocessing facility, or whatever the wild thing they called it was, was something
like 55 days or something like that.
So is that the record right now for how fast you have to turn around?
Well, I think Blue Origin already beat that, didn't they?
Yeah, I was about to say, but then Blue Origin did it in a couple weeks.
So...
Absolutely.
So leave your comments.
What do you think?
Are we in or...
You know, we constantly talk about we're near a tipping point.
Have we reached that tipping point?
Does everything change at this point?
Is this a whole new industry that's blowing up in front of...
Wrong phraseology.
Oh, having an energetic event.
Having an energetic event in front of our very eyes.
What do you guys think?
So leave your comments.
YouTube, Facebook, Twitter.
Speaking of comments, when we come back, we're gonna have comments from our last week's show,
so stay tuned.
We've always looked to the stars.
They guide us, give us comfort, help us find our way.
We see ourselves out there.
When we look up, it inspires us.
Long for something we don't yet know.
We yearn to go there.
So we venture forth.
We choose to go to the moon in this decade and do the other thing.
Not because they are easy, but because they are hard.
We'll serve to organize and vision the future.
Tranquility Base here.
No, go ahead.
Join in it or not.
Many think we stopped exploring, but we know our journey didn't end.
We've only just begun.
Perfectly at this point.
Come with us and explore tomorrow.
And welcome back.
Now, before we get into comments from our last show, I did want to give a huge shout-out
to all of the patrons of Tomorrow who have helped to make this specific segment of this
episode happen.
These are the people who have contributed $10 or more to this episode.
We've also got our Tomorrow producers.
They are people who have contributed $5 or more to this episode.
We also have our Patreon Plus subscribers.
Those people who have contributed $2.50 or more, they're also going to get, including
everyone I just mentioned, access to After Dark as soon as we post it online.
They're going to get access to the Hangouts when we have those and exclusive content on
our Patreon channel.
But wait, there's more.
If you want to get your name in the show, just a simple penny per episode, one penny,
get your name in the show.
These are our patron subscribers.
They've contributed between one penny and $2.49.
Thank you to everyone in all of those lists to helping to bring the shows of Tomorrow
to you.
We appreciate every last one of you.
For more information, head on over to patreon.com slash T-M-R-O.
Again, we are a crowdfunded show.
Hopefully you guys, we changed it up, you'll notice.
We put everyone on their own slate because it started getting, the font started getting
so small at the end, you just couldn't read your name.
So maybe when we move to 4K, you'll actually, we can go back to the small font because you
can zoom into it.
So all right, let's go ahead and get started from our last show.
The topic on our last show was, what is the International Space Station worth in three
different colors?
That's how you can tell it's important because the font has three different colors.
There you go.
So Capcom, who's up first?
This first comment comes from Aloha Milton off of YouTube.
Aloha!
I will say really quickly, this was a slightly longer version of this particular-
That is an understatement!
Yeah, it was, Milton had a lot of good things to say.
I want to be very clear about that.
Yes.
But we shorted up ever so slightly.
A lot!
Ever so slightly, like every other sentence.
So, this is what we came down to.
The value of the material and time invested in the collective effort to date is only part
of the ISS overall worth.
The International Space Station, of course.
The International Space Station value is mostly in education for all parties.
How do we do blank in space?
The question is akin to, what is the value of the Wright Flyer?
Or what is the value of Luis Alvarez's education in physics?
Economic value is not definitive as it is always relative.
In an example, you can't eat gold.
So, it's value may be more than monetary.
Yes.
Dude, dude, I just summed up the entire comment.
The worth could possibly be more than the worth, as it were.
Yes, alright.
I mean, yes, that could be.
Inspiration is useful, right?
Absolutely.
Inspired to do other great things.
You know, what you learn from it, knowledge is useful as well.
Yeah.
Yeah, absolutely.
Very important.
You know, I agree.
I don't know.
See, the gripe I have that I didn't get-
See, I built an entire-
You know how a lot of people complain on Twitter?
Like, they use social media just as their soapbox?
Yes.
I built an entire show for that.
So, you're watching it.
So, here's your soapbox.
So, now I'm back.
Now I'm back and I can use my own show again.
The thing with the International Space Station is,
it was supposed to have these really great experiments.
It was supposed to have this centrifuge.
We were going to learn all of this great stuff.
It was the stepping stone to Mars.
And it ended up not-
Like, the really cool stuff got cut.
Yeah.
So, then you look at it and go,
okay, well, I mean, it's neat.
But when you look at what it could have been,
you go, but it could have been this.
And that's what makes me sad.
That's what makes me sad,
is the possibility for what it could have been.
There you go.
Same.
Boom.
Next up.
All right.
This one comes from Tyred.
Tyred.
At least I'm going to say that that's how you pronounce it.
Tyred.
Also off of YouTube.
The International Space Station is amazing.
I agree that the end of life boosted slowly to a graveyard orbit.
After I wake up from my cryosleep in 150 years,
I would love to visit on my way between the L1 and L2 stations
before I finally depart for the Mars colonies.
You know, I feel like-
Here.
No.
I knew Ben would hate this one.
I'm obviously the only one that disagrees.
It already is, like, old and smelly.
I want the new space-
I want the new-
You guys can go on the International Space Station.
I'll go ahead and fly on the Bigelow Space Station.
Okay.
I'm just saying, I'll get better accommodations.
It will be less expensive.
I get a better view and more space.
Oh, and it's cheap.
Yeah, I said it was less expensive.
So, boom.
There you go.
Okay.
Yeah?
Does it cost more money, Ben?
It does not cost more money.
I was going to say-
Well, I was trying to say-
Are they going to have the same decorations as a Motel 6?
No.
Wow.
All right.
Next one comes from Miguel Chafin, also off of YouTube.
Let's please not talk about deorbiting the International Space Station until we've begun working on a replacement.
No!
Because we didn't even do the cool stuff on the current International Space Station.
NASA has no plan for a replacement.
Russia is planning a replacement.
Europe is kind of planning a replacement.
That's a valid point.
Wait, hang on.
Hang on.
China already has a space station up there.
What?
Does it have to be the US?
You just said a replacement.
There's already a space station up there.
So boom!
Done.
Yeah.
That was solved.
Which NASA is forbidden to cooperate on.
Yes.
They're not cooperating with Chinese space station, right?
Yeah.
NASA is forbidden.
Yeah, right.
Exactly.
Yeah.
Silly.
But didn't say it had to be NASA's space station.
I mean, we are a single species, so humanity has another space station up there.
They are adding more modules.
China's doing cool things with their space station.
So it will not be as big as the International Space Station, but that's not a requirement
in that comment.
So technically speaking, they can de-orbit ISS right now and that comment is still okay.
That's right.
All right, moving on.
Technically speaking.
Yep.
Joker XXX.
Also off of YouTube.
I don't hate the ISS.
I'm sad.
Yeah, you do.
I know.
You're like the disappointed father.
I'm the disappointed father in the ISS.
That's exactly.
I knew what it could have become, but instead, it just didn't finish school and it's like.
It could have been a contender.
It could have been somebody, but instead, it's just a bum in orbit.
It's just a bum in orbit.
Exactly.
Next.
I can't wait for that GIF.
You're welcome, internet.
Joker XXX off of YouTube says.
That is a scary picture icon.
I have always wanted to put the International Space Station in a lunar earth orbit, using
it as a short duration transport with lots of living space, fly an Orion capsule up to
it with seven astronauts and use the International Space Station to spread out and live in on
the journey.
Boom.
BA 330.
I don't need that.
The space station, there's too much mass.
There's so much mass.
You mean volume or mass on the space station?
If we're going to boost the space station into a higher orbit, like lunar orbit, that's
going to require a lot of energy to do that.
I think a lot of people think that the space station's in space and so it's really easy
to move it wherever you want to go.
Not so much.
No.
It is in an inopportune inclination to move it pretty much anywhere.
Moving it to lunar orbit, while technically possible, highly unlikely and barely technically
possible.
Very slow.
Years.
It's not a decade.
Yeah.
Do you really want to be in the 30 year old ragged space station or do you want to be
in the hot new Bigelow station?
I'm just saying.
Just going to throw that out there.
Let's make sure the module.
If Skylab was still around, I'd want to visit it.
Actually, you know what?
I would visit.
I would probably, if I was a choice between Skylab and International Space Station, I'd
probably pick Skylab.
That would be me.
I was going to say, let's wait and make sure the module works correctly.
Oh, it works.
It's fine.
Make sure it works.
It's fine.
Next up.
All right.
Next comment also off of YouTube from Soren Schumann.
Hi, Soren.
I know you're in the chat room.
Andreas Morgensen's short trip to the International Space Station actually made space flight a
cool hip topic here in Denmark.
As I'm a Dane, I'm very thankful for that.
Yeah.
All right.
So I will say that inspiration is a good thing for the space station.
So any inspiration that space station can get is a really cool thing.
But, you know, I look at this $150 billion structure, and then I look at what Blue Origin,
SpaceX, and Virgin Galactic are doing, and I think the inspiration isn't from space station.
It's from Blue Origin, SpaceX, and Virgin Galactic.
I think we're inspiring more people with those three companies, far more than with the International
Space Station.
So I think from a, not a monetary, from an inspirational standpoint, ISS is not where
it's at.
All right.
For now.
Well, okay.
For now.
What do they have planned for ISS that is going to make people go, wow, that's awesome?
I would say that the recent...
Okay.
No, that would do it.
Yeah.
That would do it.
There is cancer research being done there.
If they find a better treatment or even a cure for cancer, that would be a big deal.
Yeah.
Absolutely.
I mean, that's highly unlikely, but just throwing that out there, that would change a lot of
people's opinion.
Absolutely.
One of the experiments that they're carrying on the Dragon is mice, and those mice are
going to be doing muscle experiments to see if there's maybe some way that you can actually
develop something to help, that you can actually help people with ALS or muscular dystrophy
and all these other issues that we have to contend with here on Earth.
Little mice hands on the barbells.
Yeah.
Like that.
They're going to lift, bro.
Lift, bro.
All right.
Last comment.
Capcom.
Man.
This one comes off of Twitter, actually.
Charlie Fox.
At tomorrow, hashtag ISS worth, could the International Space Station be built today
without the shuttle?
What combinations of current vehicles could get it done?
The only thing that I think that could be used now would be Proton and maybe Arion 5
for some of the smaller modules, but most of the bigger pieces, we don't have anything
unless like the Space Launch System was online, which it isn't, but yeah.
Yeah, you need to wait for Space Launch System to come online for that.
Yeah, that would be very tough.
Yeah.
But you know, well, wait.
Maybe Falcon 10?
No, I think, wait, let's change the question a little bit.
Sure.
Could the International Space Station be built today with today's technology?
Not necessarily.
So let's use inflatable hab technology, or expandable.
Expandable.
I hate it when people call it inflatable, too.
So expandable hab technology, right?
So expandable hab.
Do you want to explain the difference really quick?
One expands, one inflates.
One.
Well, it's not, we're not blowing it up like a balloon.
Okay.
Right.
Thank you.
So you're not taking like the big old station that's going, or the big old module that's
going up there, they're not like adding air to it and it's blowing up like a giant balloon.
It's kind of expanding to its final volume.
I almost said mass.
Wrong!
It's expanding to its final volume.
Almost kind of like when something's vacuum packed to a certain extent and then you crack
that seal and the whole thing just sort of goes, it expands to its original shape.
How is that again?
It's like.
Gross.
Let's not do that again.
Okay.
That was a little juicy.
Sorry.
Okay, so let's change the question.
If we are using expandable modules, because that's part of the problem, right?
Is you don't have anything that can take something that large up, but maybe we don't need something
like that.
So, Delta IV Heavy.
Yeah.
Yeah, I forgot that.
Atlas V Heavy.
Delta IV Heavy, expandable module, now can we do it?
Yeah.
I think we could.
With Delta IV Heavy we could.
Yeah.
As long as maybe you can get a little bit bigger of a fairing on there.
Maybe.
Hmm.
Maybe.
Definitely do it with SLS though.
Yes.
Alright, that is our show everyone.
Thank you so much for watching.
Next week we're going to be talking, we have a live guest next week, we're going to be
talking about voting for space, the new political party all around space.
It's going to be fantastic.
So, absolutely.
For those of you watching live, stay with us, After Dark is up next.
If you are a Patreon Plus subscriber, you can get that as soon as it is available online
for everyone else.
It will be available in about four weeks or so.
Thank you guys so much for watching.
We'll see you next week.
Bye bye.